Chapter 7: “Tony” and Bipolar Disorder
Chapter 7
“Tony” and Bipolar Disorder
Garrett Higbee
A Vision for Biblical Soul Care
Sixteen years ago I made the difficult decision to leave my practice as a clinical psychologist, working in hospitals, residential organizations, and private practice in pursuit of a higher calling. After 15 years of counseling in a manner consistent with my clinical training, God showed me that true hope and help for man’s most profound problems are found in Christ and his Word alone. Local churches must bear the responsibility of communicating that hope to hurting individuals by biblically caring for souls. Alongside my ministry at College Park Church in Indianapolis, this vision took shape in Twelve Stones Ministries (TS), an intensive biblical counseling retreat center.
Twelve Stones Ministries
The vision for TS was to transform the culture of the local church by inspiring and equipping both leaders and laity to regain confidence in the Word of God and his Spirit as his people learned to counsel competently. A primary strategy for accomplishing this vision would involve a retreat with counselees and those who walk alongside them (“advocates”). This retreat would facilitate a return to their church community with a growing love for the Lord and a desire to see others grow in Christ. In a sense our strategy was to send a benevolent virus back into local churches as we came alongside those in the greatest need of biblical soul care so that they might become the most infectious ministers of that same care to their church communities.
At times even the strongest families or individuals are caught in the midst of a situation so intense, a conflict so hurtful, or an emotional turmoil so overwhelming, that they need to turn somewhere for help. At the TS campus we sought to provide hope through biblically based and carefully tailored individual, couple, and family counseling. Our goal was to give real answers, lasting wisdom, and spiritual encouragement to those for whom life seemed hopeless and defeating. We believed in the power of the gospel—that is, the announcement of the way of salvation through Jesus Christ by grace through faith—to heal relationships by reconciling them to God and to one another. By working alongside local churches, their friends, and extended family, we aimed at a more personal support system, loving accountability, and follow-up. Since one-size-fits-all counseling does not change the heart, our approach included careful assessment and development of a biblical plan of action for couples, parents, youth, and—when appropriate—individuals who would be advocates, helping them transition back home after their stay at TS. There is a time to warn, a time to encourage, and a time to help; but in all cases patient care and love promote the goal of restoration that God planned for people struggling to find him in the trials of life.
The ministry invites people in extreme cases or crisis situations to a retreat (usually a weekend) of intensive counseling—without the distractions that battle for their daily attention. They are surrounded by the beauty and serenity of God’s creation and the loving support of our staff. When I say intensive, I mean it. We pack about four to six months of counseling into two to three days. The people who accept our invitation often come with difficult issues to overcome: schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, suicide to name a few. At TS we do not think God and his Word need to take the backseat to a clinician when things get difficult. The hard cases are perhaps the greatest opportunities to see the power of God and his Word at work in changing lives.
The ministry’s name is a reference to a story in the Old Testament book of Joshua. In obedience to God, Joshua has the leaders of the 12 tribes of Israel erect a monument made up of “12 stones” from the Jordan River. This monument was to be a symbol for the people to look on in time of doubt and confusion in order to remember God’s awesome power, love, and faithfulness to them and future generations (Josh 4:1–9).
God’s awesome power brought a man named Tony into my life at TS. My prayer is that his story of change would also erect a monument to God’s awesome power, love, and faithfulness in the heart of each reader.
Tony’s Story
Tony was in his late thirties and married to Lisa. The couple had no children. He had been working hard at two part-time ministries—although both were actually full-time enterprises. The first ministry was as an associate pastor. The second was as the leader of a homeless ministry in a large city. On top of that, he also served in the apartment complex where they lived, caring specifically for elderly people in the building. Lisa also worked a full-time job and served alongside her husband when she could. They seemed like a couple gifted with a high capacity for work. To the observing world, Tony and Lisa had it all together; and they were beacons in their community. Things looked exactly the way Tony wanted. Secretly, however, their lives were falling apart.
Although their efforts for ministry seemed unparalleled, they had not grown in maturity or the understanding of the grace needed for highly effective ministry. Tony and Lisa claimed to be followers of Jesus Christ; however, Tony’s life in particular showed signs that he had gone off course and was following worldly things. He was often anxious and experienced periods of depression. There were clear signs he was physically neglecting his body, and he showed habits of poor time management. Indeed, Tony’s life story revealed a long-standing pattern of self-sufficiency, feeling unappreciated, anger, and shame. Tony felt rejected by his father and was envious of his brother as the favored child. He had conflict with the senior pastor of his church, where he felt used and underrecognized. He was afraid of the dark, death, demons, and missing his purpose in life.
Lisa agreed that Tony was a mess. The two had drifted from a Christ-centered identity and sense of purpose. Though their commitment to Tony’s ministries was astounding, their commitment to personal communion with God was shockingly absent—as shown by a slow decline in personal and family prayer, meditation on the Scripture, and pursuit of renewing their minds with God’s Word and applying it specifically and practically to daily life. Instead, Tony and Lisa doubled, even tripled, their investments in performance-based faith. Tony especially had a desperate need to be self-sufficient, to prove himself to others, and to protect himself. His identity was caught up in many worldly definitions of success and importance; he had an insatiable desire for significance, security, and affirmation, especially by male authorities. The one bright spot was that Tony and Lisa’s marriage was relatively stable. The house of cards that they had been building together, however, was beginning to totter. One night it finally collapsed.
