Mapping the Big Picture
Z Mapping the Big Picture APS ARE GREAT for providing a big picture sense of the proportions and contours of the spaces that we occupy. Maps help us to understand the geography through which we move, so that we know where we stand in the world and what the world is like beyond our immediate field of vision.
Maps do this by simplifying relevant features of the actual world we live in with visual symbols, such as lines, colors, dots, and shapes depicting roads, rivers, cities, and altitudes. Sociological research can also descriptively map the contours and proportions of social life by simplifying features of the social world relevant to a particular interest and representing them with symbols.
But instead of using lines, colors, and dots for its symbolic representations, sociological research often uses numbers—such as frequencies, percentages, averages—to represent through numeric abstraction the social world's dimensions and qualities. All such descriptions oversimplify the complexity of the real social world in which we live. And maps as abstractions are never as interesting as, say, personal stories. But, as with maps generally, such simplified descriptions can help to provide an overarching sense of our social world, where we stand within it, and what it looks like beyond our immediate field of vision.
In this chapter, we descriptively map the world of contemporary U.S. adolescent religion and spirituality by presenting statistical findings from the National Survey of Youth and Religion. Following chapters explore some of the cultural meanings, textures, and complexities of U.S. adolescent faith. But before getting to such meanings and complexities, we outline some of the
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
major dimensions of adolescent religion and spirituality to build a general framework of knowledge about the proportions and distributions of the matter in question. This chapter is full of numbers and percentages, which take some effort to digest. But working through the abstract statistics pays off in providing us with a clear overview of the religious and spiritual lives of U.S. teenagers.'! Even so, those who are less interested in detailed statistics but are intrigued by the cultural meanings of religion can easily skim this chapter, read its conclusion, and come back to the details later.
RELIGIOUS AFFILIATIONS AND IDENTITIES
We begin with some basic statistics about U.S. adolescent religious affiliations and identities. What kind of religious people do U.S. teens consider themselves to be? In which religious denominations are they located? According to NSYR data presented in table 1, three quarters of U.S. teens between 13 and 17 years old are Christians. About one-half of teens are Protestant and one-quarter are Catholic. Christianity, in other words, still very much dominates American religion numerically at the level of teenage affiliation. The next largest group is the 16 percent of U.S. teens who consider themselves to be not religious. Note that not all of this 16 percent acts not religious. As we will see in the next chapter, many nonreligious U.S. teens believe in God, attend church, and pray; thus, there must be something in the way they understand the term "religious" that causes them to identify themselves as not Table 1. Religious Affiliations of U.S.
Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) U.S.
Teen religious affiliation Protestant
Catholic
Mormon
Jewish ites Jehovah's Witness 0.6
Muslim 0.5
Eastern Orthodox 0.3
Buddhist Ow Pagan or Wiccan 0.3
Hindu 0.1
Christian Science 0.1
Native American 0.1
Unitarian Universalist 0.1
Miscellaneous other 0.2
Don't know/refused 1.8
Teen not religious
Teen affiliates with two different faiths 2.8
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding.
SOUL SEARCHING
religious on surveys. Seven percent of U.S. teens affiliate with one of the many minority U.S. religions, particularly Mormonism (2.5 percent) and Judaism
(1.5 percent). Finally, nearly 2 percent do not know what their religion is or refused to answer the question.
Some interesting findings are immediately apparent in table 1. First, U.S. youth are not flocking in droves to "alternative" religions and spiritualities such as paganism and Wicca. Teenagers who are pagan or Wiccan represent fewer than one-third of 1 percent of U.S. teens. There are thus twice the number of Jehovah's Witness teens as there are pagan and Wiccan teens.
Second, it does not appear that American religion, at the adolescent level at least, is being profoundly diversified by new immigrant groups. Harvard's
Diana Eck asserts that the United States is the most religiously diverse nation in the world.2 That simply is not true. The vast majority of U.S. teens (like adults) are Christian or not religious. The so-called new immigrant religions are tiny fractions of adolescent religion. Muslim teens represent one-half of 1 percent of U.S. teens, Buddhists less than one-third of 1 percent, and Hindu a mere one-tenth of 1 percent.? For every one Muslim teen in the United
States there are five in the home-grown American religion of Mormonism.* For every Buddhist teen there are five Jewish teens. The case for rapid numeric diversification and pluralization of U.S. religions seems to have been overstated. The country has indeed seen a great deal of immigration in recent decades, but many of those immigrants came to the United States as Christians, such as Catholic Latinos from Mexico, the Caribbean, and Central
America, and Christian believers from a variety of non-Christian nations seeking refuge from anti-Christian persecution in their home countries. In addition, some immigrant youth become Christians in the process of assimilating to U.S. culture.
The third finding worth noting in table 1 is that relatively few U.S. teens (2.8 percent) affiliate with more than one religion. Numerous scholarly and journalistic voices have recently called attention to an alleged rise in an eclectic, mix-and-match approach to religion among youth. We do not find evidence for this in our data. Nearly all U.S. teens affiliate with one religion or no religion. Very few adhere to two religions, and that small minority apparently does so not because they are on some syncretistic spiritual quest, but because their parents affiliate with two different religions which they wish to honor. Even more telling, only one of our 3,290 survey respondents (0.0003 percent of all U.S. teens) professed to affiliate with three religions, in this case, Catholicism, Judaism, and Buddhism. U.S. teenagers as a whole are thus not religiously promiscuous faith mixers. Almost all stick with one religious faith, if any.
Table 2 unpacks the 52 percent of Protestants seen in table 1, specifying the various denominational families and traditions that teens call their religious homes.' The proportions seen in table 2 roughly mirror the distribution of U.S. adults into these groups. Clearly, the Baptists have the largest proportion of teens here (17.3 percent), followed by other traditions with notable numbers, including Methodists (4.7 percent), Lutherans (3.5 percent), and
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
i Table 2. Protestant Denominations of the Congregations Teens Attend, Protestant U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
Adventist 0.43
Free Methodist Church 0.03
Assemblies of God 0.71
Friends/Quaker 0.11
Baptist
Holiness 0.34
Bible Church 0.22
Independent/Nondenominational 3.02
Brethren 0.21
Lutheran 3.54
Charismatic 0.04
Mennonite 0.12
Christian and Missionary Alliance 0.03
Methodist 4.74
Church of Christ
Missionary Church 0.04
Church of God 0.46
Nazarene, Church of the 0.09
Calvary Chapel 0.02
Pentecostal 1.82
Congregationalist 0.2
Presbyterian/Reformed 1.83
Disciples of Christ 0.06
United Church of Christ 0.09
Episcopalian 0.82
Vineyard Fellowship 0.02
Evangelical, Independent 0.31
Wesleyan Church 0.16
Evangelical Covenant 0.02
Just Protestant 0.18
Evangelical Free Church 0.07
Just Christian 12.58
Four Square 0.08
Don't know/refused 3.01
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding. nondenominational churches (3 percent). Most of the remainder are scattered across the vast variety of denominations and traditions that constitute U.S.
Protestantism. Note, however, that nearly 16 percent of youth do not appear familiar enough with any specific group they may be affiliated with and so answer this question as "Just Christian," "Just Protestant," or "Don't know" or refused to answer the question.
Another way of understanding the location of different Americans within various available religious traditions is by asking with which tradition they self-identify. Table 3 shows the distributions of key self-identifications for Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish parents of teenagers. Among Protestants, parents of teens are evenly split at 19 percent between fundamentalist/evangelical and mainline/liberal Protestant. Catholic parents are also evenly spread across traditional, moderate, and liberal Catholicism. The majority of Jewish parents identify with Reform Judaism; fewer identify with Conservative and Orthodox Judaism. Ten percent of parents of U.S. teens consider themselves charismatic Christians, and 14 percent identify as Pentecostal Christians (only
5 percent identify as both). How do these parents distribute on a general scale of religious liberalism-conservativism? According to findings in table 3, nearly 3 in 10 parents have not even thought enough about the issue to give an answer. Among those who offered an answer, we see a great deal of variance, although the numbers do tip toward the conservative side: 28 percent said they were religiously conservative or very conservative, and 18 percent said they were liberal or very liberal. Altogether, the findings of table 3 add to the observation that there exists a great deal of religious variation among Christian and Jewish families of U.S. teenagers when it comes to iden-
SOUL SEARCHING
Table 3. Religious Self-identities of Parents of U.S.
Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) All U.S. Parents Protestant tradition identity Fundamentalist
Evangelical
Mainline
Theologically liberal ill Other Protestant identity
Catholic tradition identity Traditional Catholic
Moderate Catholic
Liberal Catholic
Other Catholic identity
Jewish tradition identity Orthodox Jew 0.08
Conservative Jew 0.35
Reform Jew 1.16
Other Jewish identity 0.1
Parent is a Charismatic Christian
Parent is a Pentecostal Christian
Compared to other religious Americans, parent views self as religiously Very conservative
Conservative a Moderate Az, Liberal
Very liberal 5) Has not thought much about this
Don't know/refused/not religious
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to full amount due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers. tification with alternative traditions in their religions and among all U.S. parents of teens with regard to their position on a liberal-conservative spectrum,
How similar to or different from their parents are U.S. religious teens?
One popular stereotype of American youth casts them as religious dissidents who find their parents' religious beliefs and practices old and meaningless and want to have little to do with any of it. Is this so? According to NSYR data shown in table 4, about three in four religious teens in the United States consider their own religious beliefs somewhat or very similar to their parents; they are more similar to mother's than to father's beliefs (teen similarity to parent religion for nonreligious teens is examined in chapter 3). Only 6 percent of teens consider their religious beliefs very different from that of their mother and 11 percent very different from that of their father. And not all who reported "very different" for this question are rebellious, antireligious teens of religiously devout parents. Fully 37 percent of teens whose beliefs
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
Table 4. Belief Similarity of Religious U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17, to Mother and Father (Percentages) UES:
Teen Religious Tradition Religious Teens.
'CP MP BP RC 7.
EDS Religious belief similarity to mother's Very similar
Siem
a VO Somewhat similar
SHOURAS US HON AINE
2 7 B18 Somewhat different
TDosHiT4s \ AS ue2Owe
Very different
Religious belief similarity to father's Very similar
Zp ane GLO) Wenn 9s ga aie ote 1) Somewhat similar
SEE O Zo) me cy: ane bmn aries hy Somewhat different
TS eto 20) a7
Very different
Ore Bo
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Notes: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers.
Jewish respondents include only religiously Jewish, not culturally Jewish only respondents. are very different from their mother's and 45 percent whose beliefs are very different from their father's report on another question that their own religious faith is very or extremely important to them in their daily lives. They appear to hold firm to their own faith but apparently simply don't agree with their parents on most religious matters.
Religious similarity to parents varies somewhat by the religious tradition the teen belongs to, as do many of the other religion variables we examine in this chapter. Therefore, table 4 and most of the tables below split out all
U.S. teens for comparisons into six religious traditions by the denominations with which they affiliate (Appendix D explains the methods used to categorize teens into these groups by religious denomination):
¢ Conservative Protestant (CP) ¢ Mainline Protestant (MP) ¢ Black Protestant (BP) * Catholic (RC) ¢ Jewish (J) * Mormon/Latter-day Saint (LDS) Here we see that Mormon teens are the most likely among all U.S. teens to hold religious beliefs similar to their parents', followed by conservative Protestant, mainline Protestant, Catholic, and black Protestant teens. Jewish teens are comparatively the least likely to say they share the beliefs of their parents, although, to keep it in perspective, still an impressive majority of them do.
