2. Identity: The Flame of Our Union in Christ
The Flame of Our Union in Christ
I know that I am not the only woman who feels out of place in church culture. Maybe it is my Myers-Briggs score: INTJ. (I am told that only one to three percent of the female population shares this score.) Or maybe it is the fact that I am a marked woman. Rahab. Mary Magdalene. Rosaria. Maybe it is that I am much more at home in the world of systematic theology or critical theory than in the strange and scary terrain of wedding or baby showers. And often I long for just one person in church to understand me.
My past as a lesbian puts any number of well-meaning churchy women into a total tailspin.
I recall once chopping vegetables in a lovely country kitchen for a Lord’s Day fellowship meal. Sunlight was piping in through the curtains, and I was starting to feel at home in my new life as a married Christian woman. Another woman was in the kitchen assembling chicken and tomato sauce in a slow cooker. It was just she and I.
I enjoy the company of women, especially when we can be silent together, working in parallel worlds to build something. I have never felt the need to fill the peace of silence with empty chatter. She broke the silence with this question: “Is this safe? Being alone together in the kitchen?”
The question roused me out of my silence, at the same time that it baffled me. Kitchens—like libraries—are my safe spaces. What could be unsafe here?, I thought to myself. I must have had that dazed-dumb look on my face, because she repeated the question like this: “Does being alone with a woman bring back feelings for you? Those kind of feelings.”
Suddenly, the danger was exposed: I.
It was I.
I was the potential source of unsafety.
I felt that chill of isolation creep in.
She couldn’t even name those feelings, they were so dirty, or foreign, or dangerous.
I wanted to flee. I mumbled something about my being completely harmless, really, perhaps like an aged, neutered, and declawed cat, all the while wanting to say this: “Sister, don’t flatter yourself.”
I know.
Private fantasies of self-defense are unbecoming in a pastor’s wife.
I was perplexed that even though I was a new creature in Christ, that was not good enough. I pondered why my identity in Christ did not seem to be good enough for her, and it made me wonder, again, if it was good enough for God. And I was puzzled, as I have never felt that Christians who have or had unasked-for homosexual desires are unsafe simply on the grounds of these unasked-for feelings.
And I have known a lot of people who fall into this camp.
Why did she not see that my identity in Christ was bigger than my past? Because there is another category of personhood that takes preeminence: sexual orientation. I will share the problems with this category in chapters 4 and 5, but for now I want to return to this painful moment. I share this anecdote to reveal that personal experience matters. I daily long to be understood and represented justly. And although I am a new creature in Christ, my past, although covered by Christ’s blood, abides in a big way for some people. Identity in Christ, for me, always involves a healthy dose of war. War against the ghosts of who I once was, and war against the covetous machine of my own false entitlements.
In my church community, I want to do life together, sharing the joys and the ho-hums, and serving as general good company for the suffering. In order to have real community, we need to tell each other the stories of our lives. And we need to listen, even when someone else’s story makes us uncomfortable. For this reason, in part, I wrote Secret Thoughts: I want you to know from what country I emigrated, and in which country my citizenship permanently and eternally resides. I’m not a native speaker of this country. No real convert is. I will always speak in broken godliness, as new paradigms reread old feelings.
Music forms the backdrop of my rumination, and I think of the role of my past as obbligato—accompanied with harmony, and not to be omitted. Therefore, for me and for you, life experience matters. It cannot and must not be dismissed. We who claim union with Christ and a personal relationship with him have experiential knowledge of our Maker and Redeemer, and this shapes what it means to have fellowship with other believers.
The question is, How does experience matter?
The question, then, is not whether experience matters—because it does. The question is, How does experience matter? Does personal experience serve as a form of truth? Can you trust your feelings? We become proficient at what we practice. This is true for obedience and for sin. What relationship does personal experience have with other frames of interpretation or worldview (including the Bible)? What responsibility do we have to others when we tell our stories?
Many barriers arise and prevent us from seeing ourselves clearly. Pastor Ken Smith believes that a big barrier to self-knowledge is that we fail to ask the right questions and then we fail to use the Bible to answer them. Ken’s four questions about personhood are these: 1) Who am I? 2) What am I like? 3) What do I need? and 4) Where am I going? Let’s explore the first three of Pastor Ken’s questions in this chapter to help explain why identity in Christ matters.
Personal Identity in Christ’s Historical Work: Who Am I?
Personal experience and personal suffering matter to Christ. Personal suffering, including the suffering that goes with recognizing my sin as sin, has a way of blinding me. In these moments, I find the words of the Puritan Elias Pledger to be a great comfort: “I will lay the weight of my sinking spirit on the free grace of Christ.”1 They tell me that, even as I wrestle with my sin, I need to cling more to Christ than to my feelings. And the only way to do this is to invest in the attributes of God, the suffering of Christ, and the comfort of the Holy Spirit. If I create an identity carved out of my personal pain, even one caused by the sins of my flesh, I will forever struggle in a separate sphere from my God. For that reason, I believe that my personal experience must always be surrendered to what my triune God has done and who my triune God is.
