Chapter 7 of 13

On Catholic Teens

On Catholic Teens

On Catholic Teens T WAS AN AMAZING scene. There I sat among 23,000 exuberant Catholic teenagers mobbing the entire field floor and first seating level of the Houston Texans' Reliant Stadium.! This mass of rollicking Catholic teens, gathered from all over the United States in November 2003 for the biannual

National Federation of Catholic Youth Ministry's National Catholic Youth Conference, was for four days alternately bouncing to the throb of Christian hip-hop bands, fervently praying the Hail Mary and Our Father, wildly cheering the testimonies and messages of young and old Catholic speakers, and reverently celebrating the Eucharist en masse. These kids, by all appearances, were splendidly proud to be Catholic. They wore T-shirts emblazoned with in-your-face Catholic slogans, creeds, and Bible verses. They thunderously applauded the attending bishops and priests and screamed adoration for the Pope whenever his name was mentioned. Groups from parishes and dioceses roved about the stadium and convention grounds in packs, waving parish banners and bellowing Catholic cheers and chants. The throng's palpable energy was generated by this congregation of many thousands shouting, hugging, swaying, singing, and sharing together in unity—a real religious collective effervescence at work, a massive sacred experience, a distinctively Catholic spectacle that was jubilant, intense, exhausting, inspiring.

Many of the teens attending told me they had come mostly to have fun at this major event about which they had heard so much. But it was also clear that most came from lives and families much involved in their parishes

SOUL SEARCHING

and well grounded in Catholic identity. More obvious to me was how powerfully drawn many of them were to the conference's vision of practicing faith more seriously and consistently, living Catholic lives of distinctive integrity, being active members of a Church that is a force for love and justice in the world. These teens listened intently to speakers challenging them to devote their lives to Christian peacemaking and the work of justice, for instance, visibly moved by the idea that they could actually make a difference in the world. In one breakout session offering three workshop options, 14,000 teens packed to standing-room-only a workshop on "Romance without Regret" led by two dynamic Catholic youth speakers teaching the sacredness of bodily intimacy, sexual abstinence before marriage, and full commitment to Catholic moral teachings. The workshop message was veritably countercultural, yet the youth in attendance were captivated. They received the message, it seemed to me, not as oppressive traditional moralizing but as a breath of fresh air, a radical challenge. Many of the girls seemed exhilarated by the idea that they might actually take charge of their romantic relationships and may not have to barter their bodies simply to get boys' attention. Many of the boys in attendance seemed compelled by the evidently novel idea of living lives of romantic and sexual purity, integrity, and self-discipline. Afterward,

I wandered to an adjacent, sprawling convention hall jammed with teens gallivanting among hundreds of booths featuring the goods of Catholic colleges, Catholic musicians, Catholic religious orders, Catholic service ministries, Catholic clothing manufacturers, Catholic seminaries, Catholic publishers, Catholic radio and television programs, Catholic religious devotional objects, Catholic videos and cassette series, and other vendors of Catholic jewelry, stuffed animals, home decor, lawn ornaments, fashion accessories, novelties, church supplies, gifts, and other Catholic kitsch that I had no idea even existed. The sheer massiveness of the Catholic products and opportunities displayed in that convention hall was extraordinary.

What I observed at this conference might suggest that Catholic teenagers in the United States are doing quite well religiously, that Catholic youth are generally committed, enthusiastic, and serious about their faith and Church.

But such a conclusion would be mistaken. There are, of course, U.S. Catholic teenagers who are very religiously engaged, but they are not typical. In our study, Catholic teenagers, who represent nearly one-quarter of all U.S. teens, stand out among the U.S. Christian teenagers as consistently scoring lower on most measures of religiosity. Scanning many of the tables in chapter 2, for example, reveals Catholic youth scoring 5 to 25 percentage points lower than their conservative, mainline, and black Protestant peers on many of a variety of religious beliefs, practices, experiences, commitments, and evaluations. Perhaps more important for Catholics, our findings regarding Catholic teenagers show many of them to be living far outside of official Church norms defining true Catholic faithfulness."

The question is Why? Why do U.S. Catholic teenagers as a whole seem so less religiously engaged than their teenage counterparts in other U.S. Christian traditions? What might help explain the apparent overall higher levels

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

LOS of religious laxity among Catholic teenagers compared both to other U.S.

Christian teenagers and authoritative Catholic norms of faithfulness? This chapter explores possible answers to these questions. We begin by regarding the stories of three Catholic teens whom we interviewed to see some of the specific instances of teenage cases behind our statistical findings. We then examine alternative explanations for this observed relative religious laxity, considering empirical evidence that helps adjudicate among alternative explanations.

THREE CATHOLIC TEENS ON TWO COASTS

A share of U.S. Catholic teenagers are religiously and spiritually very serious, informed, and committed. In the course of conducting our 267 NSYR personal interviews with various kinds of teens living in 45 states, we did come across some white, black, and Hispanic Catholic teens who loved God and the Church, who understood and could talk about what Catholics are supposed to believe, who were involved in the ongoing life of their parishes, and who sincerely sought to live their lives as faithful Catholic believers. But they were the definite minority among the Catholic teenagers we interviewed. The majority instead tended to be rather religiously and spiritually indifferent, uninformed, and disengaged. To help convey a concrete sense of what this looks like in specific teenagers, we recount here the stories of three Catholic teenagers we interviewed from Connecticut and California: a 15-year-old white girl named Heather from Connecticut; a 17-year-old white boy, John, also from Connecticut; and a 16-year-old Hispanic boy, Alano, from Southern California. We do not present them as representative of all Catholic teens' but as specific cases of what the lives of religiously indifferent and permissive

Catholic teens can look, feel, and sound like.

Heather I met Heather and her mother at a funky coffee shop on the main commercial street of an old town neighborhood at a time scheduled between Heather's school and a babysitting job. There seemed to be some tension between Heather and her mother when they arrived, but both were friendly enough to me. Mom hung around the coffee shop for a while, to keep an eye on me, it seemed, so Heather and I set up at a wobbly table far off in a corner, laughing over trying not to spill our drinks. Thin, blonde, with blue eyes and a smile full of braces, Heather is the oldest of four siblings in what seems to be a reasonably happy family. She is a typical kid: a B student in school, does gymnastics, plays softball, and likes hanging out with her friends at the mall, by the pool, or at the movies. She's been going out with a boy for two weeks.

She likes watching reality TV shows. She gets stressed out a lot, but not often depressed. "I'm a good kid," she reports about herself.

Heather had recently gotten into trouble with her parents. Freaked-out friends had called her to come over to the house of a girlfriend who had drunk too much alcohol and had started passing out. It was a day off from

SOUL SEARCHING

school and the girl's parents were not home. Heather rushed over and helped keep her friend conscious by slapping her on the face repeatedly. They all got caught. Heather's parents feel she broke their trust: Since then, Heather reports, her mother has been keeping a much closer eye on her. She thinks her parents are too strict, mostly because she's the oldest and so setting all of the child behavioral precedents. Heather says she feels somewhat close to her father but definitely closer to her mother and more able to talk with her,

" *cause she's a girl." Even so, Heather says that, as a very private person, she maintains some distance from her mother. She does wish they could be closer, but says that "it's kind of like I don't really know how to."

