9. Nurture and the Ministry of Going
9
Nurture and the Ministry of Going
The three volunteers were right out of college. Having spent years studying youth ministry, they were now ready to plunge in and minister. After lunch, the four of us headed to the high school to spend time with students, also known as “contact work.” The school’s administration had given us permission to come onto the campus to see kids as long as we were not there to “proselytize.” I promised the administration that was fine.
“OK, guys,” I said as I parked the car. “Who wants to pray?”
“Why pray?” my friend Brandon asked.
As we talked, Brandon assured me he wasn’t against praying. “I think it’s important to pray before you teach or preach,” he said. “And I think all the staff and volunteers should pray before a youth meeting. But I never really thought about praying before contact work.”
A wonderful opportunity had presented itself, and I took advantage.
“Guys, Brandon raises a good point,” I said. “But here’s how I see this. Every time we go somewhere to see and serve students, I want to make sure we are seeing what Christ wants us to see and meeting who he wants us to meet. Praying before you teach is great, but praying before you go to meet students is important too. Let’s pray that God will open our eyes, our ears, and our hearts as we go to the school.”
One of the guys prayed, and then we walked into the school for a couple of intense hours of connecting. We talked to some of our regulars and also met some new friends.
Afterward, I asked Brandon what he thought.
“Awesome,” he said. “I had this sense that God was helping me listen more to what the kids were saying instead of always thinking about something I wanted to say.”
That day, Brandon experienced the nurturing side of adoptive youth ministry. All of us are familiar with the more public sides of ministry: teaching, preaching, and organizing events. But the quieter, subtler, more interpersonal connections between leaders and the students they serve can go a long way toward helping young people develop a relationship with Christ and with their siblings in the Christian community.
From What to Why
Today I saw this advertisement for a church seeking a youth leader:
We are looking for an experienced director of student ministry to lead and expand ministry with seventh grade through twelfth grade students and leaders. Our youth ministry seeks to build community, grow through God’s word, and reach area youth with the gospel of Jesus Christ. We have up to forty-five students in our weekly programs with around seventy registered as “active” in the church. Major responsibilities include Sunday morning Sunday school, evening youth groups, monthly events, discipleship groups, summer camps, and mission trips.
I have read hundreds of these youth leader ads, which typically focus on programmatic activities:
There’s one common denominator in these bullet items: the assumption that youth ministry is what we do with the kids who come to us. The expectation is that youth leaders put on programs that are centered on the church building and church schedule. If we do these actions well, it is assumed the job’s goals will be accomplished. That’s the way things are at most churches.
For many churches and church people, this is the only way to do youth ministry: hire a leader to do activities and events. If we build the program, kids will come and their lives will be changed.
There’s a problem with this model. It isn’t working. Yes, many students may come, but how many of them eventually stop coming? And even if they stay in our program for a while, will they start a lifelong journey of following Jesus there?
Adoptive youth ministry is different. We are far less concerned with what we do and much more concerned with why we do it and how we are moving young people toward a connection with Christ and his family. Adoptive ministry leaders are fine with “evening youth groups” or other events on the church calendar. But they’re not convinced that successfully organizing such events equals success with kids.
Let’s examine one sacred cow: Sunday school. This might work fine for some youth ministries, but let’s remember, Sunday school isn’t ministry. Sunday school is a tool we use to achieve ministry. The same goes for events, discipleship groups, and trips. As good and productive as these and other programmatic elements can be, they are not ministry but ways to express ministry.
This subtle switch from what to why is key to the success of adoptive youth ministry. Programs and activities can be great tools, but these are not the only tools we need to help students journey from the often lonely, disconnected world of adolescence or emerging adulthood into the household of God and all that comes with it.
Programs and events do not define our ministry, and we must never let them confine our ministry or hinder us from our original goals. We can’t rely on programs to move young people toward greater participation in God’s family. We need to nurture them, which means showing the kind of care that helps them grow and develop.
Why Nurture Is about Going
We’ve been talking about what versus why. Let’s add another w to the mix: where.
When leaders assume that their main job is to fulfill all the programmatic bullet items in the job description, they can forget a crucial command of Christ: to go. Instead of going to gather in lost sheep we can nurture, we take the opposite approach: “If we build it, they will come to us!” We expect the lost sheep to come to us.
Adoptive ministry embraces an intentional and proactive commitment to going in the direction of someone in need in order to nurture and care for them. That was my goal with Brandon and the other volunteers when we did contact work at the high school. I was emphasizing going, not teaching, preaching, or organizing events.
Why does adoptive ministry require us to go in order to nurture? There are four main reasons for this emphasis on going, and they are summed up in the following words: mobile, familial, communal, and strategic.
Nurture Is Mobile
If you ask some Christians what the incarnation is, they will tell you it’s something related to Christmas celebrations. But for adoptive ministry leaders, incarnation means so much more than that.
Incarnation is the word we use to describe God’s movement to our material world in the person of Jesus. “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God” (John 1:1). “The Word became flesh and blood, and moved into the neighborhood” (John 1:14 Message).
