The Gospel Advancing View of Youth Ministry
The Gospel Advancing View of Youth Ministry
I’m convinced that Jesus was a youth leader. Before you shake your head in disagreement, think about this. Most rabbis at his time engaged their disciples to follow them when they were in their teenage years.[1]
There also seems to be scriptural support for this radical assertion. Two relatively unknown Bible passages, one in the Old Testament and one in the New, indirectly point toward the likelihood that most of the disciples were teenagers when they began to follow Jesus.
In Matthew 17:24–27 we read,
After Jesus and his disciples arrived in Capernaum, the collectors of the two-drachma temple tax came to Peter and asked, “Doesn’t your teacher pay the temple tax?”
“Yes, he does,” he replied.
When Peter came into the house, Jesus was the first to speak. “What do you think, Simon?” he asked. “From whom do the kings of the earth collect duty and taxes—from their own children or from others?”
“From others,” Peter answered.
“Then the children are exempt,” Jesus said to him. “But so that we may not cause offense, go to the lake and throw out your line. Take the first fish you catch; open its mouth and you will find a four-drachma coin. Take it and give it to them for my tax and yours.”
This passage gets more interesting because all of his disciples arrived in Capernaum, but only Peter and Jesus seem to have paid the temple tax. When you cross-reference this passage with Exodus 30:14, you can see the youth ministry implications: “All who cross over, those twenty years old or more, are to give an offering to the Lord.”
All the disciples were there. Only Peter and Jesus paid. The temple tax is only for those twenty years old or older. If I’m reading this right, then Jesus was a youth leader with one adult sponsor (and one really rotten kid named Judas). He had a small youth ministry budget and no youth room. But with that small youth group, he changed the world.
The question is, how? The answer is clear.
But before we dive into the answer, you may be thinking something like, “Well, that was Jesus. Sure, he could take a group of teenagers who smelled of fish and turn them into world changers. After all he was the Son of God.”
I’m sure his disciples assumed the same. After Jesus was gone, things would go back to normal because, after all, Jesus was God in the flesh. But Jesus reminded them as he reminds us in John 14:12, “Very truly I tell you, whoever believes in me will do the works I have been doing, and they will do even greater things than these, because I am going to the Father.”
Jesus is telling us that you and I can drive the same basic model that he did with his small youth group and do even greater things! Why? Because now Jesus is working from the inside out! Through the Holy Spirit, Jesus himself is advancing his kingdom through each of us, including those involved in youth ministry—both the adults, paid and volunteer, and the believing students.
The question arises that, if this is the case, then why aren’t youth ministries seeing the same results? I believe the answer lies not in complexity but in simplicity.
The modern youth ministry model has largely abandoned the focus of Jesus and delivers, instead, a series of competing programs. We have exchanged mission for meetings. We have separated evangelism and discipleship. We have turned outreach into a program instead of a lifestyle.
What I’m about to share with you is not original with me or the ministry I lead, Dare 2 Share. It is a cutting-edge, highly relevant ministry philosophy that’s two thousand years old. It’s what I call a Gospel Advancing Ministry. It’s what we see in the Gospels and what we read about in the book of Acts.
It’s a messy approach that embraces the bad, the broken, and the bullied. But it’s an approach that truly transforms teenagers not into “good church kids” but into world changers.
When the religious crowds criticized Jesus for going into the house of a notorious sinner, he gave us a peek behind the curtain of what drove him. He simply responded, “For the Son of Man came to seek and to save the lost” (Luke 19:10).
At the core of the heart of Jesus is a desperate search-and-rescue mission for the lost. This was the lens through which he trained his disciples. His earthly ministry with his followers was basically a three-and-a-half-year mission trip laced with teaching and training meetings along the way.
Toward the end of that mission trip, Jesus connected his mission and the mission of his disciples in what is commonly called “the Great Commission.” (I call it “the Cause” because teenagers are into causes, and the term “Great Commission” doesn’t quite connect with them.)[2] He told them, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age” (Matt. 28:18–20).
