Chapter 3 of 13

1. Conversion: The Spark of a New Identity

1. Conversion: The Spark of a New Identity

1

Conversion

The Spark of a New Identity

Welcome to my world. By day, a homeschool mom and a pastor’s wife. By dark of the morning, a writer. Sometimes this perfect bubble is burst, and I get on planes and speak to church and university audiences about living a messy life in Christ. Some days, the complex tapestry of my life in Christ makes sense. Most days, though, it does not. My testimony is like iodine on starch. There is nothing neutral about it, about me, or about my life in Jesus Christ.

Of course, it is not just my testimony—the story, to the best of my ability to tell it, of how the God of the universe burst into my secular world and atheistic worldview in the person of Jesus Christ in 1999, when I was thirty-six years old, happily partnered in a lesbian relationship, and recently tenured in the English department of Syracuse University, poised and ready to work in the field of Queer Theory. Somehow, I missed the “party-like-it’s-1999” paradigm, and my world was turned upside down and inside out.

I was a true believer before I became a true believer in Christ.

Passionately pursuing truth and justice is in my blood.

I wrote about all of this in a book entitled The Secret Thoughts of an Unlikely Convert. It is a small book, and I wrote it because, as the years unfolded after my conversion, I started to look dangerously cleaned up. I’m not. Well-meaning church ladies who had been raised on the right side of the Christian tracks and who gave themselves unearned kudos for good choices thought I was one of them. In the parlance of queer culture, I “passed.” But I’m not one of them. I’m Mary Magdalene. I’m Rahab the Harlot. Left to my own devices, I am much more the whore next door than the girl next door. I’m a woman with a past, and Christ’s call on my life did not lobotomize me. Nor did it leave me with the sentiment that Christians are better, nicer, more honest and a more fun crop of cronies. We are not. No way. At least, not in my experience.

My conversion left my former friends and family thinking I was loony to the core. How could I leave a worldview that was open, welcoming, and inclusive for one that believes in Original Sin, values the law of God, seeks conversion into a born-again constitution, believes in the truthful ontology of God’s Word as found in the Bible, claims the exclusivity of Christ for salvation, and purports the redemptive quality of suffering? Only one reason: because Jesus is a real and risen Lord and because he claimed me for himself.

Life stories are messy, contradictory, and humiliating. Mine is.

I wrote Openness Unhindered as much to learn as I did to share what I have learned in the years since the publication of Secret Thoughts. If you are curious about Christianity, it is my hope that this book answers your questions about who Jesus is and what Christians believe. If you are struggling with your sin, trying to apply God’s expectations and the balm of his purpose to each clobbering temptation, my hope is that these pages will encourage you to fight the good fight, for the honor of Jesus is at stake in every encounter, every thought, every relationship, every decision. If you have lost the fight and now believe that the Bible and the God who stands behind it cannot be trusted, I hope that you will find in the pages of this book the humiliating reality that we don’t measure up, and that it is never too late to repent—again—and turn back to the God who made you. Jesus understands you better than you understand yourself. Please take my hand and join me on this journey.

For those of you who missed Secret Thoughts, let me share a little about myself.

I had a normal childhood. I was raised in the Catholic faith, and I attended, predominantly, liberal Catholic schools. My liberal, Catholic, all-girl high school discipled me in the life skills that I use today. I learned there to read deeply and well, to diagram a sentence before I tried to interpret it, and to look out for the unloved and draw them in. I also learned that the Bible was a literary text, discernible through the lenses of literary devices. It seemed to me that the resurrection of Jesus Christ was a metaphor, powerful only in worlds of words. I loved worlds of words, and so a metaphorical god with metaphorical power was good enough for me. God was simply another manifestation of the power of positive thinking, at least for me.

I had a heterosexual adolescence.

My all-girl Catholic high school dished out plenty of academic rigor and ably prepared me for college, but it did not prepare me for the sexual meat market that I met there.

I had a clear love-hate relationship with this sexual meat market.

On the one hand, I was jazzed by the attention that college men gave me. I had always been a nerd, easy to overlook, a plain Jane. But I started to blossom in college, and people noticed. On the other hand, this sexual meat market made me feel ill inside. As I courted the attention of men, I fantasized about relationships with women.

In college, I met my first boyfriend. It was a heady experience. But we graduated and it was then that I noticed it: an undercurrent of longing inserted itself into my intense friendships with women. This intrigued me, so I followed the rabbit trail.

I could not manage to contain or make sense of sexuality. It completely bowled me over. I have never felt so out of control, so metaphorically intoxicated as I did during my twenties, when the sexual backdrop of college and then graduate school mixed with my own tangled sexual desires brought this onslaught of confusion, euphoria, and chaos.

From the age of twenty-two until twenty-eight, I continued to date men and at the same time feel a sense of longing and connection that toppled over the edges for my women friends, especially my friends from my growing lesbian and feminist community base.

I never hated men. They just didn’t show up on my radar in ways as meaningful, deep, or important. I never dreamed of marriage or kids. I presumed that I was straight. Men liked me. I tolerated sexual advances. And I remained steadfastly curious about what it would be like to be with a woman.

