Chapter 6 of 16

Chapter 5: “Mary” and Paralyzing Fear

Chapter 5: “Mary” and Paralyzing Fear

Chapter 5

“Mary” and Paralyzing Fear

Dan Wickert

I had no plans to work as a counselor when I was completing my last year of medical school at the University of Illinois in Champaign. My medical pursuits were still clearly in place as I finished up my residency in obstetrics and gynecology (OB/GYN) in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Soon I moved to Lafayette, Indiana, where I have worked as a general practice OB/GYN since 1985. During my first few years of medical practice in Lafayette, I did not see the parallel between my career as an OB/GYN and my future career (unknown to me) as a biblical counselor. But Bill Goode did.

Bill was the senior pastor of Faith Baptist Church in Lafayette. He talked to me frequently about biblical counseling and consistently expressed his desire to train me as a biblical counselor. He called me when he encountered counseling cases with medical histories and jargon. He invited me to observe counseling sessions. He perceived my education and experience as a physician to be useful tools in the counseling room. He encouraged me to consider expanding my ministry.

“Why are you here?” Pastor Goode challenged me. “What will you do with your life?” He encouraged me to contemplate how I might make the greatest investment in God’s kingdom. He urged me to use my talents and skills not only in the honorable practice of medicine but also in the ministry of the Word. Fueled by a growing desire to advance the glory of God and encouraged by the Holy Spirit, I began gradually to serve in the counseling ministry under Pastor Goode’s oversight. I have been counseling and rejoicing in God’s grace since 2001.

Though I never had any personal plans to serve God through biblical counseling, I now see how he was preparing me through my seemingly unrelated medical practice. I say seemingly because the parallels between a medical doctor (who cares for the body) and a biblical counselor (who cares for the heart and mind) are strong and instructive. Three specific parallels are worth highlighting to set the stage for one of my earliest counseling cases.

From Medical Doctor to Biblical Counselor: Practices and Parallels

Listening First

As a physician I always spend my first appointment with a patient “taking history,” a priority that finds echoes in the counseling term “gathering data.” Taking history involves a detailed foray into each patient’s medical past—her medical diagnoses, prescriptions, concerns, and complaints—in order to better understand her personally, to better understand her unique situation and circumstances, and to better determine how I can help her. Solomon wisely said, “The one who gives an answer before he listens—this is foolishness and disgrace for him” (Prov 18:13). It would be foolish for me to write out a prescription for a patient before I have taken the time to read or investigate her medical history. Without enough background information I could give her the wrong medicine. I could give her medicine that does nothing to solve her problem, or worse, medicine that intensifies her problem.

Gathering data in the counseling office is just as important (if not more so) as taking history in the physician’s office. The heart and mind are complex and difficult to understand, and the symptoms of an unwell heart are wildly diverse. Counselors have a daunting task: They seek to understand aching and fractured, angry and despairing people, and try to offer help. This is impossible, of course, without prayerful, Spirit-endowed compassion along with a careful, attentive, empathetic investigation into each counselee’s history.

Hope Is Help

A second similarity between my OB/GYN practice and my counseling ministry is the emphasis on hope. A good doctor does not examine a complaining patient and conclude her first appointment by saying, “There’s no hope for you; you’re going to be miserable forever. Don’t bother scheduling another appointment.” Sadly, in the medical world, some conditions are chronic or even terminal; still I would be a terrible (and short-lived) doctor if I preempted all treatments and discussions about medical options by saying, “There’s no hope for you.”

Of course, a physician must be honest and not misleadingly optimistic. Saying to a sick patient, “You’re doing great! Go home and relax!” would be just as detrimental as pronouncing her hopeless. Real hope is not about faking optimism, turning a blind eye to the problem, or lying to the patient. Rather, hope is rooted in truth. In the medical field the truth is that God is sovereign, and I can offer information, options, medication, surgery, perspective, and other solutions to my patients. In matters of the heart, the truth again is that God is sovereign, and the Bible offers information, redemption, encouragement, rebuke, perspective, and other solutions to my counselees. Even more holistically, the Bible offers insight into the nature of God, the nature of man, the nature of living, and the nature of the joy and complete satisfaction we find only in God—only through our redemption by Jesus Christ. Medical treatments may fail. Disease can surpass the level of medical technology accessible to professionals. But God does not fail. His revealed Word is flawless and timeless, and his purposes for his people are good.

A medical doctor does not offer hope by denying or ignoring pain. Chemo aches, surgery hurts, and hospitals are lonely. Neither should a counselor ignore or discount the present, prolonged suffering of the person he is counseling. Hope is not defined by the absence of hardship. Rather, hope is found in God’s grace in the midst of hardship. Hope is found in his promise to give us a future. God offers hope to Christians when he promises, “I am persuaded that not even death or life, angels or rulers, things present or things to come, hostile powers, height or depth, or any other created thing will have the power to separate us from the love of God that is in Christ Jesus our Lord!” (Rom 8:38–39).

Assigning Homework

The third similarity between my practice as an M.D. and my practice as a biblical counselor might be considered a small thing: As a physician I cannot change people. If they are to change, they must put forth effort, so I give homework. At a basic level I instruct my patients to eat well, exercise regularly, sleep sufficiently, and drink lots of water since these practices reflect fundamental stewardship of the body. I also assign and record a specific course of treatment with medication that is relevant to each patient’s specific medical problem. If someone cannot be healthy at home, she will not be healthy at the doctor’s office.

Spiritual health is similar. Most of the counselee’s progress will be made at home, decision by decision—not in my office. Assigning homework helps the counselee make right decisions and develop good habits of thinking and acting at the most important times—when she is not sitting across from me but is alone at work or home. I often assign my counselees specific ways to measure and record their progress as well because specific results are more informative for me and are often more encouraging to the counselee.

The Greater Need

While there are many strong parallels between my medical practice and my service as a biblical counselor, I have also identified important distinctions between them. The most significant is that medicine often treats symptoms but cannot meet the patient’s greater need. Medicinal treatments cannot transform the soul.

