Chapter 8 of 13

Adolescent Religion and Life Outcomes

Adolescent Religion and Life Outcomes

Adolescent Religion and Life Outcomes S WE SAW in chapter 4, the majority of teenagers we interviewed said that religion is a good thing. But they had difficulty explaining how faith is particularly consequential or influential in their own lives. Instead, religious faith seems to operate largely invisibly, taken for granted and in the background of their lived experiences. Faith seems to help teens to feel good and maybe to behave better. But then again, many said that their nonreligious peers can be just as good and happy as believers. Many of the religious teenagers we interviewed actually had a difficult time imagining how their own lives would be much different if they were not religious, did not attend church, were not in a youth group.

The question is: Do teenagers know the truth about their own lives? This chapter examines the relationship between different levels of American adolescent religious involvement and a broad variety of outcomes in adolescents' lives. Such an examination allows us to assess whether religion is associated with any difference in teenagers' experiences. Are religious youth any different from nonreligious youth? Is faith actually consequential in the lives of American teenagers or not? Ironically, although many teens cannot see it or are not able to articulate it, according to the findings presented in this chapter, the differences between more religious and less religious teenagers in the United States are actually significant and consistent across every outcome measure examined: risk behaviors, quality of family and adult relationships, moral reasoning and behavior, community participation, media consumption,

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

DAD sexual activity, and emotional well-being. Religiously active teenagers are in fact quite different from religiously disengaged teens in a host of ways, illustrated anecdotally by the contrast between Joy and Kristen in chapter 1, which suggests that there is definitely something about religious belief and practice that shapes adolescents' lives in positive directions. Perhaps it is the work of what remains of America's historical religious traditions. Perhaps

Moralistic Therapeutic Deism is actually accomplishing some of the goals for which its adherents commend it. Perhaps it is both.

After first explaining the method used to compare different types of religious and nonreligious U.S. teenagers, we examine a variety of findings showing clear associations between religiosity and youth outcomes. We then take up the tricky question of causality and selection effects, seeking to clarify whether and to what extent we can with confidence attribute causal influence to the effects of teens' religion per se in the observed positive associations between religiosity and life outcomes. We conclude that we indeed can.

RELIGIOUS IDEAL TYPES

The first goal of this chapter is to assess whether different groups of religious and nonreligious American teenagers vary on different measures of adolescent outcomes. The initial question to answer toward this end is how best to categorize teens along different religious lines to reveal any differences in outcome measures that may exist. Different levels of religiosity in American religious culture are determined not by one but by a variety of dimensions of religion: beliefs, practices, experiences, affiliations, group participation, and so on. One option, therefore, is to run multiple analyses of all outcomes by each religion measure separately, presenting one set of tables focused on outcomes by religious service attendance, another on all of the same outcomes by importance of faith, a third on all of the same outcomes by frequency of prayer, and so on. That, however, would have the undesirable effect not only of multiplying the number of tables of findings beyond what is reasonable, but would also pull apart aspects of religion that in real people's existence conglomerate into lived, organic wholes. Ideally, we would instead devise a measure of religious difference that pulls the various dimensions of religiosity together into meaningful categories. Therefore, to be as clear and crisp as possible in our presentation of findings and in a way that reflects common understandings of religious types of people, we have chosen to create four ideal types of religious and nonreligious teenagers to compare to look for possible differences in their life outcomes. By ideal types we do not mean that no real people actually fit into those categories; most American teens do fit into one or another of the four categories. Rather, we simply mean, first, that the categories have been created around common cultural understandings of specific religious types of people and, second, that to fit into any of the categories the teen survey respondents have to reflect a number of specific characteristics that qualify them to be categorized that way. All of those who

SOUL SEARCHING

do fit those characteristics then belong together in that ideal religious type, and those who don't do not. Specifically, we have created and defined for analysis these four categories:

The Devoted (8% of American youth) Attends religious services weekly or more.

Faith is very or extremely important in everyday life.

Feels very or extremely close to God.

Currently involved in a religious youth group.

Prays a few times a week or more.

Reads scripture once or twice a month or more.

The Regulars (27% of American youth) Attends religious services two to three times a month or weekly.

Faith ranges from very to not very important in everyday life.

Closeness to God, youth group involvement, prayer, and scripture reading are variable but less religious than for the Devoted.

The Sporadic (17% of American youth) Attends religious services a few times a year to monthly.

Faith ranges from somewhat to not very important in everyday life.

Closeness to God, youth group involvement, prayer, and scripture reading are variable.

The Disengaged (12% of American youth) Never attends religious services; or attends many times a year and identifies as not religious.

Faith is somewhat, not very, or not important in everyday life.

Feels only somewhat close to God or less close.

Is not involved in a religious youth group.

Prays one to two times a month or less.

Reads scripture one to two times a month or less.

Sixty-three percent of U.S. teens fit one of these four categories. Thirty-seven percent do not fit cleanly into one of these four ideal-type categories and so are categorized as "other/mixed." Some of them might, for example, satisfy five of the features defining a Devoted teen but not the sixth; these closely approximate the type categorized but do not perfectly fit the ideal type, so are not included. All of those who do fit are ideal types of the category. The following analyses do not focus on those who do not fit cleanly into one of the ideal type categories. This means that not all American teens are included in the analyses represented in tables 34-42. There are nevertheless three important advantages of using this ideal-type approach. First, the ideal types we use to compare teens reflect the concrete way many ordinary Americans normally think about categories of religious people—extradevoted believers, regular churchgoers, sporadic participants, and so}on—much more than any abstract, numerical "scale of religiosity" we might construct from multiple survey variables. Second, we can more clearly identify any differences that exist between the 63 percent of American teens who do fit these quintessen-

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

tially distinct kinds of religious and nonreligious categories without having the comparisons and differences clouded by more ambiguous cases. Third, by combining the multiple dimensions of religiosity into a single set of concrete type comparisons, instead of examining each dimension separately, we can keep the number of tables of findings in this chapter to a reasonable and focused limit.!

Many of the outcomes we examine are also known to sometimes be affected by teen gender, age, race, family structure, parents' education, and so on. The religious ideal types used in this chapter's analyses also reflect significant, though not major, differences among them on many of those demographic variables (see table B.4 in Appendix B). To remove the possible effects of those related variables influencing the outcomes indirectly through the religious ideal types, we use multivariate regression analyses to control for seven key demographic variables—teen gender, age, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income—when testing for statistically significant differences between the religious types on outcome measures, the results of which are reported in the notes of each table. Thus, some of the observed percentage differences between Devoted and Disengaged teens, for instance, may be due to the fact that the former comprises more girls than the latter. But by using appropriate regression techniques to control for teen gender and the six other related variables, we can be confident that differences across the religious types are statistically significant even when the effects of these demographic variables are removed. This can reduce our worries that the observed differences across the religious types are really being produced by nonreligious factors and so making the religion association spurious. The religious associations remain statistically significant in every table, as explained in the table's notes, even after controlling for other key variables. What appear to be religious associations can thus confidently be understood as religious associations in fact.

ADOLESCENT RELIGIOUS TYPES AND LIFE OUTCOMES

What difference does religion make in the life outcomes of American teens?

According to the following tables, actually quite a significant difference. Table

34, for example, compares differences in risk behaviors and getting into trouble across our four ideal religious types. We see there that the more religiously involved teens are much less likely to smoke cigarettes regularly, drink alcohol weekly or more often, and get drunk every few weeks or more often. More religiously involved teens are also more likely to not drink alcohol and not smoke marijuana. By comparison, it is the least religiously active teens who smoke marijuana the most. Among those attending school, the more religiously active teens are much less likely to cut classes in school, to cut a lot of classes when they do cut, and to be expelled from school. They also tend not to earn poor grades in school. Finally, the more religiously involved teens are much less likely to be said by their parents to be rebellious or to have a bad temper. Note that, as explained above, all of the observed differences

SOUL "SEARCHING

Table 34. Risk Behaviors of and Getting into Trouble by Religious Ideal-type U.S.

Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) US.

Religious Ideal Types Devoted Regulars Sporadics Disengaged Smokes cigarettes at least once a day a

Drinks alcohol Weekly or more 5) oe

Never

Has gotten drunk every few weeks or more

in the prior year Smokes marijuana Regularly

Occasionally

Tried once or twice

Never as

Cut class in school last year (school attenders) Six or more times a Z J

Never

School grades are usually Cs, Ds, and Fs

Suspended or expelled from school four or

more times last two years (school attenders) y Parent reports teen is fairly or very

rebellious Parent reports teen has a somewhat or very

bad temper Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers, and omission of some middle-range answers. Cells of <1 are reported as ~. All differences between Devoted and Regulars compared to the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level after controlling for teens' age, sex, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income using linear, ordered logit, or logistic regression techniques; differences between the Sporadics and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls only for the "cuts class" variable. between the Disengaged teens and the Devoted and Regular teens are statistically significant after controlling for seven other demographic variables that we might expect to effect these outcomes. The Disengaged and Sporadic teen differences are, with the one "cuts class" exception, not statistically significant. In sum, American teens who are Regulars and Devoted, as defined above, are doing noticeably better than their religiously Disengaged peers on a variety of risk and trouble behaviors and attitudes. Furthermore, there appears to be a genuine religious difference at work here, net of the effects of seven other potentially related variables.

Turning to table 35, we see a similar pattern played out around issues of media consumption. The most religiously involved American teens appear to watch less television during the week and on the weekends and are much less likely to watch R-rated movies. They are also less likely to use the Internet

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

Table 35. Media Consumption of Religious Ideal-type U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) USS.

Religious Ideal Types Devoted Regulars Sporadics Disengaged Average weekday hours spent watching 2.6

1.8

2.6

2.5

TV Average weekend hours spent watching 5.9

4.4

6.1

5.8

5.4

TV All or most movies and videos teen

watches are rated R Used the Internet last year to view X-rated, pornographic Web sites (Internet users only) Once a week or more

Never

Average number of X-rated, pornoeh, 0.5

1.6

2.6

RS) graphic movies, videos, and cable programs viewed last year Average hours spent playing action 2.9

12) DE, Shi 4.1 video games per week Pct = atc ta hh ce Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

Note: All differences between the Devoted and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level after controlling for teens' age, sex, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income using linear, ordered logit, or logistic regression techniques; differences between the Regulars and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls only for the "R-rated movies,"

"pornographic Web sites," and "pornographic movies" variables; differences between the Sporadics and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls only for the "R-rated movies" variable, to view pornographic Web sites and watch, on average, fewer pornographic movies, videos, and cable programs per year. Finally, they spend considerably less time playing action video games. Again, all of these differences between the Devoted and the Disengaged are statistically significant after controlling for seven potentially related demographic variables, and some of the difference between the Regulars, the Sporadics, and the Disengaged are significant as well. We may conclude, in other words, that real differences exist along religious lines between religiously Disengaged and Devoted teens when it comes to the extent and kind of media teens consume, including kinds that concern many parents and other adults.

Table 36 examines the sexual beliefs and activities of American teenagers across the religious ideal types. Here we see major differences in beliefs about appropriate sexual conduct. Nearly all Devoted teens believe in waiting for marriage to have sex, compared to less than one-quarter of the Disengaged who believe the same. Likewise, only 3 percent of the Devoted believe it is okay for teenagers to have sex if they are "emotionally ready for it," compared to 56 percent of the Disengaged. As to actual physical and sexual behavior, differences in the teens' beliefs are at least somewhat reflected in

SOUL SEARCHING

Table 36. Sexual Belief and Activity of Religious Ideal-type U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) hse Religious Ideal Types Devoted Regulars Sporadics Disengaged Believe in waiting for marriage to have sex

SH a7

Believe it is okay for teens to have sex if

they are emotionally ready for sex Have been physically involved with another

person, more than holding hands and light kissing, since turning 13 Have ever willingly touched or been touched 34

by another person in private areas under clothes Have had oral sex

Have had sexual intercourse

aad?

Average number of sexual intercourse part3.8

Pi 2.6

3.8

4.1 ners (among sexually active teens per group) Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

Note: All differences between the Devoted and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level after controlling for teens' age, sex, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income using linear, ordered logit, or logistic regression techniques; differences between the Regulars and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls for all but the "willingly touched" variable; differences between the Sporadics and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls only for the "sex before marriage" and "teen sex okay" variables. differences in their actions. Twenty-four percent more of religiously Disengaged teens than Devoted teens have been physically involved with another person more than merely holding hands or light kissing. Whereas only 18 percent of the Devoted teens have willingly touched or been touched by another person in private areas under their clothes, 43 percent of the religiously

Disengaged have done the same. About three times the proportion of Disengaged teens have had oral sex and sexual intercourse than Devoted teens.