This repetitious lesbian sensibility rooted and grew: I simply preferred the company of women. In my late twenties, enhanced by feminist philosophy and LGBT political advocacy, my homosocial preference morphed into homosexuality. That shift was subtle, not startling. My lesbian identity and my love for my LGBT community developed in sync with my lesbian sexual practice. Life finally came together for me and made sense.

I studied Sigmund Freud. I cheered that the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders had long since removed homosexuality from its list of disorders (thus rendering homosexuality, in the eyes of the world and the academy, normal). With no prohibitions or constraints, by the time I had graduated from Ohio State with my PhD in English literature and critical theory, I left the Buckeye State with my first lesbian partner. We moved to New York for me to begin a tenure track position in the English department of Syracuse University. It was 1992.

My life as a lesbian seemed normal. I considered it an enlightened, chosen path. Lesbianism felt like a cleaner and more moral sexual practice.1 Always preferring symmetry to asymmetry, I believed I had found my real self. Many other women in my lesbian community had had a heterosexual season. We believed that was because heterosexuality had become, in the words of the late lesbian poet and English professor Adrienne Rich, compulsory. When I fell in love with a woman for the first time, I thought I had found my real self. I was hooked, and I had no intention of looking back.

What happened to my Catholic training? I believed now that faith in God was superstitious and intellectually untenable.

The name Jesus, which had rolled off my tongue in a little girl’s prayers, then rolled off my back in college, now made me recoil with anger.

As a professor of English and women’s studies, I cared about morality, justice, and compassion. As a scholar of the nineteenth century, fervent for the worldviews of Freud, Hegel, Marx, and Darwin, I strove to stand with the disempowered. My life at this time was happy, meaningful, and full.

My next lesbian partner and I shared many vital interests: AIDS activism, children’s health and literacy, golden retriever rescue, and our Unitarian Universalist church, to name a few. It was hard to argue that she and I were anything but good citizens and caregivers. The LGBT community values hospitality and applies it with skill, sacrifice, and integrity. Indeed, I honed the hospitality gifts that I use today as a pastor’s wife in my queer community.

I began researching the Religious Right and their politics of hatred against people like me. To do this, I began reading the Bible while looking for some Bible scholar to help me wade through this complex book. I took note that the Bible was an engaging literary display of every genre and trope and type. It had edgy poetry, deep and complex philosophy, and compelling narrative stories. It also embodied a worldview that I hated. Sin. Repentance. Sodom and Gomorrah. Absurd.

At this time, the Promise Keepers came to town and parked their little circus at the university. In my war against stupid, I wrote an article published in the local newspaper. It was 1997.

A lot of Christians hated that article, and many wrote letters to me about how I was going to hell. One letter, from Ken Smith, was different from the rest. I liked its tone. And its author was a neighbor. I responded to this one letter, and Ken and I became friends. Real friends. Not friendship evangelism. I was not a project to Ken. I was a neighbor, and Ken taught me that Christians value neighbors.

Ken’s letter didn’t mock; it engaged.

With the letter, Ken initiated two years of bringing the church to me. Oh, I had seen my share of Bible verses on placards at gay pride marches. That Christians who mocked me at Gay Pride Day were happy that I and everyone I loved were going to hell was as clear as the sky is blue. But Ken’s letter did not mock; it engaged. So when he invited me to dinner at his house to discuss these matters more fully, I accepted. My motives at the time were clear: surely this would be good for my research.

Something else happened. Ken and his wife, Floy, and I became friends. They entered my world. They met my friends. We did book exchanges. We talked openly about sexuality and politics. They did not act as if such conversations were polluting them. They did not treat me like a blank slate.

When we ate together, Ken prayed in a way that I had never heard before. His prayers were intimate. Vulnerable. He repented of his sin in front of me. He thanked God for all things. Ken’s God was holy and firm, yet full of mercy. At my first meal at their home, Ken and Floy omitted two important steps in the rulebook of how Christians should deal with a heathen like me: 1) they did not share the gospel with me, and 2) they did not invite me to church. Because of these omissions to the Christian rulebook as I had come to know it, I felt that when Ken extended his hand to me in friendship, it was safe to close my hand in his.

            Canonicity—refers to the books inspired by God for inclusion in the Bible.

            Hermeneutics—the method of interpreting the Bible.

I started meeting with Ken and Floy regularly, reading the Bible in earnest, with pen in hand and notebook in lap. I read the way a glutton devours. I became close friends with a member of the church, a man my age with my complex history of sexual sin, but who had made a profession of faith and had become a follower of this man-God Jesus. He helped me along with my Bible reading and questions. I started to read the Bible the way that I was trained to read a book, examining its textual authority, authorship, canonicity, and internal hermeneutics. A year later, this man and I became engaged (long story here, and you will have to read Secret Thoughts to get the fuller one). When he dumped me, that was when I knew that I belonged to Christ alone. I will be ever grateful for this face-plant of a lesson, but also for what he modeled for me: how to read the Bible, in big chunks, reading it from Genesis to Revelation many times in one year.