I have great respect for science and medicine. I have devoted decades to my medical practice precisely because I see the field as important and useful. I can testify, however—in spite of all the literature published in medical journals by top-flight scientists—that the right pills, the right operations, the right diet cannot turn dissatisfied people into content people. A woman who is anxious and depressed when she struggles to conceive will be an anxious mother who struggles with depression. Her greatest need is not medical in nature; she needs the power of God’s transforming gospel.

Although my medical background has given me helpful insights into medical counseling cases, I do not believe that one needs an M.D. or a Ph.D. to identify the greater needs of people. Non-doctors are not disadvantaged in any substantial way. All Christians—regardless of their formal academic training—have access to God’s power: “For I am not ashamed of the gospel, because it is God’s power” (Rom 1:16). Transformative power is not in one’s title or background; it is not in a degree or a list of experiences. Rather, the power that meets the greater needs of all people is found in Jesus Christ and his gospel.

In my years of counseling, I have seen this gospel power unleashed many times to save, heal, change, and help even the severely broken. Such changes are rarely instantaneous, but God is faithful. He loves to use believers like me and you to bring his life to hurting people through conversation, prayer, relationships with others in the body of believers, the preaching of the Word, the commemoration of the Lord’s Supper, and a thousand other graces in the community of faith. Our great God who is sovereign and holy gains glory for himself as he works to make his people free, forgiven, flourishing, and happy using all the graces available to us in Christ. These graces—purchased with Christ’s precious blood—ultimately transformed the desperate woman who came to my office as one of my first counseling cases.

Mary

Mary was nervous. Danger and disease were everywhere: stained carpets, spotted ceiling tiles, my black ink pen lying conspicuously on the worn desk between us. As far as she could see, every object in my office was crawling with germs and contamination. Although she was frightened as she settled into my office for that first evening session, she still managed to be friendly and talkative.

“I’m depressed,” Mary began. “I’m anxious.” This confession was the understated introduction to the last four years of Mary’s life. During this time Mary’s life had been characterized by an irrational, debilitating, and intensifying fear of AIDS.

Four years earlier Mary had married her husband, Ben. When they met, Mary and Ben were each deeply committed to Christ and Ben was pursuing a ministry degree at a Christian university. Before they met, Ben had been sexually immoral; but Mary was in love with the man he had become. They each wanted to spend their lives together pursuing Christ, so when Ben asked to marry her, she was delighted. The possibility of HIV/AIDS was particularly concerning for Mary, so in preparation for marriage, Ben was screened for sexually transmitted diseases. Ben’s tests would eventually prove that he was free from any such diseases; but while they waited for the results, Mary learned some upsetting medical news of her own: she would have difficulty conceiving.

The news devastated Mary. She had always imagined herself with children, and suddenly she felt fearful. She was fearful that she would not get the family she had always dreamed of having. She was fearful that she could not be happy without the family she had always wanted. She was fearful that she might have to settle for a life that did not give her all she desired and deserved. She also feared disappointing Ben, as well as her parents. Mary pictured herself in five years, watching her friends cooing at their chubby infants and scooping happy toddlers into their minivans. She could already feel the claws of jealousy and bitterness closing around her heart, which was throbbing with the ache of despair. Mary was crushed and was becoming increasingly listless. She couldn’t pick out clothes to wear in the mornings and didn’t want to go to work. Mary was shutting down.

This development is common in cases involving depression over medical complications. The mind affects the body, the body affects the mind, and a downward spiral begins. In Mary’s case the anxiety invoked by her potential infertility and Ben’s potential STD began to manifest itself in her body: She felt a disabling lack of energy and an overwhelming desire to stay in bed. These affectations of the body—the lack of physical activity, the listlessness—then affected Mary’s mind, making her more depressed.

By the time Ben’s tests came back negative, Mary was severely depressed. She was spending days curled up on her bed, in the fetal position. The depression, however, was only the beginning of Mary’s emotional turmoil. She was constantly anxious. In spite of Ben’s safe test results, Mary’s fear lingered and began to grow. Over a period of two months, she began isolating herself from her friends and shedding her church and ministry commitments. By the end of these two months, she couldn’t even bring herself to get dressed, leave the house, go grocery shopping, or run errands of any kind.

Mary’s isolation and lethargy were naturally straining her relationship with Ben. In spite of the difficulties, they managed to get married, but now he was striving to be a patient and understanding husband who was discouraged by his wife’s emotional collapse. After long days at work, he would return home to a dark, dirty house. Mary’s fears were debilitating. Fear dominated her mind and dictated her schedule.

When Help Hurts: The Failure of Superficial Solutions

Biblical Counsel?

Over time Mary sought various kinds of counsel. When she first began to struggle with anxiety, she spoke to a pastor affiliated with the Bible school her husband attended. Mary felt that this pastor didn’t try to understand her situation and her feelings. She did not sense that he appreciated the severe weight of anxiety she was carrying. His advice seemed superficial. His words rang hollow. This pastor certainly meant well, and he may have done a better job than Mary indicated with what was—at the time—fairly rocky soil. Still, Mary’s recollections of her experience present a sad but common stereotype of biblical counselors.

It can be easy for some counselors to treat the Bible like Tylenol, but Scripture was never intended to be prescribed for mechanical ingestion every six hours to make people feel better. This is where my earlier comparison between physicians of the body and physicians of the heart begins to break down. Counselors who prescribe Scripture are in danger of approaching their counselees in a routine, uninterested, and dispassionate way. They instruct counselees to memorize this verse and to write out that verse, but they don’t use the powerful Word as a dynamic means to encounter the living Christ. They rarely delve into the depth of biblical passages, the character of God, the beautiful implications of the gospel, or the nature of the sinful heart that fuels idolatry and deception. It is spiritual malpractice. At the end of the day, this pastor was well meaning, but he simply did not offer Mary the deep wisdom required of a complex problem like hers.

Just Have a Baby?

After the pastor, Mary sought the advice of a doctor who advised her to pursue pregnancy. He reasoned that Mary’s negative emotions were most likely the consequence of some hormonal inconsistency that would correct itself during a pregnancy. He believed that because Mary wanted a baby, a baby would make her happy. Naturally, Mary agreed, and she soon found out that she was pregnant! The immediate excitement of pregnancy along with the attention Mary received from her family and friends were enough to quell her depression and anxiety—temporarily. After the enthusiasm wore off, however, Mary’s old habits of sinful thinking began to creep back to the forefront of her mind.

