Chapter 7 of 13

5. Self-Representation: What Does It Mean to Be gay?

5. Self-Representation: What Does It Mean to Be gay?

5

Self-Representation

What Does It Mean to Be gay?

What the Word gay Means

The word gay shifted from its historical sixteenth-century meaning of merry, bright, festive, and joyous, to a precise portraiture of male effeminacy in the eighteenth century, to a new kind of person in the nineteenth century, to a term affirming the inherent goodness of homosexuality in the twentieth century.

We associate the word gay with its twenty-first century dictionary meaning: a homosexual. Importantly, the term gay became associated with homosexuality at the same time that it became associated with homosexual liberation (freedom of oppression and stigma for being gay). The term was a contested one. Gay-detractors used it pejoratively, and gay-affirmers claimed it back. The Oxford English Dictionary (OED) traces word etymologies and meanings as they change over time, culture, and use. The OED shows how both the term gay and its political advocacy and affirmation of gay rights came into existence simultaneously.1

Later in the twentieth century, after the concept of homosexuality was rightly removed from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual in 1973, the phrase “gay is good” became associated with the term, a maxim intended to shift social focus away from illness and pathology to the asserted necessity of sexual orientation as a human-defining and distinguishing term, one that heralds a new wave of diversity.

Homosexual practice is not the consequence of mental illness. That is not how the Bible records things. God declares homosexual practice a sin from which we must repent. But the concept of sexual orientation blurs the relationship between personhood and sexual practice (desired or actual). Christians are called “saints” in the Bible. We who bear Christ’s spilled blood are a royal priesthood. Any category of personhood that reduces a saint to a sum total of his or her fallen sexual behavior is not a friend of Christ.

The word gay has a power and history that Christians who claim it as self-representation need to reckon with. When Christians embrace the moniker gay, we enter into the worldview that declares political advocacy, sexual affirmation, and the overriding philosophy that homosexual practice is good. This is in contrast with the biblical norms of fidelity within marriage and chastity outside of marriage. We can use words and words can use us. The meaning and interpretation of words in context of grammar and syntax transcend our good intentions.

Therefore, to the best of our ability to discern this, God’s intent must trump ours when defining a word’s semantic range. As Christian brothers and sisters, we affirm Christ in us and working through us by grace alone, not our patterns of temptations, special interests, or even our physical conditions. Our life in the flesh matters, but it is not the most important thing. We agree with Paul that our preference is to be “absent from the body and to be home with the Lord” (2 Cor. 5:8). The blood that ties us together and to our Savior and Friend trumps all.

Words, though, are unstable creatures. We need revised dictionaries each year because new words enter into the culture, and because words do change over time. In the 1990s, many people in the gay community (myself included) ditched the term gay or lesbian for the term queer. Why? In the sixteenth century, queer was an adjective and meant perverse, strange, bad, worthless, and counterfeit. By the eighteenth century, queer became dominantly used as a verb, and it meant to interfere with or spoil (“queer a pitch”), to swindle or to cheat. By the late nineteenth century, queer was a pejorative term used again as a noun to refer to a new kind of person, a homosexual.2 In an effort to take back the word, queer activists embraced it in order to remake it on our own terms. We believed that signs (words) and signifiers (meanings) could be reshaped by sheer force of use, that they were inherently unstable and only found meaning in our usage of them. We believed in the social construction of gender and sexuality through language. We wanted to claim this term on our turf, because once it became our term, it lost its pejorative power.

So, if radical queer activists can play with language to redeem it, why can’t evangelical Christians? If language has an inherent fluidity, why not use this on our own terms? Because as Christians, we need to practice what we want to model: a call to use words honestly. A call to use words honestly, in ways that correspond to God’s truth. And, while words do have a semantic range of meaning, we are never to use this fact to deny that God’s standard for obedience is the bulls-eye.

Words function in grammar and syntax. We need to not only consider their semantic range of meaning, but also their role in a sentence, that is, their meaning-making power. Andreas Köstenberger puts it this way: “Just as every nation has laws to govern the life of its citizens, so every language has a system of grammar and syntax that stipulates proper rules and conventions of usage for that language.”3 Adjectives hold powerful laws in the English language, and adjectival modifiers serve to change the noun they modify. Indeed, the word modify means just that: “to limit, to change the form or external qualities of a thing; to shape, to give a new form of being to; to vary, to moderate, to qualify, to reduce in extent or degree.”4 A modifier limits and reduces the noun.

            Semantic—relating to the meaning of words.

