The Adoption View of Youth Ministry
The Adoption View of Youth Ministry
The success of youth ministry in this country is an illusion. Very little youth ministry has a lasting impact on students. I believe we’re no more effective today reaching young people with the gospel than we’ve ever been. . . . So let’s be honest. Youth ministry as an experiment has failed. If we want to see the church survive, we need to rethink youth ministry. What does that mean? I don’t have a clue. But my hunch is that if we want to see young people have a faith that lasts, then we have to completely change the way we do youth ministry in America. I wonder if any of us has the courage to try.
—Mike Yaconelli, “The Failure of Youth Ministry,” Youthworker Journal, May 2003
I have an apology to make. In my rush to make deadline my last column communicated the wrong message. What I thought I said and what many people read were two quite different things. I was hoping to throw some cold water on the high profile ministries out there that give the impression they’re attracting gazillions of young people to their ministries and changing the lives of gazillions more. I was trying to level the playing field by introducing a dose of reality. . . . What most of you read was, “Youth ministry is worthless, useless, and not worth doing.” I apologize. The last thing I want to do is discourage youth workers. What I intended (and didn’t accomplish) was to un-intimidate those youth workers who were discouraged because of all the “successful” ministries who were implying results different from the rest of us. . . . Maybe we don’t need a revolution in youth ministry; maybe what we need is what we’ve always needed—a few adults who are willing to follow God’s call to love young people into the kingdom of God no matter what the result.
—Mike Yaconelli, “An Apology,” Youthworker Journal, July 2003. Mike Yaconelli died in October 2003.
Around the time Mike was writing those articles, a local teacher started a small group. Three young men in their senior year of high school, fresh off camp where they together committed their lives to Christ, started meeting weekly with their middle-aged volunteer. They came to read their Bibles, share their struggles, and pray in support of one another. All three were good friends at school, active in youth group, played football together, and knew and liked their adult leader. For two of them, faith was a new thing, and they were excited to learn and grow. The third, raised in the church, had less overt enthusiasm but still was drawn in by his friends’ excitement. Each one became active in church attendance, served as a student leader, and even led younger students. When they were together, going deeply after their faith, sometimes the conversation was passionate, sometimes it felt stiff, and occasionally it just fell flat, but for most of the year the power seemed to be simply in the meeting. Each guy knew that they were cared for, and that when they met, something always good happened.
In spring, as they prepared to graduate and as life got busy, they stopped coming to the youth ministry programs but tried to keep the group together. That summer and through the next fall, they attempted to meet monthly, but it was rare when all four were able to come. The leader tried to stay in touch and connected, but because each one had gone a different way, it was not only less convenient to gather but seemed to be less desired. Soon the group stopped altogether, and soon the leader took on a new small group of incoming freshmen to “pour his life into.”
A few years later, the one who was raised in the church stopped coming to services as well—“I have to work . . .” was his reply when asked. Another started attending a Bible study at his new college. The third became a middle-school leader for a local parachurch organization while attending community college and working. Today, the one raised in the church attends now and then, but comes alone and sits in the back with his girlfriend, leaving immediately after the service is over. Neither of the others stayed involved in a church or ministry. They have simply drifted away. One, when asked via Facebook how he was doing in his faith, simply replied, “That was all great in high school, but I haven’t thought about God in quite a while.” End of conversation.
What became of these three? They were sincere about and invested in their faith. Each one prayed, served, and sought to make Christ Lord of every aspect of his life. One was an outspoken evangelist, and the other two were quieter but not afraid to talk to anyone who was interested. They were known at school for their faith, and people gave them space to live their Christian lives and yet remain socially connected. Their growth was visible and real. Yet around the time they began to look beyond the routine and expectations of high school life, and shortly thereafter, they seemed to see their faith journey as a part of a bygone era as opposed to a radical change of vocation. While Jesus still mattered, at least verbally, for a few years following graduation, the impact their faith had on their choices and lifestyles slowly began to dissipate. Within two to three years after graduation, active engagement in faith, and especially the faith community, had become a thing of the past.
For so many young people, this is their story—perhaps even the majority. There are various academic studies and market research groups that have tried to get at the scope of the issue, yet one thing is clear from all of them: even for those who were active in church or church-related discipleship ministries, by the time they move into their twenties, the faith they once saw as vital and experienced as vibrant became for most of them relegated to the narrative of a stage of life gone by. And there is no current evidence that they will come back when they “stabilize” (meaning, find a meaningful job, get married, and have children). The trends of past decades cannot possibly predict the future in such a wildly changing cultural milieu.