If anything, then, U.S. teens lean strongly toward similarity with their parents in religious belief.
This, however, raises the question of whether, regardless of their own personal religious beliefs, American teens affiliate themselves with the same religious traditions of their parents or are drifting or converting to other
SOUL SEARCHING
religious traditions. Table 5 examines the distribution of teens (in rows) by the religious traditions of their parents (in columns). Three new categories have been added: other religion (OR), not religious (NR), and indeterminate
(IND) for uninterpretable survey responses.® The diagonal line of large numbers from upper left to lower right shows the percentages of teens who share the religious tradition of their parents. Conceived as a matter of retention of youth, conservative Protestant and Mormon parents are doing the best job, retaining 86 percent of their teens each, followed by Catholics at 83 percent, black Protestants at 81 percent, and Jewish parents at 75 percent. Only 68 percent of mainline Protestant parents' teens are mainline Protestant themselves. Parents of other religions—a conglomeration of Jehovah's Witness,
Hindu, pagan, Buddhist, Unitarian, and so on—are doing considerably worse than the Mormon, Christian, and Jewish parents in retaining (at 57 percent) their youth in any of these other religions. Nonreligious parents at 63 percent are faring relatively poorly at retaining their youth as nonreligious.
Viewed from a different angle, table 5 tells us which religious traditions of parents are more or less susceptible to "losing" teens to other religious traditions or to no religion at all. Most striking are the relatively low numbers on religious switching generally. Seven and 5 percent of mainline Protestant parents have, respectively, conservative Protestant and Catholic teens. We also see the notable percentages of conservative Protestant and Catholic teens of nonreligious parents (12 and 16 percent, respectively). All other combinations of religious switching in this table, besides teens becoming nonreligious, involve a mere 3 percent or fewer of teens of different kinds of religious parents.
There appears to be, in other words, relatively little switching of teens away from their parents' religion into other religious traditions. Significant percentages of teens with religious parents, however, consider themselves nonreligious. About one-third of teens of "other religion" parents are not religious; 17 percent of teens of mainline and black Protestant parents and 18 percent of teens of Jewish parents are not religious. Mormon and Catholic
Table 5. Current Religious Tradition of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17, by Parent Religious Traditions (Column percentages)
Parent Religious Tradition Sa a a Teen current religious tradition CP MP BP RC J LDS OR) | NR IND Na aE ae Se ee nS Ae I ast
OSSD UST)
cP BG a Sti ath Rees pee f
eas
ne-siaihtsot ae Binet
~ BP ee Re Ce ee RC Sim Sry Oty 18ar whe were p tale (ent J Peat bel, breast ae nae Sue Lote eae
~ LDS Be RL. SG MATE et cee hey. ge | ME a. gel
OR HGRA OE Le Mol ao OE ee ete
NR 10°
ASS ig tS a hain IND
ae oy
i fe
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding; cells of <1 are reported as ~.
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
parents follow at 13 and 12 percent, respectively. Conservative Protestant parents show the lowest levels of teens deserting their faiths for nonreligious identities, at 10 percent. Simple religious minority status alone cannot be the explanation for these differences, because Mormons and "other religions" are both minority religions in the United States, yet they are at the far extremes in their teens becoming not religious. Such tradition-specific differences in the chance of teens becoming not religious are explored further in the next chapter. For now, we do well simply to note these differences and keep them in mind.
RELIGIOUS SERVICE ATTENDANCE
Aside from the religious backgrounds of U.S. youth, how frequently do teenagers attend religious services and with whom do they attend? According to data in table 6, 40 percent of all surveyed U.S. teens report attending religious services once a week or more, and 19 percent report attending one to three times per month; 22 percent report attending religious services a few or many times a year, and 18 percent report never attending religious services. Again,
Table 6. Religious Service Attendance of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
US.
Religious Tradition GPa MP2 BPa RG. aly oDSaa NR:
Religious service attendance More than once a week 16.0
29 4 13
~ Once a week DAD LG ele iy. -6 oF
~ 2-3 times a month ny yee
As = be
~ Once a month
~ Many times a year
ied Oped Sin i
A few times a year DW Stree 2i pete. Limam Dilek 3 6
Never
Fo Ae 2,
Would attend if totally up to teen More than once a week (pene Fea NC yeaa | Spray yr.
Once a week PU cretion cay <P OTA at alate:
Maden
2-3 times a month LS Paes ZO SLEW L788 E10
Once a month y
8) 22)
Many times a year
i bye yA)
2, A few times a year
Geral
(ea) Never
V4.
Attends more than one religious congregation
~ Attends with Both parents AS 58) 93, 36"
44.
~ Only one parent Die
ee 4G 20m Zo Lo ~ Neither parent
Baas)
Doesn't attend/Other
Sie Oe SOR Or S198 Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~.
SOUL SEARCHING
religious service attendance varies greatly by religious tradition of the teen.
Seventy-one percent of Mormon teens and 55 percent of conservative Protestant teens attend weekly or more; on the other hand, 58 percent of Jewish teens, for whom religious service attendance often means something different than for Christian teens, and 31 percent of Catholic teens attend religious services only a few times a year or never. Almost all of the nonreligious teens never attend religious services. Mainline and black Protestant teens fall in their frequency of church attendance between the extremes. Still, in all of the religious traditions (not including the nonreligious), there is notable variance in religious service attendance, with teens falling all along the spectrum.
Some observers suggest and some assume that youth attend religious services mostly because their parents make them attend, but would not attend if it were their own choice. To examine this possibility, the NSYR included the question "If it were totally up to you, how often would you attend religious services?" Perhaps surprisingly, table 6 shows that U.S. teens as a whole report that they would like to attend religious services even more than they currently do. Fully 5 percent more than those who report actually attending services once a week or more say that they would like to attend weekly or more (45 compared to 40 percent). And 7 percent fewer than those who attend only a few times a year or never say they would like to attend religious services that infrequently (32 compared to 25 percent). In other words, U.S. teens as a group profess to want to attend religious services not less, but actually more than they currently do. Some of this difference may be mere wishful thinking, with the effect of making the teens feel better about themselves more than actually motivating them to attend religious services more often. On the other hand, at least some of the teens we interviewed did report uncooperative parents and transportation problems preventing them from attending religious services more often than they did. In any case, these findings provide no evidence supporting the belief that significant numbers of teens would like to stop attending religious service and are only doing otherwise because their parents are forcing them to attend.
Table 6 also shows that, although most U.S. teens seem content adhering to only one religion, significant numbers of them attend services at more than one religious congregation. Black Protestant, Jewish, and mainline Protestant teens range on the high end, in the 20 percent range. Conservative Protestant and Catholic teens attend more than one church at 18 and 14 percent, respectively, Mormon teens are the only group that clearly attend only one congregation (or ward), with few exceptions. Thus, although U.S. youth are generally not mixing and matching different religious faiths, significant proportions of them appear to be involved with different churches or other religious congregations.
With whom do U.S. teenagers attend? Slightly fewer than half attend with both parents, 21 percent attend with only one parent, and 10 percent attend with neither parent. The last group may attend with a friend, with another family relative such as an aunt or grandparent, or by themselves. Again,
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
almost one in four never attend. More than half of Mormon, conservative Protestant, mainline Protestant, and Catholic teens attend religious services with both of their parents. Jewish teens attend with both parents at a rate about the national norm. Black Protestant teens are much more likely than all other groups to attend with only one parent, probably in part because black teens are more likely to come from single-parent families. Nearly all nonreligious teens do not attend or do not have parents with whom they might attend.
FEATURES OF FAITH
What does the NSYR tell us about the character of faith of U.S. adolescents?
Aside from organizational participation, what might we learn about teens' subjective experience of religious belief? According to table 7, an impressive proportion of U.S. teens profess that religious faith is important in their lives, both in shaping daily life and in making major life decisions. On both measures, about half of teens said that faith is very or extremely important in their lives; only about 8 percent said faith was not important at all. To simplify matters a bit, we believe that the most important dividing line separating these answer categories is between the "very" and "somewhat" important answers, a distinct impression formed through our hundreds of hours of monitoring actual telephone surveys and by conducting in-depth interviews around the country. For teens to say that faith is "very important" to them is to take a fairly strong stand on the matter. But for them to say that faith is "somewhat important" can describe some fairly inconsequential experiences of religious belief when the teens may not feel comfortable saying on a survey that "faith doesn't matter much." If so, then table 7 tells us, in rough terms, that faith is an important matter for about half of U.S. teens and not particularly important for the other half.
Table 7 also reports on how close to God U.S. teens say they feel. Thirtysix percent report that they feel very or extremely close to God; 35 percent report feeling somewhat close to God; 25 percent feel some degree of distance from God; and 3 percent do not believe in any God to feel either close to or distant from. To the extent that survey answers provide reliable measures, then, we can conclude that slightly more than one-third of U.S. teens experience an intimate relationship with God, another third feel something in the middle, neither intimate nor distant, and almost one-third either feel distant from or do not believe in God. This variance is impressive, and differs again by religious tradition. This time, however, Mormon teens do not top the charts. Rather, black Protestants and conservative Protestants rank highest on closeness to God, with nearly 50 percent of each reporting that they feel very or extremely close to God. Forty-four percent of Mormon, 40 percent of mainline Protestant, and 31 percent of Catholic teens say they feel very or extremely close to God. Only 10 percent of Jewish teens—whose traditions, note, may or may not place God at the center of Judaism—report the same,
SOUL SEARCHING
Table 7. Characteristics of Religious Faith of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) tise Religious Tradition
CPP MP BP Re
J LDS NR Importance of religious faith shaping daily life Extremely important ZOE PLO DOM aS rl Om mero
Very important
S0MA2 S31!
SSS aLO Somewhat important SD Di SA 225) A tel taliGue2e Not very important Ti SOO iG eS iid aoe Oe ae Not important at all Fhe Ons Deva te OSS Importance of faith shaping major life decisions
Extremely important ZOU Steel er alr ry ae i Very important 99% tap igg +
age GE aginery Somewhat important S128 BOL Sa 2222 Not very important
G7 Sl) sues yrdiee esd eS.
Not important at all Situg lo) Gur Se Otel Ah eae eS) How close teen feels to God Extremely close 1 lea to asia yA PLD RY Mere ee VEX)
Very close 25) Sao S pe Lae eee ih Somewhat close BO) OOM O47 eS0)
DO hoo eo Somewhat distant LAS LOY SL Pee DOK Steet ay nase:
Very distant SHINES ANB) RS aD ee ess Extremely distant Spey ily fi Di dons Dre er Dic the Sin Meow a lel Does not believe in God ee eng gee Wem Seay Re Ge ae Believers' doubts about religious beliefs in prior year
Many doubts Sie Oe wiG uk Sm eas cao Some doubts
es lest Sa, UST Sea Ie Pan bos mem A few doubts SL
SO EO) aoe oe eee No doubts 48251
S244 S457 S12 = Refused he Es ci year Nase papi ure tig Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~; doubts about religion findings for nonreligious teens are reported in table 26. a mere 1 percent more than the report of nonreligious youth. Viewed from the other direction, 64 percent of Jewish and 63 percent of nonreligious teens either feel distant from or do not believe in God; about one in four Catholic and mainline Protestant youth feel distant from or do not believe in God; between one in six and one in four Mormon and black and conservative
Protestant teens feel the same. Once again, U.S. teens of all major traditions are spread across the spectrum of closeness to God, although with a few exceptions, more say they feel close to God than distant.
