Chapter 5 of 16

Chapter 4: “Sarah” and Postpartum Depression

Chapter 4: “Sarah” and Postpartum Depression

Chapter 4

“Sarah” and Postpartum Depression

Heath Lambert

It was a beautiful summer afternoon, and I was busy working on three important responsibilities I wanted to accomplish before going home. Our church was dealing with a financial issue, and our budget team had just given me some numbers to crunch before a meeting that night. A church member had been stirring up trouble with others in the congregation, requiring me to confer with fellow church leaders about a proper course of action. Last but not least, I also was hoping to make some headway on my upcoming sermon.

As I worked feverishly, my cell phone began to ring. I did not recognize the number, considered ignoring the call, but at the last minute I picked up. “Pastor Heath,” began a concerned voice, “do you have a second?” I instantly recognized the voice. It was Clark, a highly involved and well-respected member of our congregation. He said that he and his wife, Sarah, needed to talk to me about something important. As I glanced at my calendar and began suggesting times the following week, Clark interrupted to say that it was urgent and they needed to talk today. Clark was not a demanding church member, and I could hear in his voice that he really needed help. After a quick prayer asking the Lord for grace to accomplish all that he had given me to do, I said I could meet them in about 15 minutes. As I rearranged the work on my desk and prayed for wisdom in the upcoming conversation, I wondered what was so urgent.

Clark and Sarah

Clark and Sarah were high school sweethearts who married midway through college. Originally from New England, they had moved to the area so Clark could take a job as a computer technician at a large business in our city. Sarah found work as a receptionist at a local law office. They had been married for seven years and seemed to love their life together. Clark had studied information technology in college and enjoyed applying what he learned at his company. Sarah’s position was “just a job,” but she liked it that way. She loved being able to leave her work at the office and focus exclusively on her marriage and home while not on the clock. Together they earned a comfortable living and had a happy life.

Clark and Sarah were both deeply committed Christians. They had each come to faith in Christ in high school, and they had been walking with Jesus faithfully ever since. They visited the church I served as pastor shortly after I arrived. They had grown frustrated with their former church’s drift toward liberalism and were enthusiastic about our commitment to expositional preaching. They quickly jumped into the life of our church. They rarely missed a service, served in numerous ministries, and displayed an obvious love for Christ.

Clark and Sarah were also deeply in love with each other and strongly committed to having a healthy and growing marriage. They were devoted to biblical principles regarding the structure of their marriage, serving each other, and resolving conflicts in a way that honored Christ. Apart from these foundational values, Clark and Sarah also just “clicked.” They enjoyed the same activities, kept the same schedule, and valued the same financial priorities. Their relationship was so strong and exemplary that I regularly pointed to them as a model marriage in our church.

I was only aware of one problem. Clark and Sarah both desperately wanted children, and they had some difficulty conceiving. They had never used any kind of birth control but “trusted God to give them children in his own time.” They were not trying to conceive children, but neither one would have been disappointed if Sarah had become pregnant even within their first year of marriage. After five years, however, “not trying” turned into really trying. Their efforts at having kids grew into a shared concern that conceiving children would not be possible.

After taking Clomid, however, Sarah became pregnant. In fact, just two weeks before the afternoon phone call I received from Clark, Sarah had given birth to a beautiful daughter named Zoe. Clark and Sarah were ecstatic. They were overcome with joy in God’s grace to them. They were overwhelmed with thankfulness for a healthy pregnancy and a beautiful daughter. I visited them in the hospital and also stopped by their home soon after they were discharged. Everything seemed fine. Now, as I sat in my office waiting for them to arrive, I could not imagine what might be wrong.

As soon as Clark and Sarah walked in, it was clear that something was very wrong. Sarah looked like a different person. Her face was puffy, her eyes bloodshot, and she looked absolutely exhausted. Clark was holding her hand and looked scared. I noticed they did not have Zoe with them. They explained that they had left her with a friend because they had something serious to discuss. Based on their appearance, my first instinct was a sinking fear that Clark may have committed adultery. After praying together, I asked them what was wrong.

Little Bundle of . . . What?

