Appendix A. Race, Class, Gender, Etcetera:
Appendix A. Race, Class, Gender, Etcetera Demographic Differences in U.S. Teenage Religiosity
The primary analytical approach we use in this book to examine NSYR survey data on U.S. teenage religion and spirituality has been to separate out teens into the six major U.S. religious traditions of conservative, mainline, and black Protestantism, Catholicism, Judaism, and Mormonism, and the category nonreligious.
A second analytical approach we employ to categorize teenage religiosity is the four ideal religious types used to explore teenage outcomes described in chapter
7. We think these categories provide an illuminating comparative perspective on adolescent religious differences in the United States today. However, these are not the only ways one might view variance in teenage religion. A more standard sociological approach to making sense of distinctions in people's lives is to examine differences associated with what are thought of as key demographic characteristics. What some call the "holy trinity" of these sociological variables are race, social class, and gender. We briefly examine teen religious difference in light of these demographic distinctions in this appendix. In addition, we consider how adolescent religion may differ by age of teen, structure of teen's family, ruralurban residence, regional location, and supply of religious congregations per county. During the process of writing this book, we received many inquiries about how such demographic variables distinguished religious outcomes, indicating an apparent demand for such demographic analyses of the teen religion data. Any book aspiring to present a general overview of the results of such an inclusive study of national teen religiosity, yet lacking an analysis using these kinds of demographic variables, would be incomplete. Therefore, here we examine bivariate relationships in cross-tabulations between the demographic and religiosity variables. Then we enter all of the demographic variables examined in this apnape
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
pendix into multivariate ordered logit and binary logistic regression models to determine the independent effects of each variable while controlling for the possible effects of the other variables included. These findings contribute to our basic stock of knowledge about variances in U.S. teenage religious and spiritual practices and experiences.
TEEN RACE
Race is a major social factor differentiating many people's identity, life experiences, and outcomes in the United States. Do racial differences also associate with variance in religious practices and experiences among U.S. youth? Table A.1 examines differences in religious service attendance, importance of religious faith in everyday life, personal commitment to God, current involvement in a religious youth group, frequency of personal prayer, and feelings of closeness to God according to the racial categories of white, black, Hispanic, and Asian (the numbers of Native American, Pacific Islander, mixed, and other races were too small to include in this comparison). According to the findings presented in table A.1, racial differences do indeed associate with adolescent religious differences. Surveying our six religiosity variables, we see, for example, that, with many measures of religiosity, black teenagers tend to be more religious than white teenagers: 19 percent more black than white teens say religious faith is very or extremely important in their daily lives, 14 percent more have made a commitment to live their lives for God, 17 percent more pray alone daily or more often, and 15 percent more feel very or extremely close to God. Black teens are less likely than white teens, however, to belong to a religious youth group. On many, but not all, measures, Hispanic teenagers also appear to be somewhat more religious than whites. Hispanic youth are more likely to feel close to God and to engage in personal prayer, but are also much less likely to attend youth groups and to have made a commitment to live life for God. Asian teens generally reflect somewhat lower levels of religiosity than white teens, especially in the 18 percentage point difference between them in having committed to live for God. Results of multivariate regression analyses for these race categories controlling for all of the other variables addressed in this appendix are examined below.
SOCIAL CLASS
U.S. society is characterized by a distinct social class system of inequality that separates underclass, working poor, lower-middle-class, middle-class, uppermiddle-class, and upper-class Americans.' Such class differences are defined by multiple factors, including education, income, and occupational status. Here we use three social class variables—family income, parental education, and median county family income—to explore possible differences in teenage religiosity with which they may associate. Are U.S. teenagers in higheror lower-class families and counties more or less likely to be religious?
