8. Building Your Ministry Team
8
Building Your Ministry Team
The four Gospels show us the person, character, and work of Jesus, while the book of Acts shows how the newly instituted group of people known as “the church” lived out the calling of Christ.
Sometimes things went great, as we see from these verses in Acts 2:
They devoted themselves to the apostles’ teaching and to fellowship, to the breaking of bread and to prayer. Everyone was filled with awe at the many wonders and signs performed by the apostles. All the believers were together and had everything in common. They sold property and possessions to give to anyone who had need. Every day they continued to meet together in the temple courts. They broke bread in their homes and ate together with glad and sincere hearts, praising God and enjoying the favor of all the people. And the Lord added to their number daily those who were being saved. (vv. 42–47)
Other times things weren’t so great. Factions began to develop in some of the earliest churches. Some believers thought the congregation should do one thing, while another group felt they should do the opposite.
As we read Paul’s letters to various churches, we can see him constantly trying to encourage believers to embrace unity over disunity. Often Paul’s pleas for brotherly love circled back to where it all began: the believers’ mutual adoption in Christ. Like a stern but loving father, Paul attempted to reason with his quarrelsome children.
Listen, he said. Once upon a time each and every one of us was lost in our sin and selfishness and alienated from our Creator God. But then Jesus came along, adopting all of us spiritual orphans and lovingly placing us in a brand-new family made up of fellow brothers and sisters in Christ.
So, Paul asked, why do we want to act like we acted before we knew Christ and were transformed by the Holy Spirit? Why are we sacrificing the unity of the body of Christ over squabbles concerning who has the greater status, which teachers are the best, which spiritual gifts are most important? (See Galatians 4 and Ephesians 1 where he makes these points.)
Members of the various churches were trying to settle issues using the same tough tactics that had worked for them in their business lives or in conflicts with neighbors. Paul said there must be a better way. In 1 Corinthians 12 he explains how the body should function:
Paul’s message is clear: We believers are a body, a household of siblings where each member is equally valued. Therefore, we must function as a body. Every member is called. Every member is gifted. Every person has talents to offer. Every person is necessary to the healthy functioning of the body.
I call this a “theology of team.” But it seems that the corporate world often understands the team concept much better than Christian leaders do. As I will demonstrate in the following pages, your calling as the leader of an adoptive youth ministry is not to be a manager producing results but to be a leader who produces people who produce results. You can grow this kind of dynamic team if you want to.
The Eight Essentials of Effective Teams
Carl Larson and Frank LaFasto are business leaders and consultants who spent three years finding out how teams work. They studied successful corporations, NASA, Notre Dame’s 1966 championship football team, and the five-thousand-person crew serving on the supercarrier USS Kitty Hawk. They published their results in their 1989 book, Teamwork: What Must Go Right, What Can Go Wrong. Eight characteristics inspired by their research can help strengthen our own ministry teams.
A Clear, Elevating Goal
Larson and LaFasto argue that a clear, elevating goal is the single most important characteristic of effective teams. In cases where the goal is not clear, different people have different ideas and objectives, leading to conflict and disunity within the team.
Mundane, ho-hum goals are not sufficient. In order for people to rally around it, a goal must be clear and compelling enough to hold the team members’ attention and inspire their excitement and commitment. In effective teams, not only does each member know and articulate the collective goal, but each member also knows deep down that the goal matters.
The goal of adoptive youth ministry is both clear and elevating. Our purpose is not to invite individual young people to make individual decisions about their individual spiritual lives. When we align our lives with Christ, we find ourselves in a new family where we can experience a sense of community, connectedness, unity, and teamwork that eluded us prior to coming to faith.
Unfortunately, the history of youth ministry in America has focused more on individualism than unity or community. In part, that’s because our youth work forefathers largely embraced the model of the tent revival, where each person is called to make a decision for Christ. This individual invitation to faith overflows into our individual approach to discipleship. Our culture’s value of rugged individualism outweighs the biblical mandate for unity within the body.
In youth ministry, this individualism manifests itself in believers who say, “I’m on my own to fulfill the calling that I have in Christ.” Our appeals to students are often based on personal faith and piety, not adoption into the community of believers.
You and your coworkers can successfully override these cultural currents if you commit yourself to creating a team where your goal of adoptive youth ministry is crystal clear to each and every person—from the youth leader to direct ministry volunteer to indirect ministry volunteer.
And how do you know if your team members are on board with the goal? Ask them. It’s amazing how raising questions about our core ministry goal—our reason for doing ministry in the first place—can bring clarity and resolve to discussions where people seem to have different ideas about what to do.
