Chapter 7 of 17

4. Jonathan Edwards (1703–58): Faithful to the End

4. Jonathan Edwards (1703–58): Faithful to the End

four

Jonathan Edwards (1703–58): Faithful to the End

PETER BECK

The apostle Paul told the wayward congregation of Corinthians to do whatever they did to the glory of God (1 Cor. 10:31). Jonathan Edwards told his congregation the same thing from the beginning of his ministry among them until the bitter end. He remained faithful to this grand vision to the end of his life. In his posthumously published The End for Which God Created the World, written while in pastoral exile, Edwards observes, “All that is ever spoken of in the Scripture as an ultimate end of God’s works is included in that one phrase, the glory of God.”

Jonathan Edwards stands as American evangelical Christianity’s favorite son. He preached perhaps the most famous sermon in the English language, “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God.” He, along with George Whitefield and others, embodied the power of the First Great Awakening. His fame extended to both sides of the Atlantic as his earliest works were published in hopes of preparing the church universal for a glorious work of God like the one in New England. Scholars today still laud him as America’s greatest theologian and philosopher. To the unfamiliar or the barely familiar, Edwards represents the heights of God’s work in early American history.

The rest of the story, however, is an American tragedy. It is the story of fame and infamy and of ecclesial disaster. Yet it is also the story of great faith in the God who works all things together for good (Rom. 8:28) and for his own glory (Rom. 11:36).

Destined for Greatness

God is glorified in the wisdom of redemption in this, that there appears in it so absolute and universal a dependence of the redeemed on him.

“Sinners” may be Edwards’s most famous sermon, but it was far from his first famous sermon. “God Glorified in Man’s Dependence,” preached just two years into his pastoral ministry, presaged two decades of ever-increasing glory for the son of a preacher man. In fact, everything about Edwards and his call to the ministry foreshadowed greatness.

Though not famous, Edwards’s father, Timothy, faithfully pastored his smallish congregation in East Windsor, Connecticut, for decades, modeling for his son the diligence necessary to complete the task before him. It was Edwards’s grandfather, Solomon Stoddard, who enjoyed fame serving as the pastor of the most influential church in the farthest western reaches of Massachusetts. Well-known theological opponents such as the Mathers in Boston respected Stoddard and labeled him the “pope of the Connecticut valley,” wittily criticizing his ecclesiological tendencies while acknowledging his profound reach. Unconcerned about accusations of nepotism or its potential consequences, Edwards accepted the call to join his grandfather in Northampton as his associate until Stoddard’s six-decade ministry drew to a close. Edwards was anointed the heir apparent. Providence placed the young Edwards, just twenty-three years old, in the shadow and the way of greatness.

Less than three years later, in 1729, Stoddard “died in a good old age, an old man and full of years” (see Gen. 25:8). As Edwards climbed the stairs to the pulpit, his star was on the rise. All eyes would be on him to see to what heights the grandson of the great Solomon Stoddard would ascend. Within two years he would be preaching to the assembled ministers of Boston. They received his Election Day sermon, “God Glorified in Man’s Dependence,” with glad and appreciative ears. Upon their recommendation Edwards published the sermon, and his fame began to spread. Nothing compared, however, to the lofty accolades that followed in the middle years of that decade. In the fall of 1734, Pastor Edwards faithfully preached his way through a lengthy sermon series on the doctrine of justification by faith alone drawn from Romans 4:5: “And to the one who does not work but believes in him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is counted as righteousness.” In the midst of that doctrine-heavy discourse, revival broke out in Northampton.

The quiet burg had experienced seasons of spiritual harvest several times under Stoddard, but they experienced nothing like what happened under Edwards. Over the next six months, the fires of revival spread from one home to another until nearly one-quarter of the population, upwards of three hundred of the town’s twelve hundred residents, came under the saving influence of the Holy Spirit. News of the revival spread, and soon correspondents sought an account of the surprising work of God from the pastor in Northampton. With that account Edwards’s renown spread farther—from New England to old England.

