Chapter 9 of 17

6. Andrew Fuller (1754–1815): Faithful amid Heartbreak

6. Andrew Fuller (1754–1815): Faithful amid Heartbreak

six

Andrew Fuller (1754–1815): Faithful amid Heartbreak

STEVE WEAVER

Although Andrew Fuller is a long-neglected figure, studies about him are enjoying a renaissance. William Carey, the father of modern missions, has understandably received much more interest academically and popularly. Lesser known is the circle of friends who served with Carey to awaken the English Baptists of the late eighteenth century to the cause of global missions.

Chief among these friends was Andrew Fuller, a pastor-theologian who was one of the most prominent polemicists among evangelicals at the turn of the nineteenth century. Fuller, whom Charles Spurgeon called “the greatest theologian of the century,” was unquestionably the theologian behind the modern missionary movement. Yet even among those who have become acquainted with his theology, few know Fuller’s faithfulness throughout a lifetime of heartbreak.

Who Was Andrew Fuller?

Andrew Fuller was born on February 5, 1754, in the village of Wicken in Cambridgeshire, England. He was born into a family of Baptists at a time when the Particular Baptists of England were strongly influenced by what is known as hyper- or high-Calvinism. Hyper-Calvinism is a term used to refer not to those who merely believe in the five points of Calvinism but to those who additionally affirm the eternal justification of the elect and reject the public and promiscuous proclamation of the gospel. The doctrine of eternal justification was sometimes used as an excuse not to openly invite all people to believe the gospel.

Instead, hyper-Calvinists believe that one should wait for a “warrant” or evidence of election in individuals before calling sinners to believe in Christ. Although the evangelical revival was flourishing in the United Kingdom through the preaching of men such as John Wesley and George Whitefield, most Particular Baptist congregations remained unaffected by this evangelistic movement.

Fuller’s own personal testimony is the story of his times in miniature. He was raised in a hyper-Calvinistic background. His own pastor rarely addressed unbelievers. His early experience led to later questions regarding the sinner’s duty to believe in Christ. The teaching that evidence of election was necessary before the opportunity to believe the gospel could be set before any sinner led Fuller to languish for a number of years without the confidence to approach Christ for mercy. Although Fuller read John Bunyan’s Pilgrim’s Progress and many other works that told of Christ’s sufficiency to save, he still lacked confidence that he had the right to believe in Christ.

Eventually Fuller found what he was so desperately seeking in the Word of God. Divine warnings and promises together drove Fuller to faith in Christ. In 1770 Fuller was baptized and became a member of the local Baptist church in Soham. Five years later he became that church’s pastor. However, in his early years as pastor, he was still influenced by the hyper-Calvinism of his youth and did not dare invite the unconverted to come to Jesus. By 1778 all that had changed. Fuller’s study of Scripture, his rereading of Bunyan, and his fellowship with pastors John Sutcliff of Olney, John Ryland Jr. of Northampton, and Robert Hall Sr. of Arnesby led him to change his view. Hall had introduced Fuller to the writings of the American theologian Jonathan Edwards, specifically recommending his treatise on the freedom of the will.

Edwards’s distinction between moral and natural ability/inability was seized upon by Fuller as a way of understanding both how sinners have the duty to respond to the preaching of the gospel and why Christians have the responsibility to offer the gospel to all indiscriminately. In 1781 Fuller wrote a book that would become one of the main theological foundations for the modern missionary movement. The title of the book nearly says it all: The Gospel of Christ Worthy of All Acceptation: or The Obligations of Men Fully to Credit, and Cordially to Approve, Whatever God Makes Known. Wherein is Considered the Nature of Faith in Christ, and the Duty of Those Where the Gospel Comes in That Matter. It is commonly known simply as The Gospel Worthy of All Acceptation, and it strongly called for the “promiscuous” proclamation of the gospel to all peoples.

Fuller’s commitment to world missions was shown not only in his writings but also in his actions. He was instrumental in the formation of the Baptist Missionary Society in 1792, which sent out his friend William Carey, “the father of modern missions,” to India. Fuller was elected the first secretary of the society and kept that position until his death by tuberculosis on May 7, 1815.

Trials of Andrew Fuller

Throughout his ministry, Fuller experienced his share of physical and emotional suffering. Specifically, he had a stroke in 1793 that resulted in headaches for the rest of his life. He also seems to have been prone to a depression that plagued him intermittently throughout his life. In addition, Fuller dealt with what the apostle Paul calls “the daily pressure . . . of . . . anxiety for all the churches” (2 Cor. 11:28). By all accounts Fuller was a faithful pastor, father, and husband. His faithfulness to his pastoral, familial, and missional responsibilities even while enduring heartbreaking trials with dear family members is the focus of the remainder of this chapter.