If we really want teenagers to be like Jesus, then we must cultivate in them a driving passion to reach the lost. And, as we begin to unpack this ministry approach, I believe you’ll agree that cultivating this passion in believing students not only brings lost souls into the kingdom, but leads to discipleship acceleration in their own hearts and lives.
Again, the goal here is not more evangelistic programs but nurturing teenagers to live and give the gospel in word and deed in their spheres of influence. When reaching non-Christians with the gospel becomes a primary passion of their hearts, transformation is triggered on a whole host of spiritual development levels.
It was a Gospel Advancing Ministry that transformed my life from the inside out when I was a teenager. I’ll never forget the first time I attended the youth group known as “Youth Ranch.”
I could tell right away that this youth group was different. Over a hundred urban, suburban, and rural teenagers were tightly packed into a poorly decorated youth room, interacting and laughing. The conversations were not normal; they centered on Jesus—sharing Jesus and growing in Jesus. And cliques (although I’m sure there were some) didn’t dominate the atmosphere.
Teens of different ethnicities and socioeconomic backgrounds were talking to each other. I could pick out the student leaders in the room. They were driving the conversations, introducing newcomers around, and influencing the emotional and spiritual thermostat in the room.
I immediately felt right at home.
And feeling at home wasn’t something I was used to, not even at home. I never knew my biological father, and my mom was, in many ways, like the woman at the well. She had been married at least four times—maybe more. But none of those men was my biological father. No, I was the result of a short-term relationship with a guy she met at a party.
I always wondered why my mom looked at me with those eyes of guilt. Often, my tough, inner-city mother (who was known for her proficiency in fist-fighting) would burst into tears when she talked to me. Later, my grandma filled me in on the backstory. My mom had driven from Denver to Boston to have an illegal abortion when she found out she was pregnant with me. My grandparents convinced her to come back and have the kid. Mom never knew that I knew . . . not even up to the day that she died.
I was raised “American poor” in a high crime area of Denver—in apartments and trailer parks, on a single-parent income, by a mom too proud for government assistance. I was scared and scarred during my childhood. My mom and five uncles had a reputation for violence, and I’d witnessed too much of it by the time I was barely in elementary school.
But this Youth Ranch youth group in the suburbs reached out to the city and was used by God to reach my entire family for Jesus Christ. Eventually aunts, uncles, cousins, my mom, and my half-brother, Doug, were transformed by the amazing good news of Jesus Christ. All because of one Gospel Advancing church that had an amazing Gospel Advancing student ministry.
At the end of the day, like every other teenager, what I really needed was security and significance. This security comes from the message that nothing can separate us from the love of God (Rom. 8:39). It was this gospel reality that helped me realize that I didn’t need an earthly father because I had a heavenly one. And my new Father would never leave me nor forsake me. This youth ministry provided mentors in my life who became my spiritual fathers and mothers. They poured into me and told me again and again that I was lavishly loved by God. This theological security that burst forth from the gospel saved me from a floundering, wasted, and potentially crime-ridden life.
But this Gospel Advancing student ministry didn’t stop there. The people there gave me significance, as well. I had a purpose, a mission, and a cause to live for. They relentlessly drove home the urgency of reaching other teenagers with the gospel. They trained us how to live it and how to give it. They challenged us to engage in gospel conversations everywhere we went.
As a young teenager, I stepped out and initiated a Bible study for my neighborhood friends, whom I had the privilege of leading to Christ. This didn’t come naturally to me, but I was inspired and equipped by my youth leaders. We all were.
Over the years, that youth group exploded to literally hundreds in attendance weekly. The vast majority of us had put our faith in Jesus as a result of the youth group’s outreach efforts. And a primary focus of those efforts was equipping us teenagers to share Jesus with our friends, disciple the new believers, and equip them to do the same.
