Chapter 15 of 18

Ron Hunter’s Response

Ron Hunter’s Response

Responses to the D6 View

images Greg Stier

I fully agree that Christian parents carry the primary responsibility for the spiritual development of their children. Youth leaders must do all they can to nurture and equip parents for that role. I love the view of youth leaders as “coaches” who engage, equip, and encourage parents to play the primary role of spiritual discipler in the lives of their own children.

But the challenge of this approach is that we are living in a culture where intact families, led by godly fathers and loving mothers, are a minority. To put it bluntly, the D6 approach only works when Mom and Dad are fully committed to these principles. Sadly, most of them are not.

The family landscape in America no longer looks like Leave It to Beaver. According to the Pew Research Center, among those under age thirty, more than half (52 percent) have at least one step relative;[1] in 2011, unmarried mothers accounted for 41 percent of births.[2] The statistics within the church today largely reflect the broader culture. Consider this disheartening headline from a 2014 Baylor University press release: “Evangelicals Have Higher-than-Average Divorce Rates, according to a Report Compiled by Baylor for the Council on Contemporary Families.” Researchers found that evangelical Christians are more likely to be divorced than Americans who claim no religion.[3]

Of course, broken homes and struggling families are more than statistics for me. I was raised in a fatherless home by a godless mother. Were it not for the youth leaders at a local church who invested in me, I would be another spiritual statistic. Many of the teenagers attending youth groups today are being raised in families who fall short of the D6 norm. Maybe the dad is a deadbeat. Maybe the mom is emotionally dysfunctional. Or worse yet, maybe they are both rule-driven legalists who force-feed Christianity into the souls of their teenagers. These types of parents shatter the picture-perfect postcard that Christians want to print. The reality is much messier.

Of course, we need to change the picture. We need to build dads into godly dads, and moms into powerful examples for their children (and D6 is doing a great job of this). But as we do, we need youth ministries that run triage for the growing percentage of teenagers who don’t have a dad who will mentor them or a mom who will disciple them. Another element that’s missing from this approach is the Gospel Advancing thrust that will equip moms, dads, youth leaders, church leaders, and teenagers alike for the messiness of making disciples. If we are not careful, the D6 approach could unintentionally become a holy huddle of Bible-bubbled Christians who are so sheltered from the world that they are completely irrelevant when it comes to changing society.

The primary directive of Jesus for all of his followers is to “make disciples of all nations” (Matt. 28:19). This takes proximity. It takes getting our teenagers into the grit and grime of relationships with the lost (classmates, teammates, neighbors, and so on) and “coaching” them to engage in gospel conversations. If we really want our teenagers to be like Jesus, then we need to get them out of the huddle and into the game. We need to help them put their theology to the test by equipping them to engage the lost in the conversation that matters most.

Ideally, D6 parents would exemplify this lifestyle of evangelism for their own kids. And D6 youth leaders would invest in the fatherless or motherless or the have-both-parents-but-still-aren’t-getting-it teenagers. When this happens, the discipleship will be both deep and wide. Parents and youth leaders alike will be working together to raise up young disciples who live and give the gospel.

images Brian Cosby

Ron, your D6 approach is very commendable. For the sake of organizing my response to your position, I’d like to offer what I see as some very positive aspects of your chapter and then some areas of disagreement and constructive criticism.

Positives of the D6 View

You accurately portray the typical contemporary youth ministry scene, the craziness and impossible demands of a youth pastor’s schedule, and the lack of spiritual “success” in the outcome. Your answer to this dilemma is simple and biblical: the church and home should work together as complementary institutions in the work of generational discipleship. I wholeheartedly agree.

I hear the age-segregation problem called many things today, but I’ve never heard the term “silo” being applied to it. It works. While assembly lines and fast-food restaurants produce specialized “professionals,” they aren’t taught to integrate their work into the whole. The same problem, as you note, exists in the church.

I love your call for youth pastors to help and equip parents, not replace them. I also like how you give some examples of how you see this happening at youth group and with announcements, seminars, and podcasts. This “partnership,” as you call it, between the church and home is needed more than ever.