Heather's mother is a practicing Catholic and her father is a not very religiously observant Jew. Grandparents and aunts and uncles on both sides are very religious; they do not live nearby. Heather has been raised Catholic, goes to church every week, and takes CCD classes. Her mother, in fact, is a CCD teacher. The family also observes some Jewish holidays. Heather's mother has encouraged but not forced her in the Catholic faith: "She's always been like, "You can go, I'm not going to force you to be this religion.' She was like, 'We're gonna expose you to Catholic first and if after that you want to decide to be Jewish, fine, that's your decision.' " Heather appreciates that approach: "Nobody should be forced into a religion. I think it's a matter of faith and what you believe." When she was younger, she thought she might become Jewish, but has changed her mind: "I do think there was, like, Jesus or whatever, so I don't think I would ever turn back to Judaism." I asked if she thinks religion has any influence on how people get along in her family.

"T don't think it has anything to do with it," she replied, "other than when we get in fights at church Mom says, 'Come on, knock it off, this is God's house.' " Heather can think of only one nonfamily adult, an ex-nanny she is close to, whom she can turn to in times of real trouble. She has no significant adult relationships at her church. "Not really, like I don't, no, I don't really hang out at church," she says.

Asked whether she thinks of herself as a religious or spiritual person, Heather replies, "I go through the actions but I think the faith is kind of missing. I think I believe it, but a lot of people are like, 'God talked to me,' and I don't think I really ever felt any connection like that or anything." Why not? "Maybe 'cause I'm not really waiting, not really looking for it, 'cause I just don't pay attention or whatever." But none of that bothers or worries her, she says. Who, I ask, is God? What is God like? "Just a big guy up there who just kind of like watches, looks out for you, I guess." Heather tends to view God as more loving and forgiving than demanding and judging, but says God is not particularly involved in her own life. Sometimes she doubts

Catholic beliefs, thinking "this is a bunch of crap that someone just made up, 'cause I haven't really experienced anything [myself], so I'm like, someone probably just made this up." She says she ultimately doesn't really think that is true, however. But "a lot of times when things don't go how I want them to, sometimes I'll be like, "Yeah, whatever, like thanks a lot, like wow, this wouldn't have happened if God was, like, paying attention or what-

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

ever," " I ask Heather to summarize her most basic religious beliefs. She responded: "I admit there is a God and there is a heaven and a hell and, like, if you're a horrible person you're going to hell. But I don't think I'm being judged or whatever, I don't think I'm totally conscious of that. Like, I'm gonna do what I'm gonna do and if God doesn't like it then I really don't think about that. I think God is, like, what I think of him and I'll be, like,

'Oh, help me with this,' but I'm not, like, 'God is watching so I better not do this.' Like, that doesn't really enter my head."

What about Jesus, I ask? Anything about Jesus? "Jesus. I believe in Jesus," she answers. "I don't really get the whole thing about how, well, with the Catholics, how God is Jesus and Jesus is God, I don't understand that."

Anything about the crucifixion or resurrection, I probe? "Like, I believe that and, like, okay, he died and rose, rise or whatever. But that's not something

I really think about unless it's like Easter, that Jesus like rose." Overall, Heather seems unclear on exactly what people in her religion are supposed to believe. "I don't think I've ever really, like, gotten it, like figured it out."

She doesn't refer to her own religious ideas and views as beliefs but as opinions.

Heather says she doesn't like church that much and sometimes falls asleep during services. "I don't think it really does anything," she says. "It's just more one of those actions, like I agree with what they're saying in church but other times I'm like, 'What time is it?' 'cause I wanna go home." She says the homilies and sermons usually do not engage her. "It doesn't really feel [interesting]. I think maybe when I get older it will be different." She is not involved in any church activities besides Sunday Mass and CCD. Her parish does have an active youth group, but she has never been involved, despite her mother's encouragement. "I just don't want to go," she says.

Heather does not read the Bible. As to praying, her mother used to remind her to say her prayers when she was younger but no longer does. "I wouldn't say that I pray regularly, I don't think about it that much, I guess. But if something's bothering me maybe I'll pray. If I'm not sure about something,

I'll ask, 'Help me out on this one.' And sometimes my opinion is, yeah, I kind of got a little help with that." Heather once attended a Christian camp with a Protestant friend; she enjoyed it and says it had a lasting impact on her because her mom said she was nicer when she came home. Heather says she never expresses her religious faith at school. When asked whether the Catholic Church teaches anything about dating relationships, Heather says no. What about sex, I ask, does Catholicism teach anything about sex? "They kind of teach the whole no-sex-before-marriage thing, but I don't know," she answered, "even though that's one of the main things they stress, I don't think the Church has that much of an impact on what I think about that. I know it teaches that—and I'm Catholic and know I probably shouldn't—but I just don't think I pay much attention to it. I more just ignore it than anything else." So what does Heather, who has not yet been physically involved with anyone, believe about when or under what conditions it is appropriate to have sex?

SOUL SEARCHING

I don't know. If you're comfortable and you really want to do it, I don't think there are, like, any lines. I don't think I'm ready for anything like that. I still hear in my head "Don't do that," like maybe that's from my parents or from the Church, I don't really know. But I think a lot has to do with how comfortable you are with the person, how much you trust them and stuff, I guess. And be careful, with like

STDs and pregnancy. I don't think it necessarily has to be no sex until marriage. I think that's good and nice, but maybe other times, if you want to and really feel like that for a person, you want to take it to the next level, then go ahead and do it.

Heather says that teens are under a lot of pressure to experiment with sex, to drink, and to cheat in-school. She has consumed alcohol some but not to the point of getting drunk. She tried marijuana once but didn't like it.

Heather cheats in school some, feeling bad about it but feeling even more pressure to get good grades to get into college. She says she also lies to her parents on occasion about things she is doing when she thinks they are being overprotective. "They need to just, like, trust me and know that I'm not going to kill myself," she insists. She says she does believe in moral rights and wrongs, she is no relativist. But her views of morality mostly seem oriented around not getting caught for doing wrong things. About drinking alcohol, for example, she recalls, "The first time I did it, I was a wreck, like paranoid

[about getting caught], but other times when I think I won't get caught it's taken a lot of pressure off, so a lot depends on if I think I'm gonna get caught." Like very many U.S. teenagers, Heather cannot explain what it is that makes things right and wrong beyond immediate consequences. "I'm trying to think!" she laughs. "I don't really think about this stuff too much!

I don't know, I don't really know where morality. comes from." She reports that more bad behaviors go on among teenagers, such as keg parties among eighth-graders, she says, than many parents and other adults probably want to know about. Adults, she says, "realize it, but I think a lot of times they just look the other way, they don't acknowledge it. A lot of times they just turn their heads and they kind of like put up a wall, like they don't want to get involved, don't want to have to deal with it." To illustrate, she cites an example of a male friend of hers who has been smoking pot regularly, was grounded by his mother when she first found out, but who recently got caught again and is not being punished at all. "And his dad doesn't even know yet," she reports. "His mom doesn't tell his dad, 'cause they don't like each other, like, they sleep in separate bedrooms. I really don't know why they're not divorced."

It's time for Heather to get to her babysitting job. I close by asking what she thinks she will be like religiously when she is 25 or 30 years old. She replies, "I think like, maybe I'll want to go to church by myself. Maybe, yeah. Kind of depending on what happens in that, I think I probably will,

'cause that's how I grew up, that's just like kinda routine. But," she adds to close, "maybe by then it won't be routine anymore." Whatever happens in

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

Heather's future, I think, it's clear that, despite regularly attending Mass and CCD, the Catholic Church seems to have made only a rather small dent in her believing and thinking. There are small signs here that she is hungering, exploring, and may grasp a rudimentary sense of Catholic faith. But she is hardly what the Catholic Church hopes for and expects of its faithful.