Though the excitement of 1734–35 died down less than a year later, God’s grace revisited Northampton and the rest of the middle and northern colonies six years later. As the effect of the First Great Awakening grew, so did opposition. Cries of “we’ve never done it this way before” spread across New England. Once more Edwards was called upon, this time to defend the authenticity and the vitality of the Awakening. Edwards responded faithfully, and a number of works flowed from his pen to this end. Along with these defenses he engaged in a transatlantic dialogue on the nature of revival and calls for concerted prayer for revival. While Whitefield may be the most famous preacher of the Awakening, Edwards became the “theologian of revival,” the man to whom his contemporaries and later generations would turn for an explanation of the glorious work of God in the conversion of the redeemed.

Destined for Failure

Edwards’s prayer request to his pen pal, the Scotsman Thomas Gillespie, reveals the depths to which the mighty had fallen within a decade of the zenith of his fame during the First Great Awakening. Amid a great church conflict, Edwards writes:

I desire your prayers that I may take notice of the frowns of heaven on me and this people (between whom was once so great an union), in the bringing to pass such a separation between us; and that these troubles may be sanctified to me; that God would overrule this event for his own glory (which doubtless many adversaries will rejoice and triumph in), that God would open a door for my future usefulness, and provide for me and my numerous family, and take a fatherly care of us in our present unsettled, uncertain circumstances, being cast on the wide world.

Things had gone badly. Edwards went from the pastoral penthouse to the outhouse in less than ten years. The turn of events weighed heavily upon his heart. In hindsight, none of it surprised anyone.

Circumstances beyond his control conspired against Edwards and the hopes of a long, trouble-free tenure in Northampton, the first of which was his beloved grandfather, Solomon Stoddard. Edwards faced the daunting task of replacing the legacy pastor of a storied church. Stoddard served Northampton for nearly sixty years. He was the only pastor most in the town ever knew. Only death could separate him from the congregation he built and loved. For all his gifts and newfound stature, Edwards could never truly replace Stoddard in their hearts.

Circumstances, however, forced Edwards to try. As the flames of revival burned out, Edwards addressed the failure of the revival to change the spiritual and social tenor of the town. The seeming apostasy of so many recent converts required him to examine what had happened and to proffer solutions to correct their course once more. Edwards’s most famous attempt, and perhaps the most lasting literary influence in his vast corpus, Religious Affections (1746), sought to defend the Awakening and promote Christian living among its converts by pointing out that many things masquerade as true conversion, including heightened emotions. True religious affections, however, show themselves in the believer’s reveling in God’s glory and bearing lasting fruit to that end. Edwards argued that not all professing believers are true believers—which likely included many among his congregation in Northampton.

The great treatise on the nature of saving faith proved insufficient to turn the tide of apathy in the church. With feigned agreement, they accepted his argument and denied its application. Thus, Edwards had to seek other ways to reform the assembled “saints” of Northampton. Like many modern-day pastors, Edwards sought to replace the current church covenant with one that reflected their current situation and addressed their spiritual needs, one in which the people were to “present [them]selves before the Lord, to renounce [their] evil ways, and put away [their] abominations from before God’s eyes, and with one accord to renew [their] engagements to seek and serve God.” The congregation followed the lead of their pastor and accepted his recommendation. They endorsed the new covenant while ignoring its implications.

While most of the congregation embraced Edwards’s idealism, many treated his attempts to reform the church as concerns for others but not for themselves. Such spiritual indifference ended up on the rocky shoals of Edwards’s next “innovation.” Recognizing that many in their midst possessed little more than a cultural form of Christianity, Edwards wished to reclaim an insistence upon a believer’s church akin to what he had studied in William Ames’s The Marrow Theology, a text he was essentially required to memorize during his days at Yale. This novelty was not tested immediately. The church in Northampton languished through a spiritual drought that lasted six years before another person presented himself for membership. Upon Edwards’s counsel a young man seeking admission into the church agreed to present his testimony before the congregation. The congregation balked. This insistence, they believed, violated the spirit of church membership instilled under the leadership of Stoddard decades earlier. Though long dead, their spiritual father still spoke (see Heb. 11:4). To prevent controversy, the young man withdrew his application. Later, a young woman presented herself for membership. Again controversy flared up, and again the church refused to hear Edwards’s position. She was denied admission because she wasn’t doing it the way they had in the past.

