Chapter 6 of 13

4. Sexual Orientation: Freud’s Nineteenth-Century Mistake

4. Sexual Orientation: Freud’s Nineteenth-Century Mistake

4

Sexual Orientation

Freud’s Nineteenth-Century Mistake

What is Sexual Orientation?

In a recent blog post, Nick Roen wrote about the experience of walking into a room, seeing “Rick,” and feeling that warm feeling deep inside. Nick writes:

As I noticed Rick with pleasure, the attraction produced all sorts of “I want…” desires in me. One of those desires was a sexual desire. No, I wasn’t immediately imagining what it would be like to be in bed with him, but the seed was present. However, I also experienced many heightened desires toward Rick that had nothing to do with sex. I desired to go talk to him, shake his hand, get to know him, laugh with him, and serve him a glass of punch. In other words, not only were the seeds of sexual desire present, but the seeds of desires of friendship, hospitality, emotional intimacy, sacrificial service, and love were there as well. All different desires, all colored by the same initial attraction. It is this experience of persistent attractions toward other men leading to multiple heightened desires that constitutes my definition of SSA (same-sex attraction), experiencing a homosexual orientation, or “being gay.” The whole experience, not merely the sexual parts.1

In this blog post, Nick captures the common use of the concept of sexual orientation: “an enduring pattern of emotional, romantic, and/or sexual attractions to men, women, or both sexes,” as defined by the American Psychological Association (APA). In this post, Nick talks about being sexually attracted to Rick, but also being emotionally and affectionally attracted as well. He talks about how these patterns of attraction to men are “persistent” and that they are best categorized by the ideas of “homosexual orientation,” or “being gay.” Nick goes on in his essay to talk about how some of these attractions are sexually illicit and must be put to death, and others are morally neutral and/or beneficial and should be allowed to flourish, for both personal good and greater social good. I agree. Nick then explains, though, that the whole experience, the sanctified and the sinful, are all part of his sexual orientation. What Nick says is completely accurate according to the APA’s definition of sexual orientation.

Nick is a brother in the Lord and I value him and pray for him. In his writing and in our email correspondence, he has helped me see my own blind spots and errors. Even though we disagree on things, I know that he also prays for me. Importantly, I also know Nick’s commitment to living in chastity. But Nick promotes a category of personhood that I believe does all of us more harm than good.

Let me explain why.

Nineteenth Century Origins and the Power of the History of Ideas

The concept of sexual orientation was first used by Freud, and its effect, if not intent, was to radically resituate sexuality from its biblical/creational context to something completely new: the foundational drive that determines and defines human identity. Nothing short of personhood was at stake. By defining humanity according to sexual desires and segregating it according to its gendered object, Freud was—intentionally or not—suppressing the biblical category of being made in God’s image, male and female, and replacing it with the psychoanalytic category of sexual identity. In both intent and language usage, Freud took aim at the Bible’s authority to diagnose gender and sexuality dysfunctions and prescribe solutions for them. I do not believe that this was an innocent move. Throughout his career, Freud maintained that belief in the God of the Bible was a “universal obsessional neurosis.”2 The category of sexual orientation carries with it a cosmology of personhood that undervalues image bearers of a holy God.

Freud did not come out of nowhere. Ideas shape worldview and worldview shapes culture. Freud was a product of German Romanticism. The Romantic period3 is typified by an uncontested embrace of personal experience, not merely as self-expression or self-representation, but also as epistemology and personal identity (who I am, ontologically).4

            Epistemology—study of how I know what I know.

Johann Wolfgang von Goethe’s suicide memoir, The Sorrows of Young Werther, narrated this idea for western culture. Werther took Germany by storm in 1774, tragically spawning a number of suicides, while manifesting the idea that personal experience is itself a branch of epistemology. That is, Romanticism claimed that you know truth through the lens of your personal experience, and that no overriding or objective opposition can challenge the primal wisdom of someone’s subjective frame of intelligibility. In Romanticism, this knowing and being known is identity-rooted and identity-expressive. Romanticism went beyond a solipsistic me-centered understanding of selfhood. Solipsism is the belief that only one’s own mind and its properties are sure to exist. Romanticism took this one step further to declare personal feelings and experiences the most reliable measure and means of discerning truth.

