Chapter 11 of 22

5. The Goal of Ministry in an Adoptive Church

5. The Goal of Ministry in an Adoptive Church

5

The Goal of Ministry in an Adoptive Church

Two responses to adoptive youth ministry keep ringing in my head. Both were from smart and experienced youth ministry leaders, one of whom was especially likely to give me a pass simply because I was impassioned when I talked about it. But, frankly, neither was sold.

The first said, “I don’t see why I need adoptive youth ministry. I already do that. Chap, what’s the big deal?”

And the second said, “What you’re describing is already true. We don’t have to actually do anything. God has adopted us, and so the Bible sometimes describes us in family terms. But Jesus never talked this way, and Paul uses the language sparingly, and never in a ministry context. So what’s the big deal?”

The responses were the same: “What’s the big deal?”

I love youth ministry. I love youth ministry thinking and thinkers. I love kids. And I love the frenzied diversity of the church, warts and all. At the same time, I wish that the way we have been and are doing youth ministry was the complete picture of what God is asking of us. As good as our progress has been, I can’t escape the feeling that we’ve still got to take one more step, one more leap, to do all we can to give our young the best shot at deep and lasting faith. For me that step is forming an adoptive church. Let me explain.

Keeping Your Eye on the End

So far we have explored the idea of adoptive ministry and connected that to making disciples of young people. We have looked at the essentials of adoptive ministry. Now it’s time to start thinking about putting it into practice.

As we head into implementation, the critical beginning point is to be crystal clear on where we want to end up. To do anything well, we need to know the destination. In the case of ministry, to create a structure and strategy we need to know the outcomes we’re going for. Yes, we know we want young people to know and follow Christ. But what would that mean and look like for a young college student or a twenty-seven-year-old teacher?

So let’s define the goal of adoptive youth ministry. These are my words; they may not be yours. The way I use words and the way you or your team uses words will be different. This description is intended to help you understand the essential elements of adoptive youth ministry.

While we have already addressed some basic elements of this statement, let’s explore each of the three key phrases as we prepare to implement adoptive ministry.

To Create an Environment Where Young People Are Encouraged . . .

Our most basic task in adoptive youth ministry is the environment we create for kids. Our content, our creativity, our innovation, even the numbers or quality of paid staff and leaders we have to run a great program will make very little impact if kids do not feel like they are safe, warm, and welcome.

It doesn’t take tenured scholars to figure out that people run from a cold social environment and flock to a warm one (although many have actually studied and repeatedly shown this to be true).

Think about your church. Would you describe it, if you had to make a choice, as a warm or a cold environment? This means everything from the parking to the signage to the way that people are greeted as they arrive. What about the worship service? How about church potlucks and socials, or mission trips and camps? Is your church, in sum, a generally warm church or a cold church? This is important because young people don’t like a cold environment. Who does?

Now carry this into your youth ministry (or any ministry, as the same sociological principle applies). If you can, imagine walking into your large group gathering, or a small group, or heading to camp. Would you say that these are warm or cold? You might, for example, feel like the way you do small groups is warm (in homes, with safe conversations, everyone seems genuinely comfortable). Yet when you’re honest, you may say that your room is set to the liking of the leaders rather than a warm environment for the students. A warm environment is crucial to even begin to create an adoptive ministry mindset and program. Otherwise, even for those who do continue to show up, they will have a hard time dropping their guard and truly trusting the adults.

In addition to being warm, does what you do—including everything from what happens in the parking lot to how kids or emerging adults are greeted when they enter a room to the aesthetics (music, lighting, room setup)—reflect the intention to make sure young people know that they are welcomed members of the community? This isn’t about spending money, but about commitment and intention. With even what we may consider the little things—like announcements or slides or teaching—everything we create, say, and do comes into play to create a warm or cold ministry environment. In an adoptive ministry mindset, our goal is to make sure that everything young people experience screams out at them: “This is your place. This is your church. This is your family!”

Last, and most important, do the people—everyone who represents the ministry or the church—convey a warmth toward every single young person, wherever and whoever they are? Are adults well trained to know that the goal of ministry to the young is to create a welcoming environment and everything else flows from there? Every young person deserves and longs for three things when they enter a room:

  • to know they’ve been seen (so we look them in the eye)
  • to hear their name
  • to have a genuine encounter with someone who says something nice to them
  • These are very simple things: eye contact, name recognition, and hearing something nice that connects with them. But many kids go to church and even youth groups and rarely if ever receive that kind of personal touch. Adoptive youth ministry creates connection. Because of the relational environment we are called to create, adults must be trained to know that the meeting starts when the first student shows up and it is not over until the last kid leaves. Our focus on environment, especially the relational environment, is so crucial that it should be the source from which all other ministry flows.

    . . . to Live into Their Calling in Christ as Agents of the Kingdom . . .

    The biblical and theological content of adoptive youth ministry, as we saw in chapter 4, is not as concerned with behavior or even raw cognitive knowledge (though certainly those things matter as aspects of our discipleship) as with helping students to see and hear Jesus for themselves as they engage him in community. Historically, so much of Christian discipleship has been reduced to doing Christianity instead of living into a trust in Christ that is so central and powerful that it becomes our vocation for life. Our vocation is not what is on our business card or where we receive our paycheck. It is our calling as Christ’s followers. Jesus was clear about this: “Whoever wants to be my disciple must deny themselves and take up their cross daily and follow me” (Luke 9:23). Our role in adoptive youth ministry, then, is to help our young people come to see Jesus Christ and the gospel as the calling that God has for them.

