8. John Chavis (1763–1838): Faithful in the Face of Racism
eight
John Chavis (1763–1838): Faithful in the Face of Racism
On a warm Sunday afternoon in August 1831, seven Negro slave men met for an afternoon barbecue in the woods on the plantation of Joseph Travis in Southampton County, Virginia. Their conversation lasted nearly eleven hours and was led by a strong and religious-minded slave named Nat Turner. Turner believed God had signaled him to lead an insurrection to overturn the evil of slavery. Later that evening, Turner and a band of sixty slaves attempted to make that vision a reality.
Over the course of forty-eight hours, this violent troop went from house to house, killing fifty-five white men, women, and children. After shootouts with groups of white men and some of their black slaves, many of the rebels were killed, and Turner himself was captured and subsequently hanged on November 11. He was then beheaded and publicly mutilated as a warning to other would-be rebels.
Nat Turner’s rebellion produced fear in white Americans all over the South, causing many to see every black person, slave or free, as a violent threat. Both Virginia and North Carolina passed laws making it a crime to teach blacks—literacy was thought to be a significant factor in rebellious thinking. North Carolina went further, preventing all blacks, whether slave or free, from preaching, teaching, or leading any gathering.
These new laws institutionalized white fear. Legal freedom did not protect black citizens from being lumped in with slaves, since they all shared the one thing that mattered most in the minds of white Southerners—they were Negro. Free blacks who lived productive and noble lives alongside their white neighbors were vulnerable in the face of the fearful impulses of racism. Even a black man of well-known spiritual character and who counted among his closest friends and acquaintances leading white citizens could find himself defenseless to racialized fears and irrational overreaction.
That was the experience of early nineteenth-century African American Presbyterian preacher and well-respected educator John Chavis.
Breaking Stereotypes
John Chavis does not fit the modern-day stereotype of a black man in eighteenth-century North Carolina. Though the precise details of his birth and early life are often debated, Chavis was born in either 1762 or 1763 and descended from free black settlers of Granville County, Virginia. His ancestors were property owners and were educated and respected in their communities, volunteering to serve in defense of American freedom as militiamen throughout the colonial period. Chavis himself would later serve three years in the American Revolutionary War.
Chavis likely was reared near the Presbyterian settlement of free blacks in North Carolina known as White Hall. Tom Blackwell, the principal landowner in the settlement, advocated for education, so there were cultural influences that would have helped Chavis value education. Additionally, Chavis’s ancestors were literate, so education was evidently a valued part of his family’s legacy.
There is some indication that John Chavis may have spent a fair part of his childhood as an indentured servant in the home of the Rev. William Willie, apparently a renaissance man with an abundant supply of books covering a wide array of topics. If Chavis spent several childhood years in Willie’s home, he would have had ample opportunity to stimulate his intellectual curiosity from that vast library and to interact with Willie himself. That a young black boy would have been raised in the North Carolina home of an esteemed white family in the 1770s says much about the respect Chavis’s family had in the community. And like for many white immigrants, indentured servitude would be a path Chavis would take to ensure himself a solid footing in his pursuit of all that American liberty had to offer.
There is great reason to believe that Chavis spent his later childhood and early teen years under the tutelage of the esteemed Presbyterian minister Henry Patillo as a student in the Latin grammar school he ran called Granville Hall. Patillo was a patriot and an influential pastor. Many of his students were moved by his enthusiasm for the American Republic and enlisted in the Revolutionary War cause.
In a spirit of patriotism, Chavis enlisted in the Continental Army in 1780 at the age of seventeen, which was unusual for a young black man as they were not typically seen as friendly toward the patriot cause in colonial times. No doubt, Chavis’s family legacy as property owners factored into his enlistment success. Chavis thus served faithfully in the revolutionary cause for three years.
His identity and credentials as an American patriot and valuable citizen can hardly be denied. This is seen not only by his service to the new nation but also by his membership in the elite quarters of colonial and early American society. He was clearly seen, treated, and respected by whites as a social and cultural equal.