Both a theological and philosophical issue is at stake here. The theological issue is the development of a category of personhood that rejects Original Sin. In rejecting Original Sin, the Romantics declared their belief in the inherent divinity and goodness of humanity. The philosophical issue is epistemology and the role of personal experience. Prior to the eighteenth century, experience-as-truth—even in secular contexts—would have met with real life and theological challenges. Even today, experience-as-truth is the lowest form of epistemology.

The nineteenth-century category of sexual orientation reflects Romanticism’s claim on epistemology, redefining men and women from people who are made in God’s image with souls that will last forever to people whose sexual drives and gender identifications define them and liberate them and set them apart. Indeed, while the Christian maintains that image-bearing is what sets apart humans from animals, the nineteenth century ushered in a new measure of man, one for whom sexuality and sexual pleasure became a defining marker. Thus, “sexual orientation” is what we call a neologism, and it creates fictional identities that rob people of their true one: male and female image bearers. Sexual orientation is a word that extends the definition of sexuality beyond its biblical confines. Biblically speaking, sexuality is always teleological—that is, sexual desire implies a desired object and sexual practice implies a necessary outcome. Because the APA’s definition of sexual orientation includes nonsexual affection, this re-maps personhood in a way that God does not.

            Neologism—a new word or expression, or a new meaning of a word.

Put another way, biblically speaking, there is nothing sinful and nothing “gay” about nonsexual same-sex deep and abiding friendship. Desiring to bring someone a glass of punch or sacrificially helping a friend who needs you is an expression of our image-bearing of a holy God, not our persistent patterns of sexual desire or temptation. We must stop and ask: why would the category of sexual orientation include nonsexual affiliation except for the purpose of defining in a new way what it means to be human? This is no small issue. If we privilege secular categories of personhood over and against God’s, we are doubting the Bible’s ability to understand humanity, and we are denying to ourselves our Maker’s instruction. Freud did not invent or discover or name something true about humanity that the writers of the Bible missed. Categories we use to represent image bearers of a holy God matter. Words, like kitchen washrags, carry and distribute history (and bacteria) with each use, and the category-invention of sexual orientation brings much bacteria with it.

Everyone loses when we define ourselves using categories that God does not. People who identify as heterosexual and homosexual have much to lose. In 2014, Michael Hannon wrote an absorbing essay in the journal First Things entitled “Against Heterosexuality: The Idea of Sexual Orientation is Artificial and Inhibits Christian Witness.”5 He begins his essay with Michel Foucault, the famous French historian of ideas who died of AIDS in 1980. Hannon writes:

Michel Foucault…details the pedigree of sexual orientation in his History of Sexuality. Whereas “sodomy” had long identified a class of actions, suddenly for the first time, in the second half of the nineteenth century, the term “homosexual” appeared alongside it. This European neologism was used in a way that would have struck previous generations as a plain category mistake, designating not actions, but people—and so also with its counterpart and foil “heterosexual”…with secular society rendering classical religious beliefs publicly illegitimate, pseudoscience stepped in and replaced religion as the moral foundation for venereal norms.6

Sexuality moved from verb (practice) to noun (people), and with this grammatical move, a new concept of humanity was born—the idea that we are oriented or framed by our sexual desires; that our differing sexual desires and different objects of desire made up separate species of people, and that self-representation and identity rooted now in sexual orientation, and not in the purposes of God for his image bearers. In Foucault’s words, “Homosexuality appeared as one of the forms of sexuality…when it was transposed from the practice of sodomy into a kind of interior androgyny, a hermaphrodism of the soul. The sodomite had been a temporary aberration; the homosexual was a new species”7 (emphasis mine). Prior to the nineteenth century category-invention of sexual orientation, no one’s sexual practice or sexual desire prescribed personhood or defined their personal identity.