And, of the sexually active teens in each ideal type group, the less religious teens on average have had intercourse with significantly more partners than the more religious teens. Again, we see across a variety of sexual outcome measures noticeable correlations between the degree of teen religious seriousness and cautious teen sexual attitudes and behaviors. Moreover, statistical significance tests again show the differences between all of the Devoted and the Disengaged outcomes, many of the Regulars and the Disengaged outcomes, and two of the Sporadics and the Disengaged outcomes to be statistically significant after controlling for seven possibly related other variables. As with the risk and problem behavior and media consumption findings, religious variations seem to make significant differences in the life outcomes of American teens."

Continuing this exploration of religion and adolescent life outcomes, we turn to table 37 to examine measures of teenage emotional well-being and

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

Table 37. Emotional Well-being and Attitudes about Life and the Future of Religious Ideal-type U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)

USS.

Religious Ideal Types Devoted Regulars Sporadics Disengaged Feelings about own body and physical appearance Very happy

Very unhappy

How often feels sad or depressed Usually or always ii

Never

Feels alone and misunderstood A lot

ie) Never

Sp Feels invisible A lot

Never

Feels cared for by people responsible for teen A lot

Never

Feels guilty about things in life fairly or

very often Thinks about and plans for the future Very or fairly often

Rarely or never

118) Thinks about the meaning of life Very or fairly often

Rarely or never

How often life feels meaningless to teen Always or usually i a

Never

EN ee Source; National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding, unreported don't know and refused answers, and omission of some middle-range answers. Cells of <1 are reported as ~. All differences between the Devoted and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0,05 level after controlling for teens' age, sex, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income using linear, ordered logit, or logistic regression techniques, except the "feel guilty" variable, which is significant at the 0.10 level; differences between the Regulars and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls for all but the "feel guilty" and "invisible" variables; differences between the Sporadics and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0,05 level with those controls for the "feel sad," "plan for future," and "think about meaning" variables. life and future attitudes. Here again we find significant differences between the more religious teens and religiously Disengaged teens, contrasted in this table with opposite answer categories. The more religiously serious teens are more likely than the Disengaged to feel very happy and less likely to feel very unhappy about their body and physical appearance. The Devoted and the Regulars are likewise significantly less likely to feel sad and depressed, alone

SOUL SEARCHING

and misunderstood, and invisible as a result of nobody paying attention to them. Furthermore, the less religious the teens are, the less they feel cared for by people responsible for them. Moreover, very religious teens are no more likely than other teens to feel guilty, popular stereotypes notwithstanding.

The more religious teens are also more likely to think about and make plans for the future, as well as to think about the meaning of life. And life tends much less often to feel meaningless to more religious teens than to less religious teens. Again, on every measure examined, teen religious seriousness and involvement is positively associated with greater well-being and more positive perceptions of and attitudes about life and the future, net of the possible effects of all seven control variables.

Much existing research has suggested the crucial importance in adolescents' lives of meaningful relational ties to parents and nonparent adults— grown-up friends, teachers, mentors, coaches, other parents—who can help watch over, care for, and provide resources to teens. Are there differences across our religious ideal types in such ties to nonparent adults? Table 38 shows there are indeed significant differences. The more religiously involved teens, first, tend to be more comfortable talking with adults other than parents or relatives. The Devoted in particular have a larger number of nonparental adults in their lives whom they can turn to for support, advice, and help. Moreover, the parents of the more religiously serious teens are more likely to know more of the supportive adults in their teen children's lives well enough to talk to them, expanding the reach of what sociologists call "netTable 38. Adult Ties of Religious Ideal-type U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17

(Mean averages unless otherwise noted) USS.

Religious Ideal Types Devoted Regulars Sporadics Disengaged Fairly or very comfortable talking SZ

to adults other than parents or relatives (percentages) Number of adults teen can turn to Si, 8.4

So) 4.9

5.0 for support, advice, help, not including parents Number of supportive adults teen's 4.6

Tiss!

4.6

3.8

3.4 parents know well enough to talk to Average afternoons per week spent 2.6

D3 Mehl 2.8

without adult supervision Average evenings per week spent

Aa Ds 2.1 without adult supervision Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

Note: All differences between the Devoted and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level after controlling for teens' age, sex, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income using linear and ordered logit regression techniques; differences between the Regulars and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls for only the "comfortable talking with adults" and "parents know supportive adults" variable.

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

227. work closure" around religious teens more than nonreligious teens.* The religiously Devoted teens are also less likely than their less religious peers to spend their afternoons and evenings without adult supervision. In sum, the lives of more religious teens are, compared to less religious teens, statistically more likely, net of all seven control variables, to be linked to and surrounded by adults, particularly nonparent adults who know and care about them and who themselves have social ties to the teens' parents. All of which tends to contribute to more positive, successful outcomes in youth's lives.

What about teenagers' relationships with their parents and siblings? Does religion appear to make a significant difference? Table 39 shows that Devoted and Regular teens are significantly more likely than Disengaged teens to feel close to, get along with, and hang out and have fun with both their mother and their father. Both are also more likely than the Disengaged to feel that their parents understand them, love and accept them for who they are, and pay enough attention to them. The more religious teens are least likely to think their parents give them either too much or not enough freedom to develop and express their own views about important issues, and thus are most likely to say their parents give them the right amount of freedom. Moreover, the Devoted and Regulars tend to eat more dinners per week with one or both of their parents than do the Disengaged. Finally, the more religious teens tend to get along better with their siblings than the less religious teens. Again, as the table note explains and as with the many differences examined above, these religious differences remain statistically significant even when the possible effects of other control variables are removed. There seems to be something about religion per se that positively associates with better family relationships.

Table 40 explores the comparative moral reasoning and honesty behaviors of American teens as categorized into our four religious ideal types. Once again we observe some remarkable differences. As measured by one survey question, 22 percent of Devoted teens and 61 percent of the Disengaged are moral relativists. When asked how they would decide what to do if they were unsure of what was right or wrong in a particular situation, only 1 percent of the Devoted said they would choose to "do what would help them get ahead," and 6 percent said they would "do whatever would make them feel happy."* By comparison, 16 percent of the Disengaged said they would choose what would help them get ahead and 40 percent chose what would make them feel happy. Furthermore, four times the number of Disengaged than Devoted teens often lie to their parents, while more than twice the proportion of Devoted than Disengaged say they never lie to their parents. Finally, the most religious teens are significantly less likely to cheat on schoolwork and to do things they hope their parents never find out about. All told, when it comes to moral reasoning and honesty, the differences between the most and least religious American teens are conspicuous and significant.

What about compassion for less fortunate, more vulnerable people? Do American teens differ in moral compassion and commitment to justice by religious type? Table 41 shows that the more religious teens, indeed, profess

SOUL SEARCHING

Table 39. Quality of Family Relationships of Religious Ideal-type U.S. Adolescents with Mothers and/or Fathers, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) (Teen reports)

U.S.

Religious Ideal Types Devoted Regulars Sporadics Disengaged Feels extremely or very close to mother

Gets along with mother extremely or

very well Has fun hanging out and doing things

with mother very or fairly often Feels extremely or very close to father

55)

Gets along with father extremely or very

well Has fun hanging out and doing things

with father very or fairly often Teens feel parents understand them alot

oY,

Teens feel parents love and accept thema

HE:

lot for who they are Teens feel parents pay a lot of attention

to them Amount of freedom parents give teen to develop and openly express own views on important issues Too little freedom ils}

The right amount of freedom

Too much freedom

Average nights per week teen eats dinner Sill 67, SY) a0) 4.6 with parent or adult guardian Gets along with siblings in household (teens with siblings only) Very or extremely well

Not so well, pretty poorly, or very

badly Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

Note: Some percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding, unreported don't know and refused answers, and omission of some middle-range answers. All differences between the Devoted and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level after controlling for teens' age, sex, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income using linear, ordered logit, or logistic regression techniques; differences between the Regulars and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls for all but the "get along with siblings" variable; differences between the Sporadics and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls only for the "close to mother,"

"get along with mother," "have fun with father," and "parents understand" variables. on our survey to be much more compassionate than the less religious teens.

The Devoted are more than twice as likely than the Disengaged to say they care very much about the needs of poor and elderly people in the United

States. The Regulars and even the Sporadics are also significantly different from the Disengaged on these questions. The Devoted are likewise significantly more likely to say they care about racial equality. Once again, as stated

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

Table 40. Moral Reasoning and Honesty Behaviors of Religious Ideal-type U.S.

Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) WS:

Religious Ideal Types Devoted Regulars Sporadics Disengaged Believes that morals are relative, that there

are no definite rights and wrongs for everybody If were unsure about what was right or

wrong in a particular situation, would choose to do whatever would help them to get ahead If were unsure about what was right or Pi

wrong in a particular situation, would choose to do whatever would make them feel happy Lied to parents in the prior year Fairly or very often

Never

Cheated in a test, assignment, or homework in school in the prior year Fairly or very often

Never

Did things they hoped their parents would never find out about in the prior year Fairly or very often

22, Never

iN)

Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding, unreported don't know and refused answers, and omission of some middle-range answers. All differences between Devoted and Regulars compared to the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level after controlling for teens' age, sex, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income using linear, ordered logit, or logistic regression techniques, except for the "cheated" and "did things hoped parents would not find out about" variables, which were not significant for the Regulars only; differences between the Sporadics and the Disengaged are not statistically significant for any variables. in the table notes, these differences are statistically significant even when controlling for other demographic variables that may also affect the outcomes.

Thus, more religious teens appear to possess greater moral compassion and concern for justice than their nonreligious peers—and apparently for religiously related reasons and not simply because of differences in their demographic compositions.

Finally, do professed feelings and attitudes of concern for others appear actually to get worked out in actions differently among more and less religious American teenagers? Table 42 examines differences in levels of community participation, volunteering, and giving between different types of American teens. First, we see that religious seriousness is associated with involvement in all types of organized activities. The Devoted and Regulars are involved in more than the average number of organized activities of all

SOUL SEARCHING

Table 41. Moral Compassion of Religious Ideal-type U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) WES:

Religious Ideal Types Devoted Regulars Sporadics Disengaged Personally cares about the needs of poor people in the United States Cares very much

Does not really care

Personally cares about the needs of elderly people in the United States Cares very much

oul Does not really care

Personally cares about equality between different racial groups Cares very much

Does not really care

Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

Note: All differences between the Devoted and the Regulars compared to the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level after controlling for teens' age, sex, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income using linear, ordered logit, or logistic regression techniques, expect for the "care about racial equality" variable for the Regulars; differences between the Sporadics and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls for all but the "care about racial equality" variable.

U.S. teens, while the Sporadics and Disengaged are involved in fewer. We also see large differences by religious type in teens' giving of their own money to organizations or causes. The Devoted are more than three times as likely as the Disengaged to have given more than $20 of their own money. More religious teens are also significantly more likely to do noncompulsory volunteer work or community service, with the Devoted twice as likely as the Disengaged in doing so (50 compared to 25 percent). Furthermore, the most religious tend to volunteer or do community service more often than the less religious. They are also significantly more likely to engage in the kinds of volunteer and service activities that bring them into contact with racial, economic, and religious differences, which helps generate what social theorists call "bridging" social capital that fosters social cohesion and trust.' Moreover, religiously Devoted teens have helped homeless people, needy neighbors, family friends, or other needy people a lot directly, not through an organization, at twice the rate of the national teen average (20 compared to 10 percent), while the Disengaged have done so at less than half of the rate of the national average (4 compared to 10 percent). The Disengaged are also more than twice as likely as the Devoted never to have helped other needy people directly (37 compared to 17 percent). Last, in their community participation, religiosity also correlates with organizational involvements that provide teens with experiences that cultivate their leadership skills. Whether or not those organizations include religious organizations, the more religious teens are much more likely to have been part of planning an event, leading

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

Table 42. Community Participation of Religious Ideal-type U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) USS.