I read the Bible like that the first year, arguing with its gender politics and its statements about slavery. But I kept reading it. Slowly and over time, the Bible started to take on a life and meaning that startled me. Some of my well-worn paradigms no longer stuck. As I studied the Bible, I found answers to my initial accusations. I delved into its canonicity, its hermeneutics, and its opposing theological approaches. My PhD training ably prepared me to know what a book says, to assess the integrity of its textual history and canonicity, and to make a call about its authority. God used this singular nerdy skill in the most important book study of my life.

The Bible simultaneously encouraged and enraged me.

The Bible was this unmined text, and it simultaneously encouraged and enraged me.

I had to at least ponder the hermeneutical claim that this book was different from all the others because it was inspired by a holy God and was inherently true and trustworthy. This led me to go through the presuppositional truth-claims, just to check the math of the meaning here. The logic claim starts with God’s attributes, particularly his goodness and his holiness and authority.

1) God’s goodness. If God is good, then his goodness is unrestrained by time and therefore anticipates and guards against the ill treatment of any people group. This was a book written by men who claimed to be inspired by the Holy Spirit. I noticed that its statements about sin were followed by offers of repentance and forgiveness. God deals differently with us when we deal differently with him.

2) God’s holiness and authority. If God is the creator of all things, and if the Bible has his seal of truth and power, then the Bible has the right to interrogate my life and my culture, and not the other way around. If this was a book written by men who were inspired by the Holy Spirit, then its admonitions about sin were not applied cultural phobia. Indeed, prior to reading the Bible for myself, I believed that the category of sin was merely applied cultural phobia. But even as a postmodern reader, I understood the idea that authority can depend only on that which is higher than itself. If God exists, then who is higher than God? I wondered.

My friends knew that I was reading the Bible. First, the dean of the chapel took me out to lunch and shared his belief that the Old Testament was dispensable and, with it, any prohibition about sexuality and immorality. But I had been reading and studying the three different narratives of the Old Testament, and it seemed to me that you couldn’t dispense with it in its entirety without violating a foundational rule about canonicity: no creating canons within canons. In fact, I had just gone over this in my graduate seminar in Queer Theory and it made me wonder if the chapel dean ought not sit in on my class. His position seemed like a hermeneutic of convenience, tailoring the text to fit my experience, and not a hermeneutic of integrity, where the text gets the chance to fulfill its internal mission.

            Queer Theory—a branch of gay and lesbian studies developed in 1990; emphasizes the social construction of gender and sexuality.

Even a postmodern reader-response critic knows that each text has an internal mission. The internal mission of the Bible is to transform the nature of humanity. That is why unbelievers know it is a dangerous text. I was puzzled that the chapel dean seemed to have such little understanding of this book that he had studied better than I had. It confirmed for me what all English professors suspect about the world: no one really knows how to read a book anymore.

Next, at a dinner gathering that my partner and I were hosting, my transgendered friend J cornered me in the kitchen. She put her large hand over mine and said, “Rosaria, this Bible reading is changing you.”

I felt exposed. She was right. She always was. “But what if it is true? What if Jesus is a real and risen Lord? What if we are all in trouble?” I asked.

J exhaled deeply and sat down in the chair across from mine. Her eyes looked wise and she said: “Rosaria, I was a Presbyterian minister for fifteen years. I prayed that God would heal me, but he didn’t. If you want, I will pray for you.”

This encounter gave me secret tacit permission to keep reading the Bible. My dear friend J had also read it cover to cover, many times, and had rooted around in its deep crevices for life purpose and help. The bomb she dropped also enraged me. Who is this Jesus who heals some but not others? No peace and social justice activist wants an unequal-opportunity God.

The next day, when I returned home from work, I found two large milk crates spilling over with theological books. J’s books. She was giving them to me. In Calvin’s Institutes of the Christian Religion, in the margins of a passage about the book of Romans, in J’s handwriting, was a warning: “Be careful here. Don’t forget Romans 1.”

This is what it says in Romans 1:

21 For even though they knew God, they did not honor Him as God or give thanks, but they became futile in their speculations and their foolish heart was darkened.

22 Professing to be wise, they became fools,

23 and exchanged the glory of the incorruptible God for an image in the form of corruptible man and of birds and four-footed animals and crawling creatures.

24 Therefore God gave them over in the lusts of their hearts to impurity, so that their bodies would be dishonored among them.

25 For they exchanged the truth of God for a lie, and worshiped and served the creature rather than the Creator….

26 For this reason God gave them over to degrading passions; for their women exchanged the natural function for that which is unnatural….

I found the verb clauses here to be particularly arresting—did not honor God, did not give thanks, engaged in futile speculations, became fools, exchanged the incorruptible for the corruptible. God gives us over to our lusts: when we look at the world through our lusts we dishonor our bodies and worship the world. This verse seemed to provide a haunting literary echo to Genesis 3, where Eve’s desire to live independently of God’s authority made perfect sense to me. If I were Eve, I would have done the same thing. And at the same time Eve’s, and then Adam’s, seemingly innocent sin served as the leverage for the whole world to come tumbling down, fierce and fast, bloody and brilliant.