I contend that the primary reason we have lost so many of the hearts and investment of our young when they leave the confines of the high school routine is that we have failed to provide them with the most vital resource they possessed in Christ: the God-given faith community. The leader of that small group of seniors, who happened to be me, was intent on fulfilling the call as a committed and faithful leader. While we practiced our faith together the way we had been taught—we attended church programs, sometimes took notes and discussed the sermons, and participated in the level and kind of Christian community that went beyond most of their peers—even our small little community did not seem to be enough. By the time the three students moved beyond high school, they slowly began to drift from their faith. As much as I tried to help them be faithful, “committed,” and invested, what I had given them was not enough. They were products of traditional youth ministry, each a solid “student leader” and visible follower of Christ. Yet if I am honest, beyond me, they were not as deeply connected to the fullness of the body of Christ—even the one who grew up in the church—as they needed to be. Yes, there are no guarantees, and their story is not the story of all youth ministry products, but it is the story of most. When the youth ministry lights go dim and the faith journey is no longer programmatically handed to them, they are left on their own.
The Historical Backdrop: Why We Are Where We Are
The youth ministry that now commonly functions as the model of Christian adults initiating relationships with young people so that they may come to know Jesus Christ, described by Mike Yaconelli in 2003 as an “experiment,” has been more or less the same for the past fifty-plus years. While some argue that youth ministry started hundreds of years ago when people began to address the needs—both material and spiritual—of vulnerable young people, the way we have come to practice youth ministry around the world began in the twentieth century. The zeal and focus of parachurch movements during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries partnered with churches in reaching out to the young. Most of the young people involved were already identified with a congregation but benefited greatly from the generational focus of groups like Christian Endeavor. A greater recognition of the coming generational fissures was affecting not only advertising, education, and parenting but also religious communities. In the mid-twentieth century, missional parachurch groups like Young Life and later Youth for Christ generally focused more on all young people, not just those who were involved in a church. Throughout and following World War II, the drive to introduce the young to God through Jesus Christ by seeking them out where they lived and gathered, building welcoming relationships, and speaking the gospel to them in terms they could understand had become the basic methodology of the youth ministry “experiment.” In the 1960s and 1970s, churches began to put more energy, staff, and money into the young, and through the influence of emerging leaders, books, training opportunities, and materials like Youth Specialties, what we now know as youth ministry took shape: a group of adults who were willing to invest in the lives of young people and introduce them to a relationship with Jesus.
In 1987, Mark H. Senter III and Warren S. Benson wrote one of the earliest textbooks for youth ministry. Up to this point there had been a handful of books that had helped define and ground the fledgling field of youth ministry in biblical and theological thought, but to many of the pioneering teachers in college and seminary youth ministry classes, The Complete Book of Youth Ministry was the most comprehensive to date.[1] Benson and Senter, as Christian educators, were among the first to bring together in one volume a good number of the most prominent voices in what eventually came to be known as “academic” youth ministry.[2] In the first chapter—“A Theology of Youth Ministry”—as Benson makes the case for grounding the work of youth ministry within the rubric of theology, he lands on the work of Jim Rayburn, the founder of Young Life, and the theological impetus for seeing the incarnation as the “model for youth ministry.”[3] Benson, citing his coeditor, Mark H. Senter III, offered three statements that define youth ministry.
In many ways, The Complete Book of Youth Ministry broke new ground for the thinking and doing of youth ministry. In the late 1980s and early 1990s, as colleges and seminaries across North America and eventually around the world hired faculty and instituted classes and even some degree programs, the idea of youth ministry being on solid theological and pedagogical footing encouraged faculties and administrators, and vicariously churches and pastors, to embrace youth ministry as a worthy field of undergraduate and even graduate study (to say nothing of the potential for greatly increased enrollments).
Around this same time, Wayne Rice and Mike Yaconelli of Youth Specialties, and to a certain degree Thom and Joni Schultz at Group, provided a highly visible platform for writers and speakers to influence the shape, style, and structure of youth ministry. Through their seminars and conventions, and later in their publishing, the speakers and writers were also often the academic leaders of the youth ministry “experiment.” A synergy developed around the pre-web, viral Yaconelli mantra “Jesus and kids; that’s who we are, that’s what we do” that gave youth ministry its philosophical core. Regardless of tradition, denomination, or organization, men and women who were tasked with overseeing a youth ministry program in their church, or who served as Young Life or Youth for Christ leaders, read the same books and articles, went to the same training events and conferences, and perpetuated this universal calling—roughly the same that Benson and Senter advocated: youth ministry begins when an adult “enters a student’s world” and continues “as long as they are able to use their student contacts to draw students” into “maturing relationship with God” (italics mine).