Keen Mind, Gifted Preacher
After the war, Chavis went on to serve as a Latin and Greek tutor and continually impressed everyone he encountered with his academic promise and potential. He was eventually sent to study at Princeton as the private student of its president, John Witherspoon. Witherspoon had signed the Declaration of Independence and greatly valued open and free inquiry. Chavis was nurtured in a Presbyterian faith anchored in intellectual rigor and a robust commitment to the American republic. And though he did not graduate from Princeton—completing his academic studies at Washington College in Virginia—he benefited from the young nation’s best ministerial minds, and he won their confidence in his ability and character.
As hard as it is to believe from our twenty-first-century vantage point, the overwhelming majority of blacks in postcolonial America were unconverted and superstitious. This was especially true on large Southern plantations at which the slave populations dwarfed the numbers of whites. Though for many years there had been resistance to evangelizing African slaves, by the end of the eighteenth century many Presbyterian ministers were under conviction to proclaim the gospel to them, and Chavis’s mentor, Patillo, was of that mind.
Patillo advocated for Chavis. He recognized in Chavis the graces of gospel ministry and occasionally opened his pulpit to Chavis to preach. In 1799, with Patillo’s support as well as the support of others, Chavis applied for ministerial appointment to the Lexington presbytery and was examined. In October 1800 Chavis became the first black man in America licensed to preach by the Presbyterian Church.
Understandably, Chavis was charged with preaching to the black masses in the South to remedy the spiritual darkness among them, believing he could do a better job in reaching them than white ministers could. However, Chavis’s labors were more often expended with white audiences as he traveled back and forth on horseback to various congregations. It has been said that Chavis’s speech was free of Negroisms. The enthusiastic reception he received from white congregations suggests his voice was heard with spiritual authority and that the faith of many was encouraged by his preaching and teaching.
Not long after Chavis’s commissioning as an itinerant preacher in the Presbyterian Church he completed his formal studies. Leveraging his success as an effective Latin and Greek tutor and his sterling reputation as a minister, Chavis opened a classical school in 1805 in Raleigh, North Carolina.
Continuing to challenge our modern-day assumptions, he taught white and black children together in an integrated setting. By 1808, like the gathering of cultural storm clouds, the parents of Chavis’s white students began to complain and insist that their children not be taught with black children. Chavis accommodated this demand by creating a day school for white children and an evening school for black children, with the latter having slightly lower tuition.
Still, Chavis enjoyed a buoyant reputation. His white students were among North Carolina’s aristocracy, and many of those who came up under his instruction became statesmen, influential businessmen, and scholars in their own rights. Most of Chavis’s students retained the highest admiration for him. Willie P. Mangum would become a US senator and eventually its legislative leader. He was a close friend of Chavis until his death. Charles Manley would later be governor of North Carolina. Abraham Mencher went on to serve as minister (ambassador) to Portugal and eventually territorial governor of New Mexico.
Man of Society
It would be a mistake to see the career attainments of his former students as signs merely of Chavis’s teaching prowess, which he undeniably possessed. Instead, these luminaries also indicate the heights Chavis had personally attained as a black man in North Carolina society. Between 1805 and 1830, the state’s wealthiest and most influential white families entrusted the education and character formation of their children to this black man. They knew him well and revered him.
There is good reason today to believe that Chavis is buried on the family property of Senator Mangum’s parents. Correspondence between Chavis and men such as Mangum reflects familiar cordiality and intellectual equality, with Chavis’s tone still reflecting the posture of tutor.
Controversial Legacy
It is easy to understand why the legacy of Chavis was a controversial topic at the end of the nineteenth century after the Civil War and following Reconstruction as black codes and Jim Crow laws were established against the new freedmen. These discriminations were defended among gentlemen because of the assumed inferiority of the Negro. However, if black people possessed the same capabilities and virtues as white men and women, denying them basic freedoms would be patently indefensible.
