Chapter 12 of 18

The Ecclesial View of Youth Ministry

The Ecclesial View of Youth Ministry

The Ecclesial View of Youth Ministry

Let’s be honest. Protestant youth ministry has all but deleted ecclesiology from its theological radar. It’s not so much that ecclesiology has become unimportant; rather, it is nonexistent in contemporary youth ministry thought. Youth ministries focus primarily on discipleship and worship. Of course these are central aspects, but they are not the sole ones. And they did not appear out of thin air. Rather, they flow out of two thousand years of ecclesiological evolution, starting with the churches the apostles left behind. Furthermore, it is also important to teach Christian teens that ecclesiology preceded the biblical canon for over three hundred years. As long as youth ministries do not reclaim a historically orthodox understanding of ecclesiology, it will perpetuate the myopic and thin contemporary North American expressions of pop-worship and neo-discipleship based on mega-ministry personalities, cultural trends, and repackaged curriculums decided by a handful of publishers.

Ecclesiological Resurgence

In recent years, there has been an increase in the scholarly examination of ecclesiology.[1] So why hasn’t this occurred in youth ministry?[2] Not only do youth ministry programs and churches, and therefore youth ministry leaders and practitioners, tend to separate themselves from each other, but by default they often seem to facilitate a de facto congregational polity within a congregational polity. Nevertheless, in some circles at least, there has been a resurgence of interest in the writings of the church fathers and in reappropriating Christian orthodoxy.[3] The purpose of this chapter is to examine selected issues of ecclesiology, specifically the nature and authority of the church, and suggest practices that may help reappropriate a historically orthodox ecclesiology within a youth ministry context.

Historically Orthodox Perspectives

The historically orthodox perspectives are gleaned from the works of Donald G. Bloesch, Thomas C. Oden, and Robert E. Webber. Bloesch reflects the Reformed tradition; Oden, the Methodist tradition; and Webber, the Anglican tradition.

Bloesch argues for the need to move toward a catholic evangelicalism.[4] This requires a threefold integration: (1) the need to reappraise biblical authority, (2) the need to recover evangelical distinctives, and (3) the need to recover catholic substance.[5] What is catholic substance? Let us explore what this means for us.

Oden is considered the founder of “paleo-orthodoxy,” a theological viewpoint that calls on Christians to rely on the wisdom of the traditions of the historic church, especially the early church.[6]

Webber is considered the founder of the Ancient-Future movement, a theological viewpoint committed to connecting ancient Christian faith, worship, and spirituality with the postmodern and post-Christian world. Webber clarifies his position as follows.

I have structured Ancient-Future Faith around the phenomenon of the origin of the Christian faith. I have not started . . . with the Scriptures. Rather, I begin with the work of Jesus Christ, the primordial event of the living, dying, rising, and coming again. . . .

Not starting with the Bible does not represent a lower view of Scripture. . . . Instead, the Christocentric method acknowledges the place of the Scriptures in the early Christian tradition. In the early centuries Scripture was not separated from the church or from the development of classical Christian thought, but was inextricably linked with the whole phenomenon of the rise of Christianity. In modern times the act of lifting the Bible out of its phenomenological context of the work of the Holy Spirit in the church has resulted in making the Bible the object of rational criticism. In post-modern Christianity the authority of the Bible will be restored, not by more rational arguments, but by returning it to its rightful place in the development of the entire spectrum of Christian thought in the first six centuries of the church and by learning to read it canonically once again.[7]

The early Fathers can bring us back to what is common and help us get behind our various traditions, not in the sense that we deny our own tradition, but that we give priority to the common teaching of the church.[8]

Reclaiming the Incarnational View of the Church

According to Webber, there are five stages or paradigms of the church throughout history. In the classical period, the ancient stage, the church was understood as the visible continuation of the presence of Christ in the world.[9] It was viewed as the sacrament of Christ. That is, the real presence of Christ is found in the church. “This incarnational view of the Church saw Jesus present in the assembled people, in the ministry of the bishop, presbyter, and deacon, in the word and song and at the Table. In this way, Christ continues to minister to his church and to dwell among his people.”[10]