For the past half-century, then, youth ministry has primarily focused on adults building relationships with teenagers for the purpose of helping “each and every young person grow personally and spiritually.”[5] The expression, delivery, and style of this basic premise have been debated, nuanced, contextualized, and dissected over the years. At certain points in the youth ministry landscape, a book or leader would come along and propose a corrective to a perceived movement or trajectory, whether it was pragmatic (as with Mark DeVries’s Family-Based Youth Ministry in 1994), strategic (Doug Fields’s million-plus seller Purpose Driven Youth Ministry in 1998), or programmatic (Duffy Robbins’s Ministry of Nurture in 1990).[6] In each of these and numerous other cases, and for the most part across traditions and denominations, the core has remained committed to individual young people being the recipients of a relational investment of a concerned adult, or group of concerned adults, for the purposes of the spiritual development of the adolescents’ individual journeys. Again, as Peter Benson notes, youth ministry is adults making “contact” with young people and using “their student contacts to draw students into a maturing relationship with God through Jesus Christ.”[7] Although he does not explicitly say this, it is clear that one could easily insert “draw students into a maturing individual relationship with God.”
The common denominator from the very beginning—despite corrective movements, such as including a greater recognition of the parents’ role in their kids’ spiritual growth, the development of a comprehensive ministry strategy, and the need to recognize how deeply growing up in a fragmented culture has affected all young people[8]—has been youth ministry’s focus on the individual. The seedbed of contemporary youth ministry, and where Young Life’s Jim Rayburn developed much of his missional theology, was the “tent meeting” evangelism of the early twentieth century.[9] This movement defined evangelism as the church’s job to share the “good news” with “outsiders” (Col. 4:5). To invite them to personally embrace the Christian faith became the garden youth ministry was planted and cultivated in. Much of the rhetoric summarizing the emphasis on an individual response to the gospel as the goal of contemporary discipleship has become the bumper sticker theology of youth ministry, regardless of tradition, from “Accept Jesus Christ as your personal Lord” (or sometimes “Savior”) to “Become a Christian.” By encouraging a personal decision to conversion,[10] followed by the amorphous “rededication,” the next step for those who had at some point previously “accepted” Christ (usually at camp), youth ministry has been focused on the task of helping “committed”[11] kids to “grow” in their faith. What this means is difficult to precisely pin down, but essentially it is to encourage young Christ-followers to live their lives in a way that is a reflection of how a “Christian” in a given context looks, talks, thinks, and behaves. In youth ministry seminars, articles, and books, “discipleship” is described in the “doing” of faith: consistent Bible reading, regular prayer, active church life, response to social issues in light of their faith, involvement in some sort of “ministry” where they serve others, and the like.[12] Obviously, none of these is wrong or even negative, but are they enough? Or, more important, do they represent the fullness of the call of God in the Scriptures? Perhaps this is what Dallas Willard was describing when he decried the “gospel of sin management.”[13]
For all of the good that youth ministry has done, for all of the lives that have been changed, we have moved into a “post-Christian” culture where the young have fewer relational resources than ever to navigate the complexities of entering interdependent adulthood, and the historic focus on faith as an individual responsibility has left countless young people with an inadequate understanding of the Christian faith. The danger of youth ministry exclusively dedicated to evangelizing and then personally “discipling” individuals during adolescence is that faith at its core can easily become so personal that both the daily walk and the lifelong journey as a Christian is all about and up to me. One may argue that this is not exclusively an issue in youth ministry but one found in the wider North American church, and contemporary youth ministry is no more or less culpable than the church at large. Certainly, the youth ministry models and practices focused on individual faith are a reflection of a greater individualism in society and also in the church. I contend, however, that the common complaint among youth ministers that “we want to teach our kids about community, but there is no community in our church, so we can’t” has become an excuse that youth ministry leaders and practitioners can no longer tolerate. Even if adults in a given church flee intimate relationships, deny the Johannine mandate of “loving one another” (John 15:9–17), and demonstrate in their attitudes and behavior that while they may “love the kids” from a distance, they are at best afraid of them and at worst don’t want them around, this is no excuse for us to perpetuate a gospel of individualistic faith.