John I interviewed John on a cold afternoon in the public library study room of an older, affluent suburban neighborhood. John had been hard to get in touch with to set up the interview, but, with his mother's help, I finally managed to arrange to meet him after school at the library. I arrived early and staked out the small, upstairs study room in which to conduct the interview, spreading my jacket, bag, and papers around the table and chairs to make clear the room was occupied. Anxious that my digital recording equipment might get lifted, I returned to the downstairs lobby to meet my interviewee. John finally arrived, late. He drove a car and, because his parents work, came to the interview by himself. We climbed the broadly winding stairs to the study room. John, a tall and chubby guy with short brown hair and green eyes, seemed a little nervous and fidgety as he signed his consent forms and we began.

John's parents divorced when he was very young. His mother is remarried to a policeman, whom she lived with for six years before marrying and who now seems to have a lot of free time that he spends hanging around the house.

John's mother, by contrast, spends most of her waking hours at her job. John says that he often argues with his mother, but that they are somewhat close and get along okay. About his stepfather, John says, "We're not close at all, he's the type you can't be close to, he puts up a big barricade. I've tried talking to him but he didn't respond very well, was kind of a dick. I don't think he likes me." John says his mother and stepfather do not communicate with each other very much. The parent John feels closest to is his biological father, a nominal Protestant whom he characterizes as irresponsible and lazy, and whom he visits every other weekend. Other than that, John has no significant adult relationships with relatives, teachers, or people at church. Regarding the latter, he says, "Ah, no, our church, it's not, we're not involved anymore, really we just go [to Mass]." John says he does not particularly admire anyone that he can think of.

John calls himself "a pretty boring person, just sitting at home after school all day." He has no job or girlfriend, feels in limbo as a senior in high school, and spends lots of time playing video games, hanging out with friends, and sleeping. "Now is not, you know, a peak time in life," he says. "Hopefully it'll improve. I haven't really been too successful with, you know, girls this year. I do need to muscle up a bit in the gym, with summer coming up and the beach, to be able to take off my shirt and still be able to pick up the chicks." He says he has no idea what the purpose of life is, what humans are doing on earth. No clue. "There's not really much substance to my life right now and if I think about it too much I'm gonna be miserable. I don't do

SOUL SEARCHING

anything, you know. I want my life to go somewhere but ''m also not the type of kid to beat himself up about it. You don't think about it, you just sit in front of the TV and chill and do your own thing instead of being miserable.

I just don't really let myself feel sad and depressed. When I have problems, I just think about something else."

In general, John observes, "teenagers today are a lot more emotionally fragile, too much pressure is put on them to succeed nowadays. Everyone has these feelings, everyone's depressed. Teenagers right now, like, no matter what, sometimes you're always gonna be bummin' about something. You know, you have to wake up at 6:30 and get to school, all these kids walking around like zombies, asleep, everyone's sleep-deprived." What most excites

John is skiing, because of how fast he can fly down the mountain. He also likes bowling and driving to Boston to watch Red Sox games, but without a job he does not have the money now to afford those. So he spends time at home trying to ignore his stepfather and arguing with his mother when she comes home from work. "They give me a hard time about stuff, make doing everything a pain in the ass." I ask for an example. He says that recently he and friends were caught smoking pot in a parking lot and arrested. "Not a big deal, you know," he assures me. "I'm not a get-into-trouble kid, I mean

I do stuff which normal public school kids do, but it's not a big deal, I don't make a big deal out of it." How did his parents react to his arrest? "They're assholes. Yeah, they suck," he replies laughing. "When I got arrested my mom took my car for a month and it's just like, 'Come on, I didn't do anything that bad. I got caught, I won't do it again.' But they give me a hard time."

Normally, however, "I can get by doing what I want to do. It's rare that I have to suffer a couple of consequences severe enough that it's any big deal."

John is looking forward to going away to college. "When I get into college it's just gonna stop, I can kick back, Mom's not gonna give me a hard time about grades. Things here just suck, my senior class sucks. Last year's was good, next year's will be better. Whatever, it's no big deal, ''m not really sweating it." That's what he says. In fact, throughout the interview he continued to act nervous and fidgety, not at ease.

John's mother and stepfather are Catholics. John also identifies himself as Catholic but says he does not think of himself as a religious or spiritual person. "It's just something that hasn't come into play with me yet. I think probably it will sometime but not now, but after I have a better understanding of the way things work, I'll get more religious and spiritual. I don't question why about most stuff, but when I get older I'll do that a lot more than I do now." He attends church about every two to three weeks. "We don't go to Mass every week, but I mean, we're pretty every-week people. Except the weekends that I'm with my dad." John says he believes in God. "I do, but that's a whole 'nuther part of me which really doesn't get visited much, I don't really like to think about it that much, like I told you." What does

John envision God to be like? "I think there's something else out there and at some point in my life I'll think about that a lot more but, as it is, you know, I'm Catholic and I don't really necessarily have to think about it, don't

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

have to question it, cause you know it works, I mean Jesus and it all makes sense to me, it works just fine for me." I ask John what he means by the phrase "I'm Catholic" in this context. "Just, you know, everything which has been told to me. Jesus came down, did all these things, you know, he's the one, you can look up on that picture up there on the wall of him and follow, you know, it makes sense to me, I don't question it. I accept it and I don't feel the need to ask why. I just believe everything which they say at church,

I don't disagree with any of it. And I hope that there's something after [death].

That's pretty much all. I mean, I don't intentionally wrong anybody, I try to be nice and think about them and hopefully that's good enough." I press

John on his view of God. "I don't think he's demanding at all," he elaborates.

"I think most people are good and forgiving and I think, he's okay, I like God." I ask if God has any expectations of him. "All I know is," he answers,

"I'm not angry at God, everything's okay, I'm not pissed off at anyone. Hopefully that's good enough for me right now." John says he has never had any kind of religious experience. When I ask what he thinks about angels, demons, and life after death, he simply says, "Nothing. I just hope it's okay, that I don't have to go to hell. I hope it doesn't just end, I hope I'm reincarnated as someone else." So then, I ask, does he believe there is a punishment after death for bad people? "No, I don't think bad people are really that bad," he replies. What about people like Hitler, I ask? "I knew you'd bring up Hitler," he exclaims, laughing, "I knew it. I mean, I'm not a big fan of Hitler, in any way, shape, or form. But probably [he] thought he was being a good guy, you know."

John engages in no religious practices other than attending Mass. He doesn't pray, read the Bible, rest on Sundays, or anything else. "But," he notes, "I do like the Bible, I like the stories in it." He also says religion plays no role in his family's relationships and it is a taboo topic at school. "No, it can't [play a role] at school, teachers wouldn't touch it with a ten-foot stick.

Religion? Our school? Half of my school is Jewish so you gotta be sensitive to it, it's just such a sensitive topic. A teacher's not gonna say 'Merry Christmas,' you can't even say that. You gotta be neutral." John is not involved in his parish's youth group and has never been involved in any religious retreat, missions trip, or summer camp. "I'd never go on one of those, no matter how religious I might be. It's all just people trying to feel secure about their religious beliefs. That's one thing I'd never do." He says if it were up to him he would be an "E and C Christian"—one that attends only on Easter and Christmas. How good a job has John's church been at teaching him about his religious faith? "It's been okay, I mean, CCD was just a chance to clown around on Sundays after church. I didn't like it, you couldn't like it, it sucked." But when I ask specifically about his feelings about the Catholic

Church, he grows a bit defensive on its behalf:

I think it's gotten kind of a bum rap. On an everyday basis, you're not going to run into a bad priest. Most priests are good guys, wellintentioned. [The priest abuse scandal] is too bad, really too bad that

SOUL SEARCHING

they're getting such a hard time about this. I mean, I'm not a big fan of the people sitting around in Rome, that's just people milking it in the Vatican. But the priests in church, they get shipped around. My priest is kind of new, but I've talked to him a few times. He seems like a good guy. All priests are pretty good guys. They just do what they believe and give up a lot for it. There's nothing wrong with priests, I don't have anything against them.

