12. Wang Ming-Dao (1900–1991): Faithful amid Political Coercion
twelve
Wang Ming-Dao (1900–1991): Faithful amid Political Coercion
All people suffer through various hardships, and Christians are by no means exempt. While Christians might wonder why they suffer for no apparent reason, they must continue to “trust in the Lord without the slightest shadow of doubt, uneasiness or fear. What is the basis for this radical trust in God? It’s because of God’s love shown through Christ’s redemptive work. Such a loving God would not hurt his children.”
This exhortation for Christians to suffer well in light of their standing before God was written in the mid-1900s by a Chinese pastor named Wang Ming-Dao. He was no stranger to suffering, facing numerous difficulties throughout his life. The most significant hardship he faced was government-led religious persecution. As a pastor who encouraged Christians to suffer well, one might presume that Wang remained faithful in the midst of persecution.
But he did not. At one point, he abdicated, a surprising but encouraging story that will be told later in this chapter. His failure to withstand compromise was public and even noticed by Christians outside of China. Still, by God’s grace it proved to be no barrier to later effectiveness in ministry. In the aftermath of his unfaithfulness, Wang found restoration in Christ. The words he had written earlier in life still rang true—he could trust in the Lord who had redeemed him. Therefore, Wang’s life is not a simple story of unwavering faithfulness but one characterized by uncompromising faith in both belief and practice, a comparatively uncharacteristic collapse in his faith, and dependence on Christ’s forgiveness in restoration.
Wang shows us that even when we cave to pressure and are unfaithful, God can still faithfully use weak men for his glory.
Who Was Wang Ming-Dao, and Why Is He Important?
Biographer Thomas Alan Harvey called Wang “the Dean of the House Churches” in China.
Wang had an itinerant ministry throughout China, visiting twenty-four of the twenty-eight provinces and taking the pulpit in churches of thirty different denominations. Wang was often absent from his own church for six months of the year. The massive spread of house churches in China in the 1940s and 50s owes to Wang’s work. But his early years did not foretell such a godly legacy.
Wang was born in the midst of the Boxer Rebellion, a violent uprising against colonialism in China. His family sought refuge in the Legation Quarter, a refuge for foreigners and Chinese Christians. The apparent hopelessness of the situation led Wang’s father, Wang Dzu-Hou, to commit suicide not long after being besieged by the Boxers. He left behind his pregnant wife, Li Wun-I, and one daughter.
Wang was born approximately one month after his father’s death. Wang manifested intellectual gifts from a young age, and he excelled at a primary school established by the London Missionary Society. Though he grew up attending a Christian church with his family, Wang was not converted until 1914, under the discipleship of an older peer. By 1919 Wang was teaching at a Presbyterian primary school in Baoding, approximately one hundred miles from Beijing.
Wang’s theological and ministerial development was significant in shaping a ministry that exhibited profound courage. There were seasons in which Wang paid the price for maintaining his convictions. For example, in 1920 Wang came to believe that biblical baptism was by immersion. Though some in his Presbyterian school attempted to convince him otherwise, Wang would not budge from his newfound conviction. Warned that he would not be able to teach at the boarding school if he continued to espouse believer’s baptism by immersion, Wang refused to compromise. Wang lost not only his job but also an opportunity to continue his studies abroad. Though he was greatly discouraged by these losses, Wang began preaching at various conventions and evangelistic campaigns in 1923.
Later that year, Wang began a Bible study at his home, a work that was essentially a house church. It would grow to be established as the Beijing Christian Tabernacle in 1937.
Wang’s ministry focused on two fundamentals: “On the one hand I emphasize beliefs; on the other hand I emphasize the Christian’s manner of life.” Wang was admittedly strict when it came to doctrine and practice, which led him to be criticized by other Christian leaders. He writes, “Since I do not tolerate sin, I have acquired many friends. I have also acquired enemies.” Wang argued that Christians should not fear criticism or persecution. They should pay no heed to reputation in the eyes of others and even be willing to lay down their lives. Fear of suffering would surely lead to compromise of God’s truth. For most of his life, Wang steadfastly practiced what he preached.