Religious Ideal Types Devoted Regulars Sporadics Disengaged Average number of regular, organized PRA Bil 2.4

2.0 iss) activities, clubs, classes, or organizations involved in Has given more than $20 of own

money to any organization or cause Regularly or occasionally did volunteer

Po) work or community service in the prior year (not counting required service, e.g., by school, juvenile justice program) Average total number of times per

1.07

month teens did volunteer work or community service in the prior year (not counting required service, e.g., by school, juvenile justice program) Did volunteer or service work that

aS)

brought teen into a lot of direct contact with people of a different race, religion, or economic class Helped homeless people, needy neighbors, family friends, or other needy people, not through an organization A lot

None

Involved in an organization last year

in which teen planned an event, led a meeting, or gave a presentation or speech Involving organizations not oT.

exclusively religious ORCL IV Cay Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

Note: All differences between the Devoted and the Regulars compared to the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level after controlling for teens' age, sex, race, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income using linear, ordered logit, or logistic regression techniques; differences between the Sporadics and the Disengaged are statistically significant at the 0.05 level with those controls for all but the "times per month volunteered" and "planned an event" variables. a meeting, and giving presentations or speeches. Thus, far from being "too heavenly minded to be of any earthly good," it is the more religious teens who are the most involved in their communities. And, as with the findings in the tables above, these observed differences in community participation, volunteering, and giving between more and less religious teenagers are statistically significant even when using statistical techniques that neutralize any effects of demographic composition differences between the religious ideal types. In other words, even if there were no differences between the examined

SOUL SEARCHING

religious types in race, sex, region of residence, parental marital status, parental education, and family income, religious differences in outcomes would remain significant.® "sh Religious communities may be tempted simply to feel good about these findings—and they clearly do have some reason for taking heart that their work with teens may not be inconsequential. But viewed from a different, more self-critical perspective, as judged by the norms and expectations of their own teachings and traditions, some religious communities have some cause for concern. A glass half full is also half empty. These tables do show that religiously involved teenagers are doing relatively better than religiously inactive teens. But they also show that significantly large minorities of teens who regularly attend religious services, for example, do not have particularly good relationships with their parents, appear to be moral relativists, act dishonestly in various ways, are sexually active, do not particularly care about racial equality in the United States, do not feel comfortable talking with adults, are not in any habit of giving money to other organizations or causes, and are not particularly involved in the civic life of their communities. Nobody is perfect. And different people and communities have different standards on many of these issues. Still, very many American religious communities have commitments, teachings, and expectations to which some of these results suggest more than a few quite religious American teens are not living up. The point is not that sociology stands in a position to chastise religious communities or people. The point is simply that the findings above can be interpreted from more than one perspective and that fair-minded observers of American religion, including American religious believers themselves, do well to consider the insights and implications of multiple points of view— including those that may provide unhappy news or difficult challenges.

That said, standing back from all of these tables and viewing them as a whole, we can draw some larger summarizing conclusions. First, ironically, contrary to many youth's own inability to see or articulate the influence or importance of religion in their lives, religion does in fact appear to be a significant factor that does make a considerable difference in a host of life outcomes. And these observable differences are not scattered and uneven but emerge regularly across a wide variety of adolescent attitudes, experiences, relationships, behaviors, and beliefs. The consistency across outcomes is truly striking. Moreover, as we have repeatedly noted, the religious differences across the outcomes are consistently statistically significant, at least when comparing the most and least religious, even after controlling through multivariate statistical techniques for the effects of seven other key demographic factors that might affect the outcomes through the religious types. The religion-outcome association remains, net of these controls, suggesting that there is something about different levels of teen religiosity per se that correlates with differences in teen life outcomes. Religion itself indeed does appear to matter in some way in the formation of teens' lives." Furthermore, we can observe in the tables a certain threshold of teen religiosity below which the religious association appears not often to operate. Mere sporadic investments

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

and involvements by teens in religion usually prove indistinguishable in outcomes from those of teens who are completely disengaged from religion. Religious associations with more positive life outcomes generally appear to require teens reaching the level of religiosity of at least the Regulars to be statistically significantly different from the Disengaged.

A modest amount of religion, in other words, does not appear to make a consistent difference in the lives of U.S. teenagers. It is only the more serious religious teens, the Regulars and Devoteds, whose outcomes are more consistently and significantly more positive than those of their entirely religiously Disengaged peers.

If all of this is so, then why do teens have such trouble seeing and articulating this religious difference in their own lives and that of their friends?

We believe there are two answers to that question. First, most American teenagers lack perspective on their own lives. Because they are young and their personal experiences are so immediate, they simply have a difficult time understanding and describing their lives from any larger, more objective, comparative viewpoint. And because for so many teens religion is such a takenfor-granted aspect of their lives, they have a nearly impossible time thinking about how their lives would be different if they were more or less religious.

Second, and we think most important, nearly all American teenagers believe that they are not influenced directly by anything at all, religious or otherwise.

Like most of the adults who have socialized them, teenagers take for granted an image of themselves as autonomous and self-defining individuals fully responsible for and capable of the formation of their own lives. Many teenagers actually bristle at the suggestion that they are directly influenced by people and institutions outside of themselves. Their conventional view, rather, is that others—peers, friends, parents, the media—merely provide them with information and options, but that they as autonomous individuals fully in control of and responsible for themselves make their own choices and actions independent of any external influence. This unselfconscious embrace of American individualism thus makes it very difficult for teens to perceive and explain how religion may directly influence their lives. Religion cannot, because nothing does. They are influenced by themselves. We know, however, that Americans' faith in autonomous individualism is naive. People's lives are normally in fact profoundly defined and shaped by many of the social relations, cultures, and institutions in which their lives are embedded.* All of sociology teaches this basic insight. This chapter's tables also suggest the real religious difference in teen's lives.

But is it religion itself that is causing the difference? That is the next question.

EXCURSUS: THE COMPLEXITIES OF CAUSAL INFLUENCE

Religion is significantly associated with positive outcomes across a variety of important youth attitudes and behaviors.' But can we make the inference that religious faith and practice themselves play a causal influence role in explaining these associations? Social processes of causal influence are complicated

SOUL SEARCHING

and worth thinking through carefully. The cross-sectional data on which many analyses of youth religion and outcomes are based, including the analyses in this chapter—which are gathered at one point in time rather than with the same subjects over multiple points in time—make it difficult to determine the time-ordering of key factors and the direction of cause and effect between religion and youth outcomes. Normally, all we can say with confidence is that a certain correlation exists between certain religious factors and other outcome variables. We can legitimately speak of differences in levels of youth outcomes between religious groups or types, and of statistical associations between religious variables and outcome measures. With crosssectional data, however, we typically cannot clearly establish the time-order of potentially important factors or claim that religious factors actually causally influence outcomes in the lives of youth. This is because the observed associations may be the result of different (or combinations of different) possible processes involving dissimilar relationships and directions of causal influences.

In the following pages we draw on current social research about religion as a possible causal influence in the lives of U.S. teenagers to help properly interpret the findings of tables 34-42. In short, below we suggest that the observed positive association between greater teen religiosity and positive life outcomes cannot be explained by one simple causal mechanism. Rather, the observed association is most likely the result of a combination of complex causal social processes, some of which recognize the operation of what scholars call the "endogeneity problem" in specifying sociological causal relations.

This combination, we believe, likely does involve the possibility that higher teen religiosity may select on certain personality types, such as "risk-averse,"

"conventional," or "joiner" personalities, which themselves may be more likely to be correlated with more positive life outcomes. Such selection processes complicate the commonsense inference that greater religion causes more positive outcomes in adolescents' lives. We further suggest that some self-selection or reverse causation processes also likely partially explain the observed religion-outcomes association above.

Nevertheless, although we do believe that these other complicating processes likely help to explain some proportion of the religion-outcomes associations observed in tables 34-42, we also believe that established, solid empirical research and theorizing justify the inference that various features of religious faith and practice themselves influence more positive outcomes in U.S. teenagers' lives. We thus conclude that it is not mistaken to interpret the greater positive outcomes in the lives of more highly religious U.S. teenagers as likely caused in significant part by direct influences of features of committed religious faith and practice. Religion, we suggest, is part of what helps produce the more positive observed outcomes in teenagers' lives.!° Before going there, however, we must consider other likely causal mechanisms in the larger, complicated combination of causal processes that help to interpret the findings in tables 34-42.

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

Personality Selection One potential causal process that may help partially explain why more religious U.S. teenagers appear to enjoy better life outcomes is the possibility that certain hard-wired personalities tend both to be attracted to religion and to have better life outcomes. Some scholars have suggested that certain genetically grounded personality types—variously described as risk-averse, conventionalist, conformist, clean-living, and joiners—affect both religiosity and outcomes. Some studies seem to support this hypothesis. Steven Reiss has found that young people valuing order, honor, and family is correlated with higher religiosity, while their valuing vengeance and independence is correlated with lower religiosity. In another study, Reiss and S. M. Havercamp found that devoutly religious people display lower levels of an independence trait. Other scholars have suggested an empirical relationship between religion and risk aversion. Mark Regnerus reports finding among teenagers an association between certain personality factors—having a hot temper, liking to take risks, and a lack of planning—and religiosity. More highly religious teens are less likely to possess those personality traits, and the more teens possess those personality traits, the more likely they are, according to Regnerus, to have trouble with outcomes like family relationships, health, and stealing.!! Hard-wired personality selection on religion and better outcomes, therefore, may help to account for some of the observed positive association between greater religiosity and more positive life outcomes.

Available evidence, however, suggests that personality selection does not itself entirely explain away the religion-outcomes association. Regnerus's most systematic effort to test the personality selection hypothesis with national adolescent data, for example, finds that, although personality, religiosity, and outcomes are indeed all related, the strength of the direct associations between religion and positive life outcomes are barely diminished when multiple personality factors are introduced into multivariate regression models. In other words, both personality and religion variables predict life outcomes, but personality type does not attenuate religion's statistically signifcant direct effects on life outcomes.'? It also deserves mentioning that hard-wired personalities do not necessarily mean absolutely immutable personalities. It could well be that, for some youth, religion can act back on personality types, softening, redirecting, or stretching them in new ways. For example, religion could channel a risk-seeking teenager away from the allure of drug abuse, unprotected sex, or skipping school and toward the challenges of a third world missions project or teaching rock climbing at a religious summer camp. In any case, evidence suggests that personality selection may play some role in the religion-outcomes association observed among U.S. teenagers. Still, if that is so, it is nevertheless likely only one causal process among others operating in a larger, more complex combination of influences.

SOUL SEARCHING

Reverse Causation A second causal possibility that we suspect is at work in the religious lives of some U.S. teens is a reverse causation process. The idea here is that some youth likely self-select out of religion when they get into trouble or experience some other negative outcome in life. In other words, some religious youth who, for whatever reasons, develop negative or self-destructive attitudes and behaviors subsequently reduce their religious involvement and so count on surveys as less religious, thus creating observed associations between religiosity and positive outcomes for those who did not drop out of religion because of their lack of negative outcomes. In which case, religion is not influencing positive or negative outcomes in the lives of youth. Instead, other, nonreligious factors explain different levels of family problems, delinquency, substance abuse, civic involvement, and positive attitudes about life among youth. Yet, if teenagers do for these other reasons become depressed, begin taking drugs, get in trouble at school, or develop poor relationships with their parents, they also may tend to reduce or drop out of whatever religious involvements they previously had. As a result, these negative-outcome youth sort themselves out of the pool of youth who are religiously involved. So, when researchers find positive correlations between religiosity and constructive youth outcomes, it is not because youth religiosity influenced those outcomes; rather, it is because the youth with the negative outcomes moved themselves out of the higher religious categories, leaving behind other youth with (not religiously influenced) better average outcomes.

For example, in a hypothetical church youth group of 20 teenagers, four youth from bad neighborhoods, broken families, and poor schools may start to get into trouble for selling drugs, shoplifting, and fighting. Feeling uncomfortable for various reasons with the program and other kids in the church youth group, to reduce their cognitive and emotional dissonance these four now delinquent teens stop attending church and youth group altogether. A subsequent survey of these 20 youth would then observe a strong correlation between higher youth group involvement and avoidance of delinquency. But the church and youth group themselves could hardly take credit for producing that association, because it was actually the troubled neighborhoods, families, and schools that helped produce the negative outcome of their delinquency, which religion was not able to prevent. To the extent that this process is operative, religion itself is not influencing youth toward good outcomes, but is only being avoided by youth with worse outcomes by making them feel uncomfortable and driving them away.

The best available evidence suggests that this kind of reverse-causation process may help to explain some but not all of the positive association between adolescent religion-outcomes observed in tables 34-42. Good empirical studies on the question using longitudinal data have produced mixed results.

Brent Benda and Robert Corwyn, for example, have found not only that religion predicts lower levels of delinquency on certain outcomes, but also

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

the reciprocal effect: that delinquent behaviors predict a subsequent decline in youth religiosity. Similarly, Arland Thornton and colleagues have found that while marriage without previous cohabitation tends to increase the religious involvement of young adults, cohabitation also tends to reduce religious service attendance. Using longitudinal data, Mark Regnerus has likewise found that adolescent involvement in theft decreases subsequent religious service attendance and self-reported importance of religious faith.

