Greg Stier’s Response
Responses to the Gospel Advancing View
Greg, your “Gospel Advancing” approach is clear, bold, and intriguing. For the sake of organizing my response to your position, I’d like to offer what I see as some very positive aspects of your chapter and then some areas of disagreement and constructive criticism.
Positives of the Gospel Advancing View
Broaching the topic of evangelism among Christians typically causes many to blush, squirm, and reel with embarrassment—that they haven’t evangelized enough. I constantly sense a feeling a shame and guilt when this topic gets brought up. But you have described this call and mission (or “cause” as you put it) in a very inspiring, uplifting, and exciting way. Thank you!
You do a great job in pointing out that teenagers (or any Christian, for that matter) actually grow spiritually as they boldly share the gospel. This is a point often missed. God uses the mission of the church in forming and transforming his people more and more into the image of Christ. One of the many ways this happens, as you describe it, is by being forced to depend on God. This dependence empowers a greater fellowship with God and a greater desire to grow in a deeper knowledge of him and his Word.
Another thing I really like about your chapter, Greg, is your “10 percent” discussion—how reaching 10 percent of a population or culture affects the whole. I can see this working in the local church or with students. And you rightly point to the example of Jesus in choosing twelve ordinary guys to pour his life into. In turn, those twelve had a widespread impact, which would eventually lead to millions and millions of believers all over the world. While it might seem counterintuitive to pour into a select few, it actually has a greater impact in the long run. Excellent discussion.
Finally, I love your criticism of modern youth ministry, namely, that “we have turned outreach into a program instead of a lifestyle.” It’s easy to organize a program—it’s measurable and oftentimes predictable—unlike a lifestyle! The switch from program-oriented to lifestyle-oriented mission and outreach can be costly to a youth pastor’s job, as you point out. But this is certainly Jesus’s example. Your chapter was refreshing, convicting, and encouraging all at the same time.
My Concerns with the Gospel Advancing View
While you have many helpful thoughts, I must disagree with a number of your observations and conclusions, meant here (of course) as constructive criticism.
1. Was Jesus a “youth minister,” as you suggest? Well, maybe. While they didn’t have to pay the tax, they were still “grown up” by today’s standards. In fact, people then were considered to come into manhood or womanhood around the age of thirteen. Many teenagers married and had families. Thus it’s not a direct comparison to today’s youth minister and youth. In this sense, it would be anachronistic to call Jesus a youth minister.
2. While evangelism is certainly an important aspect of ministry, it’s one aspect of many. Your view, therefore, seems to be biblically unbalanced. What do I mean? While evangelism is certainly what we see in the historical narrative passages in the Gospels and the book of Acts, there are also plenty of other areas of the Christian faith that we see throughout the pages of the New Testament: discipleship, church life, family life, church-state relationship, vocation, qualified elders and deacons, marriage, taking care of widows on the church rolls, caring for those in the household of faith, corporate worship, tithes/offerings, and all of the “one another” passages. All of these are important in forming youth because they are all part of the counsel of God.
Other than a few seemingly passing references to other books in the Bible, your focus is on the narrative descriptions rather than prescriptions. As you put it, “It’s what we see in the Gospels and what we read about in the book of Acts.” While we should learn by example and possibly even wear a WWJD bracelet, we should also pay careful attention to the commands and instruction from the entire New Testament. These, in turn, form a balanced approach with shepherding youth.
3. Another thought I have in reading your article is the overemphasis on getting youth to become “heroic, story-telling, high-fiving evangelists.” If I had to summarize your chapter, it would be this: get youth to be radical, revolutionary, world-changing heroes for Jesus! But isn’t Jesus the real Hero? What about the simple, faithful, plodding-along believer? Is every kid called to be a world changer? Does this really match up with the variety of gifts we find in Scripture? Is it wrong, as Paul writes, “to aspire to live quietly, and to mind your own affairs, and to work with your hands” (1 Thess. 4:11 ESV)? While we should seek to advance the gospel where we live, work, and play—as well as in focused local and foreign missions—the Christian life involves so much more, and so should youth ministry. I don’t think our goal is to get “teenagers to change the world.” I think our goal is to get teenagers to glorify and enjoy God forever by faithfully planting and watering the gospel through his Word, prayer, sacrament, worship, service, evangelism, and community. God changes the world through his appointed means, and he uses us to accomplish his mission.
4. Is Jesus really on a “desperate” search to seek and save the lost? Obviously, he came to seek and save the lost. But you mention his desperation a couple of times. It portrays Jesus as being frantic, without full control, desperately trying to get people to join his team. But this isn’t the Jesus we encounter in Scripture. He’s the Lord of the universe; he will build his church, and the gates of hell will not prevail against it (Matt. 16:18). He even explains why some reject him: “You do not believe because you are not among my sheep. My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me. I give them eternal life, and they will never perish” (John 10:26–28 ESV). He exudes confidence, not desperation.