Table A.2 presents differences in our six adolescent religiosity measures according to differences in the incomes of the teens' families. We have grouped family income into three broad categories. Those families earning less than
$30,000 per year are counted as low income (23 percent of the sample); those earning $80,000 or more per year in family income are counted as high income
SQUL SEARCHING
Table A.1. Religiosity by Race of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) Ss Teen Race White Black Hispanic Asian Religious service attendance More than once a week
12) g Once a week
2-3 times a month
Once a month Wi
Many times a year
A few times a year
16) 31h
NU, Never
Ie) Importance of religious faith shaping daily life Extremely important
Very important
Somewhat important
27,
Not very important
Not important at all ut
Has made a personal commitment to live life
ay for God Currently involved in a religious youth group
Frequency of teen praying alone Many times a day
About once a day 22,
DD,
A few times a week
18)
aR About once a week
1-2 times a month
ats
Less than once a month v7)
Never 1S
How close teen feels to God Extremely close 'lal
Very close 2S
Somewhat close
Somewhat distant 7, '20
Very distant
Extremely distant
HOES BOE BENE 1 OO
ee ee ee Source; National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~.
(27 percent); those earning between $30,000 and $80,000 are counted as middle income (44 percent, with the percentage balance being "don't know" and refused answers on the family income question). These are somewhat crude categories, but they aid in ease of presentation for present purposes. Table A.2 shows only fairly minor differences between the three family income groups. The only broad generalizations one might venture based on the findings are that teens in lowincome families appear to be less religiously involved in organizational aspects of religion (service attendance and youth group), and teenagers in high-income families are less likely to score higher on subjective and personal religiosity measures
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
re) Table A.2. Religiosity by Family Income of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) USS.
Family Income Low Middle High Religious service attendance More than once a week
Once a week
2-3 times a month
Once a month Lp
Many times a year
A few times a year
Never
dS Importance of religious faith shaping daily life Extremely important
Very important
Zi, Somewhat important
Not very important
Not important at all Z
Has made a personal commitment to live life 55)
for God Currently involved in a religious youth group
Frequency of teen praying alone Many times a day
About once a day oid
A few times a week
About once a week
1-2 times a month
ily Less than once a month i
Never iS
How close teen feels to God Extremely close
Very close
Somewhat close
Somewhat distant A,
ily
Very distant >
Extremely distant
Z Does not believe in God
__Does not believe 1m 700 Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers.
(importance of faith, personal prayer, closeness to God). But any such differences are not large.
What about the education levels of parents of U.S. teenagers? Does variation in parental education associate with differences in teen religiosity? Table A.3 addresses these questions, not by breaking out parental education into the twelve different possible levels measured by the NSYR parent education survey question, but by focusing on three very different ideal types of parental education. Table
A.3 compares the levels of teenage religiosity between those teens whose parents both have only high school degrees or less (N= 455), whose parents both have
Table A.3. Religiosity by Parents' Education of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17, Two-parent Households Only (Percentages) ee U.S.
Parents' Education Both At Least Both Graduate School Some College Both Have High School and At Least One a College Experience or Degrees or Degree(s) Degree Less Religious service attendance
ili
More than once a week Once a week 2-3 times a month Once a month Many times a year A few times a year Never
dtl 12, v)
Importance of religious faith shaping daily life
Extremely important Very important Somewhat important Not very important Not important at all aut
Pail
SS)
Has made a personal commitment to live life for God
Currently involved in a religious youth group Frequency of teen praying alone
Many times a day About once a day A few times a week About once a week
V5)
iil
18) 1-2 times a month Less than once a month Never
aT az
How close teen feels to God Extremely close Very close Somewhat close Somewhat distant Very distant Extremely distant Does not believe in God
3h)
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers.
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
Le. at least some college education and at least one parent has a bachelor's degree
(N=367), and whose parents both have done some work in graduate school if not earned graduate degrees (N=191). Again, these are not all-inclusive categories but ideal types that do not include all U.S. teenagers and parents but do have the virtue of identifying clear, comparative categorical differences. The findings in table A.3, nonetheless, do not reveal any major parental education differences in teenage religiosity. Teens whose parents earned bachelor's degrees appear somewhat more likely than the others to attend religious services weekly or more often and to be involved in a religious youth group, and teens whose parents have a graduate degree seem less likely than the others to report that religious faith is important in their lives or that they have made personal commitments to live their lives for God. But such differences are not major. Below we will explore results of multivariate regression analyses for family income and parental education which control for the other variables examined in this appendix.
