Chapter 8 of 17

5. John Newton (1725–1807): Faithful amid Disappointment

5. John Newton (1725–1807): Faithful amid Disappointment

five

John Newton (1725–1807): Faithful amid Disappointment

TOM SCHWANDA

In 1763 John Newton wrote to his friend, Thomas Haweis, and declared that if he were ever ordained, the essential foundation for his ministry would be “Grace, free Grace must be the substance of my discourse––to tell the world from my own experience that there is mercy . . . for the most hardened.” Many readers will know the basic outline of Newton’s life and how deeply he needed the free grace of God. His mother died of tuberculous before he was seven. Newton joined his father at sea when he was eleven, thus suppressing the early religious training of his mother. Numerous voyages on slave-trading vessels created a hardened heart that revealed gross immorality and wickedness. Newton prided himself in leading others into similar temptations and gross blasphemy. His efforts to profit from slave trading misfired, and instead he was imprisoned and brutally treated worse than a slave.

Later while crossing the Atlantic, a violent storm threatened to destroy his vessel and brought him to his knees, crying out for God’s mercy. At this same time, Newton had casually begun reading Thomas à Kempis’s devotional classic, The Imitation of Christ, and had experienced some stirrings in his neglected conscience. Miraculously, the ship reached the safety of land. Newton dated this March 21, 1748, event as his conversion but soon realized he was not a true believer until six months later.

He continued slave trading for many years until a seizure finally ended his sailing career in 1754. This might raise questions regarding the validity of his conversion, but at this period evangelicals did not yet see slavery as a vile sin. With increasing maturity, Newton lamented his former occupation and wrote a tract condemning slavery in 1787. Through his friendship with William Wilberforce, Newton encouraged his abolitionist efforts in Parliament.

Amid his numerous voyages, in 1750 Newton married Mary Catlett, better known as Polly. He found work as a tide surveyor in Liverpool and was responsible for inspecting cargo and preventing smuggled goods. Shortly before he started his civil service he met George Whitefield. A few years later he met John Wesley. As early as 1757 Newton began wrestling with whether he was being called to an ordained ministry.

Trials in Seeking Ordination

This was the beginning of seven years of intense frustration, inner struggle, and frequent questioning as Newton sought ordination in the Church of England. Numerous hurdles confronted him along the way. Many who lacked his determination would have given up long before he reached his coveted dream. For example, he lacked the proper credentials of a university education required of Anglican clergy. Exceptions were made for those who demonstrated a strong knowledge of Scripture and theology. Newton had taught himself Greek and Hebrew and had read widely in theology. Apparently the real reason for his rejection was his association with Methodists. In the eighteenth century, the term Methodist referred to any person who was “awakened” or born again to new life in Christ. Critics often accused Methodists of “enthusiasm.” Today, ministers encourage a sincere and passionate response to the gospel. But in Newton’s day, the term enthusiasm described people who were excessive in their spiritual practices, ministered outside of the Church of England, and stressed the necessity of evangelical conversion. In the previous century, enthusiasm also described people on the fringe who sought to overthrow the government.

While Newton was stunned by his initial defeats, he persisted for seven years in his desire for ordination. When prospects within the Church of England repeatedly failed, Newton questioned whether to accept any of the numerous invitations he had received from Independent and Presbyterian churches. John Wesley also invited him to become an itinerant minister with his expanding movement. Polly and her family strongly discouraged Newton from any consideration of non-Anglican ministry. This was based primarily on financial and social reasons, not spiritual ones.

Some of his relatives were shocked that he would consider leaving his lucrative government position for the instability and meager income of ministry. We can hear the deep determination and strong desire to surrender to God in a letter written to a friend in 1762: “As to laying aside all thoughts of the Ministry, it is quite out of my power: I cannot, I will not give up the desire; though I hope I shall not run before I am sent.” Newton’s sensitivity to God’s greater wisdom and timing is quite remarkable considering all his rejections.

His persistence was finally rewarded when he was ordained an Anglican minister in 1764. By that time he had presented his request to at least two bishops, two archbishops, and even the archbishop of Canterbury. The difference this time was that Thomas Haweis introduced Newton to the powerful and evangelical Lord Dartmouth. Through his influence Newton was granted the necessary meeting to be examined for ordination.

Newton’s Pastoral Ministry

Lord Dartmouth was also instrumental in sending Newton to Olney, where he served until 1779. From there he moved to St. Mary Woolnoth in London, where he ministered until his death in 1807. Newton developed a friendship with William Cowper during his time at Olney. By 1773 Cowper fell into deepening depression and attempted suicide numerous times. Despite his frequent battles with mental health, Cowper contributed about 20 percent of the hymns to the famous Olney Hymns (1779). This contained Newton’s “Amazing Grace” as well as other hymns still popular today: “How Sweet the Name of Jesus Sounds,” “Glorious Things of Thee are Spoken,” and others.

