Spiritual Seekers, the Disengaged, and
Spiritual Seekers, the Disengaged, and Religiously Devoted Teens HE PREVIOUS CHAPTER used NSYR survey data to provide an overview of the religious and spiritual lives of American adolescents. Its approach was to examine answers to survey questions by U.S. teenagers age 13 to 17 and by the teens as grouped into six religious traditions and one nonreligious category. This chapter extends that investigation by focusing on three different populations of American teens, seeking to understand more clearly their composition and defining features. First, we explore the extent and characteristics of adolescent "religious seekers" and teens who claim to be "spiritual but not religious," approaches to faith often said to be popular and widespread among American youth. Next, we examine American teenagers who identify themselves as nonreligious and who never attend religious services. Finally, we analyze American teens who are religiously highly active and devoted and attempt to identify the features that define them as a particular group of youth. All three are categories of teens that many religion observers are interested in better understanding. Furthermore, examining these types of teens in greater depth provides helpful windows into some of the key features defining and shaping the religious and spiritual lives of U.S. teenagers broadly. Finally, the findings of this chapter help to put some of the previous chapter's survey findings into clearer perspective.
A GENERATION OF TEENAGE SPIRITUAL SEEKERS?
Scholars and journalists have been writing prolifically about a purportedly widespread and growing contemporary phenomenon of "spiritual seeking"
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
by people who think of themselves as "spiritual but not religious." Seekers are described as people who have an interest in spiritual matters but who are not devoted to one particular historical faith or denomination and in fact may be hostile to traditional or organized religion per se. Such spiritual seekers are reported to be exploring the world's storehouse of faiths and spiritualities for a variety of meaning systems and practices with which to experiment in order to find some that work for them, that meet their needs. They are dispositionally open to a multiplicity of truths, willing eclectically and selectively to mix and match traditionally distinct religious beliefs and practices, and suspicious of commitment to a single religious congregation. They tend to eschew religious proselytizing as paternalistic and coercive. And they operate, whether self-consciously or not, as religious and spiritual consumers by defining themselves as individual seekers, the authoritative judges of truth and relevance in faith according to how things subjectively feel to them. Such consuming seekers are not religiously rooted or settled but are spiritual nomads on a perpetual quest for greater insight and more authentic and fulfilling experiences.!
Baby boomers, who grew up through a series of cultural revolutions and liberations from traditional American ways of life, are often said to be the original and quintessential spiritual seekers in America.* They pioneered and popularized contemporary spiritual seeking in the form of Zen meditation centers, evangelical megachurches, and more. Recently, however, some observers have suggested that the phenomenon of spiritual seeking is moving down the generational food chain and being adopted increasingly by younger
Americans, including those currently in college and even teenagers.' If this is the case, then it signals a potentially even more profound transformation of American religious culture than perhaps even some prior observers of spiritual seeking have realized. The question then is, Is this really so?
Very little reliable empirical research on the extent and characteristics of spiritual seeking among American adolescents has been conducted. Much of what informs popular stereotypes on the matter is anecdotal and impressionistic. In what follows, by contrast, we examine NSYR survey and interview data on the issue of spiritual seeking among American teenagers to provide a reliable, nationally representative picture. By so doing, we may learn not only about adolescent religion and spirituality specifically, but also about religious cultural change in the United States more broadly.
Seeker Attitudes We begin by examining a set of American teenagers' beliefs and attitudes that together represent key indicators of possible resonance with spiritual seeking—as opposed to particularistic religious faith set in historical religious traditions.t Do American teens reflect the attitudinal features of typical spiritual seekers? The findings of table 24 offer some evidence of this. Consider, for example, teens' beliefs about religion and truth. Fewer than one-third of teens (29 percent) report that they believe that only one religion is true. The majority of teens (60 percent) say they believe that many religions may be
SOUL SEARCHING
Table 24. Religious Particularity and Individualism among U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
SUAS TARA EERE SES SANE
ee ee US.
Religious Tradition CP MP BP ORG.
| UD S enix Beliefs about religion's truth Only one religion is true DOMPAG 26. molt?
BOW,
Many religions may be true 60M
N67
CTL 2* 23962 There is very little truth in any religion 9.» 4y peSthe +h e9orlasyee Be Don't know/refused Ding hi Dies seid ipee 2 psi gee apnea)
Beliefs about religious particularity People should practice only one faith AG 59.
385.5% 40. 2159 a2) It is okay to practice religions besides own Sik.
36.
(59 AO 058) Orme Ormmny Don't know/refused
Yee: eal Pl okie hei.
19) )
Beliefs about religious conversion attempts Okay for religious people to try to convert others
Everyone should leave everyone else alone ABD 75S DEAD SSS 27 SSG Don't know/refused 3a a) Pea ears Sere
Okay to pick and choose religious beliefs without having to accept teachings of faith as a whole
Agree
2753.1.
347°
G62) Disagree $2, 6h
(64 45)
(69s Don't know/refused
For believers to be truly religious and spiritual, they need to be involved in a religious congregation
Agree B2i 1 2S 274A S32)
GO Disagree
Don't know/refused
a ae
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding; cells of <1 are reported as ~. true. Only 9 percent say there is very little truth in any religion. What is clear is that most American teens believe that religion or religions possess and offer reliable truth claims. But most American teens appear to take a fairly inclusive and pluralistic position about the truth that different religions claim to possess. A substantial minority of teens do take a more exclusive or particularistic approach to truth in religion, but 29 percent is still a clear minority. To be sure, affirming that "many religions may be true" can indicate a broad range of ideas on the matter. Some of the 60 percent of teens choosing this survey answer may believe something like, "All religions are equally true,"
"All religions share the same vision of truth underneath," or "Different religions grasp different parts of a larger truth." These respondents fall on the more inclusive or religiously relativistic side of this answer. Others among this 60 percent may think, essentially, "I don't really know, but 'One religion is true' sounds awfully hard-line, so I'll say many may be true." This is more of a safe default answer than a positive commitment to pluralism. And yet others among the 60 percent affirming this response may be thinking something more like, "My religion is the one true religion, but other religions can
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
7h) reflect fragments of my true religion in their own religious teachings, and in that sense many religions may be 'true.' " This response falls closer to the exclusive side on the pluralistic spectrum. Nevertheless, whatever the answer
"many religions may be true" exactly represents among our teens, it remains clear that those respondents did not choose the sharper, more particular answer "Only one religion is true." American teenagers, then, as a group seem to lean toward an open and inclusive religious pluralism on the matter of religions' truth claims.
Regardless of their views of religion and truth, what do American teens think about the appropriateness of people actually practicing one versus more than one religious faith? On this question teens are more evenly split. About half (51 percent) say they think it is okay for people of one religious faith to also practice other faiths, that is, to practice multiple faiths simultaneously.
However, nearly another half say that people should practice only one faith.
Once again, it is only a large minority of American teens who advocate the exclusive practicing of particular faiths. A slightly larger number than those are okay with people practicing more than one faith. This may or may not indicate a positive interest in spiritual seeking, but in any case, we do see here that at least half of American teens hold an attitude about religious exclusivity that potentially lends itself to the seeker orientation.
Table 24 also examines teenagers' views about the legitimacy of religious believers attempting to convert others to their faith, which seekers are typically thought to find disagreeable. According to the seeker viewpoint, each individual must follow his or her own quest in spirituality, and not have to be confronted and perhaps pressured by others to adopt their faith. According to the findings in table 24, the slight majority of American teens, 54 percent, disagree with that position; they believe it is okay for people to try to convert others. A large minority of teens, by comparison, 43 percent, believe that when it comes to proselytizing, everyone should just leave everyone else alone. Thus, although the vast majority of teens have not adopted a "right not to be proselytized" attitude, a very large portion of teens, nearly half, do jean toward a live-and-let-live approach to faith in which believers should not try to convert others to their faith. Again, this does not itself make these teens spiritual seekers, but the attitude lends itself to that approach.
Another aspect of the spiritual seeker mentality is thought to be a readiness to selectively choose which beliefs from a religious tradition one wants to believe and which beliefs one may disregard. In contrast to more historically traditional notions of religious faith—which tend to view beliefs as hanging together in larger, coherent, interdependent systems of authoritative thought and commitment that should be embraced by faith as wholes—spiritual seekers are more prepared to customize and personally design their own faith systems from bits of belief pulled out of those larger systems. Put another way, spiritual seekers do not hesitate to discount and ignore teachings of a religious tradition that do not seem right to them. They thus act as their own spiritual authorities, adjudicating religious beliefs based primarily on their personal experiences, rather than as followers being formed by the
SOUL SEARCHING
teachings and directives of larger, coherent, authoritative faith traditions. So, where do American teenagers come down on this question? They are nearly split down the middle: 52 percent say that people should not pick and choose their religious beliefs but should accept the teachings of their faith as a whole;
46 percent believe the opposite, that it is okay to pick and choose, that one does not have to accept all the teachings of a faith. Thus, neither side claims a clear majority.
Finally, the NSYR asked teens whether religious believers need to be involved in a religious congregation to be truly religious and spiritual, as opposed to being freelance believers unattached to any specific congregation of adherents. Here the majority of American teens swings back to the more individualistic position: two-thirds say believers do not need to be involved in congregations to be religious and spiritual; only one-third say that they do. Again, the difference is not enormous but clearly leans toward an attitude amenable to that of the spiritual seeker. None of this establishes that any of these teens are actually themselves spiritual seekers, but if an opportunity and advocate for seeking did come along, a large proportion of them do appear to have the attitudinal predilection compatible with seeking. At the very least, theoretically up to half of American teenagers appear to be a potential market for a seeking spirituality.
What about differences between religious traditions? Are some types of religious teens more disposed to religious seeking attitudes than others? The evidence in table 24 shows that some clearly are. Following the general pattern of answers across religious traditions in the previous chapter, table 24 suggests that Mormon teens tend to hold the most particularistic and exclusive views of religion and tend to be the least individualistic about faith and belief. They are typically followed by conservative Protestants, who are also generally less individualistic and more exclusive about faith than most other comparison groups. Black Protestant teens then follow as the next most particularistic and least individualistic religious group, typically being distinctly different from the average American teen in these regards. Mainline Protestant answers tend to come in fairly close to the national average, reflecting a middle position. Catholic youth move relatively further toward pluralistic and individualistic approaches to faith. Nonreligious teens are in their attitudes and beliefs relatively very individualistic and inclusive when it comes to religion and faith, but not more so than Jewish teens, who on most counts are the most individualistic and inclusive about faith and belief of all of the groups compared. The vast majority of Jewish teenagers in the NSYR sample believe that many religions may be true, that it'is okay to practice more than one faith, that people should not try to convert others, that people can pick and choose their religious beliefs, and that it is not necessary for a truly religious and spiritual person to be involved in a religious congregation. The propensity toward spiritual seeker attitudes, then, is not evenly distributed across all American teens: some religious groups of teens are much friendlier to seeker attitudes than others.
Some of the religious traditions considered here may, in light of their own
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
vig commitments, find cause for concern in table 24. Consider conservative Protestants, for example. About half of their teens say that many religions may be true; more than one-third say it is okay to practice multiple religions; more than one-quarter believe people should not try to evangelize others; more than one-third say it is okay to pick and choose one's religious beliefs and not accept the teachings of one's faith as a whole; and nearly two-thirds say a person can be truly religious and spiritual without being involved in a church. It appears that these conservative Protestant youth have not been very successfully inducted into their tradition's distinctive commitment to Christian particularity, evangelism, the need to accept all that the Bible teaches, and serious church involvement. Whether this represents a decline over time in commitment among youth to these conservative Protestant distinctives and commitments we cannot say, as we do not have comparable data from earlier eras. But it certainly does appear to represent a large current-day gap between what most conservative Protestant pastors and leaders want their teens to assume and believe and what many conservative Protestant teens actually do assume and believe. The same kinds of observations might be offered for other religious groups compared in this table, perhaps especially for the Catholic youth whose religious tradition also emphasizes the uniqueness of the Catholic faith, the importance of correct Church teaching, and the centrality of the Church as an institution of faith practice.
In their attitudes expressed on the NSYR survey, then, very many teens seem quite friendly with the spiritual seeker's view of the world. But these, let us remember, are merely agreeable attitudes in response to survey questions, not necessarily actual identities and actions. Do we have evidence that American teens not only share various key attitudes with seekers but actually think of themselves as and act like spiritual seekers? We turn next to trying to answer that question.
"Spiritual but not Religious"
First, we consider to what extent American teenagers embrace the most popular slogan, perhaps even common creed, of contemporary spiritual seekers, namely, that they are "spiritual but not religious." Numerous writers identify this as the emblematic identity of seekers. Do teens identify with it themselves? According to data in table 25, only 8 percent of American teens say it is very true that they are "spiritual but not religious," 46 percent say it is somewhat true, and 43 percent say it is not true of them at all. Teens from other religions (at 17 percent) followed by nonreligious (at 13 percent) and black Protestant teens (at 12 percent) were the most likely to say this was very true of them. Teens from the remaining religious traditions were less likely than the national average to say this identity was very true of them.
