Chapter 10 of 13

Epilogue: Marriage, Ministry, Children

Epilogue: Marriage, Ministry, Children

Epilogue: Marriage, Ministry, Children

Life at the Butterfields’ in Durham, N.C., 2015

Words are like table settings. They are washed and dried, cried over and polished, taken out of the cabinet, and put back in their place. These words from me on the pages of this book are themselves table settings. They express an invitation to come to the table, pour some coffee for yourself, and join me in my kitchen. Things have changed since the close of Secret Thoughts. Things have deepened since the close of Secret Thoughts.

We moved from Virginia to North Carolina in April 2012. That was a biggie. Next, the United States exploded with questions about marriage, rejections of biblical marriage, and introductions of gay marriage. That was a biggie, too. And because of God’s transforming work in my life, there are questions from the fallout of my conversion, from the train wreck of it all—good questions, but hard ones—that I receive daily, and that I have had to face.

Fix your coffee any way you would like, and join me at the table.

Push the crumbs aside, and never mind Caspian, the orange tabby joining us on the table. He is a new guy here, a little skittish and quirky, but with a big purr.

I am grateful to God that his transforming forgiveness is also a teaching forgiveness, and a discipling journey. The Lord does not leave anyone stranded. So, I am grateful that my marriage to Kent deepens and becomes more as the years go by, and that it grows out of something that the Bible anticipates: married couples who are “equally yoked” grow together in faith and life, in union with Christ and union with each other, till death do us part. As Christians, Kent and I share a spiritual compatibility, and the Lord has faithfully matured, ripened, bloomed, and increased each of us through this.

I—like you—am asked constantly what my view of marriage is. It is the question on everyone’s mind today. Of course, it is hard for me to come to this “what is marriage” question without hearing the speech-impaired minister (who never once pronounced the letter R correctly) in the movie The Princess Bride stumbling through a protracted verbal-marathon diatribe, oblivious to how his long-windedness is being used in the story line. And, the funny side of marriage is also a great gift from God. But jokes—in order to be funny—must rest on solid ground. A joke is something that we all know is not actually true. Because we have lost our sense of shared biblical knowledge about marriage, the joke is on us.

Many Christians cannot defend biblical marriage because we cannot define biblical marriage. I know that was the case for me. And unless we can define biblical marriage, we unwittingly become complicit with the problem, with God’s image bearers reacting to the great tempestuous storm of our culture by stumbling around like the psalmist describes these men as doing in Psalm 107:27—“They reeled and staggered like a drunken man, and were at their wits’ end.” I believe today’s culture storm is meant to lead people to do what the psalmist does in the line that follows: “then they cried to the Lord in their trouble, and He brought them out of their distresses” (Ps. 107:28).

Often these days, I am called to defend marriage: both my marriage and the institution of biblical marriage. After all, how can someone like me go through all of these permutations of affection? How could I have identified as heterosexual, lived for ten years with that identification, committed acts of sexual sin, come to despise it (the sex, not the sin)? How could I then develop sexual and affectional attractions to women, live in serially monogamous lesbian relationships for a decade, and, after coming to an understanding that the Bible is true and Jesus is risen, square off against my cavernous lust? And again, how could I have come to despise it (the sin, not the sex)? And then, how could I have married Kent after my train-wreck conversion? How could someone like me embrace this one-flesh union, seeing it as something that both transcends and transforms that messy bag of fallen desires that constitute personal feelings? How could I change? Did I change? What changed? How?

Some things are a mystery, and God’s work in crafting his people is surely one of the greatest of mysteries. One thing that helped me understand my role in marriage was the reality that marriage is never only about two people. When Kent and I got married, we believed that we were better for the Lord together than separate. We wanted to be parents, and to raise children in a Christian home, with a praying mother and a praying father. While God did not open my womb, he opened my heart, and gave us children through adoption. It helped me to see and experience this, to see the enlarging and opening and developing and becoming that unfolds when God gives children to a covenant marriage.

