Chapter 9 of 13

7. Community: Representing Christ to the World

7. Community: Representing Christ to the World

7

Community

Representing Christ to the World

Some of the problems that I discuss in this book are insurmountable on their own terms. Grief, betrayal, loneliness, sin. How can any one person make meaningful inroads into problems that go so deep?

In the book of Hebrews, the writer tells us that reconciliation and restoration is done “by faith.” The writer of the book of Hebrews declares, “Time will fail me if I tell of Gideon, Barak, Samson, Jephtha, of David and Samuel and the prophets, who by faith conquered kingdoms, performed acts of righteousness, obtained promises, shut the mouths of lions, quenched the power of fire, escaped the edge of the sword, from weakness were made strong” (Heb. 11:32-34)

The same is true today. We are conquerers of the problems that we face only by faith. And Christian hospitality and the community that develops from it is, I believe, the ground zero of our life in Christ: it is how our faith is visible and serviceable, powerful and potent. Hospitality from the home, in the neighborhood, and through the membership of the local congregation has the potential to transform us. Hospitality is our “by faith” bridge to each other, through Christ.

Hospitality in the Home Is Intentional

When I was in the LGBT community, someone’s house was open every night, for food, fellowship, and advice. I presumed that that is how a community works: people have open availability with each other, and you are valued and remembered. A community is a place where others show concern if you do not show up to dinner, and celebrate when you start to turn the corner on that head cold.

In a community, when you return from a long trip and your plane lands, you send a one-word text message to someone who cares that you made it home safe. You text “safe” not because you need a ride home, but just because you are safe and home again. Your safety and the fact that you are home again matters to someone. “Safe” is all that you have to say. You don’t need anything except for the most important thing: to know and be known.

When Christ captured my affections, he enriched each fiber of my life. I became a covenant member of my church. But I still found myself longing for more when it came to Christian community.

Community in my LGBT community was based in our shared identities and oppressions, and rested in sisterly trust because of the ways we were alike. But community for Christians rests not in our personal similarities, but in our shared futures: we are all bound to live as redeemed men and women, standing in Christ’s righteousness, when he returns or when he takes us home.

Our similarities here and now do not sustain us.

Our similarities here and now do not sustain us. What matters is that we have made it home from a long journey, we are “safe,” our sins forgiven, and while the cross we bear is heavy, we have the kind company of brothers and sisters that flows from union with Christ, and our eternal future is secure.

From the very beginning of our marriage, Kent and I have committed ourselves to hospitality. Because we recognize and cherish the important covenantal relationship of husband and wife, we see our marriage as an institution that has allowed us to minister hospitality in a unique way, using the blessing of marriage to create a home of hospitality that is inclusive and open. Different seasons reflect this hospitality commitment differently: when we had just adopted a child, or had a new child in foster placement in our home, or when my aged mother lived with us, we practiced a different kind of hospitality. As Edith Schaeffer, wife of Francis Schaeffer and co-founder of the Swiss L’Abri Christian community, was fond of saying: doors have hinges. But when we have had a stable household (relatively speaking, of course), we have been able to have a more organic hospitality home, with one night designated for neighborhood ministry, the Lord’s Day designated for our church family, and other days of the week open at meal times for what I like to call rhythm-of-life connections: meeting up with our church family in regular intervals so that we can share life.

In general, after school and work is done, our door is open, and our neighbors and their kids often trail in. Sometimes friends from church who work nearby stop over for a bite and a prayer. I set out extra plates. Because Kent and I both work from home, and because the kids are homeschooled, we are hungry for more than dinner when five o’clock rolls around, and we are supplied with great joy when we hear the door open and the dogs bark their greeting to someone Jesus has sent.

Over the years, I have come to learn that Christian community is built strong when we situate it on these two biblical principles: the paradigm of adoption and the fourth commandment (keep the Lord’s Day holy). We must think about the principle behind hospitality, because Christian community must be intentionally crafted, with prayer and sacrifice. It doesn’t just flow out of the day-to-day interests of the family. Sometimes we think that Genesis 1:28 covers the whole community thing: “and God said to them, ‘Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth, and subdue it; and rule over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the sky and over every living thing that moves on the earth.’” God’s giving of children to any marriage is a great blessing (and responsibility), but this verse speaks about how to steward what God has given you, not how to create or facilitate community.

Community renders enemies friends, and strangers brothers and sisters. Christian community is family by adoption, as God weaves divergent strands into a tapestry of divine providence. By God the Father’s adoption, I became his child, and I left the home I made with Satan and his minions. Colossians 1:13 says, “For He rescued us from the domain of darkness, and transferred us to the kingdom of His beloved Son.” I can rest into this verse and feel its contours. Adoption establishes my identity in Christ, my inheritance through Christ, and my mission because of Christ. Adoption is always both/and: it is about orphaned children and orphaned image bearers who lose the status of orphan through permanent sonship.

Adoption is the only way to gospel identity.

Adoption is not a second-choice inclusion; it is the only way to gospel identity. An adopted person receives all rights, privileges, and family history. Likewise, our identity as Christians is not divided among factions. Strangers and enemies become brothers and sisters through Christ’s blood. Hospitality in the home, neighborhood, and church starts with adoption and ends with keeping the Lord’s Day together, because the purpose of our adoption is worship.

Hospitality in the Home Is Renewing

Kent and I adopted all four of our children, and not to compensate for my infertility. Likewise, God the Father’s adoption of you and me was not done to compensate for something lacking. Adoption creates belonging that weaves lives together beyond gene pools and genetic codes. But it also creates an identity crisis. It is supposed to. Russell Moore puts it best: “None of us likes to think we were adopted. We assume we’re natural-born children, with a right to all of this grace, to all of this glory.”1

But we who are in Christ lay claim to an alien righteousness, and a new heritage through adoption. And out of our adoption, God springs a new sense of belonging and homestead. This newness of life should change the way our home looks and acts.

When we gather with people for a meal and family devotions in our not-by-invitation-only home, we do this to be renewed by the Spirit of God. We are refreshed by each other’s company, by the food that nourishes us, and by the Word of God, which we read and sing from the psalter. This is the regular pattern. No matter how bad your day was, this—and praying about your awful day, if you like—is what, by God’s grace, we will do.

            Psalter—hymnal that puts the book of Psalms from the Bible to music.

In our over-structured world, this might seem like a ridiculous luxury. Where are the soccer practices, the late nights at the office, and the reading clubs? Why aren’t Kent and I too busy to do this? Because it matters a lot, that’s why. Sometimes Kent, as a pastor, has a meeting with the elders at night, or a home visit or a counseling appointment. But for the most part, and because Kent and I value hospitality more than we do privacy or personal achievement, on Thursday night and on the Lord’s Day, we are, by God’s grace, here, ready to open the door to others.

