Chapter 12 of 16

Chapter 11: “Jennifer” and an Apparent Hard Case

Chapter 11: “Jennifer” and an Apparent Hard Case

Chapter 11

“Jennifer” and an Apparent Hard Case

John Babler

What makes a counseling case hard? Is it the presence of bizarre behavior that makes the average person raise his brow? Is it the presence of an unusual difficulty that the individual counselor has never heard about? Is it a fairly “normal” problem with many layers that requires much time to sort through? When does counseling cross the line from easy to hard? Any of the factors listed here (and many more) could make counseling difficult. Generally speaking, counseling is hard when counselors sense they are in over their heads with no idea how to help, when the counseling process is going to take a long time, or when a counselee is resistant to change.

I want to tell you the story of a fairly straightforward counseling case. Most wise Christians could be helpful with this kind of case if they took the time to listen well and fully understand what was actually taking place in the mind and heart of the person involved. Many wise Christians, however, would never take the time because the case begins in the emergency room.

Background of the Case

I received the phone call early on a Monday morning. Jennifer, the wife of one of our students, was in the emergency room at a local hospital. The initial report was that she had been acting strangely for several weeks and her husband, Jim, noticed that she did not go to bed at all on Sunday night. When Jim awakened on Monday morning, he noticed that she seemed “distant” and “distracted.” After completing his Bible study, he noticed that Jennifer was crying in a corner. When he touched her shoulder, Jennifer jumped and told him she was scared that someone was coming to get her and take her away. She said she had been hearing voices all night telling her this message. She continued to cry uncontrollably for over an hour. Jim decided to take her to the emergency room. I was asked to come to provide support and counsel.

When I arrived, I found Jennifer sitting on a gurney; a friend sat in a chair across from her. It was obvious that Jennifer had been crying, but by the time I arrived, she was calmly talking. I introduced myself to Jennifer and her friend, Elaine. They were both glad I had come. After Elaine explained that Jim had to go to work and could not remain at the hospital, she excused herself so Jennifer and I could talk more privately. Jennifer apologized for “causing trouble” and explained that since arriving at the hospital they had seen several people and that blood had been drawn to run a variety of tests. She also said that a social worker had asked her to sign a release for a psychiatric evaluation. She was not sure if she wanted a psychiatric evaluation and wanted to talk to me about it.

She said she had been having a difficult time sleeping for over a week. For about three weeks she had struggled with paranoia and believed she was in danger. She grew to fear those around her, including her new husband, and found herself unable to complete even the simplest of tasks. Jennifer experienced constant difficulty sleeping and told me she had not slept more than an hour a night for the last two weeks. She became seriously concerned and had only shared the details with her mom.

She searched the Internet in an effort to diagnose herself and concluded that she likely had several mental disorders. Her family had a history of mental disorders and experienced interactions with the state’s mental health system. She knew something was clearly wrong, but she feared getting involved in the mental health system. I told Jennifer that I believed the Bible had answers for her, and I would be happy to counsel her and her husband if she was open to the opportunity. A physician soon came and told her that she had a urinary tract infection requiring an antibiotic. He would prescribe a sleep aid for her as well. He asked if she had come to a decision regarding the psychiatric evaluation. In the end she did not want it. Jennifer told me she would like to see me for counseling soon. Elaine returned, offering to take Jennifer home and help her get her prescriptions filled. Jennifer went home, called her husband and mom, and went to sleep. We scheduled a meeting for the next day.

Case Process

The process of gaining information about a counselee is always ongoing. Usually, after a first session the counselor can come to some initial conclusions about what needs to be addressed and how the path forward might look. In the case of Jim and Jennifer, the first session was a bit longer than most and yet yielded more questions than insight. When I met with Jennifer the next morning, she said she had slept for about 12 hours and was feeling a little better. Jim was not able to take time off away from his job. I began to obtain some basic information. I asked her to tell me her personal Christian testimony. She described a commitment to Christ that began when she was 13, a history of regular church involvement, and a call to ministry that came about the time she met Jim. When I asked her to describe her recent relationship with the Lord, she acknowledged that in the midst of all that had been going on in her life she had not spent much time reading Scripture or praying. She said God seemed distant from her.