On the other hand, Ann Meier's two-wave panel study of 15to 18-year-olds shows that first sexual intercourse between the survey waves did not significantly reduce or increase religiosity for boys or girls, contradicting her "religiosity adaptation" hypothesis that having sex will result in lower levels of religiosity among adolescents. And Steven Burkett's three-wave panel study of high-schoolers likewise shows that eleventh-grade girls and eleventhand twelfth-grade boys who had been drinking alcohol more heavily in the previous year were not more likely to reduce their religiosity as a result; heavier consumption of alcohol the previous year exhibited only a weak significant association with reduced religiosity for twelfth-grade girls.'

Recall, too, that our own study specifically asked teens who had reduced their levels of religiosity why they had done so. Of the nonreligious teens in the NSYR who had been raised in a religion and were asked why they had become not religious, few said something like they were beginning to get into trouble in life and started to feel uncomfortable in religious settings (table

28). The majority of them mentioned intellectual skepticism about faith or other quite vague reasons for losing their religion. Likewise, few of the NSYR teens who had stopped attending religious services that they had previously attended more often, when asked why they reduced their attendance, suggested anything like selecting themselves out of religious participation because delinquency, sexual activity, deteriorating relationships with parents, trouble at school, or other signs of poor outcomes made them feel disinterested in or uneasy with religion (table 31). Again, the vast majority had no clear reason for stopping attending, were simply disinterested, moved locations of residence, or stopped believing what religions taught. It could be that getting into trouble and consequently feeling uncomfortable in religious settings really were the reasons many of these teens became not religious and stopped attending religious services, and that they simply did not want to say so. But, if so, we found scant evidence for it.

In sum, it appears plausible if not likely that, at least with some outcomes, some teens who engage in religiously nonnormative behaviors may subsequently tend to reduce their levels of religious involvement. And this may help to account for some of the religion-outcomes associations observed in tables 34-42. We do not believe, however, that the available quantitative and qualitative evidence support the conclusion that reverse causation explains most or all of the variance in outcomes among different religious types. Most likely, reverse causation is one among a combination of relevant causal processes.

SOUL SEARCHING

Direct and Indirect Religious Effects A third causal process that we believe helps to explain the findings of tables

34-42 is what to many people will be the commonsense interpretation: that religion actually does causally influence positive outcomes, that religious practices themselves influence youth in ways that produce positive outcomes in their lives. The idea behind this possibility is straightforward: there are certain features in religious practices per se, some of which we elaborate in the next section, that have the capacity directly and indirectly to produce positive outcomes in the lives of youth. Something about religion itself causes the good outcomes for youth. By general implication, teens who increase their religious involvement should, net of other factors, reduce their chances of experiencing negative and harmful outcomes; and teens who reduce their religious practices should, net of other factors, increase their risk of negative and destructive outcomes. There are, of course, a number of specifying subvariants of these processes worth noting, accounting for conditions, exceptions, and limits possibly affecting religion's influence. One subvariant could be that religion particularly influences teenagers who are more at risk for negative outcomes, but exerts less influence among more typical adolescents.

Alternatively, religion may effectively promote and maintain positive outcomes among those already doing well in life, but may not possess the ability positively to influence youth who are already heading or deep into trouble.

It could be that religion exerts a protective influence on early and middle adolescents but becomes less of an influence among late adolescents, or vice versa. It might be that the dominant religion in the United States, Christianity, exerts significant causal influences over its adolescent adherents, but that minority religions for different reasons exert less influence.

A number of other subvariant hypotheses are conceivable and potentially empirically testable. In any case, each of them essentially represents a specification of the basic idea that something about religious practice itself causally affects outcomes in youth's lives.

Another possible complication of this religious influence process is that religion may exert causal influence on the outcomes in youth's lives not directly, but indirectly, through nonreligious mechanisms of influence. The idea is that religion need not directly influence some outcome in order to have a significant influence on that outcome. Religion can exert influences indirectly, through other factors. For example, religion may reduce delinquency in the lives of teenagers, not in some direct way, but indirectly by strengthening families, which in turn reduces delinquency; thus, greater religiosity produces stronger families, which then reduces delinquency. Religion still exerts causal influence, but strengthening families is the mechanism by which religion reduces delinquency. If this process were modeled incorrectly, a researcher might wrongly conclude that it is strong families and not religion that reduces delinquency, when in fact religion would reduce delinquency by its influence on and through the quality of family life.

Still another model of this religious influence process might suggest that

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

youth and families who, for perhaps nonreligious reasons, are already predisposed toward the outcomes of positive attitudes and practices choose to become more religiously involved as one strategy to achieve that end. This hypothesis suggests that observed positive outcomes in youth's lives are not only the result of the influences of religious practices per se, they may be driven by larger, preceding, perhaps nonreligious life orientations of youth or their families to be good and do well in life, to avoid trouble, to be as happy and involved in life as possible. Such people then choose to implement a variety of strategies at different levels and in different areas of their lives to achieve this kind of generally positive, constructive life. Religion is one such instrumentally chosen strategy, which itself is as much the result of a more fundamental, potentially nonreligious orientation toward positive life outcomes as it is a causal influence on those outcomes. Note that it is extremely difficult here to sort out which factor was causally prior to the other. Perhaps the general life orientation to be good and do well in life, to avoid trouble, and to be as happy and involved in life as possible is as much the result of generationally prior family religious involvement as it is the cause of it. Much here depends on the limits of our assumptions and adequacy of measures.

But note that either version of this possible causal process locates significant religious effects on youth attitudes, behaviors, and experiences. This view posits that religion can have an influence on positive youth outcomes. It merely attempts to move back one step in the causal sequence by suggesting some antecedent factor that explains religious involvement and positive outcomes. But clearly religious practices still exert some causal influence on outcomes; that is precisely why in this model basically constructively oriented people become involved in religion: because religion actually helps them achieve their purpose of living positive, constructive lives. Recognizing that positive outcomes are likely also the results of other, nonreligious factors, such as basic positive life orientations, does little to challenge the idea that religion likewise influences outcomes, because nobody claims that religion is the only factor influencing youth's outcomes in life. What these other versions of the religious effects process do is point out possible complexities in the ways religion may influence people's life outcomes.

To summarize: sorting through the alternative causal processes potentially involved in explaining the observed association between greater teen religiosity and more positive life outcomes is complicated business, more technically complicated than this chapter can thoroughly address.'* The bottom line, however, is this: our review of existing scholarship, our analysis of NSYR and other survey data, and our experience interviewing hundreds of teenagers around the United States persuades us that no single causal process or mechanism entirely explains the positive religion-outcomes findings in tables 34—

42. Human life is too complicated for that. We believe that some proportion of certain of the religious differences in outcomes observed in the tables are likely explained by such processes as personality selection and reverse causation. We also believe, however, that religious faith and practice can and often do exert causal effects on outcomes, that religion itself can and often

SOUL SEARCHING

does operate as a causal influence in youth's lives.1* Moreover, we must bear in mind that there are prima facie reasons for supposing that religion possesses the capacity to socialize, motivate, constrain, and direct human, including teenagers', assumptions, values, preferences, moral commitments, choices, and behaviors. It is in fact one of the bread-and-butter tasks of the sociology of religion to show empirically that religious beliefs and practices do causally shape outcomes in people's lives. Decades of research in that field accumulate to suggest the plausibility of the idea that religion can exert a causal influence on human consciousness and action. Again, in any given case, the possibility of spuriousness is real, but until it is demonstrated, it remains only a possibility. Meanwhile, scholars are justified in getting on with the business of providing most plausible interpretations of research findings. And this may well involve interpretations positing that religious influences per se can and may indeed have causal effects in forming the lives of people, including youth. More empirical research is needed to help better sort through the alternative and conjunctural causal possibilities around this question.'¢

This chapter is merely one piece of a larger puzzle.

Another key task in interpreting the findings of tables 34-42 is theorizing more specifically the sociological processes by which religion might influence outcomes in adolescent lives. If religion does influence outcomes in youth's lives, as we have suggested, can we explain how exactly that might happen?

Possible religious effects on teen outcomes can only be as plausible as the specific causal mechanisms we can theorize by which that may operate. So, why or how might religion influence the lives of American teenagers? It is to answer these questions that we turn next.

THEORIZING RELIGIOUS INFLUENCES IN ADOLESCENTS' LIVES

If we are to believe that religion exerts some causal influence in the lives of youth, we must better specify how or why it may do so. What is it about religion that might produce positive outcomes in the lives of teenagers? We suggest that religion may exert positive sociological influences in the lives of American youth through nine distinct but connected and potentially mutually reinforcing factors. These nine distinct factors cluster as groups of three beneath three larger conceptual dimensions of social influence. These three larger dimensions are moral order, learned competencies, and social and organizational ties. The nine specific factors that exert the religious influences are moral directives, spiritual experiences, role models, community and leadership skills, coping skills, cultural capital, social capital, network closure, and extracommunity links. The following pages elaborate these nine distinct but connected and potentially mutually reinforcing factors that we suggest account sociologically for religion's recurrent positive, constructive influence in the lives of American adolescents.17

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

Moral Order The first three factors influencing youth we conceptualize as dimensions of the cultural moral orders into which religions induct their adherents. By moral order, we mean to suggest the idea of substantive cultural traditions grounded on and promoting particular normative ideas of what is good and bad, right and wrong, higher and lower, worthy and unworthy, just and unjust, and so on, which orient human consciousness and motivate human action.!® Importantly, these distinctions of judgment and valuation within moral order are understood as not established by people's own desires, decisions, or preferences, but are believed to exist apart from and above them, providing standards by which human desires, decisions, and preferences can themselves be judged. It is under this larger category of moral order that the first three of the nine factors should be understood, as follows:

1. Moral directives: American religions promote specific cultural moral directives of self-control and personal virtue grounded in the authority of long historical traditions and narratives into which members are inducted, such that youth may internalize these moral orders and use them to guide their life choices and moral commitments.

This is to say that, as American adolescents go about forming practices and making choices that compose and shape their lives, religion can provide them with substantive normative bearings, standards, and imperatives to guide those practices and choices. Normally, these substantive normative directives and orders operate to foster forms of self-control toward the learning of virtues and values often expressed in positive, constructive ways. For example, different religious traditions teach their young adherents moral commitments, such as tithing from one's income for the church, synagogue, and the common good; seeking reconciliation instead of vengeance; treating one's body as the temple of the Holy Spirit; honoring one's parents and elders; avoiding self-indulgent gluttony and sexual promiscuity; respecting the dignity of others because they are made in the image of God; faithfully fasting during Ramadan; acting in honesty and fairness even at a cost to oneself; practicing Zakat, the giving of alms to the poor as Allah commands, the Four

Noble Truths, the Eightfold Path, the Five Precepts, and so on. Most religious organizations bring to these moral commitments the authority of long historical tradition and compelling narratives. The observable significant associations that religion does have with youth in various outcomes may in part be explained by the cultural moral orders that religion provides that orient consciousness and motivate action."

Of course, religions are not the only source of such moral directives and orders. Indeed, all cultures are constituted by and expressive of moral order."°

American youth, therefore (as do all modern people), live within and between multiple moral orders among which they have to negotiate, balance, compromise, and choose. Religion represents one of many potential normative

SOUL SEARCHING

orders claiming youth's allegiance and adherence. While other nonreligious moral orders (which may have deep historical roots in religious moral orders, yet have subsequently been secularized) may promote virtues and values similar to those of a religious moral order, clearly not all do. For example, as the previous chapter noted, the moral order of mass-consumer market capitalism and the advertising industry it deploys with great influence on American youth does little to promote self-control, moderation, the common good, sacrifice, honor for others, and other traditional religious virtues. Rather, contemporary American capitalism and advertising tend to promote among youth a moral order whose "virtues" include self-gratification, self-assertion, competition, insecurity, conformity, perpetual experimentation, contempt for traditional authorities, the commodification of all value, and incessant material acquisition. Thus, when various religious speakers say that they struggle against "the culture," they mean that they are up against other moral orders antithetical to their religion's moral order that vie for loyalty and conformity.

2. Spiritual experiences: American religions provide the organizational contexts and cultural substance fostering in youth spiritual experiences that may help to solidify their moral commitments and constructive life practices.