This is not just a family tradition, something that we do to demonstrate a value and demarcate a family identity. God uses practices to unfold plans, callings, and missions. This fact—that practices unfold plans—became startlingly clear when my children and I recently read The Hiding Place, by Corrie ten Boom. The book begins with some simple practices that Casper ten Boom, the family patriarch, had in place. Every morning, after breakfast, he read from one chapter of the Old Testament. Every evening, after dinner, he read from one chapter of the New Testament. Because he was the neighborhood watchmaker, he often had clients and other people from the neighborhood at his table—believers and unbelievers, Gentiles and Jews, rich and poor. They ate, talked, listened to Scripture, and God used the time that they invested in this way to build community When unmitigated evil unleashed itself in Holland, they already had a community in place, carved out of neighbors, Scripture, and doing life together. They didn’t know what for, but they were ready. First in their home and later in Hitler’s concentration camps, Corrie and Betsie shared the gospel, their food, their lives, and their sufferings. They never had a plan, but they always had a practice. They had a practice of biblical communal living, and God used them to do great things for his kingdom and glory.

But what about us? What about our homes? What stands between us and doing life with others? What barriers or values have become idols that prevent us from establishing community from our homes? Here are ten points I recently came across on Pastor David Murray’s excellent blog, headhearthand.org. Pastor David says that we are too busy, too selfish, too functional, too proud, too fearful, too safe, too superficial, too brainwashed, too competitive, and too un-Christlike. I agree.

So where do we begin? How do we create community together in this, our age of anxiety, phobia, fear, and stranger danger? How do we break bread together when there is a war against gluten raging everywhere we turn? How do we include people we do not yet know into our lives when we teach our children to beware of strangers? How do we break down the barriers between host and guest? Who are our neighbors, anyway? Would we know them without those handy window decals?

The barriers to seeing our homes as a Christian habitus—a lifegiving, Christ-honoring community—mount high. I hear excuses every day, usually coming out of my own mouth: I homeschool; I have small children whose ability to be influenced by sin rules my fretting heart; my neighbors are too busy and are never at home, anyway; I’m an introvert; I’m busy writing books and serving the church. My house is not neat enough, or decorated well enough to receive guests. (Really. I recently returned home from a two-day away speaking engagement trip to find our beloved cat stuck and struggling to release himself from the two-day old maple syrup cementing him on the kitchen table. Don’t ask how this happened. Kent and the children have no idea who allowed this to happen.)

Maybe before we jump to how we need to start with why. Why create community from our homes? Who needs it? Why isn’t our Facebook family enough, or our internet community? Why do we have to be close enough to touch each other, for real? And why does God call me to claim as my people those who are so different from me?

What does a Christian covenant home committed to hospitality provide to our world? How does it nurture people, support people in their needs, spread the gospel in deed and word, and provide the landscape for friendship of the kind that builds bridges?

1) A hospitality home creates places of compassion.

Compassion means “with suffering.”

Compassion means “with suffering” and a hospitality home generates a way to practice accompanied suffering, standing with and for each other, and being there for each other without an appointment. (Scheduling a lunch date two weeks from Tuesday simply does not serve people who are dangerously and chronically lonely.)

2) A hospitality home creates opportunities to love the unlovely, because you, Christian, have much to learn from them, and you, perhaps, need them more than they need you.

3) A hospitality home provides a first-chair seat to abide in the family of God’s orchestra.

4) A hospitality home invites the participants to put stock in the resonating effect of small things, little gestures, tiny connections, and puny attempts at connection.

5) A hospitality home creates a boundary set by God to help you not sin against him.

Where to Start in Making Your Home a Hospitality Home?

Hospitality begins with loving the stranger. So the first reality check to do is this: if everybody at your table is on the same page and from the same side of the tracks, you aren’t practicing hospitality. You may need to do a heart-check here as well. It is easier to feel safe in the company of people who are just like you, who struggle and identify with the same things you do. But creating a safe space is not the ultimate point or purpose of Christian hospitality.

The word hospitality transliterates from the Greek word philoxenia, or love of the stranger. But hospitality is not a New Testament phenomenon. We first see hospitality at work in the Old Testament, when Lot rushes to meet the strangers at the gate in Sodom to spare them from harm. Lot felt a moral responsibility to shelter them. He recognized something in the stranger that was a mirror reflection of him. We need to stop here. Do we recognize strangers as our kin? He recognized them and he acted on his recognition in a direct and forthright way. Do we? Do we recognize ourselves as having been strangers once?

            Philoxenia—love of the stranger.

1) Community begins when we remember that we were all once strangers to God. We all started out as strangers and enemies, to God and to each other. We see this in Jesus’ words in the gospel of Matthew: “For I was hungry, and you gave Me something to eat; I was thirsty and you gave Me something to drink; I was a stranger and you invited Me in; naked, and you clothed me; I was sick, and you visited Me; I was in prison and you came to Me” (Matt. 25:35–36). When we feel entitled to God’s grace, we can never get at the core sentiment behind these words. What would it take to see Jesus in the homeless and the homely?

American poet William Stafford (1914–1993) in his poem “Easter Morning” defines an encounter with Jesus like this: “You just shiver alive and are left standing/there suddenly brought to account: saved.” Stafford then portrays the challenge of discerning Jesus in the stranger, because sometimes you open your door or open your heart and you get Satan instead. He writes: “the slick voice can sell you anything even/Hell, which is what you’re getting by listening.”

The risk is laid bare in Jesus’ words: when we fail to see him in others, we cheapen the power of the image of God to shine over the darkness of the world. When we always see him in others, we fail to discern that we live in a fallen world, where Satan knows our address.

As we pray for the Holy Spirit to give us discernment about and love for others, we do well to remember that justification is “an act of God’s free grace, wherein he pardons all our sins, and accepts us as righteous in his sight, only for the righteousness of Christ imputed to us, and received by faith alone.”2 We do well to remember that we do not justify ourselves, and to heed this warning, in the words of the German martyr Dietrich Bonhoeffer, “self-justification and judging others go together, as justification by grace and serving others go together.”3

2) Community begins when we defy Stranger Danger—even when some strangers are dangerous. Kent and I do a lot of local public speaking these days on hospitality and loving the stranger. We like to minister together, and we balance each other well, I think. One routine day in May 2014, Kent and I gathered up the kids and headed to a local Baptist church to give a talk about loving the stranger. Before we left the house, we gave the dogs their treats: Kongs with frozen peanut butter. (I keep a supply in the freezer.) We were in a hurry, and we left our Bibles on the table. They were opened to the gospel of Luke. Before I left my house for the last time, I looked back. I saw that the Bibles made a rough square on the dining room table, with some LEGOs and dinosaurs as well and one lightsaber. We locked the doors behind us, both the knob and the deadbolt.

Our talk went well, we think. We hope we encouraged other Christian families to open their homes and see Jesus in those in need. After the Q&A, we piled the kids back in the car and took the familiar drive back home. It was a good day, and I was looking forward to getting home, making coffee, finishing the laundry, icing my injured foot, and reading the last chapter of Prince Caspian to the kids.