Family as Biblical Metaphor
New Testament writers, reinforcing who we are as followers of Jesus Christ post-Pentecost, typically rely on the term “assembly” of God’s people (from the Greek word ekklēsia, translated “church” in most English Bibles). In describing what it means to relate to one another and function as God’s assembly, two primary metaphors are used: we are the “body of Christ” and we are the “family of God.” In 1 Corinthians 12 Paul uses the metaphor of the body to describe who we are in relationship to one another, especially between those who hold more prominent positions or roles and those who live on the periphery, and in contrast to who Jesus is as the “head.” Using this metaphor, Paul is often misunderstood to be describing a categorically prescriptive list of the various “spiritual gifts” that God gives to his people. His argument, in fact, is much more concerned with the reality that Jesus has called us to be his “body” here on earth, even while he takes his place in the heavens as he reigns as Lord, and is therefore much more about unity and participation in the gathering of the assembly than about how one identifies and lives into his or her particular “gift.”
There are two aspects to being the body of Christ in Paul. First, there is the call to the members of the body to function as partnering agents as we collaboratively participate in Jesus’s work on earth bringing the kingdom to its ultimate end. We, as his body, are a primary means by which God has chosen to further his kingdom on earth.[14] The second aspect of living together as the body of Christ is that we are thereby intrinsically connected one to another, without regard to gifts, function, power, status, or age. Paul insists that this “body” is a whole thing—consistent with Hebraic holistic thought where, in contrast to the prevailing Platonic philosophy of the era, there is no separation in a “body”: it is one thing.[15] This concept is central to Paul’s understanding of the church: “There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus” (Gal. 3:28), to which we could safely include, “neither child nor adult.” As Richard A. Gaillardetz notes, “Paul’s theological reflections on the Christian community centered on the metaphor of the body. By speaking of the church as a body, Paul privileged the communal nature of Christian life, a spiritual coexistence, and the interdependence of all the members.”[16] The New Testament is clear on this point: all people who belong to Christ belong to one another in the community, without reservation or qualification.
The second primary metaphor describing who we are as the gathered assembly of God’s people is that we are the “family” of God. Throughout Scripture, God’s people are referred to as his “children” (as in Deut. 14:1, “You are the children of the LORD your God”).[17] Jesus not only refers to God in familial terms, but in the Lord’s Prayer he directs his disciples to call on the Lord with the same level of intimacy, “Our Father, who art in heaven . . .” (Matt. 6:9 ASV). The Spirit also leads us into one of the most sacred of family relationships when we are able to cry out to our “Abba,” essentially to call on our God in the most intimate of family terms (Rom. 8:15).[18] In John’s Gospel, the incarnation is what makes possible our new familial relationship with God, and therefore with each other, by proclaiming that “to all who did receive him, to those who believed in his name, he gave the right to become children of God” (John 1:12). The New Testament writers apply this family metaphor, consistently encouraging believers to see one another as brothers and sisters. In Galatians 6:10, we are admonished to “do good to all people, especially to those who belong to the family of believers,” and Hebrews 2:11 claims that Jesus “is not ashamed” to refer to his followers as his “brothers and sisters.”
Jesus himself affirms how his incarnation establishes the newly ordained family of God when his mother and brothers come to “take charge” of him, and he responds with the rather stark and, in terms of the overemphasis that contemporary Christians place on the institution of the family, harsh question, “‘Who is my mother, and who are my brothers?’ Pointing to his disciples, he said, ‘Here are my mother and my brothers. For whoever does the will of my Father in heaven is my brother and sister and mother’” (Matt. 12:48–50).
Ironically, the call to live as a family, while thoroughly biblical with profound theological implications, is rarely used in the development of a holistic ecclesiology. Yet, as we’ve demonstrated, the reality that God is our Father and we are his children, related not only as sons and daughters but as mutual siblings, is a crucial and illuminating picture for the church, especially in a world of increasing relational fragmentation and isolation. We regularly use words like “community” and “fellowship,” yet these and other similar terms pale in comparison to the concept of a family. Dennis Guernsey, in one of the most insightful books on family ministry, A New Design for Family Ministry, bases his argument on this single principle.