In the phrase “gay Christian,” gay is a descriptive or limiting adjective, and its job is “to indicate the quality of a noun or pronoun.”5 It indicates what kind of Christian you are. When a limiting adjective is used to define a people group, it is a mark of identity. When you modify the noun Christian with the adjective gay, you pair terms with incompatible anthropologies, and recommend a false philosophy of the soul. Adjectival modifiers create new nouns. The case in point here is the category of “gay Christian,” someone who both loves Jesus but is also, in attraction or action, persistently experiencing homosexual desires. The question is this: do we really want to say that gay Christians are a different type of Christian? Doesn’t that create the kind of ghettoizing subgroup mentality that works against and not for real unity in Christ’s Body?

Sometimes urgency creates the need to cut corners. If I feel my life is on the line, I will call out with an urgency that trumps all other rules of communication. Many people who identify as “gay Christian” are desperately trying to be heard. And the church needs to listen up, because the failure to listen degrades faithful brothers and sisters. The conservative Christian church bears some responsibility for driving brothers and sisters in Christ into this “gay Christian” ghetto with our blindness to the way that we have insensitively tried to fix or fix up all of the singles in our church.

In Christ, your self-representation is Christian.

When I question someone’s use of the term “gay Christian,” I am not saying that I do not want to hear about my sister and brother’s deep feelings and longings. I am not minimizing these feelings and identities and senses of self. I am not discounting the heavy hand of loss that these feelings seem to portend, or the deep sensitivities and character building that marginalization ushers forth. I am saying that I want to be your friend. And, I’m saying that if you stand in the risen Christ alone, your self-representation is Christian.

So in the phrase “gay Christian,” the noun Christian is changed by using a word whose sexual expression affirms behavior that stands apart from God’s commands. In this way, it is different from a linguistic place keeper that identifies cultural affiliations (like Italian American, for example). “Gay Christian” differs from Italian American because God does not condemn national origin as a sin, but he has much to say about sex apart from the covenant of marriage, personal identity apart from Christ’s exclusive claim, and self-representation that hijacks the appearance of sinful behavior and calls it grace. The word gay is only extricable from the sexual practice of homosexuality if you believe that sexual orientation is a morally neutral road map of humanity, and if it is a true measure of a man. Sexual orientation is no such animal.

It is not that adjectives can never modify the noun Christian, but they should do so in ways that neither create gratuitous factions6 nor violate God’s call that redeemed people identify themselves according to their new nature in Christ.7 New nature does not necessarily mean new feelings (although it may). “New creature” is a term that beckons God’s people to grow in Christ-likeness, to grow in sanctification, but we do harm to the call of Christ when we presume that opposite-sex desires should replace same-sex desires as the exclusive proof of real sanctification. “New creature in Christ” means that we have a new mind that governs the old feelings and a new hope that we are part of Christ’s body.

Is “gay Christian” a term of identity, as I purport? Why can’t it simply be a linguistic place keeper, one used to identify deep and abiding feelings that remain and even deepen over the years? A term that lets people know not to try to set you up with their unmarried cousins? Daniel Mattson quotes Chris Damian who defends the use of the term gay as just one adjective among others. In his article,8 Damian writes:

I am a man; I am American; I am single; I am 5'10"; I am hungry; I am tired; I am happy; I am studious…and I am gay. I’m not just one of these things, but I am all of these things. You could ask me to not categorize myself in terms of my sexual identity because I am not just my sexuality; but if you’re going to do that, you might as well not ask me to categorize myself at all.

Mattson says that Damian’s argument that gay is just one adjective among many is disingenuous. He shows by example:

Imagine a boy of fifteen. He wonders if he might be different than all of the other boys he knows. He often lies awake at night, crying himself to sleep in anguish about it. He fears his parents might reject him if he tells them. Could God still love him, if it’s true? And why would God allow this in this life anyway? He’s depressed and doesn’t know how he can survive and so he finally steels his resolve to tell his parents.

Mom and Dad, I don’t know how to tell you this, so I’ll just say it: I think I might be hungry.

We don’t know much about the boy in Mattson’s fictional story, but we do know that he is depressed and anxious and concerned because he knows God and God is speaking to his conscience. He is convicted in his conscience that he must not act on his feelings, and he does not know how to live with this. He feels that he has been dealt a harsh blow and he is fearful about his future.

Unbelievers would read this and say that the boy’s only problem is that the world around him has stigmatized the word gay. But believers see the importance here of the church family coming alongside the boy and the boy’s believing parents to help. Believers know that help comes not in destigmatizing the word gay, but in helping the boy and his family to do what all believers must do: mortify sin and live in faithfulness to God.

Gay is a term of identity.

No, gay is not just another adjective. It is a term of identity. Gay describes an intimate disclosure of real and abiding selfhood.