About half of Mormon and conservative and mainline Protestant teenagers said it was not true of them at all.
How do we interpret these numbers? Much hangs on the meaning of the "somewhat true" answers, which represent 46 percent of all teens. If these in fact are youth who are significantly starting to get into spiritual seeking,
SOUL SEARCHING
Table 25. Spiritual Seeking and Syncretistic Religious Practices among U.S.
Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) Wise 'Religious Tradition CP MP"
BP'
RC."
| LDS ORT NER Teen considers self "spiritual but not religious"
Very true
Cn eee Sy add Ly/alenan ie) Somewhat true AG M40 R1A5U5 4:7, S2 W57 HEAL OS0R S49 Not true at all
ABrA9GSAT<
-A0We Ale omiooe jogs Don't know/refused pl aimee vee meter sen beer lige | ey Meet Does
Teen tries to include in own spirituality any practices from (not asked of own religion)
Christianity
— — — —
— 32°
Buddhism, Hinduism, Zen, or other Asian GA ee Oh one a ee religion Wicca, witchcraft, or other pagan religion
Si 2) RS BINS Seen SIRS Judaism 2298), O86 onlin ay seh al2iee2 Islam Vistas iete: Ses Ws geil mies Ge al Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3,
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers; cells of <1 are reported as ~; OR = Other Religion (not Christian, Jewish, or LDS). then American teenagers indeed seem to be converting in great numbers to this alternative style of spirituality and questing. If, however, the "somewhat true" teens are instead representing in that answer something other than a partial and growing embrace of spiritual seeking, then spiritual seekers are likely only a small minority of American teens after all.
We are completely convinced by the latter interpretation and firmly believe that spiritual seeking as described above exists among only a very small fraction of American teenagers and that its influence on teens has been greatly overstated. Our reason for thinking this comes primarily from our experience personally interviewing hundreds of teenagers across the United States. Whatever their answers were to the survey question, when we came to interview questions about being "spiritual but not religious," as we will see below, the majority of all of the teenagers we interviewed said that they had never heard this phrase before, and the vast majority, even if they had heard this phrase, said that they had no clue what it meant. Most teens literally did not understand what it was we were asking about. Some struggled to provide answers because they seemed to think that they should know what we were asking about. But most simply said, "No, I haven't really heard that" and "I guess
I really don't know what it means." Thus, although the slogan "spiritual but not religious" can be seen on many bookshelves, read in many newspapers, and heard on many talk shows, very few American teenagers have heard of it, much less learned to what beliefs and lifestyles it refers. We are thus persuaded that the vast majority of teen survey respondents who said it was
"somewhat true" that they are spiritual but not religious meant by this answer to say, essentially, "Well, let's see, in some ways I think I am somewhat
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
spiritual—I do pray and go to church sometimes—but I'm really not entirely not religious, so it is neither very true nor not true at all, so I guess it must be the other answer: somewhat true." Which is to say they should have answered "Don't know" or, had they actually understood the spiritual seeking phenomenon the question was attempting to measure but which they are not actually a part of, "Not true at all." In which case, as our personal interviews clearly indicated, commitment to the kind of spiritual seeking that multiple writers have highlighted in recent years exists among only a small minority of American teenagers.
In fact, we strongly suspect that many of the 8 percent of American teens who reported that it is "very true" that they are spiritual but not religious are themselves not even spiritual seekers of the kind described above. Much of mainstream American Christianity inherits strong anti-institutional tendencies with historical roots as far back as at least the Revolutionary era.*
This individualistic, antiestablishment proclivity lives, ironically, in the heart of much of American institutional religion itself. And it has helped to form an important popular cuitural distinction between an "authentic faith"— which is personally chosen, regularly practiced, and spiritually meaningful— and an "empty faith," which is ritualistically rote, spiritually dry, and invested more in organizational associations than "real," personal experience.
Hence the very popular evangelical book authored by Fritz Ridenour, first published in 1967 and still in print today: How to Be a Christian without Being Religious.' Importantly, however, such "authentic" and "truly spiritual" faith does not reject institutional commitment and involvement. Indeed, regularly attending churchgoers might hear the "be truly spiritual and not merely religious" message preached from hundreds of church pulpits on any given week. Serious church involvement is actually important in the believer's life, from this perspective; it simply can't displace or substitute for an accompanying personal, authentic faith and meaningful spirituality. We strongly suspect that most of the teen respondents in the Christian traditions who answered "very true" that they are spiritual but not religious meant their answer in precisely this way: that in their mind and self-image institutional trappings have not displaced their personal, spiritual faith. This interpretation is corroborated by the fact that 58 percent of those who answered "very true" also attend religious services many times a year or more often, and the Christians among them, at least, are not statistically significantly more likely to say that truly religious and spiritual believers do not need to be involved in a religious congregation. Based on our experience talking through these issues face-to-face with teens around the country, we estimate that no more than 2 to 3 percent of American teens are serious spiritual seekers of the kind described above: self-directing and self-authenticating individuals pursuing an experimental and eclectic quest for personal spiritual meaning outside of historical religious traditions.
Again, our personal interviews with teenagers around the country, when examined in greater detail, confirm this interpretation of the numbers. For starters, half of the teens who the NYSR personally interviewed who had
SOUL SEARCHING
answered on the telephone survey that it was "very true" that they were "spiritual but not religious" said in their interviews later that they actually did not see any distinction between religion and spirituality. It is hard to explain their apparently inaccurate survey answers; perhaps they had a change of thinking or misunderstood the survey question. Perhaps lack of familiarity with the term resulted in less reliable answers. In any case, the "spiritual versus religious" distinction clearly was not an important conceptual or experiential difference shaping their ongoing thinking or identities.
Many of them said that they had never actually heard the phrase before. And those who had often had only the vaguest notions about what "spiritual but not religious" might mean. One white nominally Catholic boy from Wisconsin who considered himself to be nonreligious, for example, said, "What comes to mind is like weirdos, you know, like hippies and stuff like that, but I don't really care to think about it." Another white boy from New York with Catholic background but currently weakly affiliated with Ba'hai said,
"It's sort of semantics, I guess." A few, such as this nonattending Lutheran girl from Nevada who had never heard the phrase before, guessed that what other people mean by this distinction is simply that "they don't go to church but they still believe in God."
Even some of the teens who did say in their interviews that they think of themselves as spiritual but not religious were vague about what that meant.
One Jewish girl from New York, for example, explained, "I guess spirituality is just your connections and religion is more like, um, I don't know, like what you believe, like the bigger picture. I'm not sure, I don't know how to describe it." When asked specifically about the phrase "spiritual but not religious," she said it applied to herself "sort of, in a way, I'm not so much, like more towards that than anything else I guess, maybe I'm more spiritual because I don't follow my religion too much, but I don't know, I like believe in God,
I mean, | think I do, but I'm not sure." One white nonreligious boy from California pointed to a nebulous distinction between the specific and the general: "Religion is a specific religion, spiritual is more of a general thing, spiritual is kind of your own thing." And one nominal Christian girl from Arizona explained somewhat unclearly, "Being religious is being set on something. Being spiritual doesn't necessarily mean you're set on something, it just means you need something to believe in, something to, for your mind. It's just what comes with the owning of your belief, you know what I mean?"
Some of the interviewed teens who did see a distinction between religious and spiritual, whether or not they said it applied to themselves, were somewhat more clear on what the phrase might mean. One white Presbyterian boy from Southern California, for instance, focused on individual versus organized faith, explaining, "Being spiritual is more of an individual type of thing, less an organized." For himself, he noted, "I'm more spiritual than religious because I don't get caught up in a lot of [church controversies], like this and that thing is happening and you can't wear hats in church." Likewise, this black Baptist boy from South Carolina, who says he feels close to God but attends church rarely, observed, "When I think about 'religion' I think
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
of going to church. But 'spiritual' I would say is having a relationship with God like praying and anything like that. Religion is just the Bible and church.
And spiritual is just your relationship with God." And one West Coast, nonreligious boy raised in a Muslim family said simply that "religion" is believing in the Bible, while "spiritual" is believing in the paranormal. Thus, while some of these teens have somewhat more articulate views on the matter, it is far from clear that they share a common view. But generally, the phrase "spiritual but not religious" seems to denote something like a personal openness to or interest in the divine or the spiritual but a lack of certainty about or commitment to regular, visible religious practices and affiliations.
However, also in the group of self-identified "spiritual but not religious" teenagers, another quite different voice emerged in the interviews. We spoke with one Protestant Hispanic girl from Florida, for instance, who told us, "I just don't like religion, so I'd rather be spiritual." What did she actually mean by this? To be spiritual, in her view, is to "have an intimate relationship with God" when you "pray and really mean it, not like do it out of habit," whereas being religious means when "you don't really have an intimate [relationship with God]" and when things like praying are "all like very routine." This girl in fact attends church more than once a week. What she means by being spiritual but not religious is not being distant from church, but rather not being distant from God in the context of church, not having a habitualized or routinized faith. Fritz Ridenour strikes again. Similarly, this white Baptist boy from Ohio who attends church regularly explained, " 'Religion' is basically going to church, knowing God like 'book smart' and stuff; whereas a 'spiritual' relationship would be more like speaking to him daily and really feeling like you know him and you can talk to him, feeling him as a friend and more being spiritual." About himself, he said, "I feel like I can talk to Jesus and stuff but I also go to church and know the Bible decently well, so I would say I have both. But if I could pick the most important, P'd pick 'spiritual.' " Thus, some spiritual but not religious teens use these categories not to disparage or distance themselves from organized religion per se, but to emphasize the importance of personally meaningful faith that is practiced in the context of organized religion. Theirs is a critique, not of traditional religion itself, which they actually practice happily, but merely of the prospect of an empty, habitual, ritualistic faith. For them, "spiritual but not religious" is not the rejection of traditional religion but a reminder to sustain spiritual vitality within traditional religion.
Spiritual Syncretism and Experimentation Our estimate of 2 to 3 percent of true spiritual seekers is also confirmed by the other findings presented in table 25 on teens' actual seeker-like behaviors, specifically whether teens include in their own spirituality any practices from religious and spiritual traditions not their own. Their answers are instructive.
One percent of non-Muslim American teens try to include spiritual practices from Islam in their own spirituality; 2 percent of non-Jewish American teens try to include spiritual practices from Judaism in their own spirituality; 3
SOUL SEARCHING
percent of nonpagan American teens try to include spiritual practices from Wicca, witchcraft, or any pagan religion in their own spirituality; and 4 percent of American teens not affiliated with an Asian religion—such as Buddhism, Hinduism, or Zen—try to include spiritual practices from such religions in their own spirituality. Yet fully 37 percent of non-Christian and non-Mormon American teens try to include spiritual practices from Christianity in their own spirituality! In comparing across the religious traditions, we see that the teenagers most likely to be incorporating spiritual practices from other faiths and spiritualities are Jewish teens and those in the "other religion" category, that is, non-Mormon religious minorities and nonreligious teens. By comparison, only a few percent of the Christian teens are trying to incorporate non-Christian religious practices in their own spiritualities.
Three important general observations here suggest themselves. First, exceedingly few teenagers from the dominant religion in America, Christianity
(about 2 to 3 percent on average) are spiritually seeking, if by that we mean personally experimenting with religious or spiritual practices from other faiths. Second, the most likely seekers, thus defined, are by far non-Mormon religious minorities, those whose primary religious affiliations are Buddhism,
Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, Unitarianism, Christian Science, Wicca, and so on. Third, in the U.S. marketplace of spiritual practices, the religious option that is actually having the greatest influence on teen experimenters with other faiths is not an "exotic" faith or spirituality, but Christianity, the dominant
American faith. Much higher proportions of non-Christian and non-Mormon teens are incorporating Christian practices into their own spiritualities—18 percent of Jewish teens, 32 percent of "other religion" teens, and 44 percent of nonreligious teens—than Christian and Mormon teens are incorporating non-Christian practices into their spiritualities. If these data suggest any observable direction of teenage spiritual seeking in the United States, such as it is, it is of non-Christian teens seeking out Christianity, not the reverse. While this counters the conventional wisdom about spiritual seeking and may challenge normative advocates of religious pluralism, it should not be surprising.
The laws of mathematics almost determine that minorities surrounded by a dominant majority will be more influenced by the ever-present majority than the dominant majority will be influenced by the relatively scattered minorities.
That is simply the normal outcome of a statistical property of a certain structure of social distributions and relations. Furthermore, standard processes of immigrant and ethnic cultural assimilation into the dominant society also mean that non-Christians in the United States are much more likely to be influenced by Christianity than Christians are to be influenced by minority non-Christian faiths. And that is exactly what appears to be happening among American teenagers of different faiths.
