Chapter 1 of 13

Introduction

Introduction

Introduction MERICAN TEENAGERS CAN embody adults' highest hopes and most gripping fears. They represent a radiant energy that opens doors to the future for families, communities, and society. But they also evoke deep adult anxieties about teen rebellion, trouble, and broken and compromised lives.

Parents, teachers, and youth workers behold their teenagers with pride, hope, and enjoyment, but also often worry, distress, and frustration. How are our teenagers doing in life? What is happening to our relationships with them?

How will they turn out? Happy and responsible? Troubled and depressed?

Or worse? Such personal ambivalent feelings about teenagers are amplified in the discourse and images that animate our culture and institutions. Our youth, it is often said, are the future, our hope for a brighter world. Teenagers are exciting, zany, inventive, fun. We adults love them dearly, we tell ourselves, and would do anything to make their lives happy and full. And yet, adults see and fear in adolescence a dark side as well. Surly indifference and defiance. Dangerous peer pressure. Parties. Foolish choices. Drugs. Drunk driving. Crime. Pregnancy. Abortions. AIDS. Suspensions. School dropouts.

School shootings. Suicide. So, many adults worry deeply that, whatever good there is, something may also be profoundly wrong about the lives of American teenagers.

Some adults attempt to respond. Parents make efforts to talk to their kids more often, to be more involved in their lives, to involve them in sports, clubs, camps, and other constructive activities. Communities set up youth centers and organize afterschool programs. School boards incorporate char-

INTRODUCTION

acter education and community service into their curricula. And foundations and philanthropies sponsor studies and issue reports and recommendations to improve adolescent well-being. Many of these are worthy efforts, but in all of this there is often a missing element. In many discussions and activities revolving around better understanding and helping teenagers, one aspect of their lives seems frequently to go unnoticed, unconsidered, unexamined. That is their religious and spiritual lives. Very few efforts to better understand

American adolescents take seriously their religious faith and spiritual practices. This is a curious neglect. Many teenagers, as this book shows, are very involved in religion. They say on surveys, at least, that their religious beliefs and practices are important parts of their lives. They feel good about the religious congregations they belong to. Many say that faith provides them with guidance and resources for knowing how to live well. To adequately comprehend the lives of American teenagers, it therefore seems important to understand their religious and spiritual beliefs, commitments, practices, experiences, and desires. And yet, so few of us do. In fact, reading many published overview reports on adolescence can leave one with the distinct impression that American youth simply do not have religious and spiritual lives.1

This book is a response to that situation, intended to help develop a better scholarly and public understanding of the religious and spiritual lives of American adolescents. The following chapters lay out the main survey and interview findings of the National Study of Youth and Religion, a unique research project on the religious and spiritual lives of American adolescents conducted from 2001 to 2005 at the University of North Carolina at Chapel

Hill. What follows provides solid answers to questions about the character of teenage religion, the extent of spiritual seeking among youth, how religion affects adolescent moral reasoning and risk behaviors, and much more. We hope that by informing readers about the religious and spiritual lives of American teenagers we will help to foster discussions in families, religious congregations, community organizations, and beyond, not only about the general state of religion in the United States, but also about cultural and institutional practices that may better serve and help to care for America's teens.

The vast majority of research in the sociology of religion in the United States focuses on either religious institutions or on adults, age 18 and older, and many scholars who study adolescents neglect religion in their lives. This inattention to youth religion works to our detriment. American adolescents between the ages of 10 and 19 represent about 14 percent of all Americans, a population deserving the scholarly attention of sociologists of religion as much as any other group. Furthermore, because adolescence represents a crucial developmental transition from childhood to adulthood, research on teens can disclose important knowledge about religious socialization and change in the life course. Adolescents compose a population that many religious organizations, both congregations and parachurch ministries, target to exert influence in their lives. Adolescence and young adulthood are also life stages when religious conversion is likely to take place. Adolescence furthermore

INTRODUCTION

provides a unique opportunity to study religious influences on family relationships, peer interactions, risk behaviors, media use, mental and emotional well-being, and many other outcome variables. Finally, adolescence provides an ideal baseline for longitudinal research on religious influences in people's lives. There is thus a great deal of value in pursuing a big-picture, in-depth study of youth religion and spirituality in the United States.

But such a study of the religion and spirituality of youth also affords an important and distinctive window through which to observe and assess American religion as a whole. A variety of recent studies have made diverse claims about the character and transformation of American religion. Some scholars have observed that American religion has recently become profoundly diverse, inundated by waves of new immigrants greatly expanding the demographic pluralism of American faiths.2 Other scholars suggest that American religion has become culturally individualistic and subjectivistic, driven by religious "seekers" bearing consumerist mentalities about faith.3 Some writers claim that American youth have become deeply alienated from traditional institutional religion and are either opting out of faith altogether or are on quests to construct more authentic, postmodern versions of faith and spirituality.* Along these lines, some suggest that American religion generally is losing the coherence of historical religious traditions, as individuals increasingly create personal, bricolage spiritualities, eclectically mixing and matching spiritual practices from diverse faiths.' Some suggest that religion is really a marginal factor in the lives of American teenagers, not central to their real problems and concerns.* Yet others observe a growing movement among American youth returning to religious tradition, liturgy, and historical orthodoxy.'" These are all potentially important observations. But do we really know enough to be sure that these reports accurately describe the character of American religion today?

