Chapter 13 of 18

Fernando Arzola’s Response

Fernando Arzola’s Response

Responses to the Ecclesial View

images Greg Stier

While I believe that reconnecting Christian teenagers to the four characteristic of the church as “one, holy, catholic, and apostolic” is a worthy goal, it is only part of the solution.

Yes, teenagers need to know they are part of a two-thousand-year-old mighty river of reformers and transformers. Yes, they need to understand and embrace the founding creeds and elemental orthodoxy based in the Bible and forged over countless centuries. Teenagers who have a connection to the church (both here and now, as well as there and then) rise up from the myopic “Jesus is my Santa Claus” philosophy of Americanized, individualistic Christianity that Fernando rightfully disparages.

If these worthy subjects are what drive a particular youth ministry program, the four attending teenagers will have a great time. Seriously, if the subject of ancient creeds and pre-Reformation ecclesiology dominates the discussion, then it will no longer be a discussion, but a monologue in a mostly empty youth room.

What made the true ancient church (the one in the book of Acts) exciting was not their commitment to developing, dissecting, and distributing creeds but their commitment to advance the gospel of Jesus Christ among their own members and also outwardly into their communities. Prayer fueled it, communion reemphasized it, teaching solidified it, fellowship rekindled it, and creed clarified and protected it.

The early believers had a connection with their history. After all, the New Testament is built on the Old Testament! But their connection to the past served to advance the gospel and deepen discipleship.

When this connection to the past becomes the point, then it misses the point. When one becomes overly obsessed with creeds and confessions rather than Christ and his cause, then what was meant to bring stability and depth can become an idol that distracts us from our Savior.

I couldn’t agree more that we should “rely on the wisdom of the traditions of the historic church, especially of the early church”! Jesus’s call to his followers to “Come, follow me . . . and I will send you out to fish for people” (Matt. 4:19) and Luke’s recounting of the spiritual wildfire that spread through the book of Acts serve as our primers.

Nothing comes through clearer in the book of Acts than the Spirit-controlled, Gospel Advancing, life-transforming, unstoppable, missional impact of the early church. Was the early church perfect in holiness, unity, and theological purity? Certainly not—Paul’s epistles testify to several cases of rampant sin on the loose or theological confusion in the ranks of several local church bodies. These early heresies forced the apostles to clarify their theology and start building their creeds. But their creeds were developed in the midst of launching and deepening a mission movement (Acts 15:1–33), not for the sake of just building a creed.

Jesus’s missional call to advance the gospel echoes through the centuries and unites our students with Christians through the millennia who sacrificed all for the sake of Christ. Yes, we must connect them with a greater sense of the holy, catholic church, but we must engage them with Christ and his cause as we do!

images Brian Cosby

Fernando, as one who loves the significance of the local and universal church as well as its history, I really appreciated your insights and perspective. It was a breath of fresh air to read something that was appreciative of Christian heritage. For the sake of organizing my response to your position, I’d like to offer what I see as some very positive aspects of your chapter and then some areas of disagreement and constructive criticism.

Positives of the Ecclesial View

I really appreciated your research and source provision. It helped me glean a variety of perspectives on the doctrine of the church as well as its impact on a youth ministry context.

Thank you for calling out the problem of pragmatism inherited from the Enlightenment. The question shouldn’t be, as you comment, “What’s most effective?” Youth ministries shouldn’t take part in the ministry success game. This leads to an unhealthy focus on the three “B’s”: buildings, bodies, and budgets. This also leads youth pastors into one of two dead ends: pride (look how many I saved/got to come to youth group!) or despair (nobody came to my meeting . . . and nobody will come next week either). We should strive for ministry faithfulness rather than success. Besides, it’s God who provides the growth anyway (1 Cor. 3:7)!

Thank you too for pointing out the problem of modern individualism that plagues the American church today. As you note, this has led to practically a complete lack of awareness of and appreciation for those who have gone before us. The great cloud of witnesses and the “hall of faith” that the writer of Hebrews presents should at least make us consider the importance of the communion of saints down through the ages and our place in that line. Our extreme individualism is, as Timothy George has called it, an imperialism of the present—where our narcissism and hubris is on open display. Certainly this cannot fit within a biblical model of youth ministry.

I also agree that youth ministers need to teach the history of the church rather than the seven keys to your best life now or how to claim health, wealth, and prosperity. In my book God’s Story: A Student’s Guide to Church History (Christian Focus, 2014), I outline this precise need to recover a historical perspective on the Christian church—yes, even from the prophets and apostles of old!