Early in his ministry, Newton discovered the financial challenges of serving in the church. While he was appointed the minister in charge at Olney, the previous minister still occupied a nominal position and received one-third of Newton’s salary. Newton was no stranger to an assortment of trials and challenges that have plagued ministers from the earliest times.

A nearby minister gave him a hostile greeting that shocked Newton. This antagonism was due most likely to his association with Methodists. Fortunately his reception among his new congregation was more cordial. However, during the early stages of the American Revolution, Newton made comments that some critics interpreted as supporting the American colonists rather than his own homeland. Taken together, Newton experienced numerous trials during his first ministry: jealousy from other ministers, meager financial support, stress of supporting an emotionally unstable church member, and political attacks.

Newton’s move to London created increased opportunities to influence the evangelical cause. He became the most prominent evangelical Anglican in England. He either found or assisted in the formation of the Eclectic Society—a group of notable evangelical ministers and laity with an emphasis on missions that would merge into the Church Missionary Society—and the British Foreign Bible Society.

Newton’s many years of personal struggle both before and after his ordination prepared him for a significant ministry of correspondence. Through his letters, Newton provided spiritual direction to numerous clergy and laity. His moderate Calvinism shaped an irenic attitude that appropriated a wide theological spectrum, including his favorable reception of Roman Catholic authors such as Fénelon and Pascal.

Survival Skills during His Struggle for Ordination

There were four primary reasons Newton was able to withstand his unrelenting struggles over a seven-year period.

First, Newton was renewed by a constant reminder that he believed he had truly been called by God to gospel ministry. This conviction had been confirmed during an intense six-week process in which Newton carefully journaled and examined his heart to test whether he was spiritually mature and ready for ordination. He named this work Miscellaneous Thoughts and Enquiries Upon an Important Subject and engaged in Bible study, meditation, prayer, and fasting. He used Paul’s epistles to Timothy and Titus, John 14–17, and 1 John to examine his motivations for ministry. This intense period of self-examination also included wrestling with which denomination he should serve if ordained. Despite his manifest unworthiness, which he quickly confessed, Newton reached a decision in 1758 on his thirty-third birthday: God had called him to the ministry.

Second, Newton placed his total confidence in God. This was more than a cliché; it was a deep conviction that sustained him amid the varied defeats faced in coming years. One of the most critical factors for any Christian—especially ministers—is how a person perceives God. This is more than articulating a proper theological definition to defend one’s orthodoxy but the inner heart perceptions that reveal most clearly how a person actually understands God. Significantly, this inner perception exerts more influence in one’s relationship with God and others than the theologically correct confession a person might speak. Newton clearly affirmed God’s sovereignty, no doubt learned from his earlier struggles and suffering. He was amazed that God had preserved his life through myriad dangerous voyages at sea. He learned the lesson of waiting even in the uncertainty of time. Once again this response demonstrates God’s amazing grace that supported and sustained him through trials.

Third, Newton had the right perspective on affliction. It is common for contemporary Christians to see trials and challenges as a sign of God’s displeasure or even punishment. Not so for Newton. Among the most enduring legacies of Newton are his precious letters of spiritual counsel. Early in his ministry these epistles were highly acclaimed for their wisdom, depth of pastoral sensitivity, and biblical promises. Paging through the volumes of his letters one recognizes a sampling of his understanding of affliction. According to Newton, suffering helps a person better grasp the meaning of Scripture and experience the sweetness of God’s promises, strengthens a person’s fellowship with God, weakens the effect of indwelling sin, and weans a person from the deceptive enticements of the world. In other words, it prepares one for heaven.

Newton was quick to add that trials and afflictions are never random but are personalized for each individual to produce the desired results of sanctification and maturity in Christ. That is why the proper response is not resentment or flight but submission to trials, since they come from a loving God. Newton writes of this in the final verse of his hymn, “I Asked the Lord That I Might Grow”:

These inward trials I employ

From self and pride to set you free,

And break the schemes of earthly joy

That thou may’st find your all in me.

One text Newton frequently referenced when addressing affliction was 2 Corinthians 12:9–10:

But he said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” Therefore I will boast all the more gladly of my weaknesses, so that the power of Christ may rest upon me. For the sake of Christ, then, I am content with weaknesses, insults, hardships, persecutions, and calamities. For when I am weak, then I am strong.

“My grace is sufficient” in many ways represents the motto for Newton’s life and ministry. The importance of this phrase is reflected in one of his hymns, “My Grace Is Sufficient for Thee.” And further, in a variation of Romans 8:28, Newton taught, “All shall work together for good: everything is needful that he sends; nothing can be needful that he withholds.” Newton communicated the same liberating truth in his hymn “Be Gone, Unbelief, My Savior Is Near,” in which the first verse ends: “With Christ in the vessel, I smile at the storm.”

Fourth, Newton was always surrounded by a supportive community. He cultivated friendships with ease and formed a wide network across diverse boundaries. For example, members of the Eclectic Society included Independent, Methodist, and Moravian pastors and laymen. He was not afraid to bare his soul and honestly confess his doubts and fears. His vulnerability produced sensitive friendships that would give him a clear perspective.

