Brian Cosby’s Response
Responses to the Reformed View
I really appreciate Brian Cosby’s back-to-the–New Testament approach to building a biblical youth ministry model. I share his supposition that the widely accepted entertainment-focused youth ministry model is watering down our efforts to keep teenagers integrated into the church post–high school graduation. If youth group is just a fun time to keep teenagers off the streets while sprinkling a little “Jesus dust” on them in the process, then, of course, why wouldn’t they evacuate the church after (or even before) they graduate?
And I fully agree with his focus on Acts 2:42–47, which makes it clear that “God’s Word, prayer, the administration of the sacraments, service, and gospel community all provide a God-glorifying and biblical method of making young disciples of Jesus Christ.”
This “go deep” approach is necessary for teenagers to understand, embrace, and own their faith for the long haul. Teens need to learn biblical theology, embrace the sacraments, engage in service, and immerse themselves in community. These are all part of the foundation youth leaders must build for them in the youth ministry context. But if not combined with a “go wide,” Gospel Advancing drive, it can quickly turn a youth group into a small group.
Brian correctly notes the importance of engaging teenagers in evangelism and mission. But Jesus’s commissioning of his young disciples to “go and make disciples” in Matthew 28:19 was not merely part of a process. It was the purpose!
Making disciples who make disciples was the driver of the early church’s efforts throughout the book of Acts. Evangelism is not a mere spoke on a wheel to building a biblical model of youth ministry. It is the engine itself. Jesus himself said, “For the Son of Man came to seek and to save the lost” (Luke 19:10). When we follow him, his primary mission becomes our primary mission.
While far too many youth groups have veered away from these basics and become entertainment driven, it doesn’t mean that we should jerk the steering wheel and do a 180-degree turnaround. We don’t want youth group meetings to look like a liturgical service held in a medieval castle. Does an emphasis on taking teens both deeper into their relationship with God and wider into the world with the good news of Jesus mean we can never play games or have fun? I say no!
If anyone has a reason to laugh and have fun, it should be Christians. Joy was one of the distinguishing marks of the early believers: “They worshiped together at the Temple each day, met in homes for the Lord’s Supper, and shared their meals with great joy and generosity all the while praising God and enjoying the goodwill of all the people. And each day the Lord added to their fellowship those who were being saved” (Acts 2:42–47 NLT).
As long as fun and games don’t distract youth leaders from truly engaging their teens in growing deeper and going wider, then why not? After all, they are teenagers, and a dodgeball game or pizza party won’t derail a kingdom-advancing ministry.
Jesus’s missional call to go make disciples who make disciples is radical, revolutionary, dynamic, life-changing, scary, stretching, countercultural, energizing, and Gospel Advancing. Let’s take them deep and wide, and let’s have a ton of fun in the process!
Thank you, Brian, for this thorough and thoughtful article. Your commitment to the care and nurture of the young is evident, and your desire for them to come to know and follow the Savior is clear. Even in your most stinging critiques of strategies and methods of reaching out, there is no doubt that your motive is for Jesus Christ and his kingdom. Your article is “thick” (a favorite word for practical theologians) and loaded with Scripture references. Your plea for faithfulness over against success is a helpful reminder of what so easily ensnares, and your critique of the guise of “professionalism” as opposed to faithful preparation is an important reminder for those who sense a call into vocational youth ministry.
I also want to affirm, without qualification, that I fully agree that our theological convictions must be the driving mechanism for our approach to passing on faith from one generation to the next. At Fuller Theological Seminary, where I am on the faculty, we have noticed a trend that has now taken over—there are now more “nondenominational” students who attend the largest fully accredited seminary than any other denomination. Even three years ago, this was not the case. But over the past few years it’s become evident that, as so many have reported, denominations that have defined American Protestantism for centuries are on the ropes.[1] And with this decline of historically oriented, steeped-in-tradition denominations is a similar decline in loyalty to a particular theological tradition. Thus today we see churches springing up across the country that are functionally theological hybrids. This has not only also been the trend in youth ministry as well, but especially over the last few decades this has been a consistent rally cry for many in youth ministry leadership (e.g., speakers and writers) who decry the “rigidity” of denominational—and by default theological—boundaries. Given this climate, then, there is much to commend in your article, which makes the case for a return to a well-formulated and highly codified theological tradition. Not only do you plead for theological grounding, your single-focused apologetic is to your version of “orthodox Reformed” Christianity. To those who share this perspective, this article will sing like a Glasgow boys’ choir. To those who do not, or, as in the case with many of the “nondenominationals” who read this, there may be some serious dissonance.