I knew something was wrong as soon as I keyed in. My ever-hyper, effervescent, and effusive golden retriever, Sally, was cowering in the corner, hurt and scared. Clothes and dining room plates and family pictures were strewn everywhere. As we walked into the kitchen, we saw it. A window had been snapped at the frame and popped out with a crowbar. The robbers had to stand on the large dog feeding station to crawl in the broken window, so obviously they weren’t threatened by big dogs. Covering our open Bibles were those things the robbers discarded—some of my mom’s china, and the golden-colored bowl that Kent uses for baptisms. Seeing the golden baptism bowl next to the Bibles was the only sensible thing in this whole picture.

I looked at my hurt dog and kissed her face. She wagged at me, but her heart wasn’t in it. I walked through the house as if underwater. Sally trailed cautiously behind. The robbers yanked the TV off the wall, leaving holes in the wall and floor, where I suspect they must have dropped it. The drawers to all dressers hung open and their contents were strewn everywhere: socks, geography puzzles, math videos, marbles, the dog’s heart pills. The robbers stole all of my jewelry, including my engagement ring, an heirloom that had been in Kent’s family for five generations. I always feared I would hurt or lose it if I wore it, especially during summer months, when my hands are deep in garden dirt when they are not holding children or turning book pages or kneading communion bread. I had stared at it just that morning, contemplating whether it was safe to wear today, and turned down my last chance.

My mother, who recently moved to a retirement home, gifted me with her family jewelry, for safe keeping and memory’s sake. They took it all. But the close-range grief was Sally, my golden. Bruised. Sad. Shivering. When the police came, they explained it like this: big dogs are in the way, and robbers either shoot them or bludgeon them. They took our information, fingerprinted every doorknob and door frame, and left more mess and dirt in their wake.

It was awful to be robbed.

It was ironic to realize that as we advocated for hospitality to the stranger, he beat my dog and walked off with the goods, vandalizing the house just for good measure.

We all were in a state of shock. My children’s anxiety rocketed through the roof. Not one of us found OK for months.

But when it was dinnertime, our people surrounded us. I was not serving, but receiving. Our people set the table. Matthew, an exchange student from Singapore, was moving in to our house that night as the residence hall at the University of North Carolina was closing. It was so good to have his calming spirit home to help. Susanna was just leaving Duke, where she works, and picked up a rotisserie chicken and butter pecan ice cream on her way to our house. Just because she knew I would need butter pecan.

As is my routine, when I moved the prized Kroger chicken from its plastic bed to the pan, Sally got the plastic container covered in chicken grease and juice. She settled down with it in her favorite posture, nose in the corner and back feet splayed like a water buffalo in yoga (as if she could hide ninety pounds simply by giving us her backside). She held the plastic dish between her paws, and started to perk up when more people came over. Our homeschool dad friends came with tools and Scripture, dropping their lawn care and important executive jobs to help. And after dinner and prayer and Bible reading and a psalm, we started with a bucket and a rag, garbage bags and the vacuum cleaner.

It was hard to be robbed.

It was hard to have God test so powerfully and privately what we proclaimed publicly—that even if you are hurt, people can’t take the things that matter most and that will survive to the new heavens and earth: your soul and his Word.

The day after we were robbed, Kent pushed the grill to the front yard, where the picnic table was already waiting. Then, he posted three things on the neighborhood email list: we were robbed; robbers took stuff, but not things of eternal value—the Word of God and the life souls of people—and we would love for everyone to join us for burgers and hot dogs on the Lord’s Day, starting at three o’clock. As Susanna pointed out, that Lord’s Day was Mother’s Day, and my husband had just invited 300 people to our front yard. Well, that is how things go at the Butterfields’! It was a joy-filled time, with hot dogs and kids and water guns and meeting new and old friends. Twenty-one neighbors showed up, and most of our church family as well. And when our unbelieving neighbors asked how we were holding up, Kent was able to share the gospel with new legitimacy, because where God is in your loss matters more to a skeptical, unbelieving, and watching world than where God is in your plenty.

It feels awful to come home and find your house ransacked, holes in the walls, your underwear touched by the wrong hands, your journals and vitamins tossed all over the floor, and the dog you raised from mitten-size bruised and fearful. It was humiliating to not be sovereign over locked doors and engagement rings. It was painful to realize that he who is sovereign allowed this to happen, for his glory and for my own good (Rom. 8:28).

But it must feel deceptive and sinister to be the people who robbed me, bad in the way that a coat of paint and comfort of neighbors with rotisserie chicken and butter pecan ice cream can’t fix. It must create a hole in your humanity that you know will swallow up everyone you love. I realized that night that it was more awful to be my robber than me. It must be a spine-chilling nightmare from which you never awake to realize in the flesh the evil that you know you are capable of, and to get away with it.

3) Community begins when we remember that perfect love casts out fear (1 John 4:18).

We sometimes fear that our neighbors will bring problems and issues into our homes that we are not ready to discuss in front of our children. We pit the command to nurture and teach our children in the fear and admonition of the Lord against the command to love our neighbor.

We need to stop and think about this. On the one hand, we of course must protect our children from harm. And, on the other hand, we must not presume that sheltering them will accomplish this. Perhaps our children need to know that when they confront doubts and fears, sexual temptations, and moral and faith crises, that we will not be shocked, offended, or hurt by this reality.

Our children need to know that we know how serious the enemy is, how “alien” and yet powerful our righteousness in Christ is, and how deep and wide and big and powerful our sin can become if we hide it.

But if we have had a ministry to the lost, and if our children have seen us embracing our neighbors who are struggling, or burdened, or falling under the weight of sin and tragedy, perhaps, just perhaps, our children will trust us with their deep things. Perhaps they will remember that we embraced our neighbors and strangers, that we loved them and prayed for them, and that we were not jostled or unsettled to share block parties or BBQs, our churches and our homes, with troubled people. Perhaps our love of those image bearers, all of them, especially the difficult ones, will be a pledge to our children that the mosaics of their private lives are safe with us.

4) Community begins when we remember that God uses us as living epistles, and the openness or inaccessibility of our homes and hearts stands between life and death, victory or defeat, grace or shame for most people.

Consider with me the tension of 1 Corinthians 10:13: “No temptation has overtaken you but such that is common to man; and God is faithful, who will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation will provide the way of escape also, so that you will be able to endure it.” This passage speaks to the intensity, the loneliness, the danger of temptation. It also speaks to the lived tension of applying faith to our trials, and then waiting, waiting, waiting for that way of escape to present itself where it was not before. Have you ever thought that you, your house, and your time were not your own, but rather, God’s ordained way of escape for someone?