The point here is that moral directives are not simply imposed from the outside by traditions and organizations. Individuals do not simply conform their consciousness and actions to moral orders like chameleons changing colors to match their environment. Rather, humans internalize moral directives and orders in their subjective mental worlds of identity, belief, loyalties, convictions, perceptions, interests, emotions, and desires. And these subjective commitments prove often to have a fair amount of stability and continuity (if not consistency and coherence) for individuals over time. They also help to frame the issues and inform the motivations that shape outcomes in the lives of youth. Religious youth are facilitated in this process by personal spiritual experiences that often legitimate and reinforce their religious moral order.

Whether it is a conversion experience, an answer to prayer, a sensation of deep spiritual peace, a perceived word of divine guidance, the witnessing of a miracle, or something else, the religious moral orders of youth (and adults) are substantiated and reinforced in ways that bolster the influence of the moral orders on outcomes in their lives. From a sociological perspective, religious experiences tend not to float down from the sky as autonomous or self-generating encounters. Rather, sociologists are attuned to how spiritual experiences often arise from the immediate or distant contexts of religious traditions and organizations. Youth normally have conversion experiences in churches that emphasize conversion, just as youth typically witness miraculous faith healings who belong to religious cultures that emphasize prayers for healing. This does not make the experiences any less real or authentic or perhaps divinely inspired. It simply acknowledges that humans are socially constituted beings. Consequently, religious organizations and traditions pos-

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

sess the contexts and resources to help facilitate such spiritual experiences, which, in turn, often solidify the moral orders that shape various outcomes in youth's lives.

3. Role models: American religions can provide youth with adult and peer group role models, providing examples of life practices shaped by religious moral orders that constructively influence the lives of youth, and offering positive relationships that youth may be invested in preserving through their own normatively approved living.

Also solidifying the moral orders that shape various outcomes in adolescents' lives are the embodied normative models provided to youth by adult and peer role models. Religion supplies not only moral order and spiritual experiences that authenticate and fortify moral order. Religion also supplies fellow congregants, companion disciples, wise elders, exemplary representations of life shaped by the religious moral order. In many cases, religion also provides or points out the opposite: explicit cases of examples of people who have violated the moral order, fallen from grace, exemplified vice and foolishness, and so on. These help to make moral order tangible. They provide a teleological direction for growth and development. They show what a good (and perhaps bad) human life looks like, furnishing an instructive example of right (and wrong) living.2! Moreover, when youth develop relationships with such positive role models, that raises the cost to youth of violating the moral order, because that would likely damage the relationship. The youth come to be personally invested in sustaining the relationships, which normally will involve affirming and enacting the religious moral order. This can often have positive, constructive consequences in various outcomes in the lives of youth.

For example, a young person in a religious context may come to know and admire and prize a relationship with his or her youth leader, or devout aunt, ot young adult friend who has taken a particular interest in him or her. This relationship communicates to youth that people they hold in positive regard are committed to the religion's moral order and have learned with some success how to live it out in their lives. This provides them with a microplausibility structure for that moral order and a model for possible emulation."

Furthermore, the valued relationship with the youth group leader (or aunt or young adult friend) as role model tends to provide an incentive for the youth to continue to enact the religious moral order himself or herself in order to sustain the conditions for maintaining the valued relationship. All of this, we suggest, can work to reinforce the positive attitudinal and behavioral outcomes noted above.

Learned Competencies Religion shapes the lives of American adolescents in ways beyond the formative influence of moral order. A second major way that religion can influence the life outcomes of youth is by increasing their competence in skills and

SOUL SEARCHING

knowledge that contribute to enhancing their well-being and improving their life chances. Here we explicate three distinct learned competencies that religion may afford American youth.

4. Community and leadership skills: American religions provide organizational contexts where youth can observe, learn, and practice valuable community life skills and leadership skills, which are transposable for constructive uses beyond religious activities.

Most American religions take concrete form as congregational voluntary associations. As such, they provide their members, including adolescent members, with multiple and continuous opportunities to observe, learn, and practice the skills of community life and leadership. Religious congregations are ever in need of members to serve on committees, to organize programs, to provide leadership, to coordinate initiatives, and so on. Functional religious congregations also require ongoing member involvement in fundamental organizational processes. In and through this, religious youth may find themselves organizing a car wash, facilitating a Bible study, arranging a trip to Israel, sitting in as a youth delegate on a church committee, serving as altar boy or girl, helping to coordinate a social justice march, assisting in a tutoring program, planning a retreat, sitting in on a congregational meeting, reading scripture in a service, and much more. In so doing, religious youth are exposed to and have the chance to acquire and practice a series of useful capacities and skills. These may include group decision making, raising and budgeting funds, leading discussions, mobilization consensus, public speaking, enacting rituals, building coalitions, conducting meetings and services, and resolving disagreements. Learning such skills clearly enhances the religious capital of youth.?? But, following the Tocquevillian tradition, we can see that these skills may also be transposed and deployed for use in multiple nonreligious settings.2* ,The community and leadership capacities that American youth learn in religious congregations may serve them equally well throughout their lives, in study groups, student government, sports, neighborhood organizing, political activism, professional activities, business ventures, civic involvement, and beyond. Thus, religious communities may inculcate in youth abilities that can increase their confidence and functional capacities, which may enhance their well-being and life outcomes.

5. Coping skills: American religions promote a variety of beliefs and practices that can help believers cope with the stress of difficult situations social psychologically, to process difficult emotions, and to resolve interpersonal conflicts, and so enhance the well-being and life capacities of youth.

Life presents most people with various degrees of ongoing problems, obstacles, troubles, crises, and tragedies. Different people possess differing capacities to confront and deal with these difficulties. In general, people who are better able to address, cope with, negotiate, and resolve life's problems prove

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

also to be more healthy and functional. Most American religions comprise and foster many beliefs and practices that can strengthen young people's ability effectively to cope with life's problems."' Religions often offer youth a variety of cognitive and behavioral resources to address and process life's mental, emotional, and interpersonal stresses and troubles. These may include practices of prayer, meditation, confession, forgiveness, reconciliation, Sabbath keeping, small group sharing, funeral rites, cleaning rituals, and more.?®

They may also include the beliefs that a loving and omnipotent divinity is in control of one's life, that all things work together for the good of those who love God, that God understands and shares in one's suffering, that ultimately good will be rewarded and evil punished, that a divine Providence is guiding one's steps, that suffering builds character, that God gives the strength to confront and overcome injustice, and much more. Clearly, nonreligious youth are able to draw on coping mechanisms that are not obviously religious, such as "live and let live," "one day at a time," "they'll get theirs," and "try to put things into perspective"—although many of these maxims in fact do ultimately have religious roots. But religion at least can greatly expand the range of possible beliefs and practices that adolescents may draw on to deal with their life problems. Beyond that, it is possible that for some people, the sacred, divine, transcendent, cosmic, and historically traditional nature of many religious coping-enhancing beliefs and practices provides them with greater significance, depth, and power than perhaps their secular counterparts.2" For many, "nothing can separate you from the love of God" is somehow more profound and compelling than "it'll all work out in the end."

Likewise, participating with countless generations of believers in prayer and affirmation by reciting a millennia-old liturgy is somehow more meaningful and comforting than reading the various quips in the most recent edition of Chicken Soup for the Teenage Soul. Thus, religion may provide American adolescents with extra or more effective coping mechanisms for negotiating and resolving their mental, emotional, and interpersonal stresses and problems.

6. Cultural capital: American religions often provide youth with alternative opportunities (beyond family, school, and the media) to acquire elements of cultural capital that may directly enhance the well-being of youth, and may be transposable to other social settings for constructive purposes in youth's lives.

Scholars have suggested how important possession of cultural capital may be in enhancing one's life chances.?* Cultural capital in this context consists of unevenly distributed and socially distinctive tastes, skills, knowledge, and practices that are embodied as implicit practical knowledge, skills, and dispositions and objectified in particular cultural objects and credentials."

American youth enjoy a variety of contexts in which they might acquire cultural capital, including family, school, voluntary associations, and the media.

American religions, however, often provide their youth with increased and

SOUL SEARCHING

alternative opportunities to appropriate more and distinct kinds of cultural capital. For example, in American religions, children and adolescents may grow in biblical literacy, so that they better understand the Western historical context, the prophetic and wisdom traditions, scriptural moral teachings, and more. Furthermore, in religious congregations, youth can also acquire substantial musical education through participation in choirs and choruses, exposure in services to rich traditions of sacred music, learning to sing fourpart harmonies for hymns, and opportunities to play piano, guitar, or other musical instruments for worship. In addition, in the course of their religious education and practice, American youth are often exposed to and may learn about world civilizations and empires (the Babylonians, the Egyptians, the Roman Empire, etc.), Western history (the Middle Ages, the Reformation, etc.), major religious traditions (Jewish, Protestant, Catholic, etc.), major holiday traditions

(Easter, Ramadan, Rosh Hashanah, etc.), major ethical traditions (ascetic, pietistic, sacramental, natural law, etc.), and important theological categories (holiness, moral law, incarnation, repentance, etc.).*°

All of this, of course, enhances for youth the meaning and value of their religious participation. But, in addition, simply because familiarity with the Jewish and Christian (and Greek and Roman) traditions is a precondition for truly understanding Western history, civilization, and culture, acquiring through religion the knowledge and appreciation of such matters described above can also tremendously advantage youth who accumulate this cultural capital. Adolescents who have soaked up the various kinds of cultural capital available through involvement in their religion may have gained a relative edge over those who have not, in a variety of ways.*! Other factors being equal, they will likely converse more comfortably with a broader array of social contacts, perform better in their humanities and social science classes, be more impressive in the lunch and dinner conversations of their job interviews, and more. All of this tends to work toward positive, constructive outcomes in youth's lives.

Social and Organizational Ties The third major hypothesized dimension of religious influences on American adolescents concerns the social and organizational ties religion affords young people. In this we move beyond the cultural orders that shape moral judgment and action, and beyond the advantaging skills and capacities individuals can acquire. Here we are discussing structures of relations that affect the opportunities and constraints that young people face, which significantly affect outcomes in their lives.

7. Social capital: American religion is one of the few, major American social institutions that is not rigidly age-stratified and emphasizes personal interactions over time, thus providing youth with personal access to other adult members in their religious communities, affording cross-generational network ties with the potential to provide extrafamilial, trusting relationships of care

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

and accountability and linking youth to wider sources of helpful information, resources, and opportunities.

It is difficult to overestimate the importance for youth of the transgenerational and age-variable character of most religious organizations in the United

States. Most American adolescents live the vast majority of their extrafamilial lives in age-stratified institutions and consuming age-targeted products and services. Perhaps most important, American youth spend about 35 to 40 waking hours per week for between 12 and 17 years in mass-education schools that sort them into classes by single-year age differences. Teens thus spend the greater part of their weekdays with and being socialized by their age-identical peers. In off-school hours, they often spend many hours watching television programs that are also targeted for their specific age groups.

Another major use of time by young people is in sports, hobbies, and play, also very often spent with other youth of similar age.*? Structurally, therefore, the schedules and institutions that organize youth's lives tend to isolate and limit their contacts, exposures, and ideas to those available from others their own age. In such situations, trends in and pressures from peer groups become highly influential and narrow.

American religious congregations, by contrast, represent one of the few remaining major social institutions in which adolescents participate extensively that emphasizes continuity of interaction and yet is not rigidly stratified by age.°? In these religious organizations, adolescents gather together with fellow believers of all ages and life course stages. While some religious programming may be age-stratified, most central congregational functions (worship services, fellowship gatherings) mix participants of all ages. As a result, youth are exposed to many adult members of their religious communities.

This creates the possibility for forming significant relational network ties that cross age boundaries. And those ties generate the potential for relationships with older congregants who may express care for youth. Adolescents' ties to older members of their religious congregations may also afford them access to otherwise less available sources of opportunities, resources, and information. The more (strong and weak) adult ties youth have in their religious congregations, the more likely they are through them to land a good summer job, be recommended for acceptance into a competitive program, know someone who can and will help them fix their broken computer or car, and much more. All of this helps to foster and reinforce positive life choices, behaviors, and outcomes.** 8. Network closure: American religious congregations can provide relatively dense networks of relational ties within which youth are embedded, involving people who pay attention to the lives of youth and who can provide oversight of and information about youth to their parents and other people well positioned to discourage negative and encourage positive life practices among youth.