To be honest, it wasn’t as complicated as you might think.
They had one purpose: to energize a generation to evangelize their world. Discipleship shook out from there. Their premise was that teenagers could change the world, and in the process, their own hearts would be transformed by a deeper and deeper relationship with Jesus. In other words, as teenagers advanced the gospel externally into their community, the gospel would also advance internally, deeper into their hearts.
As I search the New Testament, I see this same ministry philosophy on full display in the life of Jesus and his followers. And as a youth leader and church planter, I’ve seen it work. That’s why it forms the basis for the youth ministry model I train youth leaders in all across the country.
The Benefit of a Gospel Advancing Ministry Model
Unfortunately, in the twenty-first-century youth ministry context, discipleship has been relegated to a meeting where some sort of information is exchanged between the youth leader and the attending teenagers. Stories are told. Blanks are filled. And, if you look at the statistics, not much sticks.[3]
Why? Because we have failed to capture the heart of Jesus’s desperate quest to reach the lost! We have communicated to our young people that the Christian life is about more meetings. Go to camp (meeting). Go to youth group (meeting). Go to small group (meeting). Go to church (meeting).
Yes, Jesus had meetings, but they were in the midst of an ongoing mission. He taught his disciples as he took them from town to town preaching the gospel of the kingdom. He debriefed, shared insights, and interpreted parables as he prepared his small youth group for evangelistic action. By the time he was finished, they were leading the charge for the evangelistic outreaches, and he was coaching them. This was the essence of Jesus’s discipleship process.
I’ll never forget when I was a middle school youth leader at a small Baptist church in Arvada, Colorado. My first Sunday was rough. The twenty or so middle schoolers had their arms folded and their lips curled in snarls. These kids were twelve and thirteen years old but already hardened little legalists who knew the answers and endured the meetings.
I had a full hour and fifteen minutes with them. I had no games or music planned. It was just me and my little lesson on evangelism. I was done in twenty minutes. They looked at each other when I declared the lesson was over with “this-guy’s-never-gonna-make-it” expressions. They knew that fifty-five minutes were still on the clock.
From that point on the conversation went something like this.
“Okay, I’m done with my lesson. But we’re just getting started.”
I continued, “The Bible says, ‘Be doers of the word and not hearers only,’ so now we’re going to go and do what we just learned.”
More confused looks.
“We’re going to go into the neighborhood around the church and go door to door. We’re going to tell people who we are, ask them how we can serve them (raking leaves, cleaning windows, etc.) and see if we can pray for them. Then we’re going to seek to engage them in gospel conversations. If they are open to talking, then we’ll talk with them. If they’re not, we’ll wish them a great day and move on.”
One teen shot his trembling hand up and said, “We can’t do this because we’re in Sunday school.”
I shot back, “Yeah, we’re in Sunday school. During school you take field trips, and that’s what we’re gonna do!”
One kid blurted out, “I’ll get in trouble with my parents.”
I responded, “No, I’ll get in trouble with your parents. But I only get paid $100 a month, so I don’t care if I get fired. We are doing this!”
And we did. And those trembling teenagers came back as heroic, story-telling, high-fiving evangelists. That marked a turning point in the youth group as evangelistic action became the driving force in everything we did. I would train them in the process. We prayed together. We rejoiced together. And at times we wept together over those who rejected Jesus.
I’m not saying we should quit youth group twenty minutes in and go evangelizing the neighborhood. But I am saying that when we lead the way for evangelism personally and equip teenagers to do the same, it accelerates the discipleship process faster than just about anything.
What a Tim Keller Tweet Taught Me about Teenagers
During one of his Q & A sessions, Tim Keller sent out an insightful tweet about students: “Teenagers have more information about God than they have experience of him. Get them in places where they have to rely on God.”[4]
Of course, social justice and service projects accomplish this goal. Mission trips do this too. There’s nothing like getting teenagers away from the mainland, away from technology, and putting a brick and a trowel in their hands to do some work in an impoverished part of the world. But I propose that there is nothing like relational evangelism to put teenagers in a position where they are forced to rely on God.