Wang understood his pastoral ministry as a type of prophetic ministry, “to be a trumpet call to the world and on the other hand to be a trumpet call to the church,” and that this work would “inevitably provoke opposition and bring attacks” upon himself. In light of the suffering and hardships pastors must endure, Wang gave five guidelines to follow. First, a pastor must resolve to know and follow God’s will. Second, he must love his congregation as a parent loves her children. The third and fourth points are two sides of the same coin: a pastor must not entertain thoughts of personal gain or glory; rather, he must be humble and teachable. Finally, a pastor should neither think too highly of personal honor nor fear criticism. His developing views and ministry reflected a high view of doctrinal and ecclesiological purity.
Suffering and God’s Will
Wang did not convey the Christian life as devoid of suffering, and he connected our circumstances with God’s sovereign will. In his sermon “Accepting God’s Will,” he presented the following progression: (1) the Christian suffers some hardship, (2) God does not reveal a reason for nor remove the suffering, and (3) the Christian is tempted to respond to God with frustration and anger. Such suffering should be doubly expected by those in ministry.
Wang gives a number of examples of how Christians might suffer, such as when people turn against you, the loss of a loved one, an illness without any cure in sight, and the depression and misery that often accompany incurable maladies. Wang recognized how these types of suffering tempt believers, even pastors, to bear a grudge against God.
You feel downcast and even broken-hearted. . . . You feel that the Lord has deliberately made you to bear the one thing that is most difficult to bear. . . . You ask in your heart, “What is the meaning of this?” . . . Your heart is filled with darkness and affliction.
Amid suffering, the Christian should trust in God’s goodness, as most clearly shown through the redemptive work of Christ. While human suffering and the exhortation to look to Christ are shared by all Christians, Wang recognized how pastors in particular are prone to suffering.
Wang was no stranger to affliction. He lived through various hardships, common and uncommon. He also communicated a biblical theology of suffering to his fellow Christians. While this background serves to make his later failure all the more surprising, it should also help us to see that the overall pattern of his life and ministry was one of faithfulness. His failure was a thread in his life, not the whole tapestry.
Persecution under Japanese Occupation
Wang’s faithfulness to Christ was challenged in a new way when faced with oppression from the Japanese occupation. His courage and lack of compromise was encouraging, given the numerous Chinese churches who placed themselves under the influence of the Japanese government.
In 1937 Beijing fell to Japanese forces during the Second Sino-Japanese War. Wang’s encounters and interactions with Japanese occupiers are a testimony of faithfulness during uncertain times. In 1939 the Japanese Ministry of Information required all publications, including newspapers and magazines, to publish patriotic slogans supporting the Japanese military. The Spiritual Food Quarterly, which Wang had written and edited for more than a decade, faced a stark choice: be a political tool or shut down. Refusal to publish patriotic slogans would not only hurt the publication but also present a danger to Wang’s personal well-being. After an initial bout of fear, Wang decided to continue publishing without the slogans. To his surprise he was never arrested, and the Spiritual Food Quarterly continued without propaganda for eight years.
The Japanese occupation also threatened local churches. The North China Christian Federation Promotion Committee was established by 1942, and Wang was pressured to lead his congregation into the fold or “subsequently encounter difficulties.” Wang gave two reasons for rejecting these overtures. First, Wang believed many false Christians had already joined the organization, and he refused to be yoked to it. Second, he refused due to his suspicion that the Japanese government was seeking to influence Chinese churches. Wang’s refusal to compromise reflects the difficult burden a faithful pastor must carry:
Our continued existence as a church depended on our joining [the organization]. I had the feeling that I and my colleagues were like the captain and first and second officers of a steamer, that the vessel was whipped by violent gales and buffeted by heavy seas, and that the safety or otherwise of the whole ship (the whole church) depended entirely on us few officers. Our responsibility was heavy in the extreme; we only needed to make one mistake and the whole ship would be plunged to the bottom of the sea.
