Chapter 8 of 22

2. Adoptive Youth Ministry

2. Adoptive Youth Ministry

2

Adoptive Youth Ministry

FROM ME TO US

Youth ministry has been around since at least 1844, when England’s Young Men’s Christian Association was formed to provide urban youth with positive alternatives to the sins of the city. American youth ministry really took off in the 1930s and 1940s, and pretty much ever since we youth workers have been following the same programmatic model.

For decades, the focus of the programmatic youth ministry model has been crystal clear: creating and leading programs. The youth leader’s main job is to run events and classes designed to “graduate” students who are mature in their faith.

But if you look around churches today, or talk to men and women who lead youth ministries, it’s clear that the old programmatic model isn’t working like it used to. The youth ministry machine simply isn’t generating the graduates it once did.

There are many reasons the programmatic model is failing. For one, growing up has changed so much in our culture that the ways we reach out and communicate the gospel to young people are no longer producing the outcomes we seek. There is also increasing awareness that authentic, long-term spiritual transformation is not so easily programmable. Spiritual growth is a lengthy, messy process that demands more today than what we have been offering.

Don’t get me wrong. No movement dies off quickly. The programmatic model goes on as usual in many places and can even be a viable, if not vibrant, expression of ministry. Yet, inevitably, when we rely on programs and events to literally be the sum total of our ministry, our efforts eventually become more about the machine of our program and not about the people we serve. In either case, whether we are seeing a programmatic approach diminish in ministry effectiveness or we hold on to former ways of doing the church, whenever something new and enticing comes along (whether a book, a tweaked “model,” or a popular speaker or musician) our default response is to dust off the old approaches and hope they will work this time.

The sky is not falling, because many students enjoy events, annual trips, and even the regular youth gatherings. It’s still possible to keep the old machine going with enough resources—solid leadership, a good facility, shared history, and momentum. And there will always be the superstar kids with spectacular stories that we can point to and claim as our results. “Youth ministry still works!” we say.

One thing hasn’t changed. Everyone involved in youth ministry wants to see young people come to a sincere, integrated, mature faith in Jesus Christ that is expressed in love for God, neighbor, and self. That goal has not changed. But how we go about reaching the goal has changed drastically because we realize we are missing so many kids, including even those who were raised in the church. This is more than an academic debate. It’s about the lives and destinies of the next generation. The clock is ticking for our students and us. What can we do?

Adopted into God’s Family

While the programmatic model relies on events where we can tell kids God’s story, adoptive youth ministry seeks to show young people that their calling and destiny is located not only in God’s story but among God’s people living out that story.

Many youth workers tap into the parachurch youth ministry world, but let’s look at youth ministry through the lens of the church. If we are honest with ourselves, most of us will admit that the long history of youth ministry has created two-plus generations of spiritual orphans who attend youth ministry events regularly but gradually show less and less commitment to the church, the gathered body of Christ. Once they graduate from high school and the youth ministry programming, many also graduate from church.

This has gone on too long for us to miss it or pretend it doesn’t happen. This has led me to ask an important question: What if we designed youth ministry with the end in mind? If our goal is growing the church and seeing young people grafted into this larger community of faith, what might we do to help our students reach that goal?

I actually tried to answer these questions in two earlier books: Starting Right: Thinking Theologically about Youth Ministry and Four Views of Youth Ministry and the Church. In my contributions to both books, I argue that the goal of youth ministry should be developing kids’ loyalty to and involvement in the church, but I hadn’t quite figured out a theological or even practical way to make this happen. In the last few years, many have begun to explore a more church-focused approach to youth ministry, what I call adoptive youth ministry, but across the youth ministry spectrum the program-centered way of serving young people remains the default.

Three Crises Facing Youth Ministry Today

If books do not convince people, perhaps circumstances will. I’ve noticed more and more youth ministry leaders acknowledging that the old model isn’t working. Here are three issues that should concern us.

First, we are losing kids at an alarming rate.

Second, our world is becoming increasingly secularized, presenting challenges to students that may not reveal themselves until these young people are far beyond our reach.

Third, while we have known for some time that kids are hurting, many leaders now acknowledge that there’s more hurt out there than we realized. Growing up today takes its toll on every teenager, not just those we consider “at risk.”

Let’s take a closer look at these three crises.

Numbers and Nones: We’re Losing Our Students

What’s the fastest-growing “religious” group in America today? It’s the nones: those with no religious preference or affiliation.

In 2011 the Fuller Youth Institute (FYI) launched the Sticky Faith series of books, articles, training, website, and curriculum. I coauthored the initial Sticky Faith volume with Kara Powell, executive director of FYI. Our subtitle spelled out the book’s goal: Everyday Ideas to Build Lasting Faith in Your Kids.