Over the years of our marriage, Kent and I have grown closer as our family has grown up. We have grown through the problems and difficulties of mothering and fathering, some issues unique to people who, like us, adopted two teenagers out of foster care. It has always been vital that Kent and I stand together and are not divided by children, some of whom are skilled defense attorneys for parental manipulation. Our children, especially our older ones, brought boatloads of pain and betrayal with them. They needed to be both protected from harm and disciplined. This is a hard line to tow when you adopt people who start out a foot taller than you are. Growing in my role as a mother helped me to grow into my role as a wife. Growing in my role as a wife helped me to grow in my role as a mother. Using words like wife and mother are light years away from my old vocabulary of partner and parenting. I have come to understand that I am not (only) a parent. I am a mother. God taught me that I am not a partner, but a wife. Men and women have distinct roles and gifts, and I am slowly learning this. Like most of my most cherished life lessons, I am learning this quite late in life.

In a practical book entitled What is Marriage? Man and Woman: A Defense,1 by Sherif Girgis, Ryan T. Anderson, and Robert P. George, the authors make the case that there is no such thing as parenting, arguing instead for mothering and fathering. When I first read this book (a week ago), many scattered loose ends came together for me. I must confess: I was more than a little hesitant to read this book. Books that rely on natural law tend to leave my stomach in knots. And because I read this book on a plane ride from Charlotte, N.C., to Tulsa, Okla., I did not want to endure a plane flight with a knotted stomach! But I was about to meet one of the authors and share a panel discussion at a conference, so reading the book was necessary and respectful to do. So I did it. I considered it my homework.

I read a lot of books for homework. But rarely has a book read for homework affected me like this. This book offered me the scholarly reprimand that I needed. I realized how my own vocabulary has been one of my holdouts for a worldview that still has invisible tendrils into my life.

So, here we are, at the close of this book. It’s a sunny and crisp February day in Durham, N.C., where February sometimes means short sleeves and flip-flops. Just today, a crocus popped up in the patch of leaves and dirt that I see under the homeschool room window. I texted that picture to my friends in the North under the caption: “February in Durham.” Just boasting in the Lord’s goodness. Not rubbing it in. Not too much, that is.

Kent is pastoring the church that I mentioned at the end of Secret Thoughts. We are a small church committed to hospitality and outreach. Kent faithfully preaches the Word every Lord’s Day, and we are always blessed when visitors join us for worship and the fellowship meal that follows the service. We gather weekly for a Wednesday night prayer meeting and twice a month for a women’s book study. I teach our children’s Sunday school class (on Pilgrim’s Progress) with another mom and other helpers. In a small church, everybody matters. Everybody counts. You know and are known. We celebrate the Lord’s Supper weekly, and the intensity and regularity of this sacrament brings union with Christ to the forefront of our worship each week. We sing psalms a cappella and I am one of three people who lead the congregation in singing. Nothing fancy. Kent loves serving God in this frontline way, and I love supporting him in this. We want to see our church grow in grace and numbers, and we covet your prayers for us.

Our teenage son is now a twenty-something fulltime fire fighter with his own apartment and life. Our adult daughter continues to live in another state and is happy at work. Our two little ones are old enough to make themselves mac and cheese when they don’t like the lunch menu and to shoot a squirrel with a pellet gun. (NB: when you live in North Carolina, squirrel shooting is an art and science that crosses the line from sport to culture.) My mom, who lived with us for sixteen months until we drove her crazy, moved into a retirement community and lives about two miles away. Our beloved golden retriever, Sally, died unexpectedly of a fast-growing tumor last June, one month after we were robbed and she was beaten by the robbers. Always stalwart and sweet to the end, we miss her ninety-pound presence daily.

We continue to thrive in our homeschool. We live in a neighborhood with homeschool neighbors and resonant friends, who share with me the highs and ho-hums of school, ministry, health, and daily life. Neighborhood children who participate in homeschool together have become great, good friends, and the woods behind our house are filled now with hand-sawn forts—fruit of the labor of long days of building life together after piano practice and math are done.