Overall, therefore, our general conclusion based on these data remains the same: the phenomenon of spiritual seeking recently discussed by many observers of American religion is, according to the best available nationally representative evidence—and, we will see below, our interview data as well— very limited in the extent of its influence among American teenagers. There
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
clearly are some teenagers who think of themselves as spiritual but not religious and who behave in various ways like the new spiritual seekers that writers have discussed in recent years. But they appear to be a very small percentage of all U.S. teens. And even among them, it is not easy to find one who is clear and articulate about what it all means. It appears to be much more an amorphous feeling or sensibility than a specific idea or experience catalyzing a significant cultural or religious movement.
Who Are the Seekers?
Are we able to say what kinds of teenagers, few though they may be, tend to think of themselves as spiritual but not religious or incorporate spiritual practices from other faiths into their own spiritualities? Statistical regression techniques enable us to test for associations between these spiritual seeker indicators and many other social, personal, and religious factors to see if the correlations are strong enough, given the size of the groups involved, to be considered statistically significant. By testing for a variety of factors at one time, these regression techniques compute complicated equations allowing us to isolate the possible association of each separate factor while controlling for the influences of all of the other factors simultaneously for all factors tested. This enables us to sort through the great variety of variables to identify those with the clearest and strongest associations with spiritual seeking independent of the effects of any other tested variable. What follows are the results of the analyses we ran for the two seeking variables examined above.
First, we ran logistic regression analyses identifying factors associated with teens saying that it is definitely true that they are spiritual but not religious, as distinct from saying that this is either somewhat or not true. Results reveal the following variables are statistically significantly associated with definitely being spiritual but not religious while controlling for the effects of all of the other control variables:
6 Religious tradition: Teens from minority religions (other than Judaism and Mormonism) and nonreligious teens are more likely than are mainline Protestants (the reference category) to be definitely spiritual but not religious. e5 Religious service attendance: Teens who attend religious services less often are more likely than teens who attend more often to be definitely spiritual but not religious. es Lower desired attendance: Teens who themselves would like to attend religious services less often than they do are more likely than those who would like to attend more often to be definitely spiritual but not religious.
#5 Close friends: Teens with fewer close friends involved in a religious youth group or any other religious group they themselves are involved in are more likely than teens with more friends in religious groups to be definitely spiritual but not religious.
SOUL SEARCHING
e Parent religiosity: Teens with parents who attend religious services less often and for whom faith is of low importance are more likely than teens with more religious parents to be definitely spiritual but not religious.
5 Relationship with parents: Teens who say their parents do not understand, love, or pay attention to them are more likely than teens who say that their parents do understand, love, and pay enough attention to them to be definitely spiritual but not religious."
What do we learn from this analysis? It appears that the relatively small percentage of serious spiritual but not religious adolescents in the United
States are those who are located on the culture's religious periphery, who are marginal to mainstream religious institutions. They tend disproportionately to come from (non-Jewish and non-Mormon) religious minorities—Unitarians, Muslims, pagans, Buddhists, Satanists, Taoists, Christian Scientists—all teens on the fringe of U.S. religious culture, or to identify themselves as not religious. They are likely to attend religious services infrequently or never and to want to participate in religious services even less than they already do. America's spiritual but not religious adolescents also tend to make friends with other teens who are not in the same religious organizations. They are more likely to have parents who attend religious services infrequently or never and for whom faith is of low importance in their lives. They are also teens who are less likely to feel that their parents love, understand, and pay attention to them, which is itself also a significant predictor variable of youth distance from mainstream religion. In at least these six important, distinct ways, then, spiritual but not religious adolescents are teenagers who have very weak ties to and perhaps feel outright alienation from mainstream, institutional religion. By saying that they are spiritual but not religious, these teens are likely both distancing themselves from what they consider to be religious while simultaneously maintaining a spiritual identity which, in contemporary culture, indicates that they are not hard-core, secular, atheistic materialists.
What about those relatively few teenagers who incorporate into their own spirituality practices from some other religious faith? What social or religious factors set them apart from those who engage only in the spiritual practices of their own religion? Logistic regression analyses show these variables to be statistically significantly associated with teens including into their own spirituality one or more practices from a religion not their own while controlling for the effects of all of the other control variables:
#5 Religious tradition: Jewish teens and teens from other non-Christian minority religions are more likely than are mainline Protestants to incorporate other spiritual practices, while evangelical Protestant and Mormon teens are less likely. es Lower desired attendance: Teens who themselves would like to attend religious services less often than they do are more likely than those who would like to attend more often to incorporate other spiritual practices.
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
6 Close friends: Teens with fewer close friends involved in a religious youth group or any other religious group they themselves are involved in are more likely than teens with more friends in religious groups to incorporate other spiritual practices.
5 Relationship with parents: Teens who say their parents do not understand, love, or pay attention to them are more likely than teens who say their parents do understand, love, and pay attention to them to incorporate other spiritual practices. e5 Parental marital status: Teens with divorced parents are more likely than teens with married parents to incorporate other spiritual practices.
'5 Urban residence: Urban residents are more likely than rural residents to incorporate other spiritual practices. es Family income: Teens from families with higher incomes are more likely than those with lower incomes to incorporate other spiritual practices.
6 Parent education: Teens with more highly educated parents are more likely than teens with less educated parents to incorporate other spiritual practices.
We see again that teens from minority religions, who are surrounded by a dominant religious faith not their own (Christianity), are more likely to incorporate the spiritualities of other religions into their own practices. Teens with weak social ties to mainstream American religion—low-attending teens and those with fewer close friends in religious organizations—are also more likely to experiment with or practice the spiritualities of religions other than their own. These adolescent spiritual seekers thus again appear to be socially located on the culture's religious periphery. Second, it appears that teens in family situations involving greater distance and freedom from parents—teens who feel relatively unloved, not understood, and not paid attention to by their parents, and teens with divorced parents—are more likely to experiment with or practice the spiritualities of religions other than their own. When teens' close ties to both parents break down, it seems, they are more likely to experiment with spiritual practices of faiths other than the one in which they were raised. Finally, we can see a third theme in these findings: those teens more likely to experiment with or practice the spiritualities of other religions also appear socially located in ways that make them more likely to be exposed to and have the resources to appropriate culturally different practices: they tend to live in the cities, their parents are more highly educated, and they tend to come from families with higher incomes. There thus also appear to be social class and cosmopolitanism effects at work in this version of adolescent spiritual experimentation and eclecticism, which facilitate teens' appropriations of spiritualities from other faith traditions.
Having explored spiritual seeking among U.S. teenagers, we turn now to examine U.S. teens who are entirely disengaged from American religion. Who
SOUL SEARCHING
are the American teenagers who are simply disengaged from religious beliefs, practices, and institutions? What do we know about their numbers and characteristics? And how did they come to be religiously disengaged?
RELIGIOUSLY DISENGAGED TEENAGERS
The NSYR investigated not only religious teens, but also American teenagers who-never attend religious services and who self-identify as nonreligious.
Here we review these populations of teens to better understand their social locations and experiences.
Nonreligious Teens The category "not religious" can include a variety of kinds of people. To explore these differences, the NSYR asked teens who identified themselves as not religious whether they considered themselves atheists, agnostics, just not religious, or something else. According to the data presented in table 26, 8 percent of nonreligious American teens (1.4 percent of all teens) consider themselves atheists. The same number consider themselves agnostics. This is roughly the same proportion as American adults (about 2 percent) who identify explicitly as atheist or agnostic. More than half (54 percent) of nonreligious teens do not accept those labels, but consider themselves "just not religious." Twenty-one percent don't know what kind of not-religious person they are or refused to answer the question. Nine percent said "something
Table 26. Identities and Beliefs of Nonreligious U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) Nonreligious All U.S.
Teens Teens Nonreligious teen considers self Atheist
1.4
Agnostic
1.4
Just not religious
9.6
"Religious" nonreligious
1.8
Don't know/refused Ot
Believes in God Sy — Prays alone a few times a week or more often
— Reads the Bible a few times a week or more often a —_ Teen atheists who once did believe in God
— Doubts about being nonreligious Many doubts
_— Some doubts ils) —_ A few doubts
—~ No doubts
ee Don't know/refused
—_ Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding.
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
else" and then gave a verbatim answer suggesting some link to a religious identity; most likely these teens think of themselves personally as not religious, yet are connected, perhaps by family affiliation, to some religious tradition, such as Catholic, Baptist, or Lutheran. We see, then, that nonreligious
American teens encompass a variety of identities, including some that seem confused and even connected somehow to religion. Viewed from a different angle, American teens professing a nonreligious identity are not "not religious" on all measures of religiosity. Table 26, for example, also shows that 52 percent of nonreligious American teenagers believe in God, 24 percent pray alone a few times a week or more often, and 7 percent read the Bible a few times a week or more often. Self-identified nonreligious teenagers are far from entirely secular in beliefs and practices.
The NSYR also asked the 3 percent of U.S. teens who reported that they do not believe in God whether they ever once in their lives had believed in God. Sixty-six percent of them said that at one time they had believed in God; 31 percent (fewer than one-half of 1 percent of all American teens) say they never in their lives believed in God. Most of the very few teenage atheists thus at one point in their lives lost a previous faith they had held in God.
Religious believers can have doubts about their faith. In theory, nonreligious people might also have doubts about being not religious, perhaps questioning whether they really ought instead to have religious faith. Do they?
According to the findings in table 26, half of all nonreligious teens have no doubts about being nonreligious; about one quarter (27 percent) have only a few doubts; and nearly one-quarter (23 percent) have some or many doubts about being nonreligious. Comparing these results to those for religious believers in table 7, we see that nonreligious teens have just as many doubts about being not religious—perhaps even slightly more—than religious teens have about their religious beliefs. Clearly, while the majority of both types doubt little or not at all, we see that teenage nonreligiosity is subject to just as much doubt as is teenage religious belief.
From what religious backgrounds do self-identified nonreligious American teens come? We know from table 5 in the previous chapter that currently nonreligious teens have parents that represent a variety of religious traditions, particularly minority religions and mainline Protestantism. The majority of nonreligious teens' parents, however, are also not religious. But the religion of a survey respondent parent may not be the same as the religion a nonreligious teen was raised in as a child. Is it possible to say with more precision in what religious traditions youth were raised who as teens came to think of themselves as not religious? According to table 27, 22 percent reported that they were raised Catholic, 22 percent Protestant of various sorts, 20 percent
"just Christian" (suggesting a nominal family religious identity or low involvement in church), 14 percent were raised in nonreligious families, 3 percent Mormon, 2 percent Jewish, and 1 percent or fewer were raised in a variety of other minority religious traditions. Fifteen percent did not know in what religion they were raised or refused to answer the question. The 20
SOUL SEARCHING
Table 27. Religion in Which Currently Nonreligious U.S. Adolescents Were Raised, Ages 13-17 (Percentages) Catholic
No religion
Protestant Pap Mormon
Baptist
Jewish
Lutheran
Jehovah's Witness
Methodist
Eastern Orthodox 0.4
Pentecostal
Native American 0.4
Episcopalian
Muslim 0.3
Presbyterian
General theist 0.3
Just Protestant
Buddhist 0.3
Holiness 0.4
Hindu 0.2
Nondenominational 0.4
Unitarian-Universalist 0.2
Church of God 0.3
Christian Science 0.2
Evangelical 0.1
Other 0.1
Church of Christ 0.1
Don't know/refused
Just Christian
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding. percent "just Christian" and 15 percent "don't know/refused" add some interpretive ambiguity to these findings.
What seems evident in table 27, when compared to tables 1 and 2 of the prior chapter, is that no one religious group is especially overrepresented as the religious tradition out of which nonreligious American teenagers come.
In other words, no one religious group appears to be disproportionately likely to have their youth become nonreligious in their teenage years. All religious groups seem at risk of losing teens to nonreligious identities in roughly the same proportion to their share of the teenage population. For instance, 1.5 percent of American teens are Jewish, and 2 percent of nonreligious teens were raised Jewish; 23 percent of American teens are Catholic, and 22 percent of nonreligious teens (plus some unknown percentage of the "just Christian" and "don't know" teens) were raised Catholic. Less clear is the differential probability of fundamentalist and evangelical versus mainline and liberal
Protestant youth in becoming nonreligious, because Lutheran, Methodist, Presbyterian, and even Baptist congregations can be either indistinguishably conservative or liberal Protestant without more specific information. Nonreligious teens raised Episcopalian, however, are roughly the same proportion as currently Episcopalian teens (about 1 percent for both). The same parallel holds for Pentecostal, Church of God, and Church of Christ teenagers. If the majority of the 35 percent of "just Christian" and "don't know" respondents were raised Protestant, therefore, the chances of becoming nonreligious as teens appears to be equal among all religious traditions in which the youth were raised. If, however, the majority of those 35 percent were not raised
Protestant but, say, Catholic or some minority religion, then Protestants, perhaps especially conservative Protestants, are less likely than some other group or groups to have their teenagers become nonreligious. The findings of table
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
5 seem to confirm this latter interpretation. But the 35 percent of nonreligious teenagers' inability to remember the exact kind of religion (or nonreligion) in which they were raised makes it difficult to determine this precisely.