That said, and especially for those who do not find themselves readily drawn to Cosby’s interpretation of youth ministry (I’m not sure how many Young Life staff or Purpose Driven folks are still reading, but hang in there!), it is worth repeating: there is much here that the entire youth ministry community needs to consider. Language and rhetoric aside, in this article Brian Cosby makes a strong case for deepening especially the core content of the gospel message. So as I begin this response, I will first examine the boundaries of the Reformed model, followed by a few thoughts that caused me to question how to pull off this model.
The Language and Boundaries of the Reformed Model
You have so loaded up this article, Brian, that to give a two-thousand-word response is difficult indeed! On every page there was something I underlined either because I felt like it was a needed point to be heard or something I wanted to explore further, and usually both. In sum, then, my overall concern, likely shared by many readers, is with the overt boundaries offered by the single theological framework you use. Frankly, I’m not sure that you need to limit this to the Reformed tradition; you have a great amount to say to all of us.
Specifically, I wonder if you might reconsider your proposed methodology of youth ministry residing synonymously with the notion of the “means of grace.” As you point out, the “means of grace” (even in the title of the article) is a core concept in Reformed theology. One definition you give is the means “by which he [God] does that work of saving and sanctifying,” specifically through the “ministry of the Bible, prayer, the administration of the sacraments in worship, service, and gospel community.” Interestingly, the two basic texts you use to support the distinction between “methods” that are unbiblical and the historic Reformed “means of grace” as a model for youth ministry do not say everything that you seem to be taking from them. For example, 1 Corinthians 3:7, your grounding text, does say that we plant and water but God does the growing, but in the context, planting and watering are clearly metaphors for the doing of ministry as opposed to the specificity of the method for doing ministry. Then, in Acts 2:42–47, what one could argue is hermeneutically a description of what took place, you lock into a code and create a fixed “method”/model for the church for all situations and for all of time, when we really have no idea how they went about their way (method) of doing the work of ministry (e.g., was communion delivered as a normal part of the dinnertime meal? Clearly, in Scripture, we simply do not know). Yet it is at this point that you venture into a theological rationale from Reformed documents to affirm that “means” of grace and “methods” of ministry are essentially synonymous. This gets you into what I see as unnecessarily divisive hot water. Your basic affirmations are so good, but the implicit defensiveness in your argument may overshadow them.
My concern here is that someone from a Wesleyan, Orthodox, Roman Catholic, or “nondenominational” background could do precisely what you do—grab a few verses, cite their own historical documents and a handful of their theological thinkers, and make their case—and would end up with a somewhat different “method” for ministry. To equate the “means” of how God grows individuals and his people with the methods we use to plant and water is, I believe, untenable. I don’t disagree, per se, as I believe that these things are all valuable and important aspects to our role in growth. Yet I do not see the connection between how one goes about planting and watering and how God uses what Reformed theology refers to as the “means of grace.” Consider a volunteer Young Life leader, for instance, who happens to be Presbyterian, building a friendship with a disinterested teenager or a disabled child without a closed-set agenda in the name of Christ. As the friendship grows and God moves that adolescent toward trust in Christ, the method and outcome are no different than when Paul and Barnabas were in Antioch (Acts 13:44–48). The method of what you call parachurch, after all, has a rich ecclesial history and is modeled after Paul’s planting and watering (method) and God’s grace (means).
What the Reformed Model Doesn’t Discuss
In many ways, for any person who seeks to faithfully lead young people into a vibrant, lifelong, and communally experienced faith, this article is hard to argue with. The basic theological framework of the historic “means of grace” has several different labels, depending on theological tradition (whether one is aware of the historic tradition driving their own perspective of such “means” as the Bible, Lord’s table, etc., is beside the point). This article, then, with some flexibility in the language, offers a broad and rich perspective on any youth ministry strategy.
In addition to wondering about translating the basic concepts of your argument, Brian, there are three foundational issues that I felt are either inadequately addressed or ignored altogether. First, while there is a very brief mention of developmental differences in the last section of the article, there is little recognition that developmentally, adolescents are in so many ways unique from adults, even young adults. Second, and related, there is no acknowledgment of the fairly robust research that suggests that adolescents do not by default trust adults. And third, there is an assumption that “if we build orthodox Reformed youth ministry, they will come,” yet without any substantive appreciation for how difficult it is for a church or individual to actually pull off what you recommend as the “method” of offering the “means.”