In her second trimester Mary accidentally cut her finger at a nail salon. The tiny cut reminded her of AIDS. She remembered, specifically, that AIDS is transferred and contracted by blood. Her fear came rushing back.

Over the next few months, Mary’s fear of both blood and AIDS escalated far beyond reason. Trying on clothes at the mall became a terrifying risk. Mary felt contaminated because she didn’t know where the clothes had been or who had tried them on before. She began to see her own hands as potential carriers of AIDS. Because of this she pursued the comfort and control of cleanliness and began to wash her hands obsessively. She believed that with a little soap she could wash away the threat of disease. Objects in her home that she frequently touched began to lurk in her consciousness like closet monsters, crawling with the possibility of AIDS. Mary began to regard an ink pen in her home with suspicion, washing it as frequently as she washed her hands.

The fear was suffocating. Mary couldn’t use her toilet seat one morning because she believed an intruder had broken into her home while she was gone and contaminated the toilet seat with HIV. By the time her son, Daniel, was born, Mary was miserable. She was tormented in her own house and confined to her bed, which was the only “safe place.” She was imprisoned in a home speckled with mysterious stains and everyday spots, all of which Mary now associated with AIDS. She even collected her family’s laundry under the bed because her fear of the dirty clothes prohibited her from washing them.

Like the pastor Mary met with, this physician also meant well, but his solution of having a baby does not decrease anxiety or remove depression. Babies are entirely vulnerable to harm, are prone to illness, need constant attention; and since they are unable to communicate verbally, they raise millions of questions about what they want. Babies create a steep learning curve. A newborn baby increases a woman’s concerns. New babies also do not solve depression. If Mary could not care for herself or make dinner for her husband under the regular stress of life, how could she care for an infant under the sleep-deprived stress of a first-year parent?

Mary’s pregnancy was a tremendous gift from God, but it did not rid her of all her problems as she had thought it would. It made her problems worse. God had not intended the blessing of pregnancy to redeem Mary from her crippling fears. He cared too deeply about her soul to mask her problems even with good things.

Medicate the Problem?

Once again Mary was left searching for a solution. As a last resort she began taking Prozac and Valium for her depression and anxiety. Such a decision is not uncommon. In fact, most of the men and women whom I counsel are taking or have taken multiple antidepressants, along with other medications intended to help them feel better or to treat a specific psychiatric diagnosis. As a physician I am always familiar with the details of my counselee’s medications. I recognize most antidepressants; I know how they work, the common side effects, and the mental and physical dependency that many of these drugs cultivate. Because of my knowledge in this area, many counselees want my medical advice concerning whether they should continue with their medication.

As a rule, I never advise or require counselees to stop medicating because I am not their physician. I don’t know their complete medical history, and it would be irresponsible for me to advise them out of ignorance. In many cases patients who stop taking their medication cold turkey will suffer severe withdrawal symptoms that make it even more challenging to think and act rightly. Sometimes, however, a counselee will inform me that he is ready to stop taking medication. In these cases I am always curious to hear his reasons before I advise him to talk to his doctor about stopping.

One question I typically ask is, “Why do you want to stop?” Often a counselee wants to get off medications because they do not want to be judged by their friends or family. This is not a good reason because the person is often more concerned about his own glory than the glory of God. A second question I consider is, “How are you handling life on the medication?” Are they handling the normal problems of life in a biblical, God-honoring way while they are on the medication? If not, then taking them off the medication usually will not help the counselee to please God.

Does medicine ultimately solve heart problems? No. But is God’s will ultimately going to be hindered by medicine or a lack of medicine? No. God will work his will in a counselee’s heart regardless of whether they are medicated. My goal and responsibility are to cultivate hope, to help people grow in Christlikeness, and to help them prosper in the freedom of the gospel and in God’s rich purpose for their lives.

After a desperate struggle with fear and despair, Mary got the best advice she could find, and it was all an inch deep. From a pastor she got shallow spirituality; from one physician she got bad advice (“have a baby”); and from another physician she got medication. Such wisdom, as it turned out, had no power to help Mary. I do not say this to mock Mary and the men who honestly wanted to help her. I only want to illustrate the superficiality of much advice—even when that advice parades as medical expertise and biblical counsel. Any counsel unhinged from the riches of the gospel and unplugged from the divine power of the Holy Spirit can only deal with surface issues.

Understanding Mary: Mind and Body

Before addressing how to help Mary, it is important to understand how her mind and body work together. From an anthropological perspective, a human being includes these two distinct components. What we call the “heart,” “soul,” or “mind” is the inner man; what we call the “body”—including its chemical processes—is the outer man. These two components function closely together, and Scripture often addresses them together. Deuteronomy 6:5 says, “Love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your strength.” Moses urged Israel to pursue God with all the facets of their inner man (heart and soul) and with all the functions of their outer man (strength).

There are many pathophysiological cases—cases in which the mind affects the body and the body, in turn, affects the mind. For example, an abnormally low-functioning thyroid will produce physical consequences such as decreased energy, cold intolerance, and weight gain. But it can also have emotional ramifications (depression) and mental ramifications (difficulty concentrating). A low hemoglobin level (the result of blood loss) yields similar consequences: energy loss, lightheadedness, and headaches, which combine to make it difficult for the patient to think rightly.

A much more common example of the mind-body relationship is stress. Everyday stress begins as a mental experience that is manifested in the body. When a person is stressed, his heart rate speeds up, muscle tension increases, and the digestive system is affected, all in response to stress hormones released by the body as it responds to the mind. Some people begin to perform ritualistic behaviors, like scratching one area of their body over and over again until they develop a persistent rash. Notably, the body rarely initiates stress; the mind perceives the danger, discomfort, deadlines, pressure, or confrontation in accordance with God’s design. The body merely reacts to the mind’s perception.

A final example of the mind-body relationship is grief. Anyone who has experienced severe grief understands the mental and physical effects: feelings of emptiness and sorrow, fatigue and weight fluctuations. The mind and body are connected in a wonderful, intricate, cyclical way.

