Chap Clark’s Response
Responses to the Adoption View
I was pleasantly surprised at how many times I said “Amen!” in my soul as I read your chapter, Chap. You and I have “tangled” a bit in the past when it comes to youth ministry strategy, philosophy, and focus, but your chapter spoke to me personally, because I am the result of an “adoptive” approach to youth ministry.
Galatians 3:26 reminds us, “So in Christ Jesus you are all children of God through faith.” The result of putting our faith in Christ alone based on his finished work on the cross is being adopted into the family of God. Ephesians 1:4–6 puts it this way, “For he chose us in him before the creation of the world to be holy and blameless in his sight. In love he predestined us for adoption to sonship through Jesus Christ, in accordance with his pleasure and will—to the praise of his glorious grace, which he has freely given us in the One he loves.”
This “adoption to sonship” is more than a salvific reality that’s true in heaven; it has powerful consequences on earth as well. Because God adopted me, I’m part of a family full of adopted brothers and sisters in Christ (aka “the church”). Chap, you did a phenomenal job of making a theological case for this in terms of how we view and do youth ministry.
Bravo!
Growing up, I never knew my biological father. He was in the army and abandoned me and my mom before I was even born. My mom was married four different times (that’s how many old marriage certificates I found in her footlocker after she passed away, anyway). As a result, I never had a sense of being a part of a complete family as I was growing up, so coming to faith in Jesus and viewing God as my “Father” had a deep and meaningful impact on me.
Ten years ago, when my mom was dying of cancer in hospice, we had several significant conversations about how Jesus changed everything. She asked me, “Do you remember what you used to say when you were a kid and other kids would make fun of you for not having a daddy?” I didn’t remember, so she reminded me, “You used to say ‘God’s my Daddy.’” I told my mom, “I don’t remember saying that, but I remember feeling that from the time I put my faith in Jesus.”
So when this youth ministry from the suburbs reached into the inner city where I lived to “adopt” me into their church, it was a game changer. Now, I wasn’t just a kid adopted by a heavenly Father whom I would see someday; I had brothers and sisters to embrace me, train me, and unleash me.
Mark Schweitzer, Kenny, “Timo,” “Yankee,” and a host of other adults took me in and poured into my life. They were more than traditional youth leaders to me; they were, in your words, Chap, “adoption guides.” They taught me the traditional youth ministry stuff, but much more. They helped me discover my spiritual gift, trained me to share my faith, and even taught me how to preach.
My youth leaders even set it up for me to preach in “big church” when I was twelve years old. I just about couldn’t see over the large pulpit, but I preached my first sermon there. And I wasn’t alone. Some of us teenagers were given opportunities to preach, but if you had musical skill, they put you in the band. Teenagers could lead Sunday school classes, teach in the children’s ministries, be on service teams—just about anything and everything an adult could do.
Underneath it all pulsated a heart for adoption. We were a bunch of young people that the church took in, trained up, and plugged in as viable members of the body. Although it was a very “old school” church in many ways, it modeled adoption better than any youth ministry I have seen to date.
To this day, many of the adults who spoke into my life forty years ago still speak into my life today. Even when I left the church, I still felt it was a home base for me.
So, Chap, as I read your chapter, I was not thinking of a radical new paradigm; I was thinking of the philosophy of ministry that rescued me from the streets and formed the basis for what I do at Dare 2 Share today.
All that said, I would add three things.
1. The Mission of This Approach Must Be External, Not Just Internal.
First Peter 2:9 makes it clear that we’ve been chosen for a purpose: “But you are a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, God’s special possession, that you may declare the praises of him who called you out of darkness into his wonderful light.” The purpose of our adoption is proclamation with our lives and our lips of the gospel of Jesus Christ.
A teenager who knows, owns, lives, and shares their faith has a much stronger likelihood of keeping their faith long term. In her book Almost Christian, based on the National Study of Youth and Religion, Kenda Creasy Dean identifies four marks of young people who are highly devoted to their faith traditions:
Note that community is only one component here. Teenagers who fully embrace Jesus’s message grasp the reality that something intensely important is at stake in a larger story here—the souls of their friends. They understand the truth that they—they personally—have a role to play as Christ’s ambassadors to a lost and hurting world. They truly believe Paul’s words in 2 Corinthians 5:19–20 (NLT): “For God was in Christ, reconciling the world to himself, no longer counting people’s sins against them. And he gave us this wonderful message of reconciliation. So we are Christ’s ambassadors; God is making his appeal through us. We speak for Christ when we plead, ‘Come back to God!’”
2. The Message for This Approach Must Be Grace-Based, Not Performance-Based.
Teenagers today are under huge pressures to perform for acceptance. From school, to sports, to relationships, they are used to having to do well before they can excel. It’s with this as a backdrop that I cringed a bit when I read the words you wrote about the gospel we present to teenagers: “The idea of ‘trust and obey’ is usually packaged together, thus making saving faith conditional on obedience” (italics added).