DEVELOPMENTAL REALITIES OF EARLY AND MID-ADOLESCENTS
My initial concern is how developmental differences between the early, middle, and late adolescent (or emerging adult) affect how messages and data are received, stored, and employed, especially in terms of the brain and the social environment. It seems to me that to disparage those people and programs who spend a great amount of time on affect, the relational and social environment, and other noncognitive methods to reach young people denies the generational and developmental gulf between adults and today’s young, even young adults. For early adolescents, for example, who have the basic brain capacity of children and are in the process of “pruning” what they have stored as they are seeking to prepare for adult abstract brain function,[2] being able to take in the highly abstract concepts of the Reformed model is difficult at best. I do not believe that you, Brian, would be opposed to translating, or even contextualizing, to a specific age or population, but the way you state that the method is embedded within the “means of grace” makes me wonder how one would actually go about this.
THE NEED TO BUILD TRUST WITH KIDS
Second, and related to this, my concern is how growing up in today’s performance- and individualistically oriented society has caused mid-adolescents to lack trust in adults and adult-controlled settings, and how this fact therefore makes this article, from what I have studied and witnessed, nearly impossible to pull off without some amount of “bells and whistles.” It is one thing to simply dismiss “Ignite” or Young Life for being “entertainment driven”; it is quite another to assume that young people are, in essence, clamoring for adults in a church to “teach the historic truths of the Christian faith.” It makes me wonder how you have personally handled those who feign disinterest (or actually are bored)? Do you propose simply teaching those who want to be taught and move on from those who seem to not care? Is it important to first build a bridge of trust?
With due respect to Ravi Zacharias, I’m not sure where the idea came from that the reason why the “number one fear of American teenagers is ‘to be alone’” is that “they’ve been let down over and over by the entertainment-driven culture that promises continual happiness and fulfillment.” I don’t know of any research, data, or even anecdotal support for this reasoning. There is, on the other hand, a great deal of research pointing to the reality that the reason young people feel “let down” is due to the collision of two powerful forces that all American young people face: a highly complex series of performance expectations calling for their full attention and loyalty, and a measurably exponential decrease in the necessary social capital to live up to the demands. I refer to this as “systemic abandonment.”[3] Kids are lonely because there are so few who are present for and with them without an agenda. So overcoming the lack of trust in a culture that has failed to provide them with what every generation before them has received—an adult community who walks alongside of them[4]—is a necessary prerequisite for any young person to allow him- or herself to be subject to the level of catechetical instruction you propose.
WHAT MODES OF DELIVERING THE “METHOD” SHOULD ONE USE?
Lastly, while you equate “means” with “method,” you did little with making the method something one could actually do apart from a few suggestions like “encouraging youth to memorize Scripture.” If one were to attempt to implement this “method” on the ground, hoping for “here’s how you do this” types of delivery examples, they would be in trouble. I could conceptually see in your article that the method is tied in with the “means,” but your use of the term “method” does not seem to easily answer those sticky pragmatic questions like “When?” “Who?” and “How?” I do understand that in seven thousand words there is only so much you could say, but, while you did touch on this, I found it to be lacking in the connection to the actual day-to-day delivery.
In sum, I agree that the basic elements that you refer to as “Reformed” are important and even vital ingredients to teaching the truths of the faith to anyone, including the young. I am also moved by your convictions, especially theological. I personally am not quite satisfied that the delivery methods, or the developmental and sociologically contextual questions, are addressed in the article. It seems to me that a youth ministry could be greatly strengthened by employing the essence of your argument for their content—but that the content could be implemented and delivered by a choir of relationally committed adults who are willing to receive and adopt young people into the local body of the church while throwing cream pies and singing worship songs before they teach. Ah, describe that combination, and then you’ve really got something!
There is little more important for adolescents (and for all of us) than to be assured of God’s grace. Teens are swimming in a life of ever-evolving technology, thought, and insecurities. And they are bombarded with messages at a rate that was unheard of even ten years ago. Therefore, I welcome Brian’s emphasis on the great traditions of the church, the sacraments, the ministry of the Word, prayer, service, and community. These are pillars that have stood the test of time and continue to uphold the church in its various forms.
Brian argues that entertainment-driven youth ministry hasn’t worked. I agree. For those who come from an “altar call” tradition, they may disagree, as success is often related to external matters such as attendance, responses, and excitement. I think what Brian is emphasizing is internal matters such as reflection, depth, and inner passion.