You also did a good job at your exposition of a number of passages, especially Deuteronomy 6 and Ephesians 6. You rightly state that even though Deuteronomy was written a long time ago and in a very different culture from our own, it is still just as relevant for us today. Thank you for showing how the New Testament writers (and Jesus) even affirmed the instruction of Deuteronomy to illustrate this. Deuteronomy 6 isn’t just specific to the culture of its time period; it is transcultural and transgenerational.

I like the fact that you are careful to have the youth pastor not undermine the authority or “coolness” of the parents. Rather, they are to teach youth to love and respect—“honor”—their parents.

Probably the most poignant part of your argument is your simple question, What is the biblical foundation for the age-segregated model that we see so often in youth ministries today? I asked the same question last summer to a group of youth ministry professors at a seminary in Mexico. Silence. Thanks for this wonderful chapter.

My Concerns with the D6 View

However (you knew this was coming!), I see some troubling aspects of your position. You may affirm what I’m about to point out, but I didn’t see them in your chapter.

1. In a chapter decrying age-segregated modern youth ministry programs, I would have expected to also see some biblical foundation for the position of “youth pastor.” You rightly ask the question for the biblical foundation for age segregation, but what about for the actual staff position itself?

You state, “The Bible provides no explicit description for the specific role of the youth pastor but does implicitly describe what a pastor should be and do.” Are there not actual and biblical differences between a youth minister (who isn’t found in Scripture) and a pastor (who is found in Scripture)? Similarly, what about the connection with the perpetual offices of elder and deacon? You mention, in general terms, “church leaders” throughout, but how can the youth pastor actually come alongside the specific callings of these perpetual officers?

While I actually agree with you that the position of “youth pastor” may be appropriate—with a number of qualifications—providing the biblical support for this would have made your position stronger, given your desire to see biblical support for other aspects of youth ministry.

2. You give some background into the age segregation that we see today, but you miss two other important parts: (1) the impact of human secularism and evolutionary theory on age segregation, and (2) the bigger aspect of how nearly 90 percent of Christian parents send their children to age-segregated schools. If age segregation is what you make it to be, and the impact of parents to be what it should be, then I would somehow dovetail your position into the bigger picture of how most of the teenager’s week is spent with same-peer, age-segregated relationships. How can the church and home stand in contrast to this overwhelming cultural influence? Overall, it would have been nice to see your position placed in the larger context of our culture, which devalues children. Fewer people are having children because they are an “inconvenience,” as they say, not a blessing from the Lord.

3. My biggest problem with your chapter, Ron, is that I kept asking, “Where is God in all of this?” God seems to be demoted to a sort of computer software program running in the background, or a deistic god watching how things play out. He’s certainly not presented as the almighty and gracious One saving and sanctifying his people through the means of church and home generational discipleship. In other words, the emphasis is on the working operations of people to achieve an outcome, not God.

Your discussion of the complementary institutions of the church and home are excellent, except that God is almost left entirely out of the picture. It almost seems as if you are saying that if you just exert enough hard work—a splash of church and a dash of family—then you will have the desired outcome of long-term, sustainable, and obedient generational discipleship. All this happens, however, while God is in the background. The emphasis is on “building people” through church and home (as you point out), but the Scriptures teach that it is God who gives the growth (1 Cor. 3:7).

4. Another missing part is this: What makes up the actual discipleship in home and church? It’s nice to have “teachable moments” (as you call them), but does God simply use teachable moments, or does he use his appointed means of saving and growing people in the faith—his Word, prayer, worship, service, the local church, and so on? You see, it’s what we do with those teachable moments. With such an emphasis on generational discipleship, the actual elements of this discipleship were noticeably absent.

Similarly, what does it look like—day in and day out—to lead your family in the home? Do you have a scheduled “family worship”? What do you use to disciple your children? Is D6 curriculum the only option? Some practical suggestions on this would have been helpful.

5. While I love the fact that you specifically mention the (oftentimes neglected) role of fathers, where is the biblical support for the father being his family’s “coach”? You use this term frequently to describe his role, but where do you find that in the Bible? I kept envisioning a big guy with a whistle making his kids do Bible push-ups while yelling, “Jesus loves you.” Why not simply use “father” and describe his role using Scripture? I found your use of “coach” a little distracting and perhaps out of accord with the view of the role of the father. Let’s simply state that fathers train, equip, teach, lead, pray for and with, and read to and with their children rather than constantly use “coaching” for the primary role.