If you give the average teenager a choice to go to the Amazon to build a mud hut for the poor while fighting off hungry pythons or going to their school cafeteria and dropping the “J Bomb” on a group of their friends, most teenagers would pick the pythons. Why? Because the average teenager would rather risk getting choked by a giant snake than getting choked out of their social circle!
This very real, very visceral risk causes teenagers to count the cost of following Jesus. Yes, salvation is a free gift, but growing in grace is accelerated when their faith is stretched and they learn to joyfully risk everything in service to the King.
This is exactly what James was writing about in James 2:21–22: “Was not our father Abraham considered righteous for what he did when he offered his son Isaac on the altar? You see that his faith and his actions were working together, and his faith was made complete by what he did.”
According to Genesis 15:6, Abraham was declared righteous when he believed God’s promise. More than two decades later, he put that faith to the test by his willingness to sacrifice Isaac on the altar. “His faith and his actions were working together,” and as a result his faith was matured (the word “complete” in the Greek means mature as the result of a growing process).
What does that have to do with teenagers, evangelism, and discipleship? When teenagers are willing to sacrifice what means most to them—for many, what their peers think of them—their faith and actions work together, and they are spiritually matured by that process of sacrifice.
The bottom line is that if we are serious about teenagers spiritually maturing, then we’ll want to get them sharing their faith as quickly as possible.
The Vital Elements of a Gospel Advancing Ministry
1. Equip teenagers for relational evangelism.
For teenagers to develop a lifestyle of evangelism, they need to be equipped to share their faith. This includes knowing how to naturally bring up the gospel, explain it clearly, tie in their story, and navigate various responses to the gospel. They also need to learn how to ask great questions and listen deeply to others.
Of course, this takes time, prayer, patience, and coaching. And more than anything, it takes youth leaders who are modeling evangelism personally for their students on a consistent basis.
2. Share stories, stories, and more stories.
Storytelling is the fuel of movements both big and small. What makes the book of Acts so exciting to read? All the stories of transformed lives and heroic evangelism! As teenagers share stories in youth group and youth leaders share stories in their talks, teenagers begin to see risk-taking, relational evangelism as truly transformational. As stories of evangelistic efforts begin to bear fruit and groups grow with new disciples, a Holy Spirit synergy develops; stories keep evangelism front and center, new believers share the good news with their unreached circles of friends, and excitement builds.
Of course, this process is messy. Of course, these new teenagers bring all their baggage into the group. Of course, there will be those who look at a Gospel Advancing Ministry with distain or cynicism. But, just like in the book of Acts, the momentum of changed lives overcomes all the negatives. The focus shifts from fun and games to mission and purpose.
3. Give the gospel relentlessly in youth group meetings.
Somebody once asked Charles Spurgeon what his preaching style was. His response was, “I take my text and I make a beeline for the cross.”[5]
The apostle Paul said it this way in 1 Corinthians 2:2, “For I resolved to know nothing while I was with you except Jesus Christ and him crucified.” Teenagers, both saved and unsaved, need to hear the gospel. Of course, this message can save the unbeliever, but it also serves to sanctify the believer.
Seasoned youth leader David Hertweck put it this way: “The message of the Gospel is not something that is solely necessary at the beginning of a teenager’s faith journey; it is their faithful companion every step of the way. We never graduate from the truth of the Gospel, rather we cling to it and allow it to bring about more and more change in our lives.”[6]
Why do you think Jesus left communion as a regular ordinance for the church? As a reminder that we need to continually be impacted by the message of the shed blood and broken body of Christ! The gospel’s message is simple yet profound. As we plumb its depths, it saves the unbeliever, sanctifies the believer, and supercharges the Christian’s mission to reach the lost.