Finally, how many doubts about their religious beliefs do religious U.S. adolescents have? According to table 7, relatively few. Nearly half of religious teens report having no doubts at all in the prior year; another one-third had a few doubts. Only one in 20 religious teens reported dealing with many doubts about their faith in the previous year. Furthermore, compared to the other faith variables in table 7, the doubts answers varied less by religious
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
traditions. While Mormon teens had somewhat fewer doubts and Jewish teens somewhat more, the differences are not major. In general, U.S. religious teens do not appear to struggle a great deal with doubt about their faith.
RELIGIOUS AND SPIRITUAL BELIEFS AND EXPERIENCES
What do U.S. teenagers actually believe religiously? According to table 8, more than 80 percent do believe in God, slightly more than 10 percent are unsure about their belief in God, and, as we saw above, only 3 percent definitely do not believe in God. But what is the God that most teens believe in? About two-thirds of teens say they believe in God as a personal being involved in the lives of people today; 13 percent profess something like a deist's view of God as having created the world but not being involved in it now; and 14 percent take a more New Age approach to God as an impersonal, cosmic life force. Flve percent simply do not know or refuse to answer the question.
These findings are striking in different ways, depending on what one might have been expecting. Two out of three teens profess to believe in something like the Bible's personal, historically active God. On the other hand, more than 30 percent hold a deistic, New Age, or simply uncertain picture of God. Those who assume U.S. youth have been largely secularized might
Table 8. Beliefs of U.S. Adolescents about God, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) U.S.
Religious Tradition CP MP bein ROs-e Iho eS. oN Belief in God Believes in God
Ges
Is unsure in belief about God
Se O13 2? aay Ae
Does not believe in God
» ~
Views of God A personal being involved in the lives 65x eid WOON 74.) 64) data
of people today Created the world, but is not involved
LO 8 13s elSeer lie a2
in world today Not personal, something like a cosmic
Se e3 PETA E38
life force Don't know/refused/none of these views
Does not believe in God
Zz ~ if
~ V9 Believes in a judgment day when God will reward some and punish others Yes J
——25:
No jy
iP pho emael sig 5)
Don't know/refused
Does not believe in God
~ if
~ Aly Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~.
42.
SOUL SEARCHING
be surprised by the first finding. Those who assume U.S. youth are continuing on with a biblically traditional or orthodox view of God should be surprised by the second finding. Complicating the matter is the apparent logical inconsistency of some teens in relating to God; for example, while teens who embrace a personal view of God are much more likely than others to also say they feel close to God, 22 percent of teen "deists" in our survey reported feeling very or extremely close to God (the God they believe is not involved in the world today). Go figure. The bottom line is, when it comes to their religious belief about God, U.S. teens reflect a great deal of variance on the matter, and perhaps in some cases more than a little conceptual confusion.
All of this calls for in-depth interviews with teens, which we also conducted, to delve deeper into the content and possible complexities of their beliefs; many of those findings are reported in chapter 4.
In the meantime, it is useful to probe teens with more specific survey questions about religious beliefs. The bottom of table 8, for instance, tells us that more than 7 in 10 U.S. teens profess to belief in a coming judgment day when God will reward some and punish others. The vast majority of teens maintain that at least some people will have some divine consequences, good and bad, for their faith or actions. On the other hand, about one-quarter of U.S. teens—a sizable proportion—do not believe or do not know if they believe in a divine judgment day. Our analysis of interviews in chapter 4 will also help to inform this finding.
As with most other NSYR measures, all of these belief-in-God measures show notable variance across the religious traditions analyzed. Black and conservative Protestant teens, for example, stand out for their relatively high rates of definite belief in God. Among religious youth, Jewish, Catholic, Mormon, and mainline Protestant teens are relatively likely to not be sure whether they believe in God. On the other hand, about half of nonreligious teens profess to believe in God and another third are open to the possibility; only
17 percent of them say they simply do not believe in God. Likewise, about three-quarters of Mormon and black and conservative Protestant teens believe in a personal God whom they can know, while Jewish and nonreligious teens are comparatively more likely to gravitate toward a New Age version of God. This kind of variance is even more pronounced for the question about a judgment day, which Mormon and black and conservative Protestant teens are very likely to believe in, Catholic and mainline Protestant teens are somewhat likely to believe in, and Jewish and nonreligious teens are quite unlikely to believe in.
The meaning of all of this again depends largely on what one expects and hopes for. If one's baseline assumption is the widespread loss of religious belief among youth, then U.S. teens look awfully religious by these measures.
Then again, there may be more than a few Catholic and Mormon leaders who may be justifiably concerned that roughly one in every seven of their teenagers are not even convinced that God exists, or conservative Protestant pastors who are startled to learn that 10 and 8 percent of their teens hold deistic and New Age views of God, respectively, while another 5 percent are
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
confused, silent, or atheistic on the matter. In any case, table 8 reveals both a great deal of religious belief and a great deal of variance among teens in religious belief.
Table 9 further explores a variety of specific religious belief items—1including traditionally Christian, non-Christian, and "paranormal" beliefs—for all religious types analyzed here. The items are ranked from top to bottom in order of most to least believed in. Perhaps not surprisingly, the majority of U.S. teens are confident in their belief in the existence of angels. Almost
Table 9. Religious, Spiritual, and Paranormal Beliefs of U.S, Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) USS.
Religious Tradition GP MP Be RC els OS.
INR Believes in existence of angels Definitely
oe Soe Ce So
Maybe
ZOMG H S68
1199-235-2550:
Not at all
EAS PX eae 25) Believes in divine miracles from God Definitely Glee ae RE VOSS ea 2k
Maybe S30 OM oea ee 19 SB ee eed
Not at all
«29
Believes there is life after death Definitely AO
ee OU a Foe 25) ie O
Maybe BY 2 26
ol 44"
= 19
Not at all LSRION DON B19 S SLs
o! ie) Believes in existence of demons or evil spirits Definitely AILEY ESS!RbB 78 AS 22 CEPe 7s S69
Maybe
(26 , 89 27..44, 465.19
Not at all
Neo 9: SND IN pe tyme Gf a Be) Believes in reincarnation Definitely
hi Wee
24s
Maybe 36—.
26"
33., 40"
41.35)
Not at all Sil"
—*47"
Believes in astrology Definitely
Te ah 2 eal
Maybe Bile 7S ON 3S O35s28 4726-116 215) Not at all 59m M67 oal63in 54 a 544-4509 4.83
By!
Believes in communicating with the dead Definitely
V 6a
O'S Dio 1.
Maybe 30a 24 86. 33.826).
Not at all
S$2
Believes in psychics and fortune-tellers Definitely
Cee 13> aa lO Maybe Die iGe
16m
Not at all
A GD.
BOSE A/4
Notata EOE eS Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported refused answers (don't know included in "maybe"); cells of <1 are reported as ~.
SOUL SEARCHING
as many also believe in divine miracles from God. About half definitely believe there is life after death, and four out of ten believe in demons or evil spirits. From there, the numbers believing drop off precipitously. Only small minorities of U.S. teens definitely believe in reincarnation, astrology, communicating with the dead, and psychics and fortune-tellers—although roughly one-third are open to the possibilities that these things may be real.
Once again, the general pattern across religious traditions that is by now becoming familiar is evident in this table, too. Mormon and black and conservative Protestant teens are the most likely to hold traditional, biblical religious beliefs, such as in angels, demons, and miracles, and the least likely to hold non-Christian, paranormal, or occultic beliefs. Jewish and nonreligious teens tend toward the opposite, and mainline Protestant and Catholic youth generally fall between those sets of groups.
Aside from these broad generalizations about tradition-specific differences, many observers should be interested in the results of the "maybe" answers in table 9, which give hints of significant slippage in the religious education of youth. When combined with the "not at all" answers, large segments of Catholic youth, for example, are far from convinced about the existence of angels (42 percent report maybe or not at all), miracles (45 percent), life after death (55 percent), or the existence of evil spirits (71 percent report maybe or not at all). On the other hand, 57 percent of Catholic youth maybe or definitely believe in reincarnation, 46 percent in astrology, 48 percent in communicating with the dead, and 32 percent in psychics and fortunetellers. There is an immense amount of slippage here between the official
Catholic catechism and the actual professed beliefs of Catholic teenagers.
Likewise, significant portions of conservative Protestant youth are not assured about the existence of angels (21 percent report maybe or not at all), miracles
(23 percent), life after death (38 percent), or the existence of evil spirits (42 percent report maybe or not at all). On the other hand, 33 percent of conservative Protestant youth maybe or definitely believe in reincarnation, 33 percent in astrology, 31 percent in communicating with the dead, and 21 percent in psychics and fortune-tellers. For a tradition that has so strongly emphasized the infallibility or inerrancy of the Bible, the exclusive claims of conservative Christianity, and the need for a personal commitment of one's life to God, some of these numbers are astounding. Even the conservative
Protestants evince a great deal of slippage in the effectiveness of the Christian education of their youth. At the same time, large proportions of the selfidentified nonreligious teens either definitely believe in or are open to the possibility of believing in all eight of these religious and magical ideas. Dismissive of the existence of a possible spiritual world America's professed nonreligious teens are not.
Table 10 examines various personal religious experiences of U.S. teenagers, in which we see that roughly half report having had each of a variety of religious experiences. Further analysis (not shown in the table) reveals that only 20 percent of all U.S. teenagers report not having had any of these four religious experiences. Twenty percent of teens report having experienced all
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
Table 10. Religious Experiences of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) U.S.
Religious Tradition CRAM bei. se uNGibn oe oiclOS ae NIK Has made a personal commitment to live Same ie OOM a4 tie Lol GO skeet 3 life for God Has ever had an experience of spiritual SE ZOU GAY USO me 37!
ASHE
ef I. worship that was very moving and powerful Has ever experienced a definite answer to SUC Aon wa = Olt mT as ri Sabi 07.
prayer or specific guidance from God Has ever witnessed or experienced what AGL TGO Ga SitiOO, yaaaeie WAL pice Ly apeacie teen believed was a miracle from God Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3. four, another 20 percent have experienced three of the four, 18 percent have experienced two, and 17 percent have had one of these four religious experiences (the remaining 5 percent involve don't know and refused answers).
The vast majority of U.S. religious teens and minorities of nonreligious teens, then, report having had one or more significant religious experiences.
The likelihood of a teen having had one of these religious experiences varies significantly by religious tradition. Following the general pattern observed in previous tables, conservative Protestant, black Protestant, and Mormon teens are the most likely to have had these religious experiences; nonreligious teens are the least likely; and Jewish, Catholic, and mainline
Protestant teens fall somewhere between those groups, depending on the specific question. Jewish teens, for example, are not big on making personal commitments to live for God,' but are ahead of the Catholics on experiences of powerful worship and ahead of the mainline Protestants on having witnessed a miracle. Altogether, however, we can repeat our observation that U.S. teens of almost any religious tradition are not deprived of significant religious experiences.
PERSONAL RELIGIOUS PRACTICES
Yet another important dimension of religious life worth examining is religious practices: specific actions in which religious believers engage over time that embody spiritual meaning and foster personal formation toward excellence in religious faith and works. Religious practices are spiritually significant habits intentionally engaged in for the purpose of being shaped by them toward the good as known by a religious faith. Prayer, scripture reading, meditation, and tithing are well-known religious practices, but there are many other possibilities.' Not all religious traditions encourage or require observing the same religious practices, obviously, but the NSYR survey asked all teens about many practices anyway, simply to map out proportions. Inclusion in table
11, however, does not imply that all teens should be engaging all of these practices. In any case, table 11 shows their reported engagement in a great
Table 11. Personal Religious Practices of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) U.S.
