3. Repentance: The Threshold to God and the Answer to Shame, Temptation, and Sin
The Threshold to God and the Answer to Shame, Temptation, and Sin
Shame.
No one likes the feeling of shame. No one likes to be shamed. If you do a quick word search on shame, you will see that its English roots take us directly to exposure and sexuality. Shame is the self-loathing, gut response to getting caught and knowing that God has the right and responsibility to judge (Rom. 2:14–16). Tellingly, Adam and Eve’s first emotional response to their sin was shame, and they sought to deal with their shame by hiding from God and covering their bodies. When our evil is exposed, we do the same thing: duck and cover.
When Christ claimed me for his own and I responded in surrender, I thought that shame would be a distant memory. I thought that being a new creature in Christ would insulate me against the shame of my life, from the blasphemy of my atheism (and teaching thousands of students from this perspective), to the heterosexual and homosexual sin I had committed, and in the false pride of my people-pleasing.
But something wasn’t working the way I imagined the Christian life was supposed to work. Instead of feeling cleansed by the blood of Christ, I felt shamed by it. Under the lens of my Savior’s life, death, and love, I realized that only a holy God could forgive me. I understood that no mortal man could forgive my sin. But somehow and for some reason, I kept doubting the love of God. In fact, one problem with shame was that it just wouldn’t stay in my past. The more that I read the Bible, the more sin that God uncovered in my present life. And it seemed to me that the sin I was presently committing—as a believer—was far more heinous than anything I did before I knew the risen Christ.
A friend in the Syracuse church tried to help me with this. She gave me the book Tired of Trying to Measure Up by Jeff VanVonderen.1 I read the whole book in one sitting (as I tend to do with books). I cheered all the way through Part 1, whose overarching theme is how shame wounds people, and how these wounds compel us to work harder at measuring up to the standard other people set for us. Part 1 had Rosaria written on every page. I’m a workaholic. I would have made a great Pharisee, if only sexual sin hadn’t taken me captive. I am deeply self-righteous. Pride is my raging and most dearly developed character trait. Like Sisyphus—the Greek mythological king whose punishment for chronic deceitfulness involved rolling an enormous boulder up a hill, watching it roll down, and then performing this perpetual ineffective motion for eternity—I can never run hard enough or fast enough to best the burden that dogs me.
But then I got to Part 2 of this book, and I stopped tracking with it. The overarching theme of Part 2 is that when shame wounds people, grace heals them. How? By remembering that we committed our life to Christ and by claiming and choosing to stand in the Spirit. What’s wrong with this? you might ask. How can anyone argue with grace? How can anyone argue with God’s gift of the fruit of the Spirit after conversion? Something about seeing grace as the solution to shame didn’t make sense to me. It felt to me like a step was missing. I would later learn that the missing step was repentance, and that this could be for someone a deadly step to miss.
My problem was that Psalm 119 kept ringing in my ears. The psalm starts out with foregrounding David’s problem with shame. He cries, “Oh, that my ways may be established to keep your statutes! Then I shall not be ashamed when I look upon all your commandments” (vv. 5–6). Here, David turns to the law to sort out his shame. It is not that he couldn’t have asked for grace. The Psalms are replete with cries for grace, mercy, and SOS calls for help in times of dire need. But David begs for the law to be effective in breaking down the strongholds of sin. David says here that he will be free of shame when he “looks upon all [of God’s] commandments (all of God’s moral law).” David knew that the law does not save, but he shows us something that VanVonderen misses about grace. Grace isn’t like the lollipop the doctor gives my son to distract him from the flu shot. Grace doesn’t make obedience negotiable. Grace is what picks me up out of the miry pit (Psalm 40) when the law, my tutor, condemns my natural sense of self-righteousness. When the law reveals my sin, God’s grace compels me, fuels me, inspires me to repent, knowing that it is against God as well as others that I have sinned (Psalm 51).
You can’t bypass repentance to get to grace.
You can’t bypass repentance to get to grace. Christ is manifest in our humility, not in our disobedience. Our disobedience cost Jesus everything. Payment for sin always means blood—Christ’s blood. And grace does not erase my need for the law.
But what is wrong with me that I keep on committing sin after sin, even as a believer, even as one who knows better? If repentance unto life is my threshold to God, why do I make such plodding progress in growing to be like Jesus?
Why Do Christians Still Sin?
Sometimes I wish that all birthday and holiday wrapping paper would have this printed on it: Lower Your Expectations, Increase Your Joy. Seriously. I coined this phrase long before God gave me children, and children started coveting everything each Pixar movie promised. In fact, I started to confront my problem with unreasonable expectations when I was first converted. It seemed to me that there is a difference between standards (the law of God, or the highpoint of knowledge about doctrine as portrayed in the Bible) and expectations (our ability to live up to this on our own terms).
I realized that my problem with shame was a problem with (my) expectations, not with (God’s) standards. I expected that Christians ought not to struggle with sin if we were truly converted. I expected that all of my sinful feelings ought to go away now that I am in Christ. I expected that knowing better should solve the problem of the repeat offense of sin. But after I was converted, it seemed like my struggle with sin was just ramping up. And, my pastor and church friends were discipling me to understand that the book of Romans, especially chapters 5–7, explained why. So, why do Christians still struggle with sin if we are new creatures for whom the old has passed away (2 Cor. 5:17)?
Truly, one of the most maddening and confusing realities Christians face is why we continue to sin. Do we choose it? Does sin still abide in believers? If we are new creatures in Christ, why aren’t we simultaneously converted and sanctified in a complete and satisfying way? If God loves us, why doesn’t he change our sinful desires comprehensively? Why do believers still sin? And how could my deepest desires be sinful, when they are inseparable from my sense of self, when they themselves form a reality of selfhood that diffuses into character, not claiming a discrete turf in my heart, but claiming all that I experience?
Put another way: If grace is supposed to heal me, why am I still stuck and sick? Has God passed me over? Does God not hear my prayers?
There are two different Christian views on this conundrum of why believers sin. The dominant evangelical position says that God’s solution to shame is the full knowledge that we are new creatures in Christ. Beg for more grace. But don’t even try to obey the law because you are doomed to failure. And failure, declares this theology, is virtuous, inevitable, and good, as it shows forth God’s grace. Failure has become, as Jen Wilkin says, a virtue.2 Her excellent blog piece exposes the danger of this new glamorization of failure.
There is not one moment in the Bible where we see failure as a virtue. And anyone who conflates humility with failure fails to understand the importance of the first term and the seriousness of the second. A Reformed position offers a different perspective on the problem of why believers sin, and with this perspective, a different solution. Represented by the Puritan John Owen, a Reformed evangelical position teaches us that sin dwells within us (called indwelling sin) and continues in the life of a new creature. Sin must be dealt with in a posture of Christian combat, not in expected or celebrated defeat and failure. We are to use the full armor of all of the means of grace that God gives to us. This position teaches us that conversion gives you freedom from the crime of sin and gives you liberty to respond to God’s grace of conversion through repentance and obedience. Conversion gives you the freedom to repent, not the freedom to expect failure. It was then that I got it: repentance and the love for God—and the obedience to his law that grows from them—were the missing links between shame and grace.