The presumed assault on Stoddard’s legacy continued when Edwards wished to address admission to the communion table. Stoddard, against the wishes of his contemporaries such as Increase Mather, opened the Lord’s Supper to not just local church members or even all believers but to all who desired to partake, including unbelievers. Stoddard was convinced that participation in the Lord’s Supper might lead to the salvation of some. In the Supper, he reasoned, they saw and partook of God’s grace in the crucifixion of Christ. In it, God might call them to salvation as they recognized their sinfulness and God’s mercy. The Lord’s Supper, he believed, is a “converting ordinance.”

When initially called to Northampton, Edwards, a relative newcomer to the ministry and in awe of Stoddard’s stature, accepted the practice of a truly open communion. Over time, however, he became convinced by Scripture that this was not biblical. He saw the spiritual stagnancy of the late 1740s as a reason to address the issue and correct their course. The people fell into open rebellion. They refused to listen to Edwards’s explanation. They denied him the opportunity to use his pulpit to make his case. They forced his hand and made him put his ideas to paper. In the end, though, they also refused to read his treatise, An Humble Inquiry. They wanted nothing to do with his latest attempt to change their church.

Finally, the people of Northampton understood the implications of Edwards’s ideas. By suggesting that a new church covenant was in order, Edwards was suggesting that the congregants, virtually everyone in town, failed to live up to their spiritual obligations. By requiring a valid profession of faith made in public, Edwards was suggesting their conversion and participation in the church may be invalid. By restricting the unbeliever’s access to the Lord’s Supper, Edwards might restrict their participation in an ordinance that many believed to be their birthright, the right of all who had been baptized upon birth rather than the new birth. Edwards’s ideas, they knew, assaulted more than Stoddard’s spiritual legacy. It undermined theirs.

Destined for Glory

I need the prayers of my fathers and brethren who are friendly to me, that I may have wisdom given me by my great master, and that I may be enabled to conduct with a steady faithfulness to him, under all trials and whatever may be the issue of this affair.

With the embers of the Awakening long dead and the fire of controversy in full flame, Edwards cast his future on the will of God; he called on friends near and far to pray on his behalf. With no resolution in sight and no hope for an amicable solution, the church and their pastor agreed to allow a council to convene, a committee to decide his fate. As they had done concerning the publication of Edwards’s views on communion, he and the church negotiated the details of this conclave, each hoping to their own advantage. Edwards mistook the compromise as a hopeful sign of God’s providence.

Edwards and the church determined that each side in the dispute would be represented by an equal number of hand-chosen friends or emissaries. Representing the church were friends and relatives of Solomon Stoddard, avowed enemies of the arrogant grandson who besmirched his memory. Representing Edwards would be friends and disciples from across the region. When the conclave gathered, June 19–22, 1750, the storm clouds had gathered but not all of Edwards’s representatives had. Worse, when surveyed on behalf of the council, only 10 percent of the congregation desired to retain Edwards as pastor. Then with a final, fateful vote, the council concluded the most famous pastor in American church history should be removed from his congregation. In the end Edwards lost the confidence of his people, and he lost his church by one vote. Yet Edwards’s faith remained unshaken. As one witness remembered, “I never saw the least symptoms of displeasure in his countenance the whole week, but he appeared like a man of God, whose happiness was out of reach of his enemies.”

Farewell, but Faithful

Weeks later, Edwards preached what John Piper believes to be “one of the most remarkable sermons that he—or perhaps any other pastor—has ever preached.” Edwards fittingly drew his “Farewell Sermon” from 2 Corinthians 1:14: “Just as you did partially understand us—that on the day of our Lord Jesus you will boast of us as we will boast of you.” Speaking of one final, future gathering of this pastor and his congregation, Edwards spoke of the coming judgment at which both he and they would stand before Christ and give an account of their relations with him and with one another. While painfully forthright with his audience about their complicity in the preceding controversy, he acknowledged his own shortcomings. Moreover, he spoke tenderly of his concern for their eternal well-being, offering both his heart and his prayers on their behalf. As he concluded, “But now I must bid you farewell. I must leave you in the hands of God: I can do no more for you than to pray for you.”