Your job is to make sure that every small group leader, the person who sets up the chairs, the guy who flips burgers, and the woman who drives the van to the mission trip can state the mission of adoptive youth ministry with precision (clear) and enthusiasm (elevating).
To repeat, this is the goal we have been working from:
The goal of adoptive youth ministry is to create an environment where young people are encouraged to live into their calling in Christ as agents of the kingdom within the household of God.
Leaders must ensure that this ministry goal is clearly communicated, understood, and wholeheartedly embraced by all members of the team. This won’t happen in a day. It requires a long-term commitment and regular coaching to make sure everyone gets on—and stays on—the same page.
I’ve personally seen how a clear and compelling goal can revolutionize youth ministries and empower everyone involved to promote the group’s shared vision. You will know you have arrived when the person who sweeps the floors is convinced that clean floors support an environment where students may encounter Christ alongside their spiritual siblings; when parents who sign up for the prayer ministry feel connected to the goal and can contribute through this powerful form of indirect ministry; and when team meetings are punctuated by various members quoting the goal and strategizing how to most effectively reach it.
It’s not enough that you and a handful of the most faithful volunteers know the goal. Your job is to train each and every member of your team to see that their role in the work is just as essential as that done by all the other fellow agents of the kingdom of God.
We’ll finish our look at a clear, elevating goal (as we will for each of the characteristics of effective teams) by summarizing the key elements (the dos, the don’ts, and the must) of this essential characteristic.
The Dos of a Clear, Elevating Goal
The Don’ts of a Clear, Elevating Goal
The Must of a Clear, Elevating Goal
Everyone on the team must know, believe in, and commit to this purpose.
A Results-Driven Structure
With the goal clearly in mind, you’re ready to focus on the structure of your adoptive youth ministry. But remember, your assignment as a leader is not to do everything that needs to be done, but to encourage and enable the team that will make it happen.
It’s amazing what a community focused on a single goal can achieve when they know that everything they do is pointing in the same direction. For one thing, you can stop focusing on programs and activities as ends in themselves and begin seeing them as steps toward achieving your ministry’s goals. For example:
I’m not proposing you set fire to your library of games and activities, but rather that you use adoptive youth ministry to help determine which of these activities will actually help you reach your goal and which activities will hinder your progress.
The Dos of a Results-Driven Structure
The Don’ts of a Results-Driven Structure
The Must of a Results-Driven Structure
Everyone on the team must see how everything they do points in the direction of the goal of adoptive youth ministry.
Competent Team Members
Research shows that leaders typically believe they are doing a better job of helping team members excel than they actually are. That’s too bad, because one of your most important tasks as a leader is to make sure all the people on your team are maximizing their callings. Larson and LaFasto warn about these blind spots among team leaders: “The most severe complaint about team leadership from team members involves leaders who are unwilling to confront and resolve issues associated with an adequate performance by team members. Leaders see themselves as far more active in this area than do team members.”
Let’s use football to illustrate the point. You’re the coach of a team, and all your players are committed to all eight of the team characteristics. But you’ll never win any games without a quarterback to throw passes, or without a left tackle to keep pass rushers from gang-tackling your quarterback. You need competent team members to fill these positions if you want to succeed and win.
So how do you translate this model from the football field to adoptive youth ministry? You need to make sure your team members are well suited to and capable in the roles they take on. For me, this includes basic functional competency in their area of service as well as factors like self-awareness and Christian commitment.
For example, how do you recruit competent small group leaders? Everyone who expresses a willingness to be a part of your team deserves the opportunity to work with leadership and see if their callings to serve match the ministry’s needs and expectations. Hopefully, you can place every competent volunteer in a role that fits his or her gifts and talents.
Ideally, you want to fill every role with good volunteers, but what happens if you experience a personnel shortfall? That’s where you have to make changes. Perhaps one year your ministry offers your students four small groups (for boys and girls of different ages), but the next year you can only staff two small groups. One way to address this is to offer small groups in the fall for the girls and in the spring for the guys. That would be better than keeping all four groups but having some led by people who are not competent to do so.
Helping people find a place to serve that matches their gifts is a wonderful experience, but your duty does not stop there. You must regularly train them (see chap. 7) to help them reach their full effectiveness. In doing so, you will help them grow in competency, which helps your team reach its goal.
The Dos of Having Competent Team Members
The Don’ts of Having Competent Team Members
The Must of Having Competent Team Members
A team leader’s primary role is to help others who are called to the team to succeed.
Unified Commitment
When some leaders try to ascertain the commitment level of their team members, they adopt a simple metric: commitment is revealed when people show up and do the work, and those who don’t show up don’t care.