This relationship illustrates the serious ways a counselee’s thinking can affect his physical well-being, which then makes it more difficult to think rightly, which in turn causes more physical consequences—and so on. The mind-body relationship is beautiful, but sin can turn it into torture. Persons who are stuck in patterns of sin and who are suffering mental and physical consequences should evoke a counselor’s deepest compassion. Their suffering, even when self-inflicted, is real. David mourned over such suffering in Ps 31:9–10 after his adultery with Bathsheba. He cried out, “I am in distress; my eyes are worn out from angry sorrow—my whole being as well. Indeed my life is consumed with grief . . . my strength has failed because of my sinfulness, and my bones waste away.”

Mary was experiencing the mental and physical consequences of her sinful failure to trust God. But God, who is full of grace and mercy, often uses trials to transform us into the image of his Son and to bring us into a closer, joy-producing relationship with him. She needed to experience the hope of this truth and the truths of Rom 15:13 to set her free from her enslaving fears: “Now may the God of hope fill you with all joy and peace as you believe in Him so that you may overflow with hope by the power of the Holy Spirit.”

Starting with Good News

My counseling relationship with Mary began at the request of Ben’s employer. Mary, Ben, and Daniel had just moved to Lafayette, where Ben had secured a job teaching at a Christian high school. Mary and Ben were both Christians, and Ben was enthusiastic about his new ministry job. During the job interview Ben had been honest and straightforward about his family’s struggles. He had shared openly with the school administrator, but he had also expressed confidence that God would give them victory together. The administrator was impressed with Ben’s honesty and faith. When he offered Ben the job, he also referred Mary to the counseling ministry of Faith Baptist Church. Because Mary’s case had a medical angle, she was directed to me, one of several physicians on staff at FBC.

As Mary was telling me her intricate story in our first counseling session, I focused on her understanding of the gospel. Her level of understanding in this area would determine the trajectory of our time together. Milton Vincent joined the rich chorus of contemporary authors calling on believers to preach the gospel to ourselves every day:

Over the course of time, preaching the gospel to myself every day has made more of a difference in my life than any other discipline I have ever practiced. I find myself sinning less, but just as importantly, I find myself recovering my footing more quickly after sinning, due to the immediate comfort found in the gospel. I have also found that when I am absorbed in the gospel, everything else I am supposed to be toward God and others seems to flow out of me more naturally and passionately. Doing right is not always easy, but it is never more easy than when one is breathing deeply the atmosphere of the gospel.

Mary professed that she had trusted in Jesus as her Savior and had bowed to him as her Lord. She understood the desperate condition of her heart and life without Christ. She acknowledged the pervasive necessity of the gospel in her sanctification and knew that a growing believer should overflow with the fruits of the Spirit. Mary was a believer. She trusted in Christ. As true as that was, she had been shackled to her fears for over four years. There was no satisfaction or joy in her life. What was wrong?

Mary wasn’t satisfied with her life because she was trying to locate satisfaction in temporary things that only dazzle the heart in a temporary way. She was not finding joy, hope, and satisfaction in a living Savior who could justify, adopt, and sanctify her. As a result she was unhappy and anxious. What temporary object was Mary looking to in order to be satisfied? In that early meeting one thing was clear: Mary was desperately discontent because she was seeking satisfaction in an elusive assurance that she would not get AIDS. Though Mary was a believer, she was actively pursuing an AIDS-free life more than she was pursuing Christ. This was a serious problem, but even in her deep distress, the God of steadfast love was drawing Mary back to himself.

As Mary and I began our counseling relationship, I knew God had brought us together so she could learn that her greatest need was to find her satisfaction in Christ alone. Mary needed to desire him, trust him, and seek him more than she valued protection from AIDS. She was learning the hard way that medication and a newborn would never fulfill her. Shallow spiritual balms did not take her deep enough into the riches of grace. Constant efforts at cleaning and avoiding “contaminated” objects were false refuges that would never provide the security for which she longed. I began to pray that through our times together Mary would encounter Christ and the peace which only he can provide.

Making Sense of Mary’s Fear

During our first session I asked Mary to explain exactly why AIDS was so terrifying. I learned that most of Mary’s dread stemmed from three places: a calculated fear of death, a fear of contaminating her family, and fear of her friends’ judgment. Mary did not share in depth about her fear of death, but she spoke at length about how AIDS might affect her family and her friends. The worst part about contaminating her family, she expressed, was that she would feel guilty and she would lose them. Her fear of her friends’ judgment sprang from a similar thought. They would make her feel guilty and dirty for having AIDS, and then she would lose them.

Although this fear of losing family and friends can sound natural and right, it is typically founded on a premise of entitlement. The unstated assumption is that “I deserve to have a healthy family and nice friends” or “I don’t deserve a sick family and judgmental friends.” For Mary this assumption turned into a stronger conclusion: “I must have what I deserve or I cannot be happy. I must have what I deserve or God is not good.” This demand led to crippling anxiety. Mary could not absolutely guarantee that her family would avoid contracting AIDS so she became increasingly fearful. As Mary finished describing her situation, she sighed, “I don’t know how to let it go.”

Mary’s obsessive thinking was negatively affecting both her mind and her body. As she looked at me from across my desk, hands folded neatly in her lap, I felt the crushing weight of her fear. I recognized its folly, but I was also moved by her vulnerability, her admission of weakness, and the misery of her self-induced captivity.

Who Is God? Faith Versus Feelings

In our second counseling session, I wanted to establish further the disconnect between a robust belief in the gospel of Jesus and Mary’s patterns of behavior. Often counselees are so fixated on their feelings regarding their situation that they ignore the truths God has clearly revealed in his Word. These counselees are operating under the unstated assumption, “I feel it to be true; therefore, it is true.” Such patterns of belief are a poison to trust in Christ and his promises. It is deceptive and precarious logic; it elevates a sin-cursed person’s perception of circumstances above the absolute truth that God has established. To ignore this absolute truth is to say, essentially, “My perception, my logic, and my thinking are just as good, accurate, and credible as God’s.” In contrast the imprisoned apostle Paul urged believers to set their minds not on their feelings but on what is true (Phil 4:8).