Words become culturally charged as identity markers when they stand for clusters of meaning, when their meaning changes from one cultural locator to the next, when their meaning arises out of political strife or liberation movements, and when they divide people according to political, social, or religious allegiance. Today, there is no keyword more explosively charged than gay. Raymond Williams in Keywords: A Vocabulary of Culture and Society situates words in “fields of meaning” because the “problem of meaning” is not resolved in either vocabulary, community, or culture.9 This means that a word whose definition changes because of political unrest or social transformation is not one whose contemporary meaning is stable.

Words matter. Self-representation matters. And identity in Christ bleeds union in Christ and communion of the saints. This blood is truly life-giving. And the term “gay Christian” has great potential to mislead people, even as those who use it are seeking clarity, honesty, and transparency.

What Happens to Identity When gay Modifies Christian: Nothing? Everything?

Let’s turn now to a Christian psychologist who supports Christians who identify as gay to be heard.

Mark Yarhouse, in Understanding Sexual Identity: A Resource for Youth Ministry, offers a pastoral guide to meeting people where they are. Speaking of the need to engage with people with “convicted civility,” a delicate “balance between holding convictions as a Christian and communicating those convictions with civility,”10 Yarhouse begins by defining his terms, and by distinguishing sexual identity from sexual orientation:

Sexual identity refers to the act of “labeling” oneself based on one’s sexual attractions or orientation. Common sexual-identity labels include gay, straight, lesbian, and bisexual. You may hear some kids refer to themselves as questioning, curious, or queer. Still others prefer not to adopt any label whatsoever. The difference between attractions and orientation is just a difference in the strength of those attractions and how persistent they are for a person.11

This is helpful. Affectional attractions are not sinful per se, because these attractions speak more to relational comfort or solidarity, and not necessarily to implied desire for sexual contact. But is this what most people mean when they talk about samesex attraction (SSA)? In our sex-charged world, most people use SSA to refer to sexual attraction. When the word attraction goes through the grist of culture, it implies a continuum of feeling, some affectional and some sexual. That is why the term SSA can be misleading.

            Continuum—progression of elements varying by minute degrees.  

But why would we subsume affection into the paradigm of sexuality? This is not a biblical understanding. Perhaps one purpose of the APA’s use of the term “affection” and its separating it from sexual desire (represented in the hyphenated coordinating conjunction, “and/or”) is to show the obvious: that not all people who experience homosexual desires are attracted sexually to every person of the same sex that they encounter. To those of us who have been part of an LGBT community, this is crystal clear and drop-dead obvious.

When I identified as a lesbian, I was never sexually desirous of each and every woman in my life. For example, I was part of a women’s running team, and many women on my team also identified as lesbian. A small group of us trained together almost daily over a five-year period (and two Guinness World Records!). We were the best of friends, and even though we all identified as lesbian we were never romantically attached with one another. The APA’s use of the term “affection” is meant, I believe, to help people understand this: that homosexual desire, even if consistent over time, is rarely indiscriminate.

But while the APA’s definition of sexual orientation defends people with homosexual desires from the misunderstanding that renders same-sex sexual desire indiscriminate, the paradigm can also distort or confuse the category of human affection by subsuming it within the category of sexual. When every relationship is potentially erotic, no relationship has the boundaries it needs. Maintaining a boundary around sexual behavior and making that the exclusive domain of the covenant of biblical marriage is necessary for platonic relationships to maintain their integrity as platonic. We have lost the ability to be nonsexually same-sex affectionate, and this is a costly human loss. But something else happens here: it confuses people about what is sin and what is not. Misplaced guilt is Satan’s weapon. There is no sin in homosociality—an abiding preference to find your closest and most meaningful friendships with members of your own gender. Nor is homosociality “gay.”

            Platonic—of a relationship marked by the absence of romance or sex.

Yarhouse also distinguishes between nouns and adjectives, not in terms of their grammatical purpose (how words use us), but in terms of their contemporary communicative purpose (how we use words). Yarhouse writes:

We need to distinguish between the noun (Gay) that refers to sexual identity and the adjective (gay) that refers to sexual orientation…. [I]n our culture today “gay” is used by nearly everyone (and certainly most of the youth in your youth group) to refer to a homosexual orientation. To use it to refer to identity only will be confusing to them.12

Yarhouse wants to make a clear distinction between sexual orientation and identity, but the line is not as distinct as he suggests. All acts of self-representation exist on a continuum, and a continuum allows for fluidity and overlap. We all have a deep need to know and be known, to let people know where we stand, with whom we stand, and where we hurt. I support this. But self-representation also embodies a sociological consequence, as self-representation has a community appeal to it. This community appeal means that others depend on who we say we are.