The two chapters, one in Genesis and one in Romans, stood out as bookends of my life. But not just my life. That is the rub. The Bible declares itself an owner’s manual of the human race. While I loathed this description, a little part of me was starting to see how Genesis 3 and Romans 1 stood out as the table of contents of what ails the world. Indeed, Romans 1 does not end by highlighting homosexuality as the worst and most extreme example of the sin of failing to give God the glory for creating us. Here is where this passage finds its crescendo:

29 being filled with all unrighteousness, wickedness, greed, evil; full of envy, murder, strife, deceit, malice; they are gossips,

30 slanderers, haters of God, insolent, arrogant, boastful, inventors of evil; disobedient to parents,

31 without understanding, untrustworthy, unloving, unmerciful;

32 and although they know the ordinance of God, that those who practice such things are worthy of death, they not only do the same, but also give hearty approval to those who practice them.

Homosexuality, then, is not the end-point of the problem, for God or for the world. But it is presented here as one step in the journey. Homosexuality seemed then consequential, not causal. Homosexuality, from God’s point of view, is an identity-rooted ethical outworking of Original Sin. Thousands of years before I was born, in the garden, when sin entered the world, Adam’s fall rendered my deep and primal feelings untrustworthy and untrue. According to the Bible itself, homosexuality—and the heterosexual sexual sin that I had committed—was not the root of all sin, not even the root of my sin. Romans had already cinched it for me: sexual sin is a fruit of something larger than its own desire.

I had taught, studied, read, and lived a very different notion of homosexuality.

For the first time in my life, I wondered if I was wrong. This stopped me in my tracks.

Somehow it was easier to hate the Bible when it squared off against me. When it seemed to arbitrarily single me out and oppress or marginalize me and people like me, it was easy to dismiss. But now that it was getting under my skin it became a foe of a different and more menacing kind.

I tried to toss the Bible and its teachings in the trash. I really tried. But Ken encouraged me to keep reading. I trusted him, and so did.

As I read and reread the Bible, I kept catching my wings in its daily embrace. I was fighting the idea that the Bible is inspired and inerrant—that is, that its meaning and purpose have a holy and supernatural authority that has protected it over the years of its canonicity, and that it is the repository of truth. How could a smart cookie like me embrace these things? I didn’t even believe in truth. I was a postmodernist. I believed in truth claims. I believed that the reader constructed the text—that a text’s meaning found its power only in the reader’s interpretation of it. As I told my students over and over again, without the reader, a book is just paper and glue. How could this one book lay claim to a birthright and progeny different from all others?

As I was reading and discussing these things with Ken, he pointed out to me that Jesus is the Word made flesh, and that “knowing Jesus” demands embracing the Jesus of the Bible, not the Jesus of someone’s imagination. The whole Bible. Even the places that took my life captive.

I straddled two worlds and two lives for two years. Some days, I felt like the worst of all hypocrites. And that’s because I was. Other days, I felt like a true liberal, truly loving and abiding with people who were so different from me. And this was true, too.

Was I double-minded? Was I counting the costs? Yes. To both.

The Bible got to be bigger inside me than I.

After years and years of this, something happened. The Bible got to be bigger inside me than I.

It overflowed into my world.

I fought against it with all my might.

Then, one Sunday morning, two years after I first met Ken and Floy and two years after I started reading the Bible for my research, I left the bed I shared with my partner and an hour later sat in a pew at the Syracuse Reformed Presbyterian Church. I say this not to be lurid, but to remind us that we never know the treacherous path that others take to arrive in the pew that we share Lord’s Day after Lord’s Day. Conspicuous in my appearance, I reminded myself that I came there to meet God, not fit in.

The first sermon that I heard Ken preach was intended for children. Whew, I thought. This is just my speed. Ken started to talk about the narrow gate and the wide gate and made a big deal about some silly prop that was in his pocket. I didn’t get that part. Actually, I didn’t get much of the sermon. My mind kept wandering to last year’s gay pride march, wide as it was with people just like me. That made me wonder: why does my mind keep traveling to the wide path?

I kept going back to church to hear more sermons. I had made friendships with people in the church by this time, and I appreciated the way that they talked about the sermons throughout the week, how the Word of God dwelt in them, how they referenced it in the details of their days. English professors by training love cross-texting, and I muddled over this in my mind: cross-texting the Bible with your life places you inside God’s story, God’s ontology. Is this safe? Is this deadly? I pondered these matters.

Ken was preaching through the gospel of Matthew, with its bewildering cast of characters and problems, unsuspecting folks “separated unto the gospel,” seeds choked by the world, feeding thousands with some poor and nameless kid’s bread and fish, then Jesus’ cutting question to impetuous Peter, “Do you still lack understanding?” (Matt. 15:16).