Heartbreak of the Loss of a Child

Fuller experienced the loss of eight children. In an era of high childhood mortality, most of these were lost in infancy. However, two of his children from his first marriage, Robert (whose story will be explored below) and Sally, survived infancy, and both were the source of terrible heartbreak for their father. In a journal entry from December 1785, Fuller speaks of his ill little girl and confesses, “If God should take either of my children from me, I seem as if I could scarcely sustain it.”

Over the next several months, Fuller’s diary was filled with references to his fears about the health of his six-year-old daughter. On January 8, 1786, Fuller writes, “Exceedingly distressed . . . I fear God will take away my child.” Fuller struggled with whether he was being chastised by God. Concern for his little girl occupied his mind at all times. On February 5, he writes that “the measles came out” on Sally. Of the period from March 12 to April 16, Fuller writes that he “had great exercise of heart, on account of my poor little daughter: sometimes, pleading hard with God, on her account; at other times, ready to despair, fearing that God would never hear me.” On April 21, he admits that “if God were to cut off my poor child, and were not to afford me some extraordinary support under the stroke, that I should be next to dead to the whole creation, and all creation dead to me!” Six days later he writes that he was “willing to leave her in the hands of God.” And on May 7, Fuller writes:

I was tolerably supported under the approaching death of my poor child, which I saw drawing on apace. I saw I must shortly let her fall. With floods of tears, with all the bitterness of an afflicted father mourning for his firstborn, I committed her to God, to his everlasting arms when she should fall from mine.

Nevertheless, the blow would not be easy. Fuller’s entry for the period of May 14 to 31 began bleakly. “Death! Death is all around me!” On May 25, he was especially overwhelmed with grief. He “lay before the Lord, weeping like David, and refusing to be comforted.” His grief was so great that he became ill and was unable to see his daughter in her final days. He describes how he learned of her passing from his own sick bed:

On Tuesday morning, May 30, as I lay ill in bed, in another room, I heard a whispering. I inquired, and all were silent . . . all were silent! . . . But all is well! I feel reconciled to God. I called my family round my bed. I sat up, and prayed as well as I could; I bowed my head, and worshipped, and blessed a taking as well as a giving God.

Two days later Fuller was able to get up and attend his daughter’s funeral preached by his friend John Ryland Jr. from 2 Kings 4:26—“It is well.” Fuller stated that he felt “in general now, a degree of calm resignation.” A few days later, he would record that his “resignation and serenity” came due to his belief that “the event was decided by an infallible God.” He hoped not in the belief that God had nothing to do with his daughter’s death. Rather, he found comfort in trusting a sovereign God who cannot err. In a meditation on the “Mystery of Providence” from Job 12:6–25, Fuller declares that “it is a part of that great system of providence that directs all human suffering, and will ultimately issue in the greatest good.” Fuller’s confidence in God’s sovereignty enabled him to see, even through tears, that his heartbreak would result finally in his good and God’s glory.

On June 3 he stood over her grave “with a great deal of composure” and “felt a sort of triumph over death.” The next day he preached on “these light afflictions” with a “calm and serene” mind. Although not necessarily the same sermon referenced, Fuller once preached a sermon on “The Magnitude of the Heavenly Inheritance” from Romans 8:18–23 in which he described how heavy afflictions could be considered light. He preached to others in words that he surely had to preach to himself: “They may be heavy and tedious, when viewed by themselves; but weighed against a far more exceeding and eternal weight of glory, they are light and momentary.” It was Fuller’s confidence in the future reward and reunion of heaven that enabled him to endure the heartbreak of the loss of a child.

Heartbreak of the Loss of a Wife

Another source of heartbreak was the loss of his first wife, Sarah. This occurred in August 1792, although for three months prior she seemed to have suffered from a form of dementia or Alzheimer’s. As anyone who has faced this hardship within their family or with a church member can attest, this is a dreadful disease. Alzheimer’s has often been called “the long good-bye.” On July 10, 1792, Fuller writes in his diary, “My family afflictions almost overwhelmed me; and what is yet before me I know not! For about a month past, the affliction of my dear companion has been extremely heavy.” The day before, he had written in more detail in a letter to his friend John Ryland:

My domestic trials are exceedingly great, far, very far, beyond what I ever met with before. I was taken ill last Friday, July 7, with a pain under my left breast, and was bled on Saturday. Yesterday, (Lord’s Day), I could not engage in any thing, nor could I have done so, if Mr. Hall, who providentially was in town, had not been here. I feel better this morning, though I have had but little more than two hours’ sleep. You need not speak of it; but Mrs. Fuller has not slept at all last night, and, through the effect of her hysterical complaints, she is, at this time, as destitute of reason as an infant. My heart has not much sunk, because I look upon the derangement of her mind to be temporary; but the Lord knows what is before us!

