Chapter 6 of 17

3. John Bunyan (1628–88): Faithful in Prison

3. John Bunyan (1628–88): Faithful in Prison

three

John Bunyan (1628–88): Faithful in Prison

TONY ROSE

Introducing you to John Bunyan in one chapter makes me smile. How do you describe in a few words a man who wrote sixty books? Thankfully, detailed descriptions of Bunyan’s life are readily available elsewhere. I hope to give you a peek into his life that, like an appetizer, makes you want more.

I enjoy reading the life stories of great men from the past. I usually begin with great excitement. Excitement often leads to inspiration. But then, inspiration leads to discouragement. Why? Because I end up comparing the fruit of my ministry with theirs and fall quite short. Let me both explode that myth and confess my sin. When we read of how God used another in the work of the gospel it should always stir thankfulness in our hearts. Our discouragement over someone else’s fruitful ministry reveals a selfish heart.

The benefit I now seek from reading about God’s work through others is three-fold. First, few things teach and inspire me simultaneously like a good biography. It is like having a personal mentor from the past. Second, I am brought to confess my own sin. Such self-examination has become a light into the secret discontentment of my own soul. Finally, biographies can serve as a mirror into which I look to develop a more accurate self-understanding. Richard Baxter called it the benefit of self-acquaintance. Through the life of others, I more accurately learn my own gifts and capacities.

I offer a word of advice when reading about greats from the past. Our desire for heroes seems to produce an irresistible urge to dress up great saints of the past and make them a bit more attractive than they actually were. Our present need to inspire others can lead us to needlessly exaggerate and make our heroes into idols. But Bunyan stands out from the crowd of dead pastor-theologians. “The Tinker of Bedford” wrote his autobiography with such painful transparency that it is nearly impossible to make him more attractive than he actually was. Could we stand such transparency today?

Turbulent Life and Times

Writing to pastors about faithfulness amid suffering through the lens of Bunyan’s life produced some serious confrontations in my soul. Truthfully, a normal day in Bunyan’s life would be considered a day of great suffering for most of us. Bunyan’s sixty years were lived during some of England’s most turbulent times. England was filled with civil unrest. Deadly plagues and a bloody civil war left citizens staggering through life. The battles within civil leadership were paralleled by battles within the church.

Bunyan grew up in a small village about fifty miles north of London. He and his family were a bit distant from the political and ecclesiastical conflicts for a while. Bunyan’s ancestors were landowners, but due to changing circumstances, by the time he was born the Bunyan clan was a rather poor lot. His dad was a tinker—that is, a brazier or tinsmith who made and repaired cooking pots and pans.

Bunyan had enough schooling to learn to read and write, but he was not well educated. Vocationally, he followed in his father’s footsteps. We learn from Bunyan’s Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners that he was a rather rascally youth. Because he was a natural leader, Bunyan was always first in the gang of neighborhood boys in their troublemaking escapades: “It was my delight to be taken captive by the devil [to do] his will. . . . From a child, I had but few equals . . . for cursing, swearing, lying, and blaspheming the holy name of God. So rooted and settled was I in these things, they became as a second nature to me.”

Bunyan’s environment surrounded him with hardship. The Black Plague cast its grim shadow across England again when Bunyan was eight, killing more than thirty thousand people. Eight years later, his mother and sister both died within a month. His dad quickly remarried. At age seventeen, Bunyan joined Cromwell’s Parliamentary army. He was among a group of soldiers selected for a dangerous mission to besiege a certain location. A fellow soldier asked to go in his place. A musket ball to the head killed Bunyan’s substitute. Providence was guarding Bunyan for service in Christ’s army.

Bunyan left the army in 1647 and began work as a tinker. England, however, remained in an uproar. Two years later, Charles I was put on trial and executed as a traitor. Bunyan married the same year. We don’t know his first wife’s name, but her Christian upbringing had considerable influence on him. Nine years into their marriage with four children younger than ten, one of whom was blind, his wife died. A year later Bunyan married Elizabeth. He was thirty-one; she was eighteen.

Pilgrim’s Perilous Journey

Bunyan’s interest in spiritual things seems to have been sparked by his first wife. Soon after their marriage, Bunyan began a process of serious outward transformations. People who knew him well were astonished at his newfound piety, but the changes were merely legalistic and external. One day while working, he overheard a group of women talking of spiritual things. He fancied himself rather good at spiritual conversation and joined them. Bunyan soon found himself out of his league. There was joy in their fellowship that he had never experienced. His heart yearned for what he saw in them. From that conversation Bunyan’s spiritual journey began in earnest.