Notice Foucault’s use of the words form, soul, and species. The use of the word form implies that sexual desire shapes our organizing frame, the basic building block of selfhood. The use of the word soul implies that sexuality, not God’s image, was the real harbinger of humanity. The use of the word species means that a new concept of humanity was born, at least within the history of ideas. Sexuality, according to this new definition, exceeds sexual desire. Even in Foucault’s articulation, nonsexual affections are catalogued under a person’s sexual orientation, thus relocating sexual desire from teleology (its end point) to psychology (personhood, personality, likes, dislikes, etc.). Sexual orientation is thus said to encompass every fiber of a person’s selfhood, from margin to center. If I self-define as heterosexual or homosexual, I express that this deep and originating mark of selfhood presents itself in everything I do, from how I walk the dog in the morning, stir the pot of soup at lunch, and take the garbage out at night. With this comprehensive shift in personhood, a new kind of sexual freedom emerged, where everything, including nonsexual affection, is subsumed by this new humanity of sexuality, and everything is a character trait that flows from this humanity of sexuality.

Indeed, sexual orientation went from a categorical invention to heralded immortal truth in one hundred years, taking out the concept of being created in God’s image and bearing an eternal soul in its wake. It is now a term embraced uncritically by believers and unbelievers alike. Sexual orientation defines selfhood as the sum-total of our fallen human desires. Through it, we get no glimpse of how the covenant of grace defends our real identity in Christ, or why, say, biblical marriage is a Goddesigned creation ordinance and a living reflection of Christ and the church, and not merely a man-made convenience.

Heterosexual Blindness and Comparative Sin

I believe that sexual orientation is a lose-lose paradigm for everyone, but especially if you struggle with unwanted homosexual desires. Hannon, in contrast, thinks that self-described heterosexuals have the most to lose. He writes: “The most pernicious aspect of the orientation-identity system is that it tends to exempt heterosexuality from moral evaluation. If homosexuality binds us to sin, heterosexuality blinds us to sin.”8 This heterosexual blindness seems to have two forms: excuse-making for sexual sins of a heterosexual bent (pornography, incest, fornication, and adultery), and an excessive, scintillating focus on what gay men do in bed, known in evangelical circles as the “gag reflex.”9 Indeed, because of the unwitting deceitfulness of the sexual orientation paradigm, we are much more likely to be numb to heterosexual sin and excessively focused on homosexual sin than we would have been prior to the nineteenth century.

            Paradigm—a model or pattern for something that may be copied.

Heterosexual blindness makes a Christian ignorant to the very sins that may destroy him; homosexual approval makes a person unable to enter into a gay neighbor’s life in a way that God may use to spare him from God’s wrath. Both take Christian witness out of the game. This might raise another question: does Paul’s observation in Romans 1:26 that homosexual sex is unnatural warrant the conclusion that heterosexual sexual sin (such as adultery or pornography) is a less heinous form of sin? John Murray’s commentary on the book of Romans has been used to defend this paradigm of comparative sin, as he says this on Romans 1:26: “The implication is that, however grievous is fornication or adultery, the desecration involved in homosexuality is on a lower plane of degeneracy; it is unnatural and therefore evinces a perversion more basic.”10

Does it necessarily follow that homosexual sexual sin is on a higher plane of evil? The question might be posed like this: is Murray endorsing the paradigm of comparative sin (i.e., comparing your sin to someone else’s in order to conclude that yours is not as bad)? Many Christians follow a line of reasoning like Murray’s and draw the conclusion that same-sex sin is somehow farther from the reach of God’s redemption than other expressions of sexual sin. But pride, lust, bitterness, anger, and a multitude of other sins lie behind our sexual sins in a way that prohibits sweeping generalizations as to the evil of one over and against all others. After all, there are heterosexual perversions and abuses that are unspeakably abhorrent. A heterosexually married man who rapes and abuses his wife is committing horrific evil that is in no way mitigated by the fact that it is heterosexual. God forbid that anyone might suggest otherwise.