I think about this every Lord’s Day morning as I am preparing food for the day, praying about who will join us. Behind the peaceful surface, it is a day of warfare. Perhaps you had not realized this, but the Lord’s Day is a terrible day of temptation and sin for many people. Without the moorings of a vital church community and Christian church family and the fourth commandment (“keep the Lord’s Day holy”)—and indeed, sometimes with them—it is a day awash in the twin churnings of the world: personal achievement and material acquisition. But the fourth commandment begins with the verb “remember”—one of the most pressing and recurring commands in Scripture. It says, “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy” (Ex. 20:8). Memory is best when it is collective. You see, your job is not just to keep the Sabbath holy for you, but to live in such a way that you enable a co-operative kinship, a fellowship of believers, a place at the table, available to others and not by invitation only.

We keep the Sabbath in global and communal ways by sharing ordinary means of grace given to us by God. But the Lord’s Day is not “family day.” It is not “just us” day. If you preserve this day for isolation or separation, you may unwittingly be causing your sister to stumble into sin.

In Life Together, Bonhoeffer comments,

Sin demands to have a man by himself. It withdraws him from the community. The more isolated a person is, the more extractive will be the power of sin over him, and the more deeply he becomes involved in it, the more disastrous is his isolation.4

My favorite day of the week is the Lord’s Day, and I want to share that with others. Kent and I open our home after worship and mercy ministry5 to anyone who can come. We must. We remember what it was like to not have a place to go after worship, the odd tearing away of the body as each goes off to his own corner of the world while the benediction still rings in your ears. It is cruel to the people in the church to have no place to go on the Lord’s Day, no place to belong and no place to be needed. We must work hard to search out people who are easy to neglect or overlook. We need each other.

When we are too functional, we forget the point of hospitality in the home: fellowship, not entertainment. Don’t let pride stop you from opening your home. Ignore the cat hair on the couch (or in the mac and cheese). It likely won’t kill anyone as decisively as loneliness will. Add as much water to the pot to stretch the soup. If you run out of food, make pancakes, and put the kids in charge of making that meal. See how much fun that is!

And know that someone is spared from another humiliating fall into internet pornography because he is instead walking with you and your kids and dogs, as you share the Lord’s Day, one model of how the Lord gives you daily grace and a way of escape. Know that someone is spared the fear and darkness of depression because she is needed at your house, always on the Lord’s Day, the day she is never alone, but instead safely in community, where her place at the table is needed and necessary and relied upon.

Know that someone is drawn into Christ’s love because the Bible reading and psalm singing that come at the close of the meal include everyone, and that it reminds us that no one is scapegoated in this Christ-bearing community. Know that host and guest are equally precious and fragile, and that you will play both roles throughout the course of this life. The doors here open wide. They must.

5) Community begins with an intentional plan to open the doors of the covenant community and then toss over your shoulders and carry home someone who cannot walk there herself.

Have you ever considered becoming a licensed foster parent? When you become a licensed foster parent, you have access to children in need and families in need. Even if the needs a child presents exceed your capacity and you therefore have to say no to a home placement, you are deep in the prayer loop. You can take that child to the throne of grace even if you cannot take her home. When you work with the foster care system, you meet a large population who needs the Lord and the Lord’s people. And adding to your family by adoption is a daily mirror of God’s saving work. I love being part of a transracial family, as it also reflects the diversity of the kingdom that we will one day inherit. God wants the church to be the frontline of hope and family for orphans. Don’t be afraid to show up. God will meet you there.

If many families in the church go through foster parent training together, you can become your own prayer and support group. You can provide the extra help that single covenant Christians who are members of your church may need to also become foster parents. There are too many teenagers in foster care, waiting for homes, waiting for adoption, or waiting for the mentors they need to help them in all transitions into adulthood, and most of these teenagers will only be placed in single households. Single Christians may be uniquely called for this pivotal crisis of life for teenagers in foster care.

Even if adopting or foster parenting is not your calling, you may find yourself training to be a guardian ad litem or a Big Brother or Big Sister. Perhaps you can partner with another family in the church to keep sibling groups together, or use your training to provide respite care to a family in the church with special needs foster children. You can be Aaron holding up Moses’ arms when you lock arms with someone in the adoption and foster care world.

6) Community begins when your home becomes a safe place to grieve. Do you know someone who has buried a child or a spouse? Someone who has miscarried? Someone whose same-sex desires nag at her day after day, causing her to wonder if God has forgotten her? Do you know someone whose singleness makes him feel rejected, or whose infertility makes her feel like God’s promises are not real and not really for her? Do you know someone who wears loneliness as sackcloth? The home is the place to move in close—and stay there. Home is where isolation is broken. Home is where suffering meets accompaniment. Home is the best place to incorporate people who need you into the rhythms of life together. Perhaps God gave you a home for just such a purpose. Set aside a weekly and consistent time and place, and pray that the Lord will fill that. Be intentional. Are you good company for the suffering? Why not?

7) Community begins when we learn that hospitality is for the good of the giver. We have so many barriers to practicing community in the one place that it is vitally and daily needed: the Christian home. But we fear that we will not measure up, that we are failing to protect our children in this dangerous world, that we will get in over our heads with people and their needs and that they will suck us dry in the process. We know that God commands us to practice hospitality for his glory and for the protection of the unloved, but in what way is the creation of Christian community intended for the good of the giver?

Doing life together helps us to realize that people and theological or political positions are different. People are always more complex than the ideas that they embrace.

Hospitality helps us to keep a guard over our mouth.

Practicing hospitality helps us to keep a guard over our mouth (Psalm 141) while rendering Ephesians 4:29 a verse of immediate urgency: “Let no unwholesome word proceed from your mouth, but only such a word as is good for edification according to the need of the moment, so that it will give grace to those who hear.” We live with a draught of bloody, faithful grace, given freely but agonizingly by Christ and bestowed to us, for our union with Christ, our sanctification through Christ, and communion of the saints.

As people gather around your table, Christ heals the parched land of their hearts as you share words of salt and light, informally, as it spills into the needs of the moment, with humility, patience, gentleness, with Bibles and psalters open. Doing life together means silence or sadness turns into prayer without “calling for prayer requests” or happening to have your crisis fall within the Wednesday night prayer meeting time frame. It happens when Bibles or psalters flip open as tension or division escalates, not to avoid the conflict, but to ask Jesus to enter it.

Because it is not “just us” here, because you have chosen company with hurting people, you are not going to let your guard down. This, by God’s grace, will not be a day that turns into a night of torment, as you replay what you said and wish that you could erase it. Your children are learning how to share the gospel with fluency, and how to love it before a watching world. And you see gospel fruit in your role in God’s community as a helper and healer, as a server and a caregiver, and as receiver and needer. You have sharpened your prayers with heartache over people you would never know without this ministry. You count it joy—even when you are dead tired and somebody put a hole in your wall—knowing that God will magnify your efforts. You partner with others to make your homes places where Jesus could rest his head.