When we as Christians call others to come out as gay, as a desire to create community and to find role models, we are operating in the realm of identity, as identity situates you in time, place, and culture. To put it simply, you use words, and words use you. Both are true because grammar trumps good intentions. And like it or not, the Bible’s categories for self-representation are binaries: you are either saved or you are lost. If you are saved, you are saved for God’s glory and his righteousness. He made the categories, and you don’t get to blur the boundaries. As painful as it may be, salvation stories are often “single stories,”13 as lives and loves must be abandoned for the love of God. A Christian is not someone who blends, retains, or attempts to “redeem” enslavement from which Christ’s blood grants liberty, community, friendship, and belonging.

Yarhouse explains another value in embracing the term gay—it de-stigmatizes it:

Another benefit to distinguishing between Gay as a sexual identity and gay as a sexual orientation is that it avoids stigmatizing the word “gay.” Why does this matter? Because some Christians are finding it helpful to use gay as an adjective, as a way of describing and naming their experiences.14

With Yarhouse, I oppose invoking culture war mentality about homosexuality. It oversimplifies a complex issue and is violent, not only to Christians who experience unwanted homosexual desire, but also to the compassion of Christ and the witness of the church. But I do not believe that sexual orientation is a biblically neutral starting point for this discussion. Self-representation travels on a continuum, as words can describe or identify a sense of deep and abiding persistency (situated on the continua of self-representation and identity), and assert an allegiance (situated in community). And words carry different elements of stigma sometimes for biblical and pastoral reasons, not only prejudicial ones. Gay is a word that carries stigma because of God’s moral prohibitions against homosexuality. God is jealous for sexual purity in conduct and identity, and God’s people should be also. Stigma in the hands of God is replete in the Bible, for many issues.

Because the Bible is clear on the point that homosexual practice is a sin, and because gay is a synonym for the implied desire for or practice of homosexual sex, the stigma of this term is an act of God’s love, because God uses it to convict his children of their brokenness. When the culture wars raise the banner on gay, stigma becomes oppression, I know. But we would do well to remember that stigma reveals the gospel itself as a narrative of offense, and we who claim Christ as our Lord all began as his enemies, and all perceived the stigma of this exclusion.

While Yarhouse supports adults in using the term gay, he discourages teens from calling themselves gay Christians. Instead, he recommends they use the term same-sex attraction, as teenage sexuality is fluid and definitive labels are harmful.15 Yarhouse writes: “A teenage girl [should be encouraged to] describe what she feels—she has feelings for the same sex—rather than saying something about the kind of person she is.” In contrast, “a homosexual orientation is a bit different from simply describing experiences and feelings” as it “can also be a further step toward making claims about one’s identity.” This is important because “a person’s identity determines the choices he or she makes in life.”16

I wonder, though, why this same wisdom isn’t also applicable to all Christians who struggle with homosexual desires. Sexuality constantly interfaces with other issues, including hormones and environment. I wonder why it is not also useful for people whose primary identity is in Christ to maintain a linguistic priority that emphasizes their worth and dignity as a daughter or son of the King, first, and their sexual desires (persistent, even abiding ones) as secondary. Would this not provide better redemptive language while at the same time communicating the depth of this issue, allowing all to embrace the truth that God is sovereign even over our struggles?

The Bible is clear that all sex outside of biblical marriage is a sin. The Bible is also transparent that homosociality is not sinful. In addition, temptation is not a sin, but temptations to sin are never good. They are never from God. Therefore, patterns of temptation can never be sanctified. Sometimes they arise from our own sinful desires (James 1:14). Because of this, making an identity out of sin patterns is itself a sin, as it deadens the conscience by defending the flesh instead of disciplining the conscience for godliness.

Moving up the scale, homosexual or heterosexual lust is a sin—even the unintentional and persistent kind that springs up like a hiccup or a reflex. Like all continua, however, these terms are nuanced and require careful biblical scrutiny. And, men and women register these things differently, as men move more quickly to lust and women remain (often, but not always) more comfortably in the domain of affiliation and bonding. Somewhere in this continuum, we need to confront the facts that Original Sin describes a sense of self so primal that it is coterminous with consciousness, and that it levels the playing field for us all.

            Coterminous—having the same boundaries or meaning

Is Sexual Sin a Moral Problem or Physical Problem?

Is sexual sin a moral problem? Or is sexual sin a physical problem?