He also underscores a very challenging dilemma. On the one hand, the ultimate purpose of the Christian faith is what he identifies as a “sustainable, Christ-treasuring faith.” However, I believe we not only want individual “sustainable” faith, but we also want teens connected with the institutional church, the local congregation. There lies the rub. His use of the Sticky Faith research underscores teens’ desire to go deeper in the faith through conversations, service, and relationships with leaders. These help to nurture adolescents’ spirituality.
Brian is also on point when he emphasizes that the use of entertainment as an evangelistic hook will ultimately become a functional method. But let us not become too quick to judge. This functional approach may be no different than a church using a large professional choir singing traditional hymns. The musical genres may be different, but is not the approach the same? What is important is honest faithfulness. And Brian holds all our feet to the fire when he argues that while the theological “content-talk” may sound different from how most people in youth ministry teach, the ministerial “functional-walk” seems to be the same. If it walks like a duck, and talks like a duck . . .
I appreciate Brian’s development of the “means of grace.” In my years of youth ministry experience, when I heard the term “grace” being used, it generally referred to God’s free and unmerited favor; rarely was it used in reference to its means—the Word, fellowship, the Lord’s Supper, prayer, and service. These are tangible ways of experiencing God’s grace, which help to strengthen and build up the church. This challenges youth ministry leaders to ask, “What methods do I/we use to help our teens experience the means of God’s grace?”
In the second part of the chapter, Brian provides both theological and practical insights. The insistence of focusing on the ministry of the Word over and against testimonials is valid. While there is a place to hear the stories of how people’s lives have been transformed, when this replaces biblical preaching, we lose out on being transformed ourselves. It’s easier to hear about the work of others than to do the inner work ourselves.
Prayer does seem to have fallen by the wayside for teens. The notion of spending time with God is essential, and one we take for granted; however, like all spiritual disciplines, it does require discipline. But the stillness of prayer seems to be a challenge for adolescents (and for all of us). We are all so distracted from the things of this world that it is difficult to be connected to the Spirit. Henri Nouwen poignantly yearns,
Why, O Lord, is it so hard for me to keep my heart directed toward you? Why do the many little things I want to do, and the many people I know, keep crowding my mind, even during the hours that I am totally free to be with you and you alone? Why does my mind wander off in so many directions, and why does my heart desire the things that lead me astray? Are you not enough for me? Do I keep doubting your love and care, your mercy and grace? Do I keep wondering, in the center of my being, whether you will give me all I need if I just keep my eyes on you?
Please accept my distractions, my fatigue, my irritations, and my faithless wanderings. You know me more deeply and fully than I know myself. You love me with a greater love than I can love myself. You even offer me more than I can desire. Look at me, see me in all my misery and inner confusion, and let me sense your presence in the midst of my turmoil. All I can do is show myself to you. Yet, I am afraid to do so. I am afraid that you will reject me. But I know—with the knowledge of faith—that you desire to give me your love. The only thing you ask of me is not to hide from you, not to run away in despair, not to act as if you were a relentless despot.
Take my tired body, my confused mind, and my restless soul into your arms and give me rest, simple quiet rest. Do I ask too much too soon? I should not worry about that. You will let me know. Come, Lord Jesus, come. Amen.[5]
Some youth ministries tend to be disconnected from the congregation, particularly on Sundays. Perhaps the thinking is that the “adult service” is not relevant to teens. Whatever the case may be, one of the greatest losses of the means of grace is when teens do not participate in the celebration of the sacraments or ordinances. The Lord’s Supper in particular is a means of grace that not only strengthens the individual believer but brings together the beloved community. The mystery of God is incomprehensible, and the celebration of the Lord’s Supper makes this mystery more incarnational, tangible, and immanent among us. By receiving the bread and cup, it embodies in us our union with Christ.
Thomas Oden argues in Life in the Spirit, “Because intentionally instituted by the Lord, there can be no church without a fitting sacramental life. . . . Where there is no one baptized, there is no church. Where the farewell meal is uncelebrated, one has no right to expect the true church.”[6]
The Last Supper, particularly as expressed in the Gospel of John, leads us to the model for servant leadership; as Christ washed the feet of the disciples, we are called to wash the feet of others. Yet I’m not sure what Brian means by “gospel-motivated” service. How is this different from “service”?
He then uses the term “gospel community” to emphasize its church/congregational context, which is different from parachurch ministries. I have mixed feelings here. I do agree that the church is the “God-ordained institution here on earth called to equip the saints for the work of ministry.” However, do not parachurch ministries do this as well? And often do they not do a better job? How many of our youth and church leaders come from or were trained by parachurch ministries? While I appreciate his critique, I do believe that most people in ministry seek to also “equip the saints for ministry.”