We do have a biblical model based on excusing yourself from repentance on the grounds of comparative sin. It is found in Luke 18, in the parable of the Pharisee and the Publican, and it doesn’t go so well for the Pharisee:

10 “Two men went up into the temple to pray, one a Pharisee and the other a tax collector.

11 The Pharisee stood and was praying this to himself: ‘God, I thank You that I am not like other people: swindlers, unjust, adulterers, or even like this tax collector.

12 I fast twice a week; I pay tithes of all that I get.’

13 But the tax collector, standing some distance away, was even unwilling to lift up his eyes to heaven, but was beating his breast, saying, ‘God, be merciful to me, the sinner!’”

The paradigm of comparative sin proves to be a boat with holes, as the sins of self-righteous Pharisees reveal themselves more often than not to be more heinous than the sins of humble Publicans. This is true, even if the Pharisees sin in their heterosexual lust and the Publicans sin in their unwanted homosexual lust.

The practice of sexual sin is a fruit of other, more devastating sins: pride and lust. Satan loves best those Christians who delude themselves with fantasies of excused fleshly grandeur, but then walk the road to hell with misapplied confidence. Hannon says that this presumption that heterosexual sexual orientation is sanctified simply because it is heterosexual “ushers in a pathetically uncritical and…unmerited self-assurance, not to mention an inaccurate measure for evaluating temptation.”11 I agree.

But we still must confront what the Bible says about the “unnaturalness” of homosexual sex in Romans 1:

25 For they exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshipped and served the creature rather than the Creator…

26 For this reason God gave them over to degrading passions; for their women exchanged the natural function for that which is unnatural,

27 and in the same way also the men abandoned the natural function of the woman and burned in their desire toward one another, men with men committing indecent acts and receiving in their own persons the due penalty of their error.

Romans 1 will always hold a powerful place in my life as a believer. I first read these words when I was in a committed lesbian relationship. My first response was to ridicule them. I had not always identified as a lesbian, but once I met my first lesbian lover, I was hooked. I was sure I had found my real self. And I was mighty sure that I knew myself better than this ancient book whose words called into question my ability to discern right from wrong.

But after working through the rest of the Bible multiple times, I had to confront that the God who created us has the right to define those “ordinances” of his creation,12 including human sexuality. While I came to believe that by God’s design, sexuality is for the fulfillment of God’s creation ordinance, I did not experience this truth. I only embraced God’s truth because my conscience condemned me. At a certain point, I realized that the Bible was God’s Word, and it had the right to condemn me, and not the other way around.

Through God’s power, I embraced the Bible, as I do any number of things about God and faith that in my sin or limitation I don’t experience firsthand. And because I embraced it, as a new believer who still felt very much like I lived experientially on the wrong side of the natural revelation tracks, I had to study the idea of biblical sexuality from two perspectives: 1) biblical ethics (what the Bible declares), and 2) personal growth in Christ. Personal growth in Christ flowed from the pastoral care given by Pastor Ken Smith and other members of the Syracuse Reformed Presbyterian Church, and it flowed through the means of grace that lead us, in spite of our feelings or past behavior, to live as new creatures in Christ, standing in the risen Christ alone. It occurred to me early in this journey that to declare the biblical ethics of natural law scriptural is not necessarily implying that its point of view is always pastoral.

            Natural law—the moral revelation that God gives in creation.

Natural Revelation as Biblical Ethics

Romans 1:18–20 puts forth the biblical idea of what theologians call “natural revelation”—the disclosure of God and his laws as they are seen in nature. Romans 1 says this:

18 For the wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men who suppress the truth in unrighteousness,

19 because that which is known about God is evident within them; for God made it evident to them.

20 For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes, His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen, being understood through what has been made, so that they are without excuse.

Let me tell you straight up that these words drove me mad. I hate to think in terms of wrath, punishment, and the expectation that we all learn the same lessons from the same perceptions or experiences. Every fiber in my postmodern being retaliated against this way of thinking. But here we see that God holds us responsible for “suppress[ing] the truth in unrighteousness” (v. 18). He declares that ungodliness is “evident within them” (v. 19). He portrays man as “without excuse,” because his power and character have “been clearly seen” and “understood through what has been made” (v. 20).