5. What about the centrality of parents, families, and the offices of elders and deacons in the local church? Other than a quick note about parents being their kids’ “coaches” (where’s that in the Bible?), this is at best secondary in this model. Because your focus is on seeing the example of Jesus’s evangelism, this model doesn’t take into account the plethora of passages dealing with family or the ordained leadership in the local church. This should be central to any ministry, youth ministry included.
6. What’s God’s role in evangelism? How does God save and sanctify his people? Your chapter came across with a low view of sin and a low view of God. Sin is sin. As much as we would like to twist it to be something more palatable in the realm of psychotherapy (brokenness, mistakes, etc.), the issues you describe still come back to humanity’s rebellion against the holy and sovereign God. Moreover, in a chapter focused almost solely on evangelism, it would have been nice to see how salvation comes about. How does God’s mission relate to our responsibility in evangelism?
7. You almost seem to pit a model of evangelism against the local church. Yes, the church “meets” together, and this “meeting” is not bad or unbiblical. It is part of the Christian life, as we see throughout the New Testament. Should we teach and lead youth to worship together and be discipled through a variety of means (evangelism included)? Of course. Should a youth pastor work closely with qualified church leaders (i.e., Acts 6; 1 Tim. 3; Titus 1; 1 Pet. 5) and parents to equip (young) saints for the work of ministry (Eph. 4)? Absolutely. Yet these are not really part of your model.
8. Finally, if your emphasis is on evangelism and seeing people come to saving faith, where’s the praise and gratitude for God for saving people in the first place? Rather than praise the “heroism” of me or you or any youth, we should praise God and thank him for his grace and mercy. God uses the verbal witness of the gospel to save sinners (Rom. 10:17). But he gets the glory. I’m not suggesting that you believe otherwise; it was simply disappointing to see this entirely missed in a model driven by evangelism.
Overall, and I say this with affection, although I appreciate many aspects of your chapter and approach, it seems to me rather biblically unbalanced and devoid of God’s supernatural work in regenerating souls. It also seems devoid of the primary responsibilities of the local church, parents, and God-appointed elders and deacons. In other words, you make a wonderful case for Christians being engaged in evangelism—and rightly so—but miss a holistic approach to youth ministry in the process.
“We’ve exchanged mission for meetings. We have separated evangelism and discipleship. We have turned outreach into a program instead of a lifestyle.” In these few words, Greg Stier summarizes what drives this model. His passionate (is there any other word to describe this thoughtful, articulate evangelist and his chapter?) commitment to those who do not know Christ and his plea for God’s people to see their role in verbal proclamation of the good news is infectious. I hesitate to respond because to even hint that I might be critical of this single-minded missional zeal seems to violate the very foundation of Jesus’s call to his disciples, the original apostles, as well as the fifteen-year-olds in Denver. That said, because for many years I have so appreciated Greg’s faithful commitment to encouraging young people to care about others, and especially those outside the faith, I do believe that there may perhaps be a few thoughts that could strengthen the foundation and practice of this model.
I begin with a few issues where I agree with you, Greg, and believe that your perspective is helpful in developing a solidly theological ministry emphasis. Following this, I will offer three thoughts for rethinking how this impassioned plea to a lifestyle of evangelism relates to the church as the body of Christ and its mission to the world. In closing, I will try to bring these two together.
Where “Gospel Advancing Ministry” Is an Important Component of Any Youth Ministry Strategy
1. As a seminary professor, one of the most important roles I play is to help students and church leaders be cautious in how they interpret and especially proclaim Scripture. In framing your model on what is usually called the Great Commission (although this is a label attributed to biblical editors and is not found anywhere in the actual biblical text), you begin with Matthew 28:18, “All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me,” as opposed to where most people start, “Go and make disciples” (v. 19). To affirm that all ministry flows from the authority of Jesus Christ, as you do, is vital to any biblical model of ministry. John 6:28–29: “What must we do to do the works God requires?” Jesus answered, “The work of God is this: to believe (Greek, pisteuo, “trust”) in the one he has sent.” To know, love, trust, and follow Jesus Christ, who has all the authority, is the call of the church. I appreciate how you have grounded your model on this truth.