Hospitality in the Neighborhood

G. K. Chesterton once quipped, “We make our friends; we make our enemies, but God makes our next door neighbor…. We have to love our neighbor because he is there.” The nearness of our neighbor is providential, as God never gets the address wrong.

Last year, Kent preached a series of sermons on hospitality, a rare foray into topical preaching. It was that important, he said, that he got out of his comfort zone of expository explication through a whole Bible book and took the risk of shaking up the church.

After he preached this sermon series, he and I read the book, The Art of Neighboring, by Jay Pathak and Dave Runyon.6 I liked it so much that I bought a few copies and gave them to Christian neighbors we hoped would partner with us in fulfilling what is on the surface a simple command: love your neighbor.

Summers in North Carolina are memorable for June bugs, humidity, and long night walks, when many neighbors are also out walking. That first summer in Durham, Kent and I would look longingly at our front yard, wanting to fill it with neighbors. We were hungry to get to know people better and get serious about serving our neighbors. That’s when Kent decided to apply one simple thing that we learned from The Art of Neighboring: put lawn chairs and tables in the front yard. So, he and our neighbor Ryan built a picnic table, and then positioned it in the front yard under our massive oak tree where everyone could see it. The kids and I painted it neon green (so that you could really see it). Soon, neighbors started gathering there. It became a nice spot to stop and talk, re-apply bug spray, grab water, and talk. Eventually, our pastor friend Micah Ramsey hung a tire swing off of the sturdy oak. It is now a perfect gathering spot. Not by invitation only. Come as you are.

After the picnic table assumed its front yard spot, we wrote this email and distributed it to everyone we knew in the neighborhood. Here is what it said:

Dear Friends,

Please join with us at the green picnic table on the front lawn of the Butterfields’ on Thursday, August 15, 2013, at 7 p.m. for our inaugural and weekly prayer walk. We will pray with our eyes and our hearts open, seeking to bring glory to our Triune God and raise our neighborhood needs to the Throne of Grace. Those walking without kids, dogs, and strollers might also bring a pencil and paper to collect prayer and mercy requests and gather information about our neighbors’ needs. We will meet back at the picnic table at eight o’clock and close our evening with singing a psalm and creating an action plan to meet mercy needs. Please forward this email to anyone in the neighborhood who might like to join us.

Love in Christ,

Rosaria (for the Butterfields)

Thursday night arrived. Neighbors drew near from all directions. Some came because of the email. Others tied in because they wondered what kind of a party we were having. Kent gathered us together and we prayed for God to hear us.

Something transformative happens when we pray with our neighbors like this, something we commit to doing each Thursday night. Something that has become, for us, the touchstone of our neighboring. Every Thursday night we host a neighborhood open house, and we launch it by taking back the streets in prayer.

When things become a tradition, they acquire a comfort and a predictability about them. But prayer is never predictable. If Jesus enters, even that which is rehearsed is never routine. Today, it is established that on Thursday night we will pray with our neighbors and gather together for fellowship. Thursday night neighborhood ministry is now like a tried and true friend. But our first night of prayer and fellowship happened as if in a dream.

This is how I remember that first Thursday night prayer walk.

We meet at the picnic table and introduce ourselves. There are many people here whose face I recognize but whose name I do not know. We break naturally into groups of two and three, unintentionally gender-segregating when the kids on wheels want to race down a big hill and the moms with strollers weren’t hankering for broken bones. The men take the crosscountry route, with the big kids, and the women, dogs, toddlers, and strollers stay on the path. We pray aloud in unhurried, unrehearsed, unrestrained, and unworried tones. We stir prayers and interruptions like they all go together in the same pot of soup. We stop to talk to neighbors and ask them to tell us who they are and what they need. Life layers prayer. No such thing as an interruption. Children need sippy cups, dogs need cleaning up after, and prayer marches on. Sometimes neighbors join us for a block, just to hear what we are praying for.

And then it hits me: this prayer walk is itself a breed and species of Christian hospitality.

Extending arms wide, we draw others into our posture of ambulatory bended knee, eyes wide open. We go to God together for mercy, grace, increase. Hospitality starts with emptiness, and waits together for God to complete us. On a prayer walk, we seek to give that which we do not yet have, but by faith behold as inevitable: God’s promise to keep his covenant, and the reality that he has already set apart great blessings he will only grant through prayer.

But a righteous and holy God only hears the prayers of his redeemed people, of those who, by grace, come to his throne in the alien robes of Christ’s righteousness and blood. We all come with blood on our hands, but whose blood is it? And this prayer walk is risky business. “Even though you multiply prayers, I will not listen. Your hands are covered in blood,” so declares God in Isaiah 1:15. That we cannot come to a holy God with our virtuous intentions and high-minded deeds simply does not fly with my unsaved neighbors. The exclusivity of Christ tramples on our American confidence and self-absorption. That raises the bar of responsibility on this prayer walk. Indeed, how will our unsaved neighbors come to the banquets of prayer without the intercession of God’s people? In the Acts 17 world in which we live, how will our unsaved neighbors know that the deepest meaning of their pain is that their prayers do not (yet) resonate with God?

When you stand with the suffering, you draw no lines.

When should we share and model the good news that only rings authentic because of the bad news that precedes us all? What if we are called to grieve with those who suffer because of sin and disobedience? When you stand with the suffering, you draw no lines. Neighbors stand close enough to touch.

This is messy business, this prayer walk. We don’t bother with formalities like whose turn it is to pray. We jump in. The Holy Spirit does not play card dealer.

Sometimes we pause in front of a house that we know is struggling with something, so we pray like this:

Lord, remember your covenant with your people. In Christ, there is meaning, and purpose and suffering in our pain. Please bring the Jones family to salvation, we pray, so that Bill and Jean can know your comfort in such a time as this. May this give you praise and glory. Thank you that we can pray, that we can walk, and that we can hear the laughter of our children as we do this. Thank you that we can pray with eyes open. Help us to move in close to our neighbors in their pain. Cause us to be good company for the suffering. Forgive us for the distance that we keep from others.

Sometimes our ignorance rebukes us. Why don’t we know the names of the people who live in the house on the corner, the one with the screen door that is perpetually torn? Why do we know our neighbors best by polite and anonymous waves? We pray that as God may allow us to know real stories of real people, that we would cherish this information as jewels and never gossip or betray them. We pray that God would forgive our sin of not noticing, not caring, and not initiating friendships. We repent. We do not love our neighbors like ourselves. As we walk and pray and stop and talk, we learn about the people who share our blocks. We pray for them by name, asking God to help us put away distractions and put on love.

Why do this? Why not just have the Christian neighbors over for a BBQ, or football, or board games? Why not just invite the people we know are Christians to join us in our living rooms and pray with the doors closed? Why not exclusively surround ourselves with people who are just like us?