When Jesus told his disciples to “go and make disciples,” he was challenging them to take the good news “wide” (to the ends of the earth). When he mandated that they teach these new disciples to “obey everything I have commanded you,” he was directing them to go deep.
This philosophy takes teenagers deeper into their relationship with God as they are going wider in their outreach to the lost. The deep feeds the wide, and the wide feeds the deep. (See fig. 1.1.) Of course, the deep side entails theological training as well as spiritual disciplines as central to building the student into a fully matured follower of Jesus.
Figure 1.1. Deep and wide
A Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute article titled “Minority Rules: Scientists Discover Tipping Point for the Spread of Ideas” noted the following interesting sociological phenomenon: “Scientists at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute have found that when just 10 percent of the population holds an unshakable belief, their belief will always be adopted by the majority of the society.”[7]
Have you ever wondered why Jesus poured so much into twelve young men? It’s because he was getting them fully committed toward an “unshakable” set of beliefs. When he ascended and they scattered, they took this message with them everywhere they went. They were willing to die horrible deaths because of these beliefs.
As a result of Jesus focusing on the 10 percent instead of the masses, he multiplied his efforts long after he ascended into heaven.
In the same way, when youth leaders focus their efforts on getting the most willing students ready to go deep and wide, they can multiply their efforts with the other teenagers in the group. A Gospel Advancing Ministry model requires a handful of highly committed students who are willing to help the youth leader reach other students. Being a student leader is more than just setting up chairs for youth group; it’s about filling those chairs with teenagers who are being reached for Christ.
Just like Jesus, youth leaders should minister to everyone but pour their lives into those teenagers who are willing to go all in for Christ and his cause. They will help reach the other teenagers.
5. Gospelize everything.
To truly build a Gospel Advancing Ministry model, nothing can be separated from the gospel. If we do a car wash fundraiser, we must figure out how to use it to effectively spread the gospel. If we do a service project, we must tie the gospel in. If we take teenagers on a mission trip—you guessed it—we gospelize it!
Our social justice efforts should ooze Jesus and be done in a more holistic way than the world’s. When we give a hungry person a piece of bread, we must give them the Bread of Life as well. When we give a thirsty person water, we must give them the Living Water too. When we build someone a house on earth, we build them one in heaven as well.
If we want teenagers to truly reach out to the lost and love their neighbors as they love themselves, we must coach them on how to provide physical provisions for temporal needs, along with spiritual provisions for eternal needs.
6. Make prayer a big, big deal.
The importance of prayer in this whole process cannot be overemphasized. Isn’t it interesting that Jesus was always escaping ministry opportunities to pray? He prayed for his disciples and for us (John 17:15–21). He prayed for God’s glory to be magnified and God’s kingdom to be advanced (Matt. 6:9–10). He prayed for strength to stand strong (Matt. 26:36–46). In the same way, we must pray, and we must mobilize teenagers to pray.
The thought of a Gospel Advancing Ministry model intimidates some. Or their first inclination may be to nitpick it apart and say, “Yeah, but . . .” or “Wait now . . .” or whatever. But I find that many times, hovering beneath these responses is a genuine conviction that this was Jesus’s and the early disciples’ model, though it may be quickly followed by a real fear of the implications for their life and ministry.
If the thought of building this brand of youth ministry overwhelms us, we must let it drive us to our knees in prayer. The same Jesus who said, “Go and make disciples” also said, “And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age” (Matt. 28:19–20).
We need to pray. We need to help students learn how to pray. We need to have regular prayer meetings and put more prayer into our regular meetings. When true intercessory prayer becomes the engine and not the caboose of youth ministry strategies, we will see momentum in ways we never expected.
What Kind of Adult Involvement Is Necessary?
1. Adult sponsors who model it.
The heart of the average teenager longs for authenticity in the adults who minister to them. They can sense the adults who are the real deal and the ones who are not. Their “attitude barometer” is on all the time.