Thank you for pointing out the importance of the reality of the visible church. When we look through the pages of the New Testament, we see that there is order, structure, church discipline, church officers, and so on. There are church rolls and those who belong to the church at such and such place. This visible church is extended in thousands of bodies throughout the world as the visible church universal. Thank you for calling us to the ancient roots of the church, built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets, who—under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit—presented a faith that was once and for all delivered to the saints (Jude 3).

Finally, I love your remarks about the holiness of the church as an identity marker, though not to the exclusion of individual moral holiness. We tend to focus all of our attention on the latter, without much thought to the former. But both are needed and important, so thank you.

My Concerns with the Ecclesial View

1. I would hold Donald Bloesch as “Reformed” somewhat loosely. He had a Reformed background and Reformed leanings, but to associate him with Calvinism (as such) and orthodox Reformed theology as a representative of those traditions would be going a bit too far, even if he is often labeled with “neo-orthodoxy.” The problem, historically speaking, lies in Bloesch’s own definition of Reformed, which he borrowed from Karl Barth. Barth, for his part, would hardly fit modern evangelical Reformed orthodoxy.

2. In your discussion on the insights of the three theologians from whom you glean, I found myself not really sure what your view was. I understood your position as being somewhat of a blend of the three. Is that correct? Your chapter has little to do with youth ministry. Youth ministry is part of the one, holy, apostolic, and universal church, so maybe the reader should see youth ministry simply as part of the whole. The goal of youth ministry, therefore, is for us to see ourselves as part of that church. Is that right? Ultimately, I don’t really see your position being a distinct youth ministry “model.” I see it as something to teach the youth, but I’m not sure how foundational this is to a unique methodology.

3. You state that during the Reformation, “Protestants turned away from the institutional church and turned toward the gospel.” This is not entirely accurate. Other than some who bought into what is called the Radical Reformation, most still held to some form of the church as institution. As an example, we see book 4 of Calvin’s Institutes as almost entirely concerned with this issue. Yes, they decried the abuses of the institutional (Roman Catholic) church and the errors of its theology and “worldliness,” but most still held to some institution of the church.

4. While I appreciate your call to unity in the church, we mustn’t forget that we are to have unity in the truth. You sort of point this out—that we shouldn’t opt for an “imposed” or forced unity—but in a culture where unity and tolerance are elevated, we need to be careful in distinguishing biblical unity from unity for unity’s sake. From my perspective, Fernando, there are several large, self-professing “Christian” denominations and organizations that have abandoned the core tenets of the gospel, thereby rendering them antithetical to Christ (cf. Gal. 1:9). The biblical writers would not envision “unity” or catholicity with these kinds of groups.

5. You note (in citing Ignatius) that, “Wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the catholic church.” But the Spirit of Christ is omnipresent—everywhere present. Indeed, this is one of God’s attributes. I understand the push toward the church being “incarnational,” but we need to better differentiate between divine omnipresence and the covenantal and salvific presence of Christ, which does reside in his holy and catholic church. Moreover, you reference his “real presence,” which is often attributed to Christ’s physical body and blood together with his spiritual presence (as seen in the doctrine of transubstantiation). But Jesus ascended on high and is physically in heaven. He has gone away to prepare a place for us and will come again (John 14:3). His divine Spirit, however, is “with you always, to the very end of the age” (Matt. 28:20). In this way, he will never leave you nor forsake you (Heb. 13:5). Thus, while God is everywhere present, he is “with us” (as our Immanuel) in the church in a covenantal and salvific way.

6. I would disagree with your threefold office of bishop, presbytery/priest, and deacon. In particular, I take issue with the distinction between bishop and elder. I understand, of course, the Greek distinction between bishop (episkopos) and elder (presbyteros), but they refer to the same office. For example, in Acts 20:17, Paul “called the elders [presbyterous] of the church to come to him” (ESV). He then said to them, “Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers [episkopous]” (v. 28 ESV). In Titus 1:5, Paul instructs Titus to “appoint elders [presbyterous] in every town” (ESV) and gives him qualifications. Why? “For an overseer [episkopon], as God’s steward, must be above reproach” (v. 7 ESV). Peter, too, equates the two. In 1 Peter 5:1–2, he exhorts “the elders [presbyterous]” to shepherd the flock by “exercising oversight [episkopountes]” (ESV). The two words simply describe two functions of the same office.