We commit ourselves to praying with and for our neighbors every Thursday night in order to remember. We remember what it was like before the Holy Spirit chiseled our stony heart soft. We remember what it was like before the blood of Jesus pumped our hearts whole. We remember the night terrors and the midmorning anxiety attacks, the unraveled good intentions of daily inventing ourselves and snowballing rules through which we hoped we could function. We remember what it was like to crack under the weight of this, and the loneliness of having no place to go but drugs, alcohol, sex, or lies. We remember our own predatory sin, and its legacy, and how for nothing that we could do or offer, God reached down and brought us to himself. We remember the throne of grace rising from the rubble, we remember that repentance is the threshold to God, and we want to invite others to come.

Before we started prayer walking we heard rumor of need.

One of our neighbors has Lou Gehrig’s disease. He is forty and his youngest child is two. Another neighbor has an abdominal tumor the size of a twenty-four-week-old fetus. Many neighbors have lost jobs, and the stress in their households rises high. Some neighbors are wearing telltale scarves and losing hair, but we don’t know their names. We don’t want to bring up the “C” word without at least having a first name to go with it. Some neighbors have households hard to discern. Divorced? Widowed? Shut in? Who knows? Who could know when we are too busy to care? There is a cul-de-sac at the end of the block called “Widow’s Corner,” because almost every household in that circle is inhabited by a widow. But I don’t know the first name of even one of those souls, even though I walk my dogs through this circle every day. Because they are all “shut ins,” I couldn’t recognize one of these women’s faces if my life depended on it.

How did we get to this place where we are so estranged? Once we hear their story, will we follow through on what we know? Or will we duck and run? How do we gather our arms wide and hold fast? We need each other in this prayer walk, this Christian walk. All by ourselves, we will forget, lose heart, and start walking the dogs with our smartphones glued to our ears or thumbs.

After one mile of prayer, the creeping fall darkness corners us. When we return to the picnic table, the children start running barefoot in the grass while the men finish up a list of mercy needs. I go to the kitchen to assemble something to eat for our guests, and while I am walking in the dark, I am marveling over how many neighbors came to pray. Was it fifteen? Twenty-five when you count the kids? I ponder over what I have in the kitchen for all of these people. I flick on the switch and the harsh light blinds me for a minute. I shut it off and work in the dark. I bring out a half watermelon, a loaf of fresh bread, and some honey. I move as if in a dream or underwater. My neighbors are still here, captivated by a mile high of prayer.

Something has changed among us. Some barrier of intimacy has been shattered. How? In the heavens? On the streets? Both? I slice the watermelon and dollop big spoonfuls of honey on homemade bread. The children finally sprawl, munch, lick sticky fingers, and fold into laps and on hips and on the grass. The lush full moon suspends low tonight, as it does in North Carolina in August. It almost looks like the trees can brush against it. The stars come out, and so do the psalters. I recall Psalm 147:3–4: “He heals the brokenhearted and binds up their wounds. He counts the number of stars; He gives names to all of them.”

Does the God who numbers and names the stars do the same with the broken hearts and promises of our neighbors? Is this prayer walking one way of gathering the fragments of pain, and giving all of the pieces to the God who made me and takes care of me?

As the children droop limp on shoulders, Kent passes out the psalters. We gravitate to the street light, so that we can see. Only Kent and I have sung together before. We begin to sing from the 23rd Psalm.7

       The Lord’s my Shepherd, I’ll not want,

       He makes me down to lie

       In pastures green; He leadeth me

       The quiet waters by.

       My soul He doth restore again;

       And me to walk doth make

       Within the paths of righteousness,

       E’en for His own name’s sake.

       (Psalm 23B, stanzas 1–2)

Singing a cappella on a hot summer night without preparation forges our intimacy and vulnerability. As we breathe together, I thank the God who gave us this breath. And as we break into parts, my heart sparkles with the sudden surprise that Donna’s rich alto voice vibrates in perfect partnership with Kristin’s soprano. I leap into the soprano descant, and we all breathe together. I’m getting goosebumps. We all could have been neighbors for fifty years and not have known this. Secrets and mysteries are unveiling all around us.

       Yea, though I walk in death’s dark vale,

       Yet will I fear no ill;

       For Thou art with me, and Thy rod

       And staff me comfort still.

       A table Thou hast furnished me

       In presence of my foes;

       My head Thou dost with oil annoint,

       And my cup overflows. (stanzas 3–4)

As we sing together, I realize something: we pray with strangers in the hopes that they will not remain strangers, but rather be transformed into sisters and brothers with whom we will sing in full voice into eternity. Hospitality gives God glory by revealing him as the provider and the host. It does not steal glory from God by giving the appearance of self-sufficiency. God is the author of the banquet. We are—at best—one of the means. Who knew God had so much mercy and intimacy in store for us this night?

       Goodness and mercy all my life

       Shall surely follow me;

       And in God’s house forevermore

       My dwelling place shall be. (stanza 5)

Joggers stop to listen.

The predictable parade of rolling garbage cans pause en route to the weekly resting place at the curb. Ears bend. I look up at the stars, and I know I am small, a broken reed, a bent arrow. And yet, God chooses to use even the likes of me.

Our psalm ends, and only now do we hear the chorus of tree frogs and crickets.

I have never before experienced community prayer as an act of hospitality before this night. I finally get it. God has blessings designed for us, measured out, prearranged, that he will only dispense by prayer. Why? Because prayer changes us to receive what it shakes the gates of heaven to give. I shudder to think of the lost blessings, buried under the rubble of busy schedules and fear.

It is different now, two years later. Thursdays are still neighbor nights. During the spring and summer months, we walk and pray until 8 p.m., meeting at the now-fading green picnic table under the shady oak tree in our front yard. Sometimes it is hard to get going. What will I say? What if I just repeat the same thing, over and over again?

One Thursday last September, I was feeling especially skittish about praying. Many of my usual praying neighbors were sick at home, and I was tired and getting ready for a trip the next day. It was much more practical for me to do laundry and pack than head out the door to pray. When I walked to the green picnic table, I had no idea who would meet me there. My dear friend Kristin met me with the stroller, and we started off. The bigger kids ran ahead, and it was a sweet night, just me and Kristin, her toddler in the stroller, my dog on a leash. The husbands prayed and kept pace with the big kids.

Kristin and I did not walk and pray more than one block when the Lord sent a meteor of hope and purpose. As we approached different houses, neighbors started to come out of their front doors to stop us and ask us to pray about a family member’s cancer, or the impending death of a favorite aunt. Not just one neighbor, but neighbors. Block after block. We gathered some in close and prayed together holding shoulders that were shaking in grief. It has never taken us that long to complete the “prayer loop.” But the Lord sent so many hurting hearts who needed a hand on a shoulder and a heart for Jesus.

We returned home late. The older children had already started to watch The Pink Panther on the computer and our husbands were talking in the kitchen and we could both feel it, that powerful reality that had we not shown up to pray, immeasurable blessings would have slipped through our fingers unnoticed. And perhaps even slipped through the heavens. That night we learned the art of showing up.