During the classic period, the threefold order of ministry (bishop, presbyter, and deacon) was developed. Their primary responsibility was to pass down the orthodox teachings of the faith, to shepherd the flock, and to appoint others to be faithful ministers in the church. By the end of the sixth century, as the church expanded, the bishop took over increasing responsibilities, and the unity of the church was based on the unity of the bishops. “Truth, it was argued, originated in the church with the apostles and was handed down in Scripture, summarized by the creeds and guarded and interpreted by the church.”[11]

Roman Catholicism began to develop institutionally around the thirteenth century, the medieval stage. This is most dramatically seen in the role of the pope and the hierarchical/ecclesial concept of authority. The church was no longer a community of equals. The source of power was rooted in the clergy. Decisions filtered down to the laity, who passively obeyed. Canon law defined all of the church’s actions, laws, and penalties. And during the last two centuries of the medieval era, the institutional church became morally and politically corrupt.[12]

The Reformation stage was a response to the corruptions in the church. Protestants turned away from the institutional church toward the gospel. As stated above, the Reformers identified the marks of the “true” church as a gathering of Christians where the Word of God is rightly preached and the sacraments rightly administered. During this stage, the threefold order of ministry was replaced by the presbyterian and congregational models of church government. The true church was found in the “invisible church,” which existed in the mind of God. Luther called this “a spiritual, inner christendom.”[13] This led to a shift from the “visible” church to the “invisible” church, which dominated modern Protestant thought.[14] Consequently, this led to the rise of various denominations and independent church movements, and the emergence of the parachurch movement. During this modern stage, the church was viewed by Protestants as not having a divine presence but a divine calling to proclaim the gospel message. Coupled with the rise of individualism flowing from the Enlightenment, the emphasis was on the purity and work of the local church, not the corporate body.[15]

In today’s postmodern stage, there seems to be a resurgence of interest in the visible church from the ancient times. With the increase of globalization, the universal interconnectedness of the internet, and the decline of denominational distinctions, the local church increasingly is connected to the global church.[16]

Ecclesiological Problems Inherited from the Enlightenment

Two specific problems have evolved that have significantly, and negatively, impacted the Protestant church in general, and youth ministry in particular, in its understanding of ecclesiology. Both problems were inherited from the Enlightenment.

The first problem is the emphasis on pragmatism, which has resulted in an a-theological understanding of the church.[17] Many churches have developed such a strong pragmatic perspective that the understanding of the church as the body of Christ has been replaced with the model of an effective corporation. And many church and youth ministries have adopted business models as their ecclesiological template. The pastor/youth minister is viewed as a chief executive officer, and the laity functions under this managerial leadership.[18] The church has also been co-opted as a political power base. The goal of some of these Christian groups is to legislate morality.

This pragmatic approach in the church has resulted in what is called “leadership development,” a model that is popular in Christian colleges and seminaries. Much of the curricula, books, and content are based on secular leadership models baptized and re-presented after a biblical cleansing. They may be connected with personalities and perspectives from the Scriptures, but they seldom examine the lives of Christian men and women throughout the ages.

The second problem is the emphasis on individualism, which has led to an ahistorical view of the church.[19] While certain denominations have an appreciation of church history, generally speaking, many leaders are either uninformed about church history prior to the Reformation or they intentionally reject church history prior to the Reformation. This radical individualism often leads church movements or fellowships to “start over again” instead of learning about church history. Webber wonders whether “Enlightenment rationalism has robbed the church of its mystical self concept, so that it is now regarded as little more than a human organization made up of individuals.”[20] Is this not the reality of many youth ministries, which tend to focus on contemporary matters rather than understanding their place within the communion of saints?

Recovering the Four Creedal Characteristics of the Church[21]

The Church Is One

Christ founded only one church, and he intended for that church to be one. In John 17:20–21, Jesus implores the Father to protect the unity of the church when he prays, “I ask not only on behalf of these, but also on behalf of those who will believe in me through their word, that they may all be one. As you, Father, are in me and I am in you, may they also be in us, so that the world may believe that you have sent me” (NRSV). In Ephesians 4:1–6, Paul later adds,

I therefore, the prisoner in the Lord, beg you to lead a life worthy of the calling to which you have been called, with all humility and gentleness, with patience, bearing with one another in love, making every effort to maintain the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace. There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to the one hope of your calling, one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is above all and through all and in all. (NRSV)

The early church understood this to mean the visible unity of the church. Any break with the church was taken as a serious breach against Christ’s body.[22] The emphasis on the invisible church is often attributed to the historical and seemingly perpetual schismatic nature of Protestantism; that is, what is most important is that the local body of believers faithfully proclaim the Word of God and rightfully administer the sacraments. Connection to the broader church is secondary at best.