It may seem like I am being schismatic here, pitting one theological posture over and against the other. After all, can’t we just agree that we all love Jesus? Yes, I believe that all people who call themselves Christian love Jesus. Both Christians who cry for more grace and Christians who cry for deeper repentance love Jesus. But sadly, we don’t necessarily agree on who he is and what he has done. And this is a very big problem. There is simply no getting around it: our theology matters a lot.
Schismatic—causing division.
Let’s turn to 2 Corinthians 5:17: “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creature; the old things passed away; behold, new things have come.” A Reformed theology reminds us that new creatures in Christ must mortify the flesh and put to death those sinful desires of the flesh and of the world that entice us (Rom. 8:13). In so doing, we see that grace equips us for the kind of war that renounces sin. Repentance is both an art and an ongoing spiritual practice, and it will continue until Jesus returns or we die and are glorified. The old man inside us, while dead, is like a tree cut at the root: it still sprouts a few green leaves. Or, in the words of the old magician in the movie The Princess Bride, the sin that abides in us after conversion is only “mostly dead.”
Expectations matter. And so do standards.
Because of our fallen natures, we expect that we will be repenting of sin until glory. But repentance is not simply proof of failure. It is, more importantly, a sign of God’s hand upon us. It is a conversion proof, as only a saved person can repent of sin. Because of God’s righteousness, we honor his standards for holiness by vigilantly putting to death all idols and by refusing to be idol-makers, even when it means getting a different job (and one with less prestige), choosing better friends, or throwing away your smartphone.
Why Can’t We All Just Get Along? Why Make Such a Big Deal about Sin?
John Owen says that sin abides in and acts in the lives of new creatures in Christ, and the first and most salient work of all believers is the mortification, or killing, of it. Paul’s poignant cry in Romans 7:15–17 foregrounds this doctrine: “For what I am doing, I do not understand; for I am not practicing what I would like to do, but I am doing the very thing that I hate. But if I do the very thing thing I do not want to do, I agree with the Law, confessing that the Law is good. So now, no longer am I the one doing it, but sin which dwells in me.” Let’s ponder this.
Even though I am a new creature in Christ, I still struggle with my old nature.
I see God’s grace in his convicting me of my sin and becoming sin on my behalf so that I can be crucified with him and rise again:
Therefore we have been buried with Him through baptism into death, so that as Christ was raised from the dead through the glory of the Father, so we too might walk in newness of life. (Rom. 6:4)
I attest that the law is good because it causes me to flee to Christ for salvation. Thus, I am saved by grace alone, and not by works:
For by grace you have been saved through faith; and that not of yourselves, it is the gift of God…. (Eph. 2:8)
Sin thrives in the way that God declared in Genesis 4:7: it has agency, it knows my name, it lurks, it seeks me out, and it dwells in and with me.
And, I am a believer.
Like it or not, because I stand in the covenant of grace, I must mortify my sin. Because I stand in the covenant of grace I am able to mortify sin. Daily. Hourly. No matter how long this sin has been my companion. I must never become sentimental about it. I’m called by God to put it to death. And one big proof that the grace of God is at work in me is that I know that I need to do this, even if I can’t imagine how.
But is this internal war that I feel between the old Rosaria and the new Rosaria biblical?
John Owen says yes. He tells me to expect to go to war with myself, with my old nature.
But Jeff VanVonderen says no, and calls this idea “Satan’s Con.” He writes:
The idea of having two natures at war within the believer is Satan’s Con…. The battle is not between two me’s. I am not at war with the Spirit of God either. The struggle in the Christian life is that of choosing whether to walk by the Spirit or by the flesh.3
We are left with two opposing conclusions from Christians about what ails us: Is the war I feel in myself a ploy of the Devil, or is there something vital about my sin nature that I must understand in order to walk in Christian liberty? Is this war I feel inside a lie of the Devil or a truth of Christ? The division is pretty stark here! Am I failing to apprehend the grace God has freely extended by not choosing to walk in the Spirit? Does the Bible tell me to expect failure and beg for more grace? And if the problem is that I need more grace, what does repentance of sin really mean? When I sin as a believer, am I trampling upon the blood of my Savior or am I glorifying God in my failure?
This is an important question, because as I discussed in the previous chapter, Satan is a real enemy, and he deceives and he accuses. But is the war that I feel between my old self and my redeemed one a ploy of the Devil or a battle of Christian life for which the Bible through the power of the Holy Spirit prepares and equips me to fight? Do we need more grace or a better handle on the law?
One problem with not knowing how to reconcile the law/grace landscape is it leaves a person with two competing ways to deal with sin: admitting it, on the one hand, or confessing it, on the other.
The Difference Between Admitting and Confessing Sin
Admitting Sin
Sometimes we think that admit4 merely means telling the truth or stating the obvious or making something known that we would rather not disclose. It helps, though, to realize that the word itself implies that the agent gives access to the reality that he experiences. In other words, to admit implies that you know what you did or felt was not right; maybe even you know that the Bible calls those feelings or deeds sinful, but you also know that the beating heart of this sin lives too deep inside you to disengage. Perhaps you believe that this is just you, just how you are hardwired, and because you believe that there is nothing that you can do about it, you choose to live at peace with yourself. Or perhaps you have been crafting this sin for decades, and its idolatry has made you its slave. Because you know you would lose your reputation if you came clean, you just try to do a better job of hiding it from view.
Admit—to suffer to enter; to grant entrance, whether into a place, or an office, or into the mind or consideration.
This lived reality is important when it comes to the problem of sin. If I say, “I am just a hot-headed Italian and I can’t help myself when I unleash my anger on my children and family,” I am not merely expressing that I struggle with, say, losing my temper and saying things in anger. I am also indicating that, in some way, I am entertaining this aspect of my personality as endemic to who I am, not what sin has made of me. I am, on some level, granting the sin of anger an entrance into my identity. But if I am a believer, is sin “who I am” or is it something else? And if I say, “I am a new creature in Christ and therefore I just need more grace to deal with this, but if God doesn’t provide this, it is his fault,” the game is lost before the runners line up at the starting line, as this attitude takes me off the hook of ownership of sin.
Our sin both precedes us and then dogs us, and it doesn’t really matter if we have a good reason to sin. That’s how the Bible explains it. So the first question we must ask ourselves is this: from whose point of view should I approach my sin? The default point of view for all people born after Sigmund Freud is the personal one. Our culture resoundingly believes that life is to be interpreted from the point of view of how I feel and perceive things. This explains in part why we have become a Christian culture that admits sin rather than confesses it, and doesn’t linger long enough at the cross to know the difference.