My personal experience must be surrendered because it cannot reach back to God’s eternal and transient history. Our scope and scale is too limited. I cannot find my identity in what I have done. I can only find my identity in what God has done and is doing.
God set apart a people from the foundation of the world. In that way, God’s people—all who will believe in and call upon Christ alone for salvation—were elected from all eternity. Ephesians 1:4 declares this: “He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world, that we would be holy and blameless before Him.” From the foundation of the world is a very long time. It reveals God’s forbearance and his patience, as well as his special knowledge of his children, that he did not destroy us as soon as we were born. Because of God’s eternal purpose in Christ, salvation needed to come to pass.
God redeemed his people through the blood of Christ, baptizing believers through his death and resurrection. We learn this in Romans 6:
3 Or do you not know that all of us who have been baptized into Christ Jesus have been baptized into His death?
4 Therefore we have been buried with Him through baptism into death, so that as Christ was raised from the dead through the glory of the Father, so we too might walk in newness of life.
5 For if we have become united with Him in the likeness of His death, certainly we shall also be in the likeness of His resurrection,
6 knowing this, that our old self was crucified with Him, in order that our body of sin might be done away with, so that we would no longer be slaves to sin;
7 for he who has died is freed from sin.
8 Now if we have died with Christ, we believe that we shall also live with Him,
9 knowing that Christ, having been raised from the dead, is never to die again; death no longer is master over Him.
10 For the death that He died, He died to sin once for all; but the life that He lives, He lives to God.
11 Even so, consider yourselves to be dead to sin but alive to God in Christ Jesus. [emphasis added]
Each line paints a stark contrast between the binary opposites of death and life. This word-picture of water baptism highlights the spiritual realities of what union with Christ means. Each line calls me to move my heart, feet, and hands, and to do this today. We can only trust this hope because Jesus embodies truth. Ideas such as “have been baptized into,” “have been buried with,” and “have become united to” use a special verb tense called present perfect progressive. This verb tense is used to communicate that Christ’s work is finished (or “perfect”). While it was finished before we were physically born, because believers were set apart before the foundations of the world, we are living out today (present) the fruits of Christ’s work.
Mediatorial—relating to a mediator or gobetween.
Finally, the use of the helping verb “have” included in these phrases makes the verb something we call perfect progressive: that is, Christ’s work is perfect (finished) and progressive (living on, albeit imperfectly, in his redeemed people). Here we see that our identity in Christ is transient: we are who we are not only because of who we are today, but because of the meaning of Christ’s mediatorial death and resurrection in us. Thus, our personal experience with God has a history that precedes our consciousness. Just as our physical parents likely have memories of us that precede our own, so too God our Father remembers us from before the world’s beginnings.
The life story that I share in chapter 1 does not reveal the fullness of God’s perfect plan. It does not show the future glory God holds. And it does not show the history wrecked by the fall of humanity, which scarred us all through Original Sin.
Identity tells me who I am. And, consequently, identity tells me who I am not.
Union with Christ is part of the saints’ armor.
One more crucial gift that identity in Christ bequeaths is it gives me a way to defend myself against Satan’s accusations. Union with Christ is part of the saints’ armor. Satan is the father of lies and the great deceiver whose crafty seductions initiated Adam’s fall. When he attacks, he holds an ancient claim on me. Satan lures you into sin by suggesting that it is no big deal, that its consequence is not deadly. Hence his first question to Eve: “Did God really say?” But once you have sinned, Satan accuses you with the full wrath of God, a wrath that he knows particularly well and that he wants believers to falsely own as well. Satan uses the sin of my past and the sin of my present life as extortion. He daily tells me that if my sin was revealed in its totality, everyone would know I’m a fake, a condemned sinner. In my ear, Satan hisses, “I know who you are, and I know what you have done.” And Satan is right in a half-truth kind of way. He is right when he says that I have sinned grievously. And he is right when he says that God judges sin and that my sin deserves death. Satan knows Romans 3:23 also: “for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.”
But my identity is in the risen Christ, not in some moralistic notion that I am all cleaned up or some flimsy theology that says I only needed to repent in some general sweep when I “accepted” Christ. Because my identity is in Christ, like Christian in Pilgrim’s Progress, I have to set the record straight and what fuels my resolve is deep and daily repentance to God. To my accuser I say: “You are right about the depths of my sin. You are more right than you know. I am guilty of that and so much more. And you are right that God’s punishment for what I have done is death. But here is what you do not know. You don’t seem to know Romans 6:3–11. Do you know what this passage means? Because of my union with Christ, I was put on trial. I was taken into custody. I was spat on and stripped naked. I was thrashed with metal whips by Pontius Pilate. I was tortured. I was crucified. I was castigated to hell.
