Chapter 12 of 17

9. C. H. Spurgeon (1834–92): Faithful in Sorrow

9. C. H. Spurgeon (1834–92): Faithful in Sorrow

nine

C. H. Spurgeon (1834–92): Faithful in Sorrow

ZACK ESWINE

On Sunday evenings, after he’d completed his work from the week and the day, Charles Spurgeon and his wife, Susannah, would find some quiet and sit together. Spurgeon served as pastor of Victorian London’s largest congregation, New Park Street Baptist Church. Inevitably, Susannah would ask, “Dear, should I read to you tonight?” If Charles felt particularly glad for the work of the day, if he felt that he had been faithful to the God he loved, he would say, “Yes, Wifey [that was one of his affectionate names for Susannah]. That would be very refreshing. Would you mind reading a page or two of good George Herbert?” As Susannah read, her husband’s mental and physical fatigue would subside. Sleep would come easy that night.

It isn’t that Spurgeon was unaccustomed to the hard work of ministry. He had been preaching since he was a teenager. Wherever Spurgeon preached, larger sanctuaries became necessary, and were ultimately built, to accommodate the swelling numbers of people who came to hear him. He was a phenom of the time. This meant that critics made their disappointment publicly and regularly known. On many Sunday nights, the fatigue that battled Spurgeon was more than physical. According to Susannah, her husband could be “sorely depressed in spirit following the ministry of the day.” He felt as though his faithfulness fell short of God’s worthy and lovely character. Out of his anguish of heart, he’d ask his wife to read the sober exhortations of Richard Baxter’s The Reformed Pastor. She would read page after page of Baxter’s concern for an unconverted clergy and his stern pleadings regarding the sobering and high calling of a minister’s work in Christ. According to Susannah, her husband would burst into “heart sobs,” weeping deep in his soul over the “smitings of a very tender conscience toward God.” She would cry with him, out of tender love for him. She felt that he was harder on himself than was warranted, so often having no legitimate cause for the way he upbraided his soul.

Spiritual Sorrows

Charles Spurgeon used the term fainting fits to describe our experiences with sorrow. Sorrows sometimes have a spiritual source. Spiritually, we depress. We feel as though we’ve displeased God and have no remedy, as when Spurgeon was weighed down by guilt over a sermon on a Sunday night. At other times, spiritual depression haunts us for years as it did the poet William Cowper, whom Spurgeon esteemed. The same man who wrote, “Behind a frowning providence, [God] hides a smiling face,” would also describe himself as worse than a castaway without God and dying at sea in shipwreck.

No voice divine the storm allayed,

No light propitious shone;

When, snatched from all effectual aid,

We perished, each alone;

But I beneath a rougher sea,

And whelmed in deeper gulfs than he.

These “spiritual sorrows,” Spurgeon says, “are the worst of mental miseries.” We either believe God has deserted us and left us barren in his absence, or we think God is gleefully present, happily smiting us with our actual guilt and delighting as we squirm in agony with no mercy and no way out. These are the worst kind of sorrows. Spurgeon felt that a person can learn to bear with a bleeding body or in time get through their wounds of soul, but spiritual sorrows prove nearly too much to endure.

At such times, Spurgeon reminds us that preaching the bountiful aid of the cross or the empty tomb or Jesus’s ascension will provide no felt relief or respite. Only the Garden of Gethsemane can free us in our anguish. For there, we do not have a general who stands in the back in safety demanding that we weary ones charge first into battle. On the contrary, the garden of betrayal shows us our fellow friend who steps forward to take the lead. He runs toward the fight before all of us. He faces the enemy first so that we who follow are neither alone nor without hope. We see him sweat blood drops. We watch the cheek-kisser betray his love for coins. Torchlight rouses the courage of the cowardly. They bind our Lord and mock him till dawn. So we preach this Christ of the garden, and the spiritually haunted discover the God who walks their path of mental misery, who feels their pains of anguished burden, and who beckons their comradery as fellow sufferers who overcome.

Circumstantial Sorrows

Spurgeon’s honesty about his sufferings and his open compassion for the sufferings of others can catch us off guard. After all, he was one of history’s first megachurch pastors. He preached as a Reformed Baptist to thousands each week during the nineteenth-century Victorian era in England. His messages were printed weekly in local periodicals, which meant thousands upon thousands accessed his sermons. He started various ministries and new churches, including a pastors’ college and orphanages. He offered then and now a model of ministerial success to many. Yet Spurgeon was a man transparently acquainted with terrible sorrows in body and soul. He was an imperfect man who looked to the same Savior he preached to us.

The sorrows Spurgeon experienced were not only spiritual in nature. He also named circumstances as a terrible source of sadness.