Social class influences on people's lives do not always operate at the individual or family level. People of similar social class tend to group or be grouped together socially and geographically for various reasons, creating possible social class effects at the community level, net of the individual level. Is U.S. teenage religiousness shaped by such community-level social class influences? To address this possibility, we used U.S. Census 2000 data to group counties into quartiles by the median family income of county and cross-tabulated those county income quartiles with our six teenage religiosity measures. The results, shown in table A.4, show that the highest levels of religiosity are among teens living in the poorest median family income counties and that teen religiosity generally drops off as the median family income of counties increases. The least religious teens are those living in the highest median family income counties. In other words, U.S. adolescent religiousness appears to be associated with social class at the county level, such that the higher the county family incomes, the less religious the teens who live in those counties tend to be.
TEEN GENDER
Are there gender differences in religiosity among U.S. teenagers? According to the findings presented in table A.5, there are. On each of the six religiosity variables examined, girls score higher than boys. The differences are not enormous but, as we will see below, they are statistically significant for all religion variables. On most religiosity indicators, although we can observe only a handful of percentage point differences between girls and boys across the answer categories given, after controlling for other demographic variables in multivariate regression models, teen gender remains statistically significant for all six religiosity measures. We therefore observe that teenage girls in the United States are a bit more religious than teenage boys. This finding is consistent with similar gender differences in religiosity observed among adults in the United States and in most other societies.'
TEEN AGE The years that comprise teenage status in U.S. culture actually involve major differences in maturity, experience, mobility, and independence. The life of a 13year-old is often vastly different from the life of a 17-year-old, even though only
SOUL SEARCHING
Table A.4. Religiosity by Median Family Income of County of Residence (Grouped by Quartiles) of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
USS.
Median Family Income of County Second to Next Lowest Lowest Highest Highest Quartile Quartile Quartile Quartile Religious service attendance More than once a week
22;
Once a week
JIS)
2-3 times a month
11) Once a month
Many times a year
Yi A few times a year
12.
ils)
Never
Importance of religious faith shaping daily life Extremely important
ANY
Very important
Somewhat important
ell
eis) Not very important
Not important at all
Att Has made a personal commitment
to live life for God Currently involved in a religious
png) youth group Frequency of teen praying alone Many times a day
About once a day
Pipe
V7 A few times a week DS
About once a week
1-2 times a month
iit -
Less than once a month i
Never HO)
How close teen feels to God Extremely close
Very close DS
Somewhat close
Somewhat distant sly
ing
Very distant
Extremely distant
Does not believe in God
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers. four years separate them. One may imagine that religious identification, participation, and commitment could drop off in the later teenage years, particularly after the age of 16, when many teens begin to drive cars, become more sexually active, and establish greater autonomy from their parents. Are American 16and 17-year-olds that much less religious than 14and 15-year-olds or even 13-yearolds? According to the findings presented in table A.6, not especially so. Exam-
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
Table A.5. Religiosity by Gender of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) US:
Teen Gender Male Female Religious service attendance More than once a week
Once a week
2-3 times a month
ied 12.
Once a month
yi Many times a year
A few times a year
Never
Importance of religious faith shaping daily life Extremely important
Very important onl
Somewhat important
Not very important
Not important at all
Has made a personal commitment to live life for God
oP Currently involved in a religious youth group
Frequency of teen praying alone Many times a day
About once a day 22,
Pap A few times a week
About once a week
1-2 times a month
Less than once a month il
Never 18)
How close teen feels to God Extremely close
Very close
Somewhat close 35)
Somewhat distant
Very distant Ss
Extremely distant
Does not believe in God
__ Does not believe Im SOG Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers. ining differences among the three age groups across our six religiosity variables, we observe only minor if any decreases in the religious involvements of 16and 17-year-olds compared to the younger teens. The 16to 17-year-olds, for instance, attend religious services weekly or more often only two percentage points less than the 13-year-olds. The same comparison shows only a 2 percent drop from the 13-year-olds to the 16to 17-year-olds in the. number who say that religious faith is very or extremely important in their lives. Furthermore, only 4 percent fewer of older U.S. teens are involved in religious youth groups than younger teens. We also see little change in the total percentage who pray once a day or more often between the younger and older age categories of U.S. teens.