The church is a family of families. . . . The church of the first century were called to leave their earthly familial allegiances and to bond to one another as the new family of God. The revolutionary impact of the first-century church was their love for one another as Christ had commanded them. The need for the church in the twentieth century is to respond as they responded. We are the church and we are family. Let us get on with our business.[19]
Adoption as Ministry Metaphor
If the church is to be, as Guernsey asserts, a “family of families,” then the leadership in power must be proactive in relationally connecting all members of the community, especially anyone who is disenfranchised from the dominant segment of the congregation. The church has the obligation to not only program for this but take the proactive initiative to draw those who feel like outsiders into the center. To strengthen the family imagery for the body of Christ, the apostle Paul employed the term “adoption” to describe the familial privilege we have with God and one another in Christ.[20] The power of this term is that an adopted child, by definition, receives all of the rights and privileges of a “natural” child.[21] Although the church is not often described in family terms, the idea of all members of the body being mutually included and embraced by all is a powerful ministry image, especially as we fulfill our calling to care for those who feel they do not have much of a place or relational standing. The implications for adoption as the goal of ministry present a new way of thinking about the church for everyone—small children, the elderly, the homebound, those who are divorced, the disabled, and, of course, young people, both adolescents and emerging adults.
In terms of youth ministry, where for years the young not only have been seen as a separate population but programmatically arranged to maintain and even reinforce that separation, the only way the church can begin to realize its calling to live as a family is by literally adopting the young. This is the theological and sociological rationale for youth ministry as adoption. Youth ministry is, by definition, ministry to and for teenagers, typically middle and high school students aged eleven to eighteen, and it sometimes includes college ministries. As a group, this population rarely experiences their relationship with the dominant population of the church or society at large as something to which they belong. If the church is indeed intended to be a network of familial relationships, a “family of families,” then the need for a comprehensive ministry strategy to make this happen trumps all other programmatic goals. If people do not know one another, if they do not feel cared for or necessary, and if they do not sense that the rest of the community values them, the church is simply not the church. The church must adjust its vision and structure to ensure that everyone in God’s family experiences their faith as a vital member of God’s household as expressed in the local faith community.
Adoption as the Goal of Youth Ministry
Few would argue that growing up is easier today than it was for previous generations. David Elkind (The Hurried Child) and Robert Putnam (Bowling Alone) expose how our cultural commitment to “hurrying” children is a form of giving them everything they need except for what they need most: adult support and authentic presence. While some systems and programs have sought to push against this isolating trend of abandonment, like the best of youth ministry, the societal forces have simply been too potent. One of the most visible outcomes of this increasing lack of social support and capital, according to many who study the state of the adolescent psyche, is the difficulty our young experience entering into healthy interdependent adulthood. Jeffrey J. Arnett and others have identified a whole new stage of development: emerging adulthood.[22] In every area of life, because there is so little available communal support, it is simply more difficult to grow up. This includes the area of faith development.
When it comes to the quest for a lifelong faith, with the best intentions we present a gospel where God loves them, but that same gospel comes without the long-term, broad-based familial support that they need to grow up into a healthy, mature, interdependent faith. For most, because of the individualistic and programmatic focus of youth ministry, their discipleship often becomes one more thing on the agenda. What we so often offer them is a solitary and individual trek that they are ultimately responsible to complete. In traditional youth ministry, we may use the rhetoric of community to describe our practices, and we believe that what we do actually is an expression of Christian community (although limited to peers and a handful of adults), but generally the best we offer is a shallow and generationally limited approximation of what the New Testament treats as normative. When even the most involved of our seniors graduate from the youth program, their impression of authentic biblical community is a weekly or at most biweekly event where they play the role of observer to a program that others plan and execute.
To know and be known, to intimately participate in a “family of families,” is so foreign that few graduates of even the best youth ministry programs know how or even why to seek it when they leave. The result is that youth ministry creates spiritual orphans where, when the lights are dimmed and the next class arrives, all that the students have to hold on to is a vague sense of personal responsibility. It is no surprise, then, that so many young people no longer align with a church after they graduate.[23]
As we’ve noted, all of humanity was intended for familial community, to experience the shalom of God’s reign as the Father’s sons and daughters: “It is not good for the man to be alone” (Gen. 2:18). Yet somehow we have become so focused on the isolated responsibility of the self in relationship to God, and have so sanctified the “personal journey” of faith, that we have failed our young. Youth ministry, and the church itself, has effectively removed the primary resource that God has given his people for living the life to which we are called: each other. We have left today’s abandoned adolescents as solitary spiritual nomads. For forty years of well-intentioned youth ministry, we have ignored their need for a choir of saints in order to grow up to maturity in Christ. If the gathering of God’s people is not a body, or a family of families, and is reduced to a friendly network of individuals, it is not the way of Jesus, and we are not the church. When we graduate a “solid,” core member of our youth program, even one who is a celebrated “student leader,” who has been an evangelistic force in the adolescent community, is well-grounded in biblical theology and doctrine, but has few or no familial relationships with God’s people driving all of this, we have only brought that person halfway. We have, in essence, created Christian “performers” who have learned that they are loved and blessed when they “take a stand for God” or publicly pray. The issue isn’t whether a young person’s faith is real; rather, it is whether the Christianity we have handed our young disciples is deep and relationally embodied enough in God’s family for them to rely on it in the years to come.