The NSYR asked all nonreligious teenagers who said they were raised in a religion why it was that they became nonreligious. Why did they fall away from the faith in which they were raised? This was asked as an open-ended question to which teens' answers were recorded verbatim and coded into general categories, as reported in table 28. The most common answer for becoming nonreligious (32 percent) was some version of intellectual skepticism or disbelief. These answers included teens who said, "It didn't make any sense anymore," "Some stuff is too far-fetched for me to believe," "I think scientifically and there is no real proof," and "Too many questions that can't be answered." Twenty-two percent merely said they do not know why they became nonreligious; they simply had no particular reason to offer for their apparent loss of faith. Thirteen percent referred to a general lack of interest in religion, saying things like, "It never seemed that interesting to me," "It got kind of boring," and "I just drifted away, I guess." Twelve percent of teens who had been raised in a religion explained their becoming nonreligious as simply having stopped attending religious services. Being raised religious, apparently, simply meant attending church, synagogue, mosque, temple, and so on such that when they stopped attending they were, by definition, not religious. Ten percent of nonreligious teens raised in a religion pointed to various life disruptions and troubles, such as deaths, divorces, and disappointments, as explanations for becoming nonreligious; they said things like,
"My sister got sick and died," "My parents divorced," and "Just a lot of things happened in my life that proved God didn't really help whatsoever."
Seven percent conveyed not so much a disbelief or disinterest in religion, but actually a strong dislike for religion, reporting explanations like, "The people at temple were not nice," "The lie the church has," "It didn't accept everybody's viewpoints." One percent suggested that their parents did not support their possible interest in religion, usually due to being too busy with work.
Finally, 2 percent gave vague reasons or asked to skip the question.
So what does this tell us? Half of American nonreligious teens who were Table 28. Reasons Nonreligious U.S. Adolescents Raised in a Religion Became Nonreligious, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
Intellectual skepticism and disbelief
Don't know why
Lack of interest
Just stopped attending services
Life disruptions and troubles
Dislikes religion 7.
Lacked parental support
Vague or no reason
DUCA Se On be ee ee ————————eee Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding.
SOUL SEARCHING
raised in a religion apparently lost their faith or dropped out of religion for fairly passive reasons: for lack of interest, for reasons unknown or vague, because they "just stopped" attending religious services, for lack of parental support, and so on. On the other hand, nearly 40 percent of these teens expressed more substantive reasons, such as intellectual disbelief and skepticism or some kind of active dislike of their church or religion. Ten percent seem to have dropped out of religion or lost their faith because disruptive or troubling events left them feeling that religious faith was deficient. Thus, half of nonreligious teens who leave the faith in which they were raised do so for seemingly significant emotional and intellectual reasons, and half drop out or lose their faith for what sound like rather unremarkable reasons. The former were positively incredulous, upset, or disillusioned, while the latter seemed to have simply drifted away. So we again see significant variance in teenagers' experiences with and perceptions of religion.
What is it like being nonreligious in a culture where most peers claim a religious affiliation or identity? Do nonreligious teens make an issue of their beliefs? And how are they treated perhaps as a result? Table 29 examines the responses of nonreligious American teenagers to two questions about their experiences among their peers at school. According to these findings, the large majority (64 percent) of nonreligious teers never speak out openly against religion at school. That is simply an issue they do not engage in their school settings. Sixteen percent speak out openly against religion at school only a little, and 12 percent some. Only 7 percent of nonreligious teens (about 1 percent of all teens) speak out openly against religion at school a lot. The vast majority of nonreligious teens thus appear to keep their views about religion to themselves. Comparing these figures against those of table 19 in the prior chaptet, we see that religious teens are somewhat more likely to openly express their faith at school than nonreligious teens are to speak out against religion.
How much are nonreligious teens made fun of or pressured by others for being nonreligious? According to their answers in table 29, not much: 85 percent are not pressured or made fun of at all, 13 percent only some or a little, and only 2 percent are made fun of or pressured a lot for not being religious. Comparing these answers to those of the religious teens in table 19, we see that religious teens are somewhat more likely to be made fun of or pressured by others for their religious faith than nonreligious teens are for being nonreligious. In sum, few nonreligious American teenagers are being bothered by others for their lack of religious faith, even fewer than the small minority of religious believers who are teased and pressured by others for being religious. Religion and nonreligion simply do not appear to be issues around which teens square off against each other. For most American teens, who have been well socialized into a culture of tolerance and acceptance of all cultural identity differences, as we will see in chapter 4, religion simply does not seem to matter enough to wrangle over.
Can we say with any more precision who are the American teenagers that identify as not religious? To answer this, we ran logistic regression analyses,
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
Table 29. Experiences of Nonreligious U.S. Adolescents among Peers and at School, Ages 13-17 (Percentages)
U.S. Nonreligious Nonreligious teens speak out openly against religion at school A lot
Some
A little
None
Pressured or made fun of for being nonreligious A lot
Some
A little
None
Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding and unreported don't know and refused answers. as we did with the spiritual seekers above, examining a variety of social and religious variables to see which are statistically significantly associated with teens being nonreligious. Results of our analyses show the following variables to be significantly associated, while controlling for the effects of other variables, with American teens' self-identifying as not religious:
5 Parent religiosity: Teens with parents who attend religious services less often and for whom faith is less important are more likely to be nonreligious than teens whose parents attend more often and for whom faith is more important.
6 Parental marital status: Teens with divorced parents are more likely to be nonreligious than teens with married parents.
5 Relationship with parents: Teens who say their parents do not understand, love, or pay attention to them are more likely to be nonreligious than teens who say their parents do understand, love, and pay attention to them. es Age: Older teens are more likely to be nonreligious than younger teens.
5 Lower desired attendance: Teens who themselves would like to attend religious services less often than they do are more likely to be nonreligious than those who would like to attend more often.
65 Close friends: Teens with fewer close friends involved in a religious youth group or any other religious group they themselves may be involved in are more likely to be nonreligious than teens with more friends in religious groups.
SOUL SEARCHING
5 Negative peer influences: Teens whose parents say their friends have a negative influence on their teens' lives are more likely to be nonreligious than teens whose parents say they have a positive influence.
6 Organized activities: Teen involved in fewer programs, clubs, hobby groups, sports, or other organized activities are more likely to be nonreligious than teens in more organized activities.
Multiple parental influences appear to be important in differentiating nonreligious from religious teens in the United States. Self-identifying nonreligious teenagers are more likely to have parents who themselves reflect low levels of religiosity, who are divorced, and who their teens say give them not enough attention, love, and understanding. Stated differently, teenagers with parents who are more religious, who are married, and who are perceived as expressing more love for, attention to, and understanding of their adolescent are more likely to embrace some religious identity. U.S. teens who are not religious also tend to be older and so likely enjoy greater personal freedom from their parents and over their own identity. Their parents are also more apt to say that their friends are a bad influence in their teens' lives, another sign of strained relationships between parents and teens. Furthermore, nonreligious teens are, as we might expect, less likely to have friends involved in religious groups and to want to attend religious services. Finally, they tend to be generally less involved in all types of organized activities, groups, and programs, and not merely religious organizations.
Two Nonreligious Baltimore Boys No two teenagers could possibly represent all nonreligious teens in the United
States. Any such grouping of American adolescents comprises a great deal of diversity in background, experience, and life outcomes. Here we portray two nonreligious boys from Baltimore, Maryland, not because they are somehow typical of all nonreligious adolescents—they are neither typical nor atypical— but simply to help put faces on the numbers, to convey some of the personal specifics and complexities of individual teenage cases. Such cases cannot truly represent a group, but they may illustrate certain larger points. One of the boys, Steve, who simply has no interest in organized religion, has in past years struggled with problems in life but now appears to be doing much better. The second boy, Raymond, who is Pa in serious trouble, considers himself nonreligious, yet is finding himself hesitantly attracted to a church he has stumbled upon.
Steve showed up early for his interview on a sunny morning at the public library decently dressed and with great enthusiasm and courtesy. He was, it was clear, a really nice 17-year-old, middle-class, white kid. He lives in a decent city neighborhood with his parents, works part time at a pizza shop, and generally enjoys school, where he is, he says, "a socialite, drama buff, and video enthusiast." Early in the interview Steve makes clear that he doesn't drink much, doesn't smoke or do drugs, and isn't having sex with his girlfriend, Amy, with whom he is clearly madly in love. Steve says his parents
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
love him very much. They also trust him, and rightfully so, he says, because he is a trustworthy person. He enjoys making pizzas, mountain biking, and playing "Dungeons and Dragons" with an organized game club comprised of older friends. But most of all, he likes making videos at school, where he enjoys the support of a very friendly media teacher. He is keen to buy his own digital video camera and is thinking of studying video production in college. Throughout the interview, Steve showed himself to be an earnest, caring, hard-working, affable adolescent, the kind most adults would enjoy and admire. Indeed, Steve observes about himself, "I like pleasing people."
At the same time, however, in the course of the interview it becomes clear that Steve has also struggled with his share of problems. For starters, he describes his father as a "hard ass" who in past years "worked so much I hardly ever saw him." Steve elaborates: "I don't feel like I know him well as a person, he's always been a mystery to me. I don't know much about his life or even his family. I love spending time with him but I wish we were closer. I'm closer to him now than when I was little. But it almost seems like it's too little, too late, like investing so much now, it would just almost hurt more when I have to leave."
Steve describes his mother as "really New Age-y, into a lot of weird, crazy things. She always has something new just about every week, which I love about her but at the same time it makes it kind of hard for me to relate to her. She's not a hippie but really darn close, she's a flake, but like in the best possible way." Steve's maternal grandfather, he explains, was for many years a hard-core alcoholic, mean and abusive, even to Steve—at least until he had a heart attack, which dramatically changed him into the kind person Steve now likes. Observing his grandfather's drinking, however, turned Steve off alcohol, and seeing his cousins and his older brother's friends smoke too much marijuana and some even ruin their lives on cocaine has also soured him on experimenting with drugs. In all of this, Steve is quite self-aware and self-reflective, more so than most boys we interviewed. In fact, he is able to explain that he knows that he struggles generally with emotional attachment and independence. When he was young, he recounts, an older male friend of the family named Vinny took to Steve and, by all accounts, served somewhat as a father figure. But, Steve explains, Vinny was "kinda spacey, he would always say he was going to come over, gonna do something, and he would just never show up. It was very disappointing." Steve says his mom's current
"flakiness" now "kinda retriggers that" in him.
A few years before our interview, Steve also had another problem: a nasty relationship with a girlfriend that he says drove him to attempt suicide. When
Steve was 13, he began a two-year-long romantic relationship with a girl he says was anorexic and self-hating and who emotionally abused him. "I went head over heels for this girl and she was really horrible to me, and my grades were going down and I couldn't take it any more. It was a horrible, horrible year." Steve said he stuck with her for two years because he thought he could rescue her. Complicating that situation, he says, was his ninth-grade English teacher, who was "a heinous, heinous woman. She had such a negative out-
SOUL SEARCHING
look on life and thought all teens were horrible people. She would degrade kids in class. My friend and I were the brunt of her jokes, she really would just degrade our work in front of the class and make fun of us and call us idiots." In ninth grade, Steve twice tried cutting himself, he says, in order to die. Then a friend told on him to a school counselor and his parents found out. He then went to therapy, which he says helped him a lot. "It did improve things," Steve remembers. "It was really hard for about a year after that. My parents were really hard on me and I was hard on them. We struggled, but through it we came to a closer point." Still, Steve says that he has not forgiven his former girlfriend "for anything" and that he feels guilty for trying to commit suicide, because it made his parents doubt themselves and think they had done something wrong, when, he says, they did not. He was just looking for attention in the wrong way. What does he do with his guilt? "I kind of dismiss it, kinda just deal with it. I live with it. But I feel like I have atoned for it in the last year, kind of made up for it." But it is clear in the interview that his attempts at suicide still embarrass and bother him.
Moving on to the topic of religion, Steve says: "I really can't buy into the organized religions. I'm kind of agnostic really. I don't know what I believe in. Something. I don't believe there's nothing. There's definitely a force at work. There's gotta be something. I like the idea that I've got some higher meaning, that there's some greater thing out there than the prime material right here in front of us." But what that something is, Steve doesn't know.
He sees a lot of "coincidences" in life that may point to something spiritual.
But then again, he says, they may just be mere coincidences. In any case, "Religion is just something I've never quite been able to get behind." Steve was raised Catholic but says that at 6 years old he decided that he wanted nothing to do with it: "I hated going to church and I hated Sunday School.
Everything seemed so hokey to me as a kid. It was like, 'What are you talking about? There's all kinds of great things about the world.' I felt they were trying to sell me something almost. And I still feel that way."