One way to try to address these issues and questions is through a nationally representative study of American youth. Many of these accounts tell their stories in distinctly generational terms, suggesting that American baby boomers first opened the door to profound religious changes and that younger generations now drive the cutting edge of fundamental religious transformation in America. Of all Americans, youth are often said to be the most intensely exposed to and engaged with the digital and interactive communication technologies that are thought to be transforming American culture.'

Many claim that youth are particularly influenced by a contemporary postmodern culture that profoundly reconfigures understandings of knowledge, belief, and moral reasoning.' Youth are sometimes thought to have the shallowest roots in the substance of their own historical religious traditions, knowing or caring the least about the distinctive content of their own faiths, and so quite open to alternative viewpoints.'° We also know that they are the target of intense, sophisticated, secular, mass consumer advertising campaigns trying to secure the brand loyalties of a consumer generation with hefty disposable income, and that this significantly shapes their values and assumptions."

INTRODUCTION

For these and other reasons, we might expect American teenagers to serve as excellent indicators of possible developing trends in American religion more broadly. If many of the striking claims noted above are in fact prevalent in the American religious field, we would expect to see them evident among American adolescents. If we do not find them among American adolescents, that might cast some doubt on the claims. This book thus represents in part an attempt to describe and evaluate the shape and texture of American religion broadly by viewing it through the lens of the religious and spiritual practices of religious and nonreligious American youth. The pages that follow do not engage in hypothesis testing per se but seek to use recent claims about profound changes under way in American religion as sensitizing questions and framing devices in our analyses. In this way, we may learn a great deal not only about adolescent religion and spirituality specifically—which is very important in itself—but also about American religion more broadly.

In this book, we report the findings from research conducted by the National Study of Youth and Religion (NSYR; see www.youthandreligion.org).

From July 2002 to March 2003, the NSYR conducted a national, randomdigit-dial telephone survey of U.S. households containing at least one teenager age 13-17, surveying one household parent for about 30 minutes and one randomly selected household teen for about'50 minutes. Then, in the spring and summer of 2003, 17 trained project researchers conducted 267 in-depth, face-to-face interviews with a subsample of telephone survey respondents in 45 states. The locations of each of these interviews are shown in figure 1. a ary > os ?

° ne, "% ~ * , ba >

\r to * ot » "fe L '

; Ber HE yp » §. ¥ ° rif e irs ze F, Alec'

; .

* Boe . ae &¢ ° ave, "o ° ba :

Ly $ ba . ve a z- .

i ie poe "a

Ke a Figure 1. Locations of NSYR Personal Interviews (N = 267).

INTRODUCTION

PR These interviews were sampled to capture a broad range of difference among U.S. teens in religion, age, race, sex, socioeconomic status, rural-suburbanurban residence, region of the country, and language spoken (English or Spanish). To our knowledge, this project has been the largest, most comprehensive and detailed study of American teenage religion and spirituality conducted to date (specifics on the NSYR research methods are reported in Appendixes

B and C). Altogether, the data collected provide for a dependable, representative description and analysis of the contours and character of adolescent religion and spirituality in the United States today. We address all of the major

American religious traditions and two minority religious traditions, Mormonism and Judaism, although the majority traditions receive disproportionate attention in the analysis. Other NSYR researchers will also be publishing books and reports dedicated to better understanding the religious and spiritual lives of U.S. teenagers in minority religious traditions and in specific

Protestant denominations.'"

Here is what to expect in coming chapters and how to read them. Chapter 1 begins laying out some key themes of this book by considering the stories of two Baptist girls whom we personally interviewed. Chapter 2 examines extensive, nationally representative survey findings on the religious and spiritual identities, affiliations, beliefs, experiences, and practices of U.S. adolescents. Chapter 3 focuses on three specific groups of American teenagers—

"spiritual seekers" who are "spiritual but not religious," teens who are entirely disengaged from religion, and religiously devoted teenagers—to better understand who these teens are. Chapter 4 explores in much greater depth

American adolescents' thoughts, beliefs, and feelings about and experiences of religious faith and spirituality, drawing extensively on our personal interviews. Our purpose in chapter 4 is to elaborate from adolescent discourse many of the central themes and perspectives that define religion and spirituality for the majority of teenagers, while also paying attention to minority and alternative ideas and viewpoints among youth. Chapter 5 explores some of the major social forces and factors that form the lives of U.S. youth, seeking from a sociological perspective to better understand our society's structures and systems that may significantly shape the religious and spiritual lives of teenagers. Chapter 6 zeros in on one religious group of teens, focusing on the question of why U.S. Catholic teenagers as a whole rather consistently score lower on the religiosity measures of this study. Chapter 7 addresses the question of how religious practices associate with different outcomes in adolescents' lives. There we examine evidence suggesting that greater religiosity is significantly associated with more positive adolescent life outcomes and seek to reflect theoretically why and how this is so. The chapters are meant to fit together in order but can also, with the exception of chapters 4 and S, which depend on each other to portray a bigger picture, be read independently. The conclusion summarizes and elaborates on our findings.

The religious and spiritual lives of U.S. teenagers are complicated. That complication is evident in the general flow of this book, which moves from

INTRODUCTION

a fairly positive initial perspective to a more critical tone by its middle and then back to a paradoxically positive viewpoint by its end. We hope our analyses, findings, and stories together provide an understanding of American adolescents more reliable and rich than we have enjoyed to date so as to provoke better-informed conversations among people who care about teenagers' lives in all of their concerns and complexities.

↑ Back to top

↑