She told me her parents were married and that she had two younger brothers. Two of her aunts had been diagnosed with clinical depression. During the session Jennifer received a phone call from her mother. Her father was on a flight to see her and would arrive at noon. Her mom had told her that she and her dad had discussed her situation and wanted to make sure that she was receiving good care. They were hoping I could meet with them that afternoon. I asked whether she could contact her husband Jim to see if he would be available to join the meeting. He was not able to leave work early but offered to talk with me by phone on one of his breaks.

Jennifer described her family as close and loving. They did most everything together, and her parents were involved in her life. Jennifer was 21 years old. She graduated from high school one year early and entered an accelerated college program studying journalism and psychology. She had met Jim about 10 months earlier at a church function. Their relationship developed quickly, and Jim proposed to her in June. He had received a call to ministry and was planning to enroll at Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary. Since she would graduate in December, they decided to marry on the Saturday after her graduation. Her parents liked Jim and were supportive of the marriage. She described a stressful and busy fall semester as she prepared for a wedding, finished school, and planned a honeymoon. During this time she quit exercising, did not eat well, did not have time for personal devotions, and became discouraged.

While this case continued to have unexpected twists and turns, I was able to begin ministering Scripture to Jennifer. I began by expressing compassion to her and stating that as difficult as things were I believed God’s Word had the answers to the problems she and Jim were facing. I told her that her life was in chaos and out of order. She agreed. I asked her what she thought was the most important thing in the Christian life. She answered that it was important to care for others. I asked her to open her Bible to Matt 22:36–40 and to read the verses aloud:

“Teacher, which command in the law is the greatest?” [Jesus] said to him, “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind.’ This is the greatest and most important command. The second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ All the Law and the Prophets depend on these two commands.”

We discussed that the most important thing for Christians is to love God with all of our hearts, souls, and minds. If God is not in first place, then our lives are indeed out of order, and some form of chaos is the natural result. I asked if she thought disobeying the command to love God with all of her heart, soul, and mind was a sin. She responded that she understood that it was a sin and desired to repent and get her life back in order. I said that in the rebuilding of any building the foundation must be solid. I helped Jennifer see that in order to deal effectively with the chaos in her life, she needed to purpose to love God with all of her heart, soul, and mind. Jennifer needed to know that her biggest problem was her heart—not simply the circumstances which might have caused her instability and lack of focus. Engaging this heart issue did not involve some tortuous process of introspection but rather repentant faith toward her Savior.

I challenged her to consider what it means to love God truly. Her response centered on going to church and reading the Bible. I suggested that to love God it is important to spend time with him, similar to spending time with those whom we love in order to develop our relationships with them. A regular daily Bible reading and prayer time is a way to deepen a relationship with God even as we learn from him and share our deepest concerns and needs with him. In addition to that regular time of study whereby we are exposed to the whole counsel of God, we should also be involved in more in-depth study of the Word as well as regular worship and study with other Christians. I encouraged Jennifer to begin thinking of her time with God as part of an ongoing relationship, not as a task or a series of tasks that must be completed. A regular quiet time can often become a mere task to accomplish as we begin each day. All too frequently worship can become rote as well. I told Jennifer that the first order of business was to restore and deepen her relationship to God.

Practically, I suggested two resources that might be helpful for her. The first was a Bible reading plan developed by Robert Murray M’Cheyne, which, over the course of a year, allows a person to read through the New Testament and Psalms twice and the Old Testament once. Second, I wanted her to read the book of Ephesians. I described to her how the first three chapters speak to our identity in Christ, and the latter three chapters speak of the Christian life. I asked her to read the first three chapters of Ephesians three times during the next week, to note at least five verses that personally impacted her, and to bring these with her to discuss at our next meeting. I also asked her to begin praying each day and record specific requests to God on a prayer list. Plans were made to meet with her dad, and Jim would be calling during his break from work. Jennifer was teachable and open to counsel. There was no mention of her paranoia, and she remarked at least twice how much difference a little sleep made.