Unfortunately, Fuller’s hope that his wife’s mental state would be temporary was not to be fulfilled. On July 25 Fuller cries out to God in the safe confines of his diary: “O my God, my soul is cast down within me! The afflictions in my family seem too heavy for me! O Lord, I am oppressed, undertake for me! My thoughts are broken off, and all my prospects seem to be perished!” During this time, Fuller drew encouragement from Scripture. He specifically cited biblical passages providing him support such as, “All things work together for good” (Rom. 8:28), “God, even our own God, shall bless us” (Ps. 67:6 KJV), and “It is of the LORD’s mercies that we are not consumed” (Lam. 3:22 KJV).

Throughout July and August of 1792, Sarah’s mind was almost constantly confused. During these times, she considered her husband and her children as her worst enemies. Andrew Gunton Fuller, Fuller’s son from his second marriage, records her deportment during this period.

She imagined that he was not her husband, but an imposter, who had entered the house and taken possession of all that belonged to her; supposing at other times that she had wandered from home, and had fallen among strangers. Her frequent attempts to escape rendered it necessary that she should be watched day and night.

Two weeks before Sarah died, however, she had a period of clarity, much to the delight of her husband. Fuller describes their exchange in a letter to Sarah’s father:

She had one of the happiest intervals of any during her affliction. She had been lamenting on account of this imposter that was come into her house, and would not give her the keys. She tried for two hours to obtain them by force, in which time she exhausted all her own strength and almost mine. Not being able to obtain her point, as I was necessarily obliged to resist her in this matter, she sat down and wept, threatening me that God would surely judge me for treating a poor helpless creature in such a manner! I also was overcome with grief; I wept with her. The sight of my tears seemed to awaken her recollection. With her eyes fixed upon me, she said: “Why, are you indeed my husband?” “Indeed, my dear, I am.” “Oh, if I thought you were, I could give you a thousand kisses.” “Indeed, my dear, I am your own dear husband.” She then seated herself upon my knee and kissed me several times. My heart dissolved with mixture of grief and joy. Her senses were restored, and she talked as rationally as ever.

On August 23, Fuller lost his wife of sixteen years. “Poor soul!” Fuller writes. “What she often said is now true. She was not at home . . . I am not her husband . . . these are not her children . . . but she has found her home . . . a home, a husband, and a family better than these.” Fuller had peace because he knew that Sarah was at peace. As difficult as this trial was, the most difficult still awaited Fuller.

Heartbreak of a Wayward Son

Andrew Gunton Fuller called the episode with Robert Fuller “a trial more severe even than that of losing his beloved wife.” Robert was Fuller’s oldest son. He showed an early interest in the ministry. However, as Robert had not yet publicly professed faith in Christ, in May 1796 his father found him employment with a warehouse in London. He quickly lost that job, and Fuller helped him gain employment in Kettering. Once again, Robert failed to apply himself and demonstrated a tendency to restlessness. Robert’s inability to hold down a job was a great cause of sorrow for his father, who writes to a friend:

Those who have had no instruction, no pious example, no warnings or counsels, are often seen to be steady and trusty; but my child, who has had all these advantages, is worthy of no trust to be placed in him. I am afraid he will go into the army, that sink of immorality; or, if not, that being reduced to extremity, he will be tempted to steal. And, oh! if he should get such a habit, what may not these weeping eyes witness, or this broken heart be called to endure! O my God, whither will my fears lead me? Have mercy upon me, a poor unhappy parent! Have mercy upon him, a poor ungodly child!

Fuller’s greatest fear was realized when Robert joined the army. Fuller was able to secure his discharge due to him being bound to an apprenticeship, but Robert immediately enlisted with the Marines. After serving two years, he wrote to his father expressing sorrow and seeking release. Again, Fuller secured his discharge. However, Robert’s restless spirit was again unable to be satisfied, and his father secured a job for him aboard a merchant’s ship. Before he could assume this new position, Robert was forced into service on a military ship. Not long after setting sail, Fuller received the horrifying report that Robert had been convicted of a misdemeanor, sentenced to three hundred lashes, and died from the severe punishment. When his father heard the news, he lamented in the words of David, “O Absalom! my son! my son! would I had died for thee, my son!” The report of Robert’s death turned out to be false, but Fuller’s trials with his son were far from over.