“And every time I embrace the means of grace, every time I read the Word of God and it convicts me of my sin, and every time I respond to God’s wisdom in repentance and confession of sin, every time I worship God and eat his body and drink his blood, I am risen from the tomb and resurrected into the light by the power of Jesus Christ himself, who declares to me that there is no condemnation for me any longer, because I am clothed in his righteousness by the power of his resurrection. The risen Christ in whom I stand declares to you, Satan, that you no longer have any claim on me.”
I have to have this conversation with Satan every day.
For that reason, my identity in Christ cannot be rented by sentimental attachments. It must be owned and sealed with blood.
Personal Identity and the Fall: What Am I Like?
My personal history, according to Ephesians 1, did not start with my conscious understanding of who I am or what I am like. My personal history started from “before the foundations of the world.” But things got topsy-turvy in the garden of Eden. Although I wasn’t present in body, because Adam is my federal head, it is back to the garden that we must go to see what I am like, and why personal identity is not of my own doing and not of my own definition.
Federal head—someone who acts on behalf of others as part of an agreement or treaty.
Adam’s first sin did not merely set a bad example or hold theological significance because it was a mere sin of origin—something that established the wrong musical key or held theological significance because it set the stage for bad choice-making starting at the moment of our birth.2 Sin is more complex and seductive than that. Sin has agency and intent. It is alive, and it is an active force in the spiritual warfare of a believer. Adam’s first sin is called Original Sin, and it imparts the reality that my consciousness fell thousands of years ago, long before my first birthday.
This means something that sounds unjust: I am not a sinner because I sin. Rather, I sin because I am a sinner, born with a sin nature because Adam represented me in Eden (Rom. 5:12–14). We are guilty from conception (Ps. 51:5), and wholly inclined to evil (Eph. 2:1–3). Our guilt is coram Deo—before the face of God—and not merely as a breach in human relationships. Through Adam, we inherit what is called the twofold problem of sin: guilt and corruption.3 Truth be told, this feels immeasurably unfair. But as we assess this feeling of unfairness, we need to remember that God graciously provides a better way forward in Christ than we would have had in Adam. Standing in the line of Adam is a presupposition and a premise to the gospel. As Joel Beeke puts it, “To deny the fall of man into sin is to rob the death of Christ of its redemptive meaning and saving power.”4
The term of the Reformers here—total depravity—resonates with me. Total depravity does not mean that we always do the very worst thing that we can do, or always sin in the biggest way possible, or that we are as bad as we can possibly be. Rather, it means that, because sin extends to every part of our body, being, and soul, we are totally unable to save ourselves from this predicament. Daily, we add to our inheritance in Adam by committing sins against God and our friends. It means that the best of our intentions fail us, and, even after conversion, indwelling sin holds the power of manipulation. Time and time again.
This is what I am like.
We cannot understand the ramifications of peace through the atoning blood of Jesus unless we first stop to ponder the way that Scripture describes anyone not in Christ’s relationship to God: as enemies in an all-out war. Indeed, when God sent his only begotten Son to become sin on our behalf, God saved us from one thing: himself. We cannot soft-pedal this reality: God saves us from himself. Psalm 7 records the war: his bow is ready, and arrows will penetrate into the hearts of all impenitent sinners.
Because our only access to God is through the mediatorial work of Christ, won hard through the bloody and immeasurable suffering of Jesus (Rom. 3:9–18), God’s fury is directed against every man, woman, and child who is not covered by that blood. Adding to this is Satan, roaming through the world like a roaring lion. First Peter 5:8 declares, “Be of sober spirit, be on the alert. Your adversary, the devil, prowls around like a roaring lion, seeking someone to devour.” The threat of a roaming lion is frightening enough, but also ponder the following: lions roar after they have killed and for the intent of scaring their prey into running from cover. This tells me that Satan’s threat comes with blood spilled and battles won. This is not a pretty picture. As Russell Moore puts it: “The canon of Scripture shows us tracks of blood from the very edge of Eden outward. The biblical story immediately veers from Paradise to depictions of murder, drunkenness, incest, gang rape, polygamy, and on and on and on, right down to whatever is happening with you.”5
The question hangs heavily: what is happening with you (and with me)?
The term sola scriptura gives comfort to the believer, because through it we have access to our full history. If we go to a medical doctor and we do not have access to our personal medical history, the doctor may miss some lifesaving detail. I am a mother by adoption, and I think about this every time we are at the doctor. The first time that my daughter was put on penicillin, she was sixteen months old. After five hours it was obvious that she was developing a serious allergy. By God’s grace, her allergic reaction was controllable, but it left me wondering: what other potentially lifesaving information does my daughter not have? As a mother by adoption, I learned of her penicillin allergy the hard way. More importantly, so did my daughter.
