Chapter 12 of 13

Appendix C. Interviews Methodology

Appendix C. Interviews Methodology

Appendix C. Interviews Methodology The second phase of the data collection of the National Study of Youth and Religion (NSYR) involved in-depth personal interviews with 267 teens. The purpose of the interviews was to provide extended follow-up discussions about teens' religious, spiritual, family, and social lives. The questionnaire followed closely and expanded on the topics that were included on the NSYR telephone survey.

All interviews were conducted in person and were digitally recorded (except in three cases in which the interviews ran long and because of schedule constraints had to be completed over the phone; two other interviews were conducted over the phone in their entirety). Interviews lasted an average of two hours each and ranged from about 1.5 to 3 hours long. Teens were given a $30 cash incentive to complete the interviews. The majority of the in-person interviews were conducted between March 2003 and August 2003, with a final few completed as late as January 2004. All interview subjects were selected from among the 3,370 teens who completed the NSYR telephone survey. At the conclusion of that survey, teens were asked if we could contact them again in the future. More than 98 percent of the survey respondents agreed to be contacted again in the future.

The interviewees were selected from the telephone survey respondents using a stratified quota sample. Rather than a nationally representative sample, we wanted interviewed teens to represent a range of demographic and religious characteristics in order for us to be able to draw substantive conclusions about the variety of teen experiences in the United States. Therefore, the interview sample was drawn taking into account the following demographic characteristics: region, urban/suburban/rural, age, sex, race, household income, religion, and school type.

We attempted to achieve a balance in each of these areas. We also oversampled

APPENDIX C: INTERVIEWS METHODOLOGY

home-schooled teens and those who attend private school because these are relatively understudied portions of the teen population, given that many surveys of teens are conducted in public school settings. The original telephone survey was conducted with teens between the age of 13 and 17. The time lapse between a teen completing the telephone survey and completing a personal interview could range from three months to more than a year. Therefore, the personal interviews included teens between the age of 13 and 18. The ages listed in table C.1 reflect the age of the teen at the time of the personal interview.

Table C.1. NSYR Personal Interview Demographics Region N

Gender

West South Northeast Midwest Male Female Age ily

Religion Protestant

Adventist Assemblies of God Baptist Bible Church Brethren Christian of Just Christian Church of Christ Church of the Nazarene Congregationalist Episcopalian Evangelical Lutheran Methodist Nondenominational Pentecostal aN a) f= G9 Race

White Hispanic Black Asian Native American Islander Mixed w Other ae School type

Public Private Home-schooled Magnet or charter school Not going to school/dropped out Presbyterian Catholic Mormon Jewish WO @orRrP WRN DAFF 2, Buddhist Muslim Jehovah's Witness Hindu Christian Science Eastern Orthodox Native American Pagan or Wiccan Don't know Not religious Household income Less than $10K

$10K-$20K

$20K-$30K

$30K-$40K

$40K-$50K

$50K-$60K

$60K-$70K

$70K-$80K

$80K-$90K

$90K-$100K

More than $100K Don't know Refused OR RP RP RrPNNN W Ww Language of interview English Spanish to oO BR WwW

Total interviews peliweear) sapested ergs cee es pir

SOUL SEARCHING

Seventeen interviewers conducted interviews in 45 states, each interviewer conducting between 10 and 20 interviews. Preliminary research and consultation with other youth scholars suggested the importance of matching interviewers and interviewees on race whenever possible. The majority of the 267 NSYR interviews conducted were matched on gender and race. All of the black teens in the sample were interviewed by black interviewers. Because of the sensitive nature of the interview questions asked of teens, prior to interview data collection, the NSYR obtained a Certificate of Confidentiality from the U.S. NICHD to protect the data from subpoena.

All 17 interviewers participated in a two-day training. The training covered the logistics of the interview process, procedural requirements, Institutional Review Board (IRB) concerns, the protection of human participants, safety and liability concerns, a review and discussion of the interview questionnaire, keys to interview success, and the proper use of the digital recording equipment. In addition to that training, all interviewers were required to obtain a Human Participants Training Certificate through the U.S. NIH Web site.