2. In describing your own faith journey, you affirm the familial aspect of the church that nurtured you and your family (“This youth ministry provided mentors in my life who became my spiritual fathers and mothers”), referring to these relationships as the arbiters of your “theological security.” Your zeal for mission grew and has been nurtured out of the family of God surrounding you (and your family), guiding you, and grounding you in a safe community. As is obvious from my chapter, I too believe that participating in God’s adoptive calling is where all ministry should be focused toward those who feel somewhat disenfranchised, which, in the case of youth ministry, is every young person in our midst.
3. While you earlier decry meetings “replacing” mission, you then later state that meetings have their place and are helpful as a means to mission (“Jesus had meetings,” and “we can and should have meetings”). You do not advocate diminishing or eliminating more-or-less typical youth ministry programs and even “fun” (“Let’s keep having dodgeball tournaments, pizza parties, and lock-ins. Let’s worship loud and play hard. Let’s exegete, teach, and ask hard questions”), but rather you seek to bring mission to the forefront. You recognize that to “make disciples” we must build bridges where teenagers can trust adults and develop a core understanding of our young. This is the aspect of youth ministry that I believe is so often mislabeled as merely superficial “entertainment,” and it remains a vital component of ministry to and for our young in today’s atomized church and society.
4. You experienced, were raised up, and were trained in a conviction that is similar to mine, where “I once was lost and now am found” became the mantra for using all of what I have received so that others might also be found. (I was a Young Life product and have some of the same DNA that you express in your chapter.) I not only understand where your model comes from experientially, but I resonate with your passion, especially in relation to a youth ministry landscape that sometimes seems to be more about keeping kids “healthy” and “happy” than encouraging them to be participants in the work of God. Without question, all believers need teaching and encouragement to care about those who do not know the story of God’s love in Christ.
5. I so appreciate your final emphasis on prayer as the driver and the source of insight for doing what you describe as God’s mission to evangelize the world. Prayer is, as you rightly point out, central to our lives as believers, both personally and corporately (what you call the “engine and not the caboose”).
I not only align with you in each of these points, but as I described them, I wholeheartedly agree with you. I do, however, wonder whether there are aspects to your model that have either not been as carefully considered or factored in. Or perhaps they have not yet crossed your radar screen. As I consider your model as expressed in the chapter, and as I also apply and broaden your perspective to those who have a similar view of the role of youth ministry (as in the “student leadership” movement) in nurturing the young toward a solid, lifelong, and communal trust in God, I offer these thoughts to you.
Where I Wonder about the “Gospel Advancing Ministry” Model
1. My greatest issue with not only this model for youth ministry but also others that seek to set free young people to use their gifts in ministry is that there is often too limited awareness of the developmental place and needs of today’s young.[1] Some say we ask too little of kids, and that that is the biggest problem with today’s adolescents and therefore youth ministry (e.g., Robert Epstein, Teen 2.0, and the Harris brothers, Do Hard Things). My take is that while there is truth in this perspective on one level—the young are neither empowered nor expected to “make a difference”—there is an important aspect to this that is often overlooked. The systemic erosion of adult investment and involvement in the lives of children and adolescents over the past several decades (what is known as “social capital”) has handicapped adolescents to the point where they simply have not received enough training, experience, guidance, or support to be internally prepared for adult-like responsibilities. Adolescents may be functionally capable of “sharing the gospel,” but do they have the social awareness they need to be consistent “salt and light” (Matt. 5) with those they seek to reach? Do they have the mature internal mechanisms for ferreting out their own motives or insecurities in a way that would allow for the kind of individualistic leadership being asked of them? And, most important, taking into consideration the research that demonstrates that early (eleven- to fourteen-year-old) and middle (fourteen- to twenty-year-old) adolescents have such a need for adult approval and blessing, could it be that what we think is personal conviction and commitment is actually adaptation to the expectation of the adults around them?[2]
When it comes to youth ministry primarily as evangelism, where young people are encouraged to (alone, at least implicitly) “risk everything in service to the King,” we are subjecting them to a developmentally untenable choice: either they risk their relationship to the church, youth group, and youth pastor as their leader and their “spiritual father or mother” or they deny the church pressure and continue on their own to navigate the complex social nature of their lives. I tend to think this model may, for most kids, discount their level of developmental insight and health and could therefore hurt them down the road. Even the examples you cite are adults—from Abraham to Martin Luther and Charles Spurgeon.[3] You do say that “the less mature they are, the more coaching they will generally need,” and yet you limit this “coaching” to guidance on how to be more effective as an evangelist, not on what it means to grow up into maturity as a man or woman of God. That must be our chief concern: not simply making them better, “world changing” evangelists but helping them to become whole people who know and love Jesus Christ, care for people without mixed motives that may get in the way of Spirit-driven evangelism and discipleship, and live out the kingdom of God in how they respond to and live alongside others. Then Spirit-driven evangelism will naturally pour out of them.