Steve described three childhood memories that seemed to connect to his rejection of religion. His mother, who apparently had religious questions herself, had never had Steve baptized, and her Catholic parents "chastised her for a long time" about that, worried that their grandchild would go to hell.
Also, one of Steve's Sunday School classes did a taste test once between identical-looking ground-up chocolate and coffee grounds, to demonstrate, he says, that looks can be deceiving. "I got the coffee grounds and was just pissed off. That's one of the things I remember most, is the deception." Finally, he recounts, "My best friend in kindergarten, Daniel Langdon, his mom said I couldn't hang out with him anymore 'cause I wasn't a Mormon. I often see people get stuck into trying to find the truth in religion and they shut out the world around them."
Still, Steve balances any hostility toward religion with a sense of appreciation. "It's a great guideline for people that need the guideline. I just have never felt like I need the guidelines. Religion gives people good moral foundations, it's a great foundation for people who don't have that." He has
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
friends involved in church youth groups and in the evangelical high school group, Young Life. "They love it, think it's the greatest thing in the world.
I've been invited, but I'm not really interested. I've got enough going on for me. If it works for them, fantastic, I'm happy for them." He says that whether or not there is an afterlife, "I'll be happy with whatever it is, if it's there,
[good], if it's not, I'll be happy with that too. Why can't you [simply] know the end of your life is the end of your life and that's it?" But he understands other people's "need for continuance, for self-preservation, for selfimportance" that he thinks gives rise to belief in life after death. Steve has never been to a religious summer camp, missions trip, or youth retreat. And he says his current girlfriend is "more hard-core not-religious than I am."
Steve, at least, says that he is "spiritual" and prays, which he describes as "a kind of a more inner feeling, like an inner communication for hoping somebody's betterment." He also thinks bad people, like Hitler, should be punished for their wrongs after they die "if they're not willing to let go or admit they're wrong, I think absolutely he should be punished." But he's not sure there is any kind of actual hell. Overall, he wishes people would just get along, which affects his views of religion. "I really do. I think the search for truth through organized religion is what causes conflict lots of times. It does separate people." Like your friend from kindergarten? I asked. "Yeah," Steve says.
When it comes to moral reasoning, Steve is fun to talk with, but he seems to lack solid grounding for his ideas and beliefs. He says some things are universally right and wrong and that he knows what they are. "There are fewer [moral truths] than some people would make. I wouldn't draw as many lines as some people would, but there are definite rights and wrongs: you don't steal, you don't kill, you don't cheat people in any way." But when it comes to explaining why such things are wrong, he struggles. He first says things are wrong that make people unhappy, that "ruin their day," but he cannot explain why anyone should be morally committed to other people's happiness. He then says wrong behavior has "bad consequences, it'll catch up to you," but also cannot say why one should not act immorally in cases when one knows one will never get caught. He also says that it is wrong to kill because "human life is precious and has dignity because every person is here for a reason and you shouldn't shorten their life." But he can't explain or describe where that life-dignifying reason comes from. "Maybe it's just to work at McDonalds and serve food," he offers. When asked about the idea that some people in the world do not seem to believe that each human life is precious, Steve replies, "I don't know, let each person decide for themselves, that's what everybody has to do." He says he himself doesn't feel any moral obligation to help other people by volunteering for community organizations,
"T feel like if I do, it's great, if I don't, all right." Steve says he does believe in basic, intrinsic human rights, but that he thinks they are merely "an unwritten code, really a human invention"—which, if you think about it, he says, could probably be "un-invented." What about people who are economic drains, who do not promote human evolution? Would society be justified in
SOUL SEARCHING
exterminating them? "That's not even a question about morals, it's a question of survival, which I think is above and beyond morals," Steve reasons. "It may be the most horrible thing to exterminate' people just for the sake of genes, but it would be the correct thing to do for survival. I don't think it would ever make it okay, but I think it would make it situationally justified.
Which is odd." Steve explains that evolution involves self-preservation, which in theory could wipe out contemporary humanistic notions of morality from the universe, "which is a sad thing, really. I wish it didn't have to be that way." But, he says, he does not find such thoughts depressing, but rather
"fun to think about and kind of interesting, 'cause, I don't know, I don't really let it bother me." In all of this—lacking recourse to grounding his moral commitments in, say, divine command or natural law—Steve finds himself in the common, intellectually sticky position of many of his teenage and adult contemporaries: asserting high moral standards (e.g., belief in human rights, equality, dignity of life) while possessing few coherent, rational grounds for explaining, justifying, and defending those standards. Thus, Steve began by asserting universal moral facts and human dignity, then quickly shifted to arbitrary individualism ("let each person decide for themselves"), and ended up conceding the rational justification for exterminating entire groups of humans and the extinction of traditional humanistic morality in the name of evolutionary species survival. Of course, nobody expects a 17year-old to be an articulate moral philosopher. But the apparent lack of clear bearings or firm anchors in Steve's moral reasoning are conspicuous and perhaps worrisome.
More generally, Steve's case highlights some larger themes that emerged in teen interviews. For one, the capacity of adults both to harm and to help adolescents is obvious in Steve's story. American teenagers' own individualism and assertions of autonomy notwithstanding, parents, grandparents, teachers, older friends, family relations, and parents of friends inevitably and profoundly form the lives of the youth they touch—for better and for worse.
Adults simply matter tremendously in the lives of teens, both in general and specifically when it comes to religion. Steve's personal rejection of religion, note, is set against the backdrop of an abusive alcoholic grandfather whom
Steve describes as "a hard-core Catholic"; a Catholic mother who had had enough religious doubts to not have Steve baptized and who herself later switched into "flakey" New Age experimentation; and a distant, overworked father who seems to have played no religious role in Steve's life. Steve casts the matter of religion in epistemological terms, as an inability to know. But it also appears that for Steve the issue of religious faith and practice is fraught with powerful emotional energy that is rooted in problematic relationships.
Given his past experiences, it is no wonder sociologically that Steve is not religious. Furthermore, he uses the structure of his current social relations— his antireligious girlfriend, his sustained distance from his Young Life friends' activities, his immersion in his "Dungeons and Dragons" game club—to sustain his nonreligious position. At the same time, Steve is no aggressively iconoclastic agnostic. If other people feel the need to be religious, that's great. If
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
religious beliefs turn out to be true, he's fine with that. If there's a God who stands behind the coincidences, he's open to that possibility. Religion, in Steve's view, can be a help, can provide useful guidelines, can provide people an important foundation. He just does not need that for himself. At the same time, however, when it comes to articulating the guidelines and foundations of his own moral beliefs Steve is rather at sea. He wants to defend a core of traditional, humanistic morality, but he seems to have few resources or reference points for explaining his moral beliefs and so easily gravitates to very different moral ideas. All in all, however, Steve is a very nice kid who has survived some personal griefs and mistakes and is now moving forward into what seems will be a happy, nonreligious young adult life.
Raymond, a fairly scrawny 18-year-old, nonreligious, Native American boy also originally from a middle-class household in the Baltimore area, is in many ways a more religiously open nonreligious teen than Steve is, but, by contrast, is not likely facing such a happy future. I had a very difficult time scheduling Raymond's interview, as he had recently become a transient, living in various friends' houses. When finally arranged, he showed up on time at the public library for his interview—along with four of his buddies, who I then had to inform were not invited to participate in the interview.
Raymond struck me in many ways as a good-hearted, likeable kid. But he was also clearly in trouble. A 17-year-old friend, the son of his best friend's mother's boyfriend, started him smoking marijuana at the end of seventh grade. Two years later, Raymond started dealing drugs himself, buying and selling and taking cuts of his own. "A lot of stuff we got right now is from New Hampshire. The guy actually drives it down here and delivers it, there's a whole network set up," he explains. For a while, Raymond was doing crystal meth but realized that that was messing him up, so he quit, limiting himself to smoking pot, drinking hard liquor (beer makes him sick), and smoking cigarettes. Raymond says now he does drugs in moderation: "When
I first left home, for the first two months I smoked weed every single day, I was addicted. Then I stopped for two weeks and I was like shaking, getting withdrawals, I'd get pissed off easily, you know, I wouldn't talk to nobody.
Then I really wanted to smoke some bud, so my friends would get it and then I'd be happy, you know. But I've tried to cut down a lot on that, too.
We can actually have fun being sober, you know." What, I asked, does he like about drugs? "Every time I get high, I'm always happy, I just get in a good mood, just sit there, yeah, talk to my friends, sometimes drive around.
It's just hanging out and feeling good, it's a release from everything, you know, from like all the problems I have every day, the daily problems of life."
Raymond was expelled from high school for absenteeism and then dropped out of a special remedial school because he said they were not teaching him anything he didn't already know. "I was like, 'Go to hell you guys,
I'm gonna go get my G.E.D.'" At 15, Raymond, high on pot, starting taking his mother's car on joyrides against her will and without a driver's license.
His mother eventually called the police and Raymond was arrested, put in jail, and later put on probation. "I didn't know what the heck probation was
SOUL SEARCHING
and I didn't care either. You know really, to be honest, I just kept smoking weed." Raymond has had a hard time landing a job. He has filled out many applications at restaurants and stores, but he does not understand why nobody calls him for an interview. Meanwhile, most of his current friends are school dropouts and also do drugs. At least one, he says, is in "juvie" (Juvenile Detention). The rest have fun hanging out together, cruising in cars downtown, and watching DVDs. Raymond likes to listen to heavy metal music, particularly his favorite band, Metallica. He also watches certain kinds of porn videos. "Porno is stupid shit, gay," he says. "I don't know why people watch it when it's guys having sex with girls. 'll have a picture of girls on my wall or I would watch girls going at it, like just girls, lesbian and stuff, I have videos of that, I like that, but only girls, not with guys, that's stupid, you know. Why would you want to watch that?"
Many of Raymond's troubles seem connected to his anger at his mother and his separation from his father. Raymond was adopted as a baby by parents in a troubled marriage. "I don't know why my mom and dad got married in the first place," Raymond shook his head, " 'cause they don't have anything in common." According to Raymond, when he was 14 years old, his mother decided unilaterally to divorce his father without telling anyone, mailing his father the divorce papers at work. "It sucked. My dad was crying when he told me about it, you know, and it really pissed me off at my mom."
Raymond clearly cannot stand his mother, but he adores his father. Unfortunately, his father has moved to Nebraska and Raymond rarely sees him.
After the divorce, Raymond fought continually with his mother, whom he viewed as being too strict, and finally she kicked him out of the house. "Her discipline was not effective, 'cause, you know, if I want to do it 'm gonna do it." Raymond's 13-year-old brother and 16-year-old sister have also both run away from home and are on probation after run-ins with the law. Of his sister, he says, "She hates my mom 'cause of the divorce. She'd never come back if she could." Raymond's father, by contrast, is not strict. He is a biker who drinks and sends Raymond soft-porn backgrounds for his computer desktop; his current one, he tells me, is eight topless women in bikini bottoms with hunting rifles slung over their shoulders. When Raymond told his father that he was dealing drugs, Raymond says, "He wasn't pissed. But he was like, "You better watch out. If you get caught you're going to jail for a long time.' " His dad bought him a Van Halen album when he was 8 years old, which is what originally got him into heavy metal music; his mom's attempt to replace that album with one by Michael Jackson was ineffective. Some of his friends' parents also do not seem to be encouraging him in good directions. A few nights before our interview, for example, Raymond said he had gotten drunk on vodka that a friend's mother, whom he considers a friend and counselor, gave to him.
Raymond did express some regrets for the course his life has taken.
"When I first went to high school my understanding was like, 'Wow, this is the time to party, it's high school, everybody's supposed to party in high school.' I don't know, I wish I wouldn't have that thought that, I wish I could
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
have hung out with better people, I kind of wish I would have listened to my mom, like taken her advice." Even now, Raymond says he hopes to sober up and settle down soon. "I've tried to quit dealing 'cause I know I'm gonna get caught if I don't quit. 'm not gonna smoke weed forever. I want to sober up and get my G.E.D." After that, he explains, he wants to join the Army: "I think about my future a few times a week, like, 'Darnn, what do I want to do with my life? Do I want to sit around and be a pothead all my life?' Hell no. Sometimes in bad moods or on bad days I just won't care, like I'll sit here and smoke weed forever. Then I'll wake up next morning and think,
'That was dumb.' " Why, I asked, doesn't he simply decide to sober up now?
"T don't know," he replied. "I've thought about it, but I kind of look at this as the summer to have fun and party, 'cause I'm 18 years old and I don't have to worry abcut living under my mom's roof, I can be out as long as I want. So I'm like, 'This will be a summer for fun, I'm gonna party and have fun this summer.' Then after that I just want to sober up and be clean and get my life together and straighten up. But I don't want the future to get here too quick, I want to be able to live life and still have fun, you know."