Religious Tradition MPO BPA RGAE EDS SNR CP In prior year, teen:
Practiced religious or spiritual meditation not
10: iota lOc lat gee mele including prayer Served as an acolyte or altar server Been part of a religious support of evangelism or tit
25.10
— LL AL 8 a ae pen pany prayer group that meets at school Taught a Sunday School or religious education class
Burned candles or incense that had religious or
261-22 AS
Pn seta (Dili 0 we Irae Claciad dM spiritual meaning Fasted or denied self something as spiritual
25) 20)
discipline Been part of any other scripture study or prayer 27,
SL 3 5 ae 2
5a ie group Played or sang in a religious music group or choir Read a devotional, religious, or spiritual book other
35.
— QB 2922) 287 GS than the scriptures Spoke publicly about own faith in a religious service
33) 345520)
See or meeting (not including bar/bat mitzvah) Tried to practice a weekly day of rest or Sabbath
Attended a religious music concert ~ Chose to wear jewelry or clothing expressing
Sor
PSE Vir a IEF 5} Se
APRA
NAD ES 7 US 7Ee RDS:
religious or spiritual meaning Shared own religious faith with someone not of
Sd.
Ady Sif 58: ye7 2s faith Listened to religious radio programs, or CDs or
SPATE MS TSO BLL tapes by a religious music group Worked hard to reconcile a broken relationship
Shes
50:
S615 S/S Sees Frequency of teen praying alone Many times a day About once a day A few times a week About once a week
aa)
iG (Si s0S OMe PS
19 we 2 Smt 2 Ser Shoe24 Z DSi 1A
BA lia
ite ae ae eRe Oey
6s e284 en i alke) 1-2 times a month Less than once a month Never 12:
TIRE S13
Si Public professions of faith Of all Christians: been confirmed or baptized as
SIMS 34 oe ee public affirmation of faith (not infant baptism) Of all Jewish: had a bar or bat mitzvah Of all Mormons: been confirmed or baptized as
public affirmation of faith (not infant baptism) Of all other religions: done any religious rite of passage or public affirmation of religious faith: 15 percent
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~.
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
variety of religious practices, with the first cluster of measures listed in order of participation, from least to greatest. What we see is that significant minorities of U.S. teenagers report having engaged in most of a long list of religious practices in the previous year. Fewer than 20 percent have meditated, served as acolytes, or participated in a religious group meeting at school.
Between 20 and 29 percent have taught Sunday school, burned candles or incense for religious reasons, engaged in the spiritual disciplines of fasting or self-denial, and participated in a scripture study or prayer or religious music group. About one-third of teens report having read a religious book, spoken at a religious service, practiced a religious day of rest, and attended a religious music concert, and nearly half have worn clothing or jewelry with religious meaning, shared their faith with another person, and listened to religious music outside of a concert. (Nearly 60 percent of teens report having worked toward relational reconciliation, although whether or not this was religiously motivated was not specified by the survey question.)
Differences across religious traditions for many of these practices are notable, although not consistent across them all. Mormon teens, for instance, are strong on sharing their faith and teaching Sunday school, among other practices, but seem to avoid burning candles and incense and are less likely than other groups to wear jewelry or clothing that expresses spiritual meaning. Black Protestant teens are big on playing or singing in religious music groups and choirs but come out on the lower end on spiritual meditation.
Similar comparative observations could be made for teens in other religious traditions, although space does not allow for specific mention of all interesting differences, which readers will have to study in greater depth. Suffice it to say here that significant minorities of U.S. teens of all religious traditions examined profess in their survey answers to have in the previous year engaged in nearly all of the different religious practices we asked about. Furthermore, although the NSYR did not ask all religious practice questions of nonreligious teens, for obvious reasons, more than trivial numbers of them report having engaged in the previous year in most of the religious practices about which the survey did ask. Twenty percent of nonreligious teens, for instance, listen to religious music, 15 percent wore religious jewelry or clothing, 11 percent burned candles or incense for spiritual reasons, 11 percent practiced spiritual meditation, and 9 percent attended a religious music concert. Thus, while the majority of nonreligious U.S. teenagers refrain from religious practices, not all do.
Table 11 also explores the reported personal prayer practices of U.S. teens.
Nearly 40 percent report that they pray daily or more often; nearly 30 percent pray once or a few times a week; 20 percent pray more sporadically than that; and 15 percent of U.S. teens never pray. Again, the variance in frequency of personal prayer across all U.S. teens is impressive. Mormon teens appear to pray the most often, followed by black Protestant and conservative Protestant teens. Catholics and mainline Protestants pray alone with comparative moderate frequency. Jewish and nonreligious teens are the least likely to engage in the regular practice of personal prayer. At 51 percent, the nonreligious
SOUL SEARCHING
are the most likely never to pray, but they are also slightly more likely than Jewish youth to pray once a week or more. Social location in a particular
U.S. religious tradition thus strongly influences the likelihood of teens engaging in the practice of personal prayer.
The NSYR also asked teens of different religious groups whether they have ever completed the religious rite of passage or public affirmation of faith appropriate to their tradition (table 11). On the high end, 79 percent of Mormon teens had been baptized. Fewer than half of all Christian teens together (46 percent) had been confirmed or baptized as youth, with the spread among those traditions ranging from 59 percent of mainline Protestant teens to 41 percent of Catholic teens on the high and low ends, respectively.
Only 15 percent of teens in other religions (not Christian, Jewish, or Mormon) appear to have performed a religious rite of passage or public affirmation of faith.
Because some religious practices are tradition-specific, the NSYR asked certain questions of U.S. teens in particular religious groups. The survey asked
U.S. teenagers who either identified themselves as Catholic or who had a Catholic parent—whom we here refer to as "Catholic teens"—for instance, about six specific Catholic practices. According to table 12, 71 percent of those Catholic teens have taken First Communion, nearly half have religious altars in their homes, and 44 percent prayed the rosary, Novenas, or to a special saint in the previous year. Forty percent of U.S. Catholic teenagers had participated in a confession or a reconciliation liturgy and 19 percent in a religious pilgrimage, procession, or way of the cross in the previous year.
Celebrating the Virgin of Guadalupe or a Virgin of another country of origin is a popular religious practice among many Hispanic Catholics in the United
States; fully 61 percent (this question was only asked of Hispanic Catholics) do so, according to findings in table 12. Because some Catholics are practicTable 12. Faith Tradition-specific Religious Practices of U.S. Catholic Adolescents,
Ages 13-17 (Percentages) (N=906) Attends 2-3 Times a Month or Attends Once a More Often Month or Less All (51%) Often (48%) Taken First Communion mi
Has sacred altars or images in home
bys)
Prayed the rosary, Novenas, or to special saints
57, ol in the prior year Been to a confession or reconciliation liturgy in
the prior year Participated in a religious pilgrimage, procession,
27,
way of the cross, or other similar practice Celebrates the Virgin of Guadalupe or Virgin of
country of origin (Hispanic Catholics only, N=231) as ere ener Pia ys ae eee Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
ing Catholics and others are nominally Catholic, table 12 divides the NSYR Catholic teen sample into those who attend church services two to three times a month or more often and those who attend church once a month or less often.' As we would expect, we see that the regularly attending Catholic teens engage in all of the religious practices at noticeably higher rates, in some cases at about double the rate of the lower-attending Catholic teens. Even so, significant proportions of regularly attending Catholic teenagers do not engage in various Catholic religious practices; 45 percent of them, for instance, have not been to confession or a reconciliation liturgy in the prior year. All told, the U.S. Catholic Church could be doing better at engaging its teenagers in its religious practices, though our findings hardly suggest that overall it is entirely failing to do so.
The NSYR asked another tradition-specific set of religious practices of its 72 Jewish teen respondents. These 72 either identified their first or second religion as Jewish or had a Jewish parent respondent. This sample represents a modest but nevertheless respectable number for a national sample of such a relatively small religious minority. Because there are different kinds of these
Jewish teens in the United States, we broke the sample down into three groups: teens who consider themselves "religiously Jewish" (22 percent of the sample), those who consider themselves mostly "culturally Jewish" (42 percent), and those who do not identify themselves as Jewish but have at least one Jewish parent and so may engage in some Jewish observances despite their personal lack of Jewish identity (31 percent of the sample; 5 percent responded "don't know"). Those three groups are broken out into three columns in table 13, along with all 72 sampled teens totaled together on the far left. There we see, first, that there are large differences between the three types of Jewish teenagers. As we might expect, the religiously Jewish teens
Table 13. Religious Observances of U.S. Jewish Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) (N=72) All: Teen Is Teen Teen Teen Not Jewish or Identifies Identifies _Self-identified Has a Self as Self as as Jewish but Jewish Religiously Culturally Has a Jewish Parent Jewish Jewish Parent Regularly practices Jewish traditions
observing the Sabbath Have taken classes to study Hebrew,
Jewish history, traditions, or modern Jewish life in prior two years Celebrated Hanukkah last year
Celebrated Passover last year
Celebrated Rosh Hashanah last year
Celebrated Yom Kippur last year Fe.
Celebrated Sukkot last year
Celebrated Simkhat Torah last year
Celebrated oimkhat Loran last eee Source; National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
SOUL SEARCHING
say they observe most Jewish holidays and practices at much higher rates than the culturally Jewish teens, who themselves appear to be observant at generally higher rates than the non-Jewish teens with Jewish parents. Somewhere between three-quarters and all self-described religiously Jewish teenagers report observing the Sabbath and major holidays and engage in Jewish education. Significant numbers of "culturally Jewish" teenagers are also observant of many Jewish holidays and practices. Even among the non-Jewish teens with Jewish parents, notable proportions report celebrating Hanukkah,
Passover, Rosh Hashanah, and Yom Kippur, and approximately 20 percent observe the Sabbath, engage in Jewish education, and celebrate Sukkot and Simkhat Torah. When grouped together, between 33 and about 90 percent of this sample of Jewish teenagers observe these various Jewish holidays and practices. These findings comport with our understanding of contemporary
American Judaism as centered more on family and community observance of rituals and holidays than on commitment to specific cognitive beliefs and doctrines. Measured in these specific terms, U.S. Jewish teenagers are doing fairly well in practicing their religious faith, at least no less well than teens in many Christian traditions.
News from studies and projections about the future of the Jewish community in the United States often convey dismal messages about the effects of high rates of marriage to non-Jews as well as other social processes and factors that appear to be eroding Jewish community boundaries and identities. There is no doubt that many social changes in recent decades are raising real challenges for the continuation of a distinct, coherent religioethnic Judaism in the United States. Yet the findings of table 13 should also be accounted for in considering American Judaism's future. Whatever theological beliefs Jewish teenagers embrace and however subjectively important Jewish faith and identity may or may not be to them, we at least still find notable levels of traditional Jewish observances not only among "religiously Jewish" teenagers, as we would expect, but also among the "culturally Jewish." Even teens who do not consider themselves Jewish but have Jewish parents appear to be drawn into many Jewish observances in significant numbers. The future of American Judaism is a complex and challenging subject, which we do not want naively to oversimplify here. But we do think these findings on U.S.