When Newton was presented with possible opportunities, he was quick to seek the guidance of trusted friends. He understood that emotions have the potential to distort reality and radically alter a person’s judgment. But the most significant relationship in his life was with Polly. Unlike some other early evangelical leaders whose marriages were a disaster, John loved Polly, and they enjoyed each other. Polly’s health was always frail, and eventually she suffered through a long and debilitating battle with cancer that took her life in 1790. Newton spoke of his loss of Polly as “my great trial.”

Contemporary Trials

Before I became a professor, I served as a pastor for three churches over eighteen years. In one of those congregations I was an associate pastor. When the head pastor retired, the church called a new senior pastor in just two weeks. This alarmed most of the congregation, since in my tradition the church typically spends at least one year in a careful self-study to determine the needs of the church and expectations of the new leader.

No sooner did the pastor arrive when he announced his plans to terminate the entire church staff. That meant all of the pastors and other staff members lost their positions in a few months. Suddenly I lost my ministry. I struggled for months asking, Why? What is next? How do I survive the lack of income? Like Newton, I too experienced God’s faithfulness in providing—even though it wasn’t on my timetable.

Through this extremely painful valley of darkness from which it took many years to emerge, I learned three lessons that kept me sane.

First, like Newton I recognized the value of supportive friends with whom I could be honest. Unlike some Christians who seek to create a polished veneer without struggles, my wife and I were intentional to be appropriately vulnerable and reveal our pain and brokenness. I discovered that many pastors and church leaders had been dismissed from their ministries for no valid reason other than manipulation or abuse of power.

Second, like Newton I continued my previous habits of journaling and meditating on Scripture. It is common when people suffer trials or afflictions to discontinue spiritual practices, believing God doesn’t care or has forgotten them. In addition to my regular Bible reading, I began praying the Psalms daily. I read them slowly in a meditative fashion and would often return to the same passage the next day. This practice cultivated a richer language for prayer, including the frequent reminder of the psalms of lament that invite those who struggle to cry out to our Triune God for help. Laments are based on the premise that while the believer struggles, God responds to our cries of affliction with love and in power. This also taught me to see more clearly the awesome nature and character of God.

Third, like Newton I learned the value of gratitude. Whether simple or more profound, I recorded my thankfulness for people, experiences, and insights. Gratitude had the surprising benefit of expanding my myopic vision beyond my own limited pain to see more fully. I discovered many people who suffered physically, spiritually, mentally, or relationally. I could intercede for them even as others were praying for me.

Ministry Insights

Newton reminds us that pastoral struggles and doubts are not infrequent or unusual but the norm. In fact, if we are not experiencing some sort of pastoral tension or conflict, it may well mean we are not attempting anything challenging to encourage the growth of the people we serve. When—not if—problems surface, it is not uncommon to second-guess our decisions or the particular aspect of ministry that either caused or resulted from the trials. But ministers should not read these as signs of God’s absence or neglect but as potential confirmation that we are doing something right.

Newton teaches us the critical value of trust in our sovereign God, realizing his providence is just as active in this day as in Newton’s day. This confidence comes from both a commitment to cultivate a vibrant spiritual maturity and a trust in God’s steadfast love and faithfulness. If we believe our convictions are biblical, we should seek to be faithful to God, even if it results in conflict or sharp criticism from others.

Newton also instructs us in the importance of patience and careful deliberation. When feeling trapped in a difficult or painful ministry, some believe the best way out is to jump at the first opportunity that arises and flee. Too many pastors spend a few years in a ministry only to search for a larger, wealthier congregation. This can be dangerous for many reasons. It is difficult for pastors or missionaries to create a healthy ministry if they don’t spend enough time getting to know and trust the people they serve and vice versa. Newton served only two churches; both were long-term ministries. As indicated earlier, Newton sought the wisdom of trusted friends who could see a difficult situation more objectively than he could. And further, Newton was sensitive not to run ahead of God’s timing before he was actually sent.

Amazing Grace

It can be dangerous to critique a person from the distance of history because we don’t know all the details. And even for one as prolific as Newton in his diaries, his writing does not reveal everything. For example, some readers might disagree with Newton’s patience with Polly in not accepting numerous opportunities extended to him outside the Church of England. He chose to wait until she was ready and depended on her approval in his decisions. While some might question his approach, I see it more as an indication of his wisdom. He was sensitive enough to realize that in healthy marriages spouses must listen and wait and not force their partners into something before they are ready.

Newton had learned humility through his struggles in his slave-trading years, which was further refined throughout his ministry. In 1779 Newton’s most famous work was published, a hymn that has come to be one of the most famous songs in history—in and outside of the church. It well summarizes the grace every minister needs to run the race of faith with endurance: “Through many dangers, toils, and snares I have already come. . . . He will my shield and portion be as long as life endures.”

↑ Back to top

↑