6. You didn’t mention anything about God’s covenant with us as his children. You write as someone who believes in covenant theology (i.e., continuity of Old and New Testaments, emphasis on raising children in the nurture and admonition of the Lord, etc.), but the real context is one of a covenant relationship between God and his people. His promise is for you and for your children after you (Acts 2:39). In fact, the context of Deuteronomy 6 is one of covenant (Deut. 5), with the stipulations extending into the Deuteronomy 6 passage. It also recounts God’s redeeming work as the basis of God’s commands. God works in us to will and to work for his good pleasure (Phil. 2:13). God works in us that which is pleasing in his sight (Heb. 13:21). This ongoing aspect of God’s work was absent in your discussion of youth ministry. While parents and the church should together work to accomplish generational discipleship, this is ultimately about God.

7. Finally, you noted several times the youth pastor being the “hero” of the teen and parent. While I like youth pastors, we shouldn’t forget the truer and greater Hero, God himself. Yes, youth pastors do lots of great things (by God’s grace), but youth pastors don’t save souls. They don’t sanctify sinners. They are merely arrows pointing youth to the God who saves and sanctifies.

I want to again commend you for persuasively arguing for the complementary partnership between the church and home. That message needs to be heard more than ever. I also commend your criticism of church “gimmicks” and how this isn’t the model we see presented in the pages of Scripture. But I would argue for a youth ministry position that takes into account more of the centrality of our Triune God: his sovereignty, his grace, his holiness, and his glory. He has established means of grace by which he will build his church. That said, thanks for an interesting chapter.

images Chap Clark

When we set out to put together this book, and when Ron Hunter, the founder and creator of D6, agreed to participate, I have to admit I was a bit curious. I haven’t known Ron except for his work and reputation (which is stellar on both counts). I had heard of D6 and Ron Hunter for years, but until this project, I had not had the opportunity to interact with him. My curiosity focused first on his vision for the D6 movement and his take on its wildfire growth. (D6 has gone way beyond Ron, as the term itself has become its own brand.) My even greater curiosity was to see how Ron would line up philosophically and programmatically to those who disparage youth ministry altogether, like the people behind the Divided movie, who claim to have data to support their view that youth groups are driving Christian teens to abandon faith.[4] This numerically tiny but vocal movement with a large media presence is a fringe group that, while having a few good things to say to the church, has made life difficult for some youth ministry practitioners by dismissing all the good that youth ministry does well.

As with each chapter in this book, Ron’s chapter, and our interactions as authors, has not only pleasantly settled my curiosity but has helped me become a huge fan of both Ron personally and the D6 movement. Ron, your chapter (as with the others in this book) is great: thoughtful, well resourced, and critically insightful, with an appropriate measure of grace. There are many points where I agree with you and where I resonate with your take on the historical issues that help to define and drive the D6 model. There are also, naturally, a few places where I wonder if there should be some fine-tuning of your perspective as recorded here. I will, therefore, respond in that order.

Where I Appreciate the D6 Perspective

The way you frame the church and the relationship between parents and a church youth staff is theologically solid for your perspective. The phrase “D6 views the church as the theological anchor, training ground, and resource center for discipleship” is a concise and articulate description of the scriptural call to mutual nurture of the young. Your critique regarding church departments slipping toward being “silos of isolation” is, to me, both historically accurate and an important insight for today. Your qualifier, right off the bat, that D6 “includes the home but does not exclude the church” was especially refreshing in a world where the programs and staff of churches are under attack by some who passionately advocate for the family over youth ministry (e.g., the NCFIC and Divided). I also enjoyed your comparing ministry, presumably for children and also adolescents, to coaching soccer. The need to move the church to work with parents, supporting one another and being in relationship with one another in the interests of their children, is clear throughout your article. There is so much good in how you conceive of the D6 ministry model and strategy.

I have to say, before I get into the specific way you employ Scripture to support and define the D6 model, I also deeply appreciate your commitment to making sure that whatever it is you say and promote is true to and grounded on the Bible. I too believe that all theology, and therefore all ministry practice, must be carefully and fully rooted in revelation. When deciding on any course of action, behavior, or attitude, at the core of the deliberation process—whether it is for a philosophy or strategy of ministry, or in how we treat a child, a parent, or a senior adult—is a robust and historically sound hermeneutic. I can see that is where you are also coming from. This, then, opens the door to some questions I have regarding implementing the D6 model as described here.