Jewish teenagers may contribute another important piece of the larger puzzle well worth trying to fit into the bigger picture.1°
RELIGIOUS GROUP ACTIVITIES
For many American teenagers, religious involvement means more than simply attending church, synagogue, mosque, or temple. A variety of other religious activities are often also available for their participation. Table 14 begins our examination of these activities by focusing in depth on U.S. teens' involvement in religious youth groups. According to NSYR data, 38 percent of all
U.S, teenagers are currently involved in a religious youth group, and 69 percent are now or previously have been involved in a religious youth group.
Table 14. Religious Youth Group Experiences of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) U.S.
Religious Tradition OeVin ee Bree NC aaa ISIN IS Currently involved in a religious youth group
ESE DSL PE:
RY ee 7 Nea Ever in life involved in a religious youth group
Involved in a congregation with a youth group
— (of religious service—attending teens: 85 percent) Youth group participation rate (currently
— involved in YG/YG available in congregation) Congregation has a designated youth minister
Full-time A Ung ih li a Aleta Veaaky 2s Uae a Part-time
Sh MZ oe 1 ON Qa Volunteer 2OUwSil Ueew2ty Borst 12) 8San= Don't know
ae eee Not attending congregation or no youth BOme Oe SO Na D2 fk S minister Youth group teen is involved with is Part of teen's religious congregation S26
49".
32, 5 20-22
Part of another religious congregation
5S — Of another religious faith O4SLOS 10S O44 0STS ee — Teen not in youth group 62enidAsat4sia 6G24A766 0/37 28a; Frequency of current youth group attendance
More than once a week
524 Ae oi About once a week Ne?
AY es a oe ee 2-3 times a month
a al
See Se About once a month
Ry Oe A few times a year
DS, Ves Never 62144, (45h
76 1A 73228N
O99 Number of years currently involved teen in youth group 8-10
A Se a 5-7 Tie wp es
Dea ars 2-4 US 30s Col,
f42
J if
Ape io:
Sai <1
"ee Zero 62h Adie 4S) 6259876011073 28299 Type of youth group involvement Teen is a leader gel p, LA ayalS
TsO b eet ce Teen is just a participant Ae soe Se
oe OO ee Both (leader and participant)
Agi ees ea eet Not involved
44"
45) 62)
INGE IVONWEG
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~.
SOUL SEARCHING
The lives of the majority of young Americans, then, connect to religious youth groups at some time during the teenage years. Nearly 70 percent of all teens attend a religious congregation that also sponsors a youth group; fully 85 percent of teens who attend religious services belong to congregations with youth groups. The vast majority of religious congregations with teens present, then, appear to offer youth groups for their teenagers. Furthermore, 30 percent of all teens have available to them youth group programs overseen by full-time youth ministers (whether or not the teens participate in them), according to teen reports, and nearly the same number have youth groups with part-time or volunteer youth ministers (again, whether or not they participate). Slightly more than one-third of U.S. teens (36 percent) either do not attend services at a religious congregation where they might encounter a youth group or do attend a congregation that does not sponsor any youth group. Of teens involved in religious youth groups, the vast majority (32 percent of all teens, 84 percent of youth group-involved teens) participate in a youth group from their own religious congregation. Only 4 percent of all teens participating in a youth group attend youth groups at religious congregations other than their own, and fewer than one-half of 1 percent participate in religious youth groups from another religious faith altogether.
Teen involvement with religious youth groups is highly variable by tradition. The majority of Mormon and conservative and mainline Protestant teens are currently involved in youth groups. But only about one-quarter of Catholic and Jewish youth participate in religious youth groups. Nearly onethird of currently nonreligious teens were once involved in a religious youth group, but all but 1 percent have dropped that involvement, presumably in the process of having become not religious. By dividing the percentage of teens currently involved in a religious youth group by the percentage attending congregations sponsoring youth groups, we can estimate the youth group participation rate of teens in various traditions. Mormons have the highest participation rate (75 percent), followed by mainline and conservative Protestants (64 percent each). Black Protestant and Jewish teens have participation rates of 44 and 41 percent, respectively (in many black churches, participation in youth choir functions as the equivalent of involvement in a religious youth group, about which see table 11). Of all the religious groups examined, Catholic teens have the lowest youth group participation rate, thus calculated, at 32 percent; in other words, two-thirds of Catholic teens who attend churches that sponsor youth groups do not participate in them.
But how deeply are U.S. teens involved in religious youth groups? According to table 14, nearly one-third of all teens (32 percent) report attending youth group two to three times a month or more often. Only a handful attend more sporadically. The remaining teens simply do not attend. Youth group attendance thus appears to be something teens do regularly or not do at all.
Youth group attendance varies by religious tradition as well. Fifty-seven percent of Mormon teens, 43 percent of conservative Protestant teens, and 35 percent of mainline Protestant teens attend youth group weekly or more often. By contrast, only 13 percent of Catholic and 12 percent of Jewish teens
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
attend youth group weekly or more often, and about three-quarters of those groups never attend youth group, a number surpassed only by the 99 percent of nonreligious teens who also never attend. As to years spent in youth groups, of those teens participating in religious youth groups, the majority have been involved for more than one year, with 31 percent of all U.S. teens involved for two or more years. Mormon teens tend to have been involved in youth group for more years, as have conservative and mainline Protestant teens, compared to black Protestant, Catholic, and Jewish teens. Finally, overall, one in three teens in youth groups appear to think of themselves as leaders and not merely participants. Mormon youth are the most likely to claim to be leaders in their youth groups and Catholic youth the least likely.
Table 15 examines U.S. teens' participation in a number of other kinds Table 15. Religious Group Activities of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
WES.
Religious Tradition CPP a MRSS BP PR Gras].
DS.
J.NR Frequency of religious Sunday School or CCD attendance More than once a week Pate?
LEE ES
Once a week US 2a Lowe Om kt ee ey
Almost every week PPR S OSE See Tel
A few times a month LO: eat?
Oa?
O5RS 10 ae?
Once a month
Sree dO cctndc 0. LO
A few times a year 1S Se 19)
TOG Se Oe:
Never DIU EOE ilies iat {MRE Ie)
Number of religious youth retreats, conferences, rallies, or congresses participated in
ee ee See De Oe ya ee ORS:
P20 nT3e M4 iPass an
2-4 DO
Sie eS
dor 22.
5-7
lO LO i
ae Mak Z 8+
Number of times attended religious summer camp as a camper
61o AAG]
50.
TBE 7 Se GID Toe TS ii 2-4 NA 2as QSret Uses Wenn S43
5-7
Swen cal Zi
— Number of times gone on a religious missions team or service project
ET MON NSS COMI Lee ike = 50, Oe if TP egis LR TO
2-4 USE ALG 19S:
TSA Beez?
P 5-7
~ 8+
eee, ee Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers.
SOUL SEARCHING
of organized religious group activities. Here we see, first, that 36 percent of U.S. teenagers report attending Sunday school, or CCD (Confraternity of Christian Doctrine) classes almost every week or more often; 34 percent attend sporadically, between a few times a year and a few times a month; and 29 percent never attend Sunday school or CCD. Again, the variance across all U.S. teens is great. Mormon and conservative Protestant teens attend such religious education classes the most, and nonreligious and Catholic teens attend the least.
Nearly half (45 percent) of U.S. teens have attended religious youth retreats, conferences, rallies, or congresses; 39 percent have attended religious summer camps as campers; and 30 percent have participated in a religious missions team or service project. Substantial numbers of U.S. teenagers, in other words, have at least been exposed to if not significantly involved in a variety of youth-oriented religious group learning and service activities beyond religious service attendance and religious education classes. Indeed, when answers for these three questions are combined, 60 percent of all U.S. teens have participated in at least one of these religious group activities at least once; only 40 percent have done none of these activities. Mormon and conservative and mainline Protestant teens were much more likely than the average teen to be involved in youth retreats, camps, and missions and service projects; while nonreligious and Catholic youth were much less likely than the average. Even so, fully 24 percent of nonreligious teens have participated in at least one of these religious group activities. Jewish teens are somewhat less likely than the average teen to be involved in religious retreats and missions and service projects, but they are also more likely to have attended a religious summer camp as a camper. Taken altogether, the numbers in table
15 suggest that the means by which U.S. teenagers connect to religion through organized group activities are many and significant, even if the effects of such involvements remain to be explored.
RELIGION IN RELATIONSHIPS: FAMILY, FRIENDS,
SCHOOL, AND OTHER ADULTS
Religious faith and spiritual practice are not simply matters of individual experience and institutional involvements. They are also embedded in and sometimes draw much of their life from personal relationships in families, with friends, at school, and with other adults. The NSYR asked its sample of U.S. teenagers how religion connected through and interacted with these kinds of personal social ties. Table 16 examines religious expression and interaction in the teens' families. There we see that about one-third of families
(34 percent) talk together about God, the scriptures, prayer, or other religious or spiritual matters a few times a week or more; 28 percent talk about these matters a few times a month or weekly; and 38 percent a few times a year or never. Thus, in their family conversations about matters of faith, U.S. families of teenagers are split roughly into thirds between high, medium, and low levels of discussion. Families of Mormon teens appear to talk about
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
Table 16. Religious Life in Families of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
US.
Religious Tradition Chee BE RG | LDS NR Family talks about God, the scriptures, prayer, or other religious or spiritual things together
Every day OM ES a. fetter
A few times a week LOVER QT MUSA 291832
About once a week ctl 14s aAde a 12m =A OTs. 8
A few times a month Ue Ont 26 wand Zs 208.
WG ey al@) A few times a year Ltt Loe LO 2) ee On
Never LOS ELOY ee2G Se et EE
Family gives thanks before or after mealtimes S46 sy 4)
40a lor 34)"
to Teen prays out loud or silently with one or both
parents, other than at mealtimes or religious services Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~. religious and spiritual matters the most, followed next in frequency by families of black and conservative Protestant teens. Families of nonreligious and Jewish teens talk about religion the least, with only 9 percent each talking a few times a week or more often. Families of mainline Protestant and Catholic teenagers fall between those groups. Overall, however, it is a minority of every type of household that never talks about religious or spiritual matters.
A slight majority of all U.S. families with teenagers (54 percent) is reported by teens as regularly praying to give thanks before or after mealtimes.
Families of Mormon, black Protestant, and conservative Protestant teens are more likely than the average family with teens to pray to give thanks at meals.
They are followed in frequency by Catholic (45 percent) and nonreligious teen families (18 percent). Jewish teen families are, at 13 percent, the least likely to give thanks at meals, which, like some of the other measures in this chapter, is not an expected or required religious observance for Jews anyway.
Mainline Protestant teen families pray at meals at the national average. But praying to give thanks at family mealtimes, one might think, is a rather easy and costless habit that can be as perfunctory and rote as sincere and meaningful. What about more obviously significant family religious practices? Table 16 also presents the percentage of teens whose parents in the previous year prayed together with them, out loud or silently, at times other than at meals or religious services. Forty-one percent of all teenagers report praying in this way with their parents in the previous year. Again, Mormon, black
Protestant, and conservative Protestant teens are most likely to pray with their parents, and nonreligious, Jewish, mainline Protestant, and Catholic teens are less likely than the national average to pray with their parents. The overall large minorities and sometimes majorities of teens across the religious groups whose parents pray together with them other than at mealtimes or
SOUL SEARCHING
religious services is notable and perhaps even surprising, given the intimacy that can be involved in such experiences. More generally, table 16 tells us that for a significant number of U.S. teens, religion and spirituality are not simply compartmentalized in church, synagogue, mosque, or temple, but are also expressed and shared in the family life of the home.