Sola scriptura—the Bible alone; the Bible’s grand narrative framing my own.
The same is true when we live our lives based on good intentions, good deeds, and well-meaning self-diagnoses. We, too, without accurate history from our lineage in Adam, come at things with a dangerous absence of information. Without the full history of Scripture, good intentions are not enough to accurately represent who we are and what we need. Our triune God is our enigmatic completion. The wisdom of the Bible is an alien wisdom, for without it we are clueless. Even after the Holy Spirit exchanges your stony heart for one that pumps veins fat with Christ’s blood, and you can walk in a Bible-on-life and life-on-Bible path, the war is still on.
Sola experiencia—my personal experience framing and shaping and selecting those parts of the Bible that I judge relevant for me.
There is another term, though, that daily competes for my allegiance. It is sola experiencia. Sola scriptura puts the hand of the suffering into the hand of the Savior by asserting the priority of Scripture to govern personal experience. However, sola experiencia separates me from that God—the God who made me, takes care of me, providentially allows for my afflictions, comforts me as I seek to walk in obedience to him, and gives me victory, either by granting liberty from temptations, or granting humility over how dearly I need the Lord’s forgiveness, kind company, and the renewal of hope through fellow Christians who love me and do life with me. Before I knew Christ, all I had was my personal experience and my best intentions on how to craft a life of decency in response to it. Conversion woke me to God’s blinding interrogator’s light, revealing that identity in Christ demands heroic sacrifices, sacrifices that can only be wrought by God’s power and indwelling grace.
The Bible tells me that I have a longer history with God than my memory allows, and it takes me past the garden of Eden to a majestic place called “before the foundations of the world.” This is the biblical story. This is the true story. But this may not be—and often is not—the real or experiential story of my deepest feelings. The real (the flesh-living fact of my life) and the true (God’s story and his grace to me) disengaged in the garden, when all creation groaned because of the fall, and when sin entered the world and writhed seemingly undetected into the nature of all people. When the real (what I feel) and the true (what God declares) do not come together, we feel a stinging vestige of the fall, with the painful knowledge that choosing between ourselves and God is a hue of death, only imaginable through Christ’s ransom.
When feelings are not translated through biblical wisdom, we become unmoored. We lose our anchor, and we wonder why God isn’t giving us permission to act on our feelings. This is especially agonizing when our intuition lines up with our experiences. Christians often use the expression “God told me” to describe a wide range of personal, intuitive decisions. We all know that it is very hard to distinguish a call from God from a burning personal desire. And even though we are new creatures in Christ, we still have a heart condition. Jeremiah 17:9 diagnoses our heart condition like this: “The heart is more deceitful than all else and is desperately sick.”
Our God is a personal God, and he does impress upon us—in intimate, loving, personal ways—his call on our lives, in all of its providential and sometimes heartbreaking details. This is why he gave us his Word. Proverbs 23:7 says, “For as he thinks within himself, so he is.” We are what we think. Ultimately, our intuition of God’s call on our lives must be arbitrated by the Word of God. As John Owen says, “The law grace writes in our hearts must answer to the law written in God’s word.”6 In other words, God’s grace does not grant permission to ramrod into sin because it feels good. Instead, grace answers to the law of God, found in Scripture, and not to the law of my own sin or personal desire.
God speaks to us through his Word manifested in our day-to-day lives. I started college as a music major, and one of my favorite classes was Ear Training and Sight Singing. There we learned to hear pitch and define it accurately, to read music and sing the note on the staff without musical accompaniment by recalling it to mind from the ear. We learned how to hear true music within our minds amid a world of silence or noise. We learned how to discern pitch and pathos no matter what else was going on. The same is true for Christians. We learn to discern the voice of God from the cacophony of the world and the seduction of the enemy.
Sadly, the voice of the enemy often uses our vulnerabilities and weaknesses to slay, rape, and pillage. Satan specializes in half-truths, in twisting the truth, and in appearing to redeem that which God calls sin. I often ponder those verses found in 1 Thessalonians 5: “Do not despise prophetic utterances. But examine everything carefully; hold fast to that which is good; abstain from every form of evil” (vv. 20-22). This passage reminds me that the exclusive claims of Christ will always have an edge; and I will meet that edge in the desires of my heart. In these verses, Paul gives us no liberty to hybridize gospel truth with the world’s cares. Because the Bible manifests God’s character of immutability, its wisdom—while composed before the world began—anticipates our need today, including equipping us with the wisdom we need to protect ourselves from Satan. “Did God really say?” was Satan’s question to Eve. On face value, it seems simple enough.
But nothing good comes of Satan. Nothing.