Where I Wonder whether Some Fine-Tuning Is in Order

First, in keeping with the soccer metaphor you use (and I too was a soccer coach for a brief period—don’t ask!), I so agree with these lines: “Every player wanted his or her parents to practice with them. . . . Parents’ involvement makes a huge difference, no matter the quality of the coach.” This was my experience as well. What unsettled me at that point, however, and what is also the most pronounced programmatic issue I struggle with in the D6 model you espouse, is the line in the middle of those two: “often those who had no one also had the worst attitudes.” Without pausing to reflect on the implications of this statement, you jump right into diagnosis, stating, “Church leaders desperately want a better way to equip parents so they can in turn coach their own kids.” Apparently, then, your diagnosis of why some kids “have no one” is solely because their parents have not been “equipped.” On many levels, this quick, offhand diagnosis and prescription is hard for me.

Like every one of us writing in this book, I have spent my years trying to care for kids in the name of Christ. Like every long-term youth worker, I have logged countless hours in relationships and conversations with teenagers and young adults: meals, camps, football practices, walks, drives, snacks, meetings—the gamut. In addition, I have used my academic training and the gracious Fuller Seminary sabbatical policy to study them—not just some of them, but every demographic our team and I could uncover—in the interests of understanding them so that we can care for and guide them more faithfully. That said, Ron, I am convinced that many if not most kids “have no one” not because a parent has not been “equipped to coach” but because there simply is no one. I am not only talking about overtly broken families, but this is also the case in so many “healthy” families, “intact” families, suburban, wealthy, and heavily resourced families in addition to the hundreds of thousands of families and parents in the United States who do not have the material means to be available to be their kids’ “coaches.” For these families, and there are many, many of them, the D6 model as described can become one more source of discouragement because they simply don’t have the ability (or sometimes, yes, the willingness) to pull it off.

Second, the place where I get tripped up by some who base their ministry strategy on Deuteronomy 6 is in their theological method and use of the Bible. As I’ve said, I’m grateful for the way you describe the dance between discipleship in the home and in the church. Your strategy statement, “Building believers through church and home,” states this twofold partnership. In Deuteronomy 6, especially vv. 4–7, from which you took the name of the model, there is exegetical evidence that to the Hebrew people, the Shema is not limited to parents but also includes the entire community, a both/and instead of either/or training in faith. You seek throughout the article to take this balance seriously. Yet, in actual practice—and what I’m about to say is less about your description in the chapter and more concerning others who take this idea to almost totally exclude the role of the community of adults in the church, staff or lay—this sometimes is a passage used to defend familial isolationism in the name of “biblical discipleship.” I believe that is not your desire or intent in this chapter, but the potential is there for those who, for whatever reason, do not come to grips with the interconnectedness of the church/home partnership.

This, then, leads me to my third question, and it combines the first two. In your chapter, as you begin to talk about “being a transformational leader,” you ask, “Who are the leaders and followers as they relate to youth ministry?” Your answer is that the “obvious first pair shows the youth pastor as the leader and the students as the followers. Parents and their teens are the second pair of leaders and followers.” And later you say “youth pastors lead and shepherd the youth group.” I find this to miss one of the more fundamental theological axioms of the post-Pentecost era, the role of the people in the family of faith in mutual nurture, mentoring, or discipleship. The three most pointed gift passages—1 Corinthians 12, Romans 12, and Ephesians 4—all are primarily concerned with unity in the church in the midst of various gifts and roles. They are descriptive, not prescriptive (even though most people get that one turned around and go through life looking for their “gift,” when in reality these texts teach that each person is a called and gifted contributor to the health and growth of the whole). The point in these three passages, affirmed from the upper-room discourse in John 13–17 and throughout the New Testament, is that God’s people are called to unity, to love and serve one another (Gal. 5:13), and to be a “chosen people” (1 Pet. 2:9). Ephesians 4:12 entreats leaders to “equip [God’s] people for works of service.” There seems to be overwhelming evidence that the role of leadership is to call every member of the body to participate in nurture and service to the entire family of God and to also, both individually and corporately, participate in the work of the kingdom of God.[5] The leader, then, in youth ministry and every ministry, is not the “staff” person but the people who call that church their home.