This assertion unintentionally opens the door to a performance-based approach to Christianity as opposed to the grace-based approach that sets Christianity apart from every other religion.
For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God—not by works, so that no one can boast. (Eph. 2:8–9)
However, to the one who does not work but trusts God who justifies the ungodly, their faith is credited as righteousness. (Rom. 4:5)
He saved us, not because of righteous things we had done, but because of his mercy. He saved us through the washing of rebirth and renewal by the Holy Spirit. (Titus 3:5)
In one of my favorite books, The Grace Awakening, Chuck Swindoll writes these powerful words.
I can tell you that as a sinner you need to have a stronger commitment to Christ demonstrated by the work you do in His behalf, before you can say you truly believe. My problem in doing so is this: A sinner cannot commit to anything. He or she is spiritually dead, remember? There is no capacity for commitment in an unregenerate heart. Becoming an obedient, submissive disciple of Christ follows believing in Christ. Works follow faith. Behavior follows belief. Fruit comes after the tree is well-rooted.[2]
Philip Yancey shares some profound words in What’s So Amazing about Grace? “The world runs by ungrace. Everything depends on what I do. I have to make the shot. Jesus’s kingdom calls us to another way, one that depends on not our performance but his own. We do not have to achieve but merely follow. He has already earned for us the costly victory of God’s acceptance.”[3]
Adding fine print to God’s free gift of grace is not only dangerous theologically (Gal. 1:8) but potentially damaging to teenagers psychologically, because it introduces them to a Christian version of religious performance-ism instead of the shocking, beautiful, and amazing message of God’s grace.
This psychological damage was something I experienced personally as a teenager. The same church that reached my entire family with the good news of Jesus, and was so clear on the subject of salvation being a free gift of God’s grace through faith alone, had a long legalistic list of “do’s,” “stops,” and “starts” when it came to spiritual growth. This list became a frustrating replacement for a grace-based, Spirit-empowered approach.
This same church that transformed my entire family as a result of preaching justification by faith alone messed me (and a bunch of my teenage peers) up by preaching a sanctification of performance. I meet casualties of this mind-set to this day everywhere I go.
No, we are saved by grace and we grow by grace. And our obedience to Jesus is the exciting result of salvation, not the joy-quenching requirement for one to receive it.
The performance-based youth ministry has a checklist of things you must do in addition to trusting in Jesus to be saved. The grace-based youth ministry invites teenagers to receive the free gift of salvation by faith alone in Christ alone and then challenges them to live in radical obedience as a joyful response to this amazing gift.
Which kind of family would you rather be adopted into? I choose grace! And, Chap, I’m sure you do too!
3. The Mentors in This Approach Must Be Missional, Not Traditional.
Getting teenagers plugged into a church community is only a long-term solution if that community is both deep and wide. If the adults in that church family are not modeling the life of Christ (deep) and sharing the message of Jesus (wide), then all we have done with our teenagers is perpetuate another church-going narcissist who fills in blanks in sermon outlines, participates in meetings, and gives 10 percent of their income to God.
Traditionally, adults in the church don’t have a kingdom-advancing focus. There’s a natural propensity for church to become a comfortable, inwardly focused “social” hub, to the point that many adult Christians today have virtually no social relationships with nonbelievers. Yet how can we lovingly and relationally advance the gospel and plead with the lost on Christ’s behalf when we don’t know anyone who’s lost?
To a significant extent, I believe the church’s lack of missional focus is a major contributor to why young people are leaving the church—because it’s become largely irrelevant in the world they inhabit.
But God calls all of us to more.
I’m convinced that our young people are our best hope for leading the way back to the early church’s radical, revolutionary, world-transforming model of ministry. In You Lost Me, David Kinnaman notes that young people “are desperate for a new way to understand and experience the worthy risks of following Christ. Life without some sense of urgency—a life that is safe, incubated, insular, overprotected, consumptive—is not worth living. The next generation is aching for influence, for significance, for lives of meaning and impact . . . yet we have done all we can to lower the stakes for the newest real-life protagonists in God’s grand, risky story.”[4]
If the mentors in this adoptive approach to youth ministry are not seeking to model this missional lifestyle, then the family we are adopting them into is dysfunctional. And a dysfunctional spiritual family can be as damaging as a dysfunctional human family.
Of course, this doesn’t mean that the mentors must be perfect at advancing God’s kingdom forward. They just must authentically seek to attempt this way of living. Even if these mentors are “failing forward,” teenagers will learn just as much from their honesty, failures, and frustrations as they will from their evangelistic successes.