And what does he think of other religions, like Buddhism and Hinduism? "I think they're all right, you know, all well intentioned. I kind of like Christianity, it seems the most, not reasonable, but practical. I think Voodoo is fake.

I don't like Judaism and I don't like Muslim. Nothing against the people, just as religions. Like if you were given a list of all the beliefs and asked to point to the one you want, I'd point to Christianity every time."

I ask John if he is involved in any volunteering or community service.

"Oh, speaking of community service," he replies, "I should be talking to a woman downstairs about, I have to do 20 hours a week for probation [since getting arrested], sorting books." I express curiosity. He laughs, "Well, no,

Ill scheme the hours, I'll sneak out, I know the back door here, my buddy did it. I'll do one hour for them and then take off." I try to engage John in a discussion about morality, but with some difficulty. "It's not a big deal," he repeats, "most stuff's not that big a deal. I'm not really a big fan of pondering the meaning of life, I don't see the point." It comes out, however, that he believes that morality is relative and that people only act morally in order to feel good. About himself, he reports, "I think I'm a pretty honest person. I don't cheat people, don't lie, don't deceive people, don't trick people, I'm up-front." He says he does not feel guilty about anything.

I notice that John's agitated fidgeting is getting worse. He is acting slightly odd—jittery, distracted, perturbed, a bit frenetic, not about the interview meeting per se, it seems to me, but rather about the subjects we are talking about. The thought enters my mind that maybe John is on the edge of some kind of minor emotional crackup, and I find myself hoping he does not have a breakdown during our interview.

We get into some moral specifics. John says he does not think it is wrong to cheat on tests or assignments at school. "No! When you cheat from someone, you're not taking away from them. It's high school, it's not that important, that's why. That's not a big deal at all, if it's some stupid math test, senior year, when you're not gonna take math ever again, not gonna use the stuff, who cares about if you look over and write down their answer?" He also does not think it wrong to lie to parents. "Everyone does it," he says.

"If you lie too much then that's a problem, because what are you having to lie so much about? But if you don't lie at all and follow them in every wish,

I think the people who don't lie to their parents, you know, I think there's also a problem. People have to be balanced, you gotta do a little bit of everything." He says he drinks alcohol and does drugs. "Yeah, sure, why not?

Yeah. All of them. Everything in moderation." He started in his sophomore

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

year. He explains that because he is big, he can drink two six-packs and not get sick. "It takes a lot to get me puking." Still, he comments, he does not drink and drive: "I don't want that on my record." In fact, getting caught seems to be John's key moral concern here. "I just like to have a good time with friends, have a few beers, some laughs, nothing wrong with that, smoke a nice big fattie every now and then. I'm careful, but not like from a safety point of view, it's for not-getting-caught point of view. Yeah, I mean, which might be wrong." John says that about 75 or 80 percent of students in his school drink alcohol and smoke pot. He says there is no peer pressure to drink and smoke, mostly because everyone already does it. "I mean, I don't really find any people who don't do it. Most people smoke all the time, you know, it's always there." He says he probably would do more of other, harder drugs, but doesn't have the money to afford them. He also reports that it is common for teens in his and nearby towns to hold parties when parents are away traveling, where there is a lot of alcohol, music, and some sex upstairs; eventually the neighbors call the police and the parties get broken up. John says he's looking forward to parties at college.

In the meantime, he is bummed out because, in his words, "I haven't gotten any girls recently. I'd be lying to you if I said I don't want, you know, some pussy." John thinks it is fine for teenagers to have sex—"I like sex, it's good, nothing against it"—as long as it does not create stress or guilt. He confesses, "I don't like feeling guilty. I take every possible, I'll go to any ends not to feel guilty." Teens have got to be able to handle sex mentally, he then explains, need to use birth control, and need to not hurt each other's feelings.

"Sex is no different from other things: just don't be an asshole and don't make people feel bad." He says boys are motivated to have sex partly for the feeling of "achievement," but he also expresses that he thinks it is wrong for boys to take sexual advantage of drunk girls. He says he has no idea what motivates girls to have sex. John himself had a lot of sex with different girlfriends and some girls he met at parties in eleventh grade, but he has not scored with any girls in his senior year. He figures not much more will happen till he gets to college, because he's not feeling in a very outgoing mood lately.

Do his parents know he was having sex? "Well, if you went up to my dad,"

John ventures, "and asked him if he thought I was having sex, he'd probably be like, "Yeah, I hope so.' " Does he think his Catholic religion teaches any sexual morality? "I think it's so old," he responds, "any sort of rules about sex in Christianity made up 200 years ago were pretty much so that people didn't pop out like 20 babies. They were to keep 14-year-olds from having babies 'cause they didn't have condoms back then, not some sort of moral thing. Meaning, if I have sex with a condom when I'm 17, I'm not going to hell." What does he think about pornography? "It's not bad, nothing wrong with it. I don't go looking up porn on the Internet or anything, that's cheap.

I've just gone to a couple shops and bought some DVDs, bought a couple online too, so I have a nice little selection of DVDs." He says his mom suspects he watches porn but he plays dumb and nothing has come of it. "It just relaxes me," he explains, "it's a nice relaxing way to spend the afternoon.

SOUL SEARCHING

I just get out of school, go home, close the bedroom door, pop on a porno, fall asleep, wake up, it's still on. Nothing wrong with that. When I get some more money I'll get some more, you know, keep up the variety."

After college, John looks forward to being successful, having money and a nice life. He thinks he will want to have a string of girlfriends, then get married. "Just a nice, good-looking wife, you know, a few kids, that type of thing. Just a normal American dream type of thing." Before getting married, however, he suspects he'll live with some romantic partners. "Yeah, nothing wrong with waking up to a nice honey next to me." He expects to raise his kids in the Catholic Church and looks forward to his children getting married in the Church. What will he himself be like religiously when he is 25 or 30 years old? "I don't know. No clue. Hopefully when I'm like 50 or 60 I'll be a little bit better than I am now. Then I'll be going to church a little bit more actively, one of the guys who teaches CCD or, you know, that type of thing."

Meanwhile, he says, he doesn't know if he'll get more involved in church or not. "Maybe, we'll see, we'll see."

Alano Alano pulled up to the public library for his interview in his 1967 Ford Mustang, wearing black shorts, white T-shirt, baseball shoes, and a black

Air Jordan baseball hat. Alano lives with his mother, father, and two younger sisters in a basic Southern California bungalow located in a primarily Hispanic working-class suburb near Los Angeles. In the parking slot, Alano's car engine sputters and dies. It won't restart. We agree to work on a jump-start after the interview.

Alano is a really nice guy who loves his family, works hard in school, plays and coaches city league baseball, and is infatuated with his girlfriend, whom he has been dating for four months. He is earning A's and B's in school, is hoping to attend a good college and become a successful civil engineer. He tries to only hang out with friends who are also serious about school. Besides baseball, he enjoys bowling and roller skating. Having earlier suffered watching his grandfather mistreat his grandmother when he got drunk, Alano studiously avoids alcohol and drugs. He believes they are immoral. He seems to get along well with his parents, although, if he could change anything, he wishes his father would open up more. "I want him to talk about what he feels to me, to have a close relationship with my dad and when I have a question I want an answer."

