Chapter 10 of 17

7. Charles Simeon (1759–1836): Faithful Shepherd to Hostile Sheep

7. Charles Simeon (1759–1836): Faithful Shepherd to Hostile Sheep

seven

Charles Simeon (1759–1836): Faithful Shepherd to Hostile Sheep

RANDALL J. GRUENDYKE

They were all there. And why not? He had always been there for them. On the November afternoon of Charles Simeon’s funeral, townsmen closed their shops and packed the main streets of Cambridge while hundreds of university gownsmen, for whom most lectures had been canceled that day, queued up three abreast in the King’s College court. As the solemn line of mourners, led by dignitaries and family, slowly entered through the massive, west-facing doors of King’s College Chapel, they were met by a tearful company from Holy Trinity Church, Simeon’s congregation of fifty-four years. What followed was in keeping with Simeon’s wishes—a simple service ending with “buri[al] in my college chapel,” a place marked to this day by a cross pattée; his initials, CS; and the year 1836.

When one considers Simeon’s accomplishments, it makes sense that the man for whom every Cambridge chapel bell tolled on that day was worthy of the honor. Even in human terms, Simeon was a thoroughgoing success. From his rooms in the Gibbs Building at King’s, Simeon presided over his famous Friday evening “Conversation Parties”—a Q&A on the Bible and theology for generations of undergraduates. From that same place Simeon hosted his influential Sunday afternoon preaching classes—a clinic on sermon preparation and delivery that touched decades of aspiring ministers.

From Holy Trinity Church, Simeon’s strategic approaches to pastoral care, ministerial staffing, and most of all, Bible-centered preaching led to the expansion of his congregation as well as the building in which they met at Market and Sidney Streets. As a leader in the church at large, Simeon advanced gospel proclamation by helping to found the Church Missionary Society. He also promoted the dissemination of Scripture by helping found the British and Foreign Bible Society and the popularity and influence of Bible exposition by publishing his sermons that, by the end of his life, totaled twenty-one volumes. Simeon also capitalized on an English ecclesiastical law that allowed him to appoint men of his choosing to pulpits throughout England.

But among those gathered on that soggy Saturday, there were some who remembered how it used to be—when Charles Simeon was among a despised and vast minority of evangelical Anglican ministers, when the name of the King’s College fellow was a well-traveled term of derision (e.g., “Sim” or “Simeonite”), and when the perpetual curate of Holy Trinity Church was serving as a faithful shepherd among hostile sheep.

Privilege and Pain

Charles Simeon’s early life was marked by seasons of privilege mixed with pain. He was born into privilege on September 24, 1759, but he suffered the pain of growing up without a mother. As a boy, Simeon was privileged to attend Eton, but as an adult he resolved that he would rather “murder” his own son than let him witness the evils he saw at the well-heeled prep school. As a King’s Scholar at Eton, Simeon was privileged with admission to, as well as the exclusivities of, membership at King’s College Cambridge. Simultaneously, the young scholar endured the pain of ostracism due to his evangelical faith, his conversion to which deserves some attention.

Other than a fleeting sense of pietistic devotion during a national fast day in 1776 for the beleaguered British troops fighting the “American War,” young Simeon had little if any interest in spiritual things. That dramatically changed upon his entrance to King’s when, in January 1779, Simeon learned that in three weeks he would be expected to attend the college communion service. The nineteen-year-old was mortified since, as he put it, “The thought rushed through my mind that Satan himself was as fit to attend as I.” In an attempt to soothe his disquieted soul, Simeon began voraciously reading religious literature.