Providence soon acquainted Chavis with the reality that in America’s racialized society, even close friends of different racial backgrounds saw the world through different emotional lenses. What prompted fear in white Americans often produced anger among blacks. Fears and concerns that leapt in the hearts of American Negroes were often the flipside to the same circumstances that brought relief and celebration to white hearts. This was the emotional landscape in the South before and after the Nat Turner rebellion.
In 1800, Gabriel Prosser had planned a slave rebellion in Richmond, Virginia, which was foiled when a slave told his master of the plans, leading to Prosser’s eventual capture and hanging. The year 1822 saw the arrest and execution of Denmark Vessey in Charleston, South Carolina, as his plot to lead a slave insurrection was also uncovered and thwarted. In 1829, an out-of-state white minister circulated a letter in North Carolina that many took to be a call for slave rebellion. The letter was David Walker’s famous “Appeal to the Colored Citizens of the World,” which underscored the inhumanity of slavery and called black people to claim their rightful place in the world of civilized men by decisive action, moral improvement, and hard work.
White people feared that Walker’s letter would lead to violence. When Chavis, who had become a spokesman for black people, was asked by several slaveholders of Orange County about the letter and its preaching of open rebellion, Chavis boldly replies, “I am not surprised. It is very possible that violence could erupt under the present dangerous circumstances.”
Following Nat Turner’s rebellion, Chavis wrote to his former student Willie Mangum, who was serving at the time as a congressman, saying he didn’t believe Turner guilty of the charges against him and that his hanging was a travesty of justice. Chavis’s position was anchored in his belief that the criminal justice system was inherently unfair to black people. And his letter was no doubt intended to use the social and relationship capital he believed he had with Congressman Mangum to pursue the just cause of defending American blacks from unfair treatment.
Perhaps a more strategically thoughtful response to the slaveholders regarding Walker’s letter would have included assurances that slave insurrection was unlikely, at least in North Carolina. Maybe if Chavis had exhorted those men to meet their concerns, not with threats and restrictions but with kind considerations and cordiality toward their slaves, a less hostile mindset might have ruled the day. Whatever might have been, Turner’s swift and violent revolt provided all the clarity these men needed.
In 1832 the North Carolina legislature enacted a law for the “better regulation of the conduct of Negroes, slaves and free persons of color.” A 1930 scholarly journal noted that
the statute made it unlawful for any free Negro, slave or free person of color to preach or exhort in public or in any matter to officiate as preacher or teacher . . . where slaves of different families were collected together. Any free Negro or free person of color who was duly convicted or indicted . . . [is] for each offence to receive not exceeding thirty-nine lashes on his bare back.
In a stroke of administrative muscle, the legal ground on which Chavis operated and provided for his family had quaked beneath him. All the securities that education, character, hard work, and reputation promised were erased in a flash by a law that seemed written with him in mind. No one had called John Chavis a derogatory name. He had not been threatened with violence. None of the actions commonly designated as racist were directly employed against him. Yet if God endowed all men with the unalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, Chavis was exempted even in the face of his literal defense of that principle. Because he was forbidden from teaching black students and from preaching to black congregants, Chavis’s white-student families quickly removed their children from his tutelage, and his employments were a memory.
Given the seriousness of his new situation—unable to preach or teach—Chavis appealed to the Orange County presbytery for their intervention. But they were in full submission to and no doubt in agreement with the new law. The official response from the presbytery to Chavis in his predicament reads as follows: “Resolved, that the Presbytery in view of all the circumstances of the case recommend to [John Chavis] to acquiesce in the decision of the Legislature referred until God in his providence shall open to him the path of duty, in regard to exercise of his ministry.”