The biblical concept of natural fallenness is displayed in John’s gospel, chapter 9, when Jesus meets a man born blind. This man’s disability became a source of confusion for the disciples. The disciples wonder whose sin caused this man’s blindness: his, or his parents'? And Jesus explains that his blindness is not the result of sin, but the occasion of God’s display of power. In John 9, we read,

1 As He passed by, He saw a man blind from birth.

2 And His disciples asked Him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he would be born blind?”

3 Jesus answered, “It was neither that this man sinned, nor his parents; but it was so that the works of God might be displayed in him.”

Jesus then spat on the ground, made clay out of his saliva mixed with the dust, and applied this to the man’s eyelids. Jesus instructed the man to wash in the water of Siloam, and when the man returned, his vision was restored completely. Because Jesus healed this man on the Sabbath, the Pharisees accused him of unholiness, of breaking the Sabbath. Jesus made the blind man see so that the watching world could behold the blindness of the Pharisees. For those who had eyes to see, this healing was distinctive proof that the Messiah had come. But restored sight did not solve the healed man’s problems.

Indeed, after the Pharisees interrogated the man, and the man explained that Jesus had healed him, they excommunicated the man and his parents: “[The Pharisees] answered him, ‘You were born entirely in sins, and are you teaching us?’ So they put him out” (v. 34). Excommunication would likely have put this family into poverty, social shame, and personal crisis. This blind and now healed man exemplifies the paradigm of natural fallenness. Blindness, while a natural consequence of the fall, is not a moral issue. Natural disabilities have no need to be forgiven because they are not a sin. They are healed through medical care or supernatural intervention, or they remain in the life of a person until glory.

Sexuality can be fallen in both natural and moral ways. Intersexuality17—being born with both male and female genitalia, for example—is an example of natural fallenness manifesting itself in sexuality. Intersexuality is a medical condition. Likewise, environmental accidents that result in dismemberment of genitalia can also fall into the category of natural sexual fallenness.

Original Sin levels the playing field.

But homosexual lust or sexual practice is a moral issue, as is its heterosexual counterpart outside of biblical marriage. And sexual desire for someone of the same sex is just one of many vestiges of Original Sin. Original Sin distorts a person in the way that we are all distorted. It does not set apart someone struggling with unwanted homosexual lust as somehow more distorted, or inherently more broken. Original Sin causes the actual and indwelling sin. Original Sin levels the playing field. Original Sin posits what is true about all people as God declares in Genesis 6:5: “Then the LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great on the earth, and that every intent of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually.” We pray that the Lord would reveal how we have been distorted by Original Sin from our inheritance in Adam, and for the imputation of this sin nature.

Anyone who resists sexual lust through faith in Christ is a testimony of Christian faith and God’s sanctifying grace poured into this believer. This is biblical fruit. The man or woman who does this is a hero of the faith. The Bible makes a distinction between willful or presumptuous sins and hidden or deeply buried sins, and this helps us make sense of sexual desire.18 A willful sin is one you premeditate; a hidden one (including indwelling sin) takes you by surprise, as it rises up like a reflex or involuntary response, and often takes you captive, as it resides in you and not outside of you. God calls us to repent of both kinds of sin, although the former offers us a clearer sense of danger than the latter. Affection describes a state of being that is not sinful, while lust describes a desire for something that God says is sinful. These distinctions matter.

If the nineteenth-century neologism “sexual orientation” is not a useful place to begin our conversation about sexuality, where ought we to start? If I am diagnosed with cancer, I surely don’t reject the word cancer or the diagnosis because I can’t find the word in the Bible. But even if I go through a rigorous treatment of chemotherapy under the watchful eye of the world’s most renowned medical doctor, as a Christian I know that healing comes from God’s providential hand and that Jesus himself is the great physician; I know that this medically renowned doctor is God’s means, and I thank God for that. And when we use terms whose contested definitions fall outside of a biblical world and life view, and when we ourselves serve as the diagnosing physician, we ought to take great comfort in the truth that God himself will not leave us nor forsake us.

Kent, my husband, is an avid student of church history. He often says that, in Western culture, there have been few attempts to actually eradicate the existence of the Bible. Instead, it just withers away with redefinitions of words, both biblical and common ones. It renders the Word of God no longer a substantial part of the armor of God, but merely a pacifier. My fear is that the use of the term sexual orientation when used as a morally neutral starting point for a conversation about biblical sexuality muddies the water about what Original Sin really means. It forgets that Original Sin is everyone’s preexisting condition. There are moral realities embedded in the term sexual orientation for which Christians are called to account.

What Is a Biblical Sexual Identity?

Importantly, the first two chapters of the Bible lay out God’s definition of sexuality.