The reason this is so important in light of the D6 model of youth ministry is that the formula cannot be the “youth pastor as leader” and “parents as leaders” in partnership but rather the church as leader. Everyone is a partner in the discipleship, nurture, training, and sending ministry of the body to any person, including the young. As best as I understand the work of the Spirit in and through us as the body of Christ, and therefore D6 in particular, we all are, and must see one another as, members of the one body, the one family, the one people of God. This is God’s design, to empower and equip us, by the Spirit in and through us, as we teach and serve one another. Parents, then, are obviously of supreme importance and influence, but they are not alone. And just because someone is uniquely trained, gifted, and possibly even paid does not mean they are the sole representative of the body of Christ to that child, adolescent, or family. We are the people of God. We pass on his truth and message and light. That is the message of the Scriptures. That is the point of D6.

In sum, I agree with and appreciate the goal and heart of the D6 movement, especially as you describe it here, Ron, with two vital caveats: the church must strategically commit to coming alongside and caring for the child or adolescent (and their family) whose parents are not able or willing to be a ministry partner, and the community of faith (not just the staff or leadership) must function as nurturing partners with parents.

images Fernando Arzola

Ron hits the nail on the head when he describes some of the unrealistic expectations placed on youth ministers. Many churches do write impossible job descriptions. And often parents expect youth ministers to undo years of stuff ingrained in the lives of their children—an unfair and unrealistic burden on youth workers. This also lets parents “off the hook” as it relates to the spiritual development of their teens.

I am happy to see that D6 recognizes that the church is the anchor for youth discipleship. At the end of the day, it is the local church that births, baptizes, confirms, celebrates communion, marries, welcomes back, and buries. Parachurch ministries support churches but do not replace them.

D6 is also realistic. The youth minister can only do so much work with teens. Therefore, the training of parents, guardians, grandparents, and the faith community also empowers the gathering community. It takes a Christian village to raise up Christian teens. But its emphasis on parents/guardians is refreshing in an American youth ministry culture that at times tends to overemphasize youth strategies/programming that separates teens from adults and the youth ministry from the congregation. By doing this, teens are not adequately connected with the body of Christ. And if they leave the church, when they return, they will not have strong relationships with members. This reinforces what the Catholic Church popularly and correctly emphasizes, that parents/guardians are the primary catechists. Furthermore, its developmental sensitivity demonstrates age-appropriate awareness.

Ron also appropriately underscores the importance of children’s ministry and its necessary bridge to youth ministry. This expands the traditional youth ministry paradigm from an isolated program to a more developmentally appropriate spiritual formation continuum. The use of the term “generational discipleship” is quite apropos as it demonstrates both age development and involvement of the broader faith community. More specifically, incorporating the home with the church presents a more rich and expansive education process. It may take more work, as it seems easier to focus solely on a “closed” youth ministry model; however, in the long run, it will nurture a more spiritually formed teen—and family.

By focusing on Deuteronomy 6, D6 is rooted in a biblical educational pattern that emphasizes a broader generational involvement. Ron’s argument to not dismiss Deuteronomy as being outdated or limited to ancient Israel is valid. It is often quoted by Jesus, Paul, and the New Testament. He does an excellent job in making this case. The biblical examples he provides are various and rich educational models, both from the Old Testament and New Testament. I particularly appreciate Ron’s insights (and honesty) about biblical genealogies. They do demonstrate generational trajectories. His statement about Christ-likeness is especially apt: “Christ-likeness should be rooted within the values of families and passed along within the threads of generations, as noted through all Scripture.”

Ron then spends a considerable amount on the role of the D6 youth pastor. In the section titled “Be a Transformational Leader,” he presents James McGregor Burns’s leadership definition and Paul’s leadership expectation in Ephesians. While these are certainly leadership models and insights, I’m not sure what “transformational” leadership really is. I would have welcomed a more explicit and in-depth definition. The term “transformation” is as popular and vague as the word “purpose.” What makes this leadership any more transformational than any other leadership model?