One area I would critique is that Brian, I believe, is too quick to dismiss the insights that the label Moralistic Therapeutic Deism can give. That is, its popularity seems to reflect a real yearning from adolescents who have perhaps been pushed away or confused by the competing theologies that have been marketed by the church—and frequently by contemporary American youth ministry. And while respected leaders may sometimes struggle with this perspective, I think it provides us real and deep insights into the hearts of adolescents.
Finally, his desire and passion to present a “consistently Reformed youth ministry” is admirable. However, Reformed denominations are diminishing as quickly as many others, so there must be something amiss. As I read Brian’s well-written chapter, I kept thinking that while I may debate the pros and cons of a “Reformed” youth ministry perspective, I do agree with Brian 100 percent on emphasizing God’s grace. This, I believe, is what needs to be emphasized by more and more youth ministries across the denominational spectrum.
How refreshing to read how Brian emphasizes matters of substance. This chapter covers many excellent points and correctly separates general methods from methods rooted in theology. The past couple of decades of analysis show that more churches relied less on substantive methodology and more on a pragmatic approach to evangelism and discipleship. Brian calls for a “consistently Reformed” methodology, which he describes as ministry with the Word, service, ordinances, and gospel ministry through grace. I am thankful for the attention given to realigning youth ministry purpose with a profundity of teaching. Brian, I admire the thoroughness of your section.
I read many notable and well-articulated statements in this chapter, such as how culture has created bored, purposeless teenagers “living from one pleasure high to the next, hoping to find that which will satisfy their wandering souls.” In a media-driven age, the difficultly is seen when youth pastors are constantly vying for focused attention. Some churches with larger budgets create a fairly high standard for smaller ones. More so than ever, children’s pastors feel they must offer a Disney-like experience, and youth pastors need a full-on, multisensory approach in this screen-driven culture. I will definitely differ here with Brian because I think these methods of engaging teens should be used, but with the type of depth Brian writes about and Christ expects. Brian offers the maxim, “You keep them by how you attract them.” This expression implies the “only” attraction is lights, bands, and games when it could be the combination of such along with serious Bible study and presentation of the gospel of Christ.
An old saying reflects the sentiment of this chapter: methods are many, principles are few; methods often change, but principles never do. Brian’s premise calls youth leaders to use a principled approach, and he highly criticizes methods, especially the “fluffy” or “entertaining” methods. But the methods used and the content taught sit on two distinct planes and in two different categories. Methods can transmit depth or fluff. It can be dangerous when entertaining methods are not accompanied by deeper teachings within the faith, but if the entertainment is accompanied by a depth of teaching, one can be less critical. Brian helpfully clarified that methods should not be confused with objectives, but I think he goes too far in moving all nonsubstantive methods to the unscrupulous category.
Brian discusses burnout, fatigue, and pressure felt by youth pastors under the high pastoral and parental expectations. What he does not say is the philosophy he promotes reinforces the “hired-gun” or “superhero” approach to youth ministry, where the entire weight rests on the youth pastor. While staff members and parents should feel equal responsibility for all goals set for the youth pastor, sadly, in these situations, they don’t. Never confuse blame with accountability. In contrast, the team approach tackles the problem together and holds each party accountable to help correct the small problems before they become big problems. The pressure cooker of high business-like expectations has claimed many youth pastors who no longer serve the church or Christ.
Brian is to be commended for how he elevates the sufficiency of God’s Word. Youth pastors should teach the sufficiency of Scripture so teens learn to examine life’s decisions by the matrix of God’s principles rather than career economics, zip codes, or type of handbag. Parents need to help their teen do the same. Breakthroughs emerge when the parents’ goals for their teens cease to be financial success or the appearance of success in life but rather to learn and follow God’s will God’s way.
Brian, like Greg, calls for teenagers to focus outward beyond themselves in service and ministry to others. He describes servant leadership in solid terms of leaders modeling service to the point that the teens, as followers, begin serving. Brian calls Christ the “Great Servant” and indicates that the gospel functions as the motivation. Teens who focus more on helping others will find a natural growth in their own lives simply in the preparation to serve.
A cautionary point I would emphasize is that youth ministers should not create a world that makes teens feel the youth group is the only place where they can be discipled. You should teach the teens how to dig out the truths of Scripture on their own away from the lights, drums, and even the youth pastor. You do not want parents feeling like they cannot compete with how their kids view the youth pastor or youth worship center. Teen worship should enable the teen and the parents to live out their faith and walk just as strongly when not at church.