In Genesis 1, the created purpose of Adam and Eve is to nurture the earth, to steward it, and to procreate. I believe that the Bible teaches that Adam and Eve are real, historical people, not literary characters. Genesis 1:28 says: “God blessed them; and God said to them, ‘Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth and subdue it; and rule over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the sky and over every living thing that moves on the earth.” God’s investment in humanity is capacious and majestic. But God’s investment in humanity reveals that men and women are both complementary and distinct.

In Genesis 2:23–24, God remedies Adam’s isolation by making Eve and then separating Adam and Eve into a covenant family. About this supernatural event, Adam proclaims: “This is now bone of my bones, and flesh of my flesh; she shall be called Woman, because she was taken out of Man.” Adam and Eve are similar in their nature, vocation, and soul, but they are different in their sexual distinctions. Only because of this difference can they come together as one flesh: “For this reason a man shall leave his father and his mother, and be joined to his wife; and they shall become one flesh” (Gen. 2:24). That this is not just some descriptive analysis of an ancient family, but rather a paradigm for sexuality, is portrayed in the expression “for this reason.” Heterosexuality becomes the pattern of biblical sexuality: “for this reason, a man shall leave.” He shall leave. Future tense.

Fast forward to today. This business of one flesh as found in heterosexual marriage is by God’s design. The concept of “one flesh” is rooted not only in the physical reality of conjugal union, but in the potential to procreate. The Bible declares that Eve was suitable for Adam (Gen. 2:18), that it is God who makes marriage (Matt. 19:6), and that Jesus defended the exclusivity of marriage (Matt. 19:3–6). What makes a marriage, then, is God’s design. I have known many lesbians who have monogamous, committed, and faithful relationships. But even when we add civil legalization of gay marriage to this apparent reflection of common grace, God does not recognize these unions as true because they are not by God’s design.

Marriage by God’s design intends procreation, reflection, and anticipation. In the words of The Westminster Confession of Faith, “Marriage was ordained for the mutual help of husband and wife; for the increase of mankind with a legitimate issue, and of the Church with a holy seed; and for the preventing of uncleanness.”19 Christian marriage also reflects something of God’s nature. As image bearers of a holy God, man and woman complement one another in marriage. Biblical marriage anticipates Christ’s representation on earth in his bride, the church, as seen in Ephesians 5:

28 So husbands ought also to love their own wives as their own bodies. He who loves his own wife loves himself;

29 for no one ever hated his own flesh, but nourishes and cherishes it, just as Christ also does the church,

30 because we are members of His body.

31 For this reason, a man shall leave his father and mother and shall be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh.

32 This mystery is great; but I am speaking with reference to Christ and the church.

The layered interdependence of this metaphor—Christ and the church as original, and Christian marriage as a reflection—lays out that God designs marriage for his glory and for his reflection on earth. Importantly, reflections are only valid when the original is present. Thus celebrating marriage for marriage’s sake is not a Christian impulse, because marriage was never just about lifelong companionship.

People who are heterosexually married are not, by virtue of their marriage, more sanctified or more “whole” or more rooted in God’s will than single Christians. Marriage is by God’s design, but Paul reminds us that single Christians are more useful in building the church and the Christian hospitality community, because single Christians are not as beholden to domestic and therefore worldly matters. In a majestic celebration of the biblical importance of singleness, John Piper’s sermon “Single in Christ: A Name Better than Sons and Daughters” stands as a shining treatise.20 Piper ends his commanding sermon with four points:

1) That the family of God grows not by propagation through sexual intercourse, but by regeneration through faith in Christ;

2) That relationships in Christ are more permanent, and more precious, than relationships in families;

3) That marriage is temporary, and finally gives way to the relationship to which it was pointing all along: Christ and the church—the way a picture is no longer needed when you see face to face;

4) And that faithfulness to Christ defines the value of life; all other relationships get their final significance from this. No family relationship is ultimate; relationship to Christ is.

Piper’s sermon points us to glory, where there is no earthly marriage, where our sanctification is complete, where we inhabit the new earth in complete redemption, and where we finally know how to love God and each other in fullness of truth.

What Psalm 139 Teaches Me about Identity

When I was a new believer, a friend of mine in the Syracuse RP Church was an artist. Her art studio was in the attic of her house, and her house was a block from mine. One cold autumn afternoon, when I was struggling under the weight of my new identity in Christ and the war that it was waging in my flesh and my sense of identity, she invited me up to her place of refuge—her art studio. She was a busy mother of five children, and I marveled that she had such a room in this small, hyper-functional house where four boys shared one bedroom, with wall-to-wall bunk beds sometimes barricading the door. So Virginia Woolf-like, this room of one’s own, I thought. I walked up the creaky attic steps and followed her through an opening that more resembled a hatch in a boat than a door in a house.