Freud—Sigmund Freud (1856–1939) is the founder of psychoanalysis.
When God approaches Cain after he rejects his sacrifice, God says this: “Why are you angry? And why has your countenance fallen? If you do well, will not your countenance be lifted up? And if you do not do well, sin is crouching at the door; and its desire is for you, but you must master it” (Gen. 4: 6–7). God does not take Cain’s point of view into account when he rejects his sacrifice. God does not reconsider his position because of Cain’s intentions. A sacrifice must bleed in order to count. This bedrock truth can only be apprehended through God’s point of view, not my own good intentions. So instead God rebukes Cain for pouting, and warns him that if he does not change, worse things are in store. God proclaims to Cain something vital about this enemy we call sin: it lurks at the entrance of your life, it knows you and desires you, it has a key to your heart and affections, and you must go to battle with it. Every day.
But if all we do is admit to our sin, we call a deadly truce. The truce is deadly because it is one-sided. We may lay down the weapons of spiritual warfare (Eph. 6:10–17), but Satan doesn’t, and our own natural corruption degenerates even deeper. If we value our point of view over God’s, we will be deceived and betrayed, as sin never takes a Sabbath rest. When we only admit a problem or concern or difference or something about us that we know is not right, we posture in blame shifting, wanting a watching world to see that this problem we have is of no choice of our own and therefore, at least from our point of view, should not be something whose responsibility we should have to burden.
Part of this is true. We do not choose our sin natures. We do not choose the way that Original Sin leaves a fingerprint on our desires. But when all we do is admit our sin, we reject the biblical concept that Original Sin renders me both corrupt and guilty. When we reject Original Sin, we deny the suffering of Jesus on the cross, who paid our ransom because we could not.
Confessing Sin
Compare this understanding of admitting sin to the definition of confess.5 When we confess sin, we own it. This means that sin does not come with a defense attorney who provides all of the excuses for why what God calls sin is really a grace in my life. It means that just because I like to think of myself as a hot-headed Italian does not mean that God gives me a free pass to yell at my kids. It means that my propensity to yell is not even related to my national heritage, but rather to my heritage in Adam. I yell because I am a sinner, and for no other reason.
Confess—to own, acknowledge, or avow, as a crime, a fault, a charge, or a debt.
Psalm 51 is my guide to what confession looks like. This is a psalm that we often sing before taking the Lord’s Supper. David penned it after the Holy Spirit used Nathan to convict David of a bundle of sins: adultery, murder, and deception. When confronted with my sin, a confessing spirit declares as David did in Psalm 51:
2–3 Wash me thoroughly from my iniquity and cleanse me from my sin. For I know my transgressions, and my sin is ever before me. Here David knows his transgressions. He knows that his sin was treason against a holy God, and that God alone can forgive him.
4 You are justified when You speak and blameless when You judge. David is not making excuses or trying to defend his motives. He knows that God is blameless and right in his assessment of sin.
5 Behold, I was brought forth in iniquity and in sin my mother conceived me. David knows that he was born in Adam, and that his natural inclination is to sin. This is not an excuse. It is reality.
10–13 Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a steadfast spirit within me. Do not cast me away from your presence and do not take your Holy Spirit from me. Restore to me the joy of your salvation and sustain me with a willing spirit. Then I will teach transgressors Your ways, and sinners will be converted to You. We see here in these verses a microcosm of the fruit of confession in the Christian life: God creates and recreates; God restores joy in our salvation; God sustains us with his Spirit; God uses our repentance to draw others to him.
The psalm concludes with David recalling an important attribute of God—“A broken and contrite heart, O God, You will not despise” (v. 17). God wants our confession of sin. That gives him glory. We become safe for ministry when we confess and repent. The psalm ends with a prayer that God will build the church: “By Your favor, do good to Zion; build the walls of Jerusalem” (v. 18). Confession of sin moves mountains.
Psalm 32 adds additional insight into God’s forgiveness of sin and our repentance. This psalm begins, “Blessed is he whose transgression is forgiven, whose sin is covered!” In repentance, God takes our sin away, and in faith, God clothes us (covers us) in Christ’s righteousness. When God covers our sin, we are given deliverance. When we cover our sin through denial or excuse-making, God’s hand is heavy upon us. And God’s heavy hand is a blessing! It is a sign of his love that he does not leave us in deception: “For day and night Your hand was heavy upon me” (v. 4). When we admit or toy with our sin, God’s hand is heavy. When we confess our sin, God’s hand moves to bear us up: “I said, ‘I will confess my transgression to the Lord,’ and you forgave the iniquity of my sin” (v. 5, ESV).
Iniquity is a strong word.
Iniquity is a strong word: it stands for an act of injustice. My sin is an act of injustice against a holy God. But when I confess this, the trustworthy and dependable response from God to my repentance is that God becomes my covering, my hiding place. He preserves my life, establishes my integrity, and gives me peace, purpose, and liberty.
This is even true with sins of personality or appetite. When we confess a sin, we are not asking that God or others see it from our point of view, from the vantage point of our intentions or our motives. Instead, we use God’s point of view. We submit to the righteous hand of God. We consent that the Bible is true and that the law of God condemns us. And this either drives us into mad depression or into the open arms of our Savior, Jesus Christ. The implications are far-reaching. Confession of sin is meant to drive us to Christ, for our good and for his glory.
But Christians who indulge the habit of admitting rather than confessing sin over time tend not to see their sin as sin at all. It just seems like life. At first, they may hate the sin. They may truly wish to be free of it. These brothers and sisters may be forgetting or not knowing that even in our battle with sin God gives us an opportunity to glorify him. Indeed, I believe that the job of a Christian is to glorify God in all situations, including in the repentance of sin.
The business of the Christian is not to desire just enough grace to be strong in ourselves. Indeed, strong personalities can and do make behavioral changes on the grounds of will, many of these for the good of their health and well-being. But there is no new life found in the fruit of a self-willed behavioral change. Only the risen Lord can give new life. What separates the admitting of sin from the confession of sin is the cross of Christ. And to unbelievers, the cross is a confusing distraction, a piddling annoyance, not the preeminent triumph of the Creator and Redeemer of life that trumps all empires of the world. We come to the cross in repentance, and it is at the cross that we are, over time and affliction, transformed, partly here on earth, but completely in glory (1 John 3:2; 2 Cor. 3:18).
As believers, what makes us “us” is not that we all struggle with lust or anger or laziness or sex addiction. What makes us “us” is that we have been broken in our sin, and we find our identity in the risen Christ. In John 15:4, Jesus declares, “Abide in Me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit of itself unless it abides in the vine, so neither can you unless you abide in Me.” At the moment that we become a Christian, we are given both the privilege and blessing of union with Christ through the power of the Holy Spirit. This union is permanent, irreversible, and eternal. This union with Christ helps us to see the need for radical repentance. Repentance keeps the branch and the vine indelibly linked.