When Jim called me, he apologized for not being more involved and mentioned that they needed his income to make ends meet. I asked for his perspective of what was going on with Jennifer. It quickly became apparent that Jim was overwhelmed and confused. He echoed what Jennifer had said about the challenges of their courtship, but he said that they had both been looking forward to the wedding, the honeymoon, and just being married. He told me that his parents were Christians and supportive of their marriage. Since the wedding, they had given them space to develop their life together. He said Jennifer’s family seemed almost the opposite. During their courtship there had been minimal but positive contact with them. After the wedding it seemed to Jim as if they were constantly with them. Her parents helped them move to Fort Worth and stayed with them a few days. During that time Jennifer’s dad was quick to offer suggestions, even commands, to both Jim and Jennifer. Jim said that since the first day of the honeymoon nothing seemed to be under control. I learned that Jennifer became sick on the second day of their honeymoon and remained sick until two days after they returned home. Life was somewhat normal for the first two weeks in Fort Worth. He immediately started work and school. Approximately two weeks later she began to have problems sleeping. This was about three weeks before she ended up in the emergency room. Jim agreed to meet later in the evening to continue our discussion and expressed willingness to meet with Jennifer and her father if it would be beneficial.

I met with Jennifer and her dad for a few minutes in the afternoon. Wayne, Jennifer’s father, was a pleasant man and immediately stated that he wanted to make sure everything was all right with his daughter. When he and his wife had heard about Jennifer’s visit to the emergency room, they quickly decided to travel to see her. He said that he had considered the events of the past few days and realized that both Jennifer and Jim had challenges both before and after their wedding. He specifically mentioned the importance of “leaving and cleaving.” Wayne felt that he and Jennifer’s mom might have unintentionally made the leaving hard for Jennifer. He said he would be happy to stay if he could be of any help but was prepared to return home tonight if that would be best. Jennifer had a relieved look on her face and expressed thanks to him. Wayne talked about Jennifer’s two aunts who had been diagnosed with clinical depression and said Jennifer was not currently acting like they had acted.

Normally I prefer to counsel couples together. In this case, however, I had already seen Jennifer alone. I decided to meet with Jim alone as well. My plan was to meet with them together beginning the following week. During my meeting with Jim that evening, he confirmed many of the same details Jennifer shared earlier. Jim recounted to me a solid conversion to Christ and an ongoing walk with God through repentant faith and consistent Scripture reading and prayer. Jim acknowledged that he would like to lead Jennifer in family devotions, but with all the challenges he had withdrawn based on his fear of how she might react. When I inquired about their church membership, he stated they were still working to find a church home. I assigned to him the same M’Cheyne reading plan of the Bible. I asked him to read it as well so they would be exposed to the same passages each day and also asked him to lead Jennifer in a brief discussion about at least one of the verses read each day. Another assignment was for him to consider prayerfully the instruction to husbands in Eph 5:25–33 and to list any areas where he needed to improve. We concluded our meeting with a discussion about the church as a body (Rom 12:4–8; 1 Cor 12:12–31) and how he and Jennifer in their situation needed the support, encouragement, and exhortation inherent with being members of a local church. I encouraged them to join a local church as soon as possible.

Sessions with Jennifer and Jim began with two labor-intensive days. As I prepared for our meeting, I planned to focus on strengthening the foundation of loving God before moving to loving others. When they arrived for their first evening appointment, they both appeared more comfortable than when I encountered them previously. Jennifer admitted that she still remained anxious about things in their life together, but she was sleeping well. She no longer heard voices and did not feel as paranoid. However, she still wondered whether something was seriously wrong with her psychologically. She continued to search the Internet to review symptoms of certain mental illnesses. While she concluded that her symptoms were not as severe anymore, she was still afraid that at least one of the diagnoses applied to her.