The adults who are modeling a Gospel Advancing lifestyle will have the biggest impact on teenagers, especially if they don’t have the gift of evangelism. Those adults with the gift of evangelism (like me) can sometimes freak teens out. We tell crazy stories of axe-wielding murderers we’ve led to Christ, and they cheer and clap their hands and then think to themselves, “Are you crazy? I would never do that.”
But when a “normal” adult who strives and struggles to live a lifestyle of evangelism models a Gospel Advancing approach to life, students are filled with courage. They know that if those kinds of adults can do it, then maybe they can too.
Of course, this means that we need to equip adult sponsors to share their faith relationally as well. As we equip and consistently encourage them, we’ll see more and more traction and impact on teens.
2. Parents who coach it.
The believing parents of teenagers in a youth group should consider themselves coaches in this whole process. Some teens need to be coached to get off the bench and get into the game of evangelism. Others need to be coached to stop tackling so hard in their apologetics or to run a little harder in their evangelistic initiative.
One of the simple ways to do this is to email three or four open-ended questions to parents every week based on the lesson content, questions that are designed to engage in real conversation. These should include at least one question that leans toward evangelism. For instance, if a lesson was on sexual purity, questions might include:
As youth leaders provide open-ended questions week in and week out and parents become accustomed to talking with their teenagers about spiritual things, parents will become increasingly equipped to take the primary role of discipler in the lives of their teenagers.
3. Church leaders who embrace it.
There is nothing like evangelism to rock the proverbial boat. When a youth leader starts bringing “those kinds of kids” into their youth ministry, the worries and whispers start. Before they know it, they’re in an emergency elders meeting talking about their position and whether they’re the right fit for the church.
That’s why it’s vitally important to get key church leaders on board with this strategy. Youth leaders must pray that God will grant them favor (and keep praying), then share their vision for Gospel Advancing Ministry with the board members and senior pastor.
Unfortunately, I’ve seen youth leaders who exercised this model get fired, even when they sought church leadership support in the right way. So it is a risk. But it’s a risk that’s worth taking to reach the next generation.
Unique Differences for Ages and Stages of Development
Obviously, engaging teenagers in this model takes wisdom and strategy for every age and developmental stage. I think of it like a sport. There are amateurs, rookies, and pros.
The goal is to move younger teenagers from amateurs to rookies when it comes to evangelism. Developmentally, less mature students are typically better suited to more concrete, structured training. For example, they can learn the raw truths of the gospel message and basic ways to initiate gospel conversation. The less mature they are, the more coaching they generally need. Unleash the wrong fired-up seventh grader with a handful of Gospels of John, and he’ll end up on a chair in the mall cop’s office. (I know, because I was that seventh grader!)
More developmentally mature teenagers can move from rookie to pro as their more abstract, critical-thinking skills further develop. They can learn basic apologetics and the art of listening deeply to others, so that the Holy Spirit can help them find pathways into their friends’ souls to effectively share the gospel with them. In this stage, they move from gospel presentations to give-and-take spiritual conversations. And they move beyond making converts to making disciples who in turn make disciples. This is the final developmental phase—that of coach. Young adults can move into this “multiplier” role and help other teenagers learn to share their faith effectively.
When evangelism becomes the driver in the youth ministry paradigm, discipleship will flow out in ways we never imagined. The kingdom of God will advance both inwardly into the hearts of teenagers and outwardly into the heart of the community. And, to be honest, youth ministry is way more fun and way more rewarding when lives are being transformed.
Yes, we can and should have meetings. Let’s keep having dodgeball tournaments, pizza parties, and lock-ins. Let’s worship loud and play hard. Let’s exegete, teach, and ask hard questions. But let’s gospelize it all. “I am not ashamed of the gospel, because it is the power of God that brings salvation to everyone who believes: first to the Jew, then to the Gentile” (Rom. 1:16).