If our motive in confessing sin is growing in Christ, we will grow in two ways: humility over how impossible it is to battle sin alone, and victory over the compelling seduction of our choice sins. Framing sin from the point of view of our intentions and motives does not palliate the problem or improve our standing with God or man. Why? Because sin is not my personal problem or shortcoming. Sin is, in the words of The Westminster Shorter Catechism, “any want of conformity unto, or transgression of, the law of God” (Q. 14).6 Sin is mutiny, either by its omission (“want of conformity to”) or its commission (“transgression of the law of God”).
It is the moral anesthetic of our day to ask God and our friends to only understand our sin from our point of view. This mind-set of seeing sin from a personal point of view has led to, at best, weak Christians crippled by sin and untouched by gospel power, or at worst, wolves in sheep’s clothing who hunker down with offices in the church, teaching feeble sheep a perverted catechism, one that renders sin grace and grace sin, one that confuses doubt with intelligence and skepticism with renewed hope. When we live by the belief that sin is best discerned from our own point of view, we cannot help but to develop a theology of excuse-righteousness. We become anesthetized to the reality of our own sin. One consequence of this moral anesthesia is the belief that you are in good standing with God if you give to him what the desires of your flesh can spare. But sin, biblically rendered, is both a crime and a disease, requiring both the law of God and his grace to apply it for true help.
Puritan Theology: A Blast of Fresh Air for Diagnosing Sin
As I was searching for someone to explain to me what repentance really involved, I came across a book by Thomas Watson entitled The Doctrine of Repentance,7 first published in 1668 and reprinted in a series called Puritan Paperbacks. In its pages I found a true friend, someone who also found joy and union in Christ through radical and constant repentance. This is how I first made friends with Puritan theology.
Puritan theology refers to a sixteenth- and seventeenth-century movement that spanned two continents and focused on three distinct values:
1) union with our triune God in mind, emotion, and identity;
2) Reformed and confessional theology, endorsing a systematic understanding of the Scriptures that pervades personhood and politics;8
3) a love for reforming the church in worship, faith, and practice.
What I love about the Puritans is that their doctrines of sin and grace provide a perfect balance. Puritans are realistic about the human condition. They viewed sin as more evil than hell itself, and they examined sin in its three forms: original, actual, and indwelling.
Doesn’t that sound extreme to our ears? How can sin (which we commit daily) be worse than hell (where those who reject and hate God experience eternal torment)? The first thing you notice when you ask a question like this is that the observation implies that it is God’s point of view, not our own, that matters.
Why is sin worse than hell?9 In hell, the consciousness of the soul is manifest and alert to the truth. As in the biblical parable of the rich man and Lazarus (Luke 16:19–25), the rich man is tormented in hell for the crime of his unbelief and unfaithfulness. He had a hard heart towards God and felt no remorse for the suffering of Lazarus. Now in hell, he knows it: “In Hades, he lifted up his eyes, being in torment, and saw Abraham far away and Lazarus on his bosom. And he cried out and said, ‘Father Abraham, have mercy on me, and send Lazarus so that he may dip the tip of his finger in water and cool off my tongue, for I am in agony in this flame’” (vv. 23–24). When Abraham rejects this request, explaining the law that heaven and hell divide by an uncrossable chasm, the rich man begs for the souls of his brothers. Even souls in hell indirectly make known God’s glory by revealing their conscious understanding of their evil. Hell is evidence that every knee will bow.
So, why is sin worse than hell? Hell vindicates God as our righteous judge, while sin separates us from him.
Sin: Original, Actual, and Indwelling
Anthony Burgess (not the same guy who authored A Clockwork Orange) wrote a powerful volume on sin, entitled The Doctrine of Original Sin Asserted and Vindicated against the Old and New Adversaries Thereof. In this book, he organizes sin into three categories: original, actual, and indwelling.
For Burgess and the Puritans, Romans 5–7 constituted a “divine map” of the microstudy of sin in the believer’s life. Romans 5 outlines Original Sin, and we see in this chapter that it is insidious, imputed, and inherent. Original Sin is one of the most maligned worldviews of our day. Indeed, many evangelicals meet it with uproarious rejection.
Original Sin takes its name from Augustine, who said, “Even infants are born sinners, not by their own act, but because of their origin.”10 About this Alan Jacobs comments, “And here we see what is meant by Original Sin, peccatum originalis in Augustine’s Latin: sin that is already inside us, already dwelling in us at our origin, at our very conception.”11 Our “origin” is in Adam. And this feels deeply unfair. Our most basic understanding of justice screams out against this. Jacobs says: “We struggle to hold together a model of human sinfulness that is universal rather than local, in which we inherit sin rather than choose it, and in which, nevertheless, we are fully, terrifyingly responsible for our condition.”12
Wise men rally against this idea. Jean-Jacques Rousseau, philosophical leader of the French Revolution, foregrounded a worldview based on its complete opposite: the free will of man and the belief that the “natural” innocence of children will flourish in a world filled with human creativity and goodness. The nameless creature or monster in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818 edition) is a child of the philosophy of Rousseau. He reads all the right books (including Goethe’s suicide novel, The Sorrows of Young Werther).13 After he kills in cold blood every human being that his creator loved, this creature born in a laboratory from the mind of a brilliant bachelor, and weaved together with a free will but no God-reflecting soul, laments like this: “I, the miserable and the abandoned, am an abortion, to be spurned at, and kicked, and trampled on. Even now my blood boils at the recollection of this injustice.”14
If Rousseau is right, then Frankenstein’s creature is a hero, for even as he leaves a trail of blood behind him, he has accomplished the self-actualizing task of knowing himself. But indeed, as Randell Jarrell quipped, “Rousseau was wrong: that man, when you knock his chains off, sets up the death camps.”15 It seems that Original Sin is friend or foe depending on how wide your angle is: from the housetops, we see Original Sin as dangerous time and time again. From our navel-gazing, Rousseau seems dead on. Our intentions are noble, we protest. All we need now is more grace! But good intentions do not erase or minimize the way Original Sin distorts us all.
But the story does not stop with Original Sin.
Actual sin, the second type that Burgess unveils, stems from Original Sin and is any transgression of the law of God in “thought, word or deed.”16 Actual sins are transient in comparison to indwelling sins, which Burgess describes as “fixed sins in us, and these habits of sin…strengthen our original corruption.”17 The Puritans believed that sin corrupted, crippled, and contaminated both believers and unbelievers, but not in the same way. A believer cannot die from the crime of sin (as an unbeliever can), but if he is not in constant and effective battle with sin, a believer will die of its disease, of the way that it ravages his conscience and relationships and even perhaps body.
Noetic—from the Greek nous, referring to the mind, mindfulness, and the ability to think and reason.