In response to my questions, Mary claimed to know that God was holy, good, kind, sovereign, gave believers joy, and worked all things for the good for those who love him. I asked if Mary really believed these things. She nodded. I asked if she believed them last week when she felt fearful. She shook her head. The truth was that Mary knew those truths intellectually and generally but was not pondering and embracing them daily; instead, she was focusing on her weaknesses, her fear, and her discouragement.

Thinking only on what is true is impossible because we are fallen creatures. We were born in sin, and although believers are now counted righteous before God and possess Christ’s power to obey, we will wrestle with our sin until we are perfected in heaven and our transformation into the image of Christ is complete. As we await that transformation, we still struggle against deception deep in our hearts. Mary’s heart was telling lies, and she was falling for those lies. She was basing her decisions on her feelings about what was true, rather than on the established truth of God’s Word. I pointed out to Mary that her wavering emotions were founded on shifting lies.

In fact, every sin is founded on a lie—the lie of unbelief directed toward God’s Son and his declared truth. For example, we often fail to believe that God is who he says he is. We do not believe that God will really do what he has promised to do; we suspect that God might not know or will not do what is best for us; and we doubt the way that God has ordered the world. When we believe lies and choose to sin, we experience emotional consequences such as depression, anger, anxiety, hopelessness, and many others.

Mary had not been abiding with Christ by dwelling on the truths of God’s Word. She was not trusting in God’s sovereignty or his goodness. Instead she believed the lies that she could protect herself better than God could and that she could manipulate a healthy future for herself. She did not believe God would satisfy her with his presence, love, and care. Rather, she was deceiving herself into thinking that control and good health would satisfy her. As a result, Mary’s fears escalated as she realized that she could not guarantee herself the control and protection she was craving.

Mary needed to see the infinite riches of Christ, she needed to rest in those riches, and then she needed to learn to remind herself of those riches when anxiety threatened her trust. Just like the rest of us should do, she needed to preach the truth to herself daily (starting with the gospel) instead of listening to the constant refrain of lies streaming to her from without and from within.

Laying a Biblical Foundation

If lies come from our selfish hearts, our sinful world, and our deceptive adversary Satan, then where does the exclusive and inerrant truth come from? I shared with Mary the declaration of Hebrews: “For the word of God is living and effective and sharper than any double-edged sword, penetrating as far as the separation of soul and spirit, joints and marrow. It is able to judge the thoughts and ideas of the heart” (4:12). The author of Hebrews connects this living, effective, sharp, penetrating, judging word to Christ (Heb 4:14). That means that if Mary is going to encounter her Savior she is going to need to turn from her feelings to the Word, which leads her to the Savior of her soul.

With this in mind, I challenged Mary to put her hope in Christ by looking to the truth and authority of Scripture, even when she felt the world was dangerous, even when she felt lonely or purposeless, even when she felt victory was a lost cause. The Bible would be critical in helping her determine the truth about herself and her situation. Without a standard of truth, how was Mary to know what was true about her circumstances?

Thankfully, Mary claimed the Bible as her source of truth and admitted that her feelings were not a trustworthy source of confidence. Because Mary was already a believer with confidence in Scripture, she was quickly encouraged as she saw where the Bible directed her hope in our discussion of the truth of the gospel and the reality of her redemption. We read Rom 8:28–29 together: “We know that all things work together for the good of those who love God: those who are called according to his purpose. For those He foreknew He also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son, so that He would be the firstborn among many brothers.” As we unpacked these verses together, Mary began to have hope that God’s plan for her future in Christ was good, holy, and wonderful—even when she could not see it at the time.

“You already know what’s true,” I told Mary. “We’ve talked about all of these true things. Now you have to decide, and you’ll have to decide every day and maybe even every half hour, whether you’re going to repent of your unbelief and trust Christ and believe what is true or whether you’re going to believe lies. Truth leads to repentance, restoration, satisfaction, and joy. Lies only lead to destruction.”

Mary understood. She knew that continuing in her wrong thinking would mean forfeiting victory and reembarking on a gloom-filled, fear-laden, unproductive life spent in the fetal position. She admitted that without the hope of God’s truth, her future was one of loneliness and perhaps eventual institutionalization.

“But the lies are just so overwhelming,” Mary confessed. “When I start to feel afraid, I feel like I can’t stop. It just gets worse and worse.” I sympathized with Mary’s feelings of helplessness; but for her own good and growth, such lies had to be challenged: “You feel like you can’t stop, but what is true?” I pressed. Mary shrugged.

So together we looked at 1 Cor 10:13 where Paul wrote, “No temptation has overtaken you except what is common to humanity. God is faithful, and He will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation He will also provide a way of escape so that you are able to bear it.” I explained that even when the temptation to fear seemed overwhelming, God had promised her a way of escape. God is faithful. He cares for his precious daughter. He would never allow her to face more than she could handle with his help. I asked Mary to memorize this verse so that she would be prepared the next time she faced fear and the corresponding temptation that she could not escape it.

Scripture memory is a sharp, shining weapon against temptation. Memorizing Scripture invokes the aid of the Holy Spirit—God-on-the-scene in our struggles. The Spirit who dwells within us has the power to strengthen and comfort and gladden our hearts with his Word. The psalmist says in Ps 119:11, “I have treasured Your word in my heart so that I may not sin against You.” By the power of the Holy Spirit working through the Word, we are set free from the slavery of our sinful nature (Rom 8:2, 10–11; 2 Cor 3:17), we are convicted of any hidden sin (Ps 19:12), we abound in the fruit of the Spirit (Gal 5:22–23), and we abound with hope (Rom 15:13)!

Loosening the Grip

Over subsequent sessions Mary’s progress was slow but significant. In our fourth meeting we discussed her craving for control. All of Mary’s fears—her fear of death by AIDS, her fear of infecting her family with AIDS, her fear of her friends’ judgment if she were to contract AIDS—stemmed from a desire for control. Mary wanted to control her future. She wanted to control her family’s health and well-being. She wanted to control her friends’ opinions of her. Of course, our natural desires for safety, comfort, and health are not inherently wrong. But Mary was willing to sin to get what she wanted. She was willing to stop serving her family, her friends, and her church in order to maintain her safety, comfort, and health. She was motivated, driven, and striving for control over her circumstances.