This is sometimes the case, but it’s far from a rule. People in your congregation have a variety of responsibilities. Some are in demanding professional careers. Some have children with special needs or are caring for ailing parents. Others have bad bosses who demand they work overtime without any warning. These busy people may care about your ministry but lack the freedom to be as involved as they would like to be. Please don’t make the mistake of prematurely writing off these valuable people.
Time is an important factor in measuring commitment, but I think it’s better to measure commitment by understanding people’s determination and heart. One volunteer may be retired and have extra time on his hands, allowing him to attend every single leader meeting you schedule. Another volunteer may show up late to events or programs, or even cancel at the last minute. Understandably, these kinds of scenarios can drive a wedge between team members. The consistent volunteers may even resent those they see as less committed, leading to anger and bitterness. But those who can’t attend—because they’ve been called out of town, or the boss just demanded more work—may actually be more committed to your team’s adoptive ministry goal than the ones who are there regularly.
Your role as the leader is to help potential volunteers discern what kind of involvement is reasonable. A flight attendant, police officer, or high school teacher who is also a referee should never be excluded from direct ministry simply because they may have to be late or miss meetings and events. The key to avoiding conflict is to make sure that people’s schedules and commitment are known and even celebrated team-wide.
It takes all kinds of saints to build relational bridges with the various young people in your ministry. And students generally care less about a person’s schedule than they care about a person’s willful commitment to them. Students can tell the difference between someone who truly cares and someone who is just along for the ride.
The Dos of Unified Commitment
The Don’ts of Unified Commitment
The Must of Unified Commitment
Since “health breeds health” and people want to be a part of something where they are valued and encouraged, create a family-like leadership team and ethos to foster an environment where adoptive youth ministry can flourish.
A Collaborative Climate
What does it mean to collaborate? A few simple illustrations will paint a clearer picture than a dictionary definition.
When I am dancing a slow dance with my wife, she and I collaborate by moving together instead of each of us moving separately. If we’re successful, we experience a oneness as we move together.
When I am working on an article or a book with another leader, we collaborate by sharing our ideas freely and seeing which ones make the most sense to the most youth workers instead of duking it out for control or dominance.
Collaboration is actually at the heart of all ministry, because nothing takes place unless we collaborate with the Holy Spirit in what we do. And it is especially crucial as we try to build an adoptive youth ministry.
In my experience, collaboration in youth ministry is often more about the feel or spirit of a team than the logistics involved in doing a particular task. Team members need to feel that they are working together in unity to achieve shared ministry goals. They need to “be” as a team before they “do” the team’s work. Another way to say it is this: we are called to be the people of God before we do the work of God.
What does it take to be a collaborative team member, and how can a leader foster collaboration in ministry? This can be challenging, because some people will be more naturally committed to a collaborative way of working than others. As Larson and LaFasto say, “The attitudes, styles, and interaction patterns of team members have a direct impact on performance outcomes.” (The authors’ “Collaborative Team Member rating sheet” provides a helpful tool for evaluating team members’ willingness and ability to work with others on the team.)
In some cases, collaboration is a function of personality type. People who are open, supportive, and generally positive are typically more willing to work collaboratively than those who are closed, unsupportive, and negative. Training can help Lone Rangers adopt a more collaborative approach, but this doesn’t work with everyone. When I encounter a person who has difficulty collaborating, I find a different role for them that requires less teamwork.
Your role in adoptive youth ministry is about environment as much as it is about “production” or “effectiveness.” Your willingness to serve others instead of ruling over them will go a long way toward creating the kind of dynamic spiritual climate that is magnetic to both volunteers and students.
“We are called to be the people of God before we do the work of God.”
Collaboration is important in many settings, but it’s essential when your goal is adoptive youth ministry. Our goal is clear and direct: to create an environment where adolescents are encouraged to live into their mutual adoption in Christ as siblings in the household of faith as agents of the kingdom.
If you can create a collaborative climate where all members are committed to modeling spiritual unity, the impact your volunteers have will be magnified many times.
The Dos of Creating a Collaborative Climate
The Don’ts of Creating a Collaborative Climate
The Must of Creating a Collaborative Climate
Since modeling family relationships is an essential aspect of adoptive youth ministry, ensure that the youth ministry team likes being and serving together like a family.
Standards of Excellence
If you are a salesperson, your goal is clear: make more sales. If you play soccer, your goal is to score more points and block more shots.
But a salesperson who arrives late for work, doesn’t keep accurate records, or doesn’t return phone calls will not succeed at his job. And a college athlete who ignores off-season workouts, eats poorly, and takes shortcuts in practice will eventually find herself cut from the team. That’s why successful companies and teams require a basic commitment to standards of excellence that match the task at hand.