I think there is misplaced blame regarding why substantive issues have taken a back seat to what you describe as a merely entertainment methodology. Around the mid-1970s and early ’80s, parachurch organizations began to present curriculum alternatives in place of the traditional, stale, and outdated resources of denominational publishers who had grown complacent relying on denominational loyalty to sustain their business. I know this because I was a part of a team that did this until we recognized our responsibility to meet needs with depth and excellence. The new parachurch publishers earned customers with customer service, stronger applications within lessons, and excellence in design. The problem with parachurch publishers stemmed from their desire to appeal to all denominations, therefore representing none of their distinctives. Often such an approach can lack depth and certainly does not help reinforce the core theology of one’s ecclesial identity. The quality of the design and entertainment value drew many users. In contrast, some denominational publishers’ depth of content lacked this excellence, resulting in the loss of many of their customers. Excellence without depth or depth without excellence ultimately cheats the end user.
Another point of Brian’s that I think needs clarification is his discussion of success versus faithfulness. One can have success while pursuing faithfulness, but one must desire faithfulness over success. To state it a bit more clearly, success is not the antithesis of faithfulness. Some confuse success with excellence. The suggestion of excellence as only a pragmatic philosophy fails to recognize that everything Christ did on earth contained both excellence and substance. Even before Christ performed miracles, he knew people were going to follow him for the “signs and wonders.” Christ cared about people’s physical condition and performed miraculous acts, which engaged the crowds at a seemingly more shallow level before going deeper. Christ was the master at deploying both method and content.
Brian’s subsection titled “Faithfulness over Success” implies one is exclusive from the other. Do note that success is not to be equated to excellence. Above I discussed excellence as an approach, but success is an outcome of winning or achieving. An alternative title could have introduced the motive behind the two nouns (faithfulness over success) and suggested that neither of them alone should tip the scale. Brian could have given a qualifier of motivation to show how faithfulness is the goal, and while success should be desired, only faithfulness is required. Youth pastors can only control one of the two; faithfulness is within their ability, while success has other factors of determination. While in Scripture God always calls his people to faithfulness, he does not consistently call us to be unsuccessful. Yes, he called Jeremiah to be faithful knowing his preaching and prophecy would fail to change Judah as it approached its own demise. Yet his call to Abraham was given to bear fruit. We should desire faithfulness before success, but often success can be a barometer for the depth of our faithfulness.
There seems to be a negative sentiment toward youth pastors with a large ministry or signs of success that they must have compromised solid teaching. Brian, I am not sure you are saying this or that you are totally against the types of methods you describe. I would call for a precision of wording on this matter, as some may read this and equate the use of such tools as evil. This very well may be the same misunderstanding some get when they misquote how money is the root of all evil rather than the “love of money.” The distinguishing factor is motive. A youth pastor can use special lighting, a praise band, or special events to complement the depth of teaching; they are not all mutually exclusive.
I truly loved Brian’s approach to core teachings as the framework on which all other areas are built. My favorite points within this section included citing Wayne Rice calling for parental responsibility. I think Wayne wisely knows that the task of the youth minister is about multiplying efforts to accomplish ministry. The insight of Kenda Creasy Dean that the religious devotional barometer of teenagers can be measured by their parents’ level reminds us of the need for ministers to partner with parents. We know parents shape the worldview of teenagers in areas of politics, sports, ethics, authority, and, yes, their view of God. Youth pastors can greatly influence the teenager by helping shape the parents’ worldview. Parents, even with minimal confidence, sharing their faith and values with their teens becomes a spiritual multiplier of the youth pastor’s efforts. Both Moses and Christ reached more people at a deeper level by delegating and partnering with other leaders whom they developed to accomplish more. Youth pastors could call on all parents, knowing they will get help from the same ones who help shape the rest of the teenager’s world.
Brian, you quoted Ephesians 6:4 and Deuteronomy 6:7, both showing that God always intended the primary influence to be parents, and you affirmed the responsibility of the parents. What would it look like for the youth pastor to teach the same consistency by using the Word, service, ordinances, and gospel ministry to both students and parents? At the very least, the youth pastor could seek to have a concerted effort by other staff members teaching this in tandem. Imagine, as an illustration, teaching Scripture as being like a tandem bike, with parents and kids working together, trading off who steers up front and who encourages by pedaling from the rear. At first dads and moms do the steering, but when the student gets older, he or she should take the handlebars while mom or dad pedal in support. The most effective energy spent by youth ministers would be helping dads and moms connect spiritually with their kids. Brian cited Dean as saying the teens’ faith is weak because their parents’ faith (and therefore the congregation’s) is weak. Would you rather have one faucet in your home filtered for safe drinking or have the whole house safe? Teach every person, teens and parents, the depth of Scripture, the understanding of God, and the sacrifice and redeeming power of Christ. Then the Living Water will flow from all and overflow into others.