Raymond considers himself neither a religious nor a spiritual person. His mother has long been a regular churchgoer and he has no interest in following her path. At the same time, he is intrigued by religious questions and struggles to come up with convincing answers for himself. About "that Jesus thing, you know, whether he was actually here or not," Raymond says: "I'll just sit there and think about it and, you know, I can't convince myself of one thing and can't be for sure and it pisses me off 'cause I don't like it. If I don't know something, I don't like it. But I think about this stuff all the time. I just sometimes sit and think about it for hours and hours and [eventually] fall asleep and wake up the next morning. I don't know." About the existence of God, he says, "I believe in God and everything. I don't know if it's God but something that created everything, something higher than all of us. I used to believe in the Big Bang when I was getting stoned, but when I sobered up I knew that was a bunch of crap, I was like, 'that's stupid,' you know, all of a sudden it explodes and here's everything? No, I don't think so." When asked about what God is like, he says he suspects God is something more like a higher power or life force, then adds that he and his friends were just talking the other night about whether God was more forgiving or more judging. "I think it's messed up, some of the things we do. Like we'll sin, then ask him forgiveness and he will forgive, you know, that's what I think. I don't know, I, I don't know." So, Raymond thinks people are sinful? "Yeah, all the time," he says. In general, he thinks religion is a good thing: "You gotta have something to believe in, I mean, where would we be? I think it is pretty good
*cause why would God just create the world and not let us know he's there, you know?" Raymond does not read the Bible but he does pray before meals.
"If I'm lucky enough to have food then obviously somebody's watching over me," he observes. He thinks he believes in angels, demons, heaven, hell, but is not entirely sure. He has no interest in any other religions besides Christianity, except for an intellectual interest in ancient Egyptian culture. And
SOUL SEARCHING
psychics and fortune-tellers, he says, are "a bunch of shit, they're full of crap." Raymond also seems to detest Mormon missionaries and violent Muslim extremists. Still, he says, "I'm not gonna go up and tell them that I think it's wrong."
During the interview, it came out that Raymond had recently been sporadically attending a Nazarene church in the area for a few months. A sister of one of his friends, it turns out, is a regular there and invited him to come along with her. Raymond actually seems to like it a great deal. "It's cool," he reports: "It's more structured than my mom's church and they got more things to do. They have teen nights, Wednesday night services, Sunday night church, and that's pretty cool. They have youth group and Sunday school.
They have a first service, then Sunday school, then some kind of breakfast thing where kids talk and then get together and discuss what they talked about. It's pretty cool, I like it." In fact, he has invited one of his ex-girlfriends to attend this church with him when she told him that she was interested in going to church somewhere: "I was like, 'All right, I'll take you sometime,' and she's like, 'All right, that will be cool.' " But, he says, his living situation and transportation problems have prevented that from happening yet. Recently, however, he ran into the church's Sunday School director at the mall and had a pleasant conversation with him. "He's cool, yeah, he's cool just to talk to about whatever, you know, ask advice." I asked Raymond whether he actually understood what the Nazarene church was teaching or whether he was mostly there to have a good time. "Yeah," he said, "I understand," explaining: "The last thing they talked about was, what was it? They talked about like when you prune a tree, you know? Like that's what you have to do through life, you have to take the bad things out or whatever. I can't remember exactly what they said, but it made sense, I know. That's what I like about this church, what they say actually makes sense. Unlike my mom's dumb church that talked about the same freaking thing all the time, the same freaking thing, that's what pissed me off. I was like, 'This is dumb.' " Raymond thinks he'll probably continue going to this church. "I've been actually thinking about asking Rich [his friend] if he wanted to start going again with his sister and her friend 'cause they go every Sunday and Wednesday. I know they'd let me go with them. I just don't know, it's just, if I want to, you know.
But I've been thinking about that." What exactly, I pressed further, did he find appealing about this church? "It's good people, you know. And not only that, I also actually learn, 'cause like I said I'm not even sure about this stuff and I want to learn more. Like whether you have to go to church to get into heaven or if you can just pray and be a God-fearing person and go to heaven or whatever, you know?" In fact, Raymond has been working on specific questions to which he wants to get answers from church: "I don't know who goes to heaven and hell. Like people that do drugs, I don't know, or like if I were a bum, would a bum go to hell just 'cause he lives on the streets and drinks all the time? I've actually thought of asking some people from that church but I never have gotten around to it, so I don't actually know."
In all of this, Raymond struck me as a confused but sincere person who
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
was at least in part wrestling with questions of truth and goodness. It was clear he had spent time thinking about moral boundaries and the nature of a good life. For instance, he says he attempts somewhat to watch his language: "I try to do good—I don't use the Lord's name in vain or whatever,
I know that's a sin. Whether I believe in it or not, I'm not gonna do that, you know, I'll substitute some other word for it." Also, Raymond has volunteered at a local nursing home, doing arts and crafts and puzzles with the elderly residents. "I think it's right," he explains, "it's only fair, cause they were here before us and they took care of us so we might as well take care of them." Furthermore, he says he remained a virgin until he was 17 years old. At that point, however, "I tried sex then 'cause people were making fun of me 'cause I was still a virgin at 17." His first sexual intercourse was with a girl he met when he was visiting his father in Nebraska. Since then he's had sex with numerous girls but, he says, he is not like a lot of guys who will have sex with someone right away; he really believes in getting to know someone first, waiting at least two, three, or maybe four months. One of his friends just got a girl pregnant, he said, and when he found out, "I didn't know whether to say 'Congratulations!' or 'I'm sorry,' you know?" Raymond himself is adamant about using condoms to avoid pregnancy and STDs.
In these and many other specific ways, then, Raymond seems always to keep one eye on some kind of moral compass. But he also has little compelling language to draw on to explain why he thinks things are right and wrong.
For the most part, he simply praises and condemns people and actions as "cool," "stupid," "messed up," "dumb," and as making him "pissed off."
His other noticeable approach to moral reasoning is purely consequential: certain things are wrong because they will hurt you if you get caught. "It's gonna come back and kick you in the ass later," he said about why cheating in school (which he did) is wrong. "I don't want to do drugs for the rest of my life, don't want to end up like some people I know," he said in reflecting on what is wrong with doing drugs. In part, Raymond's inarticulacy about morality seems connected to his general inability to see life within any larger meaningful framework. When asked about life's possible larger purpose, about what people are ultimately on earth for, Raymond responded: "Actually, I don't even know, I've thought about it once in a while. I actually don't think there is a point. I think this is hell right now. I guess you just have to live it out to the fullest, you know. It can be a bitch sometimes, it can be cool sometimes." He then mentioned the possibility of some kind of life after death, that "after you pass this then it gets better afterwards." But exactly how or why he's not sure. He summarized his view of life's purpose this way:
"Make life good for yourself, you know?"
As to his own life, Raymond hopes someday to own a BMW dealership.
"TI love cars and BMWs are my favorite car," he explained. "I want to have enough money just to do what I want and have a nice car, like a nice BMW, so I can drive around, and have a fairly nice house that I don't have to make payments on." Raymond subscribes to Dupont Registry, a magazine about luxury cars, houses, and boats—something that seems to help keep his
SOUL SEARCHING
dreams alive. He seems unaware, however, that the facts that he has no specific plan for reaching these goals and cannot even get the local Chinese restaurant to hire him as a busboy pose obstacles to the reaching of his career and financial goals. Raymond also says he wants someday to settle down with a woman he can "take care of." But, he explained, he probably does not want to get married, primarily because if he splits up with his woman he would be pissed if she got to take half of his BMW dealership after the divorce. So he and she will probably just live together. Finally, as to his religious future,
Raymond says, "I'll probably end up going to church, yeah, probably."
Again, Raymond is not representative of nonreligious U.S. teenagers, any more than is Steve. Yet his story highlights certain themes well worth noting about nonreligious youth. As with the lives of so many other adolescents, the role of the adults has been powerful in shaping Raymond's life generally and his religious and spiritual life specifically. His mother, father, friends' parents, and teachers have profoundly formed his outlook on life and faith. In this process, emotions generated out of positive and negative relationships seem to have played at least as important a role as cognitive beliefs. Raymond's story also illustrates another important theme that emerged from our data: the lives of self-described nonreligious teenagers actually often contain at least some religious interests, questions, practices, ethics, and values. Even a religious faith rejected can exercise a grip on the thoughts, feelings, and desires of youth. This observation connects to yet another theme: the majority of nonreligious U.S. adolescents are not particularly antireligious. Most are fairly appreciative of religion's value, even if they do not wish to appropriate it for themselves, and hold very little animosity against religion per se. Raymond hated his mother's church, but that did not make him globally antireligious. Indeed, he was quite willing to try a new church recommended by a friend's sister, which he found, upon attending, was quite intriguing. Our interviews in general suggest that this is not unusual. It could be that many
U.S. adolescents currently disengaged from organized religion could be drawn through the attention and invitations of relationships into the life of religious communities with good programs for teenagers—perhaps just as readily as similar and other forces pull teens away from religious communities. Many
American youth may be more receptive to the invitations and teachings of communities of faith than many such communities likely realize.
A final notable theme that Raymond?'s story, like Steve's, illustrates is the difficulty that many teens, but especially nonreligious teens, have in understanding and articulating what it is exactly that makes right and wrong right and wrong. The vocabulary and ideas on which Raymond draws to make sense of moral thought and behavior are impoverished. As such, in navigating the troubled waters of his own life, he seems able to express only subjective, rather arbitrary feelings and reactions to explain his own moral experience and sensibilities. Overall, he seems to be a disarranged young man lacking helpful adult guidance in his life. His circumstances and choices have placed him in a difficult position in life with fairly bleak prospects for the future.
Even so, Raymond is hearing messages that intrigue him about the need to
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
prune bad parts from trees so they will produce good fruit. Whether he draws closer to the source of those messages, however, remains to be seen.
Nonattending Teens Not all religiously disengaged American teenagers think of themselves in identity terms as not religious. Another type of religiously disengaged youth consists of those who never attend religious services, whether or not they hold some nominal religious identity as, say, Catholic or Jewish or just Christian.
What do the 18 percent of American teens who never attend religious services look like? Who are these teens who never darken the door of a church, synagogue, mosque, or temple? According to the findings in table 30, a full
43 percent of them think of themselves as part of a religious denomination or tradition. Thus, never attending religious services does not equate in the minds of many teens with being nonreligious. Or, stated differently, and as we saw in table 24 earlier, most teenagers do not think that being religious means that one has to attend religious services. For many, being religious and attending services are often disconnected matters.
Do teenagers who never attend want to attend religious services, or are they happy never to attend? According to table 30, nearly one-quarter of never-attending teens report that if it were totally up to them they would like to attend religious services regularly, that is, two or three times a month or more often. Another 10 percent say they would like to attend once a month.
Sixty-one percent say they would like to attend only a few times a year or never. If we believe these reports, it appears that a substantial minority of teens who never attend services would actually like to attend religious services regularly: 34 percent say once a month or more often. Moreover, when asked whether they expect to attend religious services when they are 25 years old, a strong majority of never-attending teens (63 percent) say yes or maybe.
Only 37 percent say definitely no.
So why do they not attend more? Nearly two-thirds of American teens who never attend services have been invited by someone to attend religious services in the prior two years. There appears to be no correlation (analysis not shown) between wanting to attend religious services more often than never and having been invited to attend religious services in the previous two years: those who want to attend services a lot more but do not are just as likely to get invited as not. Thus, nonattenders' never attending services cannot be fully explained by nobody reaching out and inviting them. Nor can it be entirely explained by unsupportive parents, as 24 percent of survey respondent parents of nonattending teens say that they attend religious services themselves once a month or more (unless, of course, some of these parents are overreporting their attendance). Nor can it be explained by a lack of experiential familiarity with religious service attendance. According to their retrospective accounts, shown in table 30, fully 27 percent of nonattending teens have regularly attended religious services for one or two years since they were 6 years old, and another 50 percent regularly attended services for three years or more since they were 6. Only 8 percent of nonattenders have
SQUL SEARCHING
Table 3Q. CGharacterisnes af US. Adolescents, Ages 15-17, (Pereamees) Not Qarrendly Attending Reigsous Services
Nonattaders who si think of themacives as part a af a reigean, denomimation, ar charch How afte nonattadess weed! amend relignens services if totally wp te thes:
More than once a week _ Oace a week ui 2-3 times a month
Qece a month re Many times a year * A few times @ year RS | Never »® Expects to attend services egellariy at age 25
Ws le Ne = Invited to attend 2 religious eevike ie prior 2 years eS Parent attends months or more afte » Years regularity attended religions wevites Gace age &
Q / g
id > aw?
as S$
s re [ we Feelings about religion in the United Sates Very positive nr Somewhat positive
Neither positive nor negative R Somewhat be | Very negative s EE Source: National Seevey of Youth and Religion, 2OQ2
Newer Percentages say net addi t 10Q dhe wt roending. never regularly attended religious services since they were & Nonattending teenagers are thus not a people devoid of experience attending riigious sen ices. So why do they not attend more regularly? Ib it because they negative feelings toward religion in general? No. When asked about thei personal feelings toward religion in the United States, nonattending teens
Were generaly positive, as shown in table 30. About half (49 percent) of nonattending teens feel very or somewhat positive about religion in the
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
vailing hostility against religion generally does not explain these teens' lack of religious service attendance.
