2. John Calvin (1509–64): Faithful in Exile
two
John Calvin (1509–64): Faithful in Exile
For many the name John Calvin evokes thoughts of a serious (even intimidating) theologian and a scholarly exegete of the Scriptures. Calvin was indeed those things, but for him theology and Bible study served his primary calling as a minister in the church of Jesus Christ. He was devoted to serving a local church in preaching and teaching, in visiting and counseling, in catechizing and disciplining as well as in writing.
Calvin did not come to the pastorate easily or automatically. As a student and young man, he was caught between three competing worlds. The first was the traditional French world of his father’s influence and contacts. His father initially wanted him to have a career in the church and then switched to wanting John to study law. Even in the sixteenth century everyone knew that being a lawyer was the way to success. The second world, which interested John Calvin the most in his student years, was the world of Renaissance scholarship. Calvin wanted an academic life to study the work of ancient writers. His first published work was a learned study of the treatise “On Mercy” by the Roman Stoic philosopher Seneca.
The third world, to which Calvin was introduced through other students at university, was the world of the Reformation. Many students in Paris were drawn to Luther’s efforts to reform the church. Calvin himself, after initial resistance, would in time embrace the Reformation.
The tensions among the worlds in which Calvin lived created a variety of struggles. He struggled with his sense of calling and with his religious convictions. When he accepted the teaching of the Reformation, he soon needed to flee from persecution in France. He still hoped for a scholarly life. His ability to write a clear and helpful introduction to Protestant theology not long after his conversion—his Institutes of the Christian Religion in 1536—demonstrated his remarkable talent as a thinker and a writer.
Calvin had planned to flee his native France for Strasbourg, in those days a quasi-independent city-state that was German speaking and part of the Holy Roman Empire. But he detoured to Geneva where he planned to pause briefly. Guillaume Farel, the initial reformer of Geneva, recognized that he needed a colleague with Calvin’s learning and organizational skills to advance the reform there and threatened Calvin with God’s judgment if he did not stay: “I denounce unto you, in the name of Almighty God, that if, under the pretext of prosecuting your studies, you refuse to labor with us in this work of the Lord, the Lord will curse you, as seeking yourself rather than Christ.” Farel’s thundering voice was Calvin’s call to the ministry. He found himself in exile with a calling he had neither sought nor wanted.
This first pastoral charge lasted less than two years. Calvin was young and uncompromising with a clear commitment to the freedom of the church to chart its own course and to practice its own discipline. He was also at times short-tempered, making submission to the authority of the city council—which governed the city-state of Geneva as well as the church there—difficult at times. When Calvin and Farel refused to administer the Lord’s Supper at Easter in spring of 1538 because they had not been permitted to exercise discipline over some church members, the city council expelled them. In effect, Calvin continued his journey to Strasbourg but seemingly as an exile from pastoral ministry.
Calvin’s plan was not God’s plan.
In October 1538, Calvin wrote a letter from Strasbourg to his former congregation. Even in exile he showed no bitterness toward the council but reminded his former flock of the mysterious purposes of God—we do not always understand God’s workings with us, but we can trust that his sovereign will is best. Calvin offers pastoral care in the form of counsel to consider how God might be at work in them through his ejection:
You have besides to consider, that these things have not thus fallen out without the dispensation of the Lord, who carries forward his purposes even by means of the wicked, according to the good pleasure of his own will. Now, that thought will turn you away from the pursuit of your enemies, to consider and look into yourselves, and so to consider, that you may acknowledge that you may have well deserved on your part to receive such a visitation, to chastise your negligence, your contempt, or even your careless slighting of the word of God. . . . Above all, take heed that you watch unto prayer; for if your whole expectation rests upon God, as it ought, there is good reason to infer that your heart should be daily lifted up to heaven.
His life and the lives of those who supported the Reformation cause would be on the line from that time forward: “We have not only exile to fear, but that all the most cruel varieties of death are impending over us, for in the cause of religion they will set no bounds on their barbarity.”