SOUL SEARCHING

The oftentimes unique cross-generational network ties that religious congregations facilitate not only potentially provide youth with important flows of information, resources, and opportunities; they also structure relational networks that facilitate more informed and effective oversight and control of youth by adults who care about them. James Coleman has theorized the importance of network closure, suggesting that higher densities of social relationships among youth, parents, and other interested adults, and among parents whose children are friends, are associated with improved youth outcomes.35 Others have also suggested that high levels of social network closure benefit youth indirectly by enabling parents more effectively to monitor and supervise their activities, communicate with other parents about their expectations and behavior, and feel supported in their own parenting.** As one of the few major American social institutions that emphasizes ongoing social interaction not rigidly stratified by age, religious congregations provide ideal settings for increasing closure in networks involving youth. In religious congregations, adolescents are able to form relationships with youth ministers,

Sunday school teachers, choir directors, rabbis, parents of friends, and other adult acquaintances, who can relationally tie back to the adolescents' parents.

These ties can operate as extrafamilial sources reinforcing parental influence and oversight. Because of the social setting, parents of adolescents in religious congregations, compared to schools or sports teams, for instance, are better able to build relationships over time with their children's friends and the parents or kin of their children's friends. Moreover, these relationships are very likely to exist among people who share similar cultural moral beliefs, facilitating higher levels of agreement and cooperation in collective oversight and social control. All of this we expect to create conditions of increased support for and supervision of youth, encouraging positive and discouraging negative behaviors among youth.

9. Extracommunity links: American religions typically comprise links to national and transnational religious organizations, providing youth with connections to positive experiences and events well beyond their local communities, which can expand their horizons and aspirations, foster developmental maturity, and enhance competencies and knowledge.

Finally, participation in the organizations of American religion very often affords youth structural connections to beneficial programs and organizations at the regional, national, and international levels. The vast majority of American religious organizations are not completely autonomous, but are linked to larger associations, denominations, conventions, and other regional and national organizations. This is as true for Southern Baptists and black Muslims as it is for Reform Jews and Roman Catholics. These regional and national organizations and associations very often involve denominational and parachurch programs, organizations, and other opportunities specifically designed to serve youth. As a consequence, local religious involvement can plug adolescents into an almost endless array of summer camps, youth retreats,

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

missions projects, teen conferences, service programs, Holy Land trips, music festivals, denominational conventions, the hajj to Mecca, and any number of other socioreligious activities. These programs and activities likely strengthen the religious faith and commitment of youth but they probably often do more than that. We may expect that, by moving youth out of local contexts and presenting them with new experiences and challenges, these programs also open up youth's imaginable aspirations and horizons, encourage their developmental maturity, and increase their knowledge, confidence, and competencies. This should, in turn, tend to reduce unhealthy and antisocial attitudes, choices, and behaviors among these youth. Once again, religion is not the only means by which adolescents might link to these kinds of larger programs and organizations. There certainly exist plenty of nonreligious summer camps, service projects, and travel opportunities. Yet, organized religion adds to these a massive superstructure of youth-oriented programs and activities that significantly increases the chances that youth will participate in and benefit from them.

Here, then, are nine sociological factors that we hypothesize as helping to explain significant observed positive associations between higher teen religiosity and more positive life outcomes. To add nuance to our argument, however, it is necessary to offer three qualifications. First, this theoretical account presumes that these nine influences do not typically operate independently, but often together and in combination as mutually reinforcing social processes. For instance, the social capital effects of religious communities could not be operative were it not for the religious moral order factor drawing cross-generational networks together over time in the first place. At the same time, those social capital effects help to reinforce in youth the cultural moral orders that religious communities promote. This reality of interdependence can present the researcher with interpretive difficulties in assessing the source or type of religious influence from a standard measure of religiosity.2"7 Nevertheless, we suggest that although these factors are believed to be interrelated and mutually reinforcing and interpretive difficulties abound, it may still be best to conceptualize these factors as analytically distinct influences.

The second qualification of the theory is that obviously not all religious organizations provide their youth with the same quantity or quality of these constructive resources and influences. Some provide most of them in high quality; others provide only few of them or offer them in weak form; and yet others may neutralize whatever good they do provide by including other detrimental practices and influences, such as abusive leaders, adult hypocrisies, and dysfunctional organization. We are not advancing a categorical claim about the effects of American religion on youth, merely theoretically exploring processes and forces that may help explain the religion-outcomes associations seen in the findings above.

Third, as we have already acknowledged, American religion is not the only place where many of these kinds of social influences might affect the lives of youth. Alternative parallel contexts include community programs,

SOU LoeSEARGHING

purchased lessons and instruction, and other nonreligious voluntary associations. Nevertheless, religious organizations are uniquely pervasive organizations in American society that do strongly encourage youth participation.

And religious organizations can provide cultural moral orders characterized by impressive scope, depth, and authority, often typically matching and often surpassing other kinds of voluntary associations or purchasable services.

Therefore, we suggest they deserve particular theoretical and empirical attention for their effects in the lives of youth.

At the same time, we must also pay attention to the possibility that religion sometimes does not positively influence adolescent outcomes and may even negatively influence adolescent outcomes. None of the above suggests that religion always or invariably has positive, constructive effects in the lives of youth. First, the larger claim here is probabilistic, not categorical. Second, religious traditions do vary, and certain religions and particular circumstances may produce negative effects in the lives of adolescents, which deserve to be investigated and theorized. We might hypothesize, then, that when religious involvement does not have significant positive effects among American youth it may be for the following reasons:

1. Inadequate supply: Some religious communities in which youth are involved provide few of the influences enumerated above, or only weak versions of them.

2. Failure to appropriate: Some youth in religious communities that do offer constructive influences may, for whatever reasons, choose to remain largely detached, marginal, and uninvolved, and so fail to engage and benefit from positive religious influences.

3. Disruptive events: Some youth who are being constructively influenced by religious involvement may have that influence disrupted and negated by specific detrimental events (such as the divorce of parents, abuse by a religious authority, disorienting tragedy, or unreconciled falling-outs with people in the religious community) that the positive religious influences are for various reasons unable to counter or overcome.

4. Competing influences: Some youth being constructively shaped by religious involvement may have those influences overwhelmed by counterinfluences from interactions in other social associations (neighborhood, work, school, the media, etc.) that promote competing moral orders and practices (risk behaviors, delinquency, family conflict, apathy, school dropout, etc.).

Some research has investigated destructive tendencies among mainstream clergy.** Other scholars have noted potentially destructive aspects and outcomes of youth participation in some religious movements." Religion may also hinder the educational attainment of some types of youth.*° Thus, religion's potential for detrimental and antisocial effects in the lives of American youth is also an issue deserving further consideration and development in future empirical and theoretical work. But those avenues of research should

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

DES AN not overshadow the broader, important observation of religion's generally positive associations observed in this chapter.

HOPE AND PRAYER IN THE CITY

What do these processes of religious influence look like in actual teenage lives? They can, of course, look quite different in various cases. We conclude this chapter by recounting the story of one teen whose life illustrates many of the kinds of positive religious influences discussed above. The teen in this case qualifies among the categories analyzed above as religiously Devoted and so quite clearly illustrates the religion-outcomes association observed in this chapter.

Antwan is a 16-year-old African American Southern California boy who, along with a 13-year-old cousin, lives with his grandparents in a rented house in a workingand middle-class neighborhood troubled by racial tensions between blacks and Mexicans. Antwan's mother lives nearby, and his father, a recovered drug addict, lives about an hour's drive away. Antwan is tall and thin. An extremely happy and outgoing kid, he wore shorts, a red T-shirt, and a black Nike headband and wristbands to the interview. His parents divorced when he was a baby. At first, he lived with his mother, then, when he was 8 years old, he moved in with his father, but his father's drug problem forced him to move in with his grandparents three years prior to our interview. Antwan likes, respects, and obeys his grandparents, who are in their

50s, and today gets along very well with both of his parents, who have since settled their differences and are now friends. "I'm real close to all of them, we can talk about anything, we get along real good," he reports. Antwan enjoys music, sports, movies, and video games. He plays the drums, the trumpet, the French horn, and the saxophone. He also plays basketball and football and hopes someday to be a professional sports player. What Antwan says he most enjoys in life, however, is "seeing my parents get along well."

Antwan is highly involved in his church, where many of his extended family relatives are members. He describes people at his church as warm, caring, loving, and accepting. While he was growing up, neither his mother nor his father took him to church much, so it wasn't until moving in with his grandparents that he began attending. "With my grandma I had no option, I just had to go to church [laughs], and I appreciate her for doing that."

Antwan greatly enjoys church services: the singing, the dancing, the praying.

He is an usher at church and serves on the church security team. He also attends Bible study on Wednesday nights and church youth group on Sunday evenings. He says of his youth group, which calls itself YES for Youth Experience Success: "It's real powerful and encouraging. We have our own dance group and host our own breakfasts. We're having our own back-toschool jam in September with live music and singers. It's important 'cause we're all in unity and it gives youth a place to go that's positive, so you won't have to go to wild parties, you'll always have a positive place to go. fal

252,

SOUL SEARCHING

wasn't in this group, I'd say about 30 percent of my friends would be real bad." Antwan once attended a regional religious youth conference called

"Acquire the Fire," which he remembers fondly for its fun activities and the teens he met there. oF Antwan is so enthusiastic about his faith community and experience that he has gotten all of his friends involved in church. "My grandmother," he explains, "always tells me I'm a leader and not a follower, 'cause I led a lot of people to church. I told them, and once I started going, they saw me and started going, too. I think they view me as a positive role model. Not all go to the same church, sometimes we visit each others' churches." Antwan also clearly benefits from adult role models at church. In particular, he names his youth group leader, Craig: "He's real tall, like, man, like 6'9", yeah, and he looks exactly like Shaq [Shaquille O'Neal], too. I really get along well with him 'cause he takes us to lots of stuff and shows us that he really cares about us." Antwan described how Craig helped him work through personal struggles and doubts by helping him see that everyone struggles with such issues.

More generally, he explains, "When I was younger, I had anger problems, about my dad, and had an attitude and took it out on everybody. But people at church still loved me for that and were really good 'cause they accepted me and encouraged me. Church has done a really good job at helping me to learn. It's a good place to go 'cause they're not gonna lie to you, they're gonna keep it real and tell the truth." Antwan says he has good relationships with all the adults in his life, except one uncle, who he says "tortures" the younger cousins. Besides his grandparents, he really admires his favorite pro basketball player, Tracy McGrady, " 'cause he's a cool basketball player, plus he does wise stuff with his money, he doesn't spend it on drugs or fancy cars, but helps people and helps his family and stuff."

Antwan claims that he did not believe in God when he was younger, "but some things that happened I knew it could only be God in that situation."

One of those situations solidifying his faith was his father's religious conversion and turning away from drugs:

My dad used to be a rapper and had a real drug problem and would leave me at home by myself and stuff. When I moved in with my grandparents, he said he didn't want to have nothin' else to do with me, which hurt me. I was very angry. My grandmother told me, "Just pray about it and God will figure it out for you, he'll help you," and I said okay and I prayed about it. Later, my dad became a Christian and went into rehab and now he goes to church and is a Christian rapper. And I knew it was God that made him change his mind, and now we're really, really, really, really close together now. He comes and picks me up about every other weekend. I can talk to him about anything. Now we're like, me and my dad are like the bestest friends.

Oh, yes, faith changed it, really, and I was like, if God can do that, then he can do other things for me, too.

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

Antwan says he has also witnessed miracles, such as crippled people in wheelchairs being able to walk after his pastor prayed over them: "They got out of the wheelchair and started walking and I was like, 'Yeah, that's a miraclea;"

Antwan says his religious faith is "the top priority" in his life. "I'm very religious and I'm very spiritual," he reports. "I'm always praying for someone

'cause they always ask me to pray for them. The main thing is to lead people to God, that's what makes me spiritual." And what is God like? "I think about, like, this almighty person that made heaven and earth and stuff. He's the highest of the highest, like, doesn't go no higher than him." All this, he says, he learned from reading the Bible. He states that he feels "really close to the Lord, I could talk to him like, about anything." He reads the Bible every day because "it gives me wisdom and shows me how to deal with certain situations, like with anger and lust and lying and stuff like that." He also prays very often, making up his own prayers that rhyme: "It's like talking to God, some of it sounds like a song, like a little rhyme or a poem." On Sundays, Antwan says, he worships, rests, prays, listens to Christian music, and gets together with his friends "to pray for the people who can't pray, like in the hospital and stuff, 'cause they're in pain, so we pray for them."