2. You ground your model on “the Great Commission” but do not mention what seems to me to be two equally as great if not more pointed commissions: “Peace be with you! As the Father has sent me, I am sending you” (John 20:21) and “You will be my witnesses” (Acts 1:8). To be witnesses, especially when being “sent” as Jesus was sent, encompasses so much more than verbal proclamation. In Matthew 25:31–46, the image of the sheep and the goats, what you tend to refer to as “social justice,” is actually a prerequisite for receiving the “inheritance” of God’s kingdom. There is no mention in this passage, or in many if not most of the others related to how we are to treat people (i.e., Sermon on the Mount, Matthew 5–7; the good Samaritan, Luke 10:25–37), of making an effort to “gospelize everything” (your point #6). I fear that in the attempt to emphasize evangelism (or more accurately, verbal proclamation), you place this above what is unfortunately often referred to, as you do, as “social justice.” Theologically, there is no such distinction, for neither the “greatest commandments” (Matt. 22:37–40) nor the “one command” (John 15:9–17) even hint at the necessity to “gospelize everything” the way you describe it.
The last thing I want to do is dampen your enthusiasm and passion for calling the church to care about the lost. And in your model there is a nod in the direction of “serving,” but clearly this is presented as a means to an end, to “seek to engage them in gospel conversations.” The danger of not allowing for the simple act of visiting prisoners or feeding the hungry as an expression of the gospel itself is to make too light of something so central to the Scriptures. As N. T. Wright puts it, “In terms that the author of Acts might have used, when the church is living out the kingdom of God, the word of God will spread powerfully and do its own work.”[4] “Social justice” and verbal proclamation together form biblical evangelism. They are inseparable; neither is the means to the other.
3. Lastly, the goal of the model, it seems to me, is lacking in a theological terminus (or telos), or even a long-term motivating force for the young disciple. “The bottom line is that if we are serious about teenagers spiritually maturing, then we’ll want to get them sharing their faith as quickly as possible.” To equate “sharing their faith” with what it means to grow into healthy adulthood in Christ seems to put the cart before the horse. “Sharing” as a “witness” comes out of experience, failure, received and embraced mercy, and reflection, and theologically it is an organic expression of maturity (again, see Matt. 25: “When did we see you . . . and feed you?”). The goal of ministry to the young is to create an environment where the inner development of identity in Christ, alignment with Jesus Christ and his kingdom (see Paul’s final years in Acts 28:30–31), and lifelong connection to the body of Christ as a cared-for yet not-quite-developed participant in God’s work in the world, including but not limited to verbally “sharing their faith,” is the call of youth ministry.
In closing, I agree with your foundational passion and commitment to the lost. Yet without the investment of adults who are committed to the long-term spiritual and developmental health of the adolescent (which you do affirm) and without the careful eye of the full range of God’s call to the believer (John 20:21 and Matt. 25, in addition to Matt. 28), we may easily end up creating great evangelists for the short term who eventually outgrow—or worse, crash out of—their commitment to Jesus Christ along the way. Yes, let us provide opportunities that honor each young person’s developmental journey as we teach them to serve in God’s kingdom, but let us always remember that we first must create the environment where they can flourish as called men and women without being expected to be “world changers.” To be a “world changer” is simply not the point of lifelong discipleship. For it is God who is changing the world, and we are his loved and set-free sent ones who follow him together as salt and light (Matt. 5:13–16).
Greg’s suggestion that Jesus was a youth leader is quite interesting. His connection between Matthew 17:24–27 and Exodus 30:14 makes for a thought-provoking discussion. If this is accurate, it changes our perspective of the disciples and underscores the truly revolutionary concept: that Christianity was birthed and spread by the lives of young people.
This upends many of our presuppositions about the ages of the disciples. Pragmatically speaking, it makes sense. Much of the travels of the disciples with Jesus would have required people who were able to abandon their lives—at least for a three-year stretch. It’s reasonable to infer that younger people were more able to do this. Many historic and contemporary revolutionary movements were started by young, idealistic people who did abandon their lives for a cause for which they were passionate. And this might be no different.
Greg then suggests that Jesus’s “small group youth ministry” strategy may serve as a model for us today. I appreciate Greg’s insight that part of the problem of contemporary youth ministry lies “not in complexity, but in simplicity.” That is, many youth ministries seem to focus more, he argues, on delivering a series of programs instead of simply focusing on Jesus. This has not been my experience, however. Most youth ministries programs do focus on Christ and don’t offer sufficient other programs other than Bible study and worship.