We need to nurture the energy, passion, longing, idealism, and cause-focused drive of our young people to help call the church back to its mission. We need to mobilize them to inject a Gospel Advancing mindset into the adults in our lukewarm churches, transforming them from comfortable “social gatherings” into healthy, missional lighthouses that actively, intentionally, and continually reach out to the lost and hurting.
Chap, overall, this chapter on adoptive youth ministry is spot-on. It put words to something I have subconsciously felt for a long time, and I will be using many of your points as I train youth leaders across the nation. Thank you.
Without question, Chap, you have given us a gift with your chapter on youth ministry as adoption into the family of faith. Thank you. I learned a lot, especially about current sociological trends, the historical development of youth ministry, and the precise failure of the church in building lasting, nurturing, and family-modeled relationships with teenagers. For the sake of organizing my response to your position, I’d like to offer what I see as some very positive aspects of your chapter and then some areas of disagreement and constructive criticism.
Positives of the Adoption View
You describe well the typical story of church-going youth who end up leaving the church after high school. Unfortunately, this is the new normal for teenagers today, and you plot their journey as most reading this book would see it today. I’ve personally observed this “journey” for a number of teenagers, and it breaks my heart.
I also appreciate the historical and theological overview of how modern youth ministry began. Throughout its relatively brief history, the core of youth ministry has remained a “relational investment” (as you put it) of a concerned adult into teenagers’ lives. However, in this type of relationship, it segregates the youth from the greater family—they are treated merely as a group of individuals rather than the biblical “body” of Christ and the “family” of God. Thus, as you rightly argue, we should not perpetuate a “gospel of individualistic faith.” In some ways, what we see happening in the church is paradigmatic of the hyperindividualistic society at large.
I love your biblical exposition of the metaphors used of the church, namely, (1) being a body with many members functioning together, serving together, and using the gifts that God has given for the building up of the body; and (2) adoption into the family of God through faith. I like that you continue to use the image of a “family of families” to describe the church.
Thank you for making this careful distinction that even well-intentioned terms like “community” and “fellowship” pale in comparison to the idea of a family. The idea of the “family” naturally assumes commitment and the well-being of the other. What are the implications of church as family? They must know one another, forgive one another, care for one another, love one another, serve one another, and so on. These couldn’t be more right on.
Finally, your analysis that most youth today think of Christian “community” as a weekly or biweekly meeting—thus rendering them as merely an observer in a program that others plan and execute—is a brilliant insight. I can see this perception all around my ministry circles. Youth ministry should move beyond a mere “private” or “personal” journey of faith. Indeed, if it doesn’t, both the journey and the faith seem to evaporate. Adults of all ages should come alongside to adopt teenagers into this family as a “mentoring community,” as you put it. Very well said.
My Concerns with the Adoption View
While I certainly do appreciate certain elements of your position as seen in your chapter, I ultimately find it lacking for the following reasons.
1. Where’s God in the salvation, development, and sanctification of youth? The family of faith is very important, but how should we understand God’s design and active role in this model? I just didn’t see an emphasis on God. You point out his design of the church as a family and body of Christ, but what about his ongoing work in that family? This one element has a huge implication on how we are to understand youth ministry (as I’ll point out below).
2. You state, “I contend that the primary reason we have lost so many of the hearts and investment of our young when they leave the confines of the high school routine is that we have failed to provide them with the most vital resource they possessed in Christ: the God-given faith community.” Similarly, you argue, “Youth ministry, and the church itself, has effectively removed the primary resource that God has given his people for living the life to which we are called—each other.” My question is simply this: Are other Christians the primary resource God has given his people to grow and mature in the faith? I think not.
While I agree that the family of God—the local church—is one of the means that God uses to grow his people, the primary means (as I see it) by which he sanctifies them is his Word, as Jesus contends (John 17:17). We must remember that the gospel is the power of God for salvation (Rom. 1:16), not people. It’s nice to have adults “love on” and “invest in” the lives of teenagers, but this falls flat apart from the whole counsel of God. Thus, I would argue that your “reason” why so many have wandered from the faith would be a secondary reason, not a primary one (even if you have sociological data to back it up).
3. You say that the “first and constant step of faith is to ‘love one another.’” While we are certainly called to love one another, this is but the second greatest commandment. Again, where is the love and affection for God? We shouldn’t miss the first and greatest commandment: to love God! Would the love for God, because he first loved us, not ultimately be “the first and constant step of faith”? Our love for one another would be a natural outworking of our love for God and his love for us.
4. Thus, to be rather blunt, I see your model as incomplete and unbalanced. The church as family is one of the several means of grace that God has given us to grow and mature—at any age or life stage. Thus, I must disagree when you argue that “the goal of youth ministry must shift away from segmenting young people off from everyone else to offering them a mutual, empowering, engaging, and supportive new family.” Rather, I see the goal of youth ministry as glorifying God by planting and watering the gospel through the means that God has already provided: his Word, prayer, sacrament, worship, service, and gospel community. Your model simply takes this last element as the foundation without giving balance to the others.