The Bible became the centerpiece of his life from that day till the day of his death. The unstoppable work of grace God began in Bunyan would lead him to the same joy in Christ those women had. But his path would be filled with torturous internal struggles that toggled between doubt and faith. He chronicled the journey with astounding frankness in his stunning spiritual autobiography, Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners.

Bunyan’s path from conversion to assurance seems to have been his first phase of suffering. His intense internal battles enabled him to write with profound insight about the human experience. Battling through sins, doubts, an unsound mind, and the devil’s onslaughts developed his assurance of God’s love and produced strength of soul to faithfully suffer through twelve years in jail.

What Bunyan recorded of his experiences has proven difficult for some modern readers. Some see him as suffering from a severe mental malady. Others think his turmoil was strictly a spiritual experience in coming to a settled faith in Christ. After my thirty years of being a pastor and spending twenty-seven of those years living daily with the Puritans’ works, I am convinced it was both. I am eternally grateful Bunyan chronicled his struggles. Had Bunyan not written of his personal battles on the way to finding strong assurance in Christ, I might still be as he once was—besieged by raging thoughts, up and down in assurance twenty times an hour.

Thankfully, those Christian ladies guided Bunyan to the church at which the godly Mr. Gifford was pastor. Bunyan’s story is a beautiful picture of the local church being what God intended it to be. From the church at Bedford, Bunyan received pastoral care, biblical instruction, and Christian fellowship that led to a sound mind and a sound faith. Grace Abounding chronicles the parallel between his faith maturing and his mind becoming sound.

Preaching His Way into Jail

The Bedford church soon realized Bunyan was gifted to speak the gospel to the human heart. In the beginning of his ministry, he struggled with intrusive thoughts of the worst kind. Doubts still raised their heads and made him stumble. I think his every word was preached as much to himself as to his congregation. He was able to preach boldly even as strange thoughts and doubts welled up inside of him because he rested on the gospel that was outside of him.

The war between godly self-confidence and grueling self-doubt grew hottest in Bunyan when he climbed behind the sacred desk:

Indeed, I have been as one sent to them from the dead; I went myself in chains to preach to them in chains; and carried that fire in my own conscience that I persuaded them to be aware of. I can truly say . . . when I have been to preach, I have gone full of guilt and terror even to the pulpit door, and there it hath been taken off, and I have been at liberty in my mind until I have done my work, and then immediately, even before I could get down the pulpit stairs, I have been as bad as I was before; yet God carried me on, but surely with a strong hand, for neither guilt or hell could take me off my work.

Bunyan’s fight to keep his faith in Christ alone is a model for pastors. Our weaknesses and temptations are reminders that our salvation and our ministry always depend on God, not us. An inkling of a thought that something in us helps guarantee our salvation or produces fruit in our ministry will lead us to either swell with foolish pride or get caught in the swift current of self-loathing.

The power of God’s Spirit on Bunyan’s preaching drew many people to hear him. He was becoming quite influential. Due to related governmental and ecclesiastical upheavals, church and state authorities told Bunyan he was not properly authorized to preach. He was ordered to stop or be jailed. Bunyan did not stop preaching the gospel. He knew God had called and commanded him to do so. He was arrested.

Authorities attempted to get Bunyan to sign an agreement that he would no longer preach the gospel without the state church’s authorization. If he did so, he could go free. Bunyan replied to their offer: “If I were out of prison today, I would preach the gospel again tomorrow by the help of God.”

Bunyan was found guilty and spent nearly thirteen years in jail. His suffering at times felt unbearable. He was deeply anguished over his young wife and the four children, especially daughter Mary who was blind: “I found myself a man, and compassed with infirmities; the parting with my wife and poor children hath oft been to me in this place as the pulling of flesh from my bones.”

Bunyan’s wife pled eloquently to the magistrate for her husband’s release, but even she was denied. Bunyan’s life certainly seems like an odd process out of which to make an influential gospel preacher. But God does seem to use jails to prepare his finest servants.

Bridled Tongue, Unleashed Pen

What enabled Bunyan to stay faithful to God through such long and unjust suffering? One significant factor was his sense of spiritual responsibility. He had become a trusted leader. Many now looked to him for instruction and example. Bunyan knew that by signing the agreement he would not only dishonor God but also become a stumbling block to a multitude of suffering believers.