In my book Toward a Prophetic Youth Ministry: Theory and Praxis in Urban Context, I suggest that most youth ministries actually fall in the “Traditional Youth Ministry” paradigm. I then suggest a “Prophetic Youth Ministry” paradigm, providing a menu of programs. The rationale is that teens have a myriad of issues with which they can use support. To focus solely on “spiritual” matters is what makes some youth ministry programs irrelevant and dualistic. Adolescents are wrestling with emotional, hormonal, sexual, biological, and social issues. I propose a more holistic paradigm and programming beyond Gospel Advancing Ministry.[5]
Nevertheless, I think Greg is on to something here! I believe the complexity he laments comes with the barrage of perspectives related to theology, worship, and spirituality in today’s Christian culture. And yes, there are too many meaningless programs. The simplicity I recommend is, yes, focus on Christ—but not necessarily simply on evangelism. While I hear him talk about discipleship, Gospel Advancing Ministry seems to be evangelistic specific.
I recommend the simplicity of spiritual disciplines. These time-tested and classic disciplines provide teens with tangible expressions of the spiritual life. I think evangelism and Bible study is too narrow.
Two of my favorite books that address spirituality, spiritual disciplines, and spiritual formation for youth and young adults are Presence-Centered Youth Ministry by Mike King and Ancient-Future Evangelism by Robert Webber.[6]
Greg argues that we have exchanged the focus on Jesus for delivering a series of programs. Fair enough. However, he then suggests “a ministry model” that seems to me to be one big evangelism program. Doesn’t this undermine the very thing he is critiquing?
He also states that his program transforms teenagers “not into good kids, but into world changers.” But what does this mean? Don’t we want our teens to be good kids? And what’s a “world changer”? In my experience, most teens who grow up spiritually mature live out a simple faith through their spheres of influence—their families, friends, work, communities, and churches. Perhaps if we think of “world changers” as “thinking globally and acting locally,” then I agree with this.
Jesus’s time here was certainly more than a mission trip. He was offering a way of life, a way of engaging creation, a way of understanding the law, a way of interacting with others, a way of living more deeply in God, a way of being more deeply human.
Greg says that at the heart of Jesus is a desperate search and rescue for the lost. I agree. But this is not all. Again, to make this the central point makes the Gospel Advancing Ministry Model just another evangelism ministry to me. And while evangelism is certainly an essential aspect of the faith, to make this the driving force seems to me to overemphasize the conversion of people rather than the love of people for the sake of their being human. Jesus didn’t evangelize. He accepted people, loved people, created community for people (especially broken people), and invited people to join him in this way and life. Isn’t the fullness of life the heart of Jesus? To help people become more fully human? To help draw people closer to God?
I am overwhelmed by your personal testimony. Thank you, Greg, for your vulnerability and honesty. I think that your experience with Youth Ranch demonstrates that the fullness of the support you received reflected the fullness of the faith beyond evangelism—fellowship, mentorship, discipleship, and service. But most important, they provided you with love and community. This, I believe, is the heart of twenty-first-century youth ministry—a nonjudgmental, inclusive community of love and support, a community where the stories of Christ are for lifting up, inspiring, and self-reflection. Even the language of “reaching the lost” smells musty to many, and it is certainly not common language for a twenty-first-century youth ministry.
I have to confess, I’m not a huge fan of the Gospel Advancing strategy for youth ministry; at least not in the traditional sense. It seems to smack of the old “fire and brimstone” approach that, I believe, is one reason why so many teens eventually leave the church. It tends to feel more like an imposition to accept a formula rather than an invitation into a deeper way of life. It tends to encourage counting heads during altar calls instead of going more deeply in the faith. It seems to breed the kind of faith that Robert Webber calls “a mile-wide and an inch deep.” I mean, are we not all lost in some way? Is not the evangelist as much a sinner in need of mercy? I am reminded of Brennan Manning’s words, “God loves us just as we are, not as we should be.”[7] This is what grace is all about, at least to me.
However, the concept of being transformed by developing a deeper relationship with Jesus certainly resonates with me. I think this happens primarily through love, by providing a loving Christian community, and through the simplicity of spiritual disciplines. Hopefully, this brings one deeper into Christlikeness.
I am reminded of the classic 1960s hymn “They Will Know We Are Christians by Our Love.” Greg suggests (or doesn’t suggest) the possibility of quitting the group after twenty minutes to evangelize the neighborhood. I like the idea of taking teens out of the classroom and into the streets. But I would recommend more community service activities that do not necessarily require verbally proclaiming the gospel in the neighborhood. I am reminded of Francis of Assisi, who is quoted as saying, “Preach the Gospel at all times, and when necessary, use words.” I think people will better absorb the gospel more through our actions than our words.