Sarah said that these first few weeks with Zoe had been hard, but she could not finish talking. She began to sob. Clark picked up where she left off, describing a trying ordeal with Zoe. Like all newborns Zoe cried often, needed constant attention, and kept a remarkably inconvenient sleep schedule. For the most part Sarah was completely uncertain about what to do with Zoe when she cried. She tried to feed her or rock her, but the crying seldom stopped. Putting Zoe to bed resulted in more crying. They had visited the pediatrician who assured them that Zoe was just a normal infant and things would improve over time. It didn’t. Sarah had not slept more than a couple of hours a night for three weeks. She was exhausted, stressed, sad—and angry.

She explained through tears that she actually had started to resent her baby. She felt no connection with Zoe and had been longing for her life to return to the way it was before Zoe was born. She missed the normal rhythm of work and her quiet evenings with Clark. She had assumed being a mother would be fun and would come naturally to her. It was not. She was now concerned that she was going to be a bad mother. Again Sarah began to sob.

Clark said that Sarah was bouncing between extremes of anger and sadness. He had never seen her this way. Clark and Sarah then began describing a serious situation: Sarah had been thinking about killing Zoe.

On one occasion Zoe had been crying and would not stop. After a long time Sarah grew past the point of frustration. Not knowing what to do, she started thinking about throwing Zoe up against the wall as hard as possible, “just so it would be quiet for a few minutes.” Late one night Zoe was crying in her crib. Sarah “tried everything” to quiet her down, but Zoe would not go to sleep. After quite some time of just staring into the crib, Sarah began to fantasize again about throwing Zoe up against the wall.

Finally, on the afternoon that Clark had called me, Zoe had been crying as Sarah was beginning to prepare dinner. As Sarah held a knife, she began to plan a scenario of picking up Zoe, slamming her on the floor, and slitting her own wrists. At that point Sarah realized that she needed help. She picked up the phone and called Clark. He came home from work immediately, and Sarah told him everything. That is when Clark called me.

Sarah described a “dark side” of her personality, which she had not seen in quite some time. As a child she had a difficult relationship with her mother. They were never close. Her mom abused alcohol and had a terrible temper. Sarah observed her mother’s fits of rage as she would yell and throw whatever was nearby. As Sarah grew up, she began to imitate her mother. Her life was marked by severe fights that would often result in yelling and throwing anything in sight. These incidents had subsided when Sarah became a believer. They vanished completely when she married Clark. “It is so easy being his wife that there has not been a reason to act that way,” she explained. “But now I’m just so confused. I thought I had put this dark side of my personality behind me.”

Clark displayed an obvious tenderness for Sarah which I had witnessed on numerous occasions. Even in our meeting he confessed his love for her several times and had one hand around her shoulders and another on her lap the entire time she talked. Clark obviously loved his wife. Nevertheless, he was a little upset over the angry outbursts Sarah had been directing at him in the last few days. She had never treated him this way, and he didn’t like it. Clark was scared. He had seen the devastating news reports of women who killed their young children, and he was desperate to keep this from happening in his own family.

Sarah was terrified. Though she did not feel a strong bond with her daughter, she did not want to hurt her. She was now rightfully concerned that she might. She loved her husband, but she knew that her anger was damaging their marriage. Sarah looked at me and asked, “Why is this happening? What is wrong with me? What can we do?”

What Is Going on with Clark and Sarah?

This is precisely the kind of problem many pastors and counselors would observe, describe as an extreme case that stands outside the bounds of Scripture, and promptly refer to a secular psychological professional. But in our time together that summer afternoon, I carefully listened to them, and Clark and Sarah gave me all the information essential to understanding what was wrong with them and how to help. The Bible, rightly understood and lovingly lived out, is overflowing with principles to help this couple. Before I expand on the scriptural understanding of the problem and unpack the solution the Bible offers, we need to bear in mind that the biblical understanding has a fierce secular competitor.

The Secular Diagnosis

The American Psychiatric Association identifies Sarah’s problem as a depressive mood disorder with a postpartum onset, or “postpartum depression” (PPD). PPD is reported in 10–13 percent of women and stands as the intermediate diagnosis in a spectrum of postpartum struggles. This disorder (often known as the baby blues) is thought to affect 50–75 percent of women after childbirth. Postpartum psychosis (PP), however, is reported to afflict just a fraction of women. The problems described in a PPD or PP diagnosis are very serious, including high levels of anxiety, marked sadness, insomnia, not feeling connected to the child, thoughts of suicide, and thoughts of harming the baby—all occurring within the first four weeks following delivery. The main difference between PPD and the more extreme PP seems to be the presence of hallucinations.