Brian’s section discusses the ordinances of communion and baptism, which have deep and careful teaching connected to each. All teens should know what each symbolizes as well as the doctrines of salvation and the cross. You could also add the teaching, even without calling it an ordinance as some do, of the washing of the saints’ feet. The model Jesus gave could be observed with the youth minister teaching Brian’s key element of serving others with humility. Even if not participated in by all teens within a service, the act could be demonstrated and taught. A number of denominations use this act in conjunction with the Lord’s Supper, showing how they went together on the eve of Christ’s crucifixion.
As one of the diverse set of readers of this book, I would be remiss not to caution against the unnecessary doctrinal polarization of this section. Brian, you laid out a strong case for substance over form as a means to reach teenagers, but you may have needlessly prompted some to skip past your section with the use of “Reformed.” I admire how you are being true to your doctrine, but I think your chapter could have easily been addressed to both Arminian/Wesleyans as well as the Reformed/Calvinists. Studies have shown a smaller percentage of the pastors from mainline denominations consider themselves Reformed/Calvinist. When asked, an equal number of Southern Baptist Convention pastors indicated their congregations reflected either an Arminian view (30 percent) or a Calvinist view (30 percent).[7] By opening this up to a broader label, you potentially double your audience without compromising your intent. Your wisdom would be welcomed beyond the Reformed churches. Your admonition works in both circles, and we all need to teach more substantively in ways that draw teens to Christ and keep them following in their faith.
Thanks for reminding us of the core issues. Teens and young adults today desire depth from the church. The surface-level worship and inconsistency within one’s life contributes to many walking away from church. This chapter reminds everyone, with abundant grace, not to neglect the Word, service, ordinances, and gospel ministry.
To Greg Stier
I love your passion and vision, Greg. Thanks for your input and feedback! Just a few items of response. You seem to suggest that my impression of youth ministry or the Christian life is joyless and never fun. How far from the truth! I’m all for having fun; I’m just against entertainment as the primary method of getting people into the church, which describes more than a few youth ministry programs (as I’m sure you would agree!).
Yes, you are correct that we are at a point of disagreement over the evangelism issue. While I believe that evangelism and missions is certainly necessary and a significant calling in our lives, Scripture teaches that it is but one aspect of many. Those of us who are married are also called to be loving husbands and wives, child-instructing parents, faithful elders who shepherd the already-saved flock of God, and the list goes on and on. Evangelism doesn’t drive these callings. Certainly faith comes by hearing the Word, and sharing the good news of Jesus is what God has called us to. But this monolithic, narrow view of youth ministry downplays the rich abundance of the multifaceted life of following Jesus.
To Chap Clark
Great points, Chap—thank you. With precision, you pick out my equating “methods” with “means,” which is certainly a goal (albeit with qualifications!). You believe that connecting these in the manner in which I’ve done it is “untenable” with regard to Scripture. That’s understandable, but let me explain further.
In my chapter, I’m trying to get at the answer to this question: What are the methods (or means) that God has called us to in his Word with regard to youth ministry? We would be agreed on much of the content, I’m sure. But in thinking through methods as means, I’m specifically talking about being engaged in ministry with an eye toward God’s sovereign grace in saving and sanctifying his people. My preaching, for example, doesn’t save. God saves. But he uses my preaching as a means of saving. Preaching is a method, therefore, of reaching the lost, but it’s also a means by which God saves the lost. Similarly, does prayer change things? No, God does. But he uses prayer to do it. Prayer is a means by which God works in and through his people.
You are correct in that I am not opposed to contextualizing the message in age-appropriate ways. And you are also correct that I should have made more than a passing comment about this. I guess I assumed this to be the case, and so I didn’t spend any ink working this out. Good point.
If you are taking my comment about the number one fear of teenagers as “being alone” to be attributed to Ravi Zacharias, then I should have said that differently. That poll came from other sources and primary research. What I was intending to communicate is that youth feel a sense of being let down when they thought something would bring satisfaction and it doesn’t. It brings a sense of discouragement and disillusionment. For example, if a teenager believed that the act of premarital sex with her boyfriend would bring security and closeness only to be rejected after the fact, it would cause incredible loneliness. That’s the point I was trying to make.