Antwan's aunt also coordinates a continual prayer group at church in which participants are assigned to pray throughout a particular hour during the week, so he spends regular time praying for his friends and family in that way. Does he resent having to spend two nights a week at church? "Un, I feel it's fair [laughs], 'cause God only asks us for, like, two days and I think that's fair. It's fairer than school, school asks for five days and God asks for only two, so, that's fair." Antwan also tithes 10 percent of his allowance and paycheck, " 'cause that's what it says in the Bible, and really 10 percent is not that much, once you think about it." How often would he attend church if it were entirely up to him? "Um, as much as I could. You have to practice faith, you can't live it all by yourself, you need to go to church because church helps you get closer to God." And how do his religious practices affect his life? "They're very important. It makes me a happier person to know that I'm doing everything that I'm supposed to and that my grandparents and them don't have to go behind me and watch what I do. It used to be less, I didn't used to read the Bible every day, but now I'm doing it every day on a consistent basis and I see it affecting my life." Is it okay to pick and choose religious beliefs or to practice more than one faith? "No, 'cause that's like playing with God and making him mad, 'cause there's a God and some people believe in different gods, but I think you should believe in the one and only

God because he's the one that made the earth and stuff. I don't think that's okay, that's being disloyal to your own religion."

Antwan says that he disagrees with moral relativism. "There is right and wrong, it's just some people they don't wanna own up to it." Where do his moral views come from? "Um, nothing but my training and my grandparents." He believes it is wrong to smoke, drink, do drugs, cheat in school, get

SOUL SEARCHING

into fights, and lie to parents. "Your parents, they brought you into the world for a purpose, to obey your parents, so you shouldn't have to lie if you're obeying them in everything," he says. Antwan's grandparents are also consistent but forgiving disciplinarians, he reports. There is a lot of opportunity and pressure to get into drinking, drugs, and sex: "People keep coming and say, 'Oh, if you don't do it then you're not cool,' but we basically just say,

'It may not be cool but we ain't gonna be the ones dying from it either.' It's pressure on us but we don't let it pressure us, cause we know we're gonna say no." Knowing his father's history with drugs, Antwan also says he takes extra care to avoid situations that might tempt him. "Usually I don't put myself in those kind of positions 'cause I have some of my dad's DNA, so I don't put myself in positions to make me want to use it." Neighborhood teen parties, he says, routinely involve drinking and drugs and "girls flashing their private parts, yeah, they show everything, they're crazy girls." Does he party?

"Me and my friends, we sometimes go to those parties but we usually don't stay very long because we know something's gonna end up happening, so usually we just go out and eat somewhere."

Antwan describes his very best friends as trustworthy, very loyal, and "kind of the popular crowd." His grandmother knows all of his friends and their parents. "She makes sure she's close to them," he says, "just in case something happens. She has little get-togethers to have my friends over just so she can get to know them, she does that intentionally to get to know them better." Antwan says religious faith makes a big difference among teens in his neighborhood: "I can see a big difference, like my friends that are Christians, when they have a problem they go and pray about it, but when kids who aren't Christians have problems, they go and fight it out. Yeah, that's different." According to Antwan, a lot of kids try to join his group of friends by "acting gangster and gang-banging and stuff," but that just turns him off.

"We really don't like that gangster acting, it really pushes us away from them more." He thinks he and his friends have a positive Christian influence on other teens: "They could be talking about shooting somebody or planning something bad, but when I come around they'Il be like, 'You can't talk about that now 'cause here comes Antwan,' like they have to stop talking about bad things when I come around, so that kind of encourages me." Clearly,

Antwan is not concerned about being "too religious." Is he ever ridiculed by other teens because of his faith? "I'm pretty sure I am, but I don't really care," he replies matter-of-factly.

Antwan says he tries regularly to help other people: "I pray for them and I say encouraging words and usually it makes them feel good and helps them during the days." He also says he tries to take care of the world around him,

"'cause it's the place that I have to live in and who wants to live in something all messed up, trash all over everywhere?" All of this, he says, is " cause of my moral and spiritual beliefs." He says he sometimes feels sad about the pain caused by his grandmother's arthritis and asthma, but he never feels alone, invisible, or neglected. He says he is happy with his body and physical appearance. When he gets upset or has a problem, "usually I talk it through

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

with someone, like my grandmother, and if that doesn't work then I go pray about it."

Antwan reports that his lowest grade at school is a B+. "I care about school a lot," he says, " cause I want to go to college and make my grandmother proud. And in the Bible it says to do the best you can in everything, in every aspect of life, and that includes in school and out of school." About his teachers, he reports, "I like all of my teachers, they're fantastic." He also regularly attends the Bible club at school. "I'm always in there," he says. He openly expresses his faith at school in other ways, including "letting people know that I'm a person you can come to and talk to and pray with you and stuff. Plus, you don't do all the drinking and cussing and use the profanity all the other kids use." Antwan is also involved in an Omega Psi Phi fraternity organization, which an elder at church connected him to, through which he has had opportunities to participate in day-long workshops led by famous black athletes about earning, saving, and spending money wisely. He himself works a part-time job at an amusement park, in order, he explains, "to make stuff easier on my grandparents, 'cause instead of them buying for me, spending money on me, I buy my own school clothes and shoes. It kind of gives them freedom to do what they want to do [with their money]."

Antwan is dating a girl whom he found attractive because "she conducted herself like a lady instead of like a wild girl." He says the Bible influences his dating because it teaches that finding a wife is a good thing and that people shouldn't have sex until marriage, which is good because it makes people base their dating relationship on something other than sex. "The teaching in my religion is wait till you're married," Antwan insists. Besides, he notes, sex poses the risks of conceiving a baby when one is not prepared to care for it, having to drop out of school, being emotionally hurt in an uncommitted relationship, and getting STDs. One of Antwan's 17-year-old acquaintances has been infected with HIV from having sex. Antwan reports that despite a lot of pressure from friends and dates to have sex, he has never been physically involved with anyone more than holding hands and light kissing. What does Antwan do with the pressures he feels to have sex? "Usually I pray about them." He also recounts that before he became a Christian, his father used to force him to view pornography, which "made me not want to see it again, like I had a bad experience with it. It's nasty to me."

Antwan says he is thinking and praying a lot about his future, that "T'll make my life all that it's supposed to be." He wants to get good grades in school, go to college, succeed in sports, and get married. When he is 25 or 30 years old, he thinks religiously he will be "stronger, a little bit wiser, more experienced, more spiritual, more of a person to inspire you." So what, when all js said and done, does he think is the ultimate purpose in life? "To worship

God, that is what I think. I definitely want to accomplish with my life giving to the kingdom of God, me giving to my parents and family, and giving back to charity and the community."

Antwan's is a life that could easily have ended badly. Growing up amid family breakup, paternal disaffection, pervasive drug abuse, racial conflict,

SOUL SEARCHING

and neighborhood violence, he has faced many factors predicting unhappy outcomes. What mostly seems to have saved him from a bad fate are the belief commitments, moral teachings, faith practices, and social relationships of his religious tradition and faith community and family. Many of the general themes we have seen in previous chapters—the profound positive and negative influences of adults in the lives of teens, the readiness of youth to follow the religion of their family, the importance of youth groups and youth ministers in the formation of teenagers' faith lives—emerge again in Antwan's story. His experience also well illustrates that the nine factors described earlier are at work forming his life in positive directions. His religion clearly provides him with moral directives by which he has learned to negotiate his life in largely helpful ways. Antwan has a clear sense of right and wrong, a strong moral compass by which he lives. His religion has also exposed him to spiritual experiences of worship, healing, and transformation that have solidified his faith, moral commitments, and constructive life practices. Furthermore, he has benefited from many positive role models, particularly his grandmother and his youth leader, Craig, who have helped him to grow in his faith and navigate life's challenges. Involvement in church and youth group is also providing him with basic community and leadership skills that he is putting to use in coordinating security for meetings, influencing peers, negotiating conflicts, helping to organize youth and school activities. Moreover, his faith has equipped him with coping skills that have enabled him constructively to process his hurt, anger, and other troubles and emotions. Rather than turning to outrage and violence, Antwan has learned to turn to prayer and to hope, which in his case, eventually paid off in his reconciliation with his father. The unity and positive atmosphere with which he describes his Youth Experience

Success youth group also appear more generally to channel his energy and feelings in positive directions. The acquisition of cultural capital is less obvious in Antwan's story, although it is not unlikely that through the programs, activities, and relationships at church he has picked up certain pieces of cultural knowledge, sensibilities, dispositions, and manners that will serve him well as he moves into life in the adult world. Antwan's ties to church, along with his grandmother's intentional efforts to get to know all of his friends, have also created a situation of network closure. He is thus situated in a system of relational ties in which adults and teens know each other, information about teenagers can flow among adults, and parents and guardians can better exercise oversight of youth. His connection to church has also enhanced his social capital, strengthening his ties to a network of adults and extended family who are positioned to provide him resources and connections to such things as national fraternity organizations. He has also benefited from religious ties to extracommunity links, such as the regional Acquire the Fire youth conference and the Omega Psi Phi organization, where he has learned to handle money wisely.

In sum, whatever one thinks about the specifics of Antwan's beliefs and morals, it is clear that religion has provided him with boundaries, directions,

ADOLESCENT RELIGION AND LIFE OUTCOMES

habits, aspirations, structures, expressive outlets, and social relationships that have crucially helped him make good choices and overcome disadvantage.

None of this is to suggest that religion is a panacea for all at-risk teenagers.

Life is never that simple. Antwan is only one case of a religiously Devoted teen, quite different from the average U.S. teenager as depicted in previous chapters, and so the positive religion-outcomes connection that statistics show pertain to all U.S. teens is particularly clear in his case. For other, less religiously devoted teens, we would expect religion's connection to outcomes to be less strong and obvious. Nor does religion's constructive role in Antwan's life mean that we can, in seeking to understand teenagers' lives, ignore other social structures and forces that also powerfully shape youth's outcomes. Religion or no religion, for example, Antwan still lives in a racialized society, the life chances of the members of which are still significantly shaped by structured social and institutional inequalities.*1 Nevertheless, these caveats notwithstanding, Antwan's story, like many of those in previous chapters, helps concretely to illustrate the ways that religious faith and practice can and, we believe, often does help to form teenagers' lives in positive and constructive ways. Antwan is only one of the 3,290 teenagers we surveyed, only one of the 267 teens we interviewed. But we believe that, in at least some ways, his particular story sheds a helpful light on the larger story of this chapter.

CONCLUSION

The religious difference and, we argue, influence of religion in the lives of contemporary American teenagers observed in this chapter provides a clear illustration of powerful sociological processes at work. Ironically, relatively few American teens, as chapter 4 suggested, reflect a religion that is centrally important in shaping their lives. And yet, we have seen that religion does indeed seem to make a significant difference in forming the lives of youth, that there are consistent and impressive differences in outcomes between highly religious American teens and nonreligious teens. There actually are real differences between the lives of the Joys and the Kristens that we think are not reducible to nonreligious factors. If so, youth's lives are being at least in part significantly shaped by religious and social identities, practices, cultures, relational ties, resources, and institutions in ways that many teens themselves often cannot even recognize or describe. Social facts and forces that are not merely the sum of individual properties appear to exert real and powerful influences in human life, whether anyone involved knows it or not.

Sociological analysis helps us to see this. In part, American teenagers' takenfor-granted individualism simply fits many of them with blinders so they are not able to see well larger social influences on their lives. The same is often true about adults. But simply because teenagers cannot see it does not make religion's influence any less real or important. To what extent these differences among all U.S. teens result from the influence of their particular historical

SQUL SEARCHING

religious traditions versus that of Moralistic Therapeutic Deism we are not able to determine here. In any case, it appears that religion really does matter, even, ironically, in the lives of religious believers who are not aware that it does. Such believers, it would seem, might be warranted in having, like Antwan, a little more faith in their own faith.

Conclusion HE TITLE OF THIS BOOK is intended to suggest three meanings. First, in the research project this book reports on, we as sociologists were embarked on a kind of sociological search for the souls of American teenagers.

We were not trying to save their souls, simply to do our best to reach and better understand them. Second, what we found when we did so is that many, though certainly not all, U.S. teenagers are themselves engaged in a kind of search for their own souls—trying to sort through their life and faith identity, beliefs, commitments, and practices in their long passages from childhood to adulthood. Teenagers, however, are not a people apart, an alien race about whom adults can only shake their heads and look forward to their growing up. Teenagers are part of us, fully members of our families, religious congregations, neighborhoods, communities, and nation. Teenagers and adults, it turns out, have much more in common with each other than not, and so need to learn better to care for each other. Communities of faith in particular often profess to care about the youth in their midst. Therefore, third, we hope that the findings of this book set various groups and communities of adults on their own processes of soul searching, for when it comes to American adult attitudes and practices regarding adolescents, we think a good deal of soul searching is warranted. To that end, we intend this book to be, among other things, a catalyst for many soul-searching conversations in various communities and organizations about the experience and place of adolescents in our society, in particular the significance of the religious and spiritual lives of teenagers today.