The historically orthodox perspective believes that one of the most important features toward reappropriating historic orthodoxy is to restore the four creedal characteristics of the church, encouraging churches to recover the ancient church’s concern for the visible church as a constitutive balance to the invisible and spiritual emphasis of the church. “The unity of the church is to be found not in its rites or creeds but in its obedience to Jesus Christ, its one head and Lord.”[23]

There will be struggles for the visible church, but the body can find strength and solace in the invisible graces that it enjoys. Oden writes,

The same single body that struggles against the principalities and powers and that expects even more severe difficulties in the future, is at the same time already victorious in virtue of its being presently united with its head in the heavenly city, anticipating that completed joy in the Lord wherein all the faithful shall praise God together at the end of days.[24]

Historically orthodox Christians recognize that the church has unfolded in many cultures and, therefore, do not necessarily believe there is a single expression of the true church. Oden explains,

The idolatrous over-evaluation of unity results in uniformity, a tyrannizing excess of superficially imposed unity. The under-evaluation or neglect of unity is divisiveness and egocentricity, imagining that one’s own individualistic opinion is more important or more closely ordained of God than the received consensual tradition. The Spirit sustains the unity of the church by enjoying and enabling centered variety, not uniformity, and by seeking and praying for reconciliation whenever centrifugal forces become intense.[25]

The characteristic of unity is also a way toward finding a common ground with the various Christian families. “This perspective will allow us to see Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant churches as various forms of the one true church—all based on apostolic teaching and authority, finding common ground in the faith expressed by classical Christianity.”[26]

The Church Is Holy

Holiness is unquestionably an important theological concept. However, for many, it is viewed primarily as a personal characteristic, not as an aspect for the whole church. In 1 Peter 1:13–16, the church, not individuals, are challenged to be holy as Christ is holy.

Therefore prepare your minds for action; discipline yourselves; set all your hope on the grace that Jesus Christ will bring you when he is revealed. Like obedient children, do not be conformed to the desires that you formerly had in ignorance. Instead, as he who called you is holy, be holy yourselves in all your conduct; for it is written, “You shall be holy, for I am holy.” (NRSV)

The church is holy because Christ is holy. While the church is a gathering of redeemed sinners, “Nevertheless, Christ through the Holy Spirit summons the church to holiness.”[27] Oden adds to this paradox when he writes,

As the body of Christ, the Church is necessarily holy, yet its holiness is enmeshed in continuing human imperfection and finitude until the end of history. The church is holy while not ceasing to be subject to the infirmities of the flesh that accompany all historical existence . . . the holiness of the church is best expressed in the imperfect or unfinished tense—that God is now sanctifying the church, now calling forth a communio sanctorum.[28]

While youth ministries should certainly continue encouraging individuals to live a life of holiness, they should also view the larger church as a holy body belonging to and made holy by Jesus Christ. Jesus called his disciples out of the world, understanding that they will remain in the world, and asked the Father to protect them from the evil one (John 17:6–18). Because they remain in the world, the church will always be close to sin and sinners. “The distinctive function of the church is to bring sinners to the way of holiness. This requires that the church should love at close quarters the sinners it is called to save, and to draw near precisely to the sinners it is called to redeem and sanctify.”[29] “The church is holy because it is marked off from the world by the interior illumination and cleansing work of the Holy Spirit. Its holiness is anchored in its Lord, but it is reflected, sometimes only dimly, in the members of his mystical body.”[30]