When I read this as an unbeliever, I found this patronizingly insulting. I loved my lesbian partners and the community that we created, and yet these verses made it evident that God wanted me to behave differently than I did. Only later as a believer could I see why this argument did not convince me: God does not claim that the gospel is found within this portrayal of his power and divinity in nature. In other words, “natural revelation” exposed my sin, but God understood that there is a difference between the diagnosis and the cure. Natural revelation portrays God’s diagnosis, but only in the gospel do I find the cure. That seemed fair. It seemed to be saying that my responsibility as an image bearer required that I know more of God than that which is found in the law. Specifically, it goaded me to know the gospel, to study it, to ponder it, to allow it to creep through the wall that I had built around my heart. Natural revelation revealed my sin and caused me to doubt the unitarian message that sin did not matter. This burgeoning awareness reminded me of one of my favorite dead white guys.

Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274 AD) believed that natural law led to natural moral awareness. Thomas Aquinas read Aristotle (384–322 BC) through a Christian lens in the same way that St. Augustine (354–430 AD) read Plato (c. 422–347 BC). I found Aquinas to be one of the best minds that ever walked the earth, and I was troubled to arrive at a conclusion that he did not. But I also knew enough about my own sins to know that some held more surface interests, while others really pulled at my heart. Sexual sin ran deep and hard for me. I needed a whole lot more than moral awareness, and I knew it, even if those around me didn’t.

But I had bigger problems than those posed by squaring off with a dead white guy, even one for whom I felt affection. Every time I heard a Christian in my church declare natural law as the trump card to end the problem of homosexual sex, I just wanted to scream. Do you have any idea how many times people have told me that the Bible made Adam for Eve, not Adam for Steve? If I had a nickel for each time, I would be a millionaire! I could not understand why people in my church were so convinced by this argument. Adam and Steve did not rock my boat in the least bit.

Natural law is effective biblical ethics and public policy, but it is an incomplete pastoral instrument, because natural law is not the gospel. When we preach the gospel, we preach the promise of a new life, new mind, new hope, new purpose, new union with Christ, new company of the Holy Spirit, new pardon of sin, new affinity for repentance and closeness with God, new love of the law, new ability to obey, new understanding of why God demands chastity outside of marriage and fidelity inside of marriage, new patience with people who do not yet know Jesus, new perspectives on suffering and affliction, addiction and change, new hatred of our own sin and patience with the sin of others, new responsibilities, new heartaches, new friendships, a new family from within the body of Christ, new allegiances, new dangers, and new grace. I needed the expulsive love of my risen Savior to whisper in my ear that my burgeoning conviction of sin was truer than what my flesh craved.

Through the power of the gospel, it became clear that God’s provision of salvation required that I understand from his point of view a biblical sexual ethic. Because God in Jesus Christ was my Savior and friend, I realized that I needed to take the time to really get to know him. I needed to steep myself in the means of grace and wean myself from the world. And God used natural revelation to reveal my sin in this way: my knee-jerk response to creation ordinances revealed to me that I was resistant to know God. And that was sin. So I committed myself to study these ordinances. It became clear that marriage between a man and a woman was by God’s design. It also seemed clear that God did not design everyone for marriage. Natural revelation told me what God required, but without gospel grace, I could no more live out these Christian ethics than I could walk on water.

Gag Reflex and the Problem of Point of View

Does the fact that homosexual sex is, according to the Bible, against nature mean that a useful Christian response to this is the gag reflex? Does it logically follow that if you are on the right side of God’s story, you should gag (i.e., become visibly sick to the point of wanting to vomit) at the sin of others?