5. You say, with reference to the fall, “The consequential loneliness and isolation are the essence of the fallen human condition.” What about sin? Certainly our sin has something to do with the fallen human condition. It is our sin that has led to our feeling lonely and isolated, not the other way around.
6. It would have helped to have a few more examples on how to “adopt” teens into family of the church. In other words, explain what it looks like for a youth worker to be a “bridge” into this family. You give a couple of quick examples, but it was still difficult to visualize this in an actual youth ministry context.
7. You talk about our “response” to the gospel call, our faith, and our obedience—and you even cite Louis Berkhof (love it!). But we must remember that all of this is from God. We were dead in sin (Eph. 2:1), not seeking God (Rom. 3:11), and unable to please him (Heb. 11:6). By his grace alone, he has removed our hearts of stone and given us hearts to believe. Surely this must be emphasized in a discussion on the doctrine of salvation, even as presented in your chapter. What I keep coming back to, Chap, is a more active role of God in youths’ lives. Where is the emphasis on his grace, his holiness, his righteousness, and his glory in youth ministry? I would categorize your model not as God-centered but as people-centered.
8. I think your entire push might be the exception to the rule of parents being specifically called and, therefore, specifically responsible to raise their children in the discipline and instruction of the Lord (cf. Eph. 6:4). If youth don’t have Christian parents, then your model kicks into full gear. I typically tell people that we must continue to state the principle, even if there are a thousand “exceptions” to the rule.
Yes, older men should mentor younger men and older women should mentor younger women (cf. Titus 2, which you might have overlooked). However, the primary responsibility of a youth’s discipleship and growth in the community of faith is his or her parents. Other concerned adults should come alongside, but your position needs to make a much more concentrated focus on the role of parents. Again, if no Christian parents are to be found, then “adopting” them would become absolutely necessary.
Chap’s introductory story reflects the honest reality of many Christian teens—they were on fire for the Lord during adolescence and eventually disconnected from the church later. This is a common narrative throughout all denominations and traditions. And his thesis is correct when he writes, “I contend that the primary reason we have lost so many of the hearts and investment of our young when they leave the confines of the high school routine is that we have failed to provide them with the most vital resource they possessed in Christ: the God-given faith community.”
It is sadly ironic that teens who have been nurtured in the faith within a church community would leave it and possibly not return to it in later years. This leads to a second irony—is it possible that parachurch ministries, a youth ministry pillar, may actually have contributed to the demise of the eventual teen-church connection?
The first part of Chap’s chapter provides a helpful snapshot on the history of youth ministry. What this highlights, in addition to demonstrating the dedication and passion of many parachurch ministry founders and leaders, is that many of these were (and perhaps remain) insufficient in keeping teens connected with the church. One wonders, after all these years, whether these ministries, although important, would change their paradigm to reflect a more intentional connection with and toward churches rather than separate from them. This leads to the concern Chap raises that perhaps one-on-one evangelizing and discipling alone may ultimately lead to an individualized faith separate from the church community.
The “body of Christ” metaphor seems to be used today with more regularity than the “family of God.” I wonder why. Is it perhaps that families are not as intact as they once were? Perhaps the diversity of the contemporary family unit may require a reenvisioning of what it has traditionally meant to be a “family of God”? Jesus’s words in Matthew 12:48–50 are challenging ones indeed, for he underscores that the “family of God” is bigger, broader, and greater than blood relatives. Hence, Chap’s recommendation for the “adoption” metaphor for ministry is apt. Not only is it a Pauline metaphor, but it seems to take into account the reality of contemporary diversity and the modern family. Not only is it appropriate theologically, but it is appropriate sociologically. Relationally, this also allows space for teens (and all of us) to experience an ecclesiological adoption option for those who do not feel connected with a local congregation. The arms of God are stretched wider and embrace more families than our often-myopic familial/denominational/traditional presumptions.
Chap also challenges our presumptions of “community.” This is very important. We all use this term, but how do we understand it, particularly within the context of youth ministry? What do we mean by community? How broad and inclusive is our understanding of community? And does our community actually perpetuate an exclusivity that pushes teens further from the church, especially as they get older and reflect on their youth ministry experiences?
This is not unlike the “All Are Welcome” signs in front of churches where all are not really welcome. Teens are often expected to join the congregational parade where all walk in unison. So, yes, this is a community, but is this a community that expands the kingdom of God, or moves teens closer to Christ, or moves them toward justice and mercy? Or does it move them out of the church and nurture a pseudo-community marked by judgmentalism and limitations, where the saints are welcomed and sinners are dismissed? Being in community is both comforting and very difficult, as Dietrich Bonhoeffer affirms.