The Church Is Catholic

For Protestants to self-identify as “catholic” does not come easily, and neither is it even comfortably discussed. Yet, because of the rich meaning and heritage of the term, “catholic” should be reclaimed by the entire church. Webber quotes Ignatius, who writes, “Wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the catholic church.”[31] Following this logic, therefore, “the Church is catholic that has all the truth—Jesus Christ.”[32] Oden agrees when he explains, “Wherever there is consent to apostolic teaching, there the whole church is becoming embodied.”[33]

The term “catholic” also means “universal,” again, underscoring the nature of the larger church. It is not bound to a particular place or time. Historically orthodox Christians call for an outward, global-looking congregation. “The church is rightly called catholic insofar as it does not cease to be universal as it becomes intensely local.”[34]

Integrative use of both of these concepts helps to understand the call of the larger church toward doctrinal orthodoxy, that is, the universal church as a body that is faithfully rooted in the truth of Jesus Christ. “The church is universal not only in the sense that it is worldwide, but also in the sense that it is grounded in the universality of the atonement. The church is identical in that it always remains true to itself in history; the church is always to remain orthodox.”[35]

Bloesch agrees, “When we confess the apostolicity of the church we acknowledge that the true church is founded on the apostles. The faith of the church must stand in continuity with their enduring witness.”[36]

The Church Is Apostolic

The church is not a philosophy-of-life group but a living body shaped by the apostolic teaching.[37] To understand the church as apostolic is to acknowledge its ancient roots. “Apostolicity indicates that the church is linked to and built on the past.”[38]

How then should we understand apostolicity? I agree with Bloesch, who writes, “The real apostolic succession consists in a reaffirmation of the teaching and doctrine of the apostles in the history of the catholic church.”[39] According to Oden, the primary task of apostolic succession is to remember and pass on the original teaching.

The task of the apostolic successor is not to improve upon the message or embellish it or add to it one’s own spin or personal tilt or idiosyncratic twist, but rather simply to remember and attest it accurately, credibly, intelligibly, contextually. To assist in correct remembering, the Holy Spirit has enabled the apostolic testimony to be written down in a canonically received body of writings consensually received as normative apostolic teaching.[40]

Here, therefore, we differentiate between apostolicity and the historical, linear episcopate. While many Christians may embrace the apostolic succession as the passing down of the orthodox teachings of the apostles, the linear, historical succession of the episcopacy is a concept that is considered secondary. Recovery of the characteristics of the church as one, holy, catholic, and apostolic may help many churches and youth ministries to look outside themselves, both individually and locally, and toward the larger, universal, and historical church.

Reappropriating Historically Orthodox Youth Ministry Practices

Practice 1: Reappropriating the Four Characteristics of the Church

As seen above, many Protestant traditions understand the marks of the church as the right preaching of the gospel and the right administration of the sacraments. This twofold concept was established by Martin Luther and John Calvin in response to their understanding of the Catholic Church’s works-based sacramental economy. They argued that the works-oriented teachings on justification and the sacraments were both contrary to the proper understanding of the gospel and the sacraments.

For Protestants, they serve as contemporary pillars firmly rooting the church against the wave of pluralistic teachings from many mainline and liberal churches. Wayne Grudem elaborates on these two marks as expression of the true church as follows.

Certainly if the Word of God is not being preached, but simply false doctrines or doctrines of men, then there is no true church. . . . When the preaching of a church conceals the gospel message of salvation by faith alone from its members, so that the gospel message is not clearly proclaimed, and has not been proclaimed for some time, the group meeting is not a church. . . . The right administration of the sacraments was probably stated in opposition to the Roman Catholic view that saving grace came through the sacraments and thereby the sacraments were made works by which we earned merit for salvation.[41]

However, the four creedal characteristics of the church, namely, one, holy, catholic, and apostolic, root the congregation beyond the Reformation to the early church. The two marks of the church stated above seem to be primarily concerned with issues of form; that is, right preaching and right sacramental administration, whereas the four characteristics of the church are more all-encompassing of the nature of the church.

“The church as one” encompasses Christ’s founding of the church, the paradox of the visible/temporal and invisible/divine nature of the church, historical schisms, the body of Christ, transcultural diversity within the unity of the church, and Christian unity.

“The church as holy” encompasses corporate holiness in addition to individual holiness, the holiness of the church based on Christ’s holiness, the struggles of the holy church vis-à-vis an unholy world, the closeness of the church with sin, the church as a community of redeemed sinners, and the nature of salvation.