In the late fall and winter, we gather in different neighbors’ kitchens or living rooms. If the weather is good, we settle on the porch. If we meet at Ray’s house, he makes a strong pot of decaffeinated coffee. If we meet at Donna and Bob’s, the little kids settle in the most comfortable TV room you could imagine, wrap themselves in handmade quilts, and watch Charlie Brown while the adults pray. After years of this, we have noticed that our doors are more open, the rhythms of our days more transparent. This makes a good bridge to the asking of hard questions and the offer of a steady hand. Weekly, and by God’s grace, our lives and needs as neighbors unfold together and before the throne of grace.

Hospitality within the Covenant of Church Membership: Belonging to One Another

The church is Christ’s bride. It is a visible sign that you are a member of the family of God. Just like you belong to a specific and visible human family, if you are a covenant member of a church, you belong in a specific way to one, singular, local congregation. Covenant membership in the visible church should mean something and translate something to a watching world. Your neighbors know details about you even if they don’t (yet) know your name. Mine know that I have an electric fence for my dogs, and that I turn on the porch light at 5 a.m. I believe church membership could be something that also translates across the picket fence. What if being a member of a Christ-honoring church communicated the attributes of God to the watching world? What if it revealed that we are a people safe with your secrets, able to help with your needs, willing to stand by you in times of grief, and able to put the hand of the suffering into the hand of the Savior? What if membership meant belonging to one another in a deep and abiding way?

As Christians we are members of both the visible and the invisible church. The visible church refers to a local body, made up of believers and unbelievers.

There is a special friendship, a deep and abiding covenant, that could bleed through one believer to another who are both bound to Christ through church membership. Membership could be strong enough to uphold those who are weak, fallen, broken, repenting, and struggling sheep. Church membership could create greater intimacy with others who have taken covenant vows.

But does it?

Imagine how different our world would be if this was so.

Church exists as Christ’s bride, and as such, its purpose is to give glory to God and stand as a testimony to the truth of Scripture from age to age. Members of a church take vows and make a covenant with God and with each other. In my denomination, the Reformed Presbyterian Church, when a person seeks covenant of church membership, after meeting with the elders and taking a class on the covenant of church membership, she stands before the body and gives assent to these official vows:

1) Do you believe the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments to be the Word of God, the only infallible rule of faith and life?

2) Do you believe in the one living and true God—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, as revealed in the Scriptures?

3) Do you repent of your sin; confess your guilt and helplessness as a sinner against God; profess Jesus Christ, Son of God, as your Savior and Lord; and dedicate yourself to His service: Do you promise that you will endeavor to forsake all sin, and to conform your life to His teaching and example?

4) Do you promise to submit in the Lord to the teaching and government of this church as being based upon the Scriptures and described in substance in the Constitution of the Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America? Do you recognize your responsibility to work with others in the church and do you promise to support and encourage them in their service to the Lord? In case you should need correction in doctrine or life, do you promise to respect the authority and discipline of the church?

5) To the end that you may grow in the Christian life, do you promise that you will diligently read the Bible, engage in private prayer, keep the Lord’s Day, regularly attend the worship services, observe the appointed sacraments, and give to the Lord’s work as He shall prosper you?

6) Do you purpose to seek first the kingdom of God and His righteousness in all the relationships of life, faithfully to perform your whole duty as a true servant of Jesus Christ, and seek to win others to Him?

7) Do you make this profession of faith and purpose in the presence of God, in humble reliance upon His grace, as you desire to give your account with joy at the Last Great Day?

In Secret Thoughts, I shared with you that taking these vows explicitly marked me as a traitor in my LGBT community. To this day, when I hear my husband read these vows to new members, I experience a dulling dizziness, complex heartache about how much I have made my Lord endure, and awe at God’s covenant love. That I now stand in Christ and with fellow believers daily reveals Christ’s power to save.

In my denomination, all who make a profession of faith and publicly commit their lives to Christ take these vows. These vows are a matter of life and death. These vows—and the other doctrinal and confessional standards of my church—are important to examine. You should not take church membership lightly. These vows are a visible sign of union with Christ and communion with the saints. Membership is soul business, with a daily dose of earthly good.

The Westminster Confession of Faith (WCF) represents the church as both invisible and visible. Of the invisible church, it says this:

The catholic or universal Church, which is invisible, consists of the whole number of the elect, that have been, are, or shall be gathered into one, under Christ the Head thereof; and is the spouse, the body, the fulness of Him that filleth all.8

The invisible church is that which God himself knows and ordains and contains. It is called “invisible” because it is invisible to us. It does not have a witness to a watching world. It is made up of all believers, across history, nation, and time. But it is, as its name suggests, invisible.

Because God cares to make himself known, he commands believers to be members of a visible church. Of the visible church, the WCF says:

The visible Church, which is also catholic or universal under the Gospel…consists of all those throughout the world that profess the true religion; and of their children: and is the kingdom of the Lord Jesus Christ, the house and family of God, out of which there is no ordinary possibility of salvation.9

I am daily stunned by this: God made the church to stand as a visible witness to a watching world and to remain as a beacon. The visible church, made up of average people with plenty of problems, sin patterns, character flaws, annoying habits, and peculiar interests. The church remains as a beacon of who God is. Not the Christian family. Not the Christian college. Not individual celebrity Christians who do a lot and get a lot of attention for doing a lot. The church alone is commended by God to hold this privilege.

But two things distort the clear visibility of the true church: 1) the ways that sin disfigures each member of the church, and, 2) the reality of wolves in sheep’s clothing who also take these vows. This is true across the wide range of denominations. There is no such thing as a pure denomination or church body. As G. I. Williamson says,

Because there is evil in true believers while they are on earth, and because there is the appearance of faith and righteousness in hypocrites, the visible manifestation of the Church is never perfect…. Every attempt to realize the perfect Church (i.e., in which there are no hypocrites at all) is doomed to failure because the Church is invisible to us in exactly the sense that it would have to be visible to us to realize this goal.10

It baffles me that God permits the visible church to contain hypocrites, but my perplexity is not the yardstick of God’s truth. Williamson explains it like this: “The true Church becomes visible, not by an identification of persons, but by an identification of presence.”11 It is not the presence of sin that renders a church worthy of the dust on your boots. Paul did not tell members of the church of Corinth to go find another church. Why?

Because the visible church is “the house and family of God.” In the church, we are “members of the household of God” (Eph. 2:19, ESV), and as such, we belong one to another—“to those who belong to the family of believers” (Gal. 6:10). The church is a covenant community, where privileges and responsibilities belong to believers, their children, and their households (Gen. 17:9–14). One of my favorite passages of Scripture, one that I roll over in my mind, my heart, my imagination, and my daily prayers, reminds us how the family of God exists to give its members comfort in times of affliction, loneliness, loss and despair.