Sin in the unregenerate is often referred to as having a noetic effect. In the unregenerate, sin corrupts knowledge as it does not lead the knower to his Maker. John Owen says it best: “The knowledge of a proud man is the throne of Satan in his mind.”18
Indwelling sin, the third type, always abides in us for as long as we live in this world, and for that reason we must constantly be mortifying it. Because it always abides, we must never speak as though we had “already obtained it or…already become perfect” (Phil. 3:12). Not only does indwelling sin abide, it also lives and acts and “labors to bring forth the deeds of the flesh.”19 It seeks to destroy us, not merely allow us to dabble with unpleasantries. Indwelling sin has agency and evil intent, and it knows where we live. Mortifying indwelling sin is the Christian’s daily battle. Later in this chapter I will talk about how to respond to this pernicious but intimate adversary.
What causes us to sin? Temptation. What is temptation? From where does it originate, and how ought the believer to gain victory over it?
Is temptation my friend or my foe?
Temptation
Oswald Chambers says that “temptation fits the nature of the one tempted, and reveals the possibilities of the nature…. Temptation yielded to is lust deified” (My Utmost for His Highest, September 17 entry). Temptation comes in many forms, but it is always personal, uncannily tailor-made for our individual moral weakness, and it takes aim at God’s character, seeking to ransack our faith.
In Matthew 26:41, our Lord commands this: “Keep watching and praying that you may not enter into temptation.” From this verse we know that temptation is an alluring evil or a moral test.
Although temptation is not sin itself, it is also not good.
Although temptation is not sin itself, it is also not good. Temptation is a mighty antagonist. In addition, we know from Scripture that the means of prevention is watching and praying.
Truth be told, watching and praying seem like a pathetic counterattack. But that is because we underestimate the spiritual armor that God gives his sons and daughters.
Since the Bible offers two distinct words that shape our understanding of human nature—temptation and sin—any worldview that attempts to understand human nature without taking these into account will fundamentally distort and deny what it means to be human.
John Owen brings helpful detail to our discussion about sin and temptation. According to Owen, temptation is “any thing, state, way, or condition that, upon any account whatsoever, has a force or efficacy to seduce, to draw the mind and heart of a man from its obedience, which God requires of him, into any sin, in any degree of it whatsoever.”20 Note that any temptation can lead a person into any sin. It is a force. And forces must be reckoned with, not passively accepted.
God does not tempt (James 1:12–15) and Jesus was tempted in all ways, but did not sin (Heb. 4:15). James 1:14–15 says this: “Each one is tempted when he is carried away and enticed by his own lust. Then when lust has conceived, it gives birth to sin, and when sin is accomplished, it brings forth death.” Temptation is not something to be celebrated. It originates with Satan and its desired end is to cause sin and separation from God. Desire can have a range of syntactical meanings in the Bible, but in these passages, it refers to something internal that entices a believer to want something he ought not have. Desire for evil things that is teleological is predatory and sinful—it will not be quenched until its object has been consumed. This is the kind of desire James refers to in these verses, the kind of desire that the King James Version and New American Standard Bible translate in James 1:14–15 as lust. Temptation, then, puts each and every one of us in a dangerous dilemma, and we do not know when it first entices us if we will be victors or victims.
Teleological—concerning the ultimate end or purpose of a thing.
In the book of Hebrews, we are told that Jesus was tempted. What does temptation mean to Jesus? Did his sinlessness mean that temptation for Jesus was not as bad as it is for us? In Hebrews 2:18 we read, “For since He Himself was tempted in that which He has suffered, He is able to come to the aid of those who are tempted.” This is a key verse. Linking temptation with suffering, we see that from the point of view of Scripture, temptation is never to be exonerated, celebrated, or minimized. It is never to become an accolade or a defining marker of who we are.
In Hebrews 4:15 we read, “For we do not have a high priest who cannot sympathize with our weaknesses, but One who has been tempted in all things as we are, yet without sin.” And Hebrews 5:8 reads, “Although He was a Son, He learned obedience from the things which He suffered.” While Jesus was tempted, Jesus was not born with a sin nature. That means that the evil that enticed him came from someplace other than his own nature. Put in the positive, it means that because he was fully holy, he would meet temptation all the way to its finished end of victory. It means that in his feelings and experiences, Jesus, while tempted, never crossed the line into sin, and conquered that temptation with perfect obedience.
This raises the question of how Jesus could be both man and God. It begs the question if the Son and the Father shared one divine will. The early church resolved this question in 451 AD with the Nicene Creed and then gave further clarification in 680 AD with the Third Council of Constantinople. The early church confirmed that Jesus had one nature, but two wills: one divine and the other human. As Mark Jones points out in a most helpful book, A Christian’s Pocket Guide to Jesus Christ: An Introduction to Christology,21 “Christ would not be properly human if his will was divine…. Christ’s human will was necessary for him to render true obedience in the place of his people.”22 Christ’s human will meant that his body, while sinless, felt the infirmities and corruptions of the world. He needed food and rest and friendship. At the same time, as Jones writes, “Christ’s…obedience to the will of his Father was obedience arising out of love for God with his human heart, soul, mind and strength.” We see this tension in John 6:38 (“For I have come down from heaven, not to do My own will, but the will of Him who sent me”) and John 10:17 (“For this reason the Father loves Me, because I lay down my life so that I may take it up again”). Donald Macleod describes Christ’s battle with temptation like this: “He felt the appeal of the sinful proposals put to Him and He had to struggle with all his might to repel them.”23 But because Christ was not born in Adam, he had no internal sin nature and therefore no fallen desires that originated from within.
Omniscient—all knowing.
For some, this inherent sinlessness makes Christ’s temptations seem insincere, as his holiness seems to set up the game in a way that would make any empathy he might have for my temptation shallow. If we think like this, we are missing an important point. Christ was truly tempted. On earth, Christ was not omniscient, according to his human nature. He relied on the Holy Spirit for power. He had to trust in God, exercise faith, and sweat blood. He was tempted to preserve his life in the wilderness (Luke 4) and in the garden (Matt. 26), but he met that temptation with faith in God and obedience, choosing the Father’s will over his own. He modeled for us what we should desire in the face of temptation: to choose the Father’s will over our own. Because he had a human will while he physically walked on earth, Jesus can truly empathize with our temptation. His empathy rests not in desiring sinful things (which is more often than not our problem with temptation), but in choosing the Father’s will over his own. His agonizing garden prayer embodies this. Matthew 26 tells us this:
39 And He went a little beyond them, and fell on His face, and prayed, saying, “My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from Me; yet not as I will, but as You will.
40 And He came to the the disciples and found them sleeping, and said to Peter, “So you men could not keep watch with Me for one hour?
41 Keep watching and praying that you may not enter into temptation; the spirit is willing, but the flesh is weak.”
42 He went away again a second time and prayed, saying, “My Father, if this cannot pass away unless I drink it, Your will be done.”