7. My final word of constructive criticism is that you offer very little biblical support for your approach to youth ministry. While the formal canon wasn’t organized as such until the early fourth century, this doesn’t negate the necessary centrality of the inspired text before then. Indeed, we have a faith that was once and for all delivered to the saints (Jude 3), recorded in the pages of Scripture. To persuasively demonstrate a unique and justifiable position on youth ministry, you need to present it from the Bible. Church history is wonderful—yes, even before the Reformation—but the church itself is built on the inspired testimony and instruction of the “apostles and prophets” (Eph. 2:20). While youth need to understand their heritage and history, God’s Word is the means of grace by which they are saved and sanctified.

images Chap Clark

In reading Fernando Arzola’s chapter on “reclaiming ecclesiology” I was reminded of how vital theological education and training is. For anyone venturing into a vocation of Christian service, regardless of the role, to build one’s life and ministry on solid, historical, and biblically orthodox theology is crucial. In an age where many are disparaging the time, energy, and cost of a degree, to prepare for and lead ministry—any ministry—without a solid knowledge of our history, foundational orthodoxy, and how the Scriptures as theologically interpreted across time have shaped who and where we are today is dangerous at best. Fred, you remind us, relying on some of the most significant thinkers of the last several decades, that we do not “do” youth ministry in a historical or theological vacuum. We instead stand on the shoulders of the men and women who have gone before us. We in youth ministry, who visit schools and parks and Starbucks, who plan and implement programs and events that engage the hearts, minds, and souls of young people, and who carry the high responsibility of representing Jesus Christ and the kingdom to emerging generations, have much to learn about the theological foundations of our task and calling.

Thank you, Dr. Arzola, for bringing us back into a much-needed look at youth ministry through the lens of theology and history, and for showing how we in youth ministry can find ourselves within God’s story since the beginning of all things.

As a practical theologian working in a seminary where we train, equip, counsel, and guide men and women for the manifold ministries of Christ and his church, I so deeply resonate with your focus on ecclesiology, or what you call “the nature and authority of the church.” I wonder whether any readers, in trying to get a more careful handle on the definition of “ecclesiology,” did what I did: went to their Mac “hourglass” in the upper-right-hand corner of the screen and typed in the word. When I did this, the first definition displayed on the Apple dictionary was this:

ecclesiology (noun) “the study of churches, esp. church building and decoration.”

Perhaps this is an example of the problem. For years the “study of the church,” as ecclesiology is typically labeled, has been extremely limited in its scope. It is no wonder that few seminary students, much less undergraduates, who study youth ministry are trained to see their calling firmly planted in the academic and liturgical bucket of “ecclesiology.” I know of no systematic theology course or instructor, scholarly article, or academic theological textbook that even hints at youth ministry as a vital application (there are certainly some out there, but I have yet to run across them). Yet this is precisely what you have done in this chapter.

In your relatively mild but fair critique of the present state of youth ministry practice, you note that youth ministry programs “tend to separate themselves from the host congregation” and that “the understanding of the church as the body of Christ has been replaced with the model of an effective corporation. . . . Youth ministries have adopted business models as their ecclesiological template.” I agree that when we build programs, hire staff, and spend money to approach a complex issue (like the perceived disinterest and distance of young people from the faith), we can easily slip into pragmatism driven by measurable outcomes (usually numbers) and superficial rubrics of success. Your critique of business models devoid of theological grounding (what you call “exegetical cleansing,” a line I rather appreciate) is also worthy of consideration. I, for one, greatly appreciate secular research that informs our exegetical orthodoxy and interpretive decisions, yet I also agree that when we hand the entire enterprise of mission—in this case, youth ministry—to the philosophical and pragmatic trappings of the world, we are in danger of using the Bible to justify our convictions, structures, and strategies.

One of the most poignant points you make, which obviously resonates with my view as expressed in the adoptive model of ministry, is the undue emphasis on individualism not only in youth ministry but in the entire church. What I especially appreciate here is that your critique focuses on the tendency to ignore, or worse, rewrite history in order to maintain the American cultural mandate of personal independence. Like N. T. Wright,[1] the way you take on the tendency of some to operate as if the Reformation trumps the Scriptures provides the backdrop for your argument for youth ministry to reengage the nature of the biblical church instead of a “human organization”: “[Evangelicals] are either uninformed about church history prior to the Reformation or they intentionally reject church history prior to the Reformation. The radical individualism [of evangelicalism] often leads church movements or fellowships to ‘start over again’ instead of learning about church history.”

Last, your use of and commitment to Robert Webber’s “four characteristics of the church,” which we get from the ancient creeds of the church, lays a helpful foundation for youth ministry. Your argument, using Webber’s four categories, invites us to refocus our work and missional structure and strategy on what God had in mind as revealed in Scripture for what it means to live and serve together as his “mystically” connected people. These four characteristics—unity, holiness, catholicity, and apostolicity—may not be common language or even thinking for most youth ministry people, but their theological power cannot be dismissed.

Where I Would Like to See This Model Take Us

All that said—without reservation, and with full support for the basic concepts you detail—I wonder first how a frontline youth ministry leader, lay or ordained, paid or volunteer, might possibly implement what it is you are asking for. In other words, my greatest critique of this model is not in the conceptual, theological, or historical framework you’ve laid out but in the “What do I do with this?”