But Greg is correct that teens would rather go to the Amazon to build huts and fight pythons than evangelize friends in the cafeteria. But why would teens want to evangelize friends in the cafeteria with their words? Is it not more effective for their friends to see the light of Christ in the teens through their actions? Here is where I think helping teens develop social awareness and consciousness, which in itself is every bit as much an aspect of Christian witness as verbal proclamation, is essential. It helps them to develop a more holistic faith perspective.
Greg’s “Gospel Advancing Ministry” advocates for teens sharing their faith as a way to strengthen their walk and obey the call of Christ. Listen to some of his profound statements from his chapter of this book. Amid the highly programmed youth ministry, the “answer lies not in complexity but in simplicity.” Greg goes on to say, “We have turned outreach into a program instead of lifestyle.” Greg teaches teens how to rake leaves and clean windows to create an opportunity to share the gospel. The power of the Gospel Advancing Ministry is that it teaches teens beyond the classroom. In this lab-like, hands-on way, the youth minister walks teens step by step through how to share their faith. The difference between Greg’s model and more typical youth ministry programs occurs when leaders get the youth out into the world to share their faith and serve within the community.
Greg suggests the youth leader embrace the bullied, broken, and, yes, even the bad kids. He quickly admits the goal is not to create kids who act good but rather to transform teens into world changers. Focusing on behavioral outcomes generates conformers more than believers. In the same paragraph, he uses the word “transform,” suggesting a youth-centric approach over a method-centric focus. While he advocates a Gospel Advancing Ministry, the efforts described emphasize the transformation of the teen more than the goal of how many were won to Christ. I really value how his approach downplays performance and emphasizes the teen’s transformation into confident, Christ-following, Christ-sharing believers.
The event-driven mentality that expects certain meetings to capture the hearts of teenagers has failed, according to Greg. He further shows the inadequacy of the meetings-based discipleship such as camp, youth group, small group, and church itself. The failure of such experiences comes from the lack of sustainability outside a “Christian environment.” The need exists for both discipleship and sharing to be part of the teen’s everyday life. To accomplish a lifestyle like this, it helps to have the youth pastor and parent working together so the church and home provide consistency for the family.
The combination of evangelizing and social justice, according to Greg, moves a teenager further along in their faith and stand for Christ. Hearts often soften as people receive acts of service done in the love Christ taught. Caring for people prepares the heart for planting the seed of the gospel. Christ repeatedly modeled serving a physical need followed by a straightforward invitation to follow him. An act of service prepares both parties, the one serving and the one being served, for a deeper conversation. Greg shows how the teen lives out James’s call to works that reflect one’s faith. Acts of service help remove selfish tendencies. The continued diminishing of selfishness brings more confidence to share his or her faith with less regard for one’s standing within the peer group.
Anytime a youth leader wishes to teach acts of service, he or she can share the power of how Jesus served people’s physical needs and connected with them personally. Jesus had a mission, but the mission was people. Christ’s model of feeding, healing, filling a need, or just affirming them helped remove their barriers to hearing the most important message of their lives.
Greg’s steps to adult involvement sound a lot like the D6 approach to youth ministry; adults modeling it, parents who coach it, and church leaders who train and embrace it. The concern I have with the remainder of his chapter is how Greg talks as if the youth leader is the only active leader in the teenagers’ lives. He just spelled out the universal principles of parental influence that constitute the major portion of the formula for shaping a child and teen’s worldview. However, the youth leader has limited opportunities to spend time with the group and even less in one-on-one mentoring situations. Enlisting the help of parents increases the long-term effectiveness of Greg’s approach. Youth leaders could involve parents regularly in the training and community outreach.
When a person reads about the lack of spiritual parental influence in Greg’s childhood, one could easily understand why his first impulse is not to include parents in this Gospel Advancing Ministry. He hints at the impact the other adults can make but does not develop the possibilities of what this combination could look like. As the power of 10 percent of teens following a Gospel Advancing Ministry can influence the entire youth group, imagine the impact of 10 percent of the parents joining their teenagers. If the teens need to find ways to be comfortable with their faith around other teens in their school, moms and dads need to consistently find ways to implement their faith alongside their own teenagers.
A key motivating factor for getting teens out sharing their faith is also getting them to rely on God. One of the most poignant realities described by Greg was when he showed how teens would rather deal with the hazards of the Amazon and build mud huts than share their faith in their school cafeteria. He argues correctly, “The average teenager would rather risk getting choked by a giant snake than getting choked out of their social circle.” This observation is one of the most insightful and accurate statements describing teenage fears. When the teens share their faith, they immediately possess an incentive to live consistently in front of their peers.