Let him who cannot be alone beware of community. . . . Let him who is not in community beware of being alone. . . . Each by itself has profound perils and pitfalls. One who wants fellowship without solitude plunges into the void of words and feelings, and the one who seeks solitude without fellowship perishes in the abyss of vanity, self-infatuation and despair.[5]
In this rapidly mobile society, perhaps the expectation of teens returning to their “home” congregation may be an unrealistic and nostalgic notion. This does not mean, however, that teens-turned-adults may not have nurtured the spirit of Christian community in their hearts. Perhaps this is a lesson for youth ministers—it is a greater good to have teens return and join a church community rather than to expect teens to return to the community of their adolescence. In other words, adoption by God supersedes attendance at a specific congregation—maybe even (dare I say it) beyond a specific denomination.
Chap’s development of moving from assent to obedience and submission is helpful indeed. It is also very, very difficult. To affirm a christological concept is one thing; to submit to it is something totally different. “The idea of ‘trust and obey’ is usually packaged together, thus making saving faith conditional on obedience,” he writes. I agree with him. This is why I am also grateful for God’s grace, for I frequently fail to obey and submit. As Bonhoeffer also poignantly and directly explains,
It may be that Christians, notwithstanding corporate worship, common prayer, and all their fellowship in service, may still be left to their loneliness. The final break-through to fellowship does not occur, because, though they have fellowship with one another as believers and as devout people, they do not have fellowship as the undevout, as sinners. The pious fellowship permits no one to be a sinner. So everybody must conceal his sin from himself and from the fellowship. We dare not be sinners. Many Christians are unthinkably horrified when a real sinner is suddenly discovered among the righteous. So we remain alone with our sin, living in lies and hypocrisy. The fact is that we are sinners![6]
This too is a message that teens need to hear—that we all need to hear. As the man said to Jesus, “I believe; help my unbelief!” (Mark 9:24 ESV). For me, the theology of adoption is also a way of exclaiming that you are welcome, even with your doubts, unbelief, and questioning. Bringing your heart and honest search for God in Christ is welcome in the beloved community.
“Adoption guides” is a helpful term and visual. Ultimately, the youth ministry leadership must undergo an inner paradigm shift for the program shift to occur. Chap states that youth ministry requires a team of adult leaders, a helpful reminder for youth leaders who may tend to separate youth ministry from the larger church. Separation not only causes teens to miss out in nurturing healthy relationships with adults, but it also places unnecessary burdens on the youth ministry leadership. It also allows for a broader contribution of ideas and, pragmatically speaking, creates a greater menu of programmatic options.
What I appreciate most about the adoption model is that it is thoughtful, reasonable, and honest. It presents a traditional theological concept in a different light. It recognizes the challenges of keeping teens connected with the church. It invites us to examine historical cycles (both in our local churches and in the youth ministry field) and suggests a perspective that encourages not only teen-church connection, but teen-God connection.
Chap’s work with Kara Powell in the Sticky Faith project brought significant insight to the youth ministry world. Both he and Kara have dedicated their lives to helping build lifelong faith into kids. What a privilege to share in this Youth Ministry in the 21st Century project with you! As I read your chapter, Chap, I could not help but ask the all-important question—why did you not publish your section as a standalone book? This material was academically researched, thoughtfully written, and can be practically applied. The section begins with a case study that could represent the typical participants of any youth group. A constant build toward the thesis of the chapter gives the reader some rich and insightful looks at the history of youth ministry while hinting at how the experiment derailed along the way. A person should buy this book if only for Chap’s taxonomy and history of youth ministry.
Chap lists three statements made by Benson and Senter from 1987, and youth ministers sometimes take their cues from their first two statements: “Youth ministry begins when adults find a comfortable method of entering a student’s world” in order to “draw the students into a maturing relationship with God through Jesus Christ.” But I believe that guiding statements might be more effective and biblical if the word “parent” replaced or accompanied the word “adults.”
While Benson, Senter, and Chap are not saying the goal stops at entering a student’s world, I offer a word of caution for anyone reaching the youth with Christ without drawing youth to Christ. Youth pastors and parents should be concerned if the goal stops at “entering the student’s world” even if the goal is to reach them where they are with the gospel. One can and should see the fallacy of entering or moving to where the lost person is and residing there, even as a believer. Jesus went to people to call people out of where they were. The goal should be to enter the student’s world to draw the student to the body of Christ. Later in the chapter, Chap makes it clear that adoption draws the student in service and heart to the community of the church in ways that serve Christ. Thank you for starting with a carefully worded goal (Benson and Senter’s) and continuing to build on it to make it better. Chap, you have a pleasant tendency to argue a point, creating desire on the reader’s part to ask a specific question, which you immediately provide the answer for.