The most noticeable change across the age groups is evident in feeling close to
SOUL SEARCHING
Table A.6. Religiosity by Age Group of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) hci aha ACAD lh inc MRD iN BESABEN RATE SPS RS DE Tay La Fay ES ILE ETS
Teen Age Group Us, 16-17 14-15
Religious service attendance
LW,
More than once a week Once a week 2-3 times a month Once a month Many times a year A few times a year Never
ily Importance of religious faith shaping daily life
ay,
Extremely important Very important Somewhat important Not very important Not important at all Sih
di,
Has made a personal commitment to live life for God
Currently involved in a religious youth group Frequency of teen praying alone 1S
Many times a day About once a day A few times a week About once a week 1-2 times a month Less than once a month Never How close teen feels to God
as Extremely close Very close Somewhat close Somewhat distant Very distant Extremely distant Does not believe in God
BS)
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers.
God, but even there the change is not enormous. In other words, older U.S. teenagers, at least through 16 and 17 years of age, appear not to be dramatically less religiously engaged than younger U.S. teenagers. We do witness modest drops in religiosity between the ages of 13 and 17 for most measures. And the religiosity of teenagers older than 17 may drop significantly. But the evidence does not suggest that teenage religiousness drops off precipitously when teens come to enjoy more independence—wheels, jobs, and real girlfriends and boyfriends.
Older high school-age teenagers seem to be less religious than younger teenagers by only a handful of percentage points.
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
FAMILY STRUCTURE
Compared to prior years, the structure of the American family has become noticeably more complicated in recent decades. The rise in rates of marital separation, divorce, remarriage, single parenthood, and cohabitation of unmarried partners has created significant numbers of American teenagers living in family forms other than nuclear families involving two married parents of children.? Do family structure variations make any difference in levels of teenage religiosity? Are adolescent youth in certain family types more or less likely to be religiously involved? According to the findings presented in table A.7, yes. In most cases, the U.S. teenagers who are most likely to be more highly religious are those whose residential parents, mostly both biological parents but also including stepparents, are married. As with teen age, the differences are not enormous, but they are noticeable. The reasons explaining any family structure association with religiosity are not hard to imagine. Parental separation and divorce are disruptive life course events that usually restructure relational networks and generally depress religious participation. Divorce and the death of a parent can also precipitate emotional crises for parents and children alike, which can be expressed as resentment or anger toward God. Many U.S. religious traditions also oppose cohabitation, birth out of wedlock, and divorce, and so, intentionally or not, likely raise the discomfort level for potential adherents in those life situations who are religiously involved. Furthermore, as a matter of parental attention and family resources, it is generally more difficult for one parent to mobilize and sustain family congregational religious involvements than it is for two parents. Finally, it may be that some religious traditions exert ongoing moral and ideological influences on their adherents that actually reduce their readiness personally to consider cohabitation, separation, divorce, and birth out of wedlock. One particularly complicating factor when it comes to family structure and religiosity, however, is race: black teenagers are both more likely than whites to have parents who are not married and are more likely to be more religious than whites. Below we use multivariate regression models to remove that race effect and perhaps other relevant associations in order to isolate the possible independent associations of family structure per se, net of race.
REGIONAL LOCATION
The United States is notably divided into culturally distinctive regions of the country: the urban Northeast, the South, the Midwestern heartland, and the Rocky
Mountain and Pacific Coast regions. Many people associate these regions with different kinds and degrees of religiosity. Do geographic regional differences actually associate with variance in teen religiosity? According to the findings presented in table A.8, they do. These findings confirm those of previous research' and show that teenagers resident in the Northeast are the least religious among the compared regions, teens who are residents of the South are the most religious, and teenagers living in the Midwest and West generally fall between these two extremes. Below we examine results of multivariate regression analyses for these regional differences that control for all the other demographic variables addressed in this appendix to see if the region variables remain statistically significant.