“The church as catholic” encompasses the proclamation of gospel truth, teaching doctrinal orthodoxy, celebration of sacraments, the relationship between the universal church and the local church, global interconnectedness, transcending place and time, and the nature of the true church.

“The church as apostolic” encompasses acknowledging the ancient roots of the church, the relationship between the contemporary church and the early church, fidelity to apostolic teaching, honoring the history of the church, honoring the communion of saints, encouragement of a missional ethos, and the passing down of the rule of faith.

Practice 2: Reappropriating an Incarnational/Visible Understanding of the Body of Christ

Webber provides a helpful five-stage/paradigmatic survey of church history. He begins with the ancient church, which emphasized the incarnational/visible understanding of the body of Christ. That is, the church was viewed as the sacrament of Christ; the real presence of Christ is found in the church. “This incarnational/visible concept of the church saw Jesus present in the assembled people, in the ministry of the bishop, presbyter, and deacon, in the Word and song and at the Table. In this way, Christ continues to minister to his church and to dwell among his people.”[42]

The incarnational/visible understanding of the church also connects the youth ministry with the larger church, the body of Christ. While youth ministries may rightfully refer to themselves as the body of Christ, they can only be understood as a part of the greater body of Christ. A tendency for youth ministries is to isolate themselves from the larger church as if to imply they are “a” body of Christ unto themselves as opposed to being a part of “the” body of Christ. The Catholic Church teaches, “In Christian usage, the word ‘church’ designates the liturgical assembly, but also the local community or the whole community of believers. These three meanings are inseparable. The church is the people that God gathers in the whole world.”[43] Individual congregations should never be regarded as a part or a component of the whole church. “The church is not a sum or composite of the individual local groups. Instead, the whole is found in each place.”[44]

This nuance is significant. Lothar Coenen affirms Millard Erickson’s insight about Paul’s writing “to the church of God in Corinth” in 1 Corinthians 1:2, when he comments on this ekklēsia reference: “It is one throughout the whole world and yet it is at the same time fully present in every individual assembly.”[45] The universal church is composed of all believers on earth and transcends geographical boundaries.

Practice 3: Developing a More Formal Teaching of Ecclesiology

Traditional youth ministry tends to focus on the spiritual concerns of individuals. Discipleship is primarily Bible study and prayer. The theology and content of worship often emphasize a group of individuals rather than the gathering of the community. The popular usage of contemporary Christian music, for example, often reinforces the “personal relationship” between the believer and Christ but rarely addresses the communal aspect of the faith. Preaching generally addresses how to apply biblical principles into one’s individual life. Happily, there has been a growing resurgence in fellowship (koinōnia) and service (diakonia). Yet, again, these are sometimes understood individualistically, as things that can help a person grow spiritually.

While helping teens to grow in spiritual maturity is a significant responsibility of the youth ministry, I suggest that a more formal teaching of ecclesiology is in order. A more formal teaching on “the church” will help youth ministries with both informational and formational issues. From the informational perspective, members of the church will become familiar with the early church; the development of church doctrine; the evolution of liturgy, worship, and the sacraments; the positive and negative contributions of the Reformation; the positive and negative contributions of the Counter-Reformation; the interaction and tension between the church and the world; the ecumenical movement; and the contemporary state of the church. Review of these issues will both create a more informed congregation and raise the corporate awareness of its place within the larger historical church.

From a formational perspective, youth members will be embedded within the body of Christ, root their faith back to the ancient church, participate in communion with the saints (both past and present), grow from the writings of Christian classics, recognize the relationship between personal holiness and corporate holiness found in Christ, and reestablish and reconnect the importance of their personal spiritual formation within the context of the local church and larger catholic church. Review of these issues, together with the above topics, will help counter the individualistic nature of Christian spirituality, and will nurture a faith grounded in the one, holy, catholic, and apostolic church.

The purpose of this chapter was to examine selected issues of ecclesiology, specifically the nature and authority of the church, and suggest practices that may help reappropriate a historic, orthodox ecclesiology within a youth ministry context.

↑ Back to top

↑