For Alano, family is much more central to life than for most of the white teenagers we interviewed. When asked who he most admires, for instance, he says, "My dad, in a sense my family, probably my dad." Why? "Because he'll go out and work the whole day for the family, just give up his whole life for us. He takes care of us and never has, never, never has any regrets or complaints, just does it." When asked how he decides between right and wrong in different situations, Alano replies, "I think about what my parents would think, what choice they would want me to make." He knows right and wrong, he says, from "just my parents and my conscience." Besides being

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

a successful engineer, Alano's purpose in life, he says, is to "raise a family and teach them right so they can go on and do the same." Later in the interview, he says he prays to God no more than a few times a month, but when he does pray, it is "to be happy, for my family to be happy, just to continue the way things are. It would be like, 'Thank you for my family and, dear God, please keep my family safe.' " This is very much in keeping with sociological research on the centrality of family in Hispanic American culture.

Very few white teenagers we interviewed talked this warmly about their families.

When it comes to religion, Alano is very positive about Catholic faith, though not practicing it much. His family is "Catholic, but," he says, "we don't go to church. I could definitely improve on that. I know the following behind it and the stories but I don't go to church enough to learn. I want to but I just don't." Alano did attend church regularly until his First Communion at age 10, but his family stopped attending a month after that. He says that his religious beliefs do mean a lot to him. "That's why I would like to go more, I would like to learn more." He does not know any adults in his church. "No, I haven't been there enough to develop relationships." He says he knows that he could become closer to God, whom he describes as "a spirit looking over everything, he can look over everything but you can have a direct relationship with him also." He contends that God is more loving and forgiving than judging, is both personal and impersonal, but more removed from life than active in it. "I don't think he's active, I just think he's looking over everything." Alano summarizes his own religious beliefs this way: "That God does exist and that he's looking on all of us. All of us." Alano also believes in heaven and hell, the latter in which bad people are punished after they die. All of this, he says, he learned from his family.

As to religious practices, Alano says that "prayer is hoping for good in your life and making the good decisions so that those things will come true, so God will help you out." He reports that he has read the Bible in his life but does not now. "Nu-uh, I don't know enough about it to read it. I would want to read it, I just don't." Although he does not attend church, he says that Sunday is a holy day on which he tries to rest and reflect. "I know I should be in church but I just sit back and think. It makes me grateful for the things I have, like that my family is safe. And I think about what actions

I could do for God to help me still." A stronger faith is, for Alano, "something that I want to do, that I strive for, I just, for some reason I just haven't.

It's something that I'm going to do, it's just that other things take up my time."

Despite not actively practicing his Catholic faith, Alano does think it influences his own moral decision making, such as refusing to drink or do drugs. When asked if he approaches social problems or world events differently because of his faith, he answers, "No. Um, well, religion comes into that a little. If a problem comes up, religion's going to come up sooner or later." He cites abortion as something he opposes because of his faith. His general view is that many religious people do the same bad things that non-

SOUL SEARCHING

religious people do, like drinking, but at least feel sorry for it and try not to drink so much later. Curiously, he says he does not think that religion affects his relationships in his family at all. He also says: being Catholic does not affect his life at school, that most of his classmates are Catholic and that religion as a topic of conversation simply does not come up much. But he does report that he has friends who he knows choose not to have sex before marriage because of their religious beliefs.

Alano thinks religion is generally a good thing that everyone should practice, "but it's by choice, I'm not going to force a person." Religion is valuable, he explains, because of "faith and I guess purity not to sin, to make the right decisions, not to lie about it. Just to know what's really out there and what life is about." It does not matter, however, which religion a person practices; it could be one of many religions. "You could make a case for all of them to be true, it just depends on the individual, the truth in probably every religion." However, he also believes people should accept all of the teachings of whatever religion they choose and not be selective. "I don't agree with that. If you're going to be Catholic you should take in the whole, because if you just take in parts you're just looking for ways to go against it. You have to believe in the whole." Alano also opposes the idea of practicing more than one faith. "You should learn about other religions but not practice both. You should learn to see what you want to follow and then follow that, find one that pertains to you and follow it. You can't pick two and go follow both."

Alano spends a lot of time with his girlfriend—much to his mother's chagrin, one learns in talking with her on the phone while trying to arrange an interview. He is attracted to her because "she's a caring person, her inner beauty I guess, how she treats others." He says she is good to talk to and that she pushes him to do well in school. He thinks a lot of teens date simply to have sex, and observes that lots of his friends have sex for purposes of social status and acceptance. He is against that. "It's wrong if that's all you're looking for in a relationship. But, yeah, if you really get to know a person and it's not just about sex but about having a real relationship, then there's nothing wrong in that, when it's not pressured but something that both want to do because they care about each other." Does he think people should wait to have sex until they are married? "Yeah. But if you find the right person,

I think it could be different." Why does he think that? "It's just, I don't know

[pause], just how I feel." He and his girlfriend are having sex. He has not told his friends and his parents do not know; he does not know how they would react if they found out. Does he think his religion teaches anything in particular about sexual morality? "To wait before you get married." Does he agree with that? "I agree with it," he says, "but I've gone against it." What does he think about that? "It's not that big of an issue," he simply says.

Alano wants someday to get married, but is open to living with a romantic partner before that. "I guess it would depend on the situation. Maybe."

What does he think he will be like religiously when he is 25 or 30 years old? "More involved than I am now. I will attend church." How religiously

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

similar or different will he be then? "The same but just more aware of religion. Because I want to learn more, and I think I will start attending."

Our time is up. We gather our things and head outside to jump-start his car. It doesn't work; we keep trying, but to no avail. Alano's girlfriend, who had cell-phoned him partway through the interview, then shows up in her own car. He assures me that they can get his Mustang started, so I take off.

The same caveat that we have given about interview subjects before applies here. Neither Heather nor John nor Alano are representative of all U.S. Catholic teenagers, either white or Hispanic. They may not even be representative of religiously apathetic Catholic teens. They simply help to illustrate what the lives of some religiously indifferent and permissive U.S. Catholic teens look like. Sociological methods, such as multivariate statistical analyses, often pull apart different factors and variables that they assume compose aspects of people's lives. Recounting the stories of people like Heather, John, and Alano helps us to also see how such factors and variables can fit together into larger, connected wholes.

TOWARD EXPLAINING TEENAGE CATHOLIC RELIGIOUS LAXITY

The relatively lower levels of religiosity among U.S. Catholic teens compared to teenagers in other U.S. Christian traditions asks for explaining. What social factors might help account for these observed differences? The following pages propose and evaluate some possible explanations.

Demographic Differences One possible explanation for relatively lower Catholic teenage religiosity is the existence of simple demographic differences associated with lower religiosity. Catholic teenagers' overall relative religious laxity, in other words, may not reflect their being Catholic per se, but rather other demographic factors known to associate with lower religiosity. Examining differences in table A.12 in Appendix A, we see, for example, that Catholic teenagers tend to be more likely to reside in the Northeast, a generally less-religious region of the country. Perhaps it is something about their greater Northeastern regional location and not Catholicism per se that pulls down Catholic teen religiosity. Catholic teenagers are also much more likely to be Hispanic than other Christian teens, and U.S. Hispanic teens generally are, according to NSYR data, slightly less likely to attend church, for example, than white and black teens. Table A.12 also shows minor differences between Catholic teens and their Protestant counterparts around parental marital status, age, and sex, all of which normally correlate with levels of teen religiosity—although admittedly not in any direction that would consistently explain differences in religiosity. But might these demographic differences together, rather than something about being

Catholic per se, help explain Catholic teenagers' relative religious laxity?