Table A.7. Religiosity by Family Structure of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) nn a Urs:
Current Family Structure Currently Never All Married Cohabiting Separated Divorced Married Widowed
Religious service attendance More than once a
week Once a week
2-3 times a month
183)
Once a month if,
g Many times a year
A few times a year
Never
2D,
Importance of religious faith shaping daily life Extremely important
i Very important
Somewhat important
Not very important
Not important at all
b319§
Has made a personal
By?
commitment to live life for God Currently involved in
a religious youth group Frequency of teen praying alone Many times a day
iy,
About once a day
A few times a week
About once a week
fil
1-2 timesa month
is lil
ii) Less than once a WE
month Never EY
ii How close teen feels to God Extremely close
US Very close D5
Somewhat close
Somewhat distant
Very distant )
Extremely distant
Does not believe in
God ee Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3 Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers.
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
Table A.8. Religiosity by Regional Location of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) ores eneeic ts Sl eerae Northeast South Midwest West Religious service attendance More than once a week
Once a week
DRS)
2-3 times a month
Once a month
Many times a year
A few times a year
Never
2S Importance of religious faith shaping daily life Extremely important
Very important
Somewhat important oh!
Deh
Not very important
Not important at all
Has made a personal commitment to live life
for God Currently involved in a religious youth group
22.
Frequency of teen praying alone Many times a day
bi About once a day 2D
A few times a week 10S)
About once a week
1-2 times a month
ia Less than once a month
we Never 116)
ie, How close teen feels to God Extremely close
Very close PB)
Somewhat close
Somewhat distant iW)
Very distant Sj
Extremely distant
Does not believe in God
__ Voes not beleve 1M AsO Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers.
URBAN-RURAL DIFFERENCES
Next we examine differences in the residential locations of teenagers along ruralurban lines, measured as population of county of residence. Are teens who live in sparsely populated counties, that is, in rural counties, more or less religious than those who reside in high-population counties? We address these questions by grouping the NSYR sample of teenagers into four categories by county population, ranging from counties with populations of fewer than 40,000 residents to counties with more than 1 million residents. We then cross-tabulate these four
SOUL SEARCHING
county population categories with our six religiosity measures. Table A.9 reports the results. There we find that U.S. teenage religiosity is indeed negatively associated with the population of counties. Teens who live in sparsely populated, rural counties score higher on our six religiosity measures than teens from more densely populated, urban counties. Comparing teens who live in the least populated group of counties with those who live in the most populated group of counties, we see,
Table A.9. Religiosity by Urban or Rural Residence (County Population) of U.S.
Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) Wis:
Teen Residential County Population Fewer than 40,000200,00040,000 200,000 1,000,000 1,000,000+ Religious service attendance More than once a week
Once a week
DAA
2-3 times a month 1)
(GE 105) yi Once a month
HE Ff Many times a year
1, A few times a year
Never
Importance of religious faith shaping daily life Extremely important
iN Very important
Somewhat important ou
Not very important ml
14!
Not important at all ii
Has made a personal commitment
to live life for God Currently involved in a religious
youth group Frequency of teen praying alone Many times a day
About once a day
A few times a week LS
About once a week
1-2 times a month
Less than once a month ip
Never
als)
How close teen feels to God Extremely close
12;
p2 Very close
Somewhat close
igi
Somewhat distant Li;
Very distant
Extremely distant
Does not believe in God
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers.
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
for example, a 15 percent difference in weekly religious service attendance, a 12 percent difference in commitment to live for God, and a 20 percent difference in youth group involvement. It appears, then, that adolescent religiosity is higher in rural areas and lower in urbanized areas. We will test below whether these differences remain statistically significant in multivariate regression models after controlling for other demographic variables.