One Lord’s Day, Pastor Ken just stopped there, turned his steel blue eyes on the congregation, and held a long pause before he turned this question on us: “Congregation: Did Christ ever say this to you?” This startled me. This was my question. This question was for me: Do I still lack understanding? Who is speaking here, the man behind the pulpit or the God-man behind the foundation and redemption of his people?

There was something about the hermeneutic of preaching that disarmed me. Indeed, even after all of these years, it still does.

The image of me and everyone I loved suffering in hell crashed over me like shark-infested waves of a raging sea. Suffering in hell not because we were gay, but because we were proud. We wanted to be autonomous. It was our hearts first, and our bodies followed. I got it. I heard it. Finally.

I counted the costs and I did not like the math.

This was my crucible, and this is my crucible: if the Bible is true, I was dead. If the Bible is false, I am the biggest fool on earth.

But God’s promises rolled in like another round of waves into my world. One Lord’s Day, Ken was preaching on John 7:17: “If anyone wills to do [God’s] will, he shall know concerning the doctrine” (NKJV). This verse exposed the quicksand in which my feet were stuck. I was a thinker. I was paid to read books and write about them. I expected that, in all areas of my life, understanding came before obedience, not the other way around. I wanted God to show me, on my terms, why homosexuality was a sin. I wanted to be the judge, not the one being judged.

Perhaps, I thought, like Eve in the garden, I wanted to eat of the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil so that I could become and replace God. I wondered. Hadn’t I already done this? Hadn’t we all? If my consciousness fell in Adam’s sin, as the Bible purports, no wonder I couldn’t think my way out of this quandary. This wasn’t a game of thinking and the matching of wits. Could my heart echo God’s call for obedience? Could I “will to do God’s will,” just this once? The stakes were so very high. They always are.

But the verse promised understanding after obedience. I wrestled with the question: Did I really want to understand homosexuality from God’s point of view, or did I just want to argue with him?

I prayed that night that God would give me the willingness to obey before I understood. Starting with my own sexuality was too scary, too impossible. So I started with Jesus. I prayed that God would be pleased to reveal his Son in me. I prayed that I would be a vessel of Jesus. I prayed that God would make me a godly woman—and then I laughed out loud at the insanity of this prayer. I prayed that God would give me the faith to repent of my sin at its foundation. What is the root of my sin?

How does one repent of a sin that doesn’t feel like sin?

How does one repent of a sin that doesn’t feel like sin at all, but rather a normal not-bothering-another-soul kind of life? How had I come to this place? What is the root of the sin of sexual identity? Being a lesbian was not just a description of the kind of sex I liked to have. Being a lesbian encompassed a whole range of feelings and perception, character qualities, and sensibilities. It reflected the depth of my nonsexual friendships and the integrated community I wanted to build with women. Being a lesbian also reflected the kind of professor I was, the classes I taught, the books I read, and the dissertations I directed. I was all in. And, I was a jumble of emotions, because according to the Bible, what I called community, God called idolatry.

I did not know what to do, so I prayed the way I had heard Ken pray. He often would call upon the Lord to teach him this or that. So I prayed that the Lord would help me to see my life from his point of view. It was then that I noticed it: as I looked around my house, I had dozens of PRIDE posters, T-shirts, coffee mugs. The flag that waved in the breeze at my porch was a PRIDE flag. Pride had become my best friend. In the LGBT world, we defined pride as a healthy self-esteem. But something started to crack a little and I dared to just ask the question: was I domesticating a tiger? Without gay pride, where would I be? Where would any of us be? In the LGBT community, the opposite of pride is self-hatred. But in the Bible, the opposite of pride is faith. Was pride keeping me from faith, or was pride keeping me from self-hatred? That was when the question inserted itself like a foot in the door: Did pride distort self-esteem the way lust distorts love? This was the first of my many betrayals against the LGBT community: whose dictionary did I trust? The one used by the community that I helped create or the one that reflected the God who created me? As soon as the question formed itself into words, I felt convicted of the sin of pride. Pride was my downfall. I asked God for the mercy to repent of my pride at its root.

The next morning, when I looked in the mirror, I looked the same. But when I looked in the mirror of the Bible, I wondered: who am I? Am I an atheist? Am I a lesbian? Do I have to have a category? Has this life of my own invention merely been a case of mistaken identity? The strongest sense of self I had at the time was my lesbian identity, but even that was pieced together by a jumble of things. If Jesus could split the world asunder, divide the soul and the spirit, judge the thoughts and intentions of the heart, could he make my true identity prevail? Who am I? Who will God have me be?

I still felt like a lesbian in my body and heart. That was, I felt, my real identity. But what is my true identity? The Bible makes clear that the real and the true have a troubled relationship on this side of eternity. For many people in the Bible, their true identity and calling comes only after a long struggle, with God, with wilderness, and with dreams and hopes and plans. The Bible makes clear that my future and my calling always echo an attribute of God. Obedience constrains; it always mirrors suffering, as every selection implies a sacrifice. What is bigger? My lesbian identity and the feminist and postmodern worldview that fuels it, or God’s authority over me and holy sovereignty over the world?

Who is this Jesus?

Did I know him?

Did I still lack understanding?