Three years later, Robert deserted in Ireland and was punished so severely that he was unable to continue his tour on the sea. He eventually made his way home to his father, but before long he reenlisted in the Marines. Four years passed before Robert wrote to his father, who replied with an earnest appeal for his son’s salvation. After assuring Robert of his forgiveness, Fuller pleads for his son’s “repentance towards God and faith towards our Lord Jesus Christ, without which there is no forgiveness from above.” He goes on to appeal to Robert’s heart with the message of the mercy of Christ:

You have had a large portion of God’s preserving goodness, or you had ere now perished in your sins. Think of this, and give thanks to the father of mercies who has hitherto preserved you. Think, too, how you have requited Him, and be ashamed for all that you have done. Nevertheless, do not despair. Far as you have gone, and low as you are sunk in sin, yet if from hence you return to God by Jesus Christ, you will find mercy. Jesus Christ came into the world to save sinners, even the chief of sinners. If you had been ever so sober and steady in your behavior towards men, yet without repentance towards God and faith in Christ, you could not have been saved. And if you return to God by Him, though your sins be great and aggravated, you will find mercy.

Subsequent letters from Robert gave the family some hope of his conversion, but there was still no certainty for them when they received word that Robert had perished off the coast of Lisbon, Spain, in March 1809. The day after the family received the news was the Lord’s Day. Fuller preached from Romans 10:8–9 and took comfort from the following three thoughts:

That the gospel is suited to sinners of all degrees, it asks not how long, or how often, or how greatly we have sinned; that it is suited to the helpless condition of sinners; that it is suited to sinners in the last extremity, it answers to the promised mercy in Deuteronomy 4:29: “If from thence thou shalt seek the Lord thy God, thou shalt find Him.” Some are far from home, and have no friend in their dying moments to speak a word of comfort, but this is near. When Jonah was compassed about by the floods, when the billows and waves passed over him, he prayed the Lord, and the Lord heard him.

At this point in the sermon, the anguished father apparently burst into tears.

In 1845, thirty years after the elder Fuller died, his son Andrew Gunton Fuller met a Mr. Waldy, a deacon of the Baptist church in Falkirk. Waldy told him that he knew his brother, Robert, while they were shipmates. Waldy and Robert had been close, and Waldy told Robert’s younger brother that Robert had been “a very pleasing, nice youth, and became a true Christian man.” Perhaps in the end, Fuller’s prayers for and pleading with Robert were answered by God. Although he never received this encouraging report, Fuller died believing that it was possible for his son to have been saved, even if he simply cried out to God for mercy in his final minutes.

School of Affliction

Fuller was a man who lived with great heartbreak throughout his ministry. In addition to his own physical maladies and weaknesses, he also endured the loss of a young child, the mental illness and eventual loss of a wife, and the agony of a wayward son. Fuller persevered through each of these trials with confidence in the sovereignty and goodness of God.

In his letter to Sarah’s father informing him of her passing, Fuller signed it with the closing, “Yours, in great affliction.” Fuller endured this affliction, as all others, with confidence in God’s sovereignty and goodness. He also clung to a view that the suffering of ministers was for their people’s good. In a sermon preached eight years after Sarah’s death from one of the texts that provided him comfort during his wife’s illness (Rom. 8:28), Fuller expands on this idea:

It is an interesting thought, that the afflictions of ministers are described in the Scriptures as generally sent them for the people’s good. St. Paul speaks of the afflictions that befell him and his brethren as designed to qualify them to comfort others with the same comfort wherewith they themselves were comforted of God. . . . Perhaps the greatest qualifications, the best instruction, the most useful learning, that any Christian minister can attain, without any disparagement of other kinds of learning, is that which is attained in the school of affliction; it is by this he becomes able to feel, to sympathize, and to speak a word in season to them that are weary.

The school of affliction is difficult, but it is God’s ordained means of equipping his ministers for usefulness. Not only was Fuller faithful to God during his heartbreaking trials, but also God was being faithful to Fuller and his congregation by equipping him for greater usefulness through the means of trials and suffering. God still prepares his ministers in this way. May the example of Fuller encourage us to submit to this severe mercy as well as he did.

↑ Back to top

↑