SUPPLY OF RELIGIOUS CONGREGATIONS IN COUNTY
Finally, we examine one social contextual religion effect at the county level on individual teenage religiosity: the religious supply-side factor of the number of religious congregations per capita in counties in which teenagers reside. The idea here is that individual religiosity may not simply reflect the desire to be religious but may also reflect the supply of religious organizations available. Clearly, religious demand and supply influence each other. But we might wish to know simply whether greater supply of religious congregations per capita is associated with variance in teen religiosity. Using data on the number of religious congregations per county in the United States and the population of counties, we calculated the number of religious congregations per capita for all counties and multiplied those numbers by 10,000. We then grouped counties into four categories, ranging from fewer than seven congregations on the low end to 20 or more on the high end.
The results of those four categories cross-tabulated with our six religiosity variables are presented in table A.10. There we see that supply of religious congregations at the county level and teenage religiosity appear positively related. Comparing the lowest and highest categories of congregation per capita (fewer than seven compared to 20 or more), we see, for example, a 20 percent difference in religious service attendance weekly or more often, a 17 percent difference in faith being very or extremely important, a 17 percent difference in commitment to live for God, and a 27 percent difference in youth group involvement. To what extent supply of religion helps to promote teenage religious practice and experience, as opposed to simply reflecting a larger historical demand for religion in a county population that teen religiosity indicates, we cannot say with precision. We can, however, observe that supply of congregations and religiosity do seem, in fact, to be positively associated. Whether this association is statistically significant after controlling for other variables, however, we are about to see.
MULTIVARIATE REGRESSION ANALYSES
To determine which of the above demographic variables are statistically significantly associated as independent variables with variance in U.S. adolescent religiosity, we ran ordered logit and binary logistic regression models including all of the demographic variables.' The results of these multivariate regressions are presented in table A.11, which names only the statistically significant variables, indicated in the positive or negative direction. Insignificant variables are left blank.
(For now, differences between boldface and nonboldface positives and negatives should be ignored.) In table A.11 we see that, with regard to race, net of all other factors, black teenagers in the United States are significantly more religious on five of the six religiosity measures than white teenagers, the one exception being youth group participation, which they are significantly less involved with com-
SOUL SEARCHING
Table A.10. Religiosity by Congregations per Capita of County of Residence of U.S.
Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) 'Congregations per Capita of WES.
County (10,000) i 7-14 15-19 20+ Religious service attendance More than once a week
Once a week
2-3 times a month
12;
13}
Once a month
a i
Many times a year
A few times a year
Never
Importance of religious faith shaping daily life Extremely important
Very important ol
CH) Somewhat important
27, Not very important
Not important at all
Has made a personal commitment to live life
for God Currently involved in a religious youth group
Frequency of teen praying alone Many times a day
Ng,
About once a day
DS A few times a week
About once a week
Te)
1-2 times a month
Less than once a month a
Never
How close teen feels to God Extremely close
Very close
Somewhat close
O70 Somewhat distant
Very distant
2) Extremely distant
aloes Suishetiegega 700 ss ve a ee Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers. pared to white teens. Hispanic teenagers, controlling for all other variables, score significantly lower than whites on the commitment to God and youth group measures, but higher on the personal prayer and closeness to God measures. Asian teenagers are only significantly different from white teens in their fewer numbers committed to live their lives for God. Thus, racial categories help to differentiate levels of religiosity among teens in the United States. These findings largely comport with those of previously published analyses,° confirming our knowledge of
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
significant racial differences in religiosity and raising ongoing research questions about how such racial differences are generated and sustained.
Social class variables show mixed results in table A.11. As also evident in the bivariate tables earlier, teenager's family income (entered here as a single, 12point, continuous variable) and parental education (entered here as a 15-point ordered scale)' are not significantly associated with teenage religiosity, with the one exception that teens of more highly educated parents are significantly less
Table A.11. Statistically Significant Variables in Ordered Logit and Binary Logistic
Regressions of Demographic Variables on Religiosity Measures, U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 Teenage Religiosity Measures Importance Commitment Youth Personal Close to Attendance _ of Faith to God Group Prayer God Race Black Positive Positive Positive Negative!
Positive Positive Hispanic Negative Negative Positive Positive Asian Negative White?