My thoughts are offered in the following three musings, and they are related to the four characteristics and suggestions for changes in youth ministry. Ultimately, I attempt to wrestle with how these characteristics actually play out in the practice of youth ministry.

UNITY: WHAT DOES IT MEAN IN YOUTH MINISTRY?

My first big question relates to how you, using Oden, Bloesch, and Webber, make a great theoretical point that one of the most serious fallouts of the Reformation is the “perpetual schismatic nature” of the contemporary Protestant church (to leave aside for this response the wildly interesting “unity” of the various subcommunities in the Roman Catholic world). Your diagnosis of our almost-flippant disregard for the “visible” church has merit, but your prescription for addressing this by “seeking unity” seems to be, at best, naively asserting what a weak nanny might try with unruly children: “Just get along!” Especially as the church wrestles with serious issues like scriptural authority, denominational disintegration, and generationally focused churches growing by gathering the young from other, more established churches, to ask the people on the lowest rung of the institutional ladder (the youth worker) to “seek unity” when many of those in power are committed to the exact opposite is fraught with communal danger, to say nothing of potential career suicide.

Perhaps you’re calling for youth ministry to teach away from individualism and toward a Christian discipleship that is committed to honoring and affirming the visible church. This, I agree, is noble and important. But I do think that we need to be careful to help people in youth ministry to navigate this with care and within the context of the larger system of the church.

HOLINESS

I agree that there has been an unwarranted and unfortunate lack of emphasis on the corporate calling to holiness as compared to the responsibility of the individual to pursue holiness, or what may be more aptly termed personal piety. Your note that this is to be a both/and as opposed to an either/or calling is so important. I would like to go further than you and Webber at this point by stating that the Spirit not only “summons the church to holiness” but also empowers the church to holiness, and in so doing summons and empowers the individual to holiness. In your chapter, while you do say that youth ministry “should certainly continue encouraging individuals to live a life of holiness,” I would have liked to see how you would help people to actually do this without shaming or moralizing. And with that, how do we both encourage personal holiness and seek corporate holiness in a youth ministry context? And just who, then, makes up this corporate “holy body” you refer to? This is, in effect, where the youth ministry rubber meets the road. To “disciple” young people toward holiness, without shaming or violating Willard’s “sin management” rebuke, while creating a vision and impetus for corporate holiness, is not only the central task of youth ministry—it is youth ministry. Help!

In youth ministry, holiness is not only often misunderstood but also rarely talked about. When it is talked about, it typically falls into the category of personal piety, or simply behaviors like drinking, doing drugs, or sex. This is where holiness becomes more about shaming young people into conformity—Dallas Willard’s “gospel of sin management” refers to contemporary discipleship models that seek to change behavior without pointing to the call of Christ and the empowerment of the Spirit.[2] Our call, then, is to encourage young people to pursue, trust, and follow Christ, both personally and as members of the body of Christ. In so doing, holiness will be sowed from the inside out. This corporate commitment to pursuing holiness as a body should not, however, be limited to the youth group or a small group; it is most readily actualized in the greater family of God (and this is what my article on adoption is trying to say as well).

CATHOLIC AND APOSTOLIC

This is where your article has the greatest potential for a new way of thinking about youth ministry, and, again, I wish you had been able to describe this in a more practical way. Perhaps it is time to move beyond our most common prototypical discipleship models of “Do this, but don’t do that” shaming and behavior adjustment, or the “Go out there (alone) and be a world changer!” challenges. Helping to plant a young person’s faith in the communal soil of ecclesial history provides them with a deep and sustainable faith to grow out of, regardless of the mode, philosophy, or methods we employ. Reinforcing historic and “passed on” faith to someone in the most transitional phase of life allows them to see themselves as carrying the torch handed to them by a long lineage of God’s people. This is sure to strengthen their experience of faith by providing a depth and lasting meaning that individualism cannot.

In addition to the benefit of the longevity of the Christian faith, when that faith is proclaimed as catholic (as you, Fred, rightly define it as “universal” faith) and apostolic (as the succession of orthodox teaching and obedience to that teaching), the credibility of the heart of that message, the kingdom of God, takes on a new gravitas, thus enabling the youth ministry student or practitioner to both recognize and embrace the validity of that faith. In middle and even high school this may rarely be a pressing issue for most disciples, but once they hit college and beyond, the intellectual challenges alone may wreak havoc on the person whose faith is limited to following a prescribed list of behaviors, attitudes, and voting tendencies. They might lose steam for continually trying to live up to the “world changer” mantle. And this is certainly your point. To be convinced that the message of Jesus Christ and the kingdom of God can not only survive but truly interact with different viewpoints but have also stood the test of time across the centuries can produce the kind of inner confidence in a young person (or a youth group) that the gospel is authentic and true. In so doing, faith may indeed become rich and deep and real.