Martin Bucer, the great reformer of Strasbourg, also recognized Calvin’s talents and appointed him as pastor of a French refugee congregation there. Calvin learned a great deal from Bucer, especially about the worship and structure of the church. During his three years there, Calvin matured as a minister and accomplished a great deal. He wrote his first biblical commentary—on Romans; significantly expanded his Institutes; penned one of the greatest defenses of the Reformation, A Reply to Sadoleto; and also married. God was leveraging Calvin’s exile to fashion the reformer into a pastor.
Back to Geneva
Then came the invitation to return to Geneva to take up his pastoral work there again. He did not want to go, seeing clearly that he would face continuing conflict and difficulty. Once again Farel had to intervene to persuade him. He returned in 1541 and served as minister there until his death in 1564. As he had feared, he experienced recurring serious troubles in several different arenas. His only child died in infancy, and his wife died relatively young, of which he writes to his close friend Pierre Viret: “I have been bereaved of the best companion of my life. . . . During her life she was the faithful helper of my ministry.”
A political faction that opposed him waxed and waned in influence, and at times Calvin feared he would be expelled again. He also feared the possibility of foreign attacks on the city. Only in the last decade of his life was the situation in Geneva peaceable. By then, however, his health was deteriorating, and he suffered from a variety of ailments ranging from kidney stones to a recurring fever.
In addition to his problems in Geneva, he also felt the pressure of the sufferings of his fellow Protestants throughout Europe. In his many letters he was often a counselor and encourager to those in trouble. Sometimes the pain was intense as when in June 1552 he had to write letters to five students from Geneva who had been imprisoned for their faith in Lyons and would ultimately be martyred for their faith. Calvin displayed his pastor’s heart by pointing them to the One who would rescue them either by life or by death:
We hope, come what may, that God of his goodness will give a happy issue to your captivity, so that we shall have reason to rejoice. You see to what he has called you; doubt not, therefore, that according as he employs you, he will give you strength to fulfill his work, for he has promised this, and we know by experience that he has never failed those who allow themselves to be governed by him.
Through all of these trials and struggles, he remained frenetically active in preaching, teaching, and writing. On his deathbed, he was still dictating the last sections of his commentary on Joshua. Colleague and friend Theodore Beza urged him to rest, but Calvin responded: “What! Would you have the Lord find me idle?”
Living in Exile
As a counselor Calvin was gentle and patient with the wavering while adamant and critical with the compromising. He stressed that Christians cannot engage in any acts of idolatry—especially attending Mass—to ensure their personal safety. They must be faithful and either suffer persecution or flee as exiles to a place of safety.
He gave that advice to Madame Bude, the widow of France’s greatest humanist scholar, Guillaume Bude. Bude had had a religious outlook rather like that of Erasmus, but Madame Bude and her children had embraced Reformed Christianity. Calvin urged her to move to Geneva, but she found the decision for such a great change in her life difficult. In his letter of encouragement to her in 1546, Calvin used an arresting image. He writes, “For while we are in this world, it is fitting that we should be like birds upon the branch.” His point is that our attachment to our lives and their circumstances must be so slight that like birds on a branch we can easily flee away to wherever God would have us to be. God is in control, not us.
He also knew, however, that exile would not put an end to suffering, suffering that was ultimately governed by the hand of God. In 1549 he wrote a touching letter to Madame de la Roche-Posay, the abbess of a convent, pointing out that the primary cause of our trials is a loving God who is more concerned for our Christlikeness than for our comfort. He counsels:
I understand quite well, that in such bondage as you now are, you cannot serve God purely without the rage and cruelty of the wicked rising up immediately against you, and without the fire perhaps being lighted. . . . Howbeit, you must remember, that wherever we may go, the cross of Jesus Christ will follow us, even in the place where you may enjoy your ease and comforts. . . . For this is the very way whereby God would make trial of our faith, and know whether, in seeking after him, we have been renouncing self.