Sticky Faith was based on research into what makes faith last. Fuller Seminary initiated its College Transition Project to explore the state of young adults’ faith after high school. The findings showed that “40–50 percent of kids who graduate from a church or youth group will fail to stick with their faith in college.” (I also addressed “sticky” issues in Hurt 2.0: Inside the World of Today’s Teenagers.)

Sticky Faith quickly became a major influence in youth ministry. It was not only the most widely cited research into the actual reality of adolescents’ long-term faith; it also confirmed what we had suspected for some time: for all the good that youth ministry has done and is doing, too many students fail to stick around through graduation.

In 2012 a team of Canadian researchers studied youth “stickiness” in their country. The study, “Hemorrhaging Faith: Why and When Canadian Young Adults Are Leaving, Staying and Returning to Church,” was sobering. John Wilkinson of the Evangelical Fellowship of Canada shared three key findings:

  • Only one in three Canadian young adults who attended church weekly as a child still does so today.
  • Of the young adults who no longer attend church, half have also stopped identifying themselves with the Christian tradition in which they were raised.
  • Four primary toxins keep young people from engaging with the church: hypocrisy, judgment, exclusivity, and failure.
  • Study after study has removed all doubt: we now know that we are losing at least half of our kids, including even some of the most committed.

    Culture Clash: Students Unprepared for a Secular Society

    Allison, who approached me at a recent youth ministry convention, is one of these lost ones, as I learned while listening to her story:

    I’m not the kind of person who ever thought I would be in this situation, because my Christian experience was so good. My parents sincerely loved God and their kids, and our home was actually pretty healthy, compared to some of the homes I’ve seen.

    My parents were deeply invested in church, and that was always a very positive thing for me. I embraced their faith and made it my own. I became active myself, and also got involved with national youth ministries. I went to a good Christian college where real thought was encouraged. And unlike other students I knew, my faith never wavered.

    After college I went into “full-time Christian service” [gestures with fingers to create quotation marks] on the staff of a parachurch youth ministry organization. Those first years were magical in every way. It was like I had been designed to do this work, and I quickly climbed the ladder into more responsible leadership positions. Everything was great.

    Then suddenly, it wasn’t. Two years into the work, it was like something was shifting in me, and the very things that had been so fulfilling and affirming and life-giving to me suddenly became chores I had to do as part of my job.

    I felt like I was in a holding pattern. I was stuck in my job, but I didn’t feel the passion anymore. That’s pretty much when I quit going to church. I didn’t really get much out of it, and no one there really connected with me.

    My parents didn’t really pick up on what was going on because whenever we talked about faith, it was always about doing ministry, not anything personal. I didn’t feel I could talk to anybody about what was going on, until I met Jeremy.

    He’s the kindest, smartest, most fun person I’ve ever met. He makes me feel alive in a way I’ve never felt before. One thing I love is he’s a seeker, you know? He doesn’t have it all figured out, chapter and verse. He’s helped me see that everything I’ve always believed about Jesus is less about God, really, than it is about me lending my support to a centuries-old cultural myth that perpetuates white, male, Protestant control.

    Chap, the way I see God has changed. For me, it’s more about love than which church you go to, and honestly, I feel kind of deceived by my parents and my church.

    Allison wasn’t asking me to help her figure out God, or her relationship with Jeremy. She wanted me to help her figure out how to maintain her job, relationships, and current lifestyle now that Christ was receding into the background of her life.

    My heart was breaking too much to come up with anything good to say. I was saddened when Allison said nobody at work had noticed anything different in her spiritual life or work performance, even though her heart wasn’t in it anymore.

    That’s when the light went on for me, as it had so many times in previous conversations. It wasn’t college or Jeremy that had convinced Allison that church was largely irrelevant. Parachurch youth ministry organizations, for the most part, can ignore the value of connecting to a local congregation, or at least implicitly communicate that a church is less than necessary for a young disciple. In this case, since middle school, Allison had not been led to consider the church as her family.

    Once Allison had some distance from the cultural Christian “bubble” that she had lived within most of her life, her worldview began to open up. Working in a ministry allowed her to maintain a Christian identity for a season. But as she began to broaden her relationships outside of her work and faith community, she encountered a whole new world she had never considered before. Her story is perhaps not so much that she lost her faith as she adjusted her faith to adapt to the new world she encountered—a new world that none of the various Christian influences in her life successfully prepared her to face.

    As time went on, she eventually left the faith of her family and ministry behind.

    Sadly, she’s not alone.