In closing, I would hope to see this ecclesiological framework and historical and theological environment and training be located within a familial framework I call adoptive ministry. To have solid historical understanding, to be taught the “four characteristics” of the church, and to know basic doctrines is indeed important. But to be trained in all of that, and even to be immersed in a community that celebrates these essentials, is not enough to sustain long-term faith in young people in a world devoid of social capital. Adoption, at the center of your article, could make what you have written all the more powerful.

images Ron Hunter

Thank you for your comments, Fernando. In response, because you spend most of your article on paleo-orthodoxy and only a small percentage applying it to youth ministry, most of my comments will deal with your suggestion of which orthodoxy youth ministry should embrace. You suggest some ideas that I can easily agree with, such as not treating ministry as a business model but instead as an ecclesiastical one, and that youth ministries should not always be isolated from the larger body. Also, youth and all other ages within the church should know about church history, doctrine, the implications of the Reformation, and the tension that exists between the church and the world. Some major early church core aspects we should never compromise include the virgin birth, bodily resurrection, the Trinity, and others. One cannot ignore history and the value that the early church fathers bring to our development of beliefs.

“Orthodoxy” means “correct belief.” “Paleo” means “ancient.” All advocates of orthodoxy, regardless of the prefix, believe they hold the correct position. The distinctive prefix differentiates one view from another. Paleo-orthodoxy attempts to reach back to a predenomination era, and as a result it creates its own distinct set of beliefs. It is ironic that distinct approaches to orthodoxy, like the paleo position, is how we arrived at so many denominations.

Reading Fernando is like reading Oden and Webber—mostly Webber. Some versions of paleo-orthodoxy stand in danger of shifting the focus from Scripture to the apostles and early church fathers as the orthodox standard of our faith. Throughout the New Testament, early church fathers, and the Reformation, the nuances, prefixes, and core beliefs became dividing lines. Even today within Christianity, mainline denominations cannot agree on core doctrines, such as inspiration, infallibility, and the authority of Scripture, that serve as our foundation of truth. Without foundational truth, the apologetic arguments quickly unravel. I would never want to step out in any apologetic argument without establishing first the premise of the inspiration, infallibility, and authority of God’s Word as given through the original authors. As Stier notes in his chapter, young people will not risk their social standing without confidence in what they believe. One cannot and should not compromise on Scripture, even when lifting up other historical teachings.

Fernando says, “Furthermore, it is also important to teach Christian teens that ecclesiology preceded the canon for over three hundred years.” The current church era owes a debt of gratitude to the early developers of ecclesiology. While the early church fathers carried on Christ’s Great Commission similarly to the apostles, their teachings begin to splinter as well. One can read about Jerome and others who felt inferior as nonmartyrs and taught self-deprivation, mutilation, and isolation.[3] Many are thankful these teachings did not make the canon of Scripture. The early church fathers do not agree with one another, and they do not always agree with themselves. One must be careful looking back and idealizing an era. One should reach back to Scripture for principles but look forward in implementing them in today’s culture. Even Christ’s methods were criticized in light of ancient teachings.

It might be idealistic to suggest that going back to the early church fathers provides a consensus that results in truth. After Christ, differences developed as more of the early fathers championed various interpretations of truth. Maximus the Confessor is a good example of a church father who stood for the truth by standing against the prevailing consensus of the church leaders in his geographic area, a stand that cost him his life. Consensus on truth did not exist during the early church fathers, and it may be presumptuous to suggest that unanimity could be reached by going back to this era.

While Fernando asks the modern church to rally around some overgeneralizations, he also brings us to some great reminders. We should recognize and show appreciation for how paleo-orthodoxy warns the church and its youth about the dangers of forgetting our roots. In fact, we should listen as Fernando cites Webber, who calls the body of Christ to the awareness of how in “the ancient stage, the church was understood as the visible continuation of the presence of Christ in the world.” However, it needs to be stressed that many evangelicals who do not strictly fit within the paleo-orthodoxy renewal have not abandoned the richness of our history. The very activity of preaching Christ, yielding to his authority, and calling people to salvation through the cross by faith connects us to the church of the past.

Through this section Fernando makes some wise insights about how the church functions today. One of the greatest problems identified is the way churches and youth pastors tend to isolate the youth group from the main congregation. Many would agree the constant isolation can cause a lack of desire to reassimilate into the main congregation as the teenagers move into young adulthood. Young-adult ministries that continue the tangential contact of youth ministries are growing. Stuart Cummings-Bond illustrated this perfectly when describing it as the “one-eared Mickey Mouse” (see fig. 4.1 below). Youth ministries sit in the peripheral of the congregation due to the desire to find their own identity, and the adults feel more comfortable when the group they least identify with functions at some distance.

