Chapter 8 of 13

6. Conflict: When Sisters Disagree

6. Conflict: When Sisters Disagree

6

Conflict

When Sisters Disagree

When Christians are divided on key issues, we must stop and listen. Because we agree that God’s glory is the ultimate end of all things, we know all who are washed clean in the blood of Christ are on the same team. We therefore ought to stop and make sure that we are really listening to each other. Not the “yes, but” listening that pounces on every point of contention. But listening with empathy. To bring our conversation about sexual identity and union with Christ to a more personal level, I want to introduce you to a friend who uses the self-representation “gay Christian.”

One thing to do when we are at an impasse with another Christian is to shut our mouths and give our Christian sister our full attention. I am grateful for my friend Rebecca and for her willingness to write this email to me (and to allow me to share our dialogue with you). This represents one email of many that we have exchanged over the past two years. You see, we are sisters in the Lord, but we disagree. And we are friends, and we disagree. Rebecca wrote this email out of love, and I share it out of love. Please hear my friend.

Since I was six years old and asked Jesus to fill me and guide my life, no other identity has meant more to me than the one I have in Christ. When I say I am gay, I am not taking on an identity. Nor do I have any desire to make my sexual orientation my identity. For me, saying I am gay is about being honest: I am attracted to other women. I didn’t choose that. But it’s real and it has significantly affected my life. Naming my reality is crucial. When things have no words, they remain confused and chaotic. Naming helps us to make sense of the world so we can live in it. In terms of language theory, language provides order. It’s like the person who has an ailment who goes from doctor to doctor desperately trying to figure out what is wrong and is finally relieved when the condition can be named. For me the word gay is no different than saying “I am deaf” or “I am quadriplegic.” It simply refers to the truth that I have an enduring affliction (whether based in biology or environment) that has not been healed despite many years of prayers. Some conditions are not healed this side of heaven. Like Paul, sometimes God allows a thorn to remain for his purposes.

Over the past twenty years I have wrestled with this question of how to be truthful about my reality. For a while I chose to say “I have same-sex attraction.” I was part of the ex-gay movement at the time and using the term gay was frowned upon. We were encouraged to make contradictory and deceptive statements like, “I am not gay; I just have same-sex attraction.” But I saw the tragic effects of that deception firsthand. I witnessed people rush prematurely into heterosexual marriages believing they were no longer gay. I saw leaders in the movement leave their spouses after ten or twenty years when the promised heterosexuality never transpired. And I have seen far too many return to samesex relationships after years of celibacy, having become disillusioned that they were, in fact, still gay. Conservative Christians capitalized on this deception too. They took these ex-gay testimonies of “I am not gay” as literally true. Court arguments against same-sex marriage and other legislation have been made on the basis of alleged change in sexual orientation. I am not saying no one changes their sexual orientation, but it’s much more complicated than many conservatives have been willing to admit. I have seen the marriages of some of these Religious Right poster children crash and burn to the ground under the weight of the deception “I am not gay.”

In the past, gay meant an identity closely associated with the rise of LGBT rights. But a lot has changed in the last fifteen years. In today’s lexicon, gay no longer means an identity. Most people under the age of thirty associate the term, not with identity or behavior, but with attraction. Merriam-Webster.com defines gay as “sexually attracted to someone who is the same sex.” Dictionary.com has “of, pertaining to, or exhibiting sexual desire or behavior directed toward a person or persons of one’s own sex; homosexual.” The conservative Christian world is one of the only places where gay still means primarily an identity associated with a sociopolitical community. The problem that develops when Christians use privatized language to define terms in contradiction to common lexical use is the risk of appearing as liars. We know what we mean by our terms, but non-Christians don’t. So when we say “I am not gay” but in truth we still have samesex attraction, we come across as frauds. We defame the cause of Christ by the appearance of deception.