One of the key themes of this book is that parents are normally very important in shaping the religious and spiritual lives of their teenage children, even though they may not realize it. It seems that many parents of teens rely primarily on the immediate evidence of the overt attitudes, statements, and sometimes behaviors that their teenage children dole out to them on a daily basis in order to estimate their current level of parental influence. Many of the attitudes and statements that teenagers communicate to their parents do not exactly express great admiration and gratitude for and readiness to listen to, emulate, or freely obey their parents. Many parents therefore appear to come to the conclusion that they have lost their influence in shaping the lives of their teenage children, that they no longer make any significant difference.
But for most, this conclusion is mistaken. Teenagers' attitudes, verbal utterances, and immediate behaviors are often not the best evidence with which to estimate parental influence in their lives. For better or worse, most parents in fact still do profoundly influence their adolescents—often more than do their peers—their children's apparent resistance and lack of appreciation notwithstanding. This influence often also includes parental influence in adolescents' religious and spiritual lives. Simply by living and interacting with their children, most parents establish expectations, define normalcy, model life practices, set boundaries, and make demands—all of which cannot help but influence teenagers, for good or ill. Most teenagers and their parents may not realize it, but a lot of research in the sociology of religion suggests that the most important social influence in shaping young people's religious lives is the religious life modeled and taught to them by their parents."
These findings in prior research are also evident in NSYR data. Take, for instance, the figures presented in table 17, which cross-tabulates differences
Table 17. Association of the Importance of Faith in Daily Life for U.S. Parents of Teenagers and of Their Adolescent Children, Ages 13-17 (Row percentages)
Teen Importance of Faith Parent importance of faith Extremely Very Somewhat Not Very Not at All Percent Total
SLE ed aia ae ce eh ED AST ELE N/E Ee Cr Were!
Extremely important
Very important
sie
Fairly important Ui
Somewhat important
Not very important
Not important at all 2)
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers.
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
Swi in the importance of faith in the daily life of U.S. teenagers (in columns) by the importance of faith for their parents (in rows). Table 17 shows clearly that the importance of faith for teenagers fairly closely tracks the importance of faith for their parents. Parents for whom religious faith is quite important are thus likely to be raising teenagers for whom faith is quite important, while parents whose faith is not important are likely to be raising teenagers for whom faith is also not important. The fit is not perfect. None of this is guaranteed or a tecciaed, and sometimes, in specific instances, things turn out otherwise. But the overall positive association is clear. Hence, of parents who report that their faith is extremely important in their daily lives, 67 percent of their teens report that faith is extremely or very important in their daily lives; only 8 percent of those parents' teens report that faith is not very or not at all important in their lives. Likewise, of parents for whom faith is somewhat important in their daily lives,
61 percent of their teens also report that faith is somewhat or not very important in their daily lives; only 8 percent of those parents' teens report that faith is extremely important in their lives. Finally, of parents for whom faith is not at all important in their daily lives, 47 percent of their teens also report that religious faith is not at all or not very important in their lives; only 2 percent report that faith is extremely important in their lives. In sum, therefore, we think that the best general rule of thumb that parents might use to reckon their children's most likely religious outcomes is this: "We'll get what we are." By normal processes of socialization, and unless other significant forces intervene, more than what parents might say they want as religious outcomes in their children, most parents most likely will end up getting religiously of their children what they themselves are. This observation we will make again in different ways in later chapters.
Other influences in the lives of many U.S. adolescents are friends and peers. Table 18 presents findings on the religious characteristics of the sampled teens' five closest friends. An average of about one-half (2.6) of all teens' five closest friends hold religious beliefs similar to those of the teens. This varies only slightly between the religious groups, with the exception of Jewish
Table 18. Religious Characteristics of Five Closest Friends of U.S. Adolescents,
Ages 13-17 (Average number out of 5) nn nnn eae EEE EEE Ey SESE ESSE ESSENSE US.
Religious Tradition Number out of 5 closest friends who CPP MPs BP ARC.
LDS NR Hold similar religious beliefs as teen does OS,
SHE Oe ROPING? = OER I Na
2 fe Are involved in same religious group as teen Tepe eS ee VDA eh 20,7 2A Are not religious OB O47 7
2052) 03057, 30.8.
= Are religious a ee | Are involved in any religious youth group AGE el Seu, o LO mel Zee.
7EMO.S Teen talks to about religious beliefs and experiences 1.8
2.1
2.0
1.8
14 14 3.1
1.2
Are bad moral influences on teen
0.3.0.3
0:3"
0:4.
0.4.
0.2) 0.3
Are bad moral intluences OM (ebm Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
SOUL SEARCHING
teens, who have a lower proportion of best friends who share their faith.'?
An average of slightly more than one out of five (1.2) of teens' five closest friends are involved in any of the same religious groups in which the teens are involved. Mormon and black and conservative Protestant teens have somewhat higher proportions of friends involved in their own religious groups, and Jewish teens have notably lower proportions. All but the Jewish religious teens have among their five best friends roughly the national average for religious teens of 0.3 friends who are not religious; Jewish teens have almost double that rate at 0.7. By comparison, nonreligious teens have an average of 1.1 of their five best friends who are religious. In other words, religious teenagers tend to make most of their best friendships with other religious teens, and nonreligious teenagers tend to make most of their friendships with nonreligious teens. Religious and nonreligious identities thus tend to cluster around and be reinforced by close friendship networks.
Religious American teens have averages of between one and almost three of their five best friends involved in some religious youth group. Mormon teens take the high end, with 2.7 friends, followed by conservative Protestants
(2.1 friends) and mainline Protestants (1.8 friends). Nonreligious, Catholic, and Jewish teens fall below the national average. Even so, on average, one out of two nonreligious teens has one of their five best friends who is involved in a religious youth group. U.S. teenagers are slightly more likely to have friends with whom they talk about religious beliefs and experiences (1.8 out of five best friends). The same groups come out as comparatively more and less likely to have best friends with whom they talk about religion: Mormons and conservative and mainline Protestants have more, and nonreligious, Jewish, and Catholic teens have fewer. Finally, U.S. teens of all types have about the same number among their best friends who they report are bad moral influences on them, about 0.3 of five best friends, with deviations from the national average ranging no more than 0.1 in either direction. From one perspective, U.S. teenagers of all religious and nonreligious kinds appear unwilling or unable to tolerate more than an average of about one out of 17 friends (= 0.3/5) who are a bad moral influence on them. Read from another perspective, as we will see in chapter 4, U.S. teens generally do not believe that anything or anybody directly influences them, but that they are selfdirected; thus, they may be significantly underestimating negative moral peer influences in this survey question. In general, however, we see in table 18 that, almost by mathematical inevitabilities, U.S. teens have significant relational network ties that link them to religious resources and likely help to reinforce their religious beliefs and commitments, such as they are. Again, religion in the lives of teenagers appears to be not simply restricted to time spent in religious congregations, but also flows in various ways and to different degrees into and through teens' relational networks.
What about religion at school? Is religious faith openly expressed by teenagers at school? What is the atmosphere in schools for religious teens? According to table 19, the great majority of religious U.S. teens openly express their faith at school in quite limited ways; 65 percent do so only some or a
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
Table 19. Experiences of School-attending U.S. Adolescents among Peers and at School, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) UES:
Religious Tradition CEa Vibe pie RO eee lo oINIS Openly expresses faith at school (religious teens)
A lot |p (2S a it tate
2-23.
Some S6n ade 32241030 24 a5 A little DO MD era ot 2Sre30) Mia o338R ii None 23 tym lS) 24420 BS a r4/9 GLO ud om Other students at school generally look down
TSetbe2Oted Os AT ieliSs
eels lS on teens who are openly religious Feel pressured or made fun of because of their religious beliefs and practices (religious teens)
A lot
— Some i
Ae ae ee 0 — A little AU oe Beye [|
— None 78:
"842
86.
44-86.
- = Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers. little. Only 12 percent of religious teens report expressing their faith a lot at school; 23 percent do not express their faith at school at all. Mormon teens
(23 percent) are most likely to express their faith a lot at school, followed by conservative and black Protestant teens (15 percent each). On the other hand, nearly half of Jewish teens and about one-third of Catholic teens never express their faith openly at school. These numbers suggest that for the vast majority of U.S. teens expressions of religious faith at school are kept to a minimum. Only fairly small minorities from each religious group—Mormons being an exception—express their religious faith at school a lot.
According to NSYR teen respondents, however, this is not because schools are perceived by teens to be especially hostile places to students who are openly religious. On average, fewer than one in five U.S. teens reports that other students at school generally look down on teens who are openly religious, although more Jewish teens (34 percent) and fewer Mormon and nonreligious teens (13 percent each) report perceptions of such antireligious condescension among students at school. Furthermore, only a minority of religious teens from all traditions report that they themselves have been pressured or made fun of because of their religious beliefs and practices; overall,
2 percent report a lot and 7 percent some pressure. Religious minority teens, Jewish and Mormon, however, do report noticeably higher levels of pressure and teasing than do religious majority (Christian) teens, perhaps for such behaviors as wearing yarmulkes, keeping Kosher, and observing Sabbath.
Still, the great majority of religious teens of all groups report only a little or no pressure or teasing. The generally limited expression of faith by teens at school observed above, therefore, likely has other causes than fear of persecution.
SOUL SEARCHING
Finally, we examine in this section the extent and nature of the relational ties that U.S. teenagers attending religious services may have with adults other than their family members in their religious congregations. What kind of relational links do religious service—attending teenagers have with fellowbelieving, nonfamilial adults? According to table 20, large majorities of teens from all religious traditions report having nonfamily adults in their religious congregations whom they enjoy talking to and who give them lots of encouragement. Jewish teens report the highest percentage (92 percent) and Catholic teens the lowest (68 percent). Religious American teens thus do not appear to be entirely relationally isolated from other adults in their congregations. Moreover, even more teenagers would like to have significant relationships with adults in their congregations. The majority of teens who do not have such enjoyable and encouraging adult ties in their congregations— between 56 percent of those Catholic and 100 percent of those Jewish
Table 20. Relationships with Adults in Religious Congregations of Religious Service— attending U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
WES Religious Tradition Attendmp CR eMP BP Re 27) LDS Teens have adults in congregation, other than
1D i 847578 =685.1792
family members, whom they enjoy talking with and who give lots of encouragement (Of all U.S. teens: 53 percent) Teens would like to have adults in congregation
7 Se S6,2
MOO FEI 7.
whom teen enjoys talking to (asked only of teens without adult in congregation to talk to)
Most adults in congregation for getting to know Very easy to talk with
snes ted aah Sinead Bl gir Asie i) Somewhat easy to talk with
545-1390 "43
36439 Neither Uf
Somewhat hard to talk with
SeeehOl Gate wih ae
Very hard to talk with
SA ed, ~
Percentage of teens who have adults in life to
65'S 65,68 j 53's) 28s)
turn to for support, advice, and help who are part of teen's religious congregation or youth group (Of all U.S. teens: 54 percent) Number of adults in a religious congregation or religious youth group attending teens can turn to for support, advice, and help (not including parents)
85.
35:
(32 ap oy 1-2 7.
195s BOG
2a 3-4
fe cdt: aS tt Met 5-6
E2510"
£140) @ = SF 7-9
SY SATIQUAy 2S Cis 10+
JTL sah
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~.