Figure 4.1. The one-eared Mickey Mouse[4]

Mark DeVries suggests that when adults and youth work together in mission and service, they tend to wind up spending time together outside a programmed context.[5] In addition, if a church never segregates by age group, all families will get to worship and interact together. The identity of totally separated youth groups can create a “cool versus the uncool” environment. This now causes churches to create the second ear to the Mickey Mouse—young-adult ministry—further separating and delaying the opportunities to create a church of all ages. In fairness to the youth and young adults, the self-centered preferences of the adults’ traditional approach to worship often leave little room for including the youth and young adults. When the adults recognize the worship includes the youth and young adults, then maybe the way “we always did church” becomes less important than showing them how to have a relationship with the Heavenly Father, even if it is slightly different from their traditions. How quickly the modern church forgets that God is the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob—not just Abraham. Thank you, Fernando, for pointing out how segregated the church can become if not intentional and inclusive.

Another insightful observation by Fernando shows how some churches tend to legislate morality today. While I agree with the statement, I disagree with which churches he assigns as doing this today. Fernando suggests that the churches that are run like a business have the goal of managing the actions of their members. Author and pastor Tim Kimmel has dedicated his life to family ministry, and he suggests the congregation or family without a grace-based approach places the youth and children in a performance mentality. Kimmel asks why we preach that “by grace through faith” allows us to be saved or become a Christ-follower, and then judge by performance as grace is left behind. Legalism is the by-product of the absence of grace and lack of the type of loving relationship that demonstrates what the Heavenly Father does for all his children.

I am grateful for how the paleo-orthodox position reminds Christians to recognize the church as a body. Christ works within and is represented by this body, and it should function as a whole rather than a collective group of individuals who are simply agreeable. Some religious leaders have been dismissive of the notion of the bride of Christ. This dangerous position ignores an important understanding given to us by our Heavenly Father, and it ignores the fact that we are called to look toward the day the church is wed to Christ at his return. Fernando’s position reminds all of us to hold in high esteem Christ’s bride, whom he loves and works within to accomplish his purpose.

Paleo-orthodoxy reminds us to seek truth over denominational labels and preconceived worldviews. Since Christ’s resurrection, the body of Christ has been on a quest to define and explain truth as each generation creates a new banner, nuance, or even theological camp. Paleo-orthodoxy reminds us that it is more important to embrace Christian truth than it is to be labeled Baptist, Methodist, or Anglican. Correct teaching is even more important than the label “evangelical”! If the youth can catch the concept that we are a family of faith pursuing truth, they will be stronger.

images Fernando Arzola’s Response

Thank you all for the thoughtful responses to my article. I will respond to you each individually.

Greg, I appreciate your honest reflections. Let me start by stating, however, that I think you too quickly dismiss the spirit of the chapter. The issue is not so much that teenagers “need to know” church history but that youth ministers should reflect on their own ecclesiological presuppositions and models. Being familiar with church history (including the history between the apostles and the Reformation) could prevent youth leaders from creating their own personal ecclesiologies based on their own personalities and temperaments. The overall purpose of the chapter is to examine an issue that I believe youth ministers, and the field of youth ministry, does not often address—ecclesiology. I reflect on the ancient practices as a template for self-reflection.

What will “drive” a youth ministry is not what I intended to address. This is secondary to me; otherwise, we fall into the same old “what programs will work this week/month/year” kind of exercises instead of examining the foundational presuppositions and theories from which the “drive” comes. My attempt was to focus more on the theory rather than the praxis.

Again, the chapter is not a curriculum to be used with teens. Rather, it serves as a theoretical and historical starting point encouraging youth leaders to reflect on their own youth ministry ecclesiologies. Sadly, I believe, most do not even think about it. They’ll examine the usual (and important) issues of worship, discipleship, service, evangelism, and fellowship, but what about Christology, soteriology, ecclesiology, and so on? Perhaps a helpful place for youth workers to begin is to ask, “What ecclesiological theory/theology/paradigm am I using/nurturing/creating?”

You write, “When one becomes overly obsessed with creeds and confessions, rather that Christ and his cause, then what was meant to bring stability and depth can become an idol that distract us from our Savior.” My response to this is, “Huh?” Again, the chapter is not meant to be a lesson curriculum. So let me push back. What a youth minister believes about Christ is his or her confession that is being passed on to teens. What a youth minister teaches teens about Christ is his or her creed that is being passed on to teens. I agree that any obsession is dysfunctional, but I think dismissing ecclesiological reflection is also unhelpful in developing a healthy youth ministry. Another question youth ministers might ask themselves is, “What traditions are being passed on in my youth ministry program?” Traditions are certainly being passed on. While I am not such a purist or so rigid as to define what this might look like, I do think that looking to the ancient teaching of the church can serve twenty-first-century youth ministry well.