Greg suggests that when teenagers adopt the lifestyle of sharing their faith and the gospel with their peers, it accelerates the discipleship process in their own lives. Does sharing automatically generate maturity in discipleship? I would like to hear more about the process of discipleship that comes from sharing the gospel. When describing the Youth Ranch youth group, he reports that “discipleship shook out from there [evangelization]”—but how? While he acknowledges the value of discipleship, the scale dramatically leans toward sharing the gospel. Paradoxically, those who emphasize discipleship rarely engage in any form of evangelism. The Great Commission passage most often quoted from Matthew suggests a cycle of reaching and teaching. Teaching grounds the new believers. While there is no waiting period to share one’s newfound faith, the need to grow deeper in Scripture will help as one shares the gospel. Most people concentrate on the evangelistic side of this passage, but this is to miss half of the command.
We have all seen strong evangelistic churches who constantly win people but whose attendance fails to keep pace with the number of new converts. The proverbial back door of the church exists in the absence of discipleship. The Matthew 28 passage speaks as much about discipleship when it says, “make disciples,” “teaching them to obey what I have commanded you.” One should teach new believers, including teenagers, to share the faith while also helping them to know and thereby gently and respectfully (1 Pet. 3:15) explain their faith. One of the best ways to balance teaching teens how to advance the gospel to their peers is also to teach them and their parents how to defend the existence of God and the validity of Scripture and other doctrines. A growing number of churches provide mission trips for families instead of just the teens. By getting the whole family dedicated to a cause, evangelism, missions, discipleship, service, and other ministries strengthen the family and the body of believers within the church.
This approach falls short if the youth minister possesses any inhibitions over sharing the gospel. To be clear, there are no exemptions for Christians to avoid the Great Commission. What happens when you find a youth minister who lacks Greg’s passion and fails to be obedient in evangelizing others? Kids tend to live stale, insular Christian lives. People dismiss this responsibility by saying, “Witnessing or evangelizing is just not my strength or gift.” I agree with Greg’s approach that teaching, modeling, and facilitating ways for teenagers to share their faith will strengthen them as long as they are simultaneously being discipled.
Greg, in the middle of the section, you discuss seven vital elements for the Gospel Advancing Ministry. These practical steps help others adopt your approach. It is always energizing when a writer takes the concepts beyond theory into practicality and shows the reader how to implement the ideas, principles, and teaching. All of the elements are vital, but two provide the fundamental connection to people: equipping teens for relational connection and sharing stories. How would you suggest training teens to be relational when their God-given bent or talent is toward tasks instead of people? Most every personality inventory categorizes people into two major subsets, those who are relational and those who are task oriented. It does not mean that each cannot possess secondary abilities in the other set, but that the other set does not come as naturally. Since this is trainable, what do you recommend to youth ministers to help the task-oriented teens become more relational and tell stories in the same compelling way that you do?
The reader understands that Greg is suggesting a balance of the need for meetings with dodgeball, pizza, and other fun activities with more substantive experiences and discussions. Greg even talks about teaching prayer and having specific prayer meetings with the teenagers. What I would like to see is more on the fourth vital element. There is little described about going deep in discipleship; rather, the whole section features going wider by sharing one’s faith. I get the sense Greg acknowledges the need for discipleship, but it just did not get much attention in this chapter. Spending a page or more on discipleship would further strengthen what is already a very good chapter.
Thank you all for your thoughtful insights. It’s always a little intimidating having “wicked smart” people critically analyze a ministry model you are passionate about and pouring your heart into. Chap, Brian, Fred, and Ron, your encouragements filled my soul with joy, and your criticisms made me think.
For me, youth ministry is an intriguing, exciting, and at times daunting venture. We all want to see students grow in Christ and go into their world to make disciples.
That’s one thing that really stood out to me across all your critiques of the Gospel Advancing Ministry model. I don’t think I emphasized the “grow” part as much as I should have. Instead, I emphasized the “go” part (after all, I am an evangelist!).
But, having been a church planter and preaching pastor in the past as well as the father of a teenager in the present, I can say that I am fully convinced that all believers need to grow and go. Brian, you wrote, “While evangelism is certainly what we see in the historical narrative passages in the Gospels and the book of Acts, there are also plenty of other areas of the Christian faith that we see throughout the pages of the New Testament,” and then you listed several. I agree. There are so many different areas that we must help teenagers grow in to become fruitful disciples of Christ.
My contention underlying the emphasis on evangelism is that teenagers “grow as they go.” I’m convinced that when young people are engaging their peers with the love and message of Jesus, they pray more, gather in church more, worship more, and study God’s Word more. For me, Brian, it’s context. The church that reached me took me through systematic theology while sending me into the harvest fields. I read my first systematic theology book when I was fifteen because my church challenged me to. The reason I read it was because of the urgency of the mission before me.