The psychiatric community believes that problems described in a PPD or PP diagnosis stem from (1) hormonal imbalances occurring in the aftermath of delivery, (2) the harsh life changes required by the entrance of another human being into one’s life, or (3) a previously undiagnosed mental illness. In order to treat the problem, psychologists first seek to rule out organic or biological causes. A number of physical issues, such as hormonal, endocrine, and vitamin deficiencies, may contribute to problems like the one Sarah was experiencing. Finding or ruling out any such problems is a critical first step. Next psychiatrists desire that women diagnosed with PPD or PP begin drug therapy using the same kinds of psychoactive drugs prescribed for other depressive, manic, and obsessive-compulsive problems. Finally, some would recommend a course of electroshock therapy. Thus, after any medical problem is ruled out, some combination of drugs, counseling, and—in rare cases—electric shock would be recommended. Interestingly, although most psychologists believe that hormonal shifts have something to do with PPD/PP experiences, such a view has never been documented. The only hormonal treatments offered are uncommon and experimental.

This thumbnail sketch represents secular psychology’s basic portrait of Sarah and Clark’s problem. The portrait is helpful in at least two major ways. First, it reminds us that Sarah is not unique or alone, and her situation should not come as a shock. Many Christians might be unaware of these more extreme types of problems and may be bewildered when they encounter someone like Sarah, but many secular thinkers have spent hundreds and thousands of hours listening, observing, and working with women just like Sarah. It is not essential to know this material to help Sarah, but the experiences of such persons may supply some missing perspectives.

Second, this research reveals that there is nothing altogether unique about secular psychology’s approach to the problem. Referral to a secular psychiatrist is not a referral to a medical guru with mystical and infinite knowledge about how to fix complex problems. Rather, it is a referral to someone who may have met with and diagnosed other women describing similar problems and will try to find a medical cause. When no medical cause presents itself, this professional will discuss Sarah’s problem with her, experiment with medication that may or may not work, and/or engage in other therapies until the problem has improved.

The question before us is this: Can Christians do a better job of understanding and helping women like Sarah in their difficulties? I firmly believe that we can and that God’s Word tells us exactly how to do so.

Word-Informed, Love-Motivated Ministry to Clark and Sarah

Many Christians would respond to Clark and Sarah’s story with confusion, apprehension, and even horror. Obviously, thoughts of suicide and killing your own baby are serious issues that seem to go against the very nature of a mother’s love. Many people are completely unaware that such a response to a new baby is possible (much less common). Further, many Christians are perplexed by the psychological lingo created by the secular mental health establishment. It is not surprising, therefore, that many would view Sarah’s problem as a difficulty high above the pay grade of Christian ministers. What happens when this becomes the prevailing perspective? This couple is sent to an “expert” who supposedly possesses exclusive resources to help.

As Clark and Sarah shared their difficulties with me, however, they revealed most of the information that a wise and loving Christian—armed with God’s Word—would need to help them. Christians don’t need to be intimidated by technical-sounding labels and drug therapies. God understands this couple’s problem, and he describes both the problem and the solution in his own terms. So the question becomes: How do we take God’s perspective on helping this couple and wisely proceed in the most helpful ways? The rest of the story answers that question.

Candle in the Dark: Starting with Encouragement

Where would you start with Clark and Sarah? After a traumatic story ending with a distraught mother, a kitchen knife, and the momentary temptation to commit infanticide and suicide, Sarah needed me to start with encouragement.

Encouragement might sound like an odd first tactic given the desperate nature of this situation. Two passages of Scripture came to mind, however, as I began to respond to this couple. The first was Matt 7:1–2 where Jesus warns his hearers, “Do not judge, so that you won’t be judged. For with the judgment you use, you will be judged, and with the measure you use, it will be measured to you.” This passage is often misunderstood to mean that Jesus forbad making any judgments at all. Just a few verses later, however, Jesus assumed that Christians will make judgments of some kind as they discern who are “dogs” and “pigs” (v. 6) and who are false and true prophets (vv. 15–20). So what Jesus clearly meant here is that we should avoid judgmental and condemnatory attitudes that are harsh and critical, judgment where we are thinking the worst of someone instead of the best (Luke 6:37–38; 1 Cor 13:7).