He started with The Whole Duty of Man (“the only religious book that I had ever heard of,” Simeon later recalled) and soon thereafter joined the Society for the Promotion of Christian Knowledge (“because I thought the books of that society would be the most useful of any I could procure”). While Whole Duty steadied Simeon to receive the February communion, it was a title by Bishop Thomas Wilson, A Short and Plain Instruction . . . of the Lord’s Supper, that God used to bring the nineteen-year-old to faith in Christ. Wilson helped Simeon see that just as the sins of God’s Old Testament people were transferred to the head of a sacrificial animal, so the sins of his New Testament people, and Simeon in particular, had been entirely conveyed onto Christ. The brilliance of this good news rose like the sun in Simeon’s heart so that “on the Wednesday [of Holy Week, I] began to have a hope of mercy; on the Thursday that hope increased; and on the Sunday morning, Easter Day, . . . I awoke early with those words upon my heart and lips, ‘Jesus Christ is risen today! Hallelujah! Hallelujah!’”

While Simeon’s newfound faith brought him great joy, it won him no friends. To be sure, there were other evangelicals in Cambridge at the time, but Simeon’s gospel effusiveness (which earned him the disdainful descriptor enthusiast), coupled with the somewhat-cloistered life of a Kingsman (who enjoyed greater privileges than students at the other Cambridge colleges), kept him from meeting any of them. Though Simeon’s predicament made for a lonely undergraduate life, it may have been those wilderness years that forced the new Christian to build and rely on his knowledge of Scripture as the source of his spiritual health.

Upon graduating from Cambridge, Simeon took up residence at King’s College as a fellow and, four months later, was ordained as a deacon in the Church of England. That same year, Simeon began sitting under the ministry of Christopher Atkinson at nearby St. Edward King and Martyr. St. Edward’s had been the furnace for the English Reformation, a fire stoked by Latimer, Barnes, and Bilney, among others. Now, 250 years later, most of that gospel heat was gone. Nevertheless, when Atkinson invited Simeon to take his place for the summer of 1782, all that changed.

The brand-new Cambridge graduate filled the linenfold pulpit with Bible-centered sermons and a demonstrative preaching style that quickly upset the St. Edward’s regulars. It also packed the remaining pews with more new faces than had been seen in a hundred years on Peas Hill. In a letter to pastor and hymn writer John Newton, John Berridge of Everton excitedly reported that since Simeon’s arrival, St. Edward’s was “crowded like a theater on the first night of a play.” Thus, it came as a significant surprise when Simeon’s summer of privilege gave way to an extended season of pain.

Simeon’s Trial

As an undergraduate, Simeon would walk through the center of Cambridge University, pass Holy Trinity Church, and wonder what it would be like to “preach the gospel there and be a herald for Him to the University.” In God’s providence—and much to everyone’s astonishment—that wish came true in the autumn of 1782. How that dream was realized led to what is arguably one of the most protracted trials ever suffered by a modern parish pastor.

Soon after learning about the sudden death of Holy Trinity’s minister, Henry Therond, Simeon asked his father to put in a good word for him with the Bishop of Ely, James Yorke. Yorke was a friend of the elder Simeon’s and was responsible for choosing Therond’s successor. Richard Simeon expedited his son’s request and, in short order, the bishop appointed the twenty-three-year-old Simeon to the Holy Trinity vacancy.

Upon hearing the name of their new pastor, the congregation erupted in protest and petitioned the bishop on behalf of their choice, John Hammond, who had at least three things weighing in his favor. First, Hammond was already ordained as a priest (Simeon was just a deacon) and had previously served a curacy at nearby St. Boltoph’s. Second, Hammond had been a minister at Holy Trinity Church since Simeon was a schoolboy at Eton. Third, Hammond’s broad theological views and political savvy were in keeping with the status quo of most Anglican churches of the time.

The bishop was so perturbed by the people’s plea, which he supposed to be a challenge to his authority, that he wrote to the young Simeon and said the job was his, and that even if Simeon had resigned (as falsely reported by the congregation to the bishop), Hammond would not be selected to serve as the next minister of Holy Trinity. Yorke’s letter sealed both Simeon’s appointment and the people’s opposition to him. In defiance of the bishop’s decision, and per their prerogative, the congregation hired Hammond as their afternoon lecturer and gave him a salary twice that of Simeon. The battle line had been drawn, and neither the people nor their leader, Hammond, was prepared to budge.