SOUL SEARCHING

So what have we learned? Having analyzed NSYR survey and interview data, what do we better understand about the religious and spiritual lives of contemporary teenagers living in the United States? A number of recurrent general themes have emerged from our analysis, which we briefly review here.

First, religion is a significant presence in the lives of many U.S. teens today.

Most have not dropped out of the religious congregations in which they were raised. Many remain regular participants in their families' communities of faith. Many profess that religious faith is important in their lives and that faith exerts a significant influence on their moral views and choices. The fact that they may not have particularly well-articulated beliefs about their own religious traditions does not alter the fact that the vast majority of U.S. teenagers embrace some religious identity, the majority are affiliated with a religious organization, and a sizable minority are regular participants in local communities of faith. In short, U.S. teens as a whole are anything but areligious or irreligious.

Second, contrary to many popular assumptions and stereotypes, the character of teenage religiosity in the United States is extraordinarily conventional. The vast majority of U.S. teens are not alienated or rebellious when it comes to religious involvement. Most are quite content to follow in their parents' footsteps. Most feel quite positive about religion, pointing out many advantages and benefits they see religion offering individuals, society, or both.

When it comes to practicing religion, most U.S. teens appear happy to go along and get along.

Third, as part of their general religious conventionality, very few U.S. youth, younger than the age of 18 at least, appear to be exposed to, interested in, or actively pursuing the kind of "spiritual but not religious" personal quests of eclectic spiritual seeking about which we have heard so much lately.

Most contemporary teenagers readily grant other people the theoretical right to pursue a religious seeker's quest and to explore and practice multiple religions. But very few teens are interested in doing that themselves. And very few even know of another teen who is a seeker. Rather, the vast majority are happy simply to accept the one religion in which they were raised. And those with dual-religion parents normally either embrace one, try to pay respect to both, or decide they are not interested in any religion. Whether spiritual but not religious seeking is or is not prevalent among older youth, we cannot say, but it is not among contemporary 13to 17-year-old teens in the United

States.

Fourth and somewhat related to the previous point: comparing statistics over time shows that the religiodemographic diversity represented by U.S. adolescents is no more varied today than it has been for a very long time.

The vast majority of contemporary teenagers living in the United States identify themselves as Christians, and most of the balance of non-Christian teenagers identify themselves as either nonreligious (many of whom actually turn out to be nominal Christians), Mormon, or Jewish. Recent popular and scholarly claims that the United States has become the most religiously diverse nation in the world are simply false as a matter of empirical religiodemo-

CONCLUSION

graphic proportions, at least when it comes to adolescent religious identity.

Whatever ideological or political interests it may serve to promote the alleged dramatic religious pluralism of the contemporary United States, empirically that idea is simply an overblown and erroneous claim.

Fifth, in general comparisons among major U.S. religious traditions using a variety of sociological measures of religious vitality and salience—which, to give a standard sociological disclaimer, may or may not have anything to do with the truth content of religious traditions or their adherents' actual subjective spiritual life and health—it is Mormon teenagers who are sociologically faring the best. Why is a story beyond the scope of this book to tell, but an interesting and important one to consider. After Mormon youth, conservative Protestant and black Protestant teenagers tend to score the next strongest on most of our sociological indicators. Mainline Protestant teens come next in religious strength, followed by Catholic, Jewish, and nonreligious teenagers. Interreligious comparisons of these sorts are notoriously tricky and perilous to make, because not all religious traditions can be lined up against each other on commensurate scales of comparison. Serious and faithful Judaism cannot be directly compared to black Protestantism, for instance, in an apples-to-apples way. Ultimately, such comparisons inevitably involve theological judgments beyond the competence of sociology to engage.

At the very least, however, comparisons within the major Christian traditions are somewhat plausible. Such differences should contribute additional empirical fodder to debates in the sociology of religion about what social factors best explain religious vitality and debility.

Sixth, contrary to popular misguided cultural stereotypes and frequent parental misperceptions, we believe that the evidence clearly shows that the single most important social influence on the religious and spiritual lives of adolescents is their parents. Grandparents and other relatives, mentors, and youth workers can be very influential as well, but normally, parents are most important in forming their children's religious and spiritual lives. Teenagers do not seem very reflective about or appreciative of this fact. But that does not change the reality that the best social predictor, although not a guarantee, of what the religious and spiritual lives of youth will look like is what the religious and spiritual lives of their parents do look like. Parents and other adults, as we have suggested, most likely "will get what they are." This recognition may be empowering to parents, or alarming, or both. But it is a fact worth taking seriously in any case.

Seventh, our findings suggest a significant supply-side dynamic operative in the religious and spiritual lives of U.S. teenagers. It appears that the greater the supply of religiously grounded relationships, activities, programs, opportunities, and challenges available to teenagers, other things being equal, the more likely teenagers will be religiously engaged and invested. Religious congregations that prioritize ministry to youth and support for their parents, invest in trained and skilled youth group leaders, and make serious efforts to engage and teach adolescents seem much more likely to draw youth into their religious lives and to foster religious and spiritual maturity in their young

SOUL SEARCHING

members. This appears to be true of local congregations, regional organizations such as dioceses and state conventions, and entire religious traditions.

Stated negatively, when religious communities do not invest in their youth, unsurprisingly, their youth are less likely to invest in their religious faith.

Supplies of resources, personnel, organizations, and programs are not the whole story, but they are a significant part of it. If, as we have said, when it comes to the religious outcomes of youth, parents and adults "will get what they are," we think it is equally true that, when it comes to youth, religious congregations, denominations, and other religious organizations generally

"will get back what they invest" and normally not a lot more.

Eighth, at the level of subjective consciousness, adolescent religious and spiritual understanding and concern seem to be generally very weak. Most

U.S. teens have a difficult to impossible time explaining what they believe, what it means, and what the implications of their beliefs are for their lives.

Many say they simply have no religious beliefs. Others can articulate little more than what seem to be the most paltry, trivial, or tangential beliefs. And others express beliefs that are, from the official perspectives of their own religious traditions at least, positively erroneous. Religion seems very much a part of the lives of many U.S. teenagers, but for most of them it is in ways that seem quite unfocused, implicit, in the background, just part of the furniture. For very many U.S. teens, religion is important but not a priority, valued but not much invested in, praised but not very describable. Our distinct impression is that very many religious congregations and communities of faith in the United States are failing rather badly in religiously engaging and educating their youth.

Ninth, and closely related to the previous point: a particular religious outlook that is distinct from the traditional faith commitments of most historical U.S. religious traditions, what we are calling Moralistic Therapeutic

Deism, appears to have established a significant foothold among very many contemporary U.S. teenagers. At the very least, it seems that when the engagement and education of youth by their religious communities is weak, then the faith of teenagers in those traditions tends to degenerate into Moralistic Therapeutic Deism. More significant than that, however, it seems to us that the relatively new and popularly compelling religious faith of Moralistic Therapeutic Deism is, in the context of their own congregations and denominations, actively displacing the substantive traditional faiths of conservative, black, and mainline Protestantism, Catholicism, and Judaism in the United States, which comprise the vast majority of teenagers. Moralistic Therapeutic Deism may not simply be what an ill-informed or nominal faith sounds like in a teen interview. It may be the new mainstream American religious faith for our culturally post-Christian, individualistic, massconsumer capitalist society. Continued research will have to investigate this possibility.

Tenth, it is impossible adequately to understand the religious and spiritual lives of U.S. teenagers without framing that understanding to include the

CONCLUSION

larger social and institutional contexts that form their lives. It is not sufficient to focus only on teenagers' individual psychological issues or moral character or smart or poor choices and behaviors, for those are often themselves powerfully shaped by the social and cultural forces of therapeutic individualism, mass-consumer capitalism, the digital communication revolution, residual positivism and empiricism, the structural disconnect of teenagers from the world of adults, adults' own problems, and other relevant cultural and social contradictions and tensions. Complicating this fact is the largely marginal social structural position in which religion typically finds itself among the mix of activities and organizations that organize teenagers' schedules and priorities. Teens and parents are not often consciously aware of these bigpicture social influences and organizing structures. But these larger contexts nevertheless are objective, structural, institutional, and cultural realities that powerfully form contemporary lives.

Eleventh, and finally, despite the fact that religion seems quite weak at the level of adolescent subjective consciousness, that most teens can hardly coherently articulate their own beliefs, that religion seems to operate mostly as an unfocused, invisible dynamic operating in the background of teenagers' lives, and that many social and cultural forces exert effects that tend to undermine serious religious faith and practice, we nevertheless observe sizable and significant differences in a variety of important life outcomes between more and less religious teenagers in the United States. Highly religious teenagers appear to be doing much better in life than less religious teenagers. We suspect that some of these differences are explained by selection and reversecausation effects. But we also believe that the empirical evidence suggests that religious faith and practice themselves exert significant, positive, direct, and indirect influences on the lives of teenagers, helping to foster healthier, more engaged adolescents who live more constructive and promising lives. Most teenagers do not insist that religion is "good for people" for no reason at all.

They are merely reflecting, however inarticulately, what seems to be an actual empirical association between religion and adolescent outcomes. More research using longitudinal data is needed, however, to better sort through the empirical correlations and causal relations and directions involved in the religion-outcomes associations. At the very least, what appears to be clearly not true is the idea that religious teenagers are essentially no different from nonreligious teenagers, that religion seems to make no difference in adolescent outcomes. Far from that, religion correlates with big differences and arguably exerts significant effects on important outcomes in teenagers' lives.

If the previous finding is correct, then such a conclusion beautifully illustrates sociological forces at work: religious identities, organizations, and practices are significantly shaping people's lives, despite the fact that at the level of subjective consciousness most of them are only dimly aware of how or why that is happening. People, sociology helps us to see, are formed by more than their own personal, individual intentions and choices. Their lives are also profoundly shaped by the patterns and structures of the cultures, organ-

SOUL SEARCHING

izations, and institutions that undergird and organize their lives, including religious ones. This perspective opens up an important larger horizon for better understanding the lives of adolescents in the United States today.

One of the biggest obstacles to our understanding teenagers' lives is the common apparent inability to see their lives within the larger, very powerful social and cultural context that forms it. We began to address this concern in chapter 5. In all of this, a specific, important impediment to making sense of adolescent life in the United States worth reemphasizing is the routine failure of adults to recognize the responsibility of their own adult world, into which youth are being socialized, for presenting huge challenges for youth.

Instead of owning this responsibility, however, adults typically frame adolescence in ways defining teenage life per se as itself a social problem and adolescents as alien creatures, strange and menacing beings, perhaps even monsters driven by raging hormones, visiting us from another planet. Teenagers— our own children—this theme suggests, are more dissimilar to us than they are like us, separated from the adult world by light years of distance and difference. Who could possibly hope to understand or relate to teenagers?

In contrast to these and other distancing stereotypical interpretations of American adolescents, our analysis and research experience suggest that adults ought to stop thinking about teenagers as aliens or even others. Any generation gap that exists between teens and adults today is superficial compared with and far outweighed by generational continuities. Contemporary teenagers have almost entirely bought into the mainstream social system, literally anxious above all to succeed on its terms.! They are well socialized to want to enjoy the consumerist and experiential benefits of U.S. society as much as they are able. Most problems and issues that adults typically consider teenage problems are in fact inextricably linked to adult-world problems.

Furthermore, most teens appreciate the relational ties they have to the adult world, and most of those who lack such ties wish they had more and stronger ties. The traditional "storm and stress" model of adolescence accurately depicts only a minority of teens, about the same number of adults at any given time who are suffering storm and stress, and, in our view, is a counterproductive lens through which adults view youth. That lens unnecessarily and unhelpfully creates distances when what is greatly needed is connection.

Adults need alternative mental and discursive models that emphasize grownups' similarities to, ties to, and common futures with youth.

Religious congregations and other religious organizations are uniquely positioned in the array of social institutions operating in the United States to embrace youth, to connect with adolescents, to strengthen ties between adults and teenagers. This could only be good for all involved. But it will not happen automatically. It will require intentionality and investment. We hope that by drawing attention to and broadening and deepening our understanding of the religious and spiritual lives of U.S. youth, this book will make some positive contribution in that direction.

↑ Back to top

↑