There unfolded a refuge that perfectly reflected my friend in aesthetics, substance, color, and messiness. The room smelled of paint and dust, and it was simultaneously drafty from the bad windows and hot from the space heater. She swept away chalk, pencils, and fiber, and motioned me to sit on this new clearing. "The Psalms are my refuge," she said.

Our identity is in finding refuge in God. Nothing more.

Our identity is in finding refuge in God. Nothing more. Your identity crisis is good, she seemed to be saying. She opened to Psalm 139. This is a psalm about you and me. The “me” in the psalm is me—and you. Believers. "The Psalms are the words of Christ," she said. "We as Christians step into a multilayered embrace from our triune God as we sing them."

So we sang. We sang the melody for the first measure, and then my friend took the alto part and I took the soprano. We sang the whole psalm. Pausing in rhythm of our breathing, and stopping to meditate silently, and then, without announcing anything, starting up again. Psalm 139 reads:

1 O Lord, You have searched me and known me.

2 You know when I sit down and when I rise up; You understand my thought from afar.

3 You scrutinize my path and my lying down, And are intimately acquainted with all my ways.

4 Even before there is a word on my tongue, Behold, O Lord, You know it all.

5 You have enclosed me behind and before, And laid your hand upon me.

6 Such knowledge is too wonderful for me; It is too high. I cannot attain it.

The verb phrases here are powerful. God has searched me, he knows me, he understands me, he is intimately acquainted with me, he anticipates my words and self-diagnosis, and he puts hedges of protection around me. His knowledge of me is “too high. I cannot attain it.”

7 Where can I go from Your Spirit? Or where can I flee from your presence?

8 If I ascend to heaven, You are there; If I make my bed in Sheol, behold, You are there.

9 If I take the wings of the dawn, If I dwell in the remotest part of the sea,

10 Even there Your hand will lead me, And Your right hand will lay hold of me.

11 If I say, “Surely the darkness will overwhelm me, And the light around me will be as night,”

12 Even the darkness is not dark to You, And the night is as bright as the day. Darkness and light are alike to You.

God’s Spirit is omniscient. He rules all dominions, including hell itself. And because of this, when our sexual desires make us feel as though we “dwell in the remotest part of the sea,” and that “darkness will overwhelm me,” God tells us that if we make our home (including our identity) with him, he will guide us safely, because to him, darkness does not disable.

Importantly, God does not say that darkness will not terrify me or that if we find others who share our feelings, we will at least dwell in the remotest part of the sea with company. No. He tells us to come to him. Jesus echoes this when he beckons: “Come to Me, all who are weary and heavy-laden, and I will give you rest. Take My yoke upon you and learn from Me, for I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for your souls. For My yoke is easy and My burden is light” (Matt. 11:28–30). Psalm 139 continues:

13 For You formed my inward parts; You wove me in my mother’s womb.

14 I will give thanks to You, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made; Wonderful are your works, And my soul knows it very well.

15 My frame was not hidden from You, When I was made in secret, And skillfully wrought in the depths of the earth;

16 Your eyes have seen my unformed substance; And in Your book were all written The days that were ordained for me, When as yet there were not one of them.

God is with us both in the remotest part of the sea and from before the foundations of the world, when our substance was unformed, but our destiny fully displayed before our Maker. He formed our most intimate substance, and we are to give him thanks, for each one of his children is “fearfully and wonderfully made.”

17 How precious are Your thoughts to me, O God! How vast is the sum of them!

18 If I should count them, they would outnumber the sand. When I awake, I am still with You.

As we dwell on God’s nature (and by implication, a foreign nature, not our own), our paradigm shifts. Because we are frail and he is not, and because he is for us, our hope lifts. Question 4 of The Westminster Shorter Catechism is one whose answer I dwell on when I sing Psalm 139. In answering the question, “What is God?” it declares: “God is a Spirit, infinite, eternal, and unchangeable, in his being, wisdom, power, holiness, justice, goodness, and truth.”21 When I ponder these words of the catechism, I am sitting under the wisdom of the great cloud of witnesses, and participating in a multi-historical communion of the saints. I am, in all of my doubts, fears, and brokenness, surrounded by help.

19 O that you would slay the wicked, O God; Depart from me, therefore, men of bloodshed.

20 For they speak against you wickedly, And Your enemies take your name in vain;

21 Do I not hate those who hate You, O LORD? And do I not loathe those who rise up against You?

22 I hate them with the utmost hatred; They have become my enemies.

These are hard words, as they show that not all enemies will be reconciled through true repentance in Christian friendship. These words model that Christians are at times called to break allegiances with people.