This makes sense in one way only: we are called to have a conscience that is sensitive to recognize sin and a Christian reflex that is quick to flee from it. But there is a serious problem with the gag reflex: it allows for a voyeuristic approach to sin. The gag reflex argument describes gay sex in unnecessary detail, unwittingly encouraging Christians to dwell on these sins to the harm and detriment of all of us. The sexual orientation paradigm has turned people into practices, thus making the gag reflex a condemnation of people themselves, not only people who engage in such practices, but also people who desire them.

While likely unintended, three things happen when Christians write blogs or books and paint a gay sex scene as an encouragement to gag:

1) The Christian writer scapegoats faithful Christians who love Jesus and yet struggle with unwanted homosexual lust. Indeed, these faithful and struggling Christians become the example of the person who should cause you to want to gag or vomit. And, likely, they are sitting in the pew next to you every Lord’s Day morning.

2) The Christian writer portrays sex acts with vivid recall that will unwittingly entice some Christians to desire it or bring to mind the repented sin of years gone by, causing grief and anguish and a general reliving of the very things that Jesus has covered with his blood.

3) The Christian writer gives ammunition to people who have exclusively heterosexual desires to unmerited self-righteousness, creating a sexual identity that is potentially marked by the deadly sin of pride. Indeed, this “gag reflex” that some evangelicals endorse reveals that the concept of sexual orientation weakened biblical sexuality for everyone by allowing heterosexually expressed sexual sin to pass under the radar as tolerable because they somehow reflect the biblical norm (including pornography and adultery), and by exposing homosexually expressed sexual sin as the only one of great moral danger.

In sum, sexual orientation is harmful for self-identified heterosexuals because it bathes heterosexual sexual desire with sanctifying impulse—even that which is directed outside of marriage, through pornography and adultery—and demonizes homosexual desires as unnatural—failing to register that what renders sexual orientation unnatural is the neologism itself. When Romans 1:26 references unnatural (“exchanged the natural function for that which is unnatural”), it regards practice, not personhood; it references what a person ought not do (morally), not who a person is (ontologically). Any believer who has been justified by God is ontologically a child of God, a son or daughter of the King, and set apart from before the foundations of the world. There is no ontological category of sexual orientation. The idea of identity emerging from sexual desire embodies a philosophy of the soul that is false. Sexual orientation is a category that adds and stirs all solipsistic fallen sexual impulses and desires into a paradigm of individual entitlement, writing off God’s covenantal relationship to his people and his teleological design of sexuality within biblical marriage, and denying that their fruit rests in redemption through Christ’s blood alone.

Christians who feel beholden by the culture to use the concept of sexual orientation ought to stop and ask one question: where ought we to situate sexual orientation in relation to biblical principles? If we were to fish around for a biblical place to contain this neologism (which is sloppy theology at best), it could only be traced to the biblical concept of “flesh.”

In the Bible, the concept of “flesh” is mainly used in three different ways: 1) to describe the human body (i.e., “flesh and blood”); 2) to describe human weakness and the perishable nature of the body (i.e., “all flesh is grass”); and 3) to describe the sinful nature of fallen man, as described in Romans 8:

6 For the mind set on the flesh is death, but the mind set on the Spirit is life and peace,

7 because the mind set on the flesh is hostile toward God; for it does not subject itself to the law of God, for it is not even able to do so.

Indeed, The Westminster Larger Catechism reminds us to “guard against the extremely common error that the word flesh means a part of our human nature. It does not refer to a “lower” nature; it refers to our whole nature as corrupted by sin.”13 Born in the sin of Adam as we all are, “there is nothing human that has not been corrupted and defiled by our fall into sin.”14 Thus, “sexual orientation,” or any term that seeks to define humanity without recognizing our fallen nature, and the redemptive grace offered in Jesus Christ, can only misrepresent humanity in the long run, even if it appears to provide some temporary clarity for the here and now.

At its best, sexual orientation is a vestige of our flesh.