As we talked, I pointed out to Mary that she had erected an idol in her heart. Where the living God should have been—in the center of Mary’s consciousness and at the center of each of her endeavors—an idol of control received her worship.

John Calvin once said that the human heart is a “factory of idols.” This is a frighteningly accurate metaphor. Just as every sin is the fruit of unbelief, at the heart of every sin is an idol. If I believe a lie about God, then I am not worshipping him; rather, I am belittling him, casting him from the throne of my heart. Man was designed for worship, so if I am not worshipping God, I am worshipping something or someone else. Mary was worshipping control. She believed the lie that having control would make her happy. She believed that having control would keep her safe, that having control would keep her family safe, and that having control over the opinions of her friends would keep her from being lonely.

Idols are powerful, but two realities cause our hearts to become dissatisfied with idols. The first is that we are created in the image of God and created for God; nothing else will give us eternal purpose or everlasting joy. When we choose to set up a dead, powerless idol and worship at its feet, then we are attended to by a dead, powerless idol that pleases temporarily and superficially. Money disappears. Fame fades away. Children grow up and leave. Our friends fail us. Control is elusive. God alone—in all of his beauty and grace—can promise us joy forever.

The second reality that causes our hearts to grow dissatisfied with idols is the grace of God. God is too good to allow his children to worship something or someone that will not satisfy. He is so good that he either wrenches our idols from our hands or makes us miserable as long as we clench and grasp. Mary was seeking her happiness, her safety, and her fulfillment in her own ability to control her circumstances. Ultimately, her warped belief that she could control her circumstances revealed Mary’s prideful worship of self in addition to her worship of control.

When the threat of AIDS exposed her illusion of power, Mary crumbled. The fear of AIDS threatened Mary’s gods, the idols of her heart: her own self and her lust for control. As a result she isolated herself and stayed in bed—her best attempt to achieve safety and relief from her fears. Living for a false god will bring each of us to this point, one way or another: a lonely, fearful life lived in the fetal position.

Is God Good?

Not only was Mary willing to neglect her family in her desperate chase for safety, but her lust for control also presented yet more evidence of her self-deception. Mary was not believing that God was good. When I challenged her with this reality, she admitted that she had difficulty surveying her circumstances and concluding, “God is good.”

“I wouldn’t say, ‘God is not good,’ said Mary, “but it’s just hard to believe that what he’s putting me through is very good.” I appreciated Mary’s honesty. She was only expressing what many believers feel in the course of suffering: How can a good God allow people to suffer? We made this a matter of discussion in our times together. I also had her memorize Ps 119:68, “You are good, and You do what is good; teach me Your statutes.” Additionally, I encouraged Mary to read Trusting God by Jerry Bridges to bolster her understanding of God’s love, his providence, and his sovereign control. This book addresses at length her major questions about God’s goodness and sovereignty. Mary was to read one chapter each week, underline anything that seemed pertinent to her situation, and we would then discuss it in our weekly meetings. This detailed process of reflection made our discussions more thoughtful, substantial, and relevant.

“We both know that the Bible portrays a good God,” I reminded her. “Do your feelings or your circumstances change that truth?” I explained that according to Ps 119:68 (and many other passages), God not only exercises sovereign control over every event in our lives, and he is not only good in the essence of his being, but he is also doing good in our everyday lives. It might not seem good, and it might not feel good. But the seeming and the feeling are not definitive.

“Think of the crucifixion of Christ—was that good?” I asked Mary. “No,” she immediately replied. Then she caught herself and continued, “Well . . . yes.” I watched the light go on in her mind. Mary knew that God had sent Christ to suffer and atone for our sins. He was tortured. He was mocked. He bled. Had Mary and I been present at his crucifixion, we would have stood beneath the cross and asked, “Why? Why is God making him suffer like this?” But the beautiful truth is that God’s ways are higher than ours (Isa 55:8–9). Our sovereign God transformed the brutal, horrifying death of his innocent Son into the best good his people could ever experience.

“What if you did get AIDS,” I asked Mary. “Is God still good? Romans 8:28 says that he works all things for your good. Would that include AIDS?” I pressed Mary to recognize that God is always good—even in the shadow of her darkest circumstances. If she were not sick for a single day of her life, God would be good. If she and her entire family contracted AIDS, God would be good. God was always working for her good.

“Isn’t he working to give me a better life?” objected Mary. “I don’t understand how that works if I get AIDS.”

“He’s working to make you more like Christ,” I explained. “He’s working to draw your heart closer to his. There are rich, popular, healthy people all over the world who are miserable; but if you are trusting in Christ, thanking him for his goodness, rejoicing in the truth of your salvation, and serving and encouraging others, then you will experience joy and satisfaction in Christ—even if you have AIDS. I can promise you that.”

Mary was beginning to learn that until she cultivated a submissive heart to the truth of God’s goodness and the rightness of his plan, she would not rid herself of fear in any long-term way. So long as an idol occupied her heart, she would remain fearful and discontent. As Mary grew in her understanding of the goodness of God, she began to taste the bitterness of her unbelief and to recognize her consuming fears as sin and rebellion. Where sin had multiplied, God’s grace multiplied all the more (Rom 5:20).

From Fear to Love

Over our next few sessions, Mary and I discussed 1 John 4:18: “There is no fear in love; instead, perfect love drives out fear.” I read this verse aloud to her and explained that the antidote to fear was not courage but faith in the bold and persevering love of God. If Mary would entrust herself to God’s love, her fears would be driven away. As she began making progress in her thinking, I challenged her to follow Christ’s example of love by living her own life in love. This would help her begin thinking of others instead of only herself, a process which, by God’s grace, would mean a complete turnaround over time. I explained that fear drives us to self-preservation but that love seeks to understand others and sacrifices to meet their needs. Fear had led Mary to avoid unpleasant situations and to expel discomfort at all costs. Now love would move her to dwell on God’s grace and thank him for the intimidating situations which were designed to mold her into the image of Christ.