Could I trust him?

Then, one ordinary day, I came to Jesus. No altar calls in a Reformed Presbyterian Church, so no fanfare or manipulation. We were singing from Psalm 119:56: “This is mine because forever all Thy precepts I preserve.” After I sang these words, I checked them in the Bible, just to be sure that the psalter didn’t have some tricky misprint in it. The Bible used a helping verb and noted the verse like this: “this has become mine.” Something about that helping verb made something shift in me. Two weight-bearing retaining walls collapsed in my mind. The first wall came crashing down because I had just sung condemnation unto myself. This Bible was not mine. I had scorned it and cursed it and despised it. But I had been reading and rereading this book, and the use of the helping verb (has in “has become”) troubled me. Two years of laborious reading embodied the helping verb “has”; it showed process, journey, pilgrimage, and danger. But, I was not “in Christ” and therefore could not possibly keep these precepts (God’s law), not in word, heart-change, or deed.

Here was the shattering of the second wall: I had read the Bible many times through, and I saw for myself that it had a holy Author; I saw for myself that it was a canonized collection of sixty-six books with a unified biblical revelation. I heard for myself that when the words “this is mine” came out of my mouth in congregational singing, I was attesting to this one, simple truth: that the line of communication that God ordained for his people required this wrestling with Scripture, and that I truly wanted both to hear God’s voice breathed in my life, and I wanted God to hear my pleas.

The fog burned away. The whole Bible, each jot and tittle, was my open highway to a holy God.

My hands let go of the wheel of self-invention. I came to Jesus alone, open-handed, and naked. I had no dignity upon which to stand. As an advocate for peace and social justice, I thought that I was on the side of kindness, integrity, and care. It was thus a crushing revelation to discover that it was Jesus I had been persecuting the whole time—not just some historical figure named Jesus, but my Jesus, my Prophet, my Priest, my King, my Savior, my Redeemer, my Friend. That Jesus.

In this war of worldviews, Ken and Floy were there. A friend in the church, R, who had become my best champion, was there for me. The church who had been praying for me for years was there. Jesus triumphed. And I was a broken mess. I lost everything but the dog.

Repentance is the posture of the Christian.

Of course, there is only one thing to do when you meet the living God. You must fall on your face and repent of your sins. Repentance is bittersweet business. Repentance is not just a conversion exercise. It is the posture of the Christian. Just like a dancer’s body finds its points and an equestrian incorporates her body weight into the movement of the horse, the Christian learns how to melt her will into God’s. Repentance is the threshold to God. When heat meets ice, the solid substance liquefies completely. Repentance liquefies the will of the flesh. Repentance is our daily fruit, our hourly washing, our minute-by-minute wakeup call, our reminder of God’s creation, Jesus’ blood, and the Holy Spirit’s comfort. Repentance is the only no-shame solution to a renewed Christian conscience because it proves the obvious: that God was right all along. To the sexual sinner, repentance feels like death—because it is. The “you” who once was is no longer, even if your old feelings remain.

Consciousness of sin resides not just in how you feel, but more potently in who Jesus is and what he has done. Your point of view and Christ’s atonement impact like a slow-motion car crash, as you see how he satisfied God’s justice for you. For me. You smell the blood and hear the agony in spurts and fits and all of a sudden you see what you could not see before: you cost Jesus everything—life, dignity, respect, peace. And he did not deserve this. Not even close. But he did more than accept this fate. He embraced it, out of love for me, and a mysterious glory that only this kind of God-love can manifest. When you step into the atonement, you are no longer a bystander. The blood is on your hands. What happens in repentance of sin is you see Jesus: “He is clothed with a robe dipped in blood, and His name is called The Word of God” (Rev. 19:13).

As I sit now at my desk and write, my kids are listening to The Magician’s Nephew on CD. Sometimes this life that I toy with on these pages seems a million miles away. Sometimes it feels like I am truly writing about someone else. But I still see the blood. Every time I repent of sins, I behold again the inseparable blood and love. Repentance is still the threshold. Loss of identity in this idol or that is still the consequence. But new creatures in Christ manifest at times a softening amnesia. And it is fear about that amnesia that calls me to tell you more about who Jesus is. I write now about matters that happened over a decade ago. God has taken me on a long journey. But like most pilgrimages, mine engenders more questions than answers.

Questions lag and nag, even after repentance, even after all of these years. Some days I want to pass as another fifty-something church lady. But these questions vex me:

What about homosexuality? Did I ever get some special insight from the Holy Spirit as to why it is a sin? Did I immediately upon conversion (or ever) feel that “unnaturalness” about homosexual sex that Romans 1 outlines? Or as a friend recently asked me, “Rosaria, when did the ‘yuck factor’ about homosexual sex hit you upside the head?” (Consider this a friendly warning: if you ask me questions like this, you will end up in a book.) Well, that is not what happened. The sinfulness of sin unfolded for me in the authority of the Bible, the growing sweetness with my union with Christ, and the slow sanctification of the mind that this births. At a certain point in life, I knew that I had to turn over the wheel to God. A little like an Alzheimer’s patient, who in a flashing moment of mental lucidity signs over his rights to his able-minded caregiver, a believer signs over her rights of interpretation to the God of the Bible. Lesbian sexuality did not feel unnatural. It occurred to me that I don’t have to feel it to believe it. And then this opened up the Scriptures in a whole new way. My feelings fell with the fall. There is no shame in this.