I asked her about her homework. She had almost completed the Bible reading plan for the week, and she also completed the assignment in Ephesians. She was encouraged by Eph 1:3: “Praise the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us in Christ with every spiritual blessing in the heavens.” She also mentioned Eph 2:1–5 as a particular encouragement to her. These verses reminded her that God had loved her even when she was dead in her sins. She said she did not profit as much from the M’Cheyne reading, but she had done it five or six days. I reminded her that God calls us to love him and that spending time in his Word was a way to spend time with him. She agreed to purpose in her heart to read Scripture and pray every day.

I asked Jim to share about his homework next. He was convicted by his time doing the homework—especially reading the Eph 5:25–26 passage about husbands loving their wives as Christ loved the church. He realized that the Bible had not been a central part of his relationship with Jennifer since they had married and that he had not loved her in this way. He began to see that he had been impatient and frustrated with her before their wedding and had withdrawn from her to some extent, thinking things would improve after the wedding. After Jennifer got sick on the honeymoon, Jim grew more distant and withdrawn. While Jim was speaking, Jennifer moved to the edge of her chair and was nodding her head in agreement. She stated that if Jim had been more loving during this time it would have been easier for her to move beyond her struggles. I asked them to open their Bibles and read Matt 7:1–5:

Do not judge, so that you won’t be judged. For with the judgment you use, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you. Why do you look at the speck in your brother’s eye but don’t notice the log in your own eye? Or how can you say to your brother, “Let me take the speck out of your eye,” and look, there’s a log in your eye? Hypocrite! First take the log out of your eye, and then you will see clearly to take the speck out of your brother’s eye.

After reading these verses, they admitted they had blamed each other for the problems in their marriage. After this breakthrough I drew them back to Eph 5:22–32 and asked each of them to explain, in their own words, the meaning of the text. Jim replied that he was to love his wife as Christ loved the church. Jennifer replied that she was to submit to her husband and respect him. I shared with them that they each had a lifetime of work in front of them, joyfully learning how to do what God called them to do individually without being distracted by what the other one was or was not doing. We discussed that all humans are self-centered and possess deceitful hearts (Jer 17:9). When we encounter problems in our relationships, the first tendency is always to blame others rather then look to our own hearts to see the sin present there. In light of Matt 7:5, they knew each must work to rid their hearts of their own sins (taking the log out of their own eye) rather than looking to the other as the source of their pain. Jim needed to focus on loving his wife as Christ loved the church and Jennifer on how she was to submit to and respect her husband.

Before concluding, I asked that they continue the M’Cheyne reading and their joint discussion during the upcoming week. Jim said he had led in a daily discussion of one of the verses from the reading, and Jennifer expressed her enjoyment of this. They also announced that they had decided on a church to join next Sunday. I asked them both to read Ephesians 4–6 three times during the week and write down at least five things that challenged them. I also asked them to plan at least one date night.

When Jim and Jennifer came to the next session, they seemed much happier and even held hands during the meeting. Jennifer had returned to a normal sleep pattern, and her physician had given her a clean bill of health. They spent time with each other and began walking together each evening. Regular Bible reading was beginning to work its way into their minds and hearts. Jennifer said she was beginning to see the M’Cheyne reading more relationally. She truly wanted to read and was blessed by the time with God, even when she was tired. In terms of “leaving and cleaving,” they concluded that Jennifer’s closeness to her parents caused some unexpected problems between them. She began their marriage sharing concerns with her parents; now she turned to Jim for counsel and support instead. They summed things up by saying that for the first time since the first two months of their relationship they were focusing on and enjoying each other and that God was prominent in their relationship.

We spent a few minutes rejoicing in the changes that had occurred since we started meeting. I asked Jim to lead us in a prayer of thanksgiving and praise. In light of the progress, I then asked what were the most significant challenges or concerns they still had with their marriage. Jennifer struggled with thoughts of how bad things had recently been and still wondered if she had a serious mental problem. While she no longer feared that she had one of the diagnoses that she had previously researched, she still felt discouraged when thoughts entered her mind regarding her past experiences and the obvious patterns of thinking that led to her recent emergency room visit. I asked Jennifer to read 2 Cor 10:3–5:

For though we live in the body, we do not wage war in an unspiritual way, since the weapons of our warfare are not worldly, but are powerful through God for the demolition of strongholds. We demolish arguments and every high-minded thing that is raised up against the knowledge of God, taking every thought captive to obey Christ.