Tony had continued living his high-stress life as usual, and he had not slept well for many days. One night he was overcome with extreme paranoia, fear, and delusions. He began yelling and screaming throughout the house and crying uncontrollably. Lisa was horrified. She had no idea what to do. She tried to calm him down, but the screaming and crying continued. Finally, scared out of her mind, and with no other idea about what to do, she called 911. Lisa pleaded, “He won’t stop screaming! What do I do? I need help. . . . I need help; he keeps yelling and crying. Please, please; I need someone to help us.” By the time the night was over, their home was full of police squads and medical personnel, and Tony had been fitted with medical and physical restraints and was gone.
He spent 10 days in a psychiatric hospital where he was given the label “bipolar,” placed on medication, and received education and counseling concerning this “debilitating disease.” In response to all this new stress, he quit his ministry positions and began planning to move across the country. Tony and Lisa felt that they had been cared for by the hospital’s supportive staff, but they could not help feeling empty as they returned home with the hope-destroying psychiatric label of bipolar disorder.
Both tried to make sense of everything. Tony felt he had pushed himself to some kind of emotional limit: “I worked myself into the ground, and now I am bipolar.” He grieved over all the hours he had invested in serving God by helping people. For what? Look where that got him. Lisa was a bit more grounded. She seemed deeply concerned for her husband and made herself available to help. Their marriage appeared to be solid, but Lisa was worried. She wanted to know how to minister to her husband, but she was also afraid he might “lose it” again: “What has happened to the man I married? Will he ever get better? What will keep him from doing this again? I can’t go through a night like that one again.” She did not have much confidence that the hospitalization or medication provided any kind of lasting hope or cure for what led Tony to such an uncharacteristic episode of terror. She also struggled with thoughts of how this would affect her dreams for starting a family. Questions constantly flooded her mind: “Is it right to bring children into this type of environment? Could I ever count on Tony being a good father? Would I be able to mother a baby and a husband? Why would you take this away from me, Lord? Haven’t I been serving you diligently?” Although she did not know how to articulate it, Lisa wanted a formula, a guaranteed approach to change. While they both appreciated the help they had received, it had not resulted in a clear plan or help in understanding how to prevent a future crisis.
At this point God directed Tony to TS through the recommendation of their pastor, who would ultimately support them as their advocate. At first they were skeptical about TS since they had received unhelpful counsel in the past from kind Christians who unskillfully attempted to provide biblical counsel. They gave general proof texts to help them feel better or solve the immediate anxiety. Unfortunately, they only addressed behavior, situational stress, and reactivity, instead of first addressing issues at a level of depth. Yet their pastor was hopeful that we could get to the heart of it from a biblical perspective, so they agreed to pursue TS for help. They believed that we could give them direction in understanding his “disorder.” Although Lisa was fearful that this could be a life-dominating issue for Tony, she had genuine hope that this might be a wake-up call for both of them and that a new start could be beneficial in many ways. Tony and his wife were desperately in need of the hope of Christ and needed to be pointed back to Scripture to begin a journey toward genuine change. To better understand how we did this, we will walk through a step-by-step account of the counseling process.
The Counseling Process
Our ministry to individuals, couples, and families at TS begins with an initial contact either by phone or through an application submitted via our website. Before meeting Tony and Lisa in person, we gathered significant information through a Personal Data Inventory (PDI)—an element of the application—and a series of extensive phone interviews with the couple and their advocate.
In Tony and Lisa’s case, we were eager to understand their hopes and fears as they entered counseling. We first sought to rule out medical or organic issues that may have contributed to their struggles. We asked for medical records to determine when Tony had a thorough medical checkup. It is important to determine if any medical issues such as a thyroid disorder or other physical problems could contribute to existing struggles. We often consult with a qualified Christian physician on the counselee’s condition to better understand the impact of physical issues, medications, and factors such as sleep and diet. In Tony’s case there were in fact both physical and circumstantial issues that contributed to his emotional breakdown. Someone manifesting bipolar symptoms or who comes in with the label has likely displayed both depressive and manic tendencies. There may be some complicating factors both physically and/or circumstantially that should be considered. For instance, sleeping habits, exercise, and diet can be a factor in mood swings. Multiple stressors or physical illness can also influence mood. A thorough investigation of all these potential factors is needed before counseling someone with this diagnosis. A medical evaluation and tests, however, showed that none of Tony’s issues were conclusively caused by any medical condition. But lack of sleep and poor self-care were evident, and he was experiencing multiple stressors that were cumulatively weakening his resistance to the temptations in his life.
Subsequently, while there may not be an exact test to measure any physical issues complicating the mood swings with bipolar symptoms, there could still be organic factors that should be addressed with those coming in with significant clinical labels. Prescription and nonprescription drugs can be a primary factor in extreme moods. The issue of medication was indeed a concern for Tony. Should he be medicated for moods? What would happen if he took himself off these medicines? How long should he be on psychotropic medications? What do they do? Again, we work closely with physicians and in his case reviewed his hospital records to address these issues. It was not our place to undermine the medical regimen he was placed on or to overstep our role as pastoral counselors. Clearly, we could not act as physicians. We desired to be sensitive to the holistic nature of his symptoms and to develop a biblical action plan geared toward healing his entire person. We counseled them to wait until the end of our time to address these questions.