At its best, sexual orientation is a vestige of our flesh. The term itself cannot be labeled sin or grace. Sexual orientation fronts a category of personhood that privileges natural desires over redeemed ones. One’s sexual orientation—heterosexual or homosexual or bisexual or pansexual (and the list will not end here)—cannot be sanctified, because sanctification would indeed cause its eradication, as sanctification obliterates all pretenses of the staying power of natural virtue or vice over and against the power of the gospel. And while you must repent of sexual sin, you cannot repent of sexual orientation, since sexual orientation is an artificial category built on a faulty premise. You have a better shot of putting Humpty Dumpty together again than reinventing sexual orientation as a biblical category.

Major doctrines of the Christian faith are at stake in this conversation. Sanctification is God’s desire and his gift to all believers: “for this is the will of God, your sanctification; that is, that you abstain from sexual immorality” (1 Thess. 4:3). Therefore, there is no such thing as a believer who has been justified by God (pardoned by judicial decree) without also being sanctified (infused with God’s grace that subdues sin and enables the believer to live in obedience). If there is truly no sanctification (including the sanctifying grace of humility that knows sin’s power in our life and our need for Jesus because of this), there is no fruit of conversion.

In the language of The Westminster Catechism, justification is imputed (a legal term that changes a person’s account and status before God). In contrast, sanctification is infused (literally, “poured in,” describing the way that God pours into believers his love and grace such that the personal character, not the legal status, of the believer is changed by God). Sanctification is “an act of God’s free grace; a work by which God infuses grace and power, a work in which God subdues sin, different in degree in different persons, incomplete and imperfect in this life, [and] a divinely planted and watered spiritual growth of Christian character.”15

What is sanctified is the believer, not the believer in the context of his or her sexual orientation, the artificial category mistake spawned by Freud and inbred into every conversation about sexual identity that has trailed along after him ever since. If you are a child of God, washed in the blood of Christ, you should never again be defined by or reduced to an “orientation” linked to a pattern of even persistent temptations.

Personal Identity and Sexual Orientation

When I “came out” as a lesbian in 1992, I had already been living as one for a few years. The experience of coming out was for me a rite of passage, embarked upon in the hope of being honest and bringing the details—private and public—of my life together. Coming out as a lesbian was my way of staking my claim at identity. Somewhere between college and graduate school, in my mind, things shifted from “Why do I feel this way?” to “This is who I am: take it or leave it.” But never did I use the concept of sexual orientation to describe my sexual identity. I was a nineteenth-century scholar and I held some scholarly suspicions about this category. Also, “sexual orientation” was not part of my lesbian, poststructural, queer culture.

Coming out, naming my experience, and claiming my personal identity mattered enough to me to risk relationships and job opportunities. I thought long and hard about the ramifications of this disclosure. Terms like “same-sex attraction” were also not in my vocabulary. I had never heard of Exodus International, and I likely would have described an “ex-gay” as an unhappy camper. And no one in the LGBT community from which I emerged would have ever claimed to have been “born this way.” We believed that sexuality was fluid. The “born this way” idea was potentially pathologizing to lesbians of my generation.

Because we were leaders in poststructural feminism and Queer Theory, disciplines that understood sexuality as a social construct, we situated ourselves—for good or bad, right or wrong—in the world of free choice. We claimed psychological proof that gender and sexuality were social constructs, and as such, matters of personal expression that can be changed, resisted, or shaped as our own individual sense of personal integrity and desire allowed. Because we believed that “gay is good,” we embraced a missionary’s zeal about political and social activism. We believed that all good things flowed from our sexual desires and the egalitarianism of our households.

            Social construct—a category created by society.

Adrienne Rich, the late feminist, lesbian, poet, essayist, and professor, gave words to my world in her essay, “Compulsory Heterosexuality and Lesbian Existence.”16 Her essay explained my feelings and personal experience in ways no one else had ever done before. I was amazed that there was a name for who I was. Like most lesbians of her generation, Adrienne Rich initially defined herself as heterosexual, was married to a man from 1953 to 1970 and bore children. She became widowed in 1970. Over time, her sexual attractions to one woman emerged. (Adrienne Rich and Michelle Cliff remained partnered until Rich’s death at age eighty-three in 2012.) Rich introduced vocabulary into my world that helped me look in a mirror and recognize what I saw.