With great agony and grief and turmoil that we cannot imagine, Jesus does what we are called to do in face of temptation: to choose God’s will over our own. Jesus met temptation with obedience, and that meant going against the natural desires of his human will. He had to do this because if he had not gone to the cross without temptation, he could not have ransomed us from our own sin. He was obeying for the Father’s honor and out of sacrificial love for you and me and all of his people.
We depend more on his obedience than we do on his being in the same boat with us. We find our only hope in his sinlessness, knowing that it resulted from a battle with sin that he experienced more deeply than we do. His perfect holiness and obedience in the face of temptation gives us proof of his sacrificial love. He understands the contours of sin and temptation better through his triumph over it than we do in our defeat.
Some people believe that if Jesus did not experience sinful internal desires such as sexual lust, then he isn’t fully human. This reveals the tendency to want to make Jesus in our own image. Jesus had intimate surroundings with his disciples. His friendships were deep and intense. He met with the woman at the well alone. But he did not have one unholy sexual thought for any man or woman. His orientation was to obey the Father.
As I am writing this, my children are waging war with lightsabers, and about one hundred stuffed animals being used as ammunition are currently careening through the hallway and encroaching into my office. The children are at the tail end of the head cold that they just gave to me. They are feeling better and I am feeling like an elephant is tap-dancing on my sinuses. Soon the battle, as all battles do, spills over into the out-of-bounds territory of my desk and writing space. Before I know what hit me, a beloved child of the covenant smacks me upside the head with a flashing lightsaber. And now I am just losing it. Really. You would be really ashamed to be me right now. I am screaming for them to stop. Just STOP. I have completely lost all self-control. And they are SO loud, and I am so weak in voice, and the lightsabers make these swooshing sounds when they make contact with something (like my head), that my children can’t even hear my protest!
Then I realize it, like another smack upside the head: my anger is sinful anger and God is protecting my children from it. From me.
I love them. I love them more than I love writing this book. I want them. I fought for them. I prayed for them before I met them. I pray for them daily and sometimes hourly. I cherish them. But sometimes, dare I say it, as a homeschool mom I fantasize about all of the liberty that yellow school bus that passes my street corner twice a day might offer.
So, what do I do? I go to God immediately with repentance. And then I push save on this chapter and get up and correct my children in kindness. They protest. They complain. They feel persecuted. I take away all stuffed animal ammo and all weapons, and I put the children in their separate rooms to read. The whole drama has taken all of ten minutes.
Done.
Quiet.
I return to my desk, and, just for good measure, insert my ear plugs.
You see, immediately as a believer, I must go to the Lord in repentance when feelings cross from temptation to sin. For me, they cross the line a lot. My track record is pathetic. I don’t know about you, but I often seem to know the line between temptation and sin when I cross it. While repentance is my threshold to God, obedience was Jesus’ threshold to God. Christ’s suffering and obedience then become our powerful inspiration.
Psalm 22 harrowingly records the temptation of Jesus on the cross:
My God, my God, to you I cry,
O why have You forsaken me?
Why are You far from giving help,
And from my agonizing plea?
All day, my God, I cry in vain;
By night, yet no relief I gain.24
This is a commanding psalm to sing in its entirety before taking the Lord’s Supper. As I type these words, I cannot help but pause to sing them. I’m not in good voice from this head cold, but somehow this psalm sounds even more accurately rendered in my weakness.
Indeed, as your voice laments through each stanza, you reflect upon the agony of Christ’s will, the cost of his obedience, the effect of his representational love. In the last words of the psalm, you experience the positive application of Christ’s sinlessness in face of temptation. Without it, we would not be at the Supper at all:
A seed will rise to do His will,
And of the Lord be made aware.
The generation that will come
Will then His righteousness declare,
To people who are yet to be,
That He has done this; it was He.25
Temptation travels on a slippery slope, and the law of gravity in our sin nature renders temptation an easy slide downward, especially if we minimize sin’s power to deceive and destroy us on the grounds that we have kept company with it for so long. Not so for Jesus. His nature was pure, and therefore his experience of temptation was different than mine. His experience was fierce and raw. Temptation insulted his divine nature, and bore holes in his human will long before the nails were driven down into his hands. Jesus was tempted in all ways. He therefore can empathize with my feelings.
He reminds me to “Get up and pray that you may not enter into temptation” (Luke 22:46). He commands me to “Watch and pray, that you enter not into temptation” (Matt. 26:41). I am not to watch my own personality or my own indwelling sin or my own good reason for making an idol out of temptations. I am to watch out for the holiness of God, made manifest in me by the shedding of blood. He sweated blood. He withstood the test. He ran the whole race.
We cannot make such claims. We have not been tested that hard, or humiliated that comprehensively. We are in the ABCs of the kindergarten of the school of temptation. By not falling into temptation, Jesus ran the whole race, while I collapsed in the first mile.
It fascinates me that Jesus used an ordinary means of grace to flee Satan’s temptations in the wilderness: he used the Word of God. This occurred during his post-baptism, post-fast, desert experience recorded in Matthew 4:1–11. Satan tempted Jesus to turn stones into bread, hurl himself from the pinnacle of the temple, and worship the Antichrist. Each time, Jesus protected himself with the shield of the Word. Why? Why did Jesus use something ordinary—something that we believers possess—instead of some extraordinary God-infused gift? To show in his mercy the true sufficiency of Scripture. To reveal that Jesus met temptation in the wilderness as a man and in the power of the Holy Spirit.
He also did this to show something important about the nature of temptation: it’s not primarily about us. That’s right. If you are in Christ, temptation is not about some essential truth or inherent wisdom about us—and therefore should not become a term of selfhood, self-representation, or identity. It is about warfare. And for Christians, it is about our allegiance to Christ in this war. Russell Moore says this:
Temptation is so strong in our lives precisely because it’s not about us. Temptation is an assault by the demonic powers on the rival empire of the Messiah. That is why conversion to Christ doesn’t diminish the power of temptation—as we often assume—but only ratchets it up.26
Making an identity out of temptation is like putting on the opposing team’s jersey at a ball game and then taking to the field: it is confusing, deceptive, and dangerous. How do we make an identity out of temptation? By collapsing what you desire with who you are. By collapsing what tempts you or what trips you up with who you will become.
If you don’t believe this, then just think about what representation means: it means to re-present, to present again for all of posterity. We who are washed by the blood of Christ are “buried with Him through baptism into death” (Rom. 6:4). Thus, believers wear the same team colors. We may struggle with different patterns of desire, but because temptation is not about us, temptation does not define us. We are covered and washed by the blood of Christ alone. To say, “temptation is not a sin, therefore my temptation pattern is morally neutral or even sanctifiable” is misguided and dangerous. It shows that we have embraced an identity that contradicts God’s revealed purpose. God’s revealed purpose for my identity always nails me to his cross.