When that young, energetic, and “passionate” disciple moves into her mid-twenties and feels alone and isolated from her roots like so many of her friends from “back then,” who is there for her? Hopefully her parents—or at least a parent—have been able to maintain some sort of bridge to faith, but even in that rare case, who else? Where does she turn when she feels like she has no one who is present who knows her, whom she can turn to when confused or hurt or in need of grace? When that all-star “student leader” eventually lands that first job, or gets married, and yet still gets to a place where he wonders whether the Jesus he knew in high school has any idea who he is or what his life is like now, where does he go? Who is there to remind him of his gifts and calling and impact? The default answer from traditional youth ministry is that our students have all that they need to live into mature Christian faith by finding a college ministry, mentor, or church where they can be nurtured. Many are beginning to recognize we have to do more, to go deeper, like Sticky Faith, which encourages extending youth ministry to a “4 + 1” model to help with the transition out of high school.[24] This is a good first step, but is one more year of connection to a particular ministry enough to provide them with the family God offers them? Without an adoptive model of youth ministry, even those broader ministry strategies focused on parents as disciplers and the most solid youth programs cannot possibly provide the intrinsic participation in the whole of the family of God that our young need to be convinced of their place and worth. It takes the entire faith community, and the global church, to commit to the long-term embrace of children, adolescents, emerging adults, and everyone else who calls Christ Lord to provide the emotional and relational environment God has for all of us.
Clearly along the way there must be an internal, personal commitment to seek out support and invest in a Christ-centered community. Yet, when it takes ten to fifteen years longer to move into interdependency as an adult—and the adolescent/emerging adult journey is by definition a time of transition, self-focus, and vulnerability—the onus falls on the mature in the community to initiate sustaining structures that can envelop the young person while they are within the relational cocoon of middle and high school. They must be convinced when they leave home that their spiritual family, the family of God, is always there for them, regardless of where or how they live. Otherwise, as we maintain the ways we have been doing youth ministry for decades, some may flourish, but the majority are destined to hit that faith wall so many young adults describe. God, while very real in high school, becomes a distant, albeit warm memory from a bygone era.
Youth Ministry as Adoption
What is the answer? The goal of youth ministry must shift away from segmenting young people off from everyone else to offering them a mutual, empowering, engaging, and supportive new family. We must abandon the notion that lifelong faith can be solidified by the time one is in high school and that external expressions of faith—especially emotional (i.e., “passionate”) outbursts and measurable outcomes—do not predict the lifelong story, and we must purpose to collectively reengage and embrace our young as members of our own family. We must rethink youth ministry so as to literally adopt them into the family of the church. Honor their gifts and calling, yes. Celebrate practices, and acts of justice and mercy, and investment in others’ lives and souls for the kingdom, certainly. But underneath and around all of these external effects and markers, we must commit to making sure every young person knows that they matter not only to God but to a large and diverse family because God and his church declare it so. To put it more clearly, The goal of youth ministry as adoption is for every child, every adolescent, and every young adult to be so embraced by the community of faith that they know they always have a home, a people, and a place where they can discover who they are and how they are able to contribute. In short, youth ministry is adopting young people into the family of God.
This definition, then, requires the community of God’s people, the local church, to create a youth ministry marked by the following three distinctives.