In “Build a Strategic Philosophy,” I agree that youth ministry leaders need to spend significant time on developing an appropriate philosophy and underlying foundations. And this insight resonates with me: “Real revolution occurs when leaders focus on a philosophy of influencing people rather than behavior.” This feels important, loving, and nonjudgmental. It focuses on people, not their behavior. Unfortunately, too many of our youth ministries and churches focus on behavior instead of people. Ron also challenges us when he states that youth should see Christ in us. Not an easy task.

As a religious educator, I was happy to see the “Build a Team Approach” section. Ron’s suggestion that various leaders (preschool, children, and youth) work together and “share the same playbook” is in keeping with the Christian education tradition. In fact, much of the D6 model seems to me to be rooted less in the youth ministry and more in Christian education. (I say this as a good thing!)

He argues the most powerful teaching to youth includes studying the Bible, defending their faith, and taking the gospel to social issues. While there is certainly a place for apologetics, I am less concerned about students defending their faith and more concerned about them deepening and growing in their faith. I am always concerned about nurturing young zealots who are more energetic about defending their beliefs than growing in their faith. My experience is that this tends to develop argumentative, dogmatic teens rather than humble followers of Christ.

Ron’s insight to youth leaders that if they “position themselves as cooler than mom or dad, they undermine the home” is right on point again. Youth leaders should position themselves as encouraging and supporting parents. This will be a challenge for younger youth workers who are trying to be relevant with teens. It is more important, I believe, to be authentic. Teens are looking for honest role models who respect them. Youth workers also have to earn the respect of parents/guardians. This does not occur overnight but through a long process of relationship building. The more support youth workers get from parents, the more support they will get for the ministry.

Overall, I think the D6 view is very helpful. However, the strongest area of critique I have is what to do with teens with no parents or an uninvolved home. While no program is necessarily applicable in all churches, I’m having a difficult time seeing the D6 paradigm applied in churches that have little parental involvement. This has certainly been my experience in many inner-city youth ministries. Here is where the D6 model seems to fall short. The heart of the program is parent/home driven. While this may work well in those congregations with greater resources and possibly a greater percentage of intact families or even those with greater parental involvement, what would this look like in poorer congregations?

images Ron Hunter’s Response

None of us has found the exclusive way to minister to youth. All of the proposed models have merit. Young ministers today who wish to effectively lead will need a layered approach, utilizing bits of each of the methods listed in this book. Knowing we must be adaptive in our approach, I trust in God’s foreknowledge. He knew the dysfunction and divorce that the New Testament and our current culture would face when he commanded us to work within a generational construct. The churches to whom Paul wrote faced an equal amount of sin and brokenness to that we face today, yet he did not relieve dads or moms of their spiritual coaching duty, as evidenced most pointedly in Ephesians 5–6. Still today, parents remain the primary influencers in the lives of youth, both in positive and negative ways. Ministry leaders cannot overlook the power of parental influence on a youth’s worldview. To ignore proven principles will handicap potential outcomes.

The biggest criticism for D6 comes from the perspective that suggests it is designed for ideal homes that contain involved dads and moms who are both present and care about their kids. The idea that we get to start with the end in mind (a perfect set of concerned parents) is as contradictory as Jesus coming to seek and save those who are already saved. Parents are not always present. Some kids have one parent. Even when a teen has one or both parents, it does not mean either of them will participate in teaching biblical principles. We do need the adoption approach and Gospel Advancing approach along with parts of the others. Kids often have two homes and very mixed messages speaking into their world—if parents are speaking at all. I know—I came from a broken home as well. My parents divorced when I was fourteen. Let’s look at some of the criticism and some counterpoints to consider.