A Believer’s Main Business: The Mortification of Sin
If temptation is not a sin, what is sin? G. K. Chesterton makes sin analogous to a rhinoceros, and says this: “If a rhinoceros was to enter this restaurant now, there is no denying he would have great power here. But I should be the first to rise and assure him that he had no authority whatever.”27 Like a rhino, sin has power without authority, but it can bully and sucker-punch the strongest Christian into doing its bidding. The Bible graciously records how heroes of the faith have fallen through the floor of temptation into sin, in part to show us that God’s grace is ever available to a believing and repenting heart. Again: temptation is not a sin. But what you do with it may be.
The Bible tells us that when a sinful desire has taken root in our heart, and when it takes on a life and agency of its own, even if we are not acting upon it, we are dealing with an indwelling sin. Pornography addicts who begin by writing erotica and go on to commit adultery did not speak their marriage vows while thinking they would ever be unfaithful. They thought, like we all do when we are in the throes of deception, that we have our sin under control. Sin starts oh-so gently. We dangle our toes over the inviting water decades before we plunge ourselves—and our loved ones—into the open-mouthed depths of the raging sea in a murderous storm.
The Bible’s solution to sin is confession and repentance—accomplished only through God’s redemptive grace—and, through the blood of Christ, the mortification of sin, including the sin of my most cherished and primal feelings.
But God does not leave us in the grave, with only the mortification of our sin for company. Psalm 40:2 declares, “He brought me up out of the pit of destruction, out of the miry clay, and He set my feet upon a rock, making my footsteps firm.” God gives us the grace to repent and mortify our sins, to be sure. Christ gives us empathy; he knows what we endure. By his death, he gave himself to us as a ransom for our sins. And by his resurrection, he gives us the hope and promise of a new life, “born again to a living hope through the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead” (1 Peter 1:3). In Owen’s (and before him, John Calvin’s) terms, we mortify our sins through his grace working in us, and he vivifies our new life. Mortification refers to putting off the “old man,” and vivification embodies the idea of being born again, given a new heart by the power of the Holy Spirit. Yes, we were all born in sin. That is why we must be born again. In Owen’s words, “The Holy Spirit works in us and upon us as we are fit to be wrought in and upon; that is, so as to preserve our own liberty and free obedience. He works upon our understandings, wills, consciences, and affections, agreeably to our own natures; he works in us, and with us, not against us or without us.”28 The majestic balm of life in Christ “by grace alone” embraces sanctification as both putting off sin and renewal in grace. And we walk in liberty.
Vivifies—enlivens or makes alive.
One very difficult aspect about sin is that my sin never feels like sin to me. My sin feels like life, plain and simple. My heart is an idol factory and my mind an excuse-making factory, especially when it comes to dealing with the kind of sin that clobbers me the most—indwelling sin—the unrelenting, ever-present kind that never takes a Sabbath and that Paul references in Romans 7: “So now, no longer am I the one doing it, but sin which dwells in me” (v. 17); “But if I am doing the very thing I do not want, I am no longer the one doing it, but sin which dwells in me” (v. 20).
John Owen confronts this in his work The Nature, Power, Deceit, and Prevalency of the Remainders of Indwelling Sin in Believers, first published in 1635. I believe that this is the most important book for contemporary Christians to read.29 Owen’s work is divided into three parts:
Part 1: The Nature of Indwelling Sin;
Part 2: The Power and Efficacy of Indwelling Sin;
Part 3: The Effect and Strength of Indwelling Sin.
This is a book to read slowly and prayerfully. It disarms as it explains the unexplainable: How can I be a new creature in Christ and have sin dwell in my heart? How can my mind be redeemed, and yet still I struggle with this fallen nature? How can I pray and fast over decades and still wake up to the same old me with the same old sin? As Kris Lundgaard, author of The Enemy Within, puts it: “Sin can be like trick birthday candles: you blow them out and smile, thinking you have your wish; then your jaw drops as they burst into flames.”30
So, how do you fight an enemy that has climbed over the wall and is now in the house? Owen recommends doing these four things:
1) Starve it. That’s right. Indwelling sin is a parasite, and it eats what you do. The Word is poison to sin when embraced by a heart made new by the Holy Spirit. You starve indwelling sin by feeding yourself deeply on the Word of God. Sin cannot abide in the Word. So, fill your hearts and minds with Scripture. Psalm singing, for me, is powerful devotional practice as it melts Scripture memory into my soul with each note. Psalm singing helps me to use everything I have to fold my will into God’s Word. Psalm selections take up large parts of a whole chapter of Scripture, and singing psalms is one way to take in the Bible in large portions and to memorize a whole book of the Bible over time. We benefit from reading the Bible comprehensively, big chunks and whole books at a time. This allows us to see God’s providence at work in big-picture ways.
Don’t make excuses. Don’t get sentimental about sin.
2) Call sin what it is. Don’t “admit” sin as a kind of benign visitor; confess it as an evil offense and put it out! You can’t domesticate sin by admitting it into your home. Don’t make a false peace. Don’t make excuses. Don’t get sentimental about sin. Don’t play the victim. Don’t live by excuse-righteousness. If you bring a baby tiger into your house, buy it a collar and leash, and name it “Fluffy,” don’t be surprised if you wake up one day and Fluffy is eating you alive. That is how sin works, and Fluffy knows her job. Sometimes sin lurks and festers for decades, deceiving the sinner that he really has it all under control, until it unleashes itself on everything you built, cherished, and loved. Be wise about your choice sins and don’t coddle them.
3) Extinguish indwelling sin. How? Mortify (kill) it. Sin is not only an enemy, says Owen. Sin is at enmity with God. Enemies can be reconciled, but there is no hope for reconciliation for anything at enmity with God. Anything at enmity with God must be mortified. Our battles with sin draw us closer to union with Christ, and in that way much good comes from dealing with sin God’s way. Indeed, as Romans 6 states, our identity comes from being crucified and resurrected with Christ:
4 Therefore, we have been buried with him through baptism into death, so that as Christ was raised from the dead through the glory of the Father, so we too might walk in newness of life.
5 For if we have become united with Him in the likeness of His death, certainly we shall also be in the likeness of His resurrection,
6 knowing this, that our old self was crucified with Him, in order that our body of sin might be done away with, so that we would no longer be slaves to sin…
4) Vivify righteousness and walk in the Spirit. Cultivate daily your new life in Christ. God does not leave us alone to fight the battle in shame. Instead, through the power of the Holy Spirit, the soul of each believer is “vivified.” “To vivicate” means to animate, or to give life to. Vivification (redemption) complements mortification, and by so doing, it allows us to see the wide angle of sanctification. The promise of redemption allows us to visualize ourselves as redeemed men and women. By so doing, it gives shape and form to our identity in Christ, even on this side of eternity.