To reject the overtures of the Japanese government could mean the congregation of hundreds of believers would no longer be able to worship together, but to accept would be to ignore conscience. Courage to remain faithful in the face of government persecution did not mean Wang was fearless; he feared for his own safety. Amid growing pressure to capitulate, and to encourage both himself and his congregation, he preached on the suffering, faithfulness, and protection that Daniel and his friends faced in Babylon. Such encouragement was necessary for Wang to stand against the ongoing pressure from Japanese authorities and other Chinese Christians throughout the occupation. Thankfully, the Beijing Christian Tabernacle was never taken over or closed down.
Persecution under Communism
With the establishment of the People’s Republic of China in 1949, the Chinese church faced a new set of challenges. While the earlier dangers of the Japanese occupation arose from outside the church, Christians now faced persecution from within. The rise of Communism in China brought with it the Three-Self Patriotic Movement, a state-sanctioned, interdenominational Protestant body that sought to tie Chinese Christians to Chinese nationalism through removal of Western influences. Their mantra was “self-governing, self-supporting, self-proclaiming.” Their effort to tie together the political and religious spheres is evident in a seven-point proposal presented at the movement’s national conference in 1954:
The Three-Self Patriotic Movement was not passive. It actively pursued political reform within the religious sphere through publications and accusation meetings. These meetings took place at various churches joining the Three-Self Patriotic Movement, at which people denounced various Christian groups and individuals as proponents of Western imperialism.
One Three-Self publication conveys the main purpose and motivation:
The central task for all Christian churches and groups is to have accusation meetings. What must we accuse? We must accuse imperialists, their servants and other decadent elements hiding inside the Church. . . . Americans sent missionaries all over China in the name of spreading the gospel but their true aim was to gather information as special agents. American imperialists raised a group of “church leaders” to be their faithful lapdogs.
Unlike numerous other Christian churches and organizations in China, the Beijing Christian Tabernacle had never formally associated with Western Christians. Therefore, while other pastors might have felt compelled to join the Three-Self movement, Wang rejected numerous overtures to membership. He could not be successfully accused of being a tool of Western imperialism.
Yet the primary reason he didn’t wish to join the Three-Self movement was doctrinal. Many of the leading figures in the movement were modernists—those with a theologically liberal perspective on central matters such as biblical inspiration, the virgin birth, the atonement, the resurrection of Christ, and his second coming. Wang raised all these as reasons for why the modernists were fundamentally different from true believers:
These people say they are Christians but they do not believe the truth in the Bible that needs to be accepted with faith. They do not believe that man was directly created by God, that Jesus was born of the virgin, that Jesus died on the cross for our sin, that the body of Jesus was resurrected, that Jesus is coming again.
Wang was strongly convinced of regenerate church membership, and refused to meet with unbelievers in a gathering he saw as existing for believers. Yet Wang’s unyielding rejection of the movement was not just over doctrinal differences. He didn’t see it merely as a gathering led by unbelievers. He believed they were insidious:
The Three-Self Church is the most effective method used by those outside the Church to destroy the Church from the inside out. Throughout history no one has ever before thought of such a clever way to destroy the Church, but today it has been discovered.
The movement not only posed an external threat to the church but also might be likened to a virus that threatened to kill it from the inside. Ironically, the Three-Self church and Wang each believed the other to be a poison within the church.
For these reasons, Wang rejected numerous overtures from Three-Self leaders to join their movement. Wang believed that the Communist government desired its people to have freedom of religion. At the same time, strict conformity to the Communist agenda was a priority of the Three-Self movement. Wang did little to ingratiate himself to Three-Self leaders by continuing to criticize their liberal theology, criticism that led many churches and individuals to flee the movement.
Soon, the kind suggestions for Wang to join changed to threats and persecution. First, movement leaders isolated Wang by denouncing friends and associates at accusation meetings. Some were arrested for ties to Western imperialism; others folded under the pressure and joined. One of Wang’s church members committed suicide after experiencing pressure to denounce Wang at one meeting. From 1951 to 1955, Wang faced growing pressure to give in to compromise. This, along with a growing fear of imprisonment, took its toll.
At last, Wang broke.
First Arrest and Compromise
On the evening of August 7, 1955, two months after publishing his most scathing critique of the Three-Self movement, “We—For the Sake of Faith,” Wang, his wife, and other church associates were arrested for being counterrevolutionary. His arrest and subsequent interrogations were dark both circumstantially and spiritually. While many Christians have stood resolute in their faith before persecution and death, this moment set the stage for Wang’s greatest failure.