With this new purpose Mary continued to make progress. Over the next month she faithfully completed the counseling assignments I gave her, some of which were service projects. She planned out two serving opportunities along with keeping a journal in which she recorded events throughout the day that triggered her fear. Then she wrote out the truths that she could turn to as weapons in the battle against fear. I urged her to repent whenever she became sinfully fearful and to thank God for each “fear trigger” which God was using to shape her. Each assignment was designed to help Mary ponder truth, cast down idols, focus on others, and rest in Christ.

After five weeks of counseling, Mary finally washed the clothes under her bed. In our eighth week together, she took her son, Daniel, to a nursing home where her goal was to visit with the residents and bring joy to their day. Throughout the afternoon she struggled to remember that God was protecting both Daniel and herself, but she persevered in faith and even touched one of the residents on the shoulder in a comforting gesture of love. Her heartfelt love and her mission to serve enabled her to overcome her fear of this sort of contact. Rather than viewing the nursing home residents as threats to her and her son’s safety, Mary was viewing her afternoon in the nursing home as a ministry, an opportunity to share her joy in the Lord. Jesus Christ defeated Mary’s lust for control as she trusted him in obedient faith. She went home happy, reaping the blessing of joy for her grace-empowered obedience.

Journaling for Growth

As we continued to meet, guided journaling became a key element in Mary’s process of change. In addition to recording her “fear triggers,” I also asked Mary to write out what she was thinking and wanting each time she saw fear in her heart and to describe how she handled each encounter with fear. Did she succumb and spiral into depression? What truths from God’s Word did she remember and preach to herself? This assignment not only helped Mary take “every thought captive to obey Christ” (2 Cor 10:5), but it also helped me follow her progress closely. She was encouraged as she flipped back through the pages each week, reading in her own writing how God had been faithful and victorious. Soon I asked Mary to add blessings and praises to her journal. “Stop and praise God for each trial you encounter,” I suggested.

Through Mary’s journaling, I could see that she was beginning to approach her life in an entirely new way. Every week we celebrated her victories, large or small, knowing that change was a gradual process and that even the small steps were worthy of celebration. In one of her entries, she wrote:

When I woke up, I was fearful for the coming week. I repented to God for my rebellion and submitted myself to Him. I’m looking at just today knowing that there will be sufficient grace for me for today. Today I became fearful about something I cut myself with. I repented to God that I want to be in control of my own life and thanked Him for all the ways He reminds me that my protection is under His control.

After a month and a half Mary met with her physician and received his approval to begin reducing her anxiety and depression medications. This was yet another victory to celebrate in the journal:

This was a victorious day, and I thanked God for his mighty power and grace that he has brought to my life. . . . I’ve had no medication this week. . . . The clothes previously under the bed are clean and worn. I can put my son in the grocery cart without wiping it down now.

Blood: The Final Proving Ground

As Mary progressed, I was fascinated by the way God designed unique trials specifically to refine her. For example, Mary feared the sight and even the concept of blood. During her nine months of counseling, she accidentally cut her hand twice at the nail salon and several more times at home. The cuts were small with no risk for infection, but these events were opportunities for her to entrust herself to God’s goodness by trusting his Son and believing his truth. After all, how often does a nail salon worker cut a client’s finger? I knew these “coincidences” were being orchestrated by Christ, the Wonderful Counselor (Isa 9:6).

Four months into counseling, Mary visited her local cable company to pay the family’s cable bill. She was running errands that afternoon, helping her husband and serving her family, and probably celebrating her recent success as she walked confidently into the poorly maintained building and paid her bill. As she finished the transaction, she heard a sharp cry. Turning abruptly, Mary saw a pale face in the doorway; the woman grimaced and held her elbow. This stranger had managed to slice her arm on a metal latch in the doorway, and a deep cut was bleeding down the length of her arm. Blood was already on the floor, on the doorframe, and on the woman; and she was standing in the middle of the only exit. Mary felt the familiar ache of fear knotting up in her stomach. The flickering exit sign over the door, however, reminded her of something.

First Corinthians 10:13, thought Mary. God will provide a way of escape. The truths she had been stockpiling in her mind flashed into action: God is good. God would never give me more than I can handle with his help. God knows I can handle this. God has prepared me for this trial. It didn’t come earlier because I wasn’t ready. But now I can please him through this and become more like Christ. God would give Mary the courage to walk through this trial as through an exit door, without being derailed by fear and self-protection.

It would not be simple or easy. Mary swallowed hard, her stomach sick and sinking. She glanced down at her feet and her strappy summer sandals, then back at the blood between herself and home. Maintaining a calm face, she walked straight past the woman and through the bloody doorway, her limbs cold and heavy. Outside the building now, she contemplated running to her car.

“Miss?”

The voice startled Mary. She turned around. The woman was calling from the doorway, white-faced and wide-eyed.

“Do you know first aid? It’s bleeding a lot.” The woman pointed to her cut. “Would you help me get to my car?”

Mary set her mouth in a shaky line, and shockingly started walking back toward the woman. Naturally she was extremely careful and made no direct contact with the woman’s blood, but she still helped this stranger apply pressure to the wound with clean bandages, and then walked her to her car. As Mary walked back to her own car and drove home, her mind was blank.

When she pulled into her driveway, she was overwhelmed with anger. She knew God had put her in this situation. He had given her another difficult opportunity to trust him, and Mary was furious with God for making her do something so awfully hard. She ripped the floor mats out of her car and peeled off her shoes and stuffed them into the trash. She went inside and tried to sleep but couldn’t—she felt overwhelmed. Eventually, with Ben’s loving, gentle encouragement, she was able to accept God’s love for her in arranging this monumental event. God had not abandoned her in her moment of need and weakness. God had used her to share his love and compassion with a stranger. God had brought her through blood.

As Mary related this story to me over the phone, I was astounded by God’s grace lavished on her life, far more abundantly than she could ever have imagined. Over time, as she continued to learn how to rejoice in God’s goodness toward her, she discovered a deep and thrilling paradox: All her hope—her sanctification, her joy, and her eternal satisfaction—was secured by Christ’s blood.