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
teens!3—say that they wish they did. Nevertheless, the vast majority of religious teenagers from all of the traditions compared also report that most adults in their religious congregations are either somewhat or very easy to talk with and get to know. Only between 6 percent (of Mormons) and 16 percent (of Catholics) report that most adults in their congregations are somewhat or very hard to talk with and get to know.
Approached from another angle, we might ask what percentage of U.S. teenagers have adults in their lives, other than their parents, whom they can turn to when they need support, advice, or help and who are part of their religious congregations or other religious groups in which they are involved.
According to NSYR data, 54 percent of all U.S. teens and 61 percent of U.S. teens who attend religious services enjoy those kinds of supportive relationships. This is noticeably higher for Mormon and lower for Jewish and Catholic youth. Yet overall, we can conclude that the majority of religious U.S. teens have nonparental adult relationships with fellow religious congregants whom they can rely on for help in life. And, according to the findings at the bottom of table 20, the majority of U.S. teens attending religious services actually have at least one potentially helpful adult in their lives, and 34 percent have three or more. Religious organizations thus appear to help foster cross-generational relational ties for large numbers of U.S. teenagers, ties we would expect to help legitimize and reinforce the religious faith and practices of those teens.
TEENS' EVALUATIONS OF RELIGIOUS CONGREGATIONS
To complete this chapter's number-filled, big-picture, descriptive overview of the religious and spiritual lives of U.S. teenagers, we consider evidence concerning teens' evaluations, according to a variety of standards, of the appeal and effectiveness of their own religious congregations. Do teens think well of their churches, synagogues, mosques, and temples? Are they happy with their experiences with them? Table 21 begins this consideration with data on various features of their congregations' general environments. There we see that the majority of all service-attending teens say that their congregation usually makes them think about important things, although Jewish teens appear more split on this question than the other teens. Furthermore, relatively few teens complain that their congregation is usually boring. The most typical response is that congregations are sometimes boring, although our in-depth interviews with teens clearly suggested that they are realistic—probably well trained by school—in expecting a certain amount of life to be boring and so are not particularly put off by religious services being boring sometimes. Table 21 also shows that the vast majority of teens find their religious congregation to be a warm and welcoming place for youth. Only small minorities rarely or never find their congregation to be warm and welcoming. If such reports tell us anything at all, then, they suggest that most U.S. teens who attend religious services feel relatively positive about the general environment of their congregation. This observation calls into question popular stereotypes assuming
SOUL SEARCHING
Table 21. Evaluations of Own Religious Congregation's Environment by Religious Service—attending U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
Usie ee Religious Tradition Attending.
CR MP be Ret sees Makes teen think about important things Usually
"58",
2a Oo, eo Sometimes
QS N33"
E2re BS &) ih Rarely i f
Never
4 oe 12
Is boring to teen Usually ite) LO spec iG ert er 20 aS Olen ehick Sometimes
35.
40)
Al Aa
Rarely
26°
1S 2h a oO.
Never
DO AS TSS
Aes Tow od Is a warm and welcoming place for teen Usually
SO"
8257-74662 18S E85.
Sometimes We ton salt yee2 1 2G 427110 Rarely
Never
ore
Regular opportunities exist to get involved in
285. eG S83t
services, such as reading or praying aloud Teenagers in congregation who are hypocrites
All
De te ~ Most
Some
229) SBS A few
Sly pi 24 30ee3t ~ Si None
34° "29.
233) 8630) sso
Don't know
~ ~ Evaluation of youth group (asked of youth group-attenders only) Likes it very much
63.
F502 oS
Ole eS Likes it somewhat
2D. AE ES4 OF 39
NAS ts AON Rees Doesn't feel either way
Srtaie
Dislikes it somewhat
{dal
s45ns a Dislikes it very much
~ ART eee = Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~; evaluation of youth group is only by respondents involved in a youth group. and some published accounts claiming that many or most religious U.S. teens think their congregation is irrelevant, tedious, cold, and off-putting. Quite the contrary, it appears.
Table 21 also shows that the large majority of U.S. teens attending religious services belong to congregations in which there are regular opportunities for youth to get actively involved in the services, such as by reading scripture or praying out loud—but not including participation in a bar or bat mitzvah. The lowest among all groups are teens in Catholic churches, but even they report opportunities for participation at 76 percent. What about
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
attending teens' assessments of the integrity of other teens in their congregations? Do they see much hypocrisy among their attending peers that might make them feel put off by their congregations? Apparently not. Only a small minority, 10 percent for the whole, say that most or all other teens in their congregation are hypocrites; more than three times that number say none of the teens are hypocrites. There appears little basis, then, for many attending teenagers to become alienated from their congregation by the perception of widespread hypocrisy among other religious youth. Finally, the NSYR asked teens who participate in a religious youth group how much they like or dislike it. Their responses show that the vast majority do like their youth groups.
On average, only 5 percent of teens do not like them. Literally all sampled Jewish teens involved in youth groups like them, and, among the rest, only mainline Protestant teens stand out (at 12 percent) as disliking their youth groups either somewhat or very much. Of course, teens who did not like their youth groups probably have mostly dropped out, accounting, in part, for the 31 percent of U.S. teens in table 14 who once had been involved in a religious youth group but currently are not. Most youth unhappy with youth groups likely vote with their feet. And the somewhat higher percentage of mainline
Protestant teens who dislike their youth groups (12 percent) may simply reflect a greater number of mainline parents who require their teens to attend youth groups, and not less appealing youth group programs per se. In any event, it does not appear to be the case that religious youth groups are peppered with teens who are unhappy with them. Most who are involved seem to like their youth groups very much.
How do teens who attend religious services evaluate the adults in their congregations? A certain conventional wisdom expects that teenagers view church adults as clueless, square, phony, or remote—something like a cross between the old Saturday Night Live church lady and Sinclair Lewis's Elmer
Gantry. Table 22 suggests a rather different picture, however. U.S. teens who attend religious services are, for example, even less likely to view adults in their congregation as hypocrites than they are to view other teens as hypocrites. Overall, seven out of ten say that only a few or none of the adults in their congregation are hypocrites; only handfuls in each tradition say that all or most adults are hypocrites. Not many attending teens, then, seem suspicious of the integrity of the adults in their congregation. Furthermore, when asked specifically about their experiences in talking with a minister at their congregation about a personal question or problem, almost none of the 19 percent of teens who had done so reported that this had been a bad or even ambiguous experience; on the contrary, nearly all reported it as a good experience. To be clear, most service-attending teens have not approached a minister in their congregation with a personal question or problem; still, perhaps no fewer teens than adults have done so and, considering the potential vulnerability involved in such a personal talk with a local religious leader, perhaps 19 percent is not too surprising. In any case, there is no evidence that teens who do have such personal talks with adult ministers find them to be unsatisfying or alienating. Again, when asked, teens attending religious
SOUL SEARCHING
Table 22. Evaluations of Adults in and Support of Religious Congregations by U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17, and Parents Attending Religious
Congregations (Percentages) Religious Tradition Uss; of Teen and Parent Attending CP MP BP RC J _ LDS Adults in congregation who are hypocrites
(teen report) All
~ ~ Most
5) He
Some pil 1S 19), 29°
A few
Bien 36, — 29 so= Oo S7.
None
Bl:
34-937
Don't know/refused
~ ~ Experience talking with adult youth minister or religious youth leader about a personal question or problem (teen report) Good
B00
16. 6 5 eae Mixed, good and bad ~
= = ee z, a Bad ~
LE IO:
EE Have not talked with a youth minister
AGS E84 Sl FASS
Perceived priority of congregational ministry to teens (parent report) A very important priority
LS dw Gm wy SOWy 47.
eG A fairly important priority
S17
A somewhat important priority
genni!
Qapgo see ils
A low priority
Gs = Is not a priority at all
~ ae oe
Don't know/refused
~ Supportiveness and helpfulness of church for parent in trying to raise teen (parent report)
Extremely supportive and helpful 22, 26.2.
14).
a3 Sooo Very supportive and helpful 38.
Es Sac 1 a PIE eed Ng 25) Somewhat supportive and helpful
20-24 19"
A little supportive and helpful
fae ed ss SUP ae
Not supportive and helpful
72210 5.
Don't know/refused
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding; cells of <1 are reported as ~; parent report variables rely on parent, not teen, religious tradition classification. services generally give high evaluation marks to the adults, both laity and ministers, in their congregations.
The NSYR also asked religious service—attending parents of teens to evaluate their congregation both for the priority their congregation places on ministering to teens and for their congregation's helpfulness to them as parents raising teens. Though not representing the viewpoint of youth, parents' answers to these questions, shown in the bottom half of table 22, do contribute to our larger understanding of the role of religious congregations in the lives of U.S. teenagers. There we find that the majority of most groups
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
of parents see ministry to teens as a very important priority in their congregation, Jewish and Catholic parents being the exceptions at 32 and 47 percent, respectively. Particularly in Mormon and conservative and black Protestant churches, ministry to youth is quite an important priority, according to attending parents. Again, with the exception of Jewish parents, few attending parents report that ministry to teens is a low or nonexistent priority, probably in part because many parents with teens actively seek out or gravitate toward congregations that prioritize ministry to teens. The numbers on the supportiveness and helpfulness of congregations to parents in raising teens are more mixed: 18 percent report that their congregation is only a little or not at all supportive and helpful; nearly one-quarter say their congregation is somewhat helpful; and more than half say their congregation is very or extremely helpful. More Mormon and black and conservative Protestant parents report their congregation as helpful, compared to the average. Jewish parents in particular tend to say their congregation is not particularly helpful to parents raising teens. Still, on balance, attending parents of U.S. teenagers give quite positive evaluations of their congregations as places in which to raise teenagers in their religious faiths.
Finally, we examine teens' evaluations of their congregations' pastoral and teaching effectiveness. The survey question asked: Do teenagers think that their own religious congregation is a good or not good place for them to go
"to talk about serious issues like family problems, alcohol, or troubles at school?" According to the data presented in table 23, most attending teens
(70 percent) rate their congregation as a very good or fairly good place to talk about such serious issues. Relatively few teens panned their congregation as a context in which to address serious issues. Only among Jewish teens was there a substantial minority giving their congregation bad marks on this question. The NSYR also asked specifically what kind of job their congregation has done in helping them better understand their own sexuality and sexual morality. Fifteen percent of all attending teens said their congregation has done nothing to help them understand sex; Jewish and mainline Protestant teens reported this well above the average for all attending teens, at 41 and 21 percent, respectively. Otherwise, the majority of attending teens gave their congregation quite high ratings on this question. Eighty-four percent of Mormon teens report that their congregation has done a fairly good or excellent job in helping them understand sex, and 67 percent of conservative Protestant, 60 percent of black Protestant, and 53 percent of mainline Protestant teens report the same. Catholic teens find their congregation somewhat more lacking on this issue. Still, the overall marks are fairly positive.
Likewise, attending teenagers rate their religious congregation with high marks for teaching them what they want to know about their faith. Overall, one out of five attending teens has no interest in learning more about their own religion; presumably, most of these are not teens who know so much that they do not need to know any more, but simply do not care to know much in the first place. Catholic and Jewish teens tend to score relatively high on lack of interest; for these uninterested teens, this question is irrelevant.
SOUL SEARCHING
Table 23. Evaluation of Religious Congregation's Teaching Effectiveness by Religious Service—attending U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
US.