After ruling out any physical origin of his mood swings and determining the impact of other physical and/or situational factors influencing Tony’s mental and emotional state, we began to listen for themes in his story that would point to heart issues. A careful assessment allowed us to connect with one another in a loving relationship, get accurate data, and begin to develop a clear direction for counseling. We cannot begin to reframe symptoms, behavior, heart issues, motives, and formative influences into biblical categories if we do not know what they are. It was clear after the initial interviews that Tony and Lisa were concerned we might be reductionists who would overly spiritualize his disorder and not address what they believed to be the physical side of this problem. They also feared condemnation for lack of faith or dependence on God for healing. As previously mentioned, Tony was only willing to come because his advocate, who heard about our work, was confident we could help. Our initial goals included providing comfort, structure, love, support, equipping the advocate, and identifying others who could be leaned on in the counselees’ existing support system and community.
One month after the night of terror, Tony and his wife arrived at TS with their pastor/advocate, whom they trusted deeply. Their advocate had to be someone in their circle of influence who loves the Lord, trusts his Word, and loves them. Advocates are an important part of the intensive counseling ministry. They are asked to walk alongside the hurting counselee(s) both during and after the counseling session(s). Throughout the counseling process we left time for interaction and discussion with the advocate and even gave him permission to respectfully question and critique the homework if something did not resonate. This provided an additional opportunity to gain involvement and gather data on their worldview. The retreat setting in the company of an advocate creates a context that is particularly effective when someone is in a crisis or has experienced trauma where extended care, encouragement, and accountability are needed. The cumulative impact of multiple consecutive hours of counseling and care can help break through issues with those who have experienced bad counseling sessions or are resistant to change for various reasons. There are few times when a counselee is going to grow and change more than in a crisis. Issues of worship, idolatry, and identity are out in the open. This is a time to seek God and see what there is to learn in each trial. Tony and his wife were tired and apprehensive when they arrived at TS. Little did they know that they would later look back on the weekend as the turning point in their lives with each other and with God.
Friday Evening
Whenever possible we spend two to four hours gathering history in the initial meeting. The time required for a couple will often be closer to four hours; an individual usually needs two hours or less. The first challenge was to listen well and understand their worldviews individually and as a couple. It is important to create a context that says to the counselees, “We are not going to rush this. We care about you, and we want to understand your experience before applying God’s Word.” It is also crucial to provide structure and a safe atmosphere.
The first night at TS we assigned Tony, his wife, and the advocate the “Motives” pamphlet by Ed Welch. This is a particularly good assignment for anyone who needs to reframe psychological diagnoses as heart issues. A large part of good counseling is helping counselees see that at the root of all psychological problems are theological errors. No one can have a proper view of self without a proper view of God. We also had them read chapter 4 in Instruments in the Redeemer’s Hands by Paul Tripp. They were to read both assignments and highlight meaningful sections. They were to have five key statements or revelations from each reading, discuss them together, and pray before going to bed. Last, they were given an assignment to review some Puritan prayers. Before ending for the night, we had an extended time of prayer together.
Saturday
In preparation for each day of counseling, we (the TS staff) pray with every individual, couple, or family each morning. We pray for their situation and share our prayer requests as well. Our day would consist of two three-hour segments: (1) listening to Tony’s life story in the morning, and (2) graphically illustrating his story on a whiteboard in the afternoon.
Segment 1: Tell Me Your Life Story
First, we had the advantage of several hours Saturday morning for data gathering through a guided life story from birth to the present day of counseling. Although this time was not focused on their marriage, Lisa also shared her life story, which greatly helped show how they interacted in their marriage. Why a whole life story to address an event that only happened in the last month? It is important for a variety of reasons. Proverbs 20:5 says, “Counsel in a man’s heart is deep water; but a man of understanding draws it out.” Slowly drawing out the heart will help you develop a sensitive and accurate biblical approach to the entirety of your counsel. Most likely it will save you time in the long run. We often waste energy on rabbit trails, focusing on problems that are not at the core of transformation and heart change.
Everyone has a past, a series of events and persons that have influenced him or provided a catalyst for him to make successive decisions in forming the way you now meet him. One’s past—though influential—is not determinative (that is, it cannot determine who a person will be forever, without the ability for change). The past is also a crucial element of knowing a person. Attention to one’s childhood, family dynamics, and long-term history can reveal significant insight into who a person has become. With Tony and Lisa, it was beneficial to listen carefully to their history, probing with questions intended to expose their hearts as opportunities arose. This allowed us to obtain valuable, heart-revealing information. By reflecting on the formative influences of the past and reframing the language Tony used, we could speak the truth in love much more clearly and sensitively into his life. Looking at the past is useful and important—not to place blame or excuse behavior but to learn themes of an individual’s heart as he emerges through multiple stories. After questioning, Tony and Lisa gained a sense that we now knew them better and cared more deeply for them. Building this relational foundation provides the distinct advantage of planting a pivot foot in their story while keeping our other foot planted in a solid understanding of Scripture. This was helpful in moving from symptoms to core heart issues.