I also was starting to learn something else: my struggle with any sin could be done to the glory of God, as repentance gives God glory. When God revealed himself to me, he left me with a driving, somewhat oxymoronic desire to make biblical sense of my place in the world as a woman covered by God. Although I had railed against normative gender roles for as long as I can remember, in both my heterosexual and homosexual relationships, I suddenly wanted to know what it would be like to be covered not only by God, but also to live under the protection of a godly husband. My conversion left me with a new sense of what sexuality is: a point of view where I could so love and treasure other image bearers that I sacrificed my lust for their purity, and one where, someday, even perhaps a woman like me could become the godly wife to a godly husband.

This was a spiritual awakening that opened me up to Scripture and to the Lord himself in a startling new way. My feelings were not proof that I didn’t measure up. My journey into repentance was proof that I was one of God’s own, one of the lost sheep, and he was leading me and guiding me and protecting me and comforting me.

I learned in this crucible to carefully distinguish common grace (which explains why my unbelieving friends are sometimes nicer, kinder, and more compassionate than my believing ones) from the fruit that grows from a redeemed life. Common grace is powerful, and I’m thankful for it, but it in itself is not a sign of Christian fruit. Christian fruit is known by its root (Christ), not by the contribution it makes to a better world. There is common grace that comes from common virtues, but only Christ can bear in someone fruit of saving grace. “All my springs of joy are in you,” declares the last line of Psalm 87. God does not patch us up, putting bandages on those ruptured virtues we possess either from personality or from intelligence. No. God gives us a new passageway to his spring, out of which his living waters flow into us, and through which we have union with Christ.

Psalm 66:18 puts it this way: “If I had cherished iniquity in my heart, the Lord would not have listened” (ESV). We all have iniquity in our hearts, and we desperately need the Lord to listen. But when we cherish something that he does not, he will not listen. In the eighth chapter of the Bible, God says this: “The intent of man’s heart is evil from his youth” (Gen. 8:21). Psalm 66 tells us not to cherish this evil intent of the heart. But who can ditch her own heart?

Apart from Christ, we can’t stand against our own hearts.

Apart from Christ, we cannot stand against our own hearts. The verses above presume that we will struggle with sin, but they warn us not to declare any sin a “sanctifiable” character quality, even if through it we may learn valuable lessons about life. Learning lessons is not God’s first priority for his children. Transformed character is. I learned here that God may, in his providence, bring good from my past, but the good that comes is not because of the sin, but in spite of it. It is very tempting to see “good” in those things that tempt us to sin or lead us to sin because then we don’t seem nearly as corrupt as Original Sin renders us. According to God, sinful temptations are inclinations to do something or become something that cost Jesus his life for my sake. We are not to try to ransom it on our own terms. Suggesting that our sin is good or produces good is tantamount to calling cancer good health.

The verse in Genesis 8 shows that our hearts are not only sinful in the affections that we embrace, but even in the intent of those desires. As Hebrews 4:12 tells us, Scripture truly pierces the heart:

For the word of God is living and active and sharper than any two-edged sword, and piercing as far as the division of soul and spirit, of both joints and marrow, and able to judge the thoughts and intentions of the heart.

It is a dangerous move to square off against Scripture, the piercing Word that discerns and purifies. But how do I know if I am cherishing sin?

When we defend our right to a particular sin, when we claim it as an “I am,” or a defining character trait, we are cherishing it, and separating ourselves from the God who promises rest for our soul through repentance and forgiveness. Jesus met sinners at the table. He sat at the table with them. But he did not join them in their choice sins. He sat with them, but he did not sin with them. We ought not expect Jesus to sin with us today. Isaiah 59:1–2 declares this: “Behold, the LORD’S hand is not so short that it cannot save; nor is His ear so dull that it cannot hear. But your iniquities have made a separation between you and your God.” When we cherish sin, we build a wall between our Maker and us. When we cherish sin we are asking God to overlook sin on the world’s terms and not because of the blood of Christ.

When I lived as a lesbian, I truly believed that I was a better person for my lesbianism, my marginalized social status, my extended lesbian community and its commitment to social justice, and the egalitarianism of my lesbian relationships. I truly believed this. But after conversion, God showed me that if I was his, I could not ask him on my terms to rename something that he calls sin, because redemption cost him his blood. Every drop. If we believe that God uses sin as a creative way to bring wisdom and insight into the world, we are telling Jesus that his pain matters nothing to us. When we are owned by God, we are ruined for the world. And this marring of us for the world is one of the birthmarks of conversion.

Our feelings can—and often do—deceive us. When we believe that our sin is not really sin, we call God a liar, and we use our personal feelings as proof. All our personal feelings prove is that Original Sin and the deceptiveness of sin are inseparable.