1. Personal Response, While Important, Is Not the Point of Ministry.
The Bible is unequivocal in the call of individual people to “come” to God through Jesus Christ. This is described in a variety of ways, such as “receiving” (John 1:12), “acknowledging” (Matt. 10:32), accepting an “invitation” (Matt. 22:1–14), “repenting” (Mark 1:15; literally, to “turn around”), and “believing” (John 3:16; 6:28–30, from pisteuō or pistis, which is usually translated as “believe, trust, or faith”—see Gal. 5:5–6). The call for each human person is to an individual, willful assent to trust God in Jesus Christ. Theologian Louis Berkhof, summarizing the Reformers’ description of “the crowning element of faith,” noted the Latin word fiducia, or “volitional” faith, as the ultimate definition of the call of faith (a trust that is of the will, as opposed to notitia, intellectual assent, or assensus, emotional agreement).[25]
Yet biblically, even a willful assent to the gospel by individually “making a commitment” (which is often used as a synonym for “receiving” or “believing in” Christ) does not take into account that the act of trusting requires the step of aligning oneself with the mission of Jesus (“As the Father has sent me, I am sending you,” John 20:21). This is where the concept of obedience is applied to faith. Jesus himself makes clear that the initial requirement to enter into the family of God is to trust (or “believe,” pisteuō [Greek], fiducia [Latin]) when he told the crowds that “the work of God is this: to believe [trust] in the one he has sent” (John 6:29). For this belief to be actualized, however, there must be an initial step of obedience into the corporate call of faith. Fiducia, without stepping out into that faith by loving “one another,” is not fiducia; at best it is assensus (emotional assent) and/or notitia (cognitive assent). The idea of “trust and obey” is usually packaged together, thus making saving faith conditional on obedience. But the biblical call is to willfully trust. Because of that trust, I therefore take the step of obedience, which begins with the call to “love one another.” Our attitudes, lifestyle, and actions toward immersion in the family of faith demonstrate that we truly believe.
That step of obedience and submission to the Lordship of Jesus Christ, then, is first and foremost an alignment with a life that is forged in intimate familial relationships with one another in the body of Christ. All too often in our zeal to encourage young people to own their faith, we have not helped them to know that the first and constant step of faith is to “love one another,” especially as this is applied to the entire family of God and not simply their small group or biological family. We regularly fail to lead them to the one reality, and one place, where God has supplied to find the encouragement, support, and familial grounding they need to foster and empower fiducia. All too often in youth ministry we forget to help them to see the plural “you” of the gospel call.
Thus, given the biblical mandate of loving one another, the point of youth ministry, and the essential corporate nature of living out faith, is to lead our young (and our old) to express and live out their place as God’s children within God’s family. We must not only model but teach that while personal faith is important, for that faith to take root, for us to be obedient and follow the call of the gospel, we must strive to establish their faith within the familial relationships of the body of Christ. This is not only their calling as believers; it is all of ours. This family of families is our grounding, our home, our destiny.
2. Youth Ministry Is an Important Beginning Point of Adoption.
The reason youth ministry developed was that young people were finding themselves increasingly alienated from dependable adult nurture and regular communal engagement, and they responded by grabbing onto one another as the only source of support and comfort they could count on (other than perhaps their family). It wasn’t that the young left the church; the church left the young. A few adults saw this and responded by initiating relationships with the intent of helping the young to see God as their advocate, and to help them to make faith their own. For decades many kids have responded to this initiative we call youth ministry. In so many ways youth ministry is as healthy and externally thriving as it ever has been. Both parachurch and church-based ministries still see many teenagers come to sincere faith who are active in their communities and able to sustain that faith into their adulthood. A theology of adoption does not mean to say that youth ministry is broken. The way we have operationalized and delivered youth ministry as being primarily about individual faith and discipleship, however, has now caught up to us in today’s atomized society. Finding oneself feeling isolated and alone is bad enough. When a young person moves beyond youth ministry with the idea that personal faith is all there is to the gospel, it is unconscionable. The fall shattered all of creation, and the consequential loneliness and isolation are the essence of the fallen human condition.
God is in the business of restoring that which was broken and bringing shalom—not just the absence of conflict but the sense of rightness and wholeness—to those who are lost (“For the Son of Man came to seek and to save the lost,” Luke 19:10). It is not that youth ministry has failed, it is that it is not enough. Young people, like the rest of us, as members of the fallen race are at core lost and alone. Youth ministry still matters and is indeed a vital entry-level expression of Christ’s love for children and adolescents. Adoption as the goal of youth ministry does not negate the important role of a targeted ministry that incorporates adventure, risk, mission and ministry opportunities, small groups, and the like. Youth ministry as adoption is best conceived as a bridge ministry intent on moving the young beyond peer-experienced faith by leading them into the welcoming arms of the adoptive family of faith. The goal of even the best and most thriving youth ministry must be a strategic commitment toward authentic, inclusive, and participatory adoption.
3. Adult Youth Ministry “Leaders” Are Adoption Guides.
In historical youth ministry, the work rises and falls on the shoulders of volunteers. Youth ministry has never been sustainable as solely the product of a gifted speaker or musician presenting a program from the front. Virtually every model and philosophy of youth ministry presupposes committed and qualified adult volunteers—even those who advocate “student leaders” to “lead” the ministry. There is almost always a recognition that it is a form of abandonment of the young when adults simply offer the programmatic scaffolding of ministry but remain disconnected and in the background. Adults are crucial players in any youth ministry.