Having an advocate in the room was invaluable, both as an intercessor and for accuracy of perspective. He also took careful notes, capturing key truths to be shared in later application. Tony and Lisa depended on him many times for reassurance and to clarify points. He was able to walk through their life story, add context, laugh, cry, and pray at key times. It was helpful to get Lisa to participate and share as well before moving to a time of diagnosing the problem biblically.
As expected, Tony shared symptoms that included periods of depression and at least one manic episode. We wanted Tony and Lisa to see that while these symptoms of bipolar were real, the underlying cause might be different from what they were taught or believed. Notwithstanding some physical habits that needed attention, we wanted Tony to see that many of his symptoms were, in fact, the result of root issues of the heart. Scripture is rich with descriptive and prescriptive language for those coming in with psychiatric diagnoses. For instance, someone suffering with what the world calls bipolar would find that the Bible has profound wisdom for him. The heart issues would be seen and described throughout the stories and proverbs as a combination of despair and uncharacteristic periods of foolishness. In our afternoon segment together we sought to take a fresh look at Tony’s story. Tony had openly offered his version of his life story; now it was time to let God’s Word offer its version of the same characters and events as we walked through the details with Tony, Lisa, and their advocate, while looking to the Scripture for perspective.
Segment 2: Listen to Your Life Story
As stated earlier, Tony’s life story revealed extensive patterns of self-sufficiency, bitterness over being unappreciated, anger, shame, feelings of rejection and envy towards his family, personal conflicts in his church, and other strange fears and behaviors. While we really wanted to help Tony with the practical problems resulting from his symptoms such as loss of income, management of his medications, or improving communication in his marriage, we were leery of jumping to conclusions or getting roped into unbiblical “behaviorism” that falls short of transformational change. Fear, especially the fear of man, was the most obvious heart issue throughout Tony’s story. Fear drove his impulsivity, which led to consequences, which led to feelings of guilt and sadness. Another issue was Tony’s performance-based faith, which could possibly be motivating him to perform for us. The more prominent motives or idolatrous lusts that became apparent as we walked through Tony’s story graphically on the whiteboard were his insatiable desire for significance, security, and affirmation—by male authorities. These themes would be essential in helping him see he had a worship disorder, not simply or necessarily a medical condition. I began to see that what Tony believed about God and the world around him had influenced his symptomatic actions, feelings, and perspectives. This biblical understanding needed to be presented so that Tony, Lisa, and their advocate could also see clearly how God’s Word diagnosed their problems more accurately than their psychological professionals had done.
The idea was to reframe their problems biblically, using their language and exposing heart themes to show them how God viewed their story. Tony had the wrong idea of why he did what he did. As biblical counselors, we have an opportunity to reframe the experiences of counselees like Tony. By giving a new interpretation to their present problems and by laying a biblical template over the psychiatric diagnostic labels, we can transform these categories of psychological syndromes into language Scripture uses.
While sin is clearly involved and at the core of any problem, legitimate suffering needs a compassionate ear. In Tony’s case, as with most counselees, it was necessary to engage each of these themes. A focus on sin would encourage repenting of sinful fear, despair, or foolishness, spending more time in the Word, and stopping sinful worry. A much more balanced approach that combines truth and grace would bring conviction of sin, but it would also focus on the power of the gospel and living in relationship with Christ. A biblical example would be the story of Christ talking with the woman at the well (John 4). In this case, Christ knew of her life and did not have to draw it out, but his words show deep conviction without condemnation. There was a call for the woman at the well to see herself honestly and to worship God for who he is. Our goal in counseling is threefold: (1) to get the counselee to see God’s character and compassion through the lens of Scripture; (2) to get the counselee to see himself and his problems as God does; (3) to get the counselee to feel God’s conviction and comfort as he peers intensely into the mirror of his Word.
Thus, the counselee needs to begin thinking theologically: how is God involved in all of this? Tony first had to correct some of his thinking about God, himself, and others, even as he renewed his mind based on the gospel and the redemptive story of the Scriptures—how God was sovereignly working from before the world began to deliver his people from sin and death unto eternal life with him to the praise of his glorious grace (Eph 1:3–14). He needed to see what God has declared for him in regard to his identity, and he needed God’s grace to enable him before trying to work in God’s strength to please him. The Bible is not an encyclopedia, and Tony’s relationship with Christ cannot be reduced to a one-dimensional strategy to alleviate fear. Our goal was not to proof text every verse that directly deals with fear but to help Tony see that he could trust God, since he essentially showed by his words and actions that God’s love was conditional, that God did not care for him, or that God would not come through in the end. By going vertical, Tony could see how far he had drifted (Heb 2:1).
Saturday Evening
That evening we asked Tony and Lisa to assess their predominant heart attitude. We used the “4 Hearts” worksheet (pp. 184–85) to help them reach their own conclusions from Scripture, see where their hearts were, and how their worldview shaped their perceptions and responses. In general, we helped them see what lenses they viewed life through, how their pasts could skew truth, and how their feelings could influence their perspectives.
Sunday
In our first full day we focused on careful assessment and “going vertical with God.” By focusing more on the relationship with Christ than temporal relationships, we helped Tony and Lisa align their priorities with what they say they value most.