There are many ironies in this response, chief among them that many of the leaders in the presbytery would have no doubt either fought in the Revolutionary War or at least revered those who did. As such they were quick to act in the interest of their freedom. Another irony is the similar lack of patience in the wise providence of God they would all soon display in the decisions leading to secession and the Civil War. It is hard to deny their counsel was less grounded in theology and more rooted in a lack of empathy for Chavis’s situation. And rooted in the belief that the appropriate response to one black man’s malevolent act is to limit the actions of all black men.
When he was unable to teach or preach and therefore unable to sustain a livelihood for his family, he appealed to the Orange County presbytery for help. That request was met with a collection providing him $52.42, while also unspeakably suspending his license to preach. For a man of Chavis’s stature and achievement, becoming a ward of the presbytery would be a great blow to his dignity, when his only infirmity was his skin color.
Chavis’s response to his situation was to confront it with grit and determination. He first tried to resume teaching by offering to tutor the children of his former student Willie Mangum, then serving in Congress and later the Senate. Chavis sent many letters over a few years to Mangum, most of which were unanswered. Though Chavis tried to maintain a gentlemanly tone, his frustration seeps through: “Is it my color, or my insignificance or the gross ignorance, which my many letters contain, the reason you have not condescended to answer one of them? Or is it your distrust of my professed, firm, unshaken, unabating friendship for you and your family? Or do you consider my friendship to be not worthy your notice?”
What is most striking in this September 1831 letter from Chavis to Mangum was Chavis’s segue from personal offense to political commentary. He exhorts Mangum to resist political friendship with “[Andrew] Jackson” and to “put on again your full coat of Federalism” and “support the renewal of the United States bank.” As a modern reader, it is difficult to discern whether this is general concern in the political fortunes of a former charge or a form of self-denial of his lower and dependent status. Perhaps it is simply Chavis’s desperate attempt to remind Mangum and himself that he is still a distinguished American.
In March 1832, still having not heard back from Senator Mangum, Chavis wrote again. In closing the letter, he mentions other former students: “Please give my respects to my son Abraham Rencher and to General Barringer, and tell them I would be glad to receive a letter from them. Tell them if I am Black I am free born American and a revolutionary soldier and therefore ought not to be thrown entirely out of the scale of notice.” These sentiments would, of course, be echoed throughout American history as black soldiers served valiantly in World Wars I and II and yet returned home to disrespect and racial violence.
Failure of Brotherly Love
Was Chavis a victim of racism? No doubt. Lumping free and slave blacks into a single class regardless of their education, actions, or Christian pedigree made blackness itself a moral category, justifying corrective action targeting blackness. This brings to mind the observations of esteemed historian Mark Noll that the slavery question for Christians in the United States was never about the right interpretation of Scripture but always a question of the full deposit of humanity in black men and women.
The racism Chavis experienced was ultimately a breakdown in brotherly love. That’s what makes racism and betrayal both sinful and discouraging—it violates the biblical admonition of love to neighbor, which in turn violates the biblical admonition of love to God. Those closest to Chavis betrayed him, and it was hurtful and perplexing. It’s always difficult to comprehend permanent fractures between brothers when Scripture brims with admonitions to forgive one another and warnings as to what will happen if these relationships remain unreconciled (Eph. 4:32; Matt. 18:15–35). Still, Chavis soldiered on in ministry in spite of relational dynamics and injustices that were difficult to swallow.
Chavis died in 1838, and the circumstances of his death are clouded in speculation. There is no triumphant moment in his story, no sense that he or his friends overcame the racism of his times. Racism, it seems, won the day. One thinks of the apostle Paul spending his remaining days in the Mamertine Prison in Rome, cold and alone, reflecting on his being abandoned, not by his enemies, but by his friends.
Shouting out to us from the early nineteenth century, John Chavis’s story summons us as Christians to examine our actions in the face of injustice, especially its systemic manifestations. When we consider Christian biography, we are often caught up in the heroism of individuals and often neglect the spiritual cowardice of the church and culture. Chavis’s account prompts us to cast our gaze more broadly so that we might see in our time not only the exceptionalism of an individual but also the character and weaknesses of the church.