The role of adults in youth ministry as adoption, however, must change from “discipling teenagers” to being agents in the adoptive process. In historical youth ministry models, adults usually function in roles such as small group leaders, “advisers,” or quasi–life guides who help individuals—or in the case of small groups, a group of individuals—to “grow in their faith.” For most adults, this lack of clarity to their purpose can be anywhere from confusing to frustrating. The ones who find satisfaction by simply being with teenagers and enjoy relationships with young, energetic disciples tend to stay involved in youth ministry for years. For those adults who are healthy and serve out of a mature faith and satisfying peer relationships, this is the best of contemporary youth ministry. But there are those adult leaders who clutch their role with young people tightly and use their “ministry” as a way to feed their own soul, perhaps in order to avoid the complexities of adult relationships or because they enjoy what kids give to them. In these circumstances, youth ministry can actually undermine healthy discipleship and will always hinder adoption, for those leaders will see their ministries being fulfilled in them. To strategically seek to “pass them off” to the larger family of the church can easily be seen as “losing my kids.” Regardless of the motive, one leader, as good as he or she is, is simply not enough of an expression of the fullness of the body to launch a young person into reliance on and engagement with the family of God.
The adult role, then, whether paid staff or volunteer, is to be the relational and at times programmatic bridge into familial connection in the Christian community. When a small group leader, for example, discovers that a high school junior is a gifted audio technician, then that leader may use that knowledge to find a way to connect that junior to the group of people who are responsible for the worship sound production. The key to this strategy, however, is not to simply use a young person’s skill or interest to connect them to a task. Rather, the tech team is tasked with adopting the teen as a member of the family of God. The junior thinks that he or she is there just to help run the audio mix, but the other adults realize that they are, and are even trained to be, literal adopters of that teenager. Spiritual practices (prayer, sharing, even a Bible study) then become a routine part of their work, and everyone welcomes the young person as if he or she were their little brother or sister, or “adopted” child.
If every adult volunteer and paid staff member has this goal in mind and is committed to not only developing the personal faith of the young people but also seeking adoption for each of them by connecting them to the broader body, they will experience a much more satisfying ministry experience. It is true that even without a clearly delineated commitment to adoption as the goal of youth ministry, some young people will find their way into a meaningful connection to the larger family of the church. A few teenagers, for example, who become preschool “teachers” during corporate worship or who play the bass in the “contemporary” service might find themselves to be organically embraced by caring adults. This does not, however, deny the strategic imperative to make this the goal of ministry for all young people, beginning with children and moving throughout the congregation (this same chapter, for example, could have been written for how a church ministers to senior adults or singles). Youth ministry as adoption seeks this for every young person.
Some churches have made great strides seeking to build relational bridges across generations by offering “intergenerational” programs, events, and opportunities (this, again, is a current outcome of the Sticky Faith movement). This is a good beginning or gateway strategy to move into the direction of adoption, but just because we program for diverse populations to meet and even get to know one another, this alone rarely translates into the same level of connection to create the long-term impact of familial adoption. Just as in a family, adoption is far more than just knowing and being around each other. Family cuts much deeper than building networks of mutual acquaintances.
Adoption, then, must be more than just allowing kids to be known or to serve or teach or sing; it is about them knowing that they are welcomed and embraced as participants in the family and that their voice and heart and perspective matter far more than their service or offering. For a worship leader to say to a singer, “You’re great, we need you! Welcome!” is not adoption. For an elderly couple to regularly seek out and speak to an eighth grader they met at a mission day is not adoption. Even classic models of individual mentoring rarely have the staying power of the multiple and diverse relationships that come naturally with an adoption ministry strategy. When we offer our young people real, mutually participatory familial relationships that go beyond the single mentor, in line with the family and body metaphors especially found in the New Testament, the church becomes a more natural and wide-ranging environment best described as a mentoring community.
When a worship leader, elderly couple, pastor, or middle-aged divorcée begins to appropriately intentionalize familial relationships with appropriate safeguards and boundaries to protect them—when members of the church send out invitations to small group meals, invest in one another’s activities, encourage others to participate in business, pastoral, or ministry decision-making networks, know one another’s stories, and mutually pray for God’s work in and through them—this is adoption.