Extending a measure of charitable judgment to Clark and Sarah meant that I needed to listen carefully to their story and try to understand how it made sense. People usually feel what they feel and do what they do for reasons that make perfect sense to them. Extending love and grace means listening carefully and trying to understand why people are doing what they are doing (especially those who have an “extreme problem”). Conversely, one displays arrogance in assuming the worst of people, silently accusing them of being kooks and giving up on them as hopeless cases simply because one is not in their situation or presumes that one’s response in the same situation would be different.

The second passage that came to mind was 1 Cor 10:13 where Paul gave a powerful encouragement: “No temptation has overtaken you except what is common to humanity. God is faithful, and He will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation He will also provide a way of escape so that you are able to bear it.” Paul sought to give hope to those struggling with sin and temptation. The hopefulness of Paul’s words rings loud and clear: there is no such thing as a unique struggler. Though people often feel alone in their difficulties, God gives hope to his people by declaring that no one is alone—no matter what we are going through. There is nothing new under the sun (Eccl 1:9–10). These two passages (Matt 7:1–2 and 1 Cor 10:13) collided together with explosive relevance for this couple.

The Bible teaches that Sarah was not alone in her difficulty no matter how extreme her problem. If I did not yet know this truth by experience, I could know it by faith from 1 Cor 10:13. Realizing this fact gave me a new, hope-filled perspective to offer Sarah—the same kind of hope Paul offered the Corinthian church. Sarah was not a solitary struggler, and God would give her the grace to change even in her desperate situation.

As Clark and Sarah finished telling me what they were going through, they each looked at me anxiously. Holding their breath and biting their lips, with furrowed brows and tense eyes, they were searching my face for a look of shock, disbelief, or disdain. They were expecting to hear me say (or see me thinking), “What a mess! You are totally insane and an unfit mother! What kind of crazy are you?” That was the last possible response on my mind. Instead they heard: “Oh Sarah, I am so sorry. It sounds like the last few weeks have been terribly difficult. I want you to know how sorry I am but also how encouraged I am that you came for help. I think we can help.” At this point I opened my Bible to 1 Cor 10:13, read it aloud, and told them that they were not alone in this struggle. Their situation made sense to me, and I knew that God would certainly give them grace to navigate and overcome their problems. I encouraged them that together we would figure out how to lay hold of God’s grace in this situation.

I wish you could have seen their faces. Clark and Sarah were expecting to be viewed as “freaks,” and their demeanor displayed this fear. When I responded with encouragement and comfort, two things happened. First, the pressure in the room deflated. The embarrassment, awkwardness, and discomfort fled. Second, both Clark and Sarah began to cry. Although Sarah had cried earlier, the tears were different now. Previously, her tears had arisen from deep wells of despair and confusion, but now her tears were flowing from relief. Sarah wanted to be a good wife and mother, and now she saw a glimmer of hope that God could alter her previously hopeless situation.

First Things First: Triage in Counseling

With seeds of hope now sown in their hearts, Clark and Sarah needed a path forward. They needed care that rightly prioritized all of the various issues that were on the table.

Sarah was in a desperate physical situation. Two weeks earlier she had been through labor, one of the most physically challenging activities any human can endure. She had not slept more than one or two hours during the last ten days. On top of that, she was trying to figure out—without experience or help—the sophisticated and demanding task of caring for a brand-new baby. Her difficulty was entirely understandable.

The Bible speaks frankly about the importance of our bodies and the role they play in both our physical and spiritual well-being. The Bible teaches that humans exist in a unity of body and soul. For instance, the apostle Paul writes, “Even though our outer person is being destroyed, our inner person is being renewed day by day” (2 Cor 4:16). Again, “An unmarried woman or a virgin is concerned about the things of the Lord, so that she may be holy both in body and in spirit” (1 Cor 7:34). The Scriptures teach in the passages above that persons have two constituent parts that exist in one unique whole; these constituent parts are called the “body” and “spirit” or the “inner person” and the “outer person.” The two elements may be distinguished but cannot ultimately be separated. Both are an essential aspect of a human being. Christians, therefore, should never discount either the spirit or the body. We do not counsel people to overcome their physical distress with some sort of “mind over matter” willpower. Instead, in harmony with Scripture, we take the body seriously. Scripture affirms that people need food (Jas 2:15–16), water (Rom 12:20), and sleep (Eccl 5:12). Paul affirmed the use of medicinal substances for the body (1 Tim 5:23).