But nothing good comes of Satan. Nothing. Not even a question from Satan is innocent. The invitation to challenge God’s authority calls out the covetous beast in us all. But often we don’t even wait for Satan to ask before jumping into the pit. We long to sample a little of the world’s flavors, to try out some of its delicacies and ideas, and to not have to feel like such a freak who can’t stay apace with culture or popularity. Those COEXIST bumper stickers seem so wise at times, so friendly, so willing to meet people where they are. Sometimes we wonder: doesn’t unity depend on seeing things from the point of view of the world? How else can we stand with the disempowered? What is so wrong with that?
Identity in Christ depends on vigilance on this point: God’s point of view must become mine, no matter how foreign such a concept is, how impossible our situation appears, or how deformed an anomaly we become to our friends. Vigilance is an exhausting stance, to be sure, and I am grateful that Christ hangs on to me as I seek to apply those verses in 1 Thessalonians.
Satan’s first attack on me is often in regards to my point of view—just as he attacked Christ on his point of view during the wilderness temptation (Luke 4). I have met Satan more than once in the last two years disguised as a brother or sister seeking Christian unity and peace, often twisting God’s truth with heartfelt personal experience. Recently the pastor of a well-respected church asked me to meet with a woman who was part of his counseling staff. When I entered her office, she directed me to a comfortable chair and made one simple request: “Rosaria, I want you to change your message.” I found this a bold and disarming request, and so I told her that I come in the gospel of peace.
She said, “Change your message.”
I told her that I stand in the risen Christ.
She said, “Change your message.”
Finally, I asked her what I ought to change in my message.
She said, “Tell people that it is only in your opinion that homosexual practice is a sin.”
I responded by letting her know that I am not smart enough to have this opinion, but that this is the position the inspired and inerrant Word of God upholds. It comes to me from the historic Christian church, handed down to us from the Apostles’ Creed, through the pages of Scripture, and so on down to me. I told her that changing my message would involve denying the plain meaning of Scripture, the testimony of the church, the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus, and the gospel.
But to the postmodern mind, this line of thinking is no slam dunk. From a postmodern perspective, her request seems reasonable enough: just own this position of mine as a personal point of view. But claiming something that is a universal truth to be a mere matter of personal preference is a lie by omission. This is the Bible’s message, and apart from Christ, I am more condemned by it than the woman who made this request.
The question remains: is the Bible’s message regulated by my personal experience (if the shoe fits, then wear it; if not, amend it to fit your experience)? Or is the Bible’s message global? Are natural virtues good enough, or are we all, apart from Christ, unable to reflect God’s expectations?
Christian unity cannot be crafted by abdicating or disguising the named identity that God gives to us. We are called to define ourselves in and through him alone. Unity depends on biblical truth, and all forms of evil must be shunned, even when its form dances in our consciousness as unwelcome but persistent company. These vestiges of the fall in our redeemed minds reveal that our imperfect sanctification will only find completion in glory. What else can we do but cling to Christ for continued renewal through the fruit of repentance, hungry for heaven?
God wants us to hear his voice through the Word of God, the discernment of the Holy Spirit, and the comfort of our redeemed life through the blood of Christ. For example, musical pitch is black and white. It is accurate, sharp, or flat. It cannot be both accurate and flat. It is exclusive in its claims. While a chorus can sing in harmony or cacophony (dissonance), a solo voice can only be accurate, sharp, or flat. So too is Scripture. And even though words have what linguists call a semantic range of meaning7 (and I will discuss this later in the book when I talk about the use of the term “gay Christian”), let us be very clear that while words can be both used and misused, God expects us to find the bulls-eye when it comes to his Word and its meaning. That is, we can never explain away the plain meaning of Scripture or its historic testimony in the church by this. The Bible is a unified biblical revelation, and while it communicates through chosen men, because each was inspired by the Holy Spirit, it is God’s unified voice. We train our ears to hear God by knowing deeply his direct Word and the theological principles that emerge from it.
I am not talking here about the themes of Christianity that we create in man-made hymns or personal artwork or dance. Nothing that we create will have the power to save, discern, or sanctify. Christian culture may be uplifting, but never at the expense of God’s Word. Not one creation of ours will come close to the sharp edges and sanctifying blood of our Savior.8 We commit our lives to the Jesus of the Bible, the Word made flesh who came to fulfill the whole law of God. Our personal experiences matter, as they all happen under the watchful providence of a merciful and loving God. But our personal experiences do not measure the validity of God’s commands. We are not called to judge God, but rather to die to self. He is the potter, we are the clay. And our Savior stands inseparable from the Word: “He is clothed with a robe dripped in blood, and His name is called The Word of God” (Rev. 19:13).