Tony was visibly tired yet more relaxed in our second day of counseling. Lisa seemed at ease, and the advocate was smiling more. We (the TS staff) again prayed for them and shared our prayer requests as well. A unique approach at TS and many churches that practice biblical counseling is the nonclinical, nonprofessional environment of counseling. Indeed, pastoral care and biblical counseling can be a refreshing change from a more sterile or professional counseling atmosphere. For example, eating and fellowshipping with the counselees gives us the opportunity to gain more access into their lives and see them in a different light. We find by taking the attitude that the ground is level at the cross and the Holy Spirit is present in the counseling room, we are able to be ourselves, to share our family news and struggles, to use humor, and even to give a comforting arm around the shoulder to let them know we do not fear them or their “disorder.”
We reviewed Tony and Lisa’s homework to see if they could understand God’s perspective on their issues and to give them some new language to reframe their experience. First Corinthians 2:13 contrasts human wisdom and things taught by the Spirit. Because we believed that both Tony and Lisa had evidence of fruit in their lives, we sought the mind of Christ together. Tony was struggling to see his motives behind the exhausting pace he had kept in ministry. Though resistant, he began talking to his wife and advocate about his performance-based faith. We reviewed his life story by pulling out themes and statements that seemed to reveal the orientation of his heart. We were able to see a number of places where he was shaped and influenced by the world and its wisdom. With help, Tony and Lisa were able to identify several key themes of his heart over the course of the day.
For example, Tony looked like a model servant, but he had been neglecting his personal relationship with Christ and had replaced service with true devotion to Christ. For years Tony had resented his father’s failures, and now that resentment had morphed into hardened bitterness. Tony was terrified of failing at his ministry and was deeply frustrated with the pastor who was his boss. He was also unusually fearful of looking incompetent in front of others. Tony was focused on his own reputation, not on Christ’s. Tony’s heart was full of the fear of man instead of reverential respect for Christ.
Part of the process of orienting Tony back toward Christ was to help him see himself, God, and others from the lens of Scripture. We worked with a few key passages in Proverbs and sections of James 3–4 to anchor his thinking biblically. This is where we started to use different words to describe the same phenomena. For instance, we helped Tony replace “impulsivity or manic episodes” with “foolish thoughts and behavior” and “needs” with “desires or demands,” depending on the intensity of his longing.
All of this understanding led to a tough second day. Tony was beginning to come to grips with the sin behind his symptoms. He was feeling ashamed for what was in his heart, and he did not want to take responsibility. Tony was defensive and seemed distant at times. Lisa was losing hope. The advocate was with us, but he wondered what it would take to get Tony engaged. Tony was wrestling with his perceived need for affirmation. He was recognizing an authority issue and slowly tracing things back to his relationship with God.
It is easy to get stuck in counseling. In team counseling we often remind one another that we cannot work any harder than the counselees, or we will become frustrated and hopeless. We need to place them at the foot of the cross in prayer and in action during the session, not just before and after. Sometimes we just need to give them some hope from Scripture, something tangible to think about and work on before calling it a day. In Tony’s case it meant taking a break, going on a walk, and taking some time to pray. This type of work is draining, and we may need to go away to pray ourselves or get counsel from a trusted mentor to gain perspective before going back in. It is hypocritical to tell a counselee to trust God while you lean on your own skills, effort, and rehearsed Bible knowledge. Sometimes more Bible knowledge only beads up on a hard heart, and prayer is often the only way to furrow the soil so the Word can take root.
After some prayer time, Tony admitted he was feeling judged. We turned to the Scriptures and reviewed 2 Cor 7:10 to compare godly and worldly sorrow. This was a great opportunity to talk openly about the difference between conviction and condemnation. One of the most powerful things we can offer to a counselee in crisis is the hope that comes from knowing God’s forgiveness and love. We also looked at Prov 28:13, which clearly says prosperity does not come from concealing transgressions but mercy comes to those who confess and forsake them. What Tony was doing was an exercise in pursuing mercy from God himself. Tony had confessed sin, but he needed to renounce it. We also looked at 1 John 1:9 to give Tony hope as he was reminded of God’s faithfulness to forgive. Eventually Tony realized his difficulties stemmed from his guilt and not our judgment. He recognized that it was God’s intent to bring conviction, not condemnation. After this he was able to repent and sensed tremendous relief in God’s long-suffering, kindness, and love.
Tony was broken. We reminded Tony that “no temptation has overtaken you except what is common to humanity” (1 Cor 10:13), and we shared some of our own personal struggles. We wanted to make clear to Tony that he was not odd or of lesser spiritual stock than any of the rest of us. We wanted to be sure we did not get stuck in counseling because of our own arrogance and pride. God was gracious, and our openness was effective. Tony began to be open and trusting again. Through the kindness of God, Tony was disarmed by this time of prayer, the teaching from Scripture, and by our personal stories.
At this point in our time together, we began to investigate a biblical theology of suffering. The hardships Tony faced created natural and obvious questions concerning how a good God can use such difficulty in the lives of one of his own children. A great assignment for further detail on this point is Paul Tripp’s Suffering: Eternity Makes a Difference. We wanted to talk about this matter with Tony in our time together.