This chapter provides a clear, distinct goal of youth ministry, which is that every child, every adolescent, and every young adult be adopted into and embraced by the community of faith so that they may always have a home, a people, and a place where they can discover who they are and how they are able to contribute. The adoption of young people into the family of God may sound simple, but it will take some breaking of routines and changing of attitudes, not to mention a healthy number of involved adults. The effort to achieve adoption is worthwhile, and time will show the value of changing the orientation of youth ministry efforts.
Chap’s section certainly reinforces the idea of adoption. He shows how the student cannot rely on the group for an individual relationship with God. But the young person likewise cannot pursue discipleship and the development of gifts on his or her own. Then he points out how the student’s growth in discipleship cannot be all about the student or left exclusively as the student’s responsibility. The need exists for the community of the church to adopt the teenagers into a loving and developing environment. People normally operate and function within a community. Christ paints the picture of both the body of Christ and the family of God, and Chap makes this a clear call to work within the wider church group and be less concerned with labels or even denominations. This community described by Chap as a “family of families” provides accountability, love, acceptance, affirmation, and service in affirming and loving ways. This adoption includes all ages and all parts of the church.
Chap identifies how the youth ministry that functions as a separate population of the church programmatically operates opposite of how a family should. Chap makes several valid points regarding the youth not existing in isolation within the church. Chap says, “For years the young were not only seen as a separate population but have been programmatically arranged to maintain and even reinforce that separation,” and “this population rarely experiences their relationship with the dominant population of the church, or society at large, as being something to which they belong.” As Chap describes the church as a network of family relationships, he calls for the interaction among the whole family. The perpetuation of isolating youth from a normal social framework that includes adults, according to Elkind and Arnett (both cited by Chap), fashions a protracted path to adulthood.
The section on the historical backdrop, or why we are where we are, talks about youth ministry as an experiment. This apt term describes how various leaders in the 1970s and ’80s theorized, practiced, and led seminars about the experience. The people writing and speaking on the topic garnered large crowds of emerging youth leaders who similarly wanted to grow their youth ministry. Youth leaders should ask, “Am I growing a youth ministry, or am I growing youth within a youth ministry?” The problem with this experiment in the earlier days of youth ministry is that those who wrote the theory of how it should be done were not fully objective. Consumer Reports brings credibility by not selling what they advocate. Youth Specialties and Group, both operating within the early years of the experiment, provided solutions to youth ministries, and, like any of us publishers, they bragged about their products as the cure to the problem. A true experiment documents the failures of certain interventions until the numbers bear out the success of the correct intervention. Who could have been objective during this time? Seminary professors, youth pastors not promoting a book, or someone else? It can be problematic when the publishing world releases books about various ministry solutions with short-success track records. Advocating unproven theories and approaches with only short-term successes may produce unintended consequences.
Youth ministry has focused on the committed teenagers and how their faith can grow. Efforts to nurture growth tend to focus on performance goals like looks, conversation, behaviors, and attitudes. Chap follows this up with a long list of popular writings about actionable ways to grow a teen’s faith, such as praying regularly, reading the Bible daily, investing in social issues, and using talents in ministry. Chap insightfully points out how the list fails to get to some heart-related issues. He suggests the need for experiencing the fullness of God without filling in the blanks, but, while an exhaustive list is not possible, he stopped short of naming more practices, such as apologetics, discipleship, and processing all decisions within a biblical worldview.
Chap, I looked for you to provide a clear definition for the word “discipleship.” You discussed how others use it and provided a critique. I would like to have seen you present at least a paragraph describing a biblically healthy, long-term discipleship apart from the functional terms of adoption. You likewise introduce a new term, “post-Christian,” and leave the reader hanging as to the intended usage of this word. Do you intend a left-leaning Christian worldview? You do, however, leave nothing to chance for the reader to grasp the words “community,” “fellowship,” “relationships,” “collaboration,” “assembly,” ekklēsia, “church,” and “family,” which allows for the adoption of youth into this larger body—Christ’s body. You emphasize a word powerfully with only italics, one that I hope readers do not overlook—you say, “The second aspect of living together as the body of Christ is that we are thereby intrinsically connected one to another, without regard to gifts, function, power, status, or age.”
Chap’s goal for adoption provides a solution for disenfranchised young adults who left high school and allowed life to swallow up their time without including a relationship with God. To be clear, the adoption approach is a viable solution along with other possibilities, some found in this book and others being accomplished by youth ministries today. The case study Chap used to launch the chapter shows the young adults placing emphasis on careers, being distracted by other things, or being loosely attached to the church community. Each of these separate issues points back to a flawed value system or lack of a Christian worldview.
The subsection about the family as a biblical metaphor should be required reading prior to the ordination of any minister. It is in this section, Chap, that you show the framework God established in both the Old and New Testaments, whereby he desired the family to be the platform for youth and children to love God and grow in their faith. Our chapters complement each other in ways that could easily be woven together for practical teaching and application. The idea of family or adoption is not an experiment but a principle commanded by God to perpetuate a faith legacy.