Even though Simeon’s new charge was just a three-minute walk from the scene of his summer success, it must have seemed like a million miles when he first stepped into the Holy Trinity Church pulpit on November 10. The resentful congregation welcomed Simeon by locking their rented pews and refusing to show up. Anyone coming to hear the new preacher had to sit in the aisles in which Simeon had set up seats at his own expense. In response to this accommodation, the church wardens tossed the seats out of the building and into the street. This led Simeon to start a Sunday evening service. At first, the church wardens opposed it, so Simeon backed off. The next year he tried to launch it again and was presented with a statement from church officers declaring that Holy Trinity had never held a third service and was in no way predisposed to do so. When Simeon tried a third time, the church wardens retaliated by locking the church doors.

Opponents at the University

Simeon was opposed not only by the people of his own parish but also by the members of his own university. When the church wardens finally agreed to let Simeon start a Sunday night service, the university scheduled a Greek lecture at the same hour. The establishment hoped to discourage students from sitting under Simeon’s gospel-centered preaching. For the undergraduates who did make it to hear Simeon, there was a price to be paid. To avoid harm from hecklers, gownsmen traveled to and from Holy Trinity Church in groups.

Following each service, Simeon or the church moderator, William Farish, stood by the north door to prevent altercations between loitering troublemakers and departing churchgoers. Despite their best efforts, stones were thrown outside the building while periodic distractions, including a drunken disturbance, took place inside. On at least one occasion, Simeon was pelted with rotten eggs. On another, he escaped being jumped at the north door when he uncustomarily departed through the south exit. Years later, recalling Simeon’s early days at Holy Trinity Church, William Dealtry said, “Within these sacred walls disorders have occurred which it required the greatest vigor, and most determined resolution to put down.”

For a dozen years Simeon faithfully shepherded his persistently hostile flock. So recalcitrant was the membership that it circulated one petition after another demanding their minister’s removal. Pastoral visitation was futile. And when, after five years, Hammond finally resigned his afternoon lectureship, the congregation bypassed Simeon and hired Butler Berry to replace Hammond. Berry held the post for seven years. In 1795 the entrenched opposition finally ended, and while never entirely free from trials (e.g., a compromised state of health hampered him in middle age from 1807 to 1820), Simeon’s best days were ahead of him. But he had suffered for twelve long years.

Simeon’s Response

To be sure, most ministers would wilt under such hostility. What steadied Simeon during that epic time of testing? At least three things, all of them lessons for today’s pastor who either is or will be under the lash of persecution—perhaps even at the hands of his own congregation.

Simeon Held On to the Word and Prayer

Simeon clung tightly to the essential means of grace—the Word and prayer—and his everyday schedule reflected that priority. While not an early riser by nature, Simeon became one by choice for the purpose of prayerfully saturating himself in Scripture. A former roommate and witness of Simeon’s daily routine once attested that he regularly rose at 4:00 a.m. Years later, Matthew Preston, one of Simeon’s curates, observed the same, noting, “He rose very early—for that purpose retiring early to rest.” Devoting the first four hours of his day to the Lord (the privilege of a lifelong bachelor), Simeon was able to prayerfully consider his life circumstances in light of God’s Word. Concerning the hostile congregation of Holy Trinity Church, he reflects:

In this state of things, I saw no remedy but faith and patience. The passage of Scripture which subdued and controlled my mind was this, “The servant of the Lord must not strive” (2 Tim. 2:24). It was painful indeed to see the church, with the exception of the aisles, almost forsaken; but I thought that if God would only give a double blessing to the congregation that did attend, there would . . . be as much good done as if the congregation were doubled and the blessing limited to only half the amount. Without such a reflection, I should have sunk under the burden.

From his sermons, it is clear that one of Simeon’s favorite verses was Psalm 81:10: “I am the LORD thy God, which brought thee out of the land of Egypt: open thy mouth wide, and I will fill it” (KJV). In the midst of his hardship, Simeon recommended that believers walk close with God, read his Word much, and pray much.