Personal Identity through Union with Christ: What Do I Need? (Part 1)
Union with Christ is a concept that helps explain the depths and width of how the believer finds life only “through God in Christ.” Colossians 3:3 says, “For you have died and your life is hidden with Christ in God.” Reformed theologians teach that believers have union with Christ in three interdependent ways:9
1) immanent union—having union with Christ from all eternity, as God set apart a people for himself from before the foundations of the world (Eph. 1:4);
2) transient union—having union with Christ in his death and resurrection, and having our identity born of this (Rom. 6:3–11);
3) applicatory union—the present and ongoing lived application of how Christ indwells us and directs us today and forevermore (Eph. 2:5–7).10
Our union with Christ is through grace until glory. When we realize that union with Christ is foundational, historical, ontological, eternal, and remaining, we are more likely to surrender ourselves to be conformed to Christ’s image, and less likely to render Jesus our imaginary friend who kindly condones all that we want because we believe in him.
Union with Christ helps us to work through the limits of (present-day) personal experience. It helps me understand something important about my own conversion. It helps me rethink that Lord’s Day afternoon in that country kitchen when I was—for the hundreth time—misunderstood by someone who was supposed to see me as a sister in the Lord.
When the Lord entered my world, I experienced that gospel-ignited “expulsive power of a new affection” (to quote the title of Thomas Chalmers’s famous sermon). That new affection was not heterosexuality, but Jesus, my Jesus, my friend and Savior. I was not converted out of homosexuality. I was converted out of unbelief. After my life in Jesus unfolded through conversion and the means of grace that God gives to his people (Bible reading, prayer, church membership, taking of the sacraments), I realized that my sin was not exclusively a sexual desire for women. My sexual desire for women hinged upon another sin. It danced on the glittering tip of the knife of pride. I was dealing with a pride that rejected patriarchy as a flat-out danger and, combining this with a homosocial affinity to women that neatly morphed into sexual practice, it was easy to claim myself a lesbian.
I became that which I had formerly loathed.
When God saved me, the renewing of my mind made me feel like I was losing my mind. Everything in my life changed. Everything. Upon conversion, the fact that women were sexually off-limits was clear, and while my body memories still claimed my attention, these winnowed, and God gave me peace through my union with Christ. While throbbing and formidable, my identity crisis necessitated my identity in Christ. I became that which I had formerly loathed and laughed at. Eventually, God gave a deep and genuine (and somewhat ironic) desire to be a godly wife, if the Lord willed.
Sexuality in our fallen and even redeemed bodies travels on a complex continuum. God knows that (and that is why he is jealous for a sexuality that corresponds to his creation order, including a sexuality of sacrificial celibacy). When the gospel meets a sexual identity and practice apart from God’s intended order in the life of one of his sheep, Jesus places a yoke of love upon you, and while the burden of loss of who you once were does not feel light, as Jesus carries the heavier part of this cross, it is good. This is how I first experienced union with Christ. It made me realize that “it is good for me that I was afflicted, that I [might] learn Your statutes” (Ps. 119:71). The opening clause of this verse, “it is good,” is a hard one. It reveals that when you are in union with Christ, God blesses you through affliction, so that you may learn obedience. Even Jesus learned obedience through suffering (Heb. 5).
Union with Christ and identity in Christ conjoin because we are made in the image of God. But where does God’s image reside in men and women? John Calvin (1509–1564) situates God’s image primarily in the soul of men and women, as this is the feature that distinguishes humanity from all other creation.
While the soul is God’s fingerprint on humanity, the body too will be resurrected. The Westminster Divines point out that humanity “in the totality of…physical-spiritual being is (rather than merely contains) the image of God.”11 Before the fall, Adam and Eve bore God’s image in true “knowledge, righteousness, and holiness.”12 And although frightfully deformed, the image of God still remains in humanity after the fall as well. Calvin maintained that the fall did not merely mean that humanity lost a likeness of God. The fall was more than a crack in the facade. After the fall, man’s reason and will were both distorted and perverted.
The fall—The fall is the event in the garden of Eden where Adam and Eve disobeyed God and ate of The Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil (Gen. 2–3).
The first chapter of Genesis reveals creation before the fall: “God created man in His own image, in the image of God He created him; male and female, He created them” (v. 27). This tells us that both men and women are created in God’s image. Even now as fallen creatures, we were created in God’s image.
But after we are called by God, redeemed by Christ, and renewed by the Holy Spirit, God commands us to “put on the new self” (Col. 3:10). Ephesians 4:24 commands us to “put on the new self, which in the likeness of God has been created in righteousness and holiness of the truth.” This command is fleshed out more thoroughly in the surrounding verses:
22 in reference to your former manner of life, you lay aside the old self, which is being corrupted in accordance with the lusts of deceit,
23 and that you be renewed in the spirit of your mind,
24 and put on the new self, which in the likeness of God, has been created in righteousness and holiness of the truth.