The 17 project interviewers were assigned to sets of specific geographic locations around the United States. Each interviewer was provided with groups of contact sheets for teens in their assigned geographic areas. The contact sheets included teen name, teen nickname (if known), parent name, address, phone number, date of telephone survey, teen age, teen gender, teen race, household income, school type, religious affiliation, and religious denomination or tradition. Also included was a place to note any changes to the contact information provided

(new phone number, additional e-mail address, etc.) and a call record. Interviewers recorded each household contact, noting the date, time, who they talked with, and the outcome of each contact. Along with the contact sheets, interviewers received instruction sheets indicating which of the teens were considered highpriority contacts. High-priority contacts were those with characteristics that were more difficult to complete, such as minority religions, lower incomes, non-public school, and minority race. As the project progressed through the interviews, the priorities shifted somewhat according to what types of teen interviews were still needed. In this way, we filled in the cells of the quota sample.

Interviewers were also provided with a survey information sheet for each teen.

This sheet contained a list of answers to selected questions from the telephone survey. It included information from the parent about family background, parent religion, family stress, and parent education and work status. It also included answers from the teen about importance of faith, moral beliefs, youth group participation, and some risk behaviors, These answers were not referred to specifically in the interviews, but were often useful in providing interviewers some background on the teens they were interviewing.

Using a standard call script provided by NSYR, interviewers made contact with potential interviewee households. Interviewers identified themselves as researchers with the "National Youth Study." The full name of the research project was not used because we did not want to introduce any bias by identifying religion as a key focus of the study. It was often helpful for interviewers to explain their connection with the project as graduate student, coinvestigator, or other.

When possible, interviewers also tried to establish a personal connection to the geographic area. For example, an interviewer might have mentioned that he or she grew up or went to school in the area. This seemed to help put some people

APPENDIX C: INTERVIEWS METHODOLOGY

at ease and reduced the sense that interviewers were total strangers from a faraway university. However, because much of the interview was about religion and we did not want to bias the answers of the teens, interviewers were instructed to avoid divulging information about their own personal beliefs and commitments

(about which there was considerable diversity on the interviewing team).

Interviewers were required to obtain verbal consent to conduct the interview from both a parent and the teen. If parents or teens seemed hesitant about participating, an additional script provided more information about the project and offered the phone number for the principal investigator, whom they could (and sometimes did) call with questions or concerns. In addition, interviewers offered to mail to hesitant respondents written information about the project and then call back in a few days. Interviewers worked hard to obtain consent from the parents. However, when teens refused to participate even after being offered additional information, interviewers made no further attempts to convert those who refused.

Upon receiving verbal consent from both parent and teen and scheduling an interview time, interviewers mailed packets of information to households. The packet contained a cover letter from the principal investigator, multiple copies of the parent and teen written consent forms, and an appointment card including a portrait photo of the interviewer. Teens were required to bring the written consent forms with them to their interviews, signed by both the teen and parent. Interviewers also called the teens at least one week prior to the interview and again the day before the interview to confirm that they were still planning to participate in the interview.

Interviews were conducted in public settings that nevertheless provided confidentiality for the teen. The ideal location for these interviews was in study rooms at local libraries. However, when these were not available, interviews were conducted in restaurants, coffee shops, mall food courts, public parks, and school cafeterias, classrooms, and libraries. Interviewers were given guidelines for how to present themselves during the interviews as well as appropriate attire to ensure consistency in the presentation of interviewers across the interviews. Specifically, interviewers did not attempt to relate to teens by dressing down or dressing in a more trendy fashion. Instead, they built rapport by presenting themselves as professional researchers with a sincere interest in teenagers' lives.