    As this whole book will reinforce, the central image for adoptive ministry is the gift of the incarnation mentioned in John 1:12—“the right to become children of God”—and this means that in the household of God the young are siblings of the old. Although few people actually talk this way about the nature of who we are together in the body of Christ, biblically there are no exceptions to this truth. Because this biblical concept is rarely talked about, perhaps this idea might at first be difficult to imagine. This will be among the most challenging hurdles you will face as you work to convince your church that it is the explicit responsibility of adults in the church to view and treat young people as their little brothers and sisters. This language alone, as people begin to get on board, can move a congregation from being slightly cold to increasingly warm. However you describe this, recognition of the co-sibling nature of the church is a necessity for adoptive youth ministry to make a dent in how young people feel about your church, or even about the Christian faith in general. If they don’t feel respected, included, and welcomed, why would they bother to remain?

    As we encourage the young to live into their calling, a key word pops out of the stated goal: “agents of the kingdom.” We will look more carefully at the idea of agency in future chapters, but for now we have to at least make sure we understand its importance. Theologically, we do not bring in the kingdom or even change the world. Our mission, to be biblical, must always be God’s mission. We are given the privilege of walking alongside God and following the promptings of the Holy Spirit as we grow to understand what God has in store for us and calls us to. This is the definition of agency: I am given power and purpose to contribute to God’s missional work. There are few adults and fewer adult-run systems and institutions that train the young in the exercise of their God-given agency. From the time they are little, youth are taught to do as they’re told and speak when spoken to. But God has bigger things in store for his children, and for his church. Yes, this is a church issue as much as a youth ministry issue, but in adoptive youth ministry the outcome of faithful biblical discipleship is unleashing the power of the Holy Spirit in God’s called agents.

    . . . within the Household of God

    This phrase is what sets adoptive ministry apart from other ways of envisioning youth ministry. If it lacked “within the household of God,” the goal could be seen as what every youth ministry does, or at least strives to do. In youth ministry circles, we have talked for years about energizing lifelong faith and the goal of nurturing passionate young people who are set free to follow hard after God. We have also worked to create an environment where kids feel safe and heard and loved, both within the youth group and by broader church leadership. In 1989, Wayne Rice’s Up Close and Personal: How to Build Community in Your Youth Group reflected what was becoming a new focus in youth ministry practice. Rice’s thinking, which still pervades youth ministry today, is that being a follower of Christ is not a solitary journey but a communal one. This was a major step forward for understanding a theology of discipleship. Community matters.

    Since then, leaders in youth ministry have recognized that we must move beyond simply building community: we need to strengthen the connections outside the adolescent peer group. This became the next wave of focus for youth ministry, and we now express this in two fundamental arenas: parent ministry and intergenerational ministry. In most churches, parent ministry has become an aspect of student ministry, at least in partnership with what has come to be called “family ministry.” And more recently the push for intergenerational ministry has become part of the overall youth ministry strategy. Both of these trends, like Rice’s book, represented further steps toward a more holistic and long-term view of ministry to the young. In churches where parent and child relationships are being encouraged and strengthened and where older generations are more connected to emerging generations, the youth ministry itself has become healthier, and deeper faith among the young is often a result.

    To many, these emphases—proactively connecting teenagers and emerging adults to one another, to their families, and to adults in a congregation—have basically settled the issue of what it means for youth ministry “to create an environment where young people are able to live into their calling in Christ as agents of the kingdom.” Why bother, then, with adoptive ministry? What is the difference?

    Let’s start with peer community. As helpful as intergroup relationships are to giving teenagers a sense of community, teenagers need more than what peers have to offer them. Young people have been raised in a culture of rampant isolation that has been described as atomized, defined as “to treat as made up of many discrete units.” There are many aspects to and reasons for this, but perhaps the most significant is the dissolution of social support for the young from adults and adult-controlled settings and systems, causing them to grow up feeling like they must live for the agenda of others and find a sense of place by “playing to the crowd.” Thus, to survive as a child, teenager, and emerging adult, young people are taught that they must perform their way into blessing. As a result, emerging generations are desperate for support, for nurture, for guidance, and for hope. As the old adage goes, two kids in a mud puddle can’t clean each other up. Someone needs to come to them with a helping hand and a clean towel.

    But aren’t intergenerational ministry and multigenerational relationships the antidote to the systemic abandonment of the young? If we just encourage the old and the young to walk together, to care for each other, isn’t that enough for young people to feel connected to the body of Christ?

    Yes and no.

    Yes, it is better than what youth ministry has been doing. Any meaningful connections are important and helpful to the overall health and psyche of an adolescent and emerging adult.

    But relational connectedness on its own is not enough to convince a young person that they are welcome and that they are vital members of a community. Sometimes, just by the nature of how a church or even a handful of adults live out their commitment to the young intergenerationally, they end up functionally applying adoptive ministry. But intentionally encouraging cross-generational relationships, or even programmatically strengthening mentoring relationships across a wide age demographic, does not necessarily offer an important piece of what young people need: contributing purpose.

    This is why the goal of adoptive youth ministry has as its trajectory “within the household of God.” A biblically driven youth ministry not only nurtures but also empowers the young to participate and contribute to the life of the body. The Scriptures make clear that everyone in the body of Christ is essential to the vitality of the community (see 1 Cor. 12 as one example). The aim of adoptive youth ministry, then, is to ensure that every person experiences life in a diverse family where everyone they meet treats them with the respect of a beloved younger sibling.

    Why does this matter? The answer lies in the goal of adoptive youth ministry: that every adult would provide for every young person a hand and a towel, to lift them up and help wash the mud from their eyes.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