25 Therefore, laying aside falsehood, speak truth each one of you with his neighbor, for we are members of one another.
These commands and promises reveal the equity with which God sets apart his people. These verses also show that there is always a gospel road into someone’s life because sin is the great leveler, formulating the comprehensive democratic condition of us all.
Personal Identity through Sanctification: What Do I Need? (Part 2)
Salvation is a great gift and mystery. God justifies the sinner through Christ’s atoning blood. He grants us the gift of faith. The power to believe comes from God, but the act is still our own. Christ infuses (or pours in) his hard-won renewal of life. Where, then, does salvation begin? It begins with God the Father’s election, his justifying love, and his legal pardon. Justification is an act of God’s free grace. God’s offer of pardon demands a response. When God calls a sinner to himself, we commit our lives to Jesus, the author and finisher of our faith (Heb. 12:2). Then we begin the lifelong journey of sanctification, being set apart and being made holy. Only Christ’s atoning blood meets God’s requirement of justice, and this is why, no matter how hard I try, I cannot save myself. When the Holy Spirit gives a person a new heart, the blood of our Savior renews the whole person “in the image of God.”13 The metaphor that the New Testament gives for this is death and resurrection, or dying unto sin and living unto newness of life. But what exactly does this renewal in the whole person mean?
Justification—the action of God declaring me righteous in his sight.
Sanctification—the process of my becoming more like Jesus.
Romans 6:6 reveals that sanctification equips the believer to go into the battle against sin, reminding us that “our old self was crucified with him, in order that our body of sin might be done away with, so that we would no longer be slaves to sin.” The promise here is not that we are given total liberty over sin, but that we are works in process. This process of subduing sin and having victory over it is described in the context of a battle (Rom. 8:13). Battles take time, bloodshed, and courage. This tells us that sanctification is a process, and it sometimes feels slow and circular. But if you are justified by God, you are in the process of being sanctified.
In a practical way, this means that while you may still have sinful desires, God equips you to not act on them. If you, by temperament and practice, have a problem with the sin of anger, God will give to you through his gift of sanctification (as you respond in love by applying yourself to the means of grace) the ability to control yourself. This does not mean that you will necessarily have a cessation of anger or angry feelings, but rather, you will have the ability to react differently as they emerge. As the Westminster Divines put it, in sanctification, sin is subdued, but not necessarily eradicated until glory.
We also see in Scripture that sanctification is not equal in all believers. Some people are given greater mastery over sin than others. First John 2 says,
12 I am writing to you, little children, because your sins have been forgiven you for His name’s sake.
13 I am writing to you, fathers, because you know Him who has been from the beginning. I am writing to you, young men, because you have overcome the evil one. I have written to you, children, because you know the Father.
14 I have written to you, fathers, because you know Him who has been from the beginning. I have written to you, young men, because you are strong, and the word of God abides in you, and you have overcome the evil one.
These verses reveal and give glory to God for different measures of sanctifying grace in the different believers mentioned here: little children, fathers, older children, young men. These categories refer not to literal age, but spiritual age: new believers to tested-and-tried believers. This passage reveals that God gives you your portion, and that we can trust that those whom God justifies, he also sanctifies and will one day glorify. We strive to work with God in sanctification by calling sin “sin” and by giving him our heart, but we do not strive against God by demanding perfection of ourselves or others. Through sanctification, God “[trains our senses] to discern good and evil” (Heb. 5:14).
Sanctification is not perfect or complete in any Christian in this lifetime, and this is not a sign that the believer is failing to do something (although we do need to keep ourselves in check and make sure that we are applying the means of grace in our lives). It is tempting to fall into the error of seeing sanctification as something that we do, and not a work of God in us to which we respond in love and humility. The Bible gives us one reason why sanctification is imperfect and unequal: our sinful nature, even after we are born again, lives on in us. Hebrews 12:1 commands us to run, even while acknowledging that we do so with the potential for entangling sin: “Therefore, since we have so great a cloud of witnesses surrounding us, let us also lay aside every encumbrance and the sin which so easily entangles us, and let us run with endurance the race that is set before us.” We often feel crippled by sin. But disabled or crippled, God still calls us—and equips us—to run.
I often speak to people who believe that God is not hearing their prayer because they have prayed their whole lives for God to take away the particular sin of unwanted homosexual desire, and he has not. I will address this specific issue more in the next chapter, when we look at the three kinds of sin believers must battle daily: original, actual, and indwelling. But for now, we need to remember that sanctification puts a wedge between you and your sin, and dislodges your allegiance to sin, but temptations may well live long. Temptation patterns linger, but they do not rule your life anymore and they do not define you. Temptation patterns are outsiders to your true nature in Christ. They don’t co-reign with Christ even as they remain. But if you are alive, you struggle with temptation. And if you have become an expert in practicing a particular sin, you can bet your bottom dollar that you have body memories that can recall this well-practiced sin to mind. I sure do. It is crucial for those of us with long track records of cultivating indwelling sin to know our enemy: woe to you if you grow sentimental about these loitering temptation patterns and try to make just a little room for them in your life.