A discussion about suffering and trials versus suffering and consequences ensued. Tony realized that he did not see God clearly in his suffering and that his behavior and choices had led him down a path away from God. Lisa had been hesitant up to this point, but she then shared her perspective of a slow decline of their spiritual life and time of prayer together. Tony was familiar with the concept of being transformed by the renewing of your mind (Rom 12:1–2), but he had not been living it out and became susceptible to the world’s trappings. He did not see his identity in Christ as his primary identity, nor did he fully embrace the redemptive power described in Gal 2:20. Though difficult, this was a breakthrough conversation about where they had wandered from the truth, how his life was no longer his own, and the need to refocus by spending time at the cross.
As God had forgiven him, Tony now had to forgive the “villains” he blamed for creating so much of his difficulty. This true need to grant forgiveness led to a great discussion on the fear of man, his father, and personal idols. Tony began to see beyond his father’s sin to his own in their relationship. This was a critical turning point in our time together. There was an obvious countenance change in Tony. He had never seen so clearly the fear or the bitterness that kept him from maturing or communing with Christ. Of course, he hoped his father would receive him well, and he would confess his sin. Regardless of his father’s response, Tony was committed to keep peace (Rom 12:18). His advocate volunteered to facilitate a meeting between Tony and his father.
Tony and Lisa came alive as we talked about being in Christ. We assigned more meditation than memorization, with the goal being to see them apply what they already knew. We also helped Tony see the need to respond to God as his holy Father. In Ps 27:10 the Lord declares that even if our own father and mother forsake us, God will not deny us. In Prov 23:26, the father appeals to the son to “give me your heart.” Tony needed to forgive his earthly father and put his hope in the Father who will not leave or forsake him.
Sunday Evening
Tony, Lisa, and his mentor had a good evening of reading and prayer. They had turned the corner and were seeing their problems in the light of Scripture. They read chapter 4 in Seeing with New Eyes by David Powlison. The chapter is entitled “Peace, Be Still: Psalm 131.” This book’s emphasis on abiding in Christ and the sufficiency of Christ reframed the performance issues and bipolar symptoms as Tony saw his foolishness and despair as part of a desperate need to be self-sufficient, to prove himself to others, and to protect himself.
One of the most meaningful assignments we often give to counselees involves their direct relationship with God. Both counselees and advocates are asked to write their own psalm to God. This psalm is obviously not inspired as are the ones in the Bible, but it is effective in trying to understand where the counselees are with regard to their view of God. They are asked to review two or three psalms related to their heart condition before outlining their own. In the case of someone like Tony, we might ask him to read and model his psalm after Psalm 22. In that passage the psalmist is afflicted but is ultimately aware of the comforting presence of his faithful God. Tony would write his psalm and, if willing, share it with everyone in the counseling process. (We specifically ask the advocates to participate in assignments for their own edification, to show we are all in need of change, and to help them better relate to the counselee as they go through the time together.) The reading of the Psalms and each of their individual psalms gave great hope and glory to God.
As we concluded our time, we discussed the importance of two critical realities. First, we looked at John 15:1–8 and the critical need for Christians to abide with Christ (see circles diagram). In our time with our counselees, we want to do more than merely give them a biblical understanding of their problems and principles to help. We want them to learn how to have a dramatic and daily relationship with Christ through prayer and Bible study. Many counselees who are spiritually dry and exhausted have benefited from reading Andrew Murray’s book on abiding, especially chapter 1, which is a masterful weaving of John 15:1–8 and Matt 11:28–30.
Second, we discussed the crucial issue of forgiveness. We asked Tony to consider three questions. First, what are some of the things for which God has forgiven you? Second, where are some areas where you need to forgive others? Third, where do you still need the forgiveness of others? Such questions encouraged Tony to consider God’s grace toward him and to look at others with more mercy as he considered sins they had committed against him. Finally, he should look at areas where he had not asked for forgiveness or fully repented of sin. Tony needed to see all three of these areas to be able to move forward in a way that would please God. He was able to see significant categories where God had forgiven him all the way back to childhood. He was then able to identify some bitterness and hurt that needed to be addressed. He realized his bitterness was, in fact, a sin against his father. He broke down, and we were able to comfort him. Mourning over being sinned against as well as our own sin is a huge part of brokenness and repentance: “Blessed are those who mourn, because they will be comforted” (Matt 5:4).
Going Home
Tony’s problems were not solved over the weekend, but by the grace of Jesus we had made some significant strides. Knowing that to put down competing desires in their hearts and old patterns of living much work still lay before Tony and Lisa, we wanted to send them home with clear direction. We developed a spiritual action plan with the following elements that included the feedback of both the couple and the advocate:
Weekend in Review
The counselees received 16 hours of biblical counseling over a three-day period, and our time ended well. Tony and Lisa had significant hope. One of the most encouraging things coming out of our time was Tony and Lisa’s confidence in God’s Word and their desire to get godly counsel going forward. They now felt they knew what to look for in a counselor. The seriousness of Tony’s diagnosis had made them leery that “Christian counseling” could really help. Seeing God’s perspective on his problems, Tony now felt that any more secular counseling would only be confusing. While staying under the care of a physician to consider the long-term medical regimen was wise, they were committed to approaching their problems from a biblical worldview. Tony saw his difficulty as rooted in a pervasive heart attitude that he could overcome with the help of God’s Word, his Spirit, and the community of Christ. Tony was no longer focusing on a diagnosis but on his heart. Lisa was much less fearful of a lifelong “curse” or sickness that she would have to learn to live with in her husband. They saw a long road ahead but had direction. Incidentally, there had been some fear of having children after Tony was diagnosed, but this fear was decreased significantly as they saw their struggles through new eyes.