Family income Parental education Negative Median family Negative Negative Negative Negative Negative income of county Female teen Positive Positive Positive Positive Positive _ Positive Teen age (older) Negative Negative Negative Negative Negative Negative Family structure Married?
Unmarried partner Negative Negative Negative Negative Negative? Negative Separated Negative Negative?
Negative Negative Divorced Negative Negative Negative?
Negative? Negative Negative Widowed Negative Negative Negative?
Never married Negative Negative Negative Negative Negative Region Northeast Negative Negative Negative South Positive Positive Positive Positive Positive Positive West Midwest?
County population (higher) Religious congrePositive Positive Positive Positive Positive _ Positive gations per capita eeein Oils abe le et ieninibe sues ot be sine te Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Notes:
'Black is negatively associated with youth group (without religious tradition controls) at the p=0.058 level and becomes insignificant with religious tradition controls entered.
2These variables are significant at the p.<0.05 levels in models without religious tradition entered and at the p=0.07 level in models with religious tradition variables entered.
3Reference group.
SOUL SEARCHING
likely to have committed to live their lives for God. The social class variable that does significantly associate with all of the religiosity variables except religious service attendance, however, is median family income of county. And this effect is net of county population and religious congregations per capita of the county.
Teenagers who are residents of counties where families tend to earn higher incomes tend to score significantly lower on five of our six religiosity measures.
Why or how things work this way we are not certain, but it appears that increased wealth at the community level is correlated with lower levels of teenage religious practices and experiences.
Teen sex and age are also significantly associated with all of the religiosity measures, even when controlling for the effects of the other variables in the models. On all variables, girls are more religious than boys. For whatever reason, religious practice and experience among U.S. teenagers are clearly gendered. For reasons more explicable, on all measures older teens are less religious than younger teens. The numbers themselves in table A.6 show these age differences are not large, but they are statistically significant.
Family structure is also clearly associated with variance in teenage religiosity.
Across all six measures, teens in families with currently married residential parents, including both biological parents and stepparents, are more religious than teens in other types of families. After controlling for race, class, and numerous other factors here, with a few exceptions, U.S. adolescents with cohabiting or unmarried parents score significantly lower on these measures of religious practice and experience than those with residential parents who are married. There are probably multiple influences at work here. The experience of marital breakup itself likely reduces religious involvement of parents and teens, for various reasons. It could also be that families that are more religiously involved are also more capable of avoiding marital breakup, for other sundry reasons. And it could be that adults who are prone to relational and family instability also tend to select themselves out of religious involvements. Sorting through these possibilities to better understand how these processes work will require more research.
Regional variables perform in the multivariate models as the findings in the bivariate table A.8 suggest they would. In these models, teenagers living in the South are consistently more religious than those living in the Midwest. The Bible
Belt effect continues to exert its influence in the lives of U.S. teens. By contrast, teenagers living in the Northeast are often less religious than those living in the Midwest. Teens living in Western states are not statistically significantly different in religiosity from those living in the Midwest. Finally, after controlling for all demographic variables in multivariate models, any rural-urban differences as measured by county population that were evident in the bivariate table A.9 become statistically insignificant. Teens living in rural counties are not significantly more or less religious than those in urban counties, net of other demographic effects.
However, the supply-side factor of religious congregations per capita at the county level is significantly related to teenage religiosity. In these models, the greater supply of religious congregations available in a county, the more personally religious are teenagers who live in those counties, net of the other demographic controls.
Before concluding, we subject these demographic analyses to a more rigorous test by entering controls for the religious traditions of teenagers. We do this because religious tradition is correlated with some of these demographic variables,
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
as evident in table A.12, and with adolescent religiosity (table B.4 likewise shows the demographic characteristics of the four religious ideal types used in chapter
7's analysis). For example, certain religious traditions that correlate with different levels of teen religiosity are also geographically concentrated. Religious traditions also vary by race, both of which are associated with teenage religiosity. So it is possible that some of the regional and racial differences observed in table A.11, for example, are actually the result of religious tradition differences, which, once accounted for, would reduce or eliminate the regional, racial, or other differences.