For Rich, all women exist on a lesbian continuum, where women-identified roles and experiences make up the fabric of life and the meaning of women’s history. Importantly, this included nonsexual affections. The term itself, lesbian continuum, upended any “sexual orientation” idea or a God-ordained gender and sexual essentialism.17 Lesbian became the new norm for all women. She wrote: “I have chosen to use the terms lesbian existence and lesbian continuum because the word ‘lesbianism’ has a clinical and limiting ring…. I mean the term lesbian continuum to include a range—through each woman’s life and throughout history—of women-identified experience, not simply the fact that a woman has had or consciously desired genital sexual experience with another woman.”18 Thus, lesbian continuum became a map over time of both women who had sexual desires for other women and those who did not, but who wanted to excuse themselves from the history of patriarchy that, divorced from God’s holy ordination, felt obligatory, compulsory, dangerous, and deadly.19

Why Words Matter

Because I am a new creature in Christ, my identity, and the words that I use to reflect that, must honor the primacy of Christ indwelling my life. It must. I died and rose again with Jesus, my Lord. For all who claim Christ, personal identity is a constant war between flesh and spirit, between the who-I-am-in-the-flesh and my new nature, redeemed, but still fallen. Much of this tension Paul captures in the book of Romans. Chapter 12 begins thus:

1 Therefore, I urge you, brethren, by the mercies of God, to present your bodies a living and holy sacrifice, acceptable to God, which is your spiritual service of worship.

2 And do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, so that you may prove what the will of God is, that which is good and acceptable and perfect.

We need to daily “renew our minds” and “present our bodies a living sacrifice,” but we can only do this by the “mercies of God.”

Because we labor for sanctification in both private devotions and in community, it is also important, vital, and lifegiving for others in your church to know, in fullness of truth, who you are. For this reason, it is important to me that Christians who struggle with unwanted homosexual desires feel safe and welcome in a church community, knowing that God’s people will meet you in your struggle and stick by your side for the long haul. It is not, in any way, immodest or un-Christian to tell people who love you that you daily bear the weight of homosexual desire, and that this affects your current relationships and your legitimate fears about the future. If this is your experience, you need to share this so that people in your church community can be your friend in a real way. There is no shame in truth telling.

Truth telling is not the same thing as coming out.

But truth telling is not the same thing as coming out. Coming out refers to a right of passage in the gay community where you set yourselves apart from your family of origin. Christians convert, and in conversion, God gives you a new family in the church. Conversion means that a Christian’s primary loyalty is to the body of Christ in its diversity, not a ghetto of like-minded believers who assemble an identity based in patterns—even fixed and pervasive ones—of temptation. Who could share the burdens of our hearts without the family of God to listen?

In one of those many passages of the Bible that brings me to tears, Jesus tells us something transformative about the family of God. In Mark 10, we read this:

28 Peter began to say to Him, “Behold, we have left everything and followed You.”

29 Jesus said, “Truly I say to you, there is no one who has left house or brothers or sisters or mother or father or children or farms, for My sake and for the gospel’s sake,

30 but that he will receive a hundred times as much now in the present age, houses and brothers and sisters and mothers and children and farms, along with persecutions; and in the age to come, eternal life.”

These verses promise that a brother or sister should never be or feel alone, isolated, unloved, or unwelcome. These verses tell us that through brotherhood and sisterhood, believers are to receive “a hundred times as much now in the present age.” That does not mean that we abandon brothers and sisters to go it alone, but rather that we walk together shoulder to shoulder, as we look forward to eternity, where our inner renewal will be complete and full. Together and in community we help each other to not lose heart, saying, with Paul, “Therefore we do not lose heart, but though our outer man is decaying, yet our inner man is being renewed day by day” (2 Cor. 4:16).

I long to see the church serving as this kind of community.

In the Christian community that Christ portrays here, our churches are intentionally diverse and we all call ourselves by the one name of greatest honor: Christian.

↑ Back to top

↑