Close to the end of your section, Chap, you make this statement: “It wasn’t that the young left the church; the church left the young.” The alienation induced by the church coexisted with the desire to be separate from what the adults were doing. It could be argued that this estrangement occurred because adults did not wish to worship with their sons and daughters’ style of worship. A little relinquishing of one’s comfort could embrace the spiritual growth of one’s child. I would rather be slightly uncomfortable with my child dedicated and following Christ than comfortable in a staunch position that infers that if they can’t worship and read the Bible the way I do, they should go to hell. While no parent would ever say that out loud, I have witnessed parents who through their traditionalism and performance mentality live out that very position. The truth is, the adults willingly let the youth find their own place just far enough away from the adult congregation to not lose control. I would submit that this dysfunctional relationship enables a mutual separation of the youth and adults.
The adoption model works well as long as the worldview of the parent and the teen has been shaped toward this idea. A gap that catches many of our teenagers is the move to college. Teens, if they look for a church, will often look for one like the one back home. Even if the home church of the teen perfectly practices adoption, what happens when that young person moves away or goes off to college? They lose this community. The teen will have to find a new church that practices the adoption process and be able to feel the assimilation potential. However, if the teen has a D6 parent, the parent is always there to coach or consult with him or her regardless of geographical location or church orientation.
If the church functions as a family of families, the goal should be to strengthen the families, not just the youth. Chap, you rightly acknowledge this chapter could address the plight of anyone who feels disconnected from the body—young adults, senior adults, adults, and others. If you wrote a completely new book with each chapter focused on a separate age and asked each to practice adoption, the challenge of a community goal may be in continually focusing on addressing the needs of the siloed age groupings rather than the unit of the family as a whole. The family needs to function as a community if the church should function as a community. Why then should we teach independent ministry focus when familial interdependence is required?
Adoption, by its very nature, accepts a child exactly where he or she is and lovingly brings him or her into the family until, over time, the child not only bears the name but embodies the identity of the family. God the Father adopted us with all of our messiness. He patiently develops us and continues the process with love, righteousness, and lots of grace. Then God hears our voice, uses our gifts, and affirms our standing not because he needs us but because he loves us. What a model for us to use in his family of families.
Before I respond to your helpful and honest comments to my article on adoption ministry as the theological grounding for any programmatic ministry, I want to first express my sincere gratitude. In general, this kind of process is always a bit frightening, for who seeks to invite public disagreement or critique? Yet each of you has been thoughtful and kind, even in those places and with those issues that you felt I could use some sharpening. These responses have been a gift.
I also want to thank each of you for the affirming and kind comments you made in your responses. It goes without saying that when a colleague makes mention in a positive way of something we have poured our hearts into, there is a deep sense of gratitude. I will specifically thank each of you for these comments personally, but for this final response I feel it is better to cut straight to the areas and issues where you either disagreed or offered me a nuance, caution, or question.
Greg mentioned that he and I have, over the years, had a more or less running clash of perspectives on certain aspects of youth ministry. One of the greatest joys of doing this project together was to have the chance, for all to see, to lay out where the Lord has led us in our vision and thinking side by side. We’ve also had a long-standing, albeit somewhat distant, deep respect and appreciation for one another. Both of these came out in our responses to each other. We still have deeply held convictions that are not completely in sync, as is evident, but we are, as we both suspected we would be if we gave ourselves the chance, very, very close in both history and outlook.
I so appreciate your reminder, Greg, that mission must be external and not internal. I am completely with you on this. But the route to get there, it seems to me, especially in a culture of abandonment and generational segmentation, needs to begin with an internal missional emphasis in order for us to be a healthy, unified vessel useful for the external mission of God. John 13–17 says very little about the external mission of the church but a great deal about our relationships with one another. If we fail to get our own internal “family” house in order, we have very little to offer the world as “sent ones” (John 20:21) who are called to be salt and light.
I am not sure that we actually disagree on your point regarding grace. I also understand the gospel to be firmly resting on God’s mercy and grace, and therefore our response is simply to trust (pisteuō) in personified grace, Jesus Christ. This is the “work” God has for us (John 6:28–30; see also Gal. 5:1–6). Trust that is not expressed, or fleshed out, in a response of obedience, however, is not biblical faith. You cite Phil Yancey’s What’s So Amazing about Grace? (a book he wrote and freely talked through while we were in a small group together) to stress the central importance of grace, and I agree with both of you on this point. When you quote him saying, “We do not have to achieve but merely follow,” he is saying what I attempted to say, that is, that our obedience is simply our “following” Jesus.