We test for this possibility by adding to our regression models variables controlTable A.12. Demographic Traits of Religious Types of U.S. Adolescents,
Ages 13-17 (Percentages) WIS:
Religious Tradition CP MP BP RC J LDS NR Age
17,
2x1) 1)
Zi.
PS)
oR)
cs,
10%
pds) Female
S1 a5)
Race White
Black
2, ~
Hispanic
We Ze
a 3)
Other race 8)
Region Northeast iW
Midwest
South
out
22) Mountain/Pacific
Parent marital status Married
Living with unmarried partner
Widowed
~ ~
Divorced
Separated
Never married
Schooi type attending Public
Catholic
ae Pa '
Private other Christian
ps ~ ~ ~
Jewish ~ = a ~ ~
= ~ Private nonreligious
Home-schooled
il ~
Other
~ ss
= = Not going to school
~ ~
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding; cells of <1 are reported as ~.
SOUL SEARCHING
ling for teenage affiliation with evangelical, mainline, and black Protestantism,
Catholicism, Judaism, Mormonism, and other religious traditions. Previously significant variables that remain statistically significant after controlling for teen religious tradition are in boldface in table A.11, and variables that become statistically insignificant are in roman.
In table A.11, we see that, net of teen religious tradition differences, many but not all of the previously significant variables remain statistically significant.
All of the teen gender and most of the black teen, median family income of county, nonmarried family structure, and South region variables remain statistically significant. The supply of religious congregations per capita by county, however, becomes statistically insignificant, along with two of the three Northeast region variables. Most likely, those counties with more congregations per capita also have concentrations of religious traditions, conservative and black Protestantism and Mormonism, with typically higher levels of teen religiosity. Furthermore, although not noted in the table, after controlling for religious tradition,
Hispanic teens become significantly higher in importance of faith compared to white teens, and larger county population becomes significantly positively associated with closeness to God. Finally, we note, first, that all of the religious tradition dummy variables are statistically significant for all models (using nonreligious as the reference group) and, second, that the Pseudo-R?s for all of the models are increased by two to 10 times the magnitude with the inclusion of the religious tradition variables. This suggests that religious tradition differences explain more of the variance in teen religiosity than do the demographic variables, which is in part why most of the tables in this book use religious tradition differences rather than demographic differences to analyze the data.
CONCLUSION
What have we learned from this appendix's analysis? In general, we see that the religiosity of adolescents in the United States is somewhat socially patterned. Sociocultural factors such as racial identity, gender, place in the adolescent life course, parental marital situation, and regional location of residence appear somewhat to influence the extent of teenagers' subjective religious experiences and commitments and organizational practices and ties. In many cases, being black, female, younger, in a family with married parents, and from the South associate with higher levels of religiosity. On the other hand, social class differences at the family level do not seem to associate with differences in teenage religiosity. U.S. adolescent religiousness appears fairly evenly spread across the range of family incomes and parental education. Social class measured at the community level as median family income of county, however, does appear correlated with teenage religiosity, even net of religious tradition differences, with teens living in higherincome counties scoring lower on the subjective religiosity measures of importance of faith, closeness to God, and frequency of personal prayer. Furthermore, very much in keeping with this book's emphasis on significant parental and adult influences in the religious and spiritual lives of teenagers, we have seen that higher levels of teen religiosity are positively associated with growing up in married parent households. For various reasons, teens whose parents are not married tend to be personally less religious themselves. Beyond these findings, we observe a significant regional difference in the religiosity of teenagers living in the South
APPENDIX A: RACE, CLASS, GENDER, ETCETERA
versus the Northeast. Stereotypical images of differences between the secular, urban Northeast and the Southern Bible Belt are borne out in the religious lives of adolescents, illustrating the sociological observation that people's lives are, net of many personal factors, significantly shaped by features of their social environment. Finally, the most significant factor differentiating levels of teenage religiosity appears to be teen religious affiliations: differences in religious traditions, themselves shaped by their own theological differences, community histories, and organizational practices, seem to best explain differences in teenage religious practices and beliefs.