One wounding incident spooked Spurgeon all his life. On October 19, 1856, as he stood in the pulpit preaching to thousands, a prankster yelled, “Fire!” The resulting panic left seven dead and twenty-eight seriously injured. Spurgeon was only twenty-two years old at the time. He and Susannah had married ten months before and were diaper-deep into the first month of parenting their twin boys in a new house full of unpacked boxes. With so many people dead, newspapers across London cruelly and mercilessly blamed him. No one knew if Spurgeon would preach again—he considered quitting. Susannah says that her husband tottered on the verge of insanity. Those close to him provided what we would call today a suicide watch to make sure he didn’t harm himself in his despair.

Twenty-five years later, Spurgeon was about to address a large audience during a session of the Baptist Union. He was older now, middle-aged, a seasoned pastor and widely known. With all seats accounted for, hundreds pressed in. Spurgeon walked onto the platform and became “entirely unmanned . . . leaning his head on his hand.” He experienced what we call a flashback or a post-trauma response. The present moment triggered a haunting memory. Spurgeon’s body responded as if threatened by danger. He preached that night but barely. Frowning providences sometimes don’t take the hint and move on. They lurk and loiter around our memory for years.

Spurgeon suggests that broken hearts come in several ways:

  • desertion—neglect or betrayal by a spouse, family member, or friend
  • bereavement—ailment or death of one we love
  • penury—job loss, financial strain, poverty of basic needs
  • disappointment and defeat—dreams unreached, goals blocked, attempts that failed, foes who won
  • guilt—regrets, pains we’ve caused others, sins against God
  • Further, Spurgeon said, we are like the victim of a crime. Say, for example, an intruder entered our homes and ransacked the living room and took all we held dear away from us while some of our neighbors slept and others sought entertainment among the late-night reruns. The circumstances leave a mark, the kind of scar that takes nearly a lifetime to fade.

    But grace doesn’t quit.

    For a time after the prank, if Spurgeon saw a Bible it made him cry. Yet he did preach again and care for Susannah and the twins again, one day at a time with Jesus. Listen in. Hear this small, adult-sized step of grace as he preached again for the first time after the circumstance that mobbed him like a gang to loot his sanity:

    I almost regret this morning that I have ventured to occupy this pulpit because I feel utterly unable to preach to you for your profit. I had thought that the quiet and repose of the last fortnight had removed the effects of that terrible catastrophe; but on coming back to the same spot again, and more especially, standing here to address you, I feel somewhat of those same painful emotions which well-nigh prostrated me before. You will, therefore, excuse me this morning. . . . I have been utterly unable to study. . . . Oh, Spirit of God, magnify thy strength in thy servant’s weakness and enable him to honor his Lord, even when his soul is cast down within him.

    How do we overcome? One imperfect, frazzled, vulnerable step at a time. We get honest about the effects of circumstances. We endure remnants of painful emotion and bodily anxiety. We cry out from our souls to God and take hold of what has always been true but what we didn’t live out before. Our greatest hope at this moment isn’t the absence of our weakness but the presence of God’s strength.

    Biological Sorrows

    Spurgeon applied what a Christian theology of persons taught him. A person is a “double being,” he would say. We are body and soul. We experience injuries and hurts that arise from spiritual and circumstantial sources. But our bodies can also promote sorrows. If spiritual pains seize upon our conscience and mental sorrows rise from negative circumstances, biological sorrows originate in our bodily chemistry. “Some persons are constitutionally sad,” Spurgeon says. “They are marked with melancholy from their birth.”

    A Christian theology of the body in a fallen world reminds us that sorrow is not itself a sin. Sorrow is a sane response to what is fallen. Spurgeon also says that depression is more of a misfortune than a fault. For these reasons, there are times when prayers, promises, Scripture reading, counsel, and preaching are not enough to help us. Not because these gifts from God are without power in Jesus to relieve and heal us, but because the medicine prescribed doesn’t fit the source of the problem. Soul remedies for bodily ailments are necessary but incomplete. What does this mean? Those of us with bodily origins for our depression can follow Spurgeon’s lead as he sought remedy and help:

  • We need to adjust our work rhythms and expectations. Spurgeon resisted this change at first, but gradually began to take regular breaks for months at a time in Mentone, France. For the sake of his health and ministry, such breaks were wise. He also used regular hot baths to relax his body and mind.
  • We need to build into our lives regular rhythms with God’s creation. Communion with nature eased the gloom and fatigue that the fog, frost, and damp of London agitated amid the pain of work. The cold, wet days of winter acted upon his sensitive frame. Dull and dreary days depressed him. His urban ministry required rural retreats to keep him flourishing.
  • We need laughter. Our trouble isn’t like the trouble of those who cannot cry and resist the sanity of sadness. Our trouble is that we cannot rest from seeing beauty in all beauty’s feisty, God-given refusal to quit when things go dark. On the advice of Proverbs 17:22, Spurgeon intentionally sought out stories of good humor and gracious strength. He read them, collected them, and told them.
  • We need to pay attention to how food and drink affect our melancholy. Spurgeon spoke of how he had to learn about the effects of what he ate.
  • We need to use medicine, not as a cure or as our “go to” but as one teammate with these others, to help us wisely navigate the sorrows our bodies prompt until Jesus comes again. Medicine is like the sixth person on a starting team of five. When a starter needs a breather, the sixth person comes off the bench to support and maintain the team for significant minutes.
  • Bringing Harm in the Name of Help