Not only had God brought her through blood and taught her through blood in the cable company building, but he had also first bought her with blood at the cross. The thing she feared most—an encounter with blood—is what God had planned since before creation to redeem her—not only for a delightful eternity but for God-glorifying growth in daily living. In one of her final journal entries, Mary wrote: “I know that nothing happens to me by chance. God is actively involved in each and every experience I have to make me more like Christ, . . . and every time he calls me to sacrifice or deny myself, he plans to give me more than I had to start with.”

Concluding Reflections

By the end of nine months, Jesus was transforming Mary as her mind was renewed (Rom 12:2). Of course, renewing the mind is a lifelong endeavor, and Mary would continue to wrestle with fear. But now she was equipped with God’s Word and knew how to lay hold of God’s power in the Spirit. She was much quicker to embrace God’s gracious purposes in using her temptation to strengthen her faith and dependence on Christ.

Looking back, I see at least two major ways in which God enabled me to help Mary. First, Mary and I went directly and consistently to the cross and the core work of atonement that God had accomplished in her life. This gospel perspective freed Mary to understand her identity in Christ and her purpose in life. To this day I am still astounded by how the gospel intersected with Mary’s sin. The one thing Mary feared the most, the one thing Mary ran from and hated—blood—was the exact thing God had used to save her forever. Blood had rescued her from a truly terrifying life and an eternity without him, and blood had given her hope for today.

Second, I chose not to focus on secular labels for Mary’s unusual behavior. When referring to her problems, I purposefully avoided all terminology outside of biblical terminology. Others (especially secular specialists) might have labeled Mary’s behavior obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), but I chose not to label her behavior as OCD in our counseling sessions because this label often weakens a person’s sense of responsibility and indirectly undercuts hope. People who embrace these labels may conclude, “I was born with OCD, and there’s no cure for that. I can’t help the way I think and behave.”

Although Mary’s struggles should not be taken lightly, the Bible is always full of hope for believers, regardless of their mental and physical circumstances or setbacks. In Mary’s case her OCD was the symptom, not the source of her struggles. Focusing on the deception of her sin nature, the sovereignty and goodness of God, and her tendency to become self-absorbed enabled Mary to see how the Bible was relevant for her problems. The Bible does not speak to OCD in contemporary medical terminology, but it does talk about the thoughts, motivations, and behaviors our culture uses to describe OCD. In other words, the Bible has a lot to say about fear, anxiety, trusting God, and loving others.

Finally, what would I have done differently? Thankfully, more than 10 years later, I am far more equipped today to help someone like Mary. Not only have I accumulated more experience, but I have also watched dozens of helpful contemporary resources stream into the hands of counselors and counselees. I did not have the following books on hand when I counseled Mary, but I would have been delighted to use them. The Cross-Centered Life and Living the Cross-Centered Life by C. J. Mahaney unpack the necessity and centrality of the cross in interpreting and living life to the glory of God. A Gospel Primer by Milton Vincent beautifully details the nonnegotiable task of preaching the gospel to oneself day by day and hour by hour. John MacArthur’s The Murder of Jesus and Hard to Believe and James McDonald’s Gripped by the Greatness of God serve as further reminders of the significance of our atonement in Christ as well as the practical implications of God’s glorious attributes. Beyond material resources, connecting Mary with one or two female mentors also would have been beneficial. Walking closely alongside godly women would have been an effective way to encourage and inspire growth in her life.

This was a lengthy and memorable case that God used for good in both of our lives. After nearly a year of counseling, Ben found a job in the south that was a better fit for the family, so he, Mary, and Daniel moved on. Although Mary still struggled occasionally with fear, she was now equipped with the theological truth and practical tools to confront temptation through Christ’s grace.

As one of my first cases, Mary’s transformation solidified my desire to serve the Lord through biblical counseling. I was inspired by her growth, by her newfound passion for truth, and by her blossoming desire to know and worship God. God had drawn her near to himself, and her joy now warmed her home and lit up her family and transformed her relationships. Mary was shining like a light before us; and because of the Holy Spirit’s work in her life, we were glorifying our Father in heaven (see Matt 5:16).

When Mary moved away at the end of nine months, a happy creature in Christ, she was neither fearless nor brave. She was, however, full of God’s love and covered in his grace.

How is Mary doing now? Just last week I contacted her, and her response beautifully portrays the transforming power of God:

My life is not my own. I daily choose to submit it to my Creator, and I have no limits or expectations for what He will do with it. . . . I only know that it will be good. It has been in that state of submission, I have been freed up with amazing energy to work with our local hospice. I have yet to get a terminal AIDS patient, but I can’t wait! I’ve also been able to love and counsel many who are troubled with addictions and are potential intravenous drug users, and it is my greatest joy to hug them and love them and partner with them toward recovery. I have been able to work with the local Child Protective Services to care for a foster boy who was a drug baby, and I adore him as my own without one moment’s regard for his health and how it could affect mine. The list goes on, and I hope it will continue to grow. The first major part of my life was consumed with thoughts of myself, my safety, and my happiness. I had built my own personal “kingdom” and was unwilling to accept anything less. Now I’m free. Free to serve, free to love the unlovely, free to offer hope to the hopeless, free to get dirty in people’s lives. Free to say yes when my God calls me! My greatest passion in life is to lift Jesus high. If that is with AIDS or any other disease or loss—bring it on. My Most High God looked upon me and declared me righteous by Christ’s blood, and there is nothing I will not suffer for Him and His glory.

God is faithful. His grace sustained Mary through every moment of weakness, raised the banner of hope in her heart, and exploded like fireworks in the dark skies of her fear. Now he will continue to work great and beautiful things through her compassion toward others.

Grace—how illuminating.

Freedom—how bright.

Blood—how cleansing!

This chapter was written with significant help from Rebecca Thomas.

Milton Vincent, A Gospel Primer for Christians: Learning to See the Glories of God’s Love (Bemidji, MN: Focus, 2008), 6.

John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, ed. John T. McNeill, trans. Ford Lewis Battles, Library of Christian Classics, vol. 20 (London: SCM Press, 1960), I.XI.8 (108).

The primary fear here in this passage is God’s judgment that has been dispelled when a person places faith and trust in Jesus for salvation. The secondary application is that fear is basic unbelief and loving trust will help Christians deal with their fears.

↑ Back to top

↑