Any Christian who objects to the use of the term gay need thoughtfully reckon with these legitimate concerns and propose alternatives that avoid the pitfalls of deception. It will not do to resort to theological abstractions about Original Sin or pat answers about sexual orientation change. The church needs to let go of its defensiveness and ask itself these questions: How do we help a young person come to grips with a potentially lifelong condition so that hope deferred doesn’t lead to disillusionment and abandonment of the faith? How do we help couples in mixed orientation marriages hold on to their marriages? What do we need to do to make lifelong celibacy a viable option in our culture for those who face that reality? How can we think cross-culturally and missionally with non-Christians who easily misinterpret our theological jargon so we don’t harm the cause of Christ?

I stand in solidarity with Rebecca on many key issues, and I am enlightened by her life journey. I share her desire for truthful self-representation, and acknowledge that sexuality rests on a continuum, ranging between fixedness and fluidity. Christopher Yuan often says it this way: God is able, but not obligated, to give you what you ask for. I heartily agree. Sexuality is not a choice (although sexual activity is). Nor is it a lifestyle—something that you put on and off with ease. I believe Rebecca when she says that sexuality is not for her an identity: that her full identity is in Christ. Rebecca and I agree that sanctification is not coterminous with heterosexuality.

Is my own experience clouding my ability to hear Rebecca’s, because, for me, my lesbianism was both an identity and sexual practice, and the scholarship that organized my life at the time corroborated this? Probably. My community and I valued and lived something called “identity politics.”1 But that is not Rebecca’s reality. Rebecca leaves us with this question: “The church needs to let go of its defensiveness and ask itself: How do we help a young person come to grips with a potentially lifelong condition so that hope deferred doesn’t lead to disillusionment and abandonment of the faith?” Although friends and prayer partners (we have never left a phone call without praying together), do Rebecca and I talk past each other, our different life experiences framing what we say and hear? Yes.

Share real life together in real time.

Rebecca asks me how do we help a young person (or old person) struggling with homosexual desires? My answer is to come to the table together. Stand side by side. Share real life together in real time. We do the same thing we would do with any other sister or brother, any other image bearer, and any other soul. We open our hearts and our homes. We open the Word. We answer the phone at midnight, and we interrupt in a permanent, consistent, and organic way seasons of loneliness for our friend. We find out where the hard places are and bring in comfort. And we keep an eagle eye on our own prejudices and assumptions, our privileges and our blind spots. We stop telling people that their problems are not big. We don’t flatten the terrain of unwanted homosexual desire by using analogies that may not fit. For example, we must stop claiming that the singleness experienced by people with unwanted homosexual desires is just like heterosexual singleness. For some, this may be so. But for others, the unique fingerprint of pain and loneliness conjured by unwanted homosexual desire is brought to a place of agony by such comparisons. In other words, we listen and we create real and regular friendship.

Rebecca is sharing her heart and also her experience in the “ex-gay” movement. This culture was shaped in part by theories rooted in Reparative Therapy2 and its claim that homosexuality is the result of experiences (trauma, bad parenting, sexual abuse) and its solution is heterosexuality. It often encouraged a “prosperity gospel” approach to sexual healing and exaggerated success rates in “conversion” from homosexual attraction to heterosexual attraction—according to Rebecca and many others who have been eye witnesses to such deception—setting this shift into heterosexuality as its most treasured goal, and bypassing the importance of glorifying Christ in our struggle. Reparative Therapy programs often made promises they couldn’t deliver, and broke the hearts and faith of many of their followers. God loves his people in our brokenness, and saved us when we were dead. If God was sovereign over the fall of humanity, is it so hard to imagine that he is sovereign over our fallen nature as well, in all of its manifestations and details, including for some people persistent unwanted homosexual desire? The issue here is saving faith.

Rebecca is my sister and my friend. I want to come up alongside of her—and have her come up alongside of me—and put this before the Lord, as we walk in faith and obedience. It is impossible to deal with the humiliating details of our lives while the logs in the eyes of others are clobbering around like drunken drivers. I imagine that this problem posed by clobbering logs is a little how it feels when I ask Rebecca not to use the word gay to refer to her sexuality.