Those of us who minister to young people have embraced a high calling that comes with high standards and expectations. The apostle Paul made this clear in a series of pastoral letters that spell out the high standards of excellence required of all servants of the gospel. Paul frequently offered his own life as a model that other leaders should emulate: “You are witnesses, and so is God, of how holy, righteous and blameless we were among you who believed. For you know that we dealt with each of you as a father deals with his own children, encouraging, comforting and urging you to live lives worthy of God, who calls you into his kingdom and glory” (1 Thess. 2:10–12).
In academic circles, there is much hand-wringing about how to discuss standards of excellence, as one journal article explained: “Because it lacks content, ‘excellence’ serves in the broadest sense solely as an (aspirational) claim of comparative success: that some thing, person, activity, or institution can be asserted in a hopefully convincing fashion to be ‘better’ or ‘more important’ than some other (often otherwise incomparable) thing, person, activity, or institution—and, crucially, that it is, as a result, more deserving of reward. But this emphasis on reward is itself often poisonous to the actual qualities of the underlying activity.”
In youth ministry settings, excellence should not become elitism. We are not separating sheep from goats here, but merely seeking to have the right people in the right spots.
As a ministry leader, you are not setting yourself apart from others but identifying with them as a fellow sinner saved by grace, and a fellow child of God who is grateful that God saw fit to adopt you into his family. You are modeling, in essence, what you are trying to elicit from your church community in adoptive youth ministry.
You do not want to send the exclusionary message that some people aren’t qualified to be involved in the ministry. It’s better to say, “Come one, come all, and we’ll get you started with our mandatory training that will help get you up to speed on our standards and practices.”
You never know who will answer the call. Nancy, a seventy-seven-year-old at a church I have been working with, offered to “help out with the kids,” and soon she was thrust into the role of a small group leader of eleventh- and twelfth-grade girls. After several months she confided in me, “I haven’t changed them, they’ve changed me!” The young women Nancy works with say the same thing. “Nancy has been such a gift to us,” one shared with me. “She loves us as we are, and she doesn’t throw advice at us or talk down to us, but treats us like we have something to offer her.”
As an adoptive youth ministry leader, your standards of excellence should focus on two things:
By committing yourself to this kind of leadership, you are probably doing something for your kids that’s way more important than any single lesson you have ever taught. You’re displaying what it really looks like to practice full inclusion among all of us siblings in God’s amazing kingdom.
The Dos of Standards of Excellence
The Don’ts of Standards of Excellence
The Must of Standards of Excellence
Team leadership must be more concerned with encouraging people to grow in their authentic walk with Christ than with running the program.
External Support and Recognition
When volunteers become frustrated, there are two things you will hear them say:
When I hear volunteers say these things, it typically means they are not getting the support and encouragement they need to thrive in their ministerial roles.
When team members feel supported and encouraged, it’s far easier for them to believe that they are making an impact. But when they don’t get that encouragement, their spirits weaken and their confidence sinks.
Larson and LaFasto’s research in the business world revealed that even sky-high salaries aren’t enough to soothe the souls of corporate titans who are discouraged about the impact or significance of their work.
I’ve seen it myself. People may have a strong inner sense of purpose and calling when they first volunteer to join your team, but the strength of that passion wanes when challenges set in and the personal payoffs seem lower than anticipated.
God has designed us to want to be in the game, to matter, and to make a difference. Positive psychology refers to this as discovering one’s purpose. But without external support and recognition, that purpose can erode into self-defeat and discouragement. Even the most faithful volunteer or staff person needs a healthy dose of both support and recognition in order to stay the course in ministry.
I suspect some readers may be getting nervous at this point. Relax! Don’t think of support and encouragement as something new to add to your endless list of duties. Rather, embrace it as a foundational part of your ongoing relationship with and training of your team members.
Think of support as the ongoing work of making sure a team member knows that they have the team—and especially church leaders—on their side. If they need something, there will be a way to find it. When they feel like they are ill-equipped for a given situation or issue, then the team has both the resources and the will to ensure that the person gets what they need.
Far too often, once the initial training and structure have been implemented, support falls off the leadership’s radar. One strategy for providing the necessary support is to enlist an indirect ministry team whose job is to provide support to the direct ministry volunteers on a consistent basis. As we saw in chapter 7, a ministry that creates a vision and support structure can provide an ideal vehicle for this type of service.
How you do it is up to you, whether specific team members are given this responsibility or a team leader builds a mutual support system among team members. Either way, it is essential that every team member feels supported by the whole and by the leader, who is ultimately responsible for the morale of the team.