    Under Pressure: Hurting and All Alone

    I write and talk so much about the hurt at the heart of so many young people that some people dismiss me as “the king of pain.” But a growing body of research shows that today’s students feel they are under intense pressure to perform to the agendas and expectations of an increasingly impersonal and disconnected world.

    Their sense of isolation, pain, and struggle is often combined with an absence of positive social support, leaving many feeling like they’re totally on their own to navigate the rapidly changing social environment. Depending on personalities and circumstances, young people can feel vulnerable, deeply bruised, angry, and intensely isolated.

    David Elkind portrays the pressure kids face: “Today’s child has become the unwilling, unintended victim of overwhelming stress—the stress borne of rapid, bewildering social change and constantly rising expectations.”

    When you grow up in an atomized, individualized society filled with agendas, worldviews, intense social-media competition, and little or no adult support, no wonder it feels like you’re living inside a pressure cooker. The prospect of journeying into mature, adjusted adulthood seems like a sick joke or, for some, a brutal death march.

    The living gospel of Christ embodied in the company of the faithful has power to confront these pressures, but too many young people eventually find that the individualistic faith they embraced when they made a personal “decision” for Christ doesn’t provide a strong enough foundation to stand on when they face the realities of life in the world.

    I know that people make fun of the millennial generation, but I do not join them. It’s a big world out there, and I’m not sure that all the youth ministry programs and special events really prepare them to survive and thrive in the world they will soon inhabit.

    I’m not saying we need to blow the whole thing up. Camps and mission trips continue to change lives. Students engaged in leadership opportunities still seem to grow and mature into Christ-centered leaders. Organizations like Young Life have a solid track record of bringing young people to Christ in middle school and high school.

    Yet they know that once a student graduates, if they haven’t been connected to a local church, there is a great probability that many of their most devoted attendees will abandon their faith. I am saying that the crises young people face today reveal the crises in our historical approach to youth ministry. The programmatic approach, which, even when done well, seems to form young people who believe that Christianity is something that belongs solely to me, is ultimately isolating and individualized. As one friend (who has chosen to remain anonymous) wrote to me in response to this chapter, “Faith is more about the youth group schedule of events than it is about growing and challenging relationships, resulting in the crisis that when kids are stripped of the program they became used to, they experience a stripping of meaning and purpose to the faith. They actually walk away with no ‘internal sense of meaning’ because it’s all been resting on external programs.”

    I believe there’s a better way. Instead of sending young people out into the world on their own, let’s introduce them to a powerful resource that’s bigger and stronger than their own internal sense of meaning: their family of faith in the universal body of Christ.

    I Was Wrong: A Theological Reflection on Youth Ministry in the Church

    If it sounds like I’m preaching to you, you’re right. But I’m also preaching to myself. When I talk about leaders who have emphasized youth ministry at the expense of the church, I must plead guilty.

    For years I’ve argued that those who do youth ministry should advocate for youth ministry. That’s why I have written, taught, and spoken on the value of youth ministry, the need for youth ministry, and the church’s culpability in not empowering a greater emphasis on youth ministry.

    I’ve pretty much looked at all ministry through the lens of youth ministry, and that’s where I made my fundamental error. My mistake was to insist—without biblical support or historical evidence—that youth ministry was the most important kind of ministry in the church. And if anybody disagreed with me, I accused them of not really caring about kids as I did.

    Now, instead of trying to separate out my personal favorite population from the Christian faith community and focusing only on that subgroup, I’m trying to focus more broadly. I want to see ministry the way Christ sees it: whole.

    For too long, too many of us have looked only at our piece of the puzzle, not the whole puzzle. May God heal our ecclesiological blindness!

    Strengthen What’s Broken

    Youth ministry is not dead, nor is it irrelevant. But it’s broken, and we need to do what we can to fix it.

    We can start by investing more energy thinking ecclesiologically than we do thinking programmatically. The question isn’t, What am I going to do next Sunday morning? It’s, What am I doing today to connect my students to all the other people in this congregation who are ready and willing to love and care for them?

    Instead of standing apart from the church and criticizing it for not caring enough, I’m going to move closer and take youth ministry in their direction. Instead of seeing youth ministry as something that’s outside the church body, I want to see the body in the fullness of its gifts for ministering to today’s children, adolescents, and emerging adults. As we lead young people to faith in Christ, let’s also usher them into a vibrant relationship with Christ’s body.

    It’s not enough to invite kids to faith and to discipleship if we do not encourage and equip them to find themselves as part of God’s household through history. Adoptive youth ministry challenges all of us to see how youth ministry fits into this story. And for that, I thank God.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