At the close of the interview, teens were given a $30 cash incentive for their participation and in appreciation of their time and effort. Interviewers also followed up interviews with hand-written thank-you notes mailed to teens. Because these interviews were with minors, a protected population, it was particularly crucial that all interviewers were aware of their responsibilities and obligations concerning the protection of interview participants and mindful of the potential safety and liability issues involved. There were three main human participant protection concerns with these interviews:

1. HANDLING SENSITIVE INFORMATION DIVULGED BY TEENS

Given the personal nature of the interviews, it was necessary to be prepared for the possibility of troubled teens revealing information about personal crises and dangers during the interviews. All interviewers were instructed about mandatory reporting and how properly to handle cases of abuse, harm to self or others, or

SOUL SEARCHING

other serious issues. In addition, all interviewers had in their possession at all times copies of a Teen Hotlines resource sheet. This sheet was prepared by NSYR staff and contained national phone numbers for a' wide range of potential teen crises. It included toll-free hotlines for suicide, mental health problems, eating disorders, family violence, and other issues that might arise during interviews.

Interviewers provided this resource sheet to any teen who appeared to be struggling with any of these issues, even cases that did not technically require mandatory reporting.

2. INFORMED CONSENT OF BOTH PARENT AND TEEN

Interviewers were required to obtain verbal and written informed consent from both parent and teen before conducting interviews. In the initial phone contact to set up the interview, interviewers obtained verbal consent from both parent and teen. Both were also informed that the teen would have the right to skip any question and to terminate the interview at any time for whatever reason. Prior to actually conducting interviews, interviewers had to collect written consent forms signed by both parents and teens; in cases where teens were 18 years old or older, parental written consent was not required. All teens were also reminded at the start of interviews and again in the middle of interviews that they were free to skip any question they were not comfortable answering.

3. PROTECTING CONFIDENTIALITY

A. Protecting Confidentiality of Teens' Answers with Respect to Parents Some parents were interested in what the interviewers were discussing with their teens. In addition, it seemed that for some teens the presence of parents or an environment that triggered concerns about their parents could have had the effect of making them more reserved and less candid in their responses during interviews. To ensure that teens were able to speak openly and honestly, interviewers took a number of precautions. First, they made sure to be very clear with parents ahead of time that parents may not listen to the interview or be in close proximity while an interview was taking place. Often, the parents brought the teens to the interview location and planned to wait for them. In these cases, interviewers made sure that the parents were well out of earshot and out of the teen's line of vision during the interviews. In restaurants, this meant choosing a table as far away from the parents as possible; in libraries, this involved trying to conduct interviews in a separate room or on a separate floor from where parents were waiting.

B. Protecting Confidentiality of Teens with Respect to Unknown Others During interviews, it was important to protect teens from having other people listening to their responses. Interviewers did their best to select locations that were confidential settings yet in public places. Interviewers also remained aware of potential eavesdroppers when locating interviews and throughout the process of interviews. Interviewers were also trained to rearrange question orderings or postpone sensitive questions if and when there were other people nearby who may overhear them.

Before and after actual interviews, interviewers followed strict procedures for handling all data and paperwork related to the interviews. The protocol was

APPENDIX C: INTERVIEWS METHODOLOGY

designed to prevent any of the data files from being linked to the contact information of the teen participants. Interviewers were trained to treat all documentation and audio files as confidential and to handle them so as to minimize any risk of teens having their interview responses identified by others.

In addition to concerns about the protection of human research participants, other basic safety and liability concerns related to the conduct of interviews with teens. Interviewers took steps to ensure their own safety during interviews, to not take unnecessary risks. It was also important to keep interviewers from getting into situations where they could be held responsible for harm (real or fabricated) to the teenager. Given these concerns, interviewers were provided with the following guidelines:

1. Always conduct interviews in a public place.

2. Never conduct interviews inside a teenager's home (very rare exceptions had to be arranged with the principal investigator, who talked with parents about particular situations beforehand).

3. Behave in such a way as to not invite suspicion or leave open the possibility of misinterpreted intentions or actions.

4, When unsure about a given neighborhood in which you may be traveling, research the area ahead of time to assess the safety factors.

5. Always let someone know where you are going and when you expect to return, and always give someone your cell phone or other contact number.

Interviewers were asked to consider carrying a safety device to interviews (e.g., whistle, pepper spray). These were optional, but were not provided by the project.

6. There were some cases where teens needed transportation to or from an interview. Interviewers were not obligated to provide this, but were allowed to choose to provide such transportation if they were comfortable doing so.

↑ Back to top

↑