A few times Bunyan was given reprieve from jail, during which he would see his family and preach at every opportunity. He was always returned to jail, and the preacher’s mouth would be shut. However, as has been the case since the prophets of the Old Testament, when the preacher is arrested his pen is set free.

Telling a preacher he cannot preach will either crush him or create him. God used the harshest of teachers to create a man of God out of the “chief of sinners.” The faculty at Bunyan’s school of internal suffering was composed of a few specialists—intrusive thoughts of a blasphemous nature that caused him to seriously think he had committed the unpardonable sin, unrelenting doubts about his salvation, and emotional upheavals that continually kept him haunted with fear. The devil used each of these issues to accuse and assault Bunyan at every turn:

While I was in this temptation, I should often find my mind suddenly put upon it, to curse or swear, or to speak some grievous thing against God, or Christ his Son, and of the Scriptures. Now I thought, surely I am possessed of the devil.

The faculty at Bunyan’s school of outward suffering included poor living quarters in the jail, ongoing severe injustice, separation from family, and restraint from preaching.

There have been times while reading Bunyan I have felt fearful or nauseated and broke out in a nervous sweat. I sit stuck in my seat thinking, Oh dear God, what would I do in such a situation? How did Bunyan see his way through? At a point early in his long path to assurance in Christ, Bunyan said something like “From that day forward I was never out of my Bible.” Bunyan’s secret was no secret at all. Through daily dependence on God’s Word accompanied by the support of his church, he found sustenance to endure the unthinkable:

I never knew what it was for God to stand by me at all turns, and at every offer of Satan to afflict me as I have found him since I came in [to jail]; for look how fears have presented themselves, so have supports and encouragements, yea, when I have started, even as it were at nothing else but my shadow, yet God, as being very tender of me, hath not suffered me to be molested, but would with one scripture and another strengthen me against all; I could pray for greater trouble, for the greater comfort’s sake.

Charles Spurgeon said of Bunyan that if you cut him he bled “bibline” because God’s Word seemingly flowed through his veins. Though confined in jail Bunyan was not merely a self-absorbed reader of the Word. He intensely labored to translate the work of grace in his heart into written words for the spiritual benefit of others.

It may sound far too simple, but Bunyan remained faithful by keeping his mind on “the things that are above, where Christ is, seated at the right hand of God” (Col. 3:1) and by humbly counting others more significant than himself, looking “not only to his own interests, but also to the interests of others” (Phil. 2:4). Note that I said simple, not easy.

God’s Word, not his circumstances, defined reality for Bunyan. Bunyan demonstrated that a mind set on Christ and serving his people produces a freedom no jail can confine. While in jail Bunyan wrote at least fourteen books and treatises, including Pilgrim’s Progress. He left himself little time to think upon his suffering.

Lessons from Bunyan

Most of us will never suffer as Bunyan did. So how does his affliction help us today? The contrast between his life and ours is the key to one lesson from Bunyan. We can be blinded by admiration or envy of heroic men of God. We should not read them hoping to mimic their actions to produce similar results. God has given us the treasure of biographies so we can see the gospel at work deep inside his servants and learn to depend on Christ in our day as they did in theirs. Comparing the fruitfulness of our ministry with those of the past or with our contemporaries is an unhealthy exercise. Yet learning from the daily faithfulness of our brothers and sisters past and present is deeply beneficial.

A second lesson from Bunyan concerns a window he opened into his life that we often keep shut. I will call this closed window secret sufferings. These secret sufferings are acute in pastors (because many erroneously suppose we are stronger Christians than “mere” church members). Our skills at hiding them become sophisticated. We would feel no shame in talking about our physical sufferings. But how many of us would feel comfortable telling someone about our doubting mind? Would you tell anyone that before you went into the pulpit your mind at times was flooded with blasphemous thoughts and you feared you might actually say them out loud? Bunyan told the world such things in his autobiography. He opened the window on his secret sufferings to free others who were suffering in secret.

I think we would agree that Bunyan’s journey to salvation and assurance is not a path common to all believers. In fact, Bunyan’s description of his faith journey is so unusual to us that many Christians find him rather strange and his experience disturbing. He was a godly man, yet atheistic thoughts assaulted his mind and undermined his assurance:

For about the space of a month . . . a very great storm came down on me, which handled me twenty times worse than all I had met with before; it came stealing upon me, now by one piece, then by another; first, all my comfort was taken from me, then darkness seized upon me, after which, whole floods of blasphemies, both against God, Christ, and the Scriptures, were poured upon my spirit, to my great confusion and astonishment. These blasphemous thoughts were such as also stirred up questions in me, against the very being of God, and of his only beloved Son; as, whether there were, in truth, a God, or Christ, or no? And whether the holy Scriptures were not rather a fable, and cunning story, than the holy and pure Word of God?