So, again, if many nonattenders profess to want to attend religious services more often, why don't they? The NSYR asked them directly: we asked religious teens who in carlics years had attended religious services more often than a few times a year but who at the time of the survey were not attending services regularly, "Is there any particular reason why you stopped attending religious services regularly?" Their answers, combined with those of the nonreligious teens represented in table 28—-who were not asked this question because their answers were anticipated to be "Because I became not religious"—are presented in table 31. There we find relatively few teens offering substantive antireligious reasons for declining religious service attendance.
Forty-one percent simply could think of no reason why they stopped attending religious services as much as they had been attending, and 17 percent said they were simply disinterested or bored. Thirteen percent attributed their declining attendance to life transitions and disruptions—mostly moving to new locations or parents divorcing; 5 percent said their parents stopped taking them to religious services; and 4 percent reported availability problems, such as lack of transportation. Three percent said they simply felt no religious needs. Only 17 percent of these teens (about 3 percent of all teens) reported a religiously skeptical or hostile reason for reducing their service attendance to a few times a year or less often: 11 percent said they stopped believing or had never believed the teachings of their congregation, and 6 percent reported some bad experience or personal dislike for religion generally as their explanation for stopping attending religious services regularly.
We cannot be certain that these accounts represent the "true" reasons behind these teens' declining religious service attendance. But insofar as they are roughly valid and reliable, we can conclude that only a small minority of American teens who have gone from being at least somewhat regular religious service attenders to attending only a few times a year or never have been motivated to do so by an active hostility toward, skepticism of, or negative
Table 31. Reasons Nonattending U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17, Who Once Attended Religious Services Stopped Attending (Percentages)
No reason or don't know
Disinterest
Life transition or disruption
Teen disbelief Bad experience with or dislikes religion Parental nonsupport Availability problem No felt religious need — wWOARaAD EE Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: Percentages may not add to 100 due to rounding.
SOUL SEARCHING
experience with church, synagogue, mosque, or temple. The great majority instead either have no apparent reason, are just not interested, have been dislodged from regular attendance by some other life disruption, have some availability or transportation problem, or just feel no need for religious meetings—all fairly nonchalant motivations for religious disengagement. Again, we see relatively little active rebellion or animosity directed toward religious practice by even religiously disengaged teenagers. Instead, they appear rather passively to see religion as simply not that important or much of a priority.
They seem to find little that is attractive or compelling about practicing a religious faith in a congregation.
Can we specify more clearly the social locations of low-attending and nonattending teens? Results of regression analyses show the following variables to be significantly associated, while controlling for the effects of other variables, with American teens attending religious services only rarely or never:
65 Parent religiosity: Teens with parents who attend religious services less often and for whom faith is less important are more likely than teens whose parents attend more often and for whom faith is more important to attend religious services only rarely or never.
5 Relationship with parents: Teens who say their parents do not understand, love, or pay attention to them are more likely than teens who say their parents do understand, love, and pay attention to them to attend religious services only rarely or never. es Parent education: Teens with less educated parents are more likely than teens with more educated parents to attend religious services only rarely or never.
6 Age: Older teens are more likely than younger teens to attend religious services only rarely or never.
6 Organized activities: Teens involved in fewer programs, clubs, hobby groups, sports, or other organized activities are more likely than teens in more organized activities to attend religious services only rarely or never.
'#5 Negative peer influences: Teens whose parents say their friends have a negative influence on their teens' lives are more likely than teens whose parents say they have a positive influence to attend religious services only rarely or never.
5 Close friends: Teens with fewer close friends involved in a religious youth group or any other religious group they themselves are involved in are more likely than teens with more friends in religious groups to attend religious services only rarely or never.
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
5 Importance of faith: Teens for whom faith is less important in their daily lives than other teens are more likely to attend religious services only rarely or never.
'es Lower desired attendance: Teens who would like to attend religious seryices less often than they do are more likely than those who would like to attend more often to attend religious services only rarely or never.
'es Race: White teens are more likely than black teens to attend religious services only rarely or never.
'6 Regional location: Teens who live in the Northeast are more likely than those living in the South and Midwest to attend religious services only rarely or never.
Parental influences again appear to be important in differentiating lowattending from more frequently attending American teens. Low-attending teenagers are more likely to have parents who themselves reflect low levels of religiosity, who are relatively less educated, and who their teens say do not give them enough attention, love, and understanding. Stated differently, teenagers with parents who are more religious, who are better educated, and who are perceived as expressing more love for, attention to, and understanding of their adolescents are more likely to attend religious services more regularly. As with nonreligious teens, youth who are low religious service attenders also tend to be older and so tend to enjoy greater personal freedom from their parents. Their parents are also more apt to say that their friends are a bad influence in their teens' lives—again, often a sign of strained relationships between parents and teens. Low-attending teens are also, as we would expect, less likely to have friends involved in religious groups, to say that faith is important in their lives, and to want to attend religious services.
Like nonreligious teens, they also tend to be generally less involved not only in religious congregations, but in all types of organized activities, groups, and programs. Low-attending teens tend to be disproportionately white compared to black and living in the Northeast compared to the South and Midwest. An attempt to draw any picture of low-attending American teenagers, then, would likely depict them as older, raised in low religion and lower education households, experiencing greater strain in their parental relationships, relationally disconnected from religious and other kinds of youth organizations and programs, and having friends who may be more likely to be in trouble. Although there are certainly many well-adjusted
American adolescents who do not attend religious services regularly, as a whole, low-attending American teens, like the nonreligious teens, appear to reflect at least some likely signs of family strain and general civic and organizational disconnection.
SOUL SEARCHING
RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENAGERS
At the other end of the spectrum from the religiously disengaged teenagers are the highly religiously active. What factors associate with American adolescents attending religious services more often, reporting faith as more important in their lives, and participating in religious youth groups? Table 32 reports the results of regression analyses of these three key measures of adolescent religiosity. Only the associations that are statistically significant after controlling for the possible effects of all other variables examined are noted as positive or negative. Here we see a number of factors that correlate with higher teenage religiosity. While controlling for all other variables in the columns, we see that evangelical and black Protestant and Mormon youth are higher than mainline Protestant youth in religious service attendance and importance of faith. Catholic and black Protestant teens and those from other minority religions are less likely than mainline Protestant teens to participate in a religious youth group. And nonreligious youth are, as expected, lower than mainline Protestants on all three measures of youth religiosity. Table 32 also shows that more frequent religious service attendance, greater importance of faith, teens' personal desire to attend religious services, and youth group participation are all significantly associated with each other. They generally all hang together as religious practices that increase and decrease with each other among more and less religious youth. Parental religious service attendance and importance of faith also exhibits a consistent effect on teenage religiosity: the more religious parents are, the more religious their teens tend to be.
Table 32 also suggests that certain other eu variables associate with teen religiosity. Teens who are involved in more! organized activities, programs, and groups are also more likely to attend religious services more often and to participate in religious youth groups. All three measures of religiosity are positively associated with teens having higher proportions of their closest friends in their religious groups, which may, of course, be both a cause and an effect of their own higher religiosity. Teens who say that their parents love, accept, and understand them are also more likely to have faith be important in their daily lives and to be part of a religious youth group. And teens whose parents monitor their lives more closely are also more likely to score higher on service attendance and importance of faith. On the other hand, it is less likely that faith is important in the daily lives of teens who say their parents do not give them enough freedom to develop and express their own views on important issues.
Finally, some demographic variables associate with teen religiosity even after controlling for the examined religious and social factors. Girls are more likely than boys and younger teens are more likely than older teens to say faith is important in their daily lives. Black youth are more likely than white to score higher on all three measures of religiosity, even after controlling for black Protestant religious tradition.? Teens whose residential parent lives with an unmarried partner are less likely than teens with married parents to participate in a religious youth group, just as teens with divorced or widowed
Table 32. Factors Associated with Increased Adolescent Religiosity, U.S.
Adolescents, Ages 13-17 Se a at a a ey) More Frequent Religious Service Youth Group Participation Greater Importance Tested Variables Attendance of Faith Religious Variables Religious Tradition Evangelical Protestant Mainline Protestant* Black Protestant Catholic Jewish Mormon Other religion Not religious Teen Personal Religiosity Positive Positive Positive Positive Negative Negative Positive Positive Negative Negative Negative Negative Religious service attendance Importance of faith Desired service attendance Parent Personal Religiosity Positive Positive Positive Positive Positive Positive Positive Attendance/Importance Positive Positive Positive Social Variables Time Demand Factors Number teen organized activities Hours teen works paid job Peer Influences Positive Positive Number of friend ties to faith Positive Friends a positive influence in life Parental Relationship Issues Positive Positive Parents love, accept, understand teen Parents monitor teen's life History of marital breakups Positive Positive Positive Positive Parents give too much freedom to think and express themselves Parents give too little freedom to Negative think and express themselves Parents give the right amount of expressive freedom* Demographic Variables Teen is female Teen age older Teen Race Positive Negative White* Black Hispanic Asian Other race Family Structure Positive Positive Positive Married* Never married Unmarried partner Divorced Widowed Separated Negative Negative Negative (continued )
SOUL SEARCHING
Table 32. Factors Associated with Increased Religiosity (continued ) an nce EEUU EEEEEEEE EEE!
More Frequent | Greater Youth Religious Service — Importance Group Tested Variables Attendance of Faith Participation Parents' education Positive Higher family income Negative Number of teens in household Region of Residence Northeast* South Positive Positive Midwest Positive West/Pacific Positive Residential Context Rural* Suburban Urban Parental political conservativism Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.
Note: *=Reference group. parents are less likely to say faith is important in their lives. Teens with more highly educated parents tend to attend religious services more often, although teens in higher-income families tend to say faith is less important in their lives. Finally, youth from all other areas of the country are more likely than those in the Northeast to be in a religious youth group, and those who live in the South also score higher on importance of faith.
In sum, we see that the religiosity of American youth is conditioned by a variety of religious, cultural, and relational factors. Although American teenagers may not be able to see, understand, or articulate such influences on their lives, it is nonetheless clear that certain faith traditions, social relationships, and cultural identities and locations shape their religious lives significantly.
The Most Highly Devoted Another way to examine factors shaping religiously committed teens is by focusing on the most highly devoted among them: the 8 percent who believe in God, attend religious services weekly or more often, for whom faith is extremely important in their lives, who regularly participate in religious youth groups, and who pray and read the Bible regularly. Kristen in chapter 1 is an example of this kind of teen. But who are these highly religiously devoted teens more generally? What social and personal factors distinguish them from other American youth? As with the analyses above, we used regression techniques to examine the influences of a variety of religious and social variables while controlling for the effects of all of the others to identify which factors are statistically significantly associated with being a religiously devoted teenager, as defined just above. The results reveal these factors as significantly associated, which generally reinforces the findings of the previous analysis:
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
5 Parent religiosity: Teens with parents who attend religious services more often and for whom faith is more important are more likely than teens whose parents attend less often and for whom faith is less important to be religiously devoted. e8 Relationship with parents: Teens who say their parents tend to understand, love, or pay attention to them more, compared to teens who say their parents tend not to understand, love, and pay attention to them, are more likely to be religiously devoted. e5 Parental marital status: Teens with married parents are more likely than teens with divorced parents to be religiously devoted.
'e6 Parent education: Teens with more highly educated parents are more likely than teens with less educated parents to be religiously devoted.
5 Organized activities: Teens involved in more programs, clubs, hobby groups, sports, or other organized activities are more likely than teens in fewer organized activities to be religiously devoted.
65 Religious tradition: Evangelical and Mormon teens are more likely than are mainline Protestants to be religiously devoted, and Catholic teens are less likely than mainline Protestants to be devoted.
65 Higher desired attendance: Teens who themselves would like to attend religious services more often are more likely than those who would like to attend less often to be religiously devoted.
#5 Close friends: Teens with more close friends involved in a religious youth group or any other religious group they themselves may be involved in are more likely than teens with fewer friends in religious groups to be religiously devoted, although this is likely as much a result as a cause of being religiously devoted.
5 Peer influences: Teens whose parents say their friends have a positive influence on their teens' lives are more likely than teens whose parents say they have a negative influence to be religiously devoted, although this may be as much a consequence as a cause of being religiously devoted.
5 Teen gender: Girls are more likely than boys to be religiously devoted.
65 Race: White teens are more likely than black and Hispanic teens to be religiously devoted.'° Here we see once again that parents have an important influence on the shape of their teenagers' religious lives. Teens are more likely to be religiously de-
112.