    Incompleteness and impatience among Christians often inflict a double wound to those who suffer sorrows. Our biblical framework reveals its incompleteness when we do not account for spiritual, circumstantial, or biological contributors to the sorrows of those we try to help. Our impatience shows itself in our trite answers and quick remedies. We become like Job’s friends, incomplete in our understanding and impatient with healing. We say true things in all the wrong ways and at all the wrong times.

    Spurgeon often spoke, openly and forcefully, against those harmful helpers who say to the depressed: “Oh! You should not feel like this!” or “Oh! You should not speak such words, nor think such thoughts.”

    “Ah!” says one, “I used to laugh at Mrs. So-and-so for being nervous; now that I feel the torture myself, I am sorry that I was ever hard on her.” “Ah!” says another, “I used to think of such-and-such a person that he must be a fool to be always in so gloomy a state of mind; but now I cannot help sinking into the same desponding frames, and oh! I would to God that I had been more kind to him!” Yes, we should feel more for the prisoner if we knew more about the prison.

    A raised voice and trite sayings cannot mend another human being. We look to Jesus with our consciences, our circumstances, and our chemistries. The sorrowing have a Savior. Our sturdy hope isn’t that we get ourselves together but that he holds us and all things together, whether we find assurance or not. Our healing isn’t what saves us. His grace saves us. Our speedy recovery isn’t what gives us hope. His unselfish willingness to find us and carry us home anchors the hope on which we lean.

    Even those who contemplate taking their lives hear Spurgeon’s appeal for life only after Spurgeon shares with them his desire to die and his surprise that in this fallen world more of us haven’t ended it all. In this fellow-feeling of a friend, who himself is acquainted with the abysmal darkness, Spurgeon then lifts his and our hope to the Man of sorrows sent from God—God himself. The Man of sorrows not only pays for our sins but also takes our howling cry up to God, “Why have you forsaken me?” The sorrowing have a savior because the Savior is also acquainted with grief, wondering why God would let the pain go unanswered.

    The God we turn to has turned first to us. He comes as a humbled one who also has suffered. We look to him for help, for healing, and for hope. The sorrowing Savior fought death to the death and won.

    Run to the Fight

    Where does this leave us? Spurgeon as a fellow sorrower calls out to us:

    The soul is broken in pieces, lanced, pricked with knives, dissolved, racked, pained. It knows not how to exist when it gives way to fear. Up, Christian! You are of a sorrowful countenance; up and chase your fears. Why would you be ever groaning in your dungeon? Why should Giant Despair forever beat you with his Crabtree cudgel? Up! Drive him away!

    But how? If our greatest hope isn’t our present healing but his everlasting love, what do we do? With all of his promises, words, counsel, and saving graces; with all of his natural provisions of retreat, laughter, creation, quiet, rest, hot baths, and medicines; with every cavernous longing for the redemption of every aching thing—we look at our accuser, and we whisper if we cannot shout: “You might be right, but Jesus!”

    You might be right, things are worse than I thought, but Jesus!

    You might be right, all is lost, but Jesus!

    You might be right, I am abandoned, but Jesus!

    You might be right, I am forfeit, but Jesus!

    You might be right, I should stay down, but Jesus!

    You might be right, it would be too late for me, but Jesus!

    You might be right, I am out of reach, but Jesus!

    You might be right, I am a sinner, but Jesus!

    You might be right, they might be better off without me, but Jesus!

    You might be right, I could deserve to die, but Jesus!

    Feel the Bottom

    Charles Spurgeon cherished a particular picture. The engraver portrayed the moment in Pilgrim’s Progress in which Christian panics as he’s being swallowed up by the deeps of a river and going under. The portrait shows Christian’s companion, Hopeful, pushing up with his arm around Christian and lifting up his hand, shouting, “Fear not! Brother, I feel the bottom.”

    With this picture in his mind, the preacher so familiar with sorrows rejoices with those listening to him. “This is just what Jesus does in our trials,” Spurgeon proclaims. “He puts his arm around us, points up and says, ‘Fear not! The water may be deep, but the bottom is good.’”

    It may be that you suffer from a mental sickness in the form of depression of spirit. Things look dark, and your heart is heavy. Life is like a foggy day. Providence is cloudy and stormy, and you are caught in a hurricane. Your soul is exceedingly sorrowful, and you are bruised as a cluster trodden in the winepress. Yet cling close to God, and never let go of your reverent fear of him. However exceptional and unusual may be your trial, with Job whisper these words, “Though he slay me, yet will I trust him.”

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