As we considered this passage, I emphasized that contrary to what we often think we are not powerless over our thoughts. By the Holy Spirit’s power, we can take them captive to the obedience of Christ. I also pointed out that taking thoughts captive is done in the context of spiritual warfare. Jennifer asked what it would look like to take thoughts captive. I asked her to read Eph 4:22–24: “You took off your former way of life, the old self that is corrupted by deceitful desires; you are being renewed in the spirit of your minds; you put on the new self, the one created according to God’s likeness in righteousness and purity of the truth.” The biblical process of change is not presented as simply ceasing something. Rather, it is a process of “putting off” the old and “putting on” the new—being renewed in the spirit of your mind. I asked Jennifer if she could think of how these verses could help her in taking her thoughts captive. She answered that when thoughts occurred that did not line up with God’s Word, she could immediately pray and ask God to help her arrest those thoughts and set her mind on Scripture or some truth that would honor God.

They decided it would be good for Jennifer to volunteer with a particular ministry as well as join a women’s Bible study that had just begun at their new church home. I wanted to help them better fulfill the second greatest commandment of loving their neighbor. I suggested that they were each other’s closest neighbor, and displays of neighborly love should begin at home. As we explored the truth about real love, we considered 1 Cor 13:4–8:

Love is patient, love is kind. Love does not envy, is not boastful, is not conceited, does not act improperly, is not selfish, is not provoked, and does not keep a record of wrongs. Love finds no joy in unrighteousness but rejoices in the truth. It bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things. Love never ends.

Over the coming week they both were to look for at least three different opportunities to serve each other as a way of demonstrating love.

In light of Jennifer’s sickness during their honeymoon and the challenges thereafter, sexual intimacy had been nonexistent. As they focused on these problem areas and ways to love and serve each other, God had been working to deepen their sex life as well. Over time Jim realized that his tendency in the marriage was impatience with Jennifer as she worked though various problems in her own heart and mind. This was his greatest challenge as he reflected on 1 Corinthians 13. Jennifer struggled with keeping a record of wrongs. She mentioned that once she recognized this pattern, she began to see that when Jim or someone else sinned against her, she would withdraw and become sullen. During these discouraging times, she struggled with thoughts about something being seriously wrong with her. Since she had begun to take her thoughts captive, she had also discerned other thoughts that needed to be addressed as well.

I reminded them that the church was a body and that they needed not only to find their places and use their gifts, but they could call on the body to assist them as well. I suggested that they both pray that God would lead Jim to a godly man who could disciple and encourage him and that he would lead Jennifer to a godly woman who would do the same.

Concluding Reflections

Six months after counseling, Jim and Jennifer were still doing well. Jim was excelling at seminary, and Jennifer was enjoying volunteering at the pregnancy center. They were active in a local church, and God had provided Jennifer relationships with older women who were able to help her in many ways. Initially, I considered this a hard counseling case due to the presentation, the extent of the problems, and the initial challenges of the persons involved. Many counselors might have focused on the paranoia and the voices Jennifer heard in her mind. The error in such a focus, once Jennifer was given a clean bill of health, would have been to perpetuate the selfish focus of her heart. My approach exhibited a focus on God and his Word.

The case of Jennifer and Jim reveals that sometimes bizarre and serious behavior can be a product of a combination of stressors, bad decisions, sleep deprivation, significant changes in life, and the ever-present challenge of spiritual warfare for the Christian. Planning a wedding, finishing a challenging college degree, graduation, a wedding, an illness, a major move, and sleep deprivation would impact anyone. Once the emergency symptoms were dealt with, counseling proceeded in a way that any wise and growing Christian should be equipped to navigate. This case serves as an example of why biblical counselors should not be intimidated by challenging situations. A combination of the hope that comes through God’s Word, the Holy Spirit, and the body of Christ can be the beginning of healing, growth, and a new commitment to marriage. Jennifer and Jim were initially discouraged with little hope and not sure what to do, but God brought healing and wholeness to them.

↑ Back to top

↑