Brian, thank you for the thoughtful response. I can see you took time to reflect on the chapter. For this, I am grateful. Let me jump right into the critiques.

I agree that Donald Bloesch may not necessarily be considered the most “classical” representative of the Reformed tradition. You write that “to associate him with Calvinism (as such) and orthodox Reformed theology as a representative of those traditions would be going a bit too far.” Maybe. But I have also read enough traditional “Reformed” theologians who offer differing opinions on Reformed matters. So who’s to say who is the best representative?

As it relates to this chapter, my perspectives were indeed a blend of Donald Bloesch, Robert Webber, and Thomas Oden. I certainly may not agree with each of them 100 percent, but they were selected for their ability to honor tradition and speak to its place in the contemporary church.

You are correct that I didn’t specifically provide a youth ministry model. What I attempted to provide was a perspective that I believe is missing in youth ministry. The chapter, I hope, encourages youth ministry leaders to consider and reappropriate ancient practices within their youth ministry contexts. This is not significantly different from the traditional practices you suggest in your chapter. However, I am not limiting this to a Reformed model. How this might look within each context will vary.

The Reformed tradition has certainly held on to some of the more institutional marks/pillars. But, at least in my personal experience, particularly in the urban context, I still see that most youth ministries are focused primarily on the Bible and not on the traditions. I say this with no judgment, of course; I simply see it as limiting. Becoming familiar with and reappropriating some of the ancient Christian practices will, I believe, broaden and enrich youth ministries and reintegrate them more deeply into the church.

Your points about “unity in the church” and “unity in the truth” are well taken. And your concern about living in a culture where unity and tolerance are elevated above biblical unity “for unity’s sake” is appreciated. I am committed to being kind and respectful (1 Pet. 3:15), but that does not mean that biblical unity is not vital. I don’t mean to imply this necessarily reflects your opinion, so forgive my assumptions. But the fears you mention usually come from a conservative (or sometimes literal) interpretation of Scripture or tradition, or from a politically/socially right-of-center perspective that views a left-of-center perspective as necessarily “antithetical to Christ.” In addition, would your critique not also apply possibly to those who interpret Scripture literally?

Furthermore, varying Christian traditions and denominations (Roman Catholic and Reformed, for example) may view each other’s theological perspectives as contrary to unity, even if they agree on certain political/social matters. The biblical writers did not envision any of these types of divisions; therefore, to ask whether they envisioned unity with these groups is unhelpful.

I appreciate your insights regarding the distinctions among bishop, priest/presbytery, and deacon. (I would expect nothing less from a Reformed perspective!) This is a good time to remind all of us that the church existed prior to the biblical canon. Therefore, many of the traditions that were developed occurred prior to, or simultaneously with, the writings of the New Testament. We both addressed this, so I won’t dwell on it. It is, however, also helpful to remember that the various Protestant interpretations developed fifteen hundred years after the birth of the church. Of course, this is not to minimize those perspectives, but simply to place the traditions in historical context. We may not necessarily agree with the Roman Catholic or Eastern Orthodox understanding of Scripture or tradition, but they provided the paradigm from which Protestantism based its reworked models.

Finally, Brian, you critique my perspective by saying it offers little biblical support. I would push back and say that just because something is extrabiblical does not mean it’s unbiblical. Nevertheless, I agree that my perspective leans primarily on the traditions of the church, which flow from Scripture. That was the intention of the chapter. But doesn’t this reinforce an implicit message? Yes, the Christian church must be rooted in the Holy Bible, but the Christian church is bigger than the Bible. While we should not base our ecclesiology on unbiblical teachings, let us also embrace the traditions of the church as part of the teaching ministry.

Thank you, Chap, for your kind words of introduction. I particularly appreciate your affirmation of the necessity of youth ministry to more intentionally connect with church history.

Often when I hear youth ministry leaders say, “We stand on the shoulders of men and women who have gone before us,” they generally are referring to those in the brief history of youth ministry, or perhaps their own denominational leaders. Or, if they are more historically keen, they may go back as a far as the Reformers. Sadly, they rarely refer to standing on the shoulders of the apostles, the ancient fathers who led the worldwide expansion of the church, or the early church. This is why the reappropriation of the terms and concepts of catholicity and apostolicity are so important. And I am glad that you agree. These are phrases that are not comfortably said by our Protestant brethren, yet they should be reclaimed. As Ignatius writes, “Wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the catholic church.”