The trust issue is interesting. All of us—teenagers included—have a harder time trusting someone just because of their position or status, thanks in part to the television reporting constantly displaying the faults and moral failures of those in positions of authority. This was a very small aspect (a passing comment) in my article, but that’s what I was getting at.
Good point on the fact that I didn’t get very specific with practical “how-to” examples. That’s what I tried to do in my book! It’s hard to argue my position in seven thousand words and give a host of examples of what it might look like. But I concede that I should have given a few more. Point well taken. Thanks again for your insights!
To Fernando Arzola
You are very encouraging and gracious; thanks for taking it easy on me! I’m glad you can appreciate a focus on God’s grace in youth ministry—both in its content and method.
You asked about the distinction between “service” and gospel-motivated service. The difference lies, as you might guess, in the specific motivation. All sorts of people around the world give themselves to so-called “good works” of service: the man in Peru handing out food, the doctor in China serving the outcast and sick, the woman in Moldova helping people grow their own food. But without faith, their service doesn’t please God. Paul writes in Romans 8:7, “The mind governed by the flesh is hostile to God.” The writer of Hebrews agrees: “Without faith it is impossible to please God” (Heb. 11:6). Gospel-motivated service would be that service rendered in light of God-given faith as a response to the gospel—service that is pleasing to the Lord.
You question my critique of parachurch youth groups, and that is understandable. They do seem to “work,” but I’m sure you would agree that we’re not after pragmatism but faithfulness to God and his Word. Parachurch youth ministries that usurp the weekly ministry of the local church are not the God-established institution on earth called “to equip the saints for the work of ministry” (Eph. 4:12 ESV), the “pillar and buttress of the truth” (1 Tim. 3:15 ESV), the bride and body of Christ (Eph. 5:23–27; Rom. 12:5) of which God has given overseers (Acts 20:28), and directives on worship and ministry (1 Cor. 14:26–40). Indeed, it’s hard to find any biblical support for a “parachurch” youth group that usurps the local church.
For some reason, you seem to think that I dismiss the research of Christian Smith in the Moralistic Therapeutic Deism (MTD) findings. But I actually appreciate the research of MTD! Perhaps the confusion is that I’m sad at what they uncovered in their research.
Finally, you write, “Reformed denominations are diminishing as many others, so there must be something amiss.” That might be true of some, but the denomination that I am a minister in—the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA)—is one of the fastest-growing denominations in the nation. At the time of writing this response, the latest PCA report (from 2013) noted growth in both the number of churches and members.
I really do appreciate your kindness and graciousness. Thank you for your reaffirmation of the means of grace in youth ministry and your input. I’m very grateful!
To Ron Hunter
Thank you very much for your feedback and input, Ron. Just a few quick thoughts. You argue that we can have both entertainment and substantive content, which is true. I’m all for having fun. But the point I’m making is that entertainment relegates the substantive items (Word, prayer, sacraments, worship, service, community) to the periphery. Moreover, can you really make a case for entertainment-driven youth ministry from the Bible? As a seminary-educated pastor, I surely can’t do it!
You differ over my separation of faithfulness and success, calling it a “flawed comparison.” That’s understandable. I love to see success, truly, but I’m called to faithfulness because God is the One who gives the success (cf. 1 Cor. 3:7). You note that I believe that excellence is simply a pragmatic philosophy that should be dismissed. I don’t remember ever saying that anywhere in my chapter. We should absolutely strive for excellence in the things that God has given us to do. Our approach, however, is not toward being the most successful but rather being faithful to God.
You write, “A cautionary point I would emphasize is that youth ministers should not create a world that makes teens feel that the youth group is the only place where they can be discipled.” I actually fully agree 100 percent with that statement, so I’m not sure what I said that led you to believe I think otherwise.
Finally, you question my use of “Reformed.” I understand that I would probably have a bigger audience if I didn’t use the term, but it accurately describes what I’m trying to do. I’m stressing the sovereign grace of God in youth ministry, not humanity’s goodness that somehow overcomes their dead-in-sin plight and their ability to become children of God through self-will. If it is God who saves and sanctifies (and it is!), then what are we called to do? The answer is to avail ourselves to the means by which he grows us by his grace. Thus, I’m offering a consistent view that dovetails God’s sovereignty in salvation and sanctification with our responsibility of planting and watering the gospel. I do appreciate your emphasis on the family, as that is a great burden of my own heart. I give a hearty “amen” to you!

Greg Stier