Simeon Held On to Humility

Upon Simeon’s appointment to Holy Trinity, business magnate and evangelical statesman John Thornton advised the young minister that “to soar heavenward” he must “grow downwards in humility.” Simeon took Thornton’s words, along with those of other eminent well-wishers, to heart and submitted himself to the same church wardens who hated him. Simeon reasoned, “I wished rather to suffer than to act; because in suffering I could not fail to be right; but in acting I might easily do amiss.”

Simeon’s reactive posture of humility was shaped by his proactive practice of the same. Throughout his early years, the young pastor humbly sought the counsel of elder clergymen, especially Henry Venn, in matters of life and ministry. Simeon also put his preaching under the scrutiny of a Mr. Rilands, whom he describes as “a faithful friend,” since only such a friend would “show you your deficiencies.” Later, Venn writes to Rilands, “None can bear and receive profit from reproof like [Charles Simeon].” During this painful period, Simeon carried in his wallet the humble reminder “Talk not about myself,” and in 1788 he observes, “The three lessons that a minister has to learn, 1. Humility—2. Humility—3. Humility.”

At a point in life when Simeon was “more conspicuous for his courage and energy than his discretion,” the Lord honored the young minister’s commitment to humility by preventing his passion from ever harming his work.

Simeon Held On to His Ministry

The hostility of Simeon’s church did not tempt him to walk away from his ministry. If those who rented the pews at Holy Trinity Church stubbornly refused to fill them on Sunday morning, then Simeon gratefully preached to the men and women who gladly filled the aisles. Most of them were university students, the working class, and residents of the parish house who, if they hoped to eat, were required by law to attend church twice on Sunday. Simeon also began to preach in modest village congregations. He even delivered early morning sermons to farmhands who gathered in a nearby barn. Around this same time, Simeon used Sunday afternoons to teach future ministers how to preach.

Simeon held on to and advanced his ministry outside of the pulpit as well. When the church wardens at Holy Trinity prevented parishioners from meeting with Simeon in their building, the young minister rented a room in town. And during this time Simeon successfully started a youth group as well as a network of affinity-based small groups, the leaders of which Simeon supervised on a monthly basis. Even during those difficult years, Simeon regularly donated a third of his income to advance the ministries of others, including those dedicated to church schools, local pastors, needy widows, and more. Simeon refused to let the opposition inhibit his ministry to all. And he certainly kept what was happening within the flock from preventing what could be done outside.

Simeon’s Legacy

In Charles Simeon’s early days of ministry, it appeared that the people of Holy Trinity Church opposed him because they wanted John Hammond to be their minister. That was partly true, but over time it became apparent that their hostility was largely “due to the directness of [Simeon’s] Gospel preaching.”

Gratefully, Simeon’s suffering did not frustrate the Lord’s work in and through him as, over time, he was rewarded for his pastoral faithfulness and tenacity. Simeon’s devotion to the good news strengthened the Trinity pulpit as well as her people. His ministerial example was followed by numerous protégés who furthered gospel proclamation throughout Great Britain and beyond. Simeon’s ministry set a standard for ministers and gospel workers not only in his lifetime but beyond it as well.

Today, the ministries of Universities and Colleges Christian Fellowship (UCCF) in the United Kingdom, InterVarsity Christian Fellowship (IVCF) in the United States, and International Fellowship of Evangelical Students (IFES) elsewhere in the world can trace the roots of their university-based ministries back to the enduring influence of Charles Simeon. And around the globe, the broadly influential ministries of Phillip Jensen (Australia), Dick Lucas and the late John Stott (England), and Kent Hughes (United States) have Simeon’s gospel fingerprints all over them—ongoing testimonies to a faithful shepherd among hostile sheep and to the Great Shepherd by whom he was steadied and sustained.

↑ Back to top

↑