Edwards rightly knew this last appearance before his former congregation would not be his last, but he wrongly assumed their next meeting would be in eternity. Their meetings would be much sooner and much more frequent. With nowhere else to go, Edwards and his family remained in Northampton while they waited for God’s will to become apparent. As awkward as that must have been for him—there was only one church in town for him and his family to attend—the church begrudgingly came back to Edwards and asked him to fill his former pulpit until they could find a suitable replacement. Edwards supplied the pulpit for months before finally admitting the burden was unhealthy for them. A contingent of parishioners approached Edwards vowing their support should he decide to start a second church in Northampton. He graciously acknowledged their loyalty but demurred on account of his desire to be no further burden to his old congregation.

Thus, after nearly twenty-five years in Northampton, Edwards found himself cast upon turbulent seas with no prospect of security in sight. His faith, however, remained intact. He tells one correspondent, “I have now nothing visible to depend upon for my future usefulness, or the subsistence of my numerous family. But I hope we have an all-sufficient, faithful, covenant God to depend upon. I desire that I may ever submit to him, walk humbly before him, and put my trust wholly in him.”

Edwards’s tale of faithfulness does not end in failure, however. In what might be considered his wilderness experience as he literally proceeded into the wilderness of Massachusetts to serve as pastor of a small missionary outpost that ministered to the native population, Edwards served the church at large in a way heretofore impossible. Though God did not directly answer Edwards’s many prayers during the controversy, he answered a greater kingdom need. Free of the hassles of an unappreciative congregation, Edwards produced many of his greatest and most important works during his five-year sojourn in Stockbridge. He wrote Freedom of the Will, Original Sin, and his two treatises, The Nature of True Virtue and The End for Which God Created the World. These works continue to affect Christians and have secured Edwards’s legacy for generations to come.

Years later, worried about unfinished works, Edwards reluctantly accepted the call to the presidency of the College of New Jersey (Princeton) on the advice of friends who believed God had greater plans yet. After his arrival, in an attempt to lead the local population by example, Edwards received an immunization against small pox, a common killer in early America. Unfortunately, he contracted the disease and died within weeks. To the end Edwards remained faithful to God and his will for his life.

Faithful Example

By all appearances Edwards was destined for greatness. He enjoyed opportunities many pastors long for. Edwards had the right family name. The most famous preacher of the day hired him to be his associate, heir to a most important pulpit. After just one sermon he became famous, a published author. His preaching led to revival, a significant renewal of a long-established church. After that revival, he became a noted expert, his opinion on a host of matters sought after by those who recognized his genius. His writings influenced pastors across the English-speaking world. Change the name and the context and Jonathan Edwards’s story represents the aspirations and hopes of many pastors of our generation.

Yet Edwards’s greatest example may be what we find in his failure. He proves that pedigree guarantees nothing, neither success nor appreciation. If the greatest theologian in American history can be removed from his pulpit for standing on principle, it can happen to anyone. Edwards’s example teaches the powerful lesson that one’s legacy is not built upon popularity, or lack thereof, but on faithfulness to God and a willingness to be used as God sees fit, whether in fame and fortune or anonymity and sacrifice.

Had Edwards not been fired, some of the most important theological works in the last 250 years might not have been written. Setting his reputation aside, consider the fact that Freedom of the Will, written after his dismissal while he labored among the Indians of Stockbridge, became the theological foundation that would help launch the modern missionary movement in England forty years later. Likewise, it was not Edwards’s pastoral ministry that shaped evangelicalism in the nineteenth century but his Religious Affections and The Life of David Brainerd. Today Edwards’s legacy is not measured by his failures but by his faithfulness.

↑ Back to top

↑