Terms of self-representation can be honest declarations. But language emerges from different philosophical and theological commitments. When I say that Original Sin explains that we are all born this way, I am not intending a “theological abstraction” or suggesting that some people don’t have heavier crosses to carry than others. Because of our fallen nature, sin is a sharp nail stuck in the flesh of our earliest consciousness, wedged in there from before the foundations of the world. For some people, that imprint of Original Sin takes the form of unwanted homosexual desires. Even after regeneration by the Holy Spirit, our sanctification can be slower than we want.

To me, Original Sin is a democratizing idea.

In Christ, though, sanctification is a gift from God, not a willful act. If we live in the means of grace, then the pace of sanctification is God’s blessing, and we should not disparage God’s good gift by seeing it as paltry. So to me, the fact that our primal sins are also original to our consciousness is not meant as an assault or a minimizing of their power and presence. To me, Original Sin is a democratizing idea.

Rebecca refers to her sexuality as an enduring affliction, in part because Rebecca is committed to chastity and, unlike what I had done, Rebecca does not act on a sexual desire that dishonors God. But even enduring afflictions come to us from the fall, rendering neither “biology” nor “environment” neutral, sinless realities. She asks us to see that there is diversity among people who struggle with homosexuality. Rebecca says that for some, same-sex attraction is natural fallenness, while for others, it is moral fallenness. She asserts that if homosexuality is the consequence of moral fallenness—as it was for me—we would expect it to diminish in the sanctification process as we grow in the fruit of the Spirit. But I do not read sanctification in the light of a dramatic change of feelings, but rather, in the heart change that lives sacrificially for Christ in obedience to his will, in spite of feelings that run counter to God’s command.

Rebecca stands in a different place than I did. She is devout and godly, and shares with us that she has experienced little change in her homosexual desires even as she has grown in the fruit of the Spirit and in sanctifying grace in other areas of her life. To me, her ability to exercise godly self-control over unwanted sexual desires is a shining example of sanctification. Rebecca concludes that the fallenness of her sexuality is like a physical disability. She reminds us that while God does promise growth in sanctification during this lifetime, God does not promise natural/physical healings.

Are we, Rebecca and I, disagreeing over words or more? And what ought we to do with this?

Have we broken fellowship, broken communion of the saints, with Christians who identify as gay because we can’t get our vocabulary and the theology from which it emerges squared up at the get-go?

Can I walk side-by-side with my friend Rebecca even though we disagree on the use of the adjective gay for any Christian?

Yes.

Am I being politically correct?

No. I’m being biblically correct.

Can we open the Word together, pray together, and praise God as we are shattered? If not, why not? If Rebecca was my neighbor (and I’m praying for this), could we also worship together, bake bread, play cards with Kent and the children, serve meals at a shelter, share books, walk the dogs? I would like that.

Rebecca is my friend, but she is also a covenant child and a godly daughter of the King.

As Rebecca writes:

The conservative Christian world is one of the only places where gay still means primarily an identity associated with a sociopolitical community. The problem that develops when Christians use privatized language to define terms in contradiction to common lexical use is the risk of appearing as liars. We know what we mean by our terms, but non-Christians don’t. So when we say “I am not gay” but in truth we still have same-sex attraction, we come across as frauds. We defame the cause of Christ by the appearance of deception.

We do not want to come across as frauds. We do not want to defame the cause of Christ by the sin of self-deception. I support my friend’s right to accurate self-disclosure, to knowing and being known, to living in a Christian community where she is not daily or hourly assaulted by extra-biblical teaching about what a changed life in Christ looks like. I share with Rebecca the desire that when unbelievers overhear or engage Christians, we are people who speak with clarity and truth. I desire that laws of grammar and syntax, laws that we use to create communities of interpretative clarity, be honored. I support Rebecca in wanting to be known for how she struggles in the intimacy of her church community. I also hear Rebecca when she asserts that the under-thirty crowd interprets gay differently than I do. What we hear is important. What God intends is important, too.

Rebecca advocates for her right to name her experience, to be honest about her lived reality, and to not pretend that they are not what they really are. But she also puts forth a challenge, and not one that I can meet alone. If I don’t like the term gay, what is a better form of self-representation?