Sometimes when I speak to church and college audiences, I am asked if I am healed. Sometimes the person asking the question will say: “God does not make people gay. So if your homosexual desire does not disappear in this lifetime, then you are either not a believer or not praying hard enough.” Both the use of the term “healing” and the “pray the gay away” philosophy strike an unbiblical chord to me, and I said that to my questioner.
In my life, I have experienced how the Lord has both forgiven my sin and delivered me from it, but that does not mean that temptations do not tarry. Sin is sin.
Sin is treason, not sinus trouble.
Sin is treason, not sinus trouble. God forgives sin; he does not heal sin. Indeed, there is something deeply deceptive about praying that God would give me only what I need to be strong in myself. The strength that the gospel promises is the strength found only in continued dependence upon Christ. We know from the Bible that not until glory will we experience full sanctification and the complete eradication of our sinful nature. But do not let this minimize your hope for vitality in Christ today. Today is the day of salvation and sanctification, for you and for me. Like Jacob, we must lay hold of God and not let go (Gen. 32:24–32).
One reason I am writing this book is that I believe we need a more stalwart understanding of sin, repentance, and sanctification to provide pastoral care to all people struggling with unwanted sexual temptations. We must stop seeing sin and sanctification exclusively as things that we do. Deliverance from a lifelong sin pattern means that you—with God’s strength—have the ablity to not act on that which God forbids, and to not love that which God abhors. It also means that if you fall, through repentance, you are renewed, knowing that falling does not mean falling away. It means that you grow in humility, knowing that you need the Lord every step of the way. God gives you victory over sin, but he does not lobotomize you. God warns us to not put confidence in ourselves, but only in him: “let him who thinks he stands take heed that he does not fall” (1 Cor. 10:12). God gives victory by equipping you to do battle with sin, and by giving you the humility to know that you need him every step of the way. Since warriors can get battle weary, God calls us to walk alongside one another to extend kind comfort. James 5:16 comforts us with this: “Therefore, confess your sins to one another, and pray for one another so that you may be healed. The effective prayer of a righteous man can accomplish much.”
We desire victory over sin because we desire to be ever close to God. “The nearness of God is my good,” declares Psalm 73:28. I long to walk side-by-side with fellow believers who are in the battle. But Scripture warns us against the danger of denying our guilt, even when the sin with which we struggle is unasked for and unwanted. That is, Scripture warns us against pitting our point of view against God’s: 1 John 1:8: says, “If we say that we have no sin, we are deceiving ourselves and the truth is not in us.” This tells me that what I need is the ability to see my life from God’s point of view. And when we have God’s Spirit renewing us daily, we have real hope that the God who has forgiven our sin will also deliver us from temptation to sin. I have tasted this sweet gift, and the Lord freely gives this grace to those who seek him.
We also struggle with the reality that God dispenses sanctifying grace in different measures. It is very hard for American Christians to see that God gives some people one cross to bear and others ten. Indeed, this violates our sense of fairness and justice. But we don’t get to choose the portion that God gives to us. And it is not Christian kindness to deny to fellow image bearers that following Christ is hard and will cost you everything. Philippians 3 powerfully reveals Paul’s ongoing struggle with sin:
12 Not that I have already obtained it or have already become perfect, but I press on so that I may lay hold of that for which also I was laid hold of by Christ Jesus.
13 Brethren, I do not regard myself as having laid hold of it yet; but one thing I do: forgetting what lies behind and reaching forward to what lies ahead;
14 I press on toward the goal for the prize of the upward call of God in Christ Jesus.
Like Paul, we are called to press on in God’s strength and continue our battle against sin. We can trust God that he knows what sin is. And if we are a believer, having been justified by God, we are called to respond to God’s gift with daily renewed love for God and his means of grace.
Through salvation, God gets the glory, while we who are saved and being sanctified, get the blessing.
If we rush through Bible reading and prayer time, we miss the blessing and the power. Often because of misplaced priorities, we unwittingly limp along on a starvation diet of Scripture, forgetting that we have an appointment with Satan, our deceiver and accuser, the minute we rise from our reading chair. Our time in the Word and in prayer should change us. Through it, we should be transformed, equipped, encouraged, and prepared. We should never neglect our Bible reading and prayer time, knowing that we do so only at our own spiritual peril.
But if we get the blessing, why do we sometimes struggle with shame? Why is it hard to remember who we are in Christ?
Shame is my biggest nightmare, and I imagine that if you also come to Christ out of a life of sexual sin, you might feel the same way. Shame is what we feel when Romans 2:14–16 hits home, knowing deep down and without a doubt that God will judge the secrets of men.