But don’t stop there. Adults who give themselves away in the service of young people deserve—and often need—strong and regular doses of external recognition. Some leaders do this at an annual “volunteer banquet.” Others recognize volunteers during a worship service at the end of the year. And while general public expressions of appreciation are fine, we can go further in encouraging and supporting our volunteers.
In a healthy family, members encourage one another when they see someone is hurting or needs an emotional lift. That’s what an adoptive church does in the household of God. In ministry it is all too easy to focus on the tasks that we do in ministry rather than fostering adoptive community family-like care. A harried single mother may need an extra measure of care, and when a volunteer goes out of her way to step in, leadership should do our best not only to encourage that volunteer’s commitment but also to acknowledge that this kind of service is what ministry is about.
Instead of handing out plaques, have appreciative church members tell personal stories of how they saw each individual team member play a valuable role in a teen’s life. Have leaders stop by a volunteer or small group meeting just to say thank you to the team member. Send someone an email, thanking them for the specific spiritual gift they bring to the body.
The key is to support and encourage team members in ways that are specific and clear so they know someone notices and appreciates all their work and effort.
The Dos of External Support and Recognition
The Don’ts of External Support and Recognition
The Must of External Support and Recognition
The team leadership must ensure that every member knows that they matter as a person more than as a leader.
Principled Leadership
For a team to function well, members must trust their leader. This is so foundational that it should hardly need mentioning, but unfortunately many of us know from personal experience that it does need mentioning.
So what does “principled leadership” look like in practice? I consider three things essential.
First, a ministry team leader must treat others in a way that aligns with the message we proclaim. In adoptive youth ministry, where the entire emphasis is family-like relationships among equally valued siblings, a leader who treats people like they are tools or pawns on a chessboard undercuts the theological foundations of the ministry.
When each team member is treated as a called and gifted peer, students see what kinds of relationships they can expect in the church at large. But when students see leaders take advantage of others or exploit their power, the game is up. Our words matter, but our actions speak much louder.
Second, we ministry leaders must seek consistency in how our personal faith affects and informs our daily living. There must be alignment between what we say and how we live if we expect students and volunteers to place confidence in us as trustworthy and reliable guides on the journey of faith.
I have used the words consistency and alignment, but young people have their own word for people who do what I’m talking about: authenticity.
Some leaders project that they are wise in all things and utterly invincible, which can make them seem unapproachable. Others project that they are weak and uncertain and beset by constant sins and temptations, which makes them seem just like the kids. Why would kids trust that person? For many young people today, authenticity is a high value. But they also want adults in their lives who, while honest about their real life struggles, also have the ability to move through their circumstances with hope and faith. The rule of thumb, then, for those of us serving adolescents relationally is to offer ourselves as a friend on a journey without inviting young people into our current or habitual struggles. Some adults have used kids as best friends or even confidants. But kids have enough to worry about for themselves, and this is the last thing they need from someone in a leadership role. Instead, we need to find our own safe places to wrestle with the difficult struggles of life and faith.
And above all, if you (or anyone else on the team) have lost your spiritual footing, or become involved in immorality, or for some reason lost faith in Christ, you must be honest enough to step away from the leadership role, if even for just a season.
Third, while we must be deadly serious about our responsibility as leaders, we must remain approachable and teachable. Being open to helpful and respectful critique, offering a spirit of collegial friendship to one another (and students), and seeking to be connected with team members beyond the ministry roles we play will all go a long way in creating a sense that the leader can be trusted.
The Dos of Principled Leadership
The Don’ts of Principled Leadership
The Must of Principled Leadership
The team leader must be a person who leads as the first among equals who encourages the inherent worth of each team member.
Building the Ministry Team
It takes a commitment to strategic thinking to facilitate an adoptive ministry and to create the kind of environment where young people feel nurtured, empowered, and included. For adoptive ministry to take hold, how you put the pieces together to implement your vision is crucial. First, it is important to create your ministry based on your context (chap. 6). Second, you will gather around you ministry partners who are committed and trained to flesh out your goal (chap. 7). Finally, your work is to build a team of people who will represent Jesus Christ and the local community in relationship with students and young adults. This chapter is about that team, making sure that everyone is on the same page with the style and end goal of everything that happens in the name of ministry. Each person, whether their role is visible or background, small or large, is a crucial link in helping a young person make the transition from the isolating world of adolescence and emerging adulthood into the family-like community of God’s household. Taking each volunteer seriously, then, is what adoptive ministry is all about.
Now the table is set and the meal is ready. It’s time to roll up our sleeves and serve our young siblings.