It was neither Tony’s diagnosis nor even his resistance to counseling that proved to be the most difficult problem. Tony’s problems were—at their core—theological. Tony was seeing that his worst problem had to do with a worship disorder. His odd behavior was symptomatic of a deeper heart issue. His stress and anxiety were due to a history of unforgiveness, fear of man, and unbiblical responses to conflict, especially interpersonal problems. Ultimately, Tony had never fully embraced the gospel or lived it out consistently. It really came down to a need Tony and Lisa had—to have an encounter with Christ who could engage their problems in a unique way. God knew they had been disappointed with previous counseling, that their issues had them exhausted and doubtful, and that they had been exposed to worldly wisdom that had them confused. The bipolar label left them feeling stigmatized and hopeless. The blend of grace and truth pierced their hearts and gave them new hope. Understanding that their problems were spiritual in nature and grew out of human sinfulness brought them hope. How can this be hopeful? Because sin has a cure. His name is Jesus.
What of the bipolar diagnosis? The symptoms that such a label point to were never ignored in our time with Tony and Lisa. We never minimized the seriousness of the problems that a bipolar diagnosis signifies. Instead, we listened carefully, gave them hours more of our time than they had received in other counseling, and provided an understanding that was superior to the secular one because it reflected God’s truth. Tony and Lisa each reported that it was a turning point in their lives with God and each other.
A Monument to God’s Power, Love, and Faithfulness
Tony and Lisa both decided it was best to follow through with plans to move to a new area. They had relatives in the community where they planned to move, and they were going to stay with them as they looked for new jobs and for a place to rent. For the time being they also chose a job with less stress for Tony. Lisa was capable of helping with income and was prepared to pursue employment until they had children. Tony had repented of his performance-based faith and fear of man. He was excited to spend time pursuing his relationship with Christ and serving others in ways that were less formal than vocational ministry. The advocate was committed to weekly phone calls and even accompanied Tony as he sought reconciliation with relatives. Tony went and asked his father’s forgiveness. He also granted forgiveness. By God’s grace Tony claims that his days of being stuck in a past full of fear, bitterness, and shame are behind him.
It is important to mention here how critical it was that Tony and Lisa were diligent to pursue deep involvement in their church community within a few months. Though counselees can take many positive steps toward biblical change, problems do not disappear after a few intense days. Because we know this to be true, we spend time discussing the importance of community and how to participate in it. Counselors must be careful not to overlook the importance of engagement with the larger Christian community outside of counseling.
As we prepared Tony and Lisa to engage in community, we asked them to realize that the interaction we had together was deeper than the kind to which most Christians are accustomed. Most of their peers will not have had this experience and may be less inclined to be as serious about a biblical worldview and doing the serious work of pursuing Christ in a daily way. Advocates can be helpful in assisting counselees to stay on track.
In the last three years Tony and Lisa have continued to make significant progress. They stayed in close touch with their advocate for the first year as they transitioned to the new area. Tony reported that the first six months were the hardest. He believed what we said about his identity and hope in Christ was true, but he continued to look back in fear and times of unbelief, wondering if he could ever really be “normal” after what they went through in their worst days. He cited a few things that were most helpful from our time together. First, the balance of truth and grace was extremely helpful. Tony and Lisa heard the truth, but they heard it spoken kindly from people they knew cared for them. Second, Tony and Lisa appreciated the reframing of his problem away from the “disease model” and toward the spiritual. Tony was not sick—he was sanctified and justified in the name of the Lord Jesus (1 Cor 6:11). Finally, Tony was gripped by Gal 2:20, “I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. The life I now live in the body, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave Himself for me.” Tony’s life was no longer his own. He was identified and defined by the work of Jesus for him. Such an understanding was freeing for both Tony and Lisa.
Tony decided to see a doctor as soon as he was settled in their new area to discuss phasing-out the medication, trusting his wife and advocate to help him be discerning in this matter. He knew in his heart that the psychiatrist’s claim that he would always need medication was not necessarily true. Incidentally, he eventually chose to stop taking his medications against medical advice, which was not our recommendation, but he has been off his medications for over two years. It has not always been easy, but he has never experienced a “breakdown” or severe mood swings since discontinuing them. He credits the Lord’s working through his time in Scripture, his small group, and his family as the reasons he has been able to progress in his walk with Christ. Though difficult, he literally forced himself to memorize and meditate on significant passages like Psalm 139—a breakthrough for him from his perspective. He stated that Christ became very real and present as he encountered him in his Word.
Tony took a few part-time jobs, but he is now a full-time teacher in a public school and reports being content and doing well. The testimony of his advocate is that “God snatched them out of that dark period.” He said that the way we did not condemn or make light of the secular counsel but brought to light the superiority of the Word of God was life changing to him, and to Tony, and Lisa. Although he was primarily there for Tony, he told us he reviews the notes he took for himself and his family periodically to this day. He felt that if we had been less gracious and patient that we would have lost Tony to unbelief, and Tony would have fallen for the distortions of a secular system. Not every case ends so well, but this case was a monument to God’s faithfulness: someone with a serious psychiatric label and a history of poor counsel can experience a dramatic turnaround by God’s grace.