The incarnation sets the Christian faith apart from all others. While the incarnation was a one-time event, God was intentionally reaching into creation long before he sent his Son to earth. From the very beginning, God was a visiting God. He walked in the garden, looking for the hiding Adam and Eve (Gen. 3:8–9). God is a going God, a pursuing Lover. The incarnation isn’t the beginning of this story but its fulfillment. During Jesus’s life on earth, God continued to walk among us in new and amazing ways.
Jesus began his public ministry walking among the people and calling his disciples to follow him. Matthew tells us that “as Jesus was walking beside the Sea of Galilee, he saw two brothers, Simon called Peter and his brother Andrew.” Watching them fish, Jesus said to them, “Come, follow me, and I will send you out to fish for people” (Matt. 4:18–19).
One day Jesus was traveling through the land of the despised Samaritan people (John 4:4 says he “had to go through Samaria”). He sat down at a deserted well outside of town; he had sent the disciples into town to buy food. Soon a woman approached the well and, although it was outside both religious and social rules, Jesus initiated a conversation with her that would transform her life, as she became the first evangelist in the Gospel of John to a town where she was an outcast! It is as if Jesus had decided to put himself in the position to be there when she showed up (again, “he had to go through Samaria”—nobody has “to go through Samaria”; there were other options). The way the connection unfolded—Jesus sending his disciples off without him, sitting alone by a well, waiting, and then honoring a woman with a tough history by speaking to her, affirming her value by taking the dialogue to pretty deep places, and finally openly telling her that he was the expected Savior—indicates that this is no ordinary encounter. He was there, with her and for her, and his initiative altered her story in a way that changed her and her town’s life. Jesus had to go through Samaria.
Jesus never stayed put. He constantly traveled, observed, listened, and cared. His ministry of nurture was a going, mobile ministry. Likewise, Jesus sent his disciples to go and minister in his name. He told them in Luke 9:2 “to proclaim the kingdom of God and to heal the sick.” He goes further in Luke 10:1. He “appointed seventy-two others and sent them two by two ahead of him to every town and place where he was about to go.” And in the upper room with his disciples after the resurrection, Jesus told them, “As the Father has sent me, I am sending you” (John 20:21).
After Jesus had ascended into heaven (Acts 1:9), the disciples gathered together to pray and wait for the Holy Spirit to direct their next steps. The Spirit arrived in power on the day of Pentecost. Jews from many nations who had gathered in Jerusalem for the holy day were shocked to hear Jesus’s message spoken in their own languages by the power of the Spirit. This was the early church’s first big evangelistic event, and it added thousands to the embryonic household of God (Acts 2).
Later, as the church was scattered because of persecution, leaders like Philip heeded Jesus’s call to take the good news to the “ends of the earth” (Acts 1:8). Later still, Paul took three major trips in order to come alongside others to minister to those who needed the love and grace of the Savior. In his first letter to the Thessalonians, Paul reminds them that his and his companion’s “visit to [them] was not without results” (1 Thess. 2:1).
The early church knew that ministry means going to those who are in need of the gospel and of the love of Christ’s body. Somewhere along the line we seem to have forgotten this. Adoptive ministry is mobile. It seeks to resurrect this lost calling, particularly in church-centered youth ministry.
You will search the New Testament in vain for any hint of our contemporary “build it and they will come” methodology. Christ was a man on the move, and Christians were a faith community committed to going.
As early disciples went, they took their brothers and sisters in the Christian family with them. Paul shows that ministry should be as nurturing as a mother’s love: “We were gentle among you. Just as a nursing mother cares for her children, so we cared for you. Because we loved you so much, we were delighted to share with you not only the gospel of God but our lives as well” (1 Thess. 2:7–8).
Look carefully and you can see Paul addressing four aspects of nurture:
Nurture Is Communal
What’s the best way to disciple a young person? When I raise that question, many people express support for the one-on-one mentoring model. I know many believers who swear by this approach, which involves one mature believer guiding one who is younger in the faith.
I have mentored younger believers, and older leaders have mentored me. It’s a solid model. But adoptive ministry proposes an important tweak.
We believe the ministry of nurture is best delivered in community. God’s household is not a collection of isolated mentors and mentees, but a family of co-mentoring siblings. In God’s big family, we love all our siblings, and we naturally nurture one another, keeping no record or score of who is nurturing the other person most. It’s not a contest. We all share in the familial call to care for our brothers and sisters in Christ.
Familial nurturing is exactly what so many kids today want and need. As we grow into our adoption in God’s family, and grow in our love of each other, this nurturing atmosphere becomes a powerful way to draw kids into full participation in the household of God. All of us have been knit together through adoption, and all of us—adults and students—nurture one another in community.
Nurture Is Strategic
Nurture may sound warm and fuzzy, but it’s also strategic. Adoptive youth ministry wants to create the kind of welcoming space where young people can explore the message of the gospel and move incrementally into deeper faith. Programs alone can’t create that kind of space. We need to do what Jesus did to create an environment where trust and transformation take place.