But that still leaves the question unanswered: what is the sin of homosexuality? The sexual practice alone? The desire? What is temptation? Where do we draw the line between the temptation to sin and the sin itself?

Homosociality is an abiding and deep comfort afforded in keeping company with your own gender, and finding within your own gender your most important and cherished friendships. This is not a sin. Neither is this “gay.” But once that comfort level shifts to sexually desiring a person with whom you are not biblically married, you are in sin. Since we have a sin nature, the question is not what to do if you sin (because you will). The question is what to do when you sin. How can we learn to enlist the Lord’s power in defeating temptation before it defeats us?

But even if you see in yourself a temptation pattern, this does not mean that you are a dangerous person, unable to ever get close to people. This means for you what it means for me: that we are all good company when Jesus mediates our relationships. So yes, depending on what you do with them, feelings may be sinful. Jesus addresses this when he says: “Out of the heart come evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts, false witness, slanders. These are the things which defile the man” (Matt. 15:19–20). I came away from this pivotal moment with this: homosexual lust is a sin, but so is heterosexual lust and homophobia. It is sinful to write people off because they sin in ways that offend you. God holds up the same mirror for us all, and none of us reflects the image of God in righteousness, holiness, and knowledge apart from Christ.

            Homophobia—the fear and hatred of people who identify as LGBT, and the wholesale writing off of their souls.

Sin must be fought at its deepest level. The root of my lesbianism was pride. The root of my heterosexual sin was pride as well. For others, the root of sexual sin may be lust or sexual addiction. Some sins are harder to battle than others. But God gives believers the gift of repentance. Repentance is a gift from God. And repentance is the daily posture of the Christian, not some one-time Sinner’s Prayer shibboleth. We must never repent of sin in surface ways, like weeding our gardens by snipping the tops off of the dandelions. When we do this, we deceive ourselves and we risk hardening our heart to God’s kind call. For it is the “kindness of God” that leads us to repentance (Rom. 2:4).

For my readers who lose the struggle with temptation and fall into sexual sin, please know that I (and other Christians) understand the shame and the temptation to hide your sin. Please, to the Christians who are reading this and do not struggle with homosexual desires, do not add weight to the burden by thinking that homosexuality is the biggest of all sins, or that its solution is heterosexuality. The solution to all sin is Christ’s atoning blood. In Christ, we are new creatures. We are redeemed men and women who “have been buried with [Christ] through baptism into death” (Rom. 6:4) and are no longer slaves to the sin that once defined us, although likely it still knows our names. We are all called to holiness. And holiness violates my self-love and my confidence in my natural virtues. The Bible calls my natural virtues filthy garments: “For all of us have become like one who is unclean, and all our righteous deeds are like a filthy garment; and all of us wither like a leaf and our iniquities, like the wind, take us away” (Isa. 64:6). God repeats “all of us” three times. Not just some of us. All of us are in this snare if we trust in our natural virtues.

            Atonement—the reconciliation of God and humankind through Jesus Christ.

At the writing of this chapter, I am a fifty-two-year-old pastor’s wife who homeschools two of her four children, serves the church where my husband, Kent, is the pastor, and tries to live as an “out” Christian. Kent and I got married on May 19, 2001, the day after he graduated from seminary. God has blessed us, and our marriage, faith, and family are places where we take true rest. But no matter how many years tick away, I am and will always be Rahab—a woman with a past. So, what does a person like me do with such a past? I have not forgotten. Body memories know my name. Details intrude into my world unpredictably, like when I am kneading the communion bread or homeschooling my children. I take each ancient token to the cross, for prayer, for more repentance, for thanksgiving that God is always right about matters of sin and grace. I think about what it means to inhabit the story of the Bible, and how repentance is a daily fruit of my new life in Christ. Paul’s question in Romans 6:21 is one that I ask myself: “What fruit did you have then in the things of which you are now ashamed?” (NKJV).

The layers of my life in Christ always unfold in a double-directional way. I live and think in a forward way, preparing for eternity. But I continue to repent of sins I committed years ago, as the Lord brings them to mind from out of the miry depth of my history. I have come to understand that this soul business keeps me close to the Lord who is the keeper of my soul, my history, and my future.

I am told that stories like mine are dangerous. Conversions like mine have the potential to create “the danger of the single story,” or the belief that converted people are changed. Both are true. Conversion stories are dangerous and converted people are changed by God. Converted people change and depart from their sins. We are all changed by justifying faith and the sanctification that God provides. We all repent and believe as a response to the Holy Spirit’s gift of a new heart. We all stand with the blood of our Savior on our hands. That is the Bible’s story. All who have met the risen Lord are changed. And we are all called to forsake the sin that we loved best before we met the Lord.

The Bible is inerrant, but my testimony is not. The testimony of who I was when God broke into my world is not diagnostic or proscriptic. But I leave it with you for your consideration and the reminder that Christ redeems your struggle by giving you greater union with him as you walk through it. Christ also gives you a new identity, the identity of one who overcomes.2

↑ Back to top

↑