Beyond faith in a general sense, Calvin looked to certain specific truths and promises of the Word of God—namely, his faith in Christ and his deep trust in God’s providential will—to sustain him in his days of trouble. Calvin is famous for his strong teaching on the absolute sovereignty of God in daily providence and in predestination. For Calvin this doctrine is not abstract or speculative but intensely practical. As he powerfully expresses in his preface to his Commentary on the Psalms:
[The Psalms] will principally teach and train us to bear the cross. . . . By doing this, we renounce the guidance of our own affections and submit ourselves entirely to God, leaving him to govern us, and to dispose our life according to his will, so that the afflictions which are the bitterest and most severe to our nature, become sweet to us, because they proceed from him.
As Christians our aim must be to grow in confidence in God’s good purposes for us in all things so that we can embrace even our worst trials as coming from his fatherly and loving hand. Still, though God is sovereign, we don’t always know his will for the future. We are called to depend on a sovereign God as pilgrims and strangers—exiles—in this world.
Calvin and a Pastoral Theology of Exile
Perhaps most fundamentally, Calvin was an exile whom God raised up to minister to exiles. Calvin was providentially displaced three times—from his home country in France, from Geneva to Strasbourg in 1538, and then back to Geneva in late summer of 1541.
A few days before his return from Strasbourg to Geneva, Calvin wrote to his intimate friend Guillaume Farel, admitting that his decision to return to the place at which he’d suffered the humiliation of expulsion was a path chosen by God, not one he would have chosen for himself. Farel had advised Calvin to return. Obviously, the reformer had needed some convincing:
As to my intended course of proceeding, this is my present feeling: had I the choice at my own disposal, nothing would be less agreeable to me than to follow your advice. But when I remember that I am not my own, I offer up my heart, presented as a sacrifice to the Lord. . . . I submit my will and my affections, subdued and held-fast, to the obedience of God; and whenever I am at a loss for counsel of my own, I submit myself to those by whom I hope that the Lord will speak to me.
From a human perspective, Calvin’s original ouster made little spiritual sense. How would the church profit from so short a time with Calvin during his first tenure in Geneva? How would it now profit from his return? The answer to those questions took shape quickly as the exiled reformer became a minister to exiles. In ways unknown to us, God often prepares us well in advance to face challenges and perform his work in the future.
Beginning in 1542, Protestants from numerous regions and countries, including England, Italy, the Netherlands, Scotland, and Calvin’s native France, fled to Geneva in a steady stream. All came seeking asylum from religious persecution in their home countries. Many, including scores of young men following a call to preach the Reformation’s gospel of grace, came to Geneva because Calvin was there.
The population of Geneva doubled by 1555 and reached a peak of slightly more than twenty-one thousand by 1560. Having so many sympathizers to the Reformation cause gather in Geneva pleased Calvin: “I am . . . much preoccupied with the foreigners who daily pass this place in great numbers, or come here to live.” Ultimately, Calvin trained and prepared many of those refugees to return to their native lands as evangelists and pastors. Through Calvin’s work, Geneva became a hub for foreign missions. Foremost on Calvin’s heart was his homeland. Between 1555 and 1562, more than one hundred ministers left Geneva for France, clandestinely serving new churches there under threat of arrest and worse.
The thrice-exiled Calvin teaches today’s pastor at least four things related to a pastoral theology of exile.
Exile Is a Fundamental Posture for Every Minister
Calvin was a high-bred, brilliant man with clear gifts for writing; a bent toward close, careful study; and a personality seemingly more suited for the life of a scholar. Prior to being arrested by the wrathful threats of Farel, Calvin was en route to Strasbourg and a life of research and writing in service of the church. But God had other plans—Calvin served exactly half his life, twenty-seven years, as a pastor. To Calvin’s mind, it was leaving a high calling to stoop down low—like Moses eschewing Egypt for the people of God or the Son of God forsaking the riches of heaven for the poverty of a fallen world.