Religious Tradition Attending CP MP BP RC J _ LDS How good congregation is for talking about serious issues, problems, and troubles A very good place
52°38 7°48
40> °65 A fairly good place
26m S22 I Tee? aad An okay place
16621 ms2oy a2 Sint dl Se wld Not a good place
9S 75 a A bad place
we le Oe Don't know/refused
ee Job congregation has done helping better understand own sexuality and sexual morality An excellent job
SS 229352 T8PE21
A fairly good job
~Slvve2sen3ie A658 An okay job
iD a Oe ee Grau
Not a good job
tie ae 2h Oma
Has done nothing for understanding sexuality
eS Don't know/refuse j 20a 2h See aes ene) Job congregation has done helping teach what teen wants to learn about own religion An excellent job QT SI 24:435.517
26747 A fairly good job ee yaN ae We es, An okay job
18) 18)
Not a good job
(Tire OReSS ge? elegy. c A bad job
poe (UI LEE Sey Teen not interested in learning about own religion
T4821 Sie ZIEDO B19 Kind of congregation teen anticipates attending when 25 years old Kind of congregation teen goes to now U7, 8098179 i 74 73,051
A different kind of congregation
I) ae 2S
Sake, Will not attend anywhere i
a NOS 30) mal Don't know/refused
cS eae ees ead ie AS Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding; cells of <1 are reported as ~.
But for those teens who do have some interest in learning about their faith, the majority report that their congregation does a fairly good or excellent job at teaching them what they want to learn. A significant minority of all but Mormon teens give the lukewarm answer that their congregation does only an "okay job." Very few attending teens give their congregation more critical ratings than that. Most teens who care about learning more about their own religious faith, then, tend to view their congregation as doing an adequate if not quite a good job in teaching.
Finally, the NSYR asked attending teenagers what kind of religious congregation, if any, they think they will attend when they are 25 years old. We interpret their answers as indirect evaluations of their current religious con-
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
gregation, insofar as dissatisfied customers will presumably stop returning when the choice is fully theirs. In fact, 77 percent of all attending teens said that they expect at age 25 to attend the same kind of congregation they attend now; 14 percent said they anticipate attending a different kind of congregation; only 7 percent said they do not think they will be attending anywhere at all, which closely fits with the 9 percent of currently attending teens who said they would never attend if the choice were entirely up to them whether and how much to attend religious services. Mormon and conservative and mainline Protestant teens were the most likely to say they expect to attend the same kind of church they currently attend, at 83, 80, and 79 percent, respectively. Yet Mormon teens were also relatively more likely to say they expect not to attend services at all (10 percent) or to refuse to answer or say that they did not know the answer (5 percent). Jewish teens were the most likely by far to say they did not expect to be attending religious services at age 25 (30 percent) and to refuse to answer or say "don't know" (11 percent).
Nevertheless, overall, attending U.S. teens did not offer a clearly negative judgment on their religious congregations by suggesting in response to this question that they look forward to doing something very different or to entirely dropping out of religious attendance when they are older. For most traditions, the vast majority expect to keep attending religious services that are similar to those they attend at present.
CONCLUSION
Surveys cannot tell us everything or perhaps even the most important and interesting things there are to know about people and their lives. Surveys do have real limits in the insights they can render about the social world and personal experiences, perhaps especially about the lives of adolescents and perhaps especially about faith and spiritual practices. All of this is important to bear in mind. Nevertheless, survey research findings can provide an important, general starting point for further understanding of what we want to know about people's lives. We began this chapter by suggesting that, although survey data may oversimplify the complexity of the real social world, they can also help to draw a kind of map that provides an overarching sense of our social world, where we stand within it, and what it looks like beyond our immediate field of vision. We believe the NSYR findings presented in this chapter have done precisely this. Having ploughed through and begun to digest the multitude of numbers in this chapter, we can now proceed forward with a big picture in our minds of the rough proportions and contours describing the religious and spiritual lives of U.S. teenagers. In the following chapters, with other data, we confirm or question some of what we learned in this chapter. We also add complexity and specify our findings. In some cases, we reinterpret the meaning of some of the numbers reviewed here. By chapters 4 and 5 we will come to see many of these numbers in a considerably more critical light. But this chapter's survey findings provide an important,
SOUL SEARCHING
sound, and fairly comprehensive starting point for further investigations in following chapters. th All of the findings in the 23 tables presented above and their implications for various academic scholars, faith communities, and secular organizations are too numerous to highlight and summarize in this conclusion. Readers will have to draw from this chapter what is most relevant for them and their communities. But an attempt to briefly summarize some of this chapter's major observations and conclusions seems warranted, as incomplete or tentative as they may be. We believe these observations include the following:
5 The vast majority of U.S. teenagers identify themselves as Christian, either among the broad array of American Protestant denominations or as Catholic
(tables 1 and 2). Significant minorities of other U.S. adolescents are nonreligious, Mormon, and Jewish. The percentage of other minority faiths that often draw a great deal of public attention—paganism, Wicca, Buddhism,
Muslim, and so on—remains at the start of the twenty-first century very small. Few U.S. teens appear to be dabbling with, much less switching to, such alternative faiths.
5 The majority of U.S. teenagers tend to be quite like their parents when it comes to religion. They tend to share similar beliefs (table 4), tend to be situated in the same general religious traditions (table 5), and tend to attend religious services with one or both of their parents (table 6).
5 A substantial minority of U.S. teenagers regularly practice religious faith.
Four out of ten say they attend religious services weekly or more often (table 6), pray daily or more often (table 11), and are currently involved in a religious youth group (table 14). Between one-quarter and one-half report engaging in a broad variety of other religious practices in the previous year
(table 11). This means, of course, that the majority of U.S. teenagers practice religious faith only sporadically or not at all.
6 About half of U.S. teenagers report in their survey answers strong subjective importance and experiences of religious faith in their own lives, measured as importance of faith, closeness to God, commitment of life to God, experience of powerful worship, answer to prayer, lack of religious doubts, and receiving guidance from God (tables 7 and 10). This means that the other half of U.S. teenagers express weak or no subjective attachment to religion and have fewer or no religious experiences. (More critical chapters ahead also examine in greater depth the actual substantive character of the religious faith and view of God that most U.S. teens profess to hold.) es The vast majority of U.S. teenagers profess to be theists and to believe in divine judgment (table 8). Between four and six out of ten U.S. teens also say they believe in angels, demons, divine miracles, and life after death, though many fewer believe in reincarnation, astrology, communicating with the dead,
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
and fortune-telling (table 9). In these ways, many U.S. teenagers appear quite conventional in following many of the traditional beliefs of the Jewish, Christian, and Mormon heritages. At the same time, significant proportions of other teens express uncertainty about these beliefs. Furthermore, when probed about their more precise images of God, about one-third of teens do not believe that God is personal and involved in the lives of people today
(table 8). Broadly speaking, then, as far as survey answers can tell, most U.S. teens appear to embrace rather conventional, apparently traditional beliefs about religion and the supernatural; still, we have some reason to critically probe further into the more specific content and texture of teens' beliefs, to see just how traditional they may be after all.
'#5 Religious youth groups seem to be an important part of the religious and spiritual experiences of a substantial minority of U.S. adolescents (table 14).
Nearly four in ten U.S. teens are involved in a religious youth group and have been for multiple years. About seven in ten have been involved in a religious youth group at some time in their lives. Most of those currently involved belong to youth groups sponsored by their own religious congregation. As to frequency of involvement, one-quarter of all U.S. teens report attending religious youth group weekly or more often; more than one in three youth group—attending teens sees him or herself functioning in a leadership role in their youth group. Viewed from the other direction, however, all of this also means that the majority of U.S. teenagers are not involved in a religious youth group, and nearly half of U.S. teens who at one time did participate in a religious youth group no longer do so.
5 Large numbers of U.S. teenagers have been or are currently involved in a variety of other organized religious activities (table 15). About half attend
Sunday school monthly or more often and have participated in at least one religious youth retreat, conference, rally, or congress. Nearly four in ten U.S. teens have attended a religious summer camp as a camper, and nearly three in ten have participated in a religious missions team or service project. Of course, this also means that substantial majorities of U.S. teenagers have never been involved in such religious camps, conferences, retreats, and projects.
5 Religious congregations appear to be important sites for U.S. teenagers to make significant contact with adults other than family members. Most attending U.S. teens have adults in their congregation whom they enjoy talking to and who encourage them, and the majority who do not have such adults wish that they did. Most also report that adults in their congregation are rather easy to talk to and get to know and that they believe they can turn to these adults for support, advice, and help in life (table 20).
6 Religion and spirituality for the majority of U.S. teenagers find some expression in the life of their families. Many U.S. families with teenagers appear
SOUL SEARCHING
to talk together about God, the scriptures, prayer, or other matters of faith.
More than half pray to give thanks at mealtimes, and four in ten U.S. teens say they have prayed with one or both of their parents other than at mealtimes in the previous year. Most parents normally exert significant influence in forming the religious and spiritual lives of their adolescent children (table
1h 5 When it comes to U.S. teenagers' close friendships and school experiences, however, religion seems somewhat more remote than in their families and religious congregations. On average, half of their closest friends do not share their religious beliefs, and the majority of their closest friends are not involved in any of their own religious groups. U.S. teens are more likely than not to have close friends with whom they never talk about religious matters (table
18). Furthermore, although most U.S. teenagers report that schools are not hostile to teens who are seriously religious, only about one in ten teens expresses their religious faith at school a lot (table 19). Thus, the visibility and perhaps significance of religious faith and practice for U.S. teens seem to drop off markedly in spheres outside of religious congregation and family.
5 Most U.S. teenagers seem to hold rather positive general attitudes about religion and their own congregation. More than six in ten say they would attend religious services regularly (two to three times a month or more often) if it were entirely up to them (table 6). Of religious service—attending U.S. teenagers, most report that their religious congregation is relationally warm and intellectually stimulating, provides opportunities for youth to get involved in services, offers youth groups which they like very much, and provides a good context for learning about faith and talking about serious life issues (tables 21 and 23). Nearly eight in ten attending U.S. teens say that they expect to attend the same congregation they are currently involved with when they are 25 years old (table 23). Very few attending teens say that many teens or adults in their congregation are hypocrites, and almost none report having had bad experiences interacting with their clergy or youth leaders
(table 22). It is difficult to tease out from these survey statistics exactly how positively enthusiastic and committed U.S. teenagers are about and to their religious congregations, and what exactly that means and reflects. But at the very least we can observe that relatively few teens appear to be actively negative about or hostile toward their religious congregations.
'es Comparisons of the many religion measures across the religious traditions examined in this chapter reveal a noticeable pattern of religiosity, ranging from Mormons at the high end, to conservative and black Protestants, further down to mainline Protestant and Catholic teens, and then to Jewish and nonreligious teens on the lower end. This book does not seek to explain this larger pattern; we simply note it here. Explanations, however, would likely appeal to strictness or subcultural identity theories to help make sense of these across-tradition differences.'4
MAPPING THE BIG PICTURE
aA This is a good start. But we have to do much more digging to fill in details and to explore the more complex meanings of and feelings about such religious and spiritual matters among U.S. teenagers. By chapters 4 and 5 we will have significantly qualified the initial view developed here. Before diving headlong into interpreting the data and findings from our 267 personal interviews with teenagers in 45 states around the country, however, the next chapter focuses on better understanding three specific religious groups of U.S. teens: the few "spiritual but not religious" teens who are often thought of as "spiritual seekers," teens who appear entirely disengaged from American religion, and teens who are highly devoted religiously. Better comprehending these three types of teenagers will provide important depth to the picture that this chapter begins to sketch.