Last, your comment that mentors must be missional is a crucial element to the adoptive model. Without people who are both inwardly and externally missional, there is a theological disconnect and therefore brokenness in our life together. I agree. For the adoption view to have any impact not only in the lives of our kids but in us as well, people must be committed to how God has called us to live, both together and in our mission in the world that God loves.
Brian, to your thoughts, my initial response was simply “Wow!” Your list of eight areas of concern or disagreement was thorough, well stated, and fairly comprehensive (and I had no idea in seven thousand words I could elicit this much depth of response and conversation!). But in response to you, I will try and go point by point in bite-sized chunks, listing your point number alongside my response, trusting that this will not be our last shot at dialogue.
“Where is God?” (1) Great question, related as well to your question regarding the “greatest command” (3). Without the ability to really go after this here, I fall to Jesus and Paul. Jesus does affirm that to “love God” is “the first and greatest commandment” (Matt. 22:37–38). He then says, as you well know, that “the second is like it,” and “all the Law and the Prophets hang on these two commandments” (22:39–40). I can see how my view can look “people centered” (7) on the surface, and I wish I had somehow addressed this concern more up front. Yet, in addition to Jesus’s equating how we treat others as “being like” how we love God, throughout Paul’s letters he consistently calls Christ-followers to love one another as they live out their love for God. In Philippians 2, for example, he admonishes his flock to be “like-minded, having the same love, being one in spirit and of one mind” (v. 2). This may sound “people centered,” but the Scriptures are consistent in the message that love for God is expressed in how authentically we love one another (1 John 4:20) and also the world (“Who is my neighbor?” Luke 10:29). By the way, you also made a good catch when you challenged my statement “the primary means by which God” (2). Before you wrote your response, I had already changed it to “a primary means by which God.” Well done.
As you see in my chapter, I have no problem with the goal of youth ministry being to nurture the faith of the young (4). Where I do think I would like more conversation is how we do that with a population that is, by definition, in transition, in need of relational and emotional nurture, and who also does not readily receive adult leadership and teaching without first seeing how trustworthy that adult is. Discipleship is a lifelong process, and to take development seriously we must first embrace, encourage, listen to, and empower our young within appropriate developmental realities before we expect them to meaningfully respond to the “means of grace” in an adult-like way. Similarly, as to your comment regarding sin (5)—“our sin has led to our feeling lonely and isolated”—I agree. Yet the consequence of our sin, regardless, is this experience. That was my point. Yes, regardless of the theological tradition, human sin has consequences, and one of them is being, and therefore feeling, isolated.
Last, you wonder how we can actually pull the adoption model off (6) as you go back to Deuteronomy 6, affirming that “the primary responsibility” for discipleship of children is their parents (8; see my comments for Ron’s D6 view on this). Ron, you also make this a staple argument (and, as an aside, I didn’t quite “overlook” Titus 2; I simply chose not to use it, for lots of reasons I won’t go into here). As much as I believe that parents who are sincerely walking with Christ are an important and often an effective discipling force and presence—and currently, from all indications, by far the most potent (see my and Kara Powell’s comments on this in Sticky Faith)—I believe that particular text (Deut. 6), in light of the entire Scripture, is not meant to say that parents are “primary.” Even the best parents fail, are inconsistent, and are wholly insecure when it comes to simply parenting, much less discipling, their kids today. The best parents need the church as their family to grow as followers of Christ, and so do their kids! As a father of three, I am so grateful for those Christian friends who poured into our kids’ lives in partnership with us.
Fred, given your history and current work with college students, you have a unique take on how difficult the road from high school to adulthood is for so many. That you see the adoption model of ministry as both theological as well as sociological brings an added dimension to the need for the church to reinvest in our young in intimate familial relationships. With all the various expressions of family in today’s society, and with even the best of these needing all the help they can get, your conviction regarding our role in the community of faith to be the refuge for all members is essential.
I agree with you, as well, that the move from trust to obedience and submission is difficult for all of us, especially if our relationships are not authentic and safe. For decades youth ministry has been based on a simple foundation: an adult committed to coming alongside a young person so that he or she has the opportunity to encounter and follow the living God in the person of the risen Jesus Christ. As Youth Specialties’ Mike Yaconelli used to relentlessly hammer into us all, “Youth ministry is about Jesus and kids. That’s it. That’s all it is.” But this approach has also been allowed to be reduced to one adult and one kid, whether a small group leader, a mentor, or a youth pastor who cares for “each one.” Yes, at its most basic level, I believe youth ministry is as simple as Jesus and our young. But that does not excuse subjugating our young to thinking that their faith is up to them, that in the final analysis God expects them to go it alone, even with a mentor to help along the way. “This is my command: Love one another.” Youth ministry is inviting our young into the calling, life, and work of the kingdom as members of the family of God. That’s the essence and point of the adoption model of ministry.

Greg Stier