Not everyone experiences the torturous processes of an obsessive mind like Bunyan. However, if we do—especially if we are pastors—we tend to keep that window closed. Doubts and blasphemous thoughts are considered off-limits for Christians, especially pastors.

Bunyan, like the young Martin Luther, had an overactive conscience and a faulty understanding of grace. This wedding of disparate spiritual partners left Bunyan open to forming terribly inaccurate conceptions of God and of himself. Wrong conceptions of God in an unsound mind can produce overwhelming floods of fear, depression, despair, and hopelessness.

On his worst days Bunyan could not tell the difference between the urges and impulses of his mind and emotions from the voice of God in Scripture. For instance, Bunyan said Satan perennially hammered him with questions about Scripture: “[Satan] would assault me with this, how can you tell but that the Turks [Muslims] had as good Scriptures to prove their Mahomet [Muhammad] the Saviour, as we have to prove our Jesus is?”

Bunyan’s experience is described in Pilgrim’s Progress when Christian is walking through the valley of the shadow of death. Christian heard his thoughts as voices. He could not tell if his thoughts were his own or if someone else was speaking to him. Bunyan described how he would gain assurance from a Scripture passage suddenly coming to mind only to tumble into the pit of doubt by hearing a competing voice of accusation.

Free at Last

Reading Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners set me free. I was one of those pastors who experienced what Spurgeon called “fainting fits” and Richard Baxter called “a crazed wit.” I kept my thoughts, feelings, and fears secret for years. The window to my soul was shut and locked. There was no way I would let anybody see inside me. I thought no one else, especially pastors, went through such things. I prolonged and intensified my secret suffering by keeping it hidden from others. Secrecy is the devil’s tool. Bunyan’s frightening transparency brought me comfort and gave me courage to open the window to my soul’s dark corner. I learned from Bunyan that if I would ever know God and myself accurately, it must be through Scripture.

Our conceptions of God are worthless and dangerous unless they are formed by God’s self-description in Scripture. Without the gospel all our notions of God are mere caricatures. God made us in such a way that our true affections follow our mind’s impressions. That means to genuinely love God we must know him truly. My ill concept of God mixed with a subtle form of pride drove me to deep despair. I “felt” I was such a terrible sinner that God could not forgive me. My dear wife asked me one day, “Tony, what makes you think you are so special that you are the only person in the world God can’t forgive?” It was the most stingingly insightful question I had ever been asked.

With Bunyan’s help I finally grasped the reality of my sinfulness and the necessity of resting on Christ’s merits alone. Stripped of all pretended righteousness, with all my sin exposed, God’s gospel taught me to run to Christ. I no longer needed “fig leaves”—closed windows to cover my unrelenting shame. “Naked and exposed to the eyes of him to whom we must give account,” I heard the voice of Jesus, my High Priest, say to me, “With confidence draw near to the throne of grace” (Heb. 4:13, 16).

Resting completely on Christ, though confined to jail, John Bunyan was no longer consumed with self but was set free to get the gospel out to others. God used Bunyan’s greatest weakness to become his greatest strength. His obsessive mind was now sanctified and unfettered to write unceasingly of his majestic Savior.

Is it possible that you have a window to your soul you keep shut? Are you ashamed to open it? Shame is a chain that keeps us from the freeing power of God’s grace. You may be trying to hide the very part of you that God can greatly use. I leave you with Bunyan’s own words. If you need them I pray they will help you, as they have me, to open that window and exchange the chain of shame for the freedom of grace. They are summarized in the title of one of his works: Come and Welcome to Jesus Christ. In the school of affliction, Bunyan learned that Christ was his anchor amid the flood:

Note, when providences are black and terrible to God’s people, the Lord Jesus shows himself to them in wonderful manner; the which sometimes they can as little bear, as they can the things that were before terrible to them. They were afraid of the wind and water; they were also afraid of their Lord and Savior, when he appeared to them in that state. . . . Note, that the end of the appearing of the Lord Jesus unto his people, though the manner of his appearing be never so terrible, is to allay their fears and perplexities.

↑ Back to top

↑