Another sign of the growth and stability in this couple’s life subsequent to counseling was their response to a miscarriage a few months back. They handled it well with appropriate grief and leaning on support from their community. When a counselee weathers significant trials with grace and dependence on God after counseling, that is a great sign of growth and change. Tony and Lisa are not the same. Tony is not stuck with a new identity as a psychiatric case or damaged goods. Lisa has been helped by the process to trust God more as well. Involving her and the mentor changed them all and drew them closer to God and each other. May God continue to get the glory for what he has done in this couple and now in the community around them. Tony is writing a book about this journey, and I pray and hope it will help many who are struggling to find God’s Word, his Spirit, and his community when life gets hard.
The names and background information have been changed to honor confidentiality.
Ed Welch, Motives: Why Do I Do the Things I Do? (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 2003).
Paul David Tripp, Instruments in the Redeemer’s Hands: People in Need of Change Helping People in Need of Change (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 2002), 57–74.
Paul David Tripp, Suffering: Eternity Makes a Difference (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 2001).
David Powlison, Seeing with New Eyes (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 2003), 75–90.
Andrew Murray, Abiding in Christ (Bloomington, MN: Bethany House, 2003), 13.
Ed Welch, When People Are Big and God Is Small (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 1997).
FOUR COMMON HEART THEMES
FOUR HEARTS
Flesh Bent
Flesh Statement
Flesh Question
Renewed Statement
Renewed Question
Renewed Heart
ANGER
Torch lighter
Divisive
Prov 29:22
“I deserve some ____________!”
“My will be done.”
“Is God really on my side?”
“How do I get respect?”
“Christ is my Lord.”
“His will be done.”
“Whom can I serve?”
“How do I forgive?”
Yielding and Submissive
Tender and Kind
FOOLISHNESS
Broken Cisterns
Self-reliant
“I want it now.”
“I can’t help myself.”
“Is God really enough?”
“How can I get more?”
“God is worthy and awesome.”
“God is enough.”
“Whom can I bless?”
“Can I wait on him?”
Reverent Fear,
Seeking Wisdom,
Self-control
DESPAIR
Vain Striver
Giving Up
“I need to be understood.”
“No one knows my pain.”
“Is God compassionate?”
“Does anyone really care?”
“God is compassionate and near.”
“I am in his sovereign hands.”
“Whom can I give to?”
“Where is my hope?”
Hopeful
Giving
Praise and Worship of God
FEAR
Man Pleaser
Eyes on trial
Forgetting God
“I am unlovable.”
“I can’t risk it.”
“I can’t see a way out of this situation.”
“Is God trustworthy?”
“Does anyone love me?”
“Does anyone really care about me?”
“I trust God with all my heart.”
“My esteem comes from Christ’s love.”
“Whom should I need less and love more?”
“With Christ as my friend whom or what shall I fear?”
Trusting and Loving More Than Needing
Gratitude for All Things
Anger—The person characterized by an angry heart has a propensity to make an idol of power, control, having his own way, or to be covetous. This person might find himself making conscious and/or unconscious statements like, “I want respect or peace!” or “I can’t believe so and so!” A person who chooses not to deal with an angry heart may be characterized by bitterness, judgment toward others, discontentment, lack of joy, strained relationships, and/or continual conflict in relationships. Others might comment that his actions and attitude can be volatile, ungrateful, condemning, grouchy, intimidating, irritable, or difficult.
Foolishness—The person characterized by a foolish heart has a propensity to make an idol of escape, pleasure, self-sufficiency, or self-gratification. He may find himself constantly in pursuit of certain feelings, objects, or the accumulation of things. This person may find himself making conscious and/or unconscious statements like, “I want it now!” or “I just can’t help myself!” The person who chooses not to deal with a foolish heart may be characterized by consuming addictions, blame-shifting, irresponsibility, and self-destruction. Others might comment that his actions and attitude are cavalier, irresponsible, lazy, selfish, or immature.
Despair—The person characterized by a despairing heart has a propensity to make an idol of easing pain, feeling good, and creating comforts. This person may find himself making conscious and/or unconscious statements like, “I deserve!” or “I’m totally helpless!” The person who chooses not to deal with a despairing heart may be characterized by a victim mentality, an inordinate need for security, self-pity, strained relationships, and a propensity to self-medicate or escape through fantasy or self-destructive behavior. Others might comment that his behavior or moods are melancholy or down in the dumps. When relating to others, he can be distant, isolating, draining, or self-absorbed.
Fear—The person characterized by a fearful heart has a propensity to make an idol of security, perfection, or looking better than he is. This person may find himself making conscious and/or unconscious statements like, “Will they reject me?” or “I can’t risk it!” or “Where is God?” The person who chooses not to deal with a fearful heart may be characterized by false guilt and shame, social and/or spiritual paralysis, fear of man, and a shaken faith. Others might comment that his behavior or moods are up and down, nervous, tentative, and his social interactions are sometimes avoidant or even paranoid in nature.