Jesus went to the woman at the well. She would not have initiated the conversation herself. He reached out to her at a shared space: a well. (Today he might visit high schools, libraries, or coffee shops.) In that space she could feel his warmth. That’s all she needed to trust him. The setting was safe, and they talked. When he told her he was “the one,” she immediately ran to tell the world, “Come, see a man who told me everything I ever did. Could this be the Messiah?” (John 4:29).
Adoptive nurture is strategic. It creates spaces where we tell kids: You matter to us. We care about you. We’re not asking you to sign on a dotted line. We just want to share some of our family’s love with you. Or as J. B. Phillips translates it, “Because we loved you, it was a joy to us to give you not only the Gospel of God but our very hearts—so dear did you become to us” (1 Thess. 2:8).
From Why Back to What: Gathering Together
Some people get so caught up in the what of ministry that they forget the why. Now that we’ve explored why we must go and why we must nurture, let’s go back to the what of activities and programs.
We need to do activities and events with kids. We can organize these activities so they achieve the goals of adoptive youth ministry if we keep our focus on our three main reasons for gathering: to build trust, to build warmth, and to explore Christ’s good news together.
We Gather to Build Trust
When we get together, we have fun. We play (even though some killjoys claim play and fun have no place in adolescent ministry). We enjoy games together that you can’t enjoy sitting alone in a room with a phone or laptop.
Why? Getting young people to smile is often the first step toward helping them feel safe. Even on an otherwise serious mission trip or leadership retreat, there’s nothing better than for everyone to jump in a lake with their clothes on, or run around spraying the leader with Silly String. One of the greatest gifts adolescents bring to a faith community is that they still know how to have a blast.
Smiles help build trust. When we are flying down a zip line, or having a mud fight, or watching an obnoxiously flippant but oh-so-funny video, students have the ability to say, “These people actually want me to have fun! It’s not all about them; they know I need to let loose sometimes!” As we play together, we find ourselves more open to sharing the deeper issues of our lives together. And this is essential to helping kids prepare for inclusion within God’s household of siblings.
A warm community is what every young person seeks. A place of safety. A place where they can let down, take off their shoes, and sip hot cocoa with their closest friends in the midst of a cold winter storm.
Many researchers have discovered that for collaboration to be genuine and heartfelt, people need to feel the warmth of the community. In the study detailed in Growing Young, Powell, Mulder, and Griffin note that “we were surprised by how much of growing young is influenced by whether or not congregations are warm and accepting.” Adoptive nurture, then, is creating the space that every young person feels is warm and accepting when we gather.
As Paul shows, ministry means sharing “not only the gospel of God but our lives as well” (1 Thess. 2:8). Adoptive nurture takes place within a gathering of young people where friendship and safety are the highest values. Conformity and competition are out; unity and acceptance are in.
To nurture the young, we need to value laughter over lectures, and authentic connection over Christian acculturation. There is ample time in a warm, nurturing, familial atmosphere to dissect and examine what real-life faith is, means, and looks like. But it is vital that our adoptive nurture is located within a gathering that can only be described as warm.
We Gather to Explore Christ’s Good News Together
Why do we sing at our gatherings? Why do we teach? When I attend youth ministry gatherings, events, camps, and retreats, I often head to the back of the room during the singing and teaching times. I want to experience what the whole group is experiencing. Up front, the sophomore girls are waving their hands and praising God, but things feel totally different in the back half of the room.
That’s where most of the guys and many of the girls are sitting (unless the leader compels them to stand). Sometimes it seems they’re checked out. They might be talking to each other, or staring into space, or even trying to sort of sing without being totally into it.
Why the poor response? It’s not because they do not long to worship God, at least not all of them. Rather, for many, what we call “worship” seems like people screaming over a cheesy performance by a band of rock-and-roll wannabes.
Why do we sing at our gatherings? Why do we teach? We say we are presenting the gospel in a relevant way that connects to young people’s lives. That’s not the way it always looks from the back half of the room.
Let’s sing with gusto. Let’s teach the truth with passion. But let’s do these things in a way that brings us together as God’s family. Instead of relying on a group of elite performers, let’s create spaces and gatherings that build trust and facilitate warmth among the entire group.
We need to find ways to nurture every student, not just the ones who might love group singing or solo teaching. Our task in adoptive nurture is to know our students well enough to maintain the trust and warmth we work so hard to cultivate. Then when the time comes to explore the gospel, that exploration will be okay because it is nestled within that familial relational setting.
You may need to let kids talk to you as you teach. You will survive.
Better yet, find ways for them to share things that matter to them with the group: a meaningful poem, a funny video clip, a sad text message from a friend, or a Bible verse that encourages them.
Let’s sing. Let’s study Scripture together. But let’s also use other tools that help us create the spaces where safe, warm, communal relationships can flourish.