As Calvin writes in commenting on 2 Corinthians 4:7, family trees and intellectual acumen are insignificant factors in God’s economy:
It is true, indeed, that all mortal men are earthen vessels. Hence, let the most eminent of them all be selected, and let him be one that is adorned to admiration with all ornaments of birth, intellect, and fortune, still, if he be a minister of the gospel, he will be a mean and merely earthen depository of an inestimable treasure.
Exile Does Not Change the Pastor’s Fundamental Calling of Faithfulness to God’s Word
Calvin returned to Geneva on September 13, 1541. After being disgraced and ejected from his first pastorate there, surely Calvin would be tempted to unload on his opponents in his pulpit debut. In a 1540 letter, Calvin openly told Farel that he preferred to die “a hundred deaths to this cross” of returning to the church in Geneva.
In his first appearance in the Geneva pulpit, Calvin responded in a far different manner than might be expected: he took up preaching the Bible at the chapter and verse at which he had left off forty months earlier:
When I came before the people to preach, everyone was eaten up with curiosity. But, remaining completely silent about the events which surely they all expected me to mention, I set forth very briefly the principles of my ministry, and then quickly and discreetly I recalled to mind the faith and the integrity of those who supported me. After this introduction I began to comment on the text at the place where I had stopped (at the time of my banishment). By doing this I wanted to show rather than having given up the teaching office, I had only been interrupted for a while.
Exile Means Surrendering Our Desires, Personalities, and Gifts to God and Remaining Faithful When He Uses Them in Unexpected Ways
Calvin wanted to be a scholar. God wanted him to pastor in Geneva. God got his man. God’s providence sometimes strikes us as strange because we are not writing our own script. This was certainly true in Calvin’s story. The introverted Calvin preached God’s Word faithfully at least a half-dozen times each week and faithfully shepherded his flock. He also wrote commentaries on most of the Bible, completed five editions of the Institutes, and published dozens of other theological works—all as a pastor. Calvin was the Reformation’s pastor-theologian par excellence, though he never sought the first descriptor in that couplet. This in spite of a personality and gifts seemingly more bent toward academia. God used the necessity of reformation to reinvent Calvin the scholar as Calvin the pastor. In turn, God used him to raise up other pastors to shape and spread the Reformation’s recovered gospel.
Early biographer Jean-Daniel Benoit writes:
One loves to speak of him as the Reformer of Geneva. It would be perhaps more correct to refer to him as the pastor of Geneva, because Calvin was a pastor in his soul, and his reformatory work, in a good many respects, was only the consequence and extension of his pastoral activity.
Calvin’s life and ministry demonstrates that our desires, personalities, and gifts belong to God, and he often uses them in ways that we may never understand.
Exile Is God’s Will, and His Meticulous Providence Will Comfort and Sustain Us When Perplexing Affliction Comes
Calvin sought to go to Strasbourg, and he finally got there by means of exile from Geneva—spirited there by the wicked decision of evil men. Calvin’s stay in Strasbourg was brief, and his return to Geneva was unwelcomed. Pastors often face unjust suffering of various kinds from incorrigible critics inside the church to incomprehensible circumstances without. Even unjust suffering is not outside God’s control, Calvin argues:
When we are unjustly wounded by men, let us overlook their wickedness (which would but worsen our pain and sharpen our minds to revenge), remember to mount up to God, and learn to believe for certain that whatever our enemy has wickedly committed against us was permitted and sent by God’s just dispensation.
Conclusion
One contemporary teacher called the vocation of ministry a death sentence, meaning it is death to self-will and an embrace of God’s will. When a man leaves safe harbor and guides his vessel into the tumultuous sea of pastoral ministry, he never knows which direction the waves may take him.
But, like Calvin, he can rest assured that God does know, and that truth liberates him to preach the gospel of grace with abandon, resting in Solomon’s truth that while man makes his plans, a sovereign God orders his steps (Prov. 16:9).