To test this hypothesis, we ran multivariate regression analyses statistically

SOUL SEARCHING

removing the effects of these demographic differences from the negative association of Catholic teens with church attendance, importance of faith, and religious youth group participation, using mainline Protestant teens as the reference group. These regression analyses examined whether the significant negative effect of teens being Catholic on these three religiosity outcomes was diminished or made statistically insignificant when controlling for the effects of possibly related demographic factors. The statistical results show, however, that none of these demographic factors explain away the Catholic factor. That is, the statistically significant negative correlations between U.S. teens being

Catholic and levels of church attendance, importance of faith, and youth group participation compared to mainline Protestant teens are hardly reduced when the possible effects of Northeast regional location, Hispanic race, parental marital status, teen age, and teen sex are removed. The statistical coefficients with demographic controls entered remain nearly the same as without the controls. In other words, even if there were no demographic differences in regional location, race, teen age, and so on, U.S. Catholic teens would still score significantly lower on these religiosity measures. The evidence therefore fails to support a differential demographics hypothesis of lower Catholic teen religiosity. Some other factors must be at work.

Parental Religiosity One of the major themes of this book has been the profound influence, both positive and negative, that parents and other significant adults often exert in the lives of U.S. teenagers. The religion of U.S. teenagers often follows and looks a lot like the religion of their parents.4 Perhaps the relatively lower levels of Catholic teen religiosity simply reflect relatively low levels of Catholic parent religiosity. Perhaps the issue is not U.S. Catholic teen religious practice at all, but overall U.S. Catholic religious practice generally, as engaged and modeled by adults. That Alano's family stopped attending church immediately after his First Communion when he was 10 years old is an example of that. Is there broader evidence for or against this possibility?

As recently as the mid-twentieth century, U.S. Catholic adults attended church at far higher rates than U.S. Protestant adults. But the second half of the twentieth century saw a major decline in Catholic church attendance, particularly among its younger adult members.' By the late twentieth century,

U.S. Catholic adults showed similar if not lower levels of reported church attendance and importance of faith in life than U.S. Protestant adults.® But any such differences between Catholic and Protestant adults in general are not large. What about for the specific population in question, Catholic parents of teenagers? Table 33 shows that, compared to their Protestant peers,

U.S. Catholic parents of teenagers are somewhat less likely than conservative and black (but not mainline) Protestant parents of teens to attend church regularly and are more likely than the same to attend infrequently or never.

U.S. Catholic parents of teenagers are also much less likely than all of their Protestant counterparts to participate in organized activities at church other than regular worship services, such as Bible studies, potluck meals, music

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

practices, and small groups. Catholic parents of teens are less than half as likely as all U.S. parents, including nonreligious parents, to do so weekly or more often, and nearly 10 percent more likely never to do so at all. The U.S.

Catholic parents of teenagers, in other words, are less involved in the community lives of their parishes outside of regular services than are U.S. Protestant parents of teens. Furthermore, table 33 shows that Catholic parents of teenagers are somewhat less likely than their conservative and black (but not mainline) Protestant counterparts to say that their religious faith is very or extremely important in their lives and to be married to a spouse who shares the same religious faith. Altogether, such relatively lower levels of religiosity and parental religious solidarity among U.S. Catholic parents of teenagers could help explain relative lower levels of religiosity among U.S. Catholic teens. But do they?

To answer this question, we again ran multivariate regression analyses removing the possible effects of parental religiosity from the negative correlation of Catholic teens with church attendance, importance of faith, and religious youth group participation, again using mainline Protestant teens as the reference group. These analyses thus examined whether the significant negative effect of teens being Catholic on our three religiosity outcomes was diminished or made statistically insignificant when controlling for the possible effects of lower parental religiosity. The statistical results show that they indeed are. The originally statistically significant differences between Catholic and mainline Protestant teen religious service attendance, for example, are reduced when controlling for parental church attendance, importance of faith, and shared parental religious faith separately in addition to demographics. And that difference is made statistically insignificant when the effects of parental involvement in church beyond regular worship services is removed.

Table 33. Religious Practices of Christian Parents of U.S. Adolescents, Ages 13-17

(Percentages) U.S. Christian Traditions LES: of Parents CP MP BP RC Se cl ae Parental religious service attendance 2-3 times a month or more often

Many times a year or less often

Participates in activities of church other than regular worship services Once a week or more often D8)

Never

Importance of faith shaping major life decisions Very or extremely important nS

P2, Not very important or not important at all

Both parents share same faith (2-parent families) Co,

Both parents share same taith \¢-parent tab Source: National Survey of Youth and Religion, 2002-3.

SOUL SEARCHING

When all four parental religiosity variables are entered into the same regression model, three of the four parental religiosity variables (all except parental importance of faith) remain statistically significantly associated with frequency of teen church attendance, while the coefficient for the Catholic teen variable is reduced by nearly one-third and becomes statistically insignificant.

In plain English, the lower levels of church attendance by U.S. Catholic teens compared to their mainline Protestant peers can be significantly explained by the lower levels of religiosity of their parents. The differences among teens, in other words, disappear when we account for the differences among the parents.'

A similar but less clear-cut pattern emerges for our regression analysis of teen importance of faith. Controlling for the four parental religiosity variables reduces the coefficients for the negative Catholic teen association with importance of faith. And that association is made statistically insignificant when one of the four parent variables tested individually (church activities beyond attendance) is controlled for. In ordinary language, the lower levels of importance of faith reported by U.S. Catholic teens compared to mainline Protestant teens can be explained partly by the lower levels of religiosity of their parents. The religious (Catholic versus mainline Protestant) differences in importance of faith among teens again are reduced and, for one parent religiosity control, disappear when we account for the religious differences among the parents.

The same findings do not emerge, however, from our analysis of teen religious youth group participation. Even when we control for four different parental religiosity variables, U.S. Catholic teenagers remain statistically significantly less likely to participate in a church youth group than mainline

Protestant teens. This is partly because mainline Protestant teens participate in church youth groups at relatively very high rates (see table 14), such that the gap between Catholic and mainline Protestant teenagers is larger for youth group attendance than for church attendance and importance of faith.

This remaining significant Catholic teen difference thus suggests that differences in parental religiosity, though very important in explaining aspects or degrees of relatively lower Catholic teenage religiosity, do not explain all of the differences. There are probably other factors worth considering to answer our larger question.

Parish and Diocesan Institutional Commitment and Infrastructure Another likely explanation for the comparatively lower levels of Catholic teen religiosity is an apparent lower level of institutional commitment and investment of the U.S. Catholic Church to and in youth ministry at the parish and diocesan levels. Simply put, the U.S. Catholic Church appears in its institutional infrastructure to invest fewer resources into youth ministry and education than do many other Christian traditions and denominations in the United States. Take parish-level youth groups, for example. We have already seen in table 14 that while between 81 and 86 percent of Protestant teens belong to church congregations that offer youth group programs, only 67 percent of Catholic youth do.® Table 14 likewise shows that about half the

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

2A, percentage of Catholic youth compared to Protestant youth belong to churches with full-time, paid youth ministers (21 percent Catholic compared to 37-44 percent other Christian).? This may help to explain why only 12 percent of Catholic teens attend youth group once a week or more often, compared to 23-43 percent of other Christian teens (see table 14).

The impression given by these numbers is reinforced by the church evaluations of Catholic parents of teens. According to reports presented in table

22, Catholic parents are much less likely than other types of Christian parents to say that ministry to teenagers is a very important priority in their church congregation (47 percent compared to 56-80 percent, depending on the Protestant tradition). Catholic parents are more likely than other types of Christian parents to say that ministry to teenagers is only a somewhat important priority in their congregations (23 percent compared to 9-14 percent). Similarly, U.S. Catholic parents of teenagers are noticeably less likely than other Christian parents to say that their church has been very or extremely supportive and helpful to them as parents in trying to raise their teens, and are more likely to say that their church has been somewhat or a little supportive of them as parents of teens (see table 22). At the parish and perhaps diocesan level, therefore, the Catholic Church seems to be relatively weak when it comes to devoting attention and resources to its youth and their parents.'° Effective youth ministry and the engagement of teenagers in vibrant lives of faith cannot be manufactured through simple organizational programs. At the same time, churches are social organizations. It is difficult for them to mobilize for successful youth ministry and the Christian education of teens when those are not institutional priorities of dioceses and parishes providing the kind of attention, budgets, training, personnel, publications, and other infrastructural supports needed."