Your highlighting that the definition of “ecclesiology” as “the study of churches” may be, in itself, a hindrance toward better understanding is right on. It sounds dry and academic. If we solely understand ecclesiology as an intellectual examination of a historical model, then this will perpetuate the problem. However, if we understand ecclesiology as a dynamic and living organism that serves as the backbone of our institutional and functional ministries, then it provides a very different understanding. I think Brian Cosby’s chapter on youth ministry and the Reformed tradition underscores the interconnectedness between history, tradition, and contemporary youth ministry.

You state, “My greatest critique of this model is not in the conceptual, theological, or historical framework you’ve laid out, but in the ‘What do I do with this?’” This made me smile. Although I offer some practices to help “reappropriate historically orthodox youth ministry practices,” I agree that I really didn’t present a youth ministry model. (By the way, your model is excellent, Chap.) My attempt here was to focus more on the theory rather than the praxis, to focus more on the “why” than on the “how.” This book will provide several “how” models. First, I wanted to raise ecclesiological awareness; second, to examine ancient/classical ecclesiological perspectives; and third, to suggest that it behooves twenty-first-century youth ministries to reappropriate more intentional ecclesiological practices. As you know, whether we realize it or not, we all have ecclesiological presuppositions. My hope is to raise more intentional and conscious reflection.

My reflections on the visible and invisible church were precisely to critique the individualism that often occurs in many youth ministries. That is, the excessive focus on the visible in many Protestant denominations and traditions tends to reinforce an individualistic spirituality. (This, of course, is different from one’s personal spirituality—a conversation for another day.) Recognizing the reality and place of the visible church helps one to better appreciate, I think, the interconnectedness between youth ministries and the church, both local and universal. I think awareness of the visible church is also significant within the context of social justice. If justice is viewed as an optional part of one’s individual spirituality, then it remains only one item on a menu of individualistic options. If, however, it is understood as an aspect of the visible church, then we begin to understand peace and justice as a constitutive extension of the body of Christ—one that is as essential as baptism and the Lord’s Supper.

Your insights on holiness are excellent, Chap. Much better than any efforts I could attempt. You are correct when you write, “The Spirit not only summons the church to holiness but also empowers the church to holiness.”

I wish to underscore your emphasis that holiness, in certain church and ministry circles, is limited to certain behaviors as opposed to a deeper, conscious awareness of the Spirit in our lives. I affirm your concern that the church in general, and youth ministries in particular, should encourage holiness without shaming or moralizing. By focusing primarily on individualistic “holy behaviors,” we begin to nurture an exclusivistic church of do-gooders instead of a safe and loving place for sinners.

Ron, thank you for your thoughtful and comprehensive response. I appreciate the fullness of your insights and affirmations on several of my points.

You are correct that most of the chapter focuses on the early church and ancient traditions. The overall purpose of the chapter was to use the early church as a template for examining ecclesiology, a topic that is rarely examined in youth ministry circles. You write, “Some versions of paleo-orthodoxy stand in danger of shifting the focus from Scripture to the apostles and early church fathers as the standard.” Perhaps. But, the apostles and their followers were the writers and compilers of the Scriptures. And the writings of the early church fathers were the original commentaries on Scripture—and tradition. Should not those who lived among the apostles (or among the followers of the apostles) and who also participated in the establishing and expansion of the early church have an authoritative perspective on the ecclesiology of the church?

I agree when you write, “Without foundational truth, the apologetic arguments quickly unravel. I would never want to step out in any apologetic argument without establishing first the premise of the inspiration, infallibility, and authority of God’s Word as given through the original authors.” My response is, “Whose interpretation of foundational truth?” And what does inspiration, infallibility, and authority really mean? For example, I have a feeling we would hear many varying perspectives from the members of the Society of Biblical Literature.

I am not stating that youth ministries should “go back to the early fathers” in a literal sense. What “going back” might look like now in the contemporary reality is secondary. However, the ecclesiological pillars have served the church well for two millennia. Perhaps these should at least be reflected on by current youth ministries instead of too quickly trying to find “new” models of being church. It seems to me the emergent church has found a way to reflect on and incorporate the practices of the ancient church into its contemporary faith communities.

Also, you mention, “Consensus on truth did not exist during the early church fathers, and it may be presumptuous to suggest that unanimity could be reached by going back to this era.” You are correct. Nevertheless, ecclesiologically speaking, I would give the ancient practices the benefit of the doubt, or at least a second look.

My one critique of your overall generous response is that you seem to reduce the totality of the chapter to “paleo-orthodoxy.” I certainly refer to this, but my attempt was to remain faithful to and rooted in the orthodox faith of history.

↑ Back to top

↑