I propose “living in chastity with unwanted homosexual desires.” I propose this because it does not use a term that already has a secular political movement behind it, and because it makes clear that the one who bears it also strives to live by God’s Word and his rules for sexual behavior.

Because I love Rebecca as my sister in the Lord, I see her standing in robes of righteousness, and I want her words to illuminate this status as a daughter of the King. And with all my heart, I believe that using gay to modify Christian dishonors God.

I understand that my alternative language also carries negative cultural baggage. But is it dishonest? Does it falsify your experience to say that you are someone who lives in chastity with unwanted homosexual desires? I am not trying to defend the exgay movement, but I too see a big difference between saying “I am gay” and saying “I am living with unwanted sexual desires.” I need dialogue in real time on this. If my alternative language is unsatisfactory, then we need to work together on better language. In Christ, we are part of a body of believers, and therefore self-representation is a body issue. This takes time, friendship, and proximity. It takes community. Real community. Not blogs or “internet communities.” This is a feet-on-the-floor and place-at-the-table problem. I’m game. I intend no violence when I ask you to use different language, language befitting the King’s ransomed daughter. But I am asking nonetheless. I come in Christian love.

Our testimonies are not inspired; only the Word of God is. My testimony is neither representative nor proscriptive. And regeneration always renews the mind, even if our feelings remain unchanged to the degree that we want, and if our sanctification is slower than we expected. I realized through my new life in Christ’s blood that the root of my lesbianism was the sin of pride—the pride that declared that my body would not be a commodity under male headship or patriarchy. Pride fueled sexual desires in me that exempted itself from men and directed itself to women. But the Word of God testified against my pride and the sexual desire that it ignited. I could not stand under the weight of its honor. After a radical conversion and the radical repentance it exacted, and after the wreckage of this, my lesbianism seemed like a case of mistaken identity, not an accurate self-representation. After conversion, my lesbianism revealed itself in a different hue than the one that Rebecca is facing, because sexuality is more complex than gay, straight, or bi. After conversion, life always looks different, as we have been humbled by a holy God and redeemed by the blood of our Friend and Savior, and comforted by the Holy Spirit.

I realize not everyone who embraces the term “gay Christian” will adopt the alternative language that I have proposed here. Not everyone will reject the word gay as an unhelpful and dangerous self-representation for the unified witness of Christ to a watching world. Conflict forces this issue and makes casualties out of friendships. So I will stand here: people are bigger (and more important than) the positions they take. This is my call to a new Christian ethics. Before we are fallen creatures, we are soul-infused ones, called to bear God’s image in knowledge, righteousness, and holiness. And while our “flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God” (1 Cor. 15:50), when Jesus comes, and our bodies and souls are reunited, when we inherit a new earth, when we walk in complete sanctification in glory, we will know it: “the dead will be raised imperishable, and we will be changed” (1 Cor. 15:52). God’s people all inherit this promise.

People are not their positions.

People are not their positions (or their problems). Our fallenness and the sinful nature that it bequeaths will not remain so in the new heaven we inherit after Jesus returns. I want to stand with Rebecca and walk in this Christian world together, continuing to pray, open the Word, repent of our sins, and seek God’s guidance as we lock arms in Christian friendship. I want to share a place at the table with Rebecca. A complex friendship, to be sure, but I would not have it any other way.

What is my take-away hope for you as you read this? Friendship and neighborly proximity are necessary components to working through theological differences in Christian love. Ideas are not enough. Ideas buttressed with sarcasm and anger and thrust through the channels of the internet do more harm than good. Ideas have never been enough. Not for God. Ideas that divide must travel with warm pots of chicken soup when a friend is sick, and shoulder-to-shoulder gardening when the irises in one yard beg for thinning so that they can root in the next yard. Ideas that divide must travel on the back of Christian life practices that allow us to stand shoulder to shoulder as we submit before our holy and loving God. This is the Christian labor of real neighbors.

↑ Back to top

↑