Transformed Catholic Schools and CCD Another piece of this larger puzzle involves understanding the historical transformation of Catholic schools and CCD in the United States. One of the reasons the U.S. Catholic Church may somewhat neglect youth ministry, considered broadly, at least in comparison to other Christian traditions and denominations, may be because Catholic schools and CCD no longer function as well as they had for decades as means by which the Church evangelized, ministered to, and educated its youth. Youth groups as they are popularly known today do not have a strong legacy in the U.S. Catholic Church. Rather,

Catholic schools and CCD have historically been the primary vehicle for Catholic youth ministry and education. Beginning in the nineteenth century, the U.S. Catholic Church mobilized its own schools to maintain control over the formation and training of its young people, as a structural bulwark against the cultural pressures of U.S. public schools, which often sought to acculturate and Protestantize Catholic youth. For many decades, Catholic schools provided a reasonably strong Catholic grounding and education for the Church's youth. Catholic parents, priests, and bishops thus rested assured that their youth were being well socialized and educated as Catholics, taught

SOUL SEARCHING

the doctrines of the Church, and nurtured in their faith. After 1935, thanks to the promotional work of the Vatican's Sacred Congregation of the Council? and the organizational initiatives of Bishop Edwin O'Hara of Great

Falls, Montana, any Catholic students lacking an adequate Catholic school education could otherwise be taught through a parish-based catechetical CCD program.'?

But much of that has changed. Many of today's Catholic schools and CCD programs are very different from those of, say, the 1960s. Various historical forces, beyond the scope of this chapter to elaborate, have profoundly transformed Catholic schools in recent decades. Catholic schools of a previous era, for instance, were normally guided and staffed primarily by priests and nuns educated and dedicated by life calling to distinctively Catholic instruction and pedagogy. But only 5 percent of the staff of today's nearly 8,000

Catholic schools consist of priests, nuns, and religious brothers. And the Catholic theological knowledge and commitments of the 95 percent of today's lay Catholic school teachers—not all of whom are necessarily Catholic themselves—is sometimes quite thin, however solid are their mainstream academic credentials and aptitudes. According to J. Fraser Field, executive officer of the Catholic Educator's Resource Center:

Having received their training in secular universities, most Catholic teachers are poorly equipped to appreciate the positive historical and cultural impact of Catholicism and are therefore generally lacking in the background necessary to share these riches with their students. As a consequence, most Catholic schools ...depend on the same textbooks and other resources as those used in the public schools, and, staffed, for the most part, by graduates of the same universities as the public schools, are, outside of the subject of religious education, teaching almost exactly the same content as the public schools, content that is decidedly impoverished in the rich heritage and meaning of Christian faith and culture."

Changing family demographics have also helped to transform U.S. Catholic schools. Originally founded to serve primarily an immigrant Catholic working class, Catholic schools have increasingly become institutions for affluent Americans. The proportion of well-to-do students in Catholic schools doubled between the early 1970s and the late 1990s, by which time nearly half of all Catholic secondary school students came from the wealthiest quarter of U.S. households.'* There are cases of inner-city Catholic schools for which simply attending to the basic educational, nutritional, and social needs of poor students consumes most of the schools' resources, such that educating students in distinctive Catholic theology, ethics, and identity is an unaffordable luxury. In more typical cases, however, Catholic schools have grown into college prep academies with competitive admissions standards and hefty tuition rates, serving the more privileged of their communities, whether Catholic or not, and more dedicated, by demand of parents, to getting their students admitted to prestigious colleges than to teaching them about the Trinity,

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

sin, the Virgin Mary, the atonement, and faithful Christian living. In related situations, some Catholic schools have developed into regional sports powerhouses, dedicated in recruitment and programming to maintaining their football or basketball prowess, perhaps to the detriment of distinctively Catholic socialization and education. Thus, Pennsylvania State University education sociologist David Baker rightly observes:

Higher social class students and their families are more demanding customers, they are very adept at having schools provide what they want... rigorous academic preparation. As Catholic schools continue to attract and adapt to this kind of a student, priorities at schools change radically. ... Catholic school leadership is compromising an older basic religious mission in favor of intensive academics. ... In short, the old common Catholic school is fast becoming an elite private school in which indoctrination into the faith may be taking a back seat to academic preparation.'® Furthermore, although in 1970 only 2.7 percent of students enrolled in Catholic schools were non-Catholic, by 2003 that number had quadrupled to 13.5 percent—a size reaching a critical mass with the potential to reshape school cultures and faculty and administration perceptions of pluralism, inclusivity, and mission." So, according to David Baker, fewer than half of Catholic high school principals today identify "religious development of the student" as their school's primary mission, a drop to nearly the same percentage of principals who state "academic excellence" as their school's chief objective.

What happened to CCD? Reorganizations of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) in 1975 and 1980 abolished what had been the well-staffed organizational hub of CCD, the National Center of Religious

Education, and reduced and disbursed its education specialist personnel in other departments and programs. Since then, the work of developing and promoting CCD in the Church has been much more fragmented and piecemeal in approach. According to Berard Marthaler, since the reorganizations, there has been no single agency that keeps abreast of developments in the field, no coordinating effort either in identifying the issues or of plotting a strategy for the catechetical mission of the Church in the U.S. ... By 1989, mention of the Confraternity and CCD has all but disappeared from the Catholic Directory. ... CCD has come to be a label for generic programs, makeshift substitutes for parochial schools concerned entirely with the instruction of children. Many diocesan offices no longer use the term CCD because of its negative connotations, and individuals have invented new meanings for the acronym, e.g., "Christian Character Development.""*

None of this is to deny that there are very many highly competent, extremely dedicated, distinctively Catholic educators working in the U.S. Catholic Church today. There most definitely are. But they themselves will often

SOUL SEARCHING

be the first to say that today's Catholic school system and CCD are not at all what they used to be, that something profound about the "Catholicness" of the education has been lost in recent decades. In any case, even if Catholic schools were doing a superb job at distinctively Catholic youth formation and ministry, their influence would still be limited, for fewer than 15 percent of secondary-school-age Catholic teens in the United States now attend a Catholic school.!2 Furthermore, as the stories of Heather and John illustrate, the CCD program has declined in its ability effectively to reach, educate, and form contemporary Catholic youth who do not attend Catholic schools.

The institutional systems that the U.S. Catholic Church has long relied on—for good reason or not—to accomplish its youth ministry and education have thus become structurally and culturally weakened in recent decades. And not enough has been done in response to shore up the system. It appears, in other words, that too many U.S. Catholics have through inertia continued to rest assured that old organizational structures were taking care of their children when in fact they increasingly have not been. And so many or most

Catholic teenagers now pass through a Church system that has not fully come to terms with its own institutional deficit and structural vacuum with regard to providing substantial and distinctive Catholic socialization, education, and pastoral ministry for its teenagers. As a result, the Catholic Church today comprises large proportions of teenagers like Heather, John, and Alano.