In Mark 10, Jesus comforts Peter (and me) with these words:

29 Truly I say to you, there is no one who has left house or brothers or sisters or mother or father or children or farms, for My sake and for the gospel’s sake,

30 but that he will receive a hundred times as much now in the present age, houses and brothers and sisters and mothers and children and farms, along with persecutions; and in the age to come, eternal life.

Through the people of God identified by membership in the visible church, the Lord gives us family. And this family makes up for our real loss and persecutions “a hundred times as much.” The family of God is meant to reveal this to a skeptical, love-starved watching world.

The visible church is charged with gathering believers and growing them in the means of grace (Bible reading, private devotions, daily confession, fellowship), rightly administering the preached Word and the sacraments, and providing both teaching and ruling elders who discipline themselves and provide church members with pastoral oversight and counseling as we grow in sanctification and godliness, manifesting integrity, hospitality, and charity one to another. Martyn Lloyd-Jones deemed church membership as “the biggest honor which can come a man’s way in this world.”12 I agree.

This is all very fine and good. Very lofty and noble and high-minded. But if each believer in my congregation took each vow to heart, we could be a transformed community, enfolding each other into vital fellowship and meaningful relationships. Membership is soul business, but its effect, if people fulfill their vows, will transform communities.

Membership exists to help us stay the course, to not give up when things get hard, and to be reminded in the wilderness of sin and doubt how to fix our eyes upon Jesus and his glory. Membership is not just an ideological position paper, delineating a set of theological pet peeves. Membership is a pledge to show up in each other’s lives. To be there in real ways. And to make sacrifices for each other. In practical ways, it means that church membership in the visible church ought not to be broken lightly.

As a pastor’s wife, I have seen the ugliest side of people when they start to believe that the sins of others in our church are intolerable, or when they pack up and leave instead of receiving the repentance of others, or sticking around long enough to work on reconciliation. The people who leave the church because they think they are too good for it have no idea the hurt that they cause—for the people who love them and miss them, and for the people hurt by the things they said and the things they didn’t say when they broke fellowship.

Sin hurts the church. Public sins cause damage to the name of Christ and build horrific stumbling blocks between image bearers and their God. Sin brings down churches and families. But sometimes the smaller, private, socially acceptable sins can also be horrific. The sin of failing to reconcile because you think yourself better than your brothers or sisters can rot the life out of the fellowship of believers.

In my history in the church, I have witnessed the way both public and private sins destroy lives and relationships and render the covenant of church membership to be a matter of convenience, no more binding upon the conscience than your YMCA membership. This does irreparable harm to the witness of Christ. Public sins demand public repentance and/or public church discipline. A public sin has a known perpetrator and a known victim.

The church in Corinth had to deal with notorious public sins: thieves, drunks, adulterers, men who practiced homosexuality, and a man who lived openly and proudly in an incestuous relationship (and then later repented, broke off his relationship, and was restored into membership of the church). But the church in Corinth also had to deal with people who got drunk at the Lord’s table, and people who used the church for their own ends and interests. God condemns both, and, with repentance and reconciliation, renews both kinds of sinner.

Importantly, church members are to be united in love, not shared social standing in the world of comparable lifestyle choices and interests. The Westminster Confession of Faith declares, “All saints…being united to one another in love…have communion in each other.”13 First John 4:10–12 declares, “In this is love, not that we loved God, but that He loved us and sent His Son to be the propitiation for our sins. Beloved, if God so loved us, we also ought to love one another. No one has seen God at any time; if we love one another, God abides in us, and His love is perfected in us.” Because God is invisible, if our love for one another within the visible church is evident, God’s love “is perfected” in us, or, completes us. We become useful vessels who reflect who God is. When he reconciled believers to himself, he also reconciled believers to one another.

The visible, local church is thus a community of believers united not in shared experiences or sociological categories or sin patterns, but in love. Diversity is necessary for real love for God and love for each other. One reason why it is hard for people to live in community is that we lack loyalty and we know it. We reason with ourselves that we will stick with a particular congregation until some precious line is crossed, and then we will pick up our church membership like so many marbles and take them elsewhere. With a church on every corner, we can afford infidelity, right? Loyalty to the church flies in the face of selfish ambition and self-love, as loyalty depends on personal sacrifice and the willingness to reconcile and forgive. Love for fellow believers should cause three things: loyalty within the local body of the church (and therefore resisting the temptations to break covenant vows for small offenses), opennness in confessing sin and seeking help for hidden shame, and fellowship with believers in other denominations.

Many sins work against this kind of love. One of the kindest things that church members can do is to check themselves against common sins that rip churches apart. These are, of course, big sins of adultery, murder, and abuse, deceptive living, hypocrisy, deceit. But they also include sins like gossip, anger, pride, and lack of forgiveness. Being a member of a church gives you daily practice at tending the graces of fidelity, respectability, hospitality, and peaceability. Failure to practice these graces leads believers who think more highly of themselves than others to take their marbles and find a church with “better” people. This may seem like a fair call. But there is a reason why people like this are called “well-intentioned dragons.”14 Disloyalty tears the church apart as easily as murder.

Every church split tells the unbelieving world that the church is a negligible artifact, a sentimental institutional relic at best, and not the triumph of Christ and his protection over the watching world. Every church split tells other believers that there is no real reason to join a church, suggesting that it is safer to just “rent” your seat until something that serves you better comes along.

Christian, if you trample on the church like this, when persecution comes, where will you go? When persecution comes, to where will you bring your neighbors?

Chesterton says that God makes your neighbors, even as you make your friends and your enemies. A similar principle can be extended to church membership: you don’t choose your brothers and sisters in the church—God does. It is tempting to think that if only you could choose your brothers and sisters, all would be well. After all, doesn’t it make sense that people who share the same hobbies and interests make for better brothers and sisters? Don’t you want your children to be around people just like them—and you? Wouldn’t you have more fun—and more friends—if the people in your church shared your peculiarities, sin patterns, and blind spots? Shouldn’t you break your covenant vows to your church to widen your circle of friends? Not if you are a true believer. If you break the covenant of church membership because you don’t like the people in your church, think about what you are doing. The Lord Jesus Christ died for the people you reject. You are trampling the blood of the Son of God under your feet.

The majestic hope for a world to which Jesus will return implies that the church is strong in love, doctrine, and community. Christian community in the home, neighborhood, and from within the covenant of church membership leaves believers wide open for love and friendship. Effective ecumenical love roots in God’s truth. And when this kind of love takes hold, chapter 7 of the book of Revelation gives us this word-picture as encouragement of what is inevitable:

9 After these things I looked, and behold, a great multitude which no one could count, from every nation and all tribes and peoples and tongues, standing before the throne and before the Lamb, clothed in white robes, and palm branches were in their hands;

10 and they cry out with a loud voice, saying, “Salvation to our God who sits on the throne, and to the Lamb.”

↑ Back to top

↑