Though he originally received a lengthy prison sentence, Wang was released after little more than a year on September 29, 1956, after confessing to multiple crimes he did not commit. Out of fear of a long imprisonment or death and concern for his wife’s well-being, Wang gave in to state interrogators who wished to use him to help unify Chinese Christians under the state church.
On September 30 Wang read a confession, “My Self-Examination,” at a large gathering of the Three-Self movement. An American report gives the details:
In his “self-examination” before a Christian audience he emphasizes his “political mistakes,” also his failure to cooperate with the Government and with the patriotic movement in the Church, especially in the war effort and in support of socialist construction. He confesses wrong attitudes to the Communist Party and to the liberal church leaders who sought his support. There is no evidence that he made any retraction of Christian faith or repudiated any of his basic theological beliefs.
Released from prison, Wang was unable to enjoy his freedom. One of the conditions of his release was to join the Three-Self church and preach as a part of the movement. He was torn between his ongoing conviction against joining the movement and the fear of returning to prison.
Imprisoned for Life, Yet Liberated
Wang’s wife was a faithful support for him during these seasons of inner turbulence. She even advocated before the director of the Religious Affairs Bureau for his release from the conditions placed on him to preach for the movement. About six months after his release, Wang grew convinced he could not fulfill his promise to wed his church to the movement.
Soon after moving from the Beijing Christian Tabernacle, on April 29, 1957, Wang and his wife were rearrested and placed in a detention center, where they remained for six years. In 1963, the final court decisions and sentences were passed:
The accused Wang Mingdao is found guilty of counter-revolutionary crime and is sentenced to life-long imprisonment with all political rights permanently revoked. The accused Liu Jingwen is found guilty of counter-revolutionary crime and is sentenced to fifteen years’ imprisonment (from 29 April 1958 to 28 April 1973), with all her political rights revoked for a further five years after release.
Wang’s greatest fears had been realized. But reaching the bottom of despair also convinced him that he had been unfaithful to God by lying to preserve his life. Whereas he was once afraid of being executed, staying in prison, and his wife dying in prison, Wang now accepted his lot and retracted the confession he had made under duress. He was able to find a sense of peace through confessing his true beliefs before God and the state. He now sought to speak and act on the truth, no matter the consequences.
Lengthy Torture, Exemplary Faith
From 1957 to 1979 Wang served his sentence in the detention center in Beijing, a mining camp in Datong, and a labor camp in Yingying. Throughout these years, he suffered from deteriorating health and was tortured by fellow inmates. Despite these hardships, Wang’s confidence in the Lord grew to a point of openly singing praises in prison, something he would never have done previously. Wang continued to give an honest account of his personal convictions throughout his imprisonment.
Wang was released from prison in 1979, finally rejoining his wife in Shanghai. She had been released by the government in 1974. Wang entertained many international visitors, including Billy Graham. Though the government was concerned about his ongoing influence, he openly shared his struggles and failures with all visitors.
As he wrote in “Accepting God’s Will,” Wang sought and received forgiveness for his sins. Not only did he experience God’s forgiveness in conversion, but he was also restored by God’s forgiveness after he faltered. “God had lifted him up again and enabled him to stand, so he was just as joyful now as when he had first believed.”
Wang Ming-Dao experienced suffering throughout his pastoral ministry from both Christians and the government. As one who shepherded fellow believers to withstand any temptation to compromise in the face of hardship, he was expected to practice what he taught, and faithfulness to Christ was the pattern of his life. The faithfulness he portrayed throughout his life and ministry stood in stark contrast to his failure under Communist oppression.
Temptation to compromise is not uncommon for those in pastoral ministry. Leaders in the church must always be vigilant to cling to the good news of Jesus Christ, not only as a preventive against sin but also when repentance and restoration are needed when we do fall short. Leaders must be willing to speak the truth, even if it may cost them everything.
Wang’s story clearly shows that, even if leaders in the church betray their callings, God is able to write a different ending to their stories.