SOUL SEARCHING
voted—as measured by this conglomeration of variables—who have more highly religious parents, who have positive and loving relationships with their parents, and whose parents are married.'! Better-educated parents are also more likely to have religiously devoted teens. Religiously devoted youth also tend to be more broadly involved in a variety of organized groups, programs, and activities; thus religious devotion and involvement in many other kinds of organizations seems to go together in a larger life package of participation and engagement. Teens from religious traditions that are relatively demanding—conservative Protestantism and Mormonism—which also are most likely to offer organized religious youth groups (see table 14 in chapter 2), tend to be more religiously devoted, and Catholic teens tend to be less devoted. Religiously devoted teens want to attend religious services frequently and have a strong personal attraction to life in religious congregation. They also have more close friends in the religious groups in which they are involved and their parents believe their friends are a good influence on their teens' lives, although, as noted above, these are likely as much consequences as causes of teen religious devotion. Finally, girls, who in general are more religious than boys, and white teens, compared to black and Hispanic teens, are more likely to be religiously devoted. Thus, teenage religious devotion is not randomly distributed, but tends to be identifiably socially located in specific types of families, religious traditions, friendship networks, orientations to participation, and gender and racial identities.
Religious on Their Own There are many other potential ways to examine religious devotion among American adolescents, most of which are beyond the scope of this chapter to explore. Here, however, we do examine one other group of religiously devoted youth: those who attend religious services without their parents. We know that parental attendance is a powerful predictor of teen attendance, but what about teens who do not appear to be encouraged by their parents' attendance? Which teens, that is, among those not accompanied by one or both of their parents—either because their parents do not attend at all or attend services of a different religion or congregation—attend more services on their own? What factors among this group differentiate those who attend religious services more and less? Of all teens not attending religious services with one or two parents, after controlling for many standard demographic variables, the following factors stand out as significantly associated with more frequent attendance:
'6 Popularity at school: Teens who say they are part of the popular group at school are more likely than those not part of the popular group to attend religious services without parents more often. e5 Organized activities: Teens in more programs, clubs, hobby groups, sports, or other organized activities are more likely than teens in fewer organized activities to attend religious services without parents more often.
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
'#6 Regional location: Teens living in the South and Midwest are more likely than those living in the Northeast to attend religious services without parents more often.
#5 Religious tradition: Teens in the conservative and black Protestant traditions are more likely than teens in mainline Protestantism to attend religious services without parents more often; self-identified nonreligious teens are less likely.
6 Youth group participation: Teens who are involved in a religious youth group are more likely than those who are not to attend religious services without parents more often.
#5 Religious youth activities: Teens who have participated in more religious youth activities—such as religious missions teams, summer camps, social service projects, and retreats—are more likely than those who have participated less to attend religious services without parents more often, although it is unclear whether this is a cause or a result of greater attendance.
When teenagers do not have parents with whom to attend religious services, other social factors can nonetheless encourage and discourage their frequency of attendance. One appears to be the sociability and confidence of teens as reflected in their greater popularity at school and involvement in a larger number of organized activities. More popular and active teens appear more ready, willing, and able to attend religious services on their own. Another factor is simply living in the South or Midwest, both regions that supply relatively more religious congregations per capita and reflect greater normative acceptability of religious service attendance. Conservative and black Protestant churches also appear to do a relatively better job of drawing teens to church who are not accompanied by their parents. Finally, more frequent religious service attendance without parents is also significantly associated with greater involvement by teens in religious youth groups and other religious youth activities, although we cannot be sure if these are the causes or effects of more frequent service attendance. Among these variables, the most robust are teens' youth group involvement, experience with religious camps and retreats, and conservative Protestant affiliation.
We pressed this analysis of independently attending teens one step further, narrowing down to only those teens who do attend religious services at least more than once or twice a year and thus have a tie to a specific religious congregation, some characteristics of which they are able to report. Which variables significantly predicted greater religious service attendance for this population of teens who attend without their parents? Involvement in more organized activities, in religious youth groups, and with religious camps and missions trips remain significantly associated with their more frequent service attendance. The presence of any designated youth minister in the teen's congregation is also statistically associated with increased teen attendance without parents. However, a closer analysis shows that only the presence of a
SOUL SEARCHING
full-time youth minister in the congregation, compared to no designated youth minister at all, significantly increases these teens' attendance. Congregations with only volunteer and part-time youth ministers are not significantly different from those with no designated youth minister in increasing the attendance of teens who do not attend with their parents, when other variables are controlled for. Thus, we see that religious service attendance of independent youth is significantly increased by key institutional factors, particularly by religious youth groups led by full-time youth ministers who can create the kind of relationships and programs that draw youth who do not otherwise have parental support to attend into greater attendance at religious congregations.
Alyssa's Spiritual Mother and Father The importance of dedicated youth ministers in the lives of teens lacking parental support in faith as evident in the survey analysis above is illustrated in the story of Alyssa, a 15-year-old white girl we interviewed in Milwaukee,
Wisconsin, the only member of her family who regularly attends church.
Alyssa's mother died of cancer when she was 6, and she and her three siblings have been raised by their father in an urban, blue-collar neighborhood. When
Alyssa's mother died, her father stopped attending church: "I think it was a big push when my mom was with it too and it was easier to go along because he had a companion, but I guess now he feels like it's a waste of time. But I still go and I love it." Alyssa says that at her church she enjoys what she calls her "spiritual mother and father":
It's like real parents, except in a different way. My real dad supports me with money and stuff like that, but these are parents that you can actually talk to like friends. They are very helpful, like when I can't go to my dad on certain things 'cause he won't understand it, I go to them. They're very understanding, but at the same time, if you know better and still do something, they'll tell you what's wrong with that and rebuke you. It's very helpful just to have someone like that around. My spiritual mother, she's very motivated and determined for everything, she'll just go after what she wants, and it's always good things she wants so it's not like a bad motivation. She's just a woman of God, she's really cool. Ever since [we met] she's just been counseling me.
Alyssa says her sister brought her to this church's youth group when she was getting "into drugs and stuff." She says her life without the youth group would be very different because she would probably still be doing drugs.
What does she enjoy about her youth group? "Friendships, a lot of friendships, a lot of people who care about you, not because of who you are but they just care about you automatically. It's like so cool." Alyssa also has other support beyond her family for her life and faith. About the teachers at her
Christian school, for example, she says, "I love them all. A lot of them have been through a lot in their life and now they're Christians so they tell us
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
testimonies and it's helpful just to hear that they went through something [hard], too, you know? One teacher, she's been really like a mother-figure, too." In addition, Alyssa says that many of her good friends also attend her church and that they talk about faith matters a lot, because she explains, "we have this thing at my church called 'accountability partners.' "
We would expect Alyssa's father's lack of interest in religion and the untimely death of her mother, which Alyssa says caused much grief and trouble in her own life—anger, rebellion, drug abuse, and early sexual activity with many partners—to work against Alyssa's religious faith. Yet it appears that a set of important and densely connected social ties, at the center of which stand her youth group leaders, has come in her middle teenage years to provide her with emotional support and relational connections to a serious, committed life of faith.
CONCLUSION
Spiritual seekers, the religiously disengaged, and the religiously devoted— three interesting and religiously important types of American teenagers. What have we learned about who these various types of teens are and what factors associate with their religious identities and choices? There is much that might be said, but at the very least the following observations seem to stand out:
6 The majority of American teenagers appear to espouse rather inclusive, pluralistic, and individualistic views about religious truth, identity boundaries, and need for religious congregation. A significant minority of U.S. teens do hold fairly particularistic attitudes on these matters, but most tend in their attitudes to be fairly liberal, relativistic, and open to differences among religious types. When it comes to their thinking about what is legitimate for other people, most affirm pluralism, religious inclusivity, and individual authority. This is true for notable percentages of teens even in America's more conservative and strict religious traditions.
5 Very few American teenagers, however, appear themselves to be active spiritual seekers who think of themselves as spiritual but not religious and actually incorporate spiritual practices of other faiths into their own lives.
We estimate their number to be about 2 to 3 percent of all U.S. 13to 17year-olds. Thus, while most U.S. teens hold the attitude that other people should be free to mix and match religious traditions and spiritual practices, almost none of them are actually interested in doing that themselves. Most appear content, rather, to identify with and practice only one religious faith.
#6 Parents of teenagers appear to play an important role in the character of their children's religious lives. In the immediacy of parenting teenagers, parents may feel a loss of control and influence over their teens, but nationally representative statistics show that the religious practices and commitments of parents remain an important influence on the religious practices and com-
SOUL SEARCHING
mitments of their teenage children. Family socialization generally seems to work when it comes to teenagers' religious faith and practice. Furthermore, the quality of relationships that parents build with their teenagers and their own choices about marriage relationships, education, and occupations—insofar as they have choices in these areas—also create family contexts that again form the outcome of their teenagers' religious and spiritual lives.
5 Teenagers' friendships seem related to their religious lives in important, if not always unexpected, ways. Greater and lesser adolescent religiosity appears to be reflected in the composition of friendship groups: the more religiously serious and involved a teen is, unsurprisingly, the more their good friends also seem to be. Moreover, parents of less religious U.S. teenagers are more likely to say that their teens' friends are a negative influence on them, while parents of religiously devoted teens think their teens' friends are a positive influence. We do not know how much of this is the cause or effect of more and less teen religiosity or even a reflection of problematic parent-teen relationships. But we can say that the character of American teenage religion and spirituality has a definite social component or correlation that varies with levels of teen religiosity.
5 American adolescent religion and spirituality appear to be significantly related to a larger propensity to get involved in a broader range of other organized social activities. U.S. teens who are more religiously serious and active are also more likely to be involved in a larger number of other programs, clubs, hobby groups, sports, or other organized activities; less religiously active teens tend to be involved in fewer. This may reflect differences in personality types, general family orientations toward social involvements, the encouragement and facilitation of religious organizations to get involved in other groups, or some other factor; our data are not able to determine this. But U.S. adolescent religiousness clearly does seem related to a positive propensity toward broader social involvements.
#5 Certain religious traditions in the United States appear more or less capable of eliciting serious, multifaceted religious devotion in their teenagers.
Conservative Protestantism and Mormonism seem especially likely and Catholicism appears particularly unlikely to produce highly religiously devoted teenagers (all compared to mainline Protestantism).
6 Very many religiously disengaged American teenagers appear to be religiously disconnected for what seem to be rather vague or unremarkable reasons. Many cannot explain their disengagement from religion; many seem simply to have drifted. Only a minority of them report definite skepticism, disbelief, or dislike of religion as explanations for their personal religious disengagement. In other words, many religiously disengaged U.S. teens may in fact have fairly low levels of commitment to and investment in their reli-
SPIRITUAL SEEKERS AND RELIGIOUSLY DEVOTED TEENS
gious disengagement, and so may be more susceptible to religious engagement by proactive religious agents than may be commonly supposed.
6 In the absence of parental encouragement by example to attend religious services, religious congregations that offer teenagers organized youth groups—particularly those with full-time, paid, adult youth group leaders— seem to make a significant difference in attracting teens to attend congregational religious services. Well-developed, congregational-based youth groups with established youth leaders likely provide teens who lack active parental support appealing doorways into and relational ties encouraging greater religious participation in the life of religious congregations.
As was true of the conclusions of the previous chapter, these observations do not exhaust the details of what we have learned in this chapter's analysis.
Nor do they come close to describing all there is to know about American teenage spiritual seekers, nonreligious teens, nonattending teens, and highly religiously devoted teens. There is much room for further research on these types of U.S. adolescents. But this chapter's analysis is a start, we believe, that can begin to fill out our picture of key aspects of the religious and spiritual lives of American teens. What is clear, among other things, is that adolescent religiosity is socially patterned. How religiously serious and involved American teenagers are is not merely randomly or individually determined, but reflects the influence of particular social locations and especially key social relationships and organizations. Parents, friends, youth organizations, religious congregations, and youth group leaders all appear to have significant influence on the shape and extent of American teenagers' religious and spiritual lives.
Beneath our survey measures of factors such as religious service attendance, religious devotion, spiritual seeking, and the like, lay multiple layers of complicated religious and spiritual meanings, perceptions, experiences, assumptions, and feelings that require different research methods to adequately access and interpret. To make better sense of our NSYR survey statistics and findings, therefore, we followed up a subsample of our survey respondents with in-depth, personal interviews conducted in the cities and towns around the country where they actually live. Returning somewhat to and greatly expanding on the method and tone of chapter 1—where we pondered the stories of the two Baptist girls, Joy and Kristen—the next chapter explores in much greater detail what religious faith and spiritual life looks, sounds, and feels like from the perspective and in the words of these teenagers themselves. The systematic, interpretive analysis of hundreds of teen interviews in the following chapter should add greater depth to, more complex meaning around, and clearer understanding of the significance of the survey findings examined in this and the previous chapter. In what follows, the overall picture painted so far becomes more complicated and, from the perspective of many religious traditions, probably more troubling, as the voices of teens explain just what they mean by God, faith, and religion.