Sexual sin is often the one that brings whole households and churches into ruin. After a while, people battling sexual sin grow weary. It may seem that God is calling unmarried Christians to be sexually repressed people.
But God’s vision of sexuality, what Bible professor and author Christopher Yuan calls holy sexuality, is not a white-knuckling, hand-slapping, self-deprecating life practice. Not at all. God is calling us to so greatly love others that we do not desire for them anything that might separate them from God. Holy sexuality is a love so big that it treasures the purity of another, exonerating that person’s status as an image bearer or a daughter or son of the King, and not dehumanizing him or her through manipulating lust.
Redemption brings a person beyond obedience to a deeper union with Christ and a greater love for fellow image bearers through self-denial. Killing or mortifying sin is not enough. We must go through this battle to find joy in melting our will with God’s, even as God’s will often crosses our own. Vivification is an invitation to read all of Scripture not merely as something which gives us good advice, but rather a living text that meets us in our redeemed soul and thereby shapes our desires.
In my experience, this reshaping of desires through the godly gift of redemption is complex and dialogic, not flat, singular, and finished. It engages me in a daily back-and-forth that the psalmist does in Psalm 62. This psalm begins with David describing his practice. He says: “My soul waits in silence for God only” (v. 1). By the fifth line, David is not listening to himself and his woes. Instead, he is talking to himself using God’s Word. He says, “My soul, wait in silence for God only” (v. 5, emphasis mine). David is applying redemptive courage. He is taking himself by the scruff of the neck and telling himself what to do. He knows the sad state of his condition, but he is not causing himself to become more and more depressed by the fact of this. How? He is seeing the facts of his life through the lens of faith that God has given him.
Dialogic—relating to dialogue or conversation.
After he talks to himself (instead of listening to himself), he then talks to himself about who God is. Redemption is the imposition of God’s character, will, power, and life into our own, bringing us from death to life. David is not condemning his feelings. He is using his faith to interpret his personal experience. He declares, “Trust in Him at all times, O people; pour out your heart before Him” (v. 8). He is declaring that a saved man is never alone with his problems, and ought not act as though he is. A saved man or woman always has God’s kind company.
He concludes the psalm in confidence that even if God will not give him his heart’s desires, he can trust that God will answer his prayers rightly: “Once God has spoken; twice I have heard this: that power belongs to God; and lovingkindness is yours, O Lord, for you recompense a man according to his work” (vv. 11–12).
The work to which the psalmist refers is not works-righteousness. It is not white-knuckling it through clobbering temptation with a stubborn will. The work here refers to the counterintuitive power of melting your will with your Maker’s through the vivification of the Lord’s work.
The work of a believer is responsive, not initiative. We respond to God’s love because we must. Like Peter, when called to do the impossible, we do not look to our limitations, but we ponder this: “Lord, to whom shall we go? You have words of eternal life” (John 6:68). Owen says this: “Mortification of any sin must be by a supply of grace. Of ourselves, we cannot do it.”31 The gospel does not take us halfway there. God takes us all the way home. But if what you seek is grace apart from Christ’s blood, you will never get home.
A Biblical Solution to the Problem of Shame
A biblical solution to the problem of shame is a godly understanding of both law and grace, remembering that confession of sin glorifies God,32 and that the promises in God’s covenant with you are a banquet of encouragement. We can model that for one another as we do life together. When Kent proposed to me, I understood that he really could forgive me for the sexual sin of my past. I felt years of sin melt away when Kent showed me by his actions that he did not have higher standards for me than God has. He showed me that he truly believed that repentance brings glory to God. But this is counterintuitive. Only a Christian walking with the kind company of the Holy Spirit could find peace and joy and God’s love in repentance of sin.
John Owen also speaks of shame. He says that shame roots not in God failing to understand our weakness, but in ourselves failing to understand God’s greatness. Owen says: “A universal respect to all God’s commandments is the only preservative from shame.”33 In this way, Owen echoes David, who puts it this way: “Then I shall not be ashamed when I look upon all your commandments” (Ps. 119:6). What stands between one believer feeling shame at hearing that Original Sin makes us corrupt and guilty and another finding peace in this theology?
The problem of shame may be one of doctrine or life or both. Shame may result from your sin or from the sin of someone else that landed on you. It may be that good theology is rendered in harsh and unloving hands. Or it may be that some sins are coddled and hidden (for a while) while others rage like a silent wildfire through the lives of believers. But I believe that the missing link for believers to come together in a healthy understanding of sin is Christian love for God’s righteousness and for one another, the kind of love that sticks it out in hard times. I will say more about this love in the last chapter, but for now please know that loyal fellowship of believers is not an “add on” to good doctrine. Fellowship of believers is often the vein through which the Savior’s blood pumps us whole and well.
After Pentecost, believers were “continually devoting themselves…to fellowship” (Acts 2:42). In a real Christian community, there is no shame in repentance. Real Christian communities view repentant sinners as God sees them: cleansed and robed in Christ’s righteousness. And we know that the battle with sin is not finished until we die or Christ returns. For this reason, “from now on we recognize no one according to the flesh” (2 Cor. 5:16). Redeemed people are not known or recognized according to categories of the flesh.
Many people reject the full understanding of sin (original, actual, and indwelling) because it is credited with causing shame and undue emotional duress. Where is the grace in a gospel that calls my deepest desires and most primal senses of self “sin”? An orthodox understanding of sin has been credited with causing Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), depression, self-harm, and suicide, among other tragedies. But this is not the way God orchestrates believers to experience repentance. Repentance is how grace flows to the humble heart (James 4:6). Repentance feels like God lifting the weight of conflict off of your shoulders. It feels freeing to finally see what you did not see before, and liberating to release the anger and shame and self-defensiveness that sin always requires.
Repentance of sin is an honor that adorns royalty.
Even when the consequences are dire, it feels glorious to experience that the Lord’s burden is much lighter than that of the world, and his yoke befitting to my nature and capacity. Repentance of sin is an honor that adorns royalty. It is the full expression of Christian liberty, and through the Lord’s forgiveness, repentance rings one singular note: peace.
To live without shame, both the nature of God and the nature of man must be held in uncompromising love. We must embrace a true biblical understanding of the nature of redeemed people, and a faithful biblical understanding of the God who made us. If both are not held in the strictest love, other worldly identities creep in and subtly seduce us into serving two masters.
Sometimes, these worldly identities enter into the church intending to be a helpful category, meant to smooth the bridge of understanding among God’s people. One such worldly category is the concept of sexual orientation, the idea that people are born with a fixed sexual orientation—gay, straight, or bisexual. But this category is unstable and will not stop changing. We are told that sexual orientation is a true and abiding category of humanity. In the next two chapters, I show how this concept has been harmful to all people, but especially, I believe, to believers who struggle with unwanted homosexual desires.