Upward Mobility and Acculturation Until recent decades, Catholics in the United States were commonly regarded by many other Americans as dangerous outsiders. Their faith was seen as threatening the dominant Protestant evangelical religious order and their hierarchical Church polity and allegiance to Rome as threatening the American democratic political order. Moreover, most Catholics came to the United

States as poor immigrants from European countries other than England, and so were often viewed by established Anglo-Americans as racial minorities, ethnic aliens, dirty riffraff. For these reasons, U.S. Catholics were recurrently maligned, persecuted, and socially excluded."° During the twentieth century, however, U.S. Catholics made remarkable gains in socioeconomic status, which helped to facilitate their eventual growing social acceptance in U.S. culture and institutions, the election of the Roman Catholic John Kennedy as president in 1960 being the key symbolic turning point in this process. By the 1970s and 1980s, U.S. Catholics had become among the best-educated, occupationally privileged, and most affluent Americans.*! That rapid upward mobility was paralleled by a major decline, though not elimination, of antiCatholic sentiment in U.S. culture.?? This major transformation in the social position of U.S. Catholics has, in turn, had profound consequences on U.S.

Catholicism itself. Sociologist James Davidson, for example, observes that "U.S. Catholics have gone from being a relatively small, working class, and highly segregated population of largely white Europeans who trusted social institutions, especially their pre-Vatican II Church, and stressed the importance of obeying church teachings, to being a larger, more privileged . . . pop-

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

2S ulation that is more highly integrated into American society and culture, more skeptical of all social institutions, including the post-Vatican II Church, and more inclined to stress the importance of thinking for themselves."

Everything that sociologists of religion know about how socioeconomic status and cultural difference shape religiosity—whether Troeltsch's "churchsect" theory, Stark and Finke's "religious tension" theory, or Smith's "subcultural identity theory"'—predicts that this upward mobility and social and mainstream cultural integration would have had the consequence of weakening American Catholics' religious identity and commitment." By most accounts, this is precisely what has happened, although, not to oversimplify, the effects of Vatican II also seem to have played a role in this process. In the second half of the twentieth century, U.S. Catholicism saw a significant decline in regular church attendance, in the strength of religious orders, in the number of new priestly vocations, and in ordinary American Catholics' readiness to learn, embrace, and live out Church doctrines and teachings.

American Catholics generally became more acculturated, more individualistic, and more selective in appropriating elements of the Catholic worldview as they personally saw fit. What is more, such new approaches to faith and Church tended to be expressed generationally; that is, they were especially concentrated among younger Catholics.?5 These trends clearly show up in the stories of Heather, John, and Alano.

To understand the greater religious laxity of contemporary U.S. Catholic teens compared to the other Christian teens we observed in this study, we need to set their experience within this larger historical experience of upward mobility, mainstream acculturation, and declining religious strength in twentieth-century U.S. Catholicism. Today's Catholic teenagers are, often without even knowing it, living out their lives on the cutting edge of a profound religious transformation that pushes forward with a half-century of momentum and that has in recent decades weakened the religious identities and commitments of multimillions of U.S. Catholics. As a whole, today's

Catholic teens come from relatively prosperous families and enjoy great chances for success in mainstream society. There is little about their religious identity that, in their cultural context, automatically reminds them of their distinctiveness or tension with the larger culture. Thus, the Catholicness in their larger personal identities and lives is increasingly able to slip into the background of their overall concerns, activities, practices, and commitments.

Whether contemporary U.S. Catholic teenagers attend Mass regularly, understand what Catholics believe, and live up to Catholic morality is simply not a pressing issue for many of them. This is exactly what we heard from the majority—though not all—of Catholic teens we interviewed around the country.

CONCLUSION

We do not intend this chapter to convey the impression that U.S. Catholic teenagers are uniquely religiously or spiritually in trouble. Most of the aspects

SOUL SEARCHING

of religious laxity that we focus on and illustrated in this chapter are also readily evident in the lives of teens in other Christian traditions in the United

States. The differences are not categorical, but mostly a matter of degree.

Furthermore, this chapter in no way claims to have comprehensively analyzed the religious and spiritual lives of U.S. Catholic teenagers. That would take an entirely separate, in-depth book dedicated to that task. The U.S. Catholic

Church and its adherents are simply much too complex racially, ethnically, regionally, theologically, generationally, and social-class-wise to cover in a single chapter. Simply addressing differences between Hispanic and white

Catholic youth would require much more analysis and discussion beyond the scope of this book to engage. Our more modest purpose has been simply to ask a question that seems to us to emerge from many of this book's findings and to offer some preliminary possible answers to focus attention, generate discussion, and stimulate further research.

To summarize, then, both our quantitative survey data and qualitative personal interview evidence point to the same conclusion: compared both to official Catholic norms of faithfulness and to other types of Christian teens in the United States, contemporary U.S. Catholic teens are faring rather badly.

On most measures of religious faith, belief, experience, and practice, Catholic teens as a whole show up as fairly weak. We think this can be attributed to a number of causes. In general, the U.S. Catholic Church seems to have become at least somewhat devitalized as a result of Catholic upward mobility and mainstream acculturation in the later part of the twentieth century; Catholic teenagers today merely reflect the leading edge of that larger trend. In addition and as part of that broader process, the organizational means that the Catholic Church historically employed to more or less successfully accomplish its work with youth, Catholic school and CCD, have in recent decades had the world around them change and have themselves changed in ways that, for whatever good they do accomplish for Catholic and other youth, render them inadequate to serve as the primary vehicles for contemporary youth socialization, education, formation, and ministry. The old wineskins cannot hold the new wine, and so it is often spilled and lost. Complicating these factors is the apparent relatively low institutional priority that youth evangelization, formation, and ministry appear to garner at the parish and diocesan levels, at least, of the U.S. Catholic Church. Evidence suggests that more than a few of today's Catholic youth may be falling through the organizational cracks without much notice.

Finally, many of these processes appear to get played out at the family level by Catholic parents of teenagers. As we wrote in chapter 2, the best general rule of thumb for religious adults considering the possible faith outcomes of their youth is "We'll get what we are." Most American teens turn out religiously to look a lot like their parents—not always, but very often— for understandable reasons. It does not appear to be the case that most U.S.

Catholic parents of teenagers are struggling mightily to live out vibrant lives of Catholic faith and yet find their teenagers to be religiously apathetic and resistant. Rather, it appears that the relative religious laxity of most U.S.

ON CATHOLIC TEENS

DA, Catholic teenagers significantly reflects the relative religious laxity of their parents. Once again, teens effectively embody and reproduce the larger adult world of which they are a part. Thus, we think the evident "problem" of Catholic teens is rightly seen in part as a larger challenge of Catholic adults generally and parents specifically.

During one plenary session of the Houston National Catholic Youth Conference described in this chapter's opening, I sat next to a very friendly, middle-age chaperone for an attending group of teens from the Midwest.

Chatting with him, I asked exactly how many teens were attending the conference from his diocese. He answered with an amused smirk, "Oh, I think our bus brought twenty-three of the little shits ..

. er, I mean kids, including one of my own little sh—, uh, kids." He was clearly tired of boisterous teenagers, understandably, and needed a good night's sleep. Later, I mentioned his comment to a life-long Catholic youth minister, one of the Conference organizers. "Well," he replied wearily, "sometimes it seems we have as much work to do educating and training our adults as we do our teens."

The jubilant, intense, exhausting, and inspiring Houston Conference reveals the great potential that the U.S. Catholic Church has for seriously engaging and forming its teenagers. But our research findings show that the Church has a long way to go to reach that immense potential. Getting from where the majority of U.S. Catholic teens currently are with regard to their religious faith and lives to achieving the huge religious potential that appears to exist for them would seem to require that the Church invest a great deal more attention, creativity, and institutional resources into its young members—and therefore into its own life. Undeniably, the future shape of the U.S.

Catholic Church vitally depends on it.

↑ Back to top

↑