As I write these words, Christians around the world are praying for the breakdown of wicked forces who have become killing machines and regimes in the Middle East. A friend last night at prayer meeting talked about viewing a YouTube video that displayed a brutal beheading, and how he wished he had not viewed that video, as the images of the murder scene haunt him day and night.

Our tendency is to find others who sin like we do.

I understand how he feels. All sin against God, all wickedness, finds its ultimate end in murder. Therefore, our loyalty must be to God, and it must go so deep that we own God’s attitude about sin, especially when it comes to dealing with our own sin. Our tendency is to find others who sin just like we do, so that we won’t be alone. We search for role models, so that we might minimize the sinfulness of our sin. We enlist others to help us in calling our sin a sanctifying grace. But we ought to quake in fear when we we find ourselves traveling that path. Because without intending it, such “covering” of sin renders us enemies of God, and not friends.

23 Search me, O God, and know my heart; Try me and know my anxious thoughts;

24 And see if there be any hurtful way in me, And lead me in the everlasting way.

God must search us to unearth our buried motives and providential prospects. We cannot search ourselves using the wisdom of the world. Self-knowlege is God’s handiwork. And, when God exposes sin, he does this to call us to repentance unto life, such that the path to the “everlasting way” is rendered clear. This is God’s promise to all. The “whole” Christian, in matters of faith and repentance, must come to God alone and on God’s terms. This psalm gives me great comfort, as it helps me hand over the reins to God in all matters of identity and fear.

Do Christians, the Church, or the Witness of Christ Benefit from Asserting Sexual Identities Apart from Biblical Marriage?

Do we see anything in the Bible about compatibility, sexual orientation, gender identity, mixed-orientation marriages, and so forth? Is the Bible silent about these things? Hardly. The Bible is replete with examples of human diversity, including experiences felt and lived by sexual minorities. What does this say about all of us, in all of our brokenness and frailty?

Sam Allberry says it best: “Desires for things God has forbidden are a reflection of how sin has distorted me, not how God has made me.”22 So while marriage is by God’s design, God does not design every person for marriage. And that is because he needs single men and women to be on the front lines of ministry. But that does not mean that their biblically married friends abandon them on the front line alone.

As all Christians attempt to discern matters of sin and grace and work together to give God glory in all of the details of our lives, I fear that our current language (i.e., sexual orientation, mixed-orientation marriage, gay Christian) is creating its own Tower of Babel in our churches. God created men and women so that we would enjoy him forever (eternally) and so that we would give him glory (on earth and in heaven). But when we even unwittingly create subcategories of Christians based in patterns of sexual sin, we are in effect taking aim at the very God who will safely hedge us in as we feel lost in the depth of the sea, as Psalm 139 outlines.

When we create subcategories of Christians to minimize the power of sin to seduce, we no longer share the same refuge that God promises in the Psalms, and the identity as refuge-takers that God offers. This becomes a problem not just for the individual Christian, who struggles to see God’s love in the reality of his or her brokenness, but also for the Christian community at large and the visible church. As Richard Baxter put it long ago:

It is almost incredible how much ground the devil takes when he has once made sin a matter of controversy: some are of one mind, and some of another; you are of one opinion, and I am of another. If it were ever a controversy whether drunkenness, sexual promiscuity, swearing, stealing, or any villainy were a sin or not, it would be committed more commonly and with much less regret of conscience. By this means, good men themselves are dangerously disabled to resist sin, and are more prepared to commit it. Take heed lest the devil cast you into this sleep of carnal security.23

Our choice of vocabulary is no small thing. It may very well be the life jacket that keeps you afloat in this “sleep of carnal security” that we call the new normal. So, what ought we to do?

Christian love that is stronger than the lines that divide believers is the only response. I propose that we develop and maintain real Christian love for all believers, especially people who think differently than we do.

We need to make a committed effort to live out 2 Corinthians 13:11: “Be made complete, be comforted, be like-minded, live in peace; and the God of love and peace will be with you.” This stands in direct contradiction to the spirit of contention. Avoiding strife and contention was so important to the great Jonathan Edwards, the eighteenth-century American theologian, that his famous “Farewell Sermon” to his congregation ended with these words:

However wrong you may think others have been, maintain with great diligence and watchfulness a Christian meekness and gentleness of spirit; and labor, in this respect, to excel those who are of a contrary part…. And never think you behave yourselves as becomes Christians, except when you sincerely, sensibly, and fervently love all men, of whatever party or opinion, and whether friendly or unkind, just or injurious, to you or your friends, or to the cause and kingdom of Christ.24

Peace does not come naturally. Peace must be pursued.

↑ Back to top

↑