Like all good conversations, this one that you and I share here will close for now. It is soon to be dinner time, and I will need to nag (uh, prompt) the children to set the table. Forks on the left, knives on the right. We will set a few extra plates. We have neighbors and church friends coming over, as usual. I put out two pots of soup on the stove this morning (blackeyed peas—southern style—and a vegetarian Indian lentil curry). I will cut the bread that I made yesterday and toss a salad. Friday is a soup and bread night—or pizza night—because our homeschool co-op meets at our home on Fridays and it is a day busy with Narnia novels and keyword outlines and kids forgetting to take their shoes off when they race through our house. Maybe after dinner and family devotions, we will watch a movie and I will get out my knitting. I’m making fingerless mittens for everyone this year, using some old mohair from my Syracuse yarn stash. These are good days. Full with meaning and paradox.

Life in the Lord is always a good mix of meaning and paradox.

I leave you with a favorite prayer poem that captures this, “Valley of Vision,” from a book also called The Valley of Vision.2

       Lord, high and holy, meek and lowly

       Thou has brought me to the valley of vision,

       where I live in the depths but see thee in the heights;

       hemmed in by mountains of sin I behold thy glory.

       Let me learn by paradox

       that the way down is the way up,

       that to be low is to be high,

       that the broken heart is the healed heart,

       that the contrite spirit is the rejoicing spirit,

       that the repenting soul is the victorious soul,

       that to have nothing is to possess all,

       that to bear the cross is to wear the crown,

       that to give is to receive,

       that the valley is a place of vision.

       Lord, in the daytime stars can be seen from the deepest wells,

       and the deeper the wells the brighter thy stars shine;

       Let me find thy light in my darkness,

       thy life in my death,

       thy joy in my sorrow,

       thy grace in my sin,

       thy riches in my poverty

       thy glory in my valley.

Saints of old were often clear on a point on which contemporary Christians are muddled: you can’t defend the right to yourself (including your right to pursue things that God has forbidden) and at the same time defend God’s righteousness. We all are “hemmed in by mountains of sin.” In the school of Christ, we will “learn by paradox” that to lose your life is to gain Christ. In Christ’s strength, you must choose: you or God. If you choose yourself, you will always feel alone, even in a crowd or internet community of like-minded thinkers. This is because Christ knows you better than you do.

These are challenging times, to be sure, but these times are in God’s sovereignty, too. And we are to thank God for these times, as he has providentially used them for our witness, allowing us to speak truth to our neighbors and friends who do not yet know the Lord. If we stand in Christ, we are not alone. If we stand in our own self-defense, we place ourselves in exile. But Jesus is living and he intercedes for us. Jesus promises. He promises to be “with [us] always, even to the end of the age” (Matt. 28:20).

In the Lord, each day holds the promises of God for you, with renewed mercies from the Lord to guide you as you face new challenges. Who knows what great things the Lord has for us today? With eyes to see and hands to help, open and unhindered by the Spirit through Christ’s atoning love, imprinted on my heart by the gift of repentance. God alone knows the great things he crafts out of the details of our days.

Thank you, friend, for reading these thoughts. I pray that the Lord will anoint you as you pursue him. He is able to do immeasurably more than we ask or imagine, so pour out your heart to him. May he fill you with his truth, his salvation. May you walk in valor according to his calling for you, whether that calling takes you to grand or meager places. May you remember who you are, may you hold fast to Christ without wavering, may you contend for your faith, which is a precious jewel. May you test in the Word each little grace to see that it be sound and true. May our gracious Lord lead you into Christian friendships and family, church membership and community, so that you are strong in the family of God even when you are weak in yourself. May you impact the world, extending the hand of our Savior to the lost and the lonely, the despised and the rejected. May you be clothed in the armor of God, and go to battle against sin and Satan with courage, holding nothing back. Together, may we see revival in this land as we go from God’s strength to strength.

Amen. Peace be with you.

↑ Back to top

↑