Chap and Greg quickly point out that “most” kids are from broken homes and cite Pew Research that “among those under age 30, more than half (52%) has at least one step relative.” Look at the reverse of the 52 percent and notice the 48 percent who need help to not become like the 52 percent. If we concentrate on simultaneously helping the 48 percent grow stronger in their marriage and parenting skills, they will have a positive influence on reducing the 52 percent statistic. While we cannot overlook ministering to those who have no parent present, the biggest asset the kids and youth ministry leaders have is getting parents to become more involved in their kids’ lives. Greg noted that 41 percent of births occur among unwed mothers—my response is that 100 percent of the 41 percent of moms need our help to be involved, and most are willing to listen even if out of desperation. D6 fits the half that has parents, and the other half need what Chap describes in the adopted model of D6 dads and moms. We can still help spiritually abandoned kids find their way to significance when we invest in them, even when their parents do not. Ministry is messy; God never suggested a clean or easy way to connect with hurting people. However, the newest studies by Shaunti Feldhahn, a Harvard-trained researcher, in her recent book The Good News about Marriage: Debunking Discouraging Myths about Marriage and Divorce indicates the divorce rate is significantly lower than the often-quoted 50 percent. Kids of divorce still exist, as do the absentee dads and moms—even in church—but there is no better place to improve the trends.

I agree with Chap that when parents are absent, the community of the church must come around the teen to provide influence. However, the moms and dads who fill the gap at church must be careful not to use the adoption terminology at the risk of offending the unchurched parents who may take offense to this as an affront to their parenting. You still need to mentor and be there for them, but also look for a chance to connect with and, hopefully, one day hand off that responsibility to the student’s parent.

Cosby, the presence of God is firmly established in the primary text of Deuteronomy 6. The first three verses tell us that we (parents, grandparents, and adults) are to (1) love God, (2) love his Word, and (3) teach our kids to do the same. I spent more time with my article trying to help people get past the current routines and practices of our day. I made some basic assumptions that God, his Son, his Word, and the work of the Holy Spirit were nonnegotiables, and I assume their presence. If God is absent from my chapter, it was not intentional. I argued for a very different paradigm than youth ministry as it has been conducted in its own separate world. I showed the value of youth ministry in collaboration with children and young adult ministry to prevent losing the teens in between each transition from one age group to the other. When each ministry operates in its own “silo,” the emphasis on its own world makes others less attractive unless you build a long-term plan of discipleship that includes the input of every age-ministry leader. You are correct, without the centrality of God and his Word, nothing else we do will matter.

I use the term “coach” to describe the training and equipping role of the parents of teens. The coaching metaphor gives the title “father” an active description that everyone can visualize. As many of you suggested, a large number of kids do not have a positive mental image of what a father should do. The word “coach” implies training, practicing, putting them out on the field of life, and bringing them back to the sidelines for pep talks, new plays, and even first aid. Coaching is not controlling or hovering over teenagers. The term “coach” was meant to complement the role of dads of teenagers, which is different from dads of children or even adult kids. Each stage requires parenting adaptation as our kids grow from a very dependent stage to becoming independent, just as God designed.

The idea that this is not what the church looks like is flawed. While you correctly claim that the majority of homes are broken, the number you quoted is 52 percent. That is hardly a landslide, and to ignore the other half, which is far from an insignificant minority, would be negligent. One can look at the shift in the medical world to an emphasis on wellness care and see the benefits of emphasizing annual physicals and blood work. Physicians place a significant value on prenatal care for expecting moms. Why don’t physicians and insurance companies just wait and treat the sick and hurting? The wellness care, screenings, and prenatal care have significantly reduced late-stage terminal diagnoses, infant mortality, and general health problems of involved people. Has cancer been eradicated? No—oncologists still treat cancer patients, but with early treatments the prognoses for many have been more positive today than even ten years ago. Ministry could learn from the medical field and provide preventative ministry. Is there a learning curve to get men to get an annual physical? Yes, and so there is in getting that same dad involved in his son or daughter’s spiritual values and biblical worldview. It will take a generation of work to turn this around, but God gave us the method in his Deuteronomy 6 commands, which show up throughout Scripture. Youth ministry leaders should not position themselves to minister exclusively to broken families. That approach creates a reactive ministry rather than a strategic one that helps prevent such statistics.

D6 youth ministry works with the children’s minister and the young-adult ministry, and hopefully has someone coordinating all generations of collaborative discipleship. A youth minister who wants to make ministry more effective in the long run will take the time to enlist available parents and seek to cultivate others to help with kids who don’t have involved parents. D6 ministers can envision teaching youth to be the parent described in Deuteronomy 6 and Ephesians 6, and work to help their parents model it.

↑ Back to top

↑