And it was a good reminder to emphasize the glory of God in this whole endeavor. I live by the motto attributed to St. Ignatius, Ad majorem Dei gloriam inque hominum salutem (“For the greater glory of God and salvation of humanity”). God is the hero of the story. He is the hero of my story. I fully agree with you on that point.
Chap, thanks for the reminder as well that “the systemic erosion of adult investment and involvement in the lives of children and adolescents over the past several decades (what is known as ‘social capital’) has handicapped adolescents to the point where they simply have not received enough training, experience, guidance, or support to be internally prepared for adult-like responsibilities.” I agree that teenagers need adults to pour the love and knowledge of Jesus Christ into their lives to give them that encouragement, support, and training when it comes to living the gospel and sharing it. Your adoption model of youth ministry does a wonderful job demonstrating this. I guess where you and I may differ is when it comes to whether they can be given the “adult responsibility” of making disciples.
It was that very responsibility (in the context of adults who cared for, discipled, prayed for, and encouraged me) that transformed me as a teenager. I’ve seen this calling, this cause, give teenagers a sense of purpose for their Christian lives that pulled them out of the muck of their self-absorption like nothing else could. I believe hurt teenagers can actually find healing as they take others to the hospital. But, to your excellent point, they need to be nurtured, loved, and poured into in the process. Thanks for reminding me of that, Chap!
The teen years, as we all know, are years of learning, excitement, and adventure. Why not tap into that adolescent boldness and point it toward advancing the mission and message of Jesus? I’m convinced that’s what Jesus did with his young disciples. We can too!
Fred, regarding the Gospel Advancing model, you wrote, “It seems to smack of the old ‘fire and brimstone’ approach which, I believe, is one reason why so many teens eventually leave the church.” Fred, that’s the last thing I want. Your words remind me to unpack this more clearly in the future as I share the Gospel Advancing Ministry model with others.
When I refer to evangelism, I’m not talking about stapling gospel tracts to people’s foreheads and bullhorn bullying them into the kingdom. I’m referring to teenagers loving the unreached, building relationships with them, and sharing the good news of the hope that we have in Jesus. I constantly coach teenagers to “engage, don’t enrage” when it comes to reaching their peers with the gospel. Your words reminded me of the need to truly clarify what I mean by evangelism. And you are right in saying that some of the terminology may smell a little “musty.” But, however we phrase it, we need to get our teenagers serious about sharing the good news of Jesus in their communities and contexts.
You also mentioned, “Perhaps if we think of ‘world changers’ as ‘thinking globally and acting locally,’ then I agree with this.” Yes, that’s what I mean. Actually, I would go a step further and say, “Act globally and act locally.” Our teenagers need a global view as well as a local one. They need to work in the soup kitchen and on the mission field—all the while advancing the gospel, of course!
Ron, you critiqued, “What I would like to see is more on the fourth vital element. There is little described about going deep in discipleship; rather, the whole section features going wider by sharing one’s faith.” To be honest, the only reason I didn’t dive deeper into this point is that the vast majority of the teen curriculum out there (to a greater or lesser degree) focuses on teenagers growing deeper in their faith. But I agree that this “deep and wide” emphasis deserves its own page (or chapter)! Teenagers need to grow deeper. I also agree that, ideally, parents are the key driver when it comes to helping teenagers grow deep and wide.
One point I may not have emphasized enough in my chapter is what I mean by the term “Gospel Advancing.” As teenagers advance the gospel externally, it advances deeper into their own hearts. As they share it externally, they own it more and more internally. As they speak the good news to others, they are reminded of all Jesus sacrificed for them and learn to more fully embrace a life of knowing, loving, and serving him out of deep gratitude for this greatest gift of all.
My hope and prayer is that all of our chapters click together like building blocks. I pray along with my friend Chap that youth ministries spiritually adopt these teenagers into their churches so they can be ministered to on the deepest level. I pray along with Brian that teenagers become grounded in prayer, fellowship, discipleship, and the sacraments as they all keep their eyes on the King to bring him the glory that he deserves. I pray with Fred that we help build into teenagers a view of the church that erupts from the idea that we are all “one, holy, catholic, and apostolic church” on mission, both locally and globally. I pray with my friend Ron that moms and dads can be called back to their “D6” mission of being the primary spiritual coach in the lives of their teenagers. And finally I pray that that final piece (maybe the wheels) clicks on to enable youth ministries to mobilize their teenagers to advance the good news of Jesus in their Jerusalem, Judea, Samaria, and to the uttermost parts of the earth!
Thanks again, guys. This has been an exciting journey!

Brian Cosby