The life and ministry of Elijah clearly exemplifies this necessity to care for one’s body. After God defeated the prophets of Baal on Mount Carmel, Elijah’s life was in danger because of his faithfulness to God. He found himself running for his life:

Then Elijah became afraid and immediately ran for his life. When he came to Beer-sheba that belonged to Judah, he left his servant there, but he went on a day’s journey into the wilderness. He sat down under a broom tree and prayed that he might die. He said, “I have had enough! Lord, take my life, for I’m no better than my fathers.” Then he lay down and slept under the broom tree. Suddenly, an angel touched him. The angel told him, “Get up and eat.” Then he looked, and there at his head was a loaf of bread baked over hot stones and a jug of water. So he ate and drank and lay down again. Then the angel of the Lord returned a second time and touched him. He said, “Get up and eat, or the journey will be too much for you.” (1 Kgs 19:3–7)

It is remarkable how much Sarah has in common with Elijah. Elijah had been through a physically and spiritually challenging ordeal—literally running for his life. In fact, his situation was so bad that he wanted to die, and he even asked God to take his life. God would soon teach Elijah some specific lessons too (vv. 9–18), but this was not the time. In this moment God provided for Elijah’s physical needs—sleep, food, and drink. This demonstrates that care for one’s body is a principle endemic to the Scriptures.

What did all of this mean for Sarah? This was not the time for much of anything on her part except for sleep and nourishment. Many issues would need to be addressed with Clark and Sarah as time went on. The only thing I did that afternoon, however, was to explain that other issues could be postponed while we made rest and food Sarah’s priority. I also insisted that Clark make an appointment for Sarah to see her physician as soon as possible. The Bible’s clear teaching on the importance of the body encourages seeking the assistance of trained medical professionals in situations such as this.

After describing all of this to Clark and Sarah, I explained that beginning at that moment, Sarah was off-duty until the next day. This meant that Clark was responsible for dinner that night, caring for Zoe until the next morning, and getting a babysitter for Zoe so we could meet the following day. Being off-duty also meant that Sarah was not allowed to get up with Zoe during the night. That would be Clark’s job. I also asked Clark to take the day off work tomorrow. He needed to be available to help out around the house and to return for another meeting with me. Clark seemed a bit concerned about this request, but I explained that this was an emergency. He needed to take serious and deliberate action to bring relief to this desperate situation.

I framed my instructions to Clark and Sarah in this way because I wanted to guarantee that Sarah would get some much-needed rest. Sarah’s physical recuperation was not my only goal. I did not go into detail about this at that moment, but I wanted Clark to begin serving his wife and daughter. This was not the time to address the issue in a direct way, but I was concerned that for two weeks, in the face of his wife’s mounting exhaustion and increasing irritation, it had not occurred to Clark to help Sarah so she could get some sleep. Giving them basic instructions the way I did helped me begin addressing the issue even before we unpacked it together. Giving Clark responsibility for Zoe also ensured that Sarah would not have the opportunity to harm Zoe if she was tempted again.

After these instructions, we prayed together and set up a time to meet the next morning. I told Clark and Sarah that I would handle everything else.

Surrounded by Love: The Hands and Feet

of the Local Church

Clark and Sarah desperately needed help, and God in his providential care had raised me up to walk with them during their time of need. I was not going to be able to minister to them alone, however. I also would need help. Anticipating events like this one, the Holy Spirit inspired 1 Pet 4:9–11:

Be hospitable to one another without complaining. Based on the gift each one has received, use it to serve others, as good managers of the varied grace of God. If anyone speaks, it should be as one who speaks God’s words; if anyone serves, it should be from the strength God provides, so that God may be glorified through Jesus Christ in everything. To Him belong the glory and the power forever and ever. Amen.

This passage is about the glory of God. God desires to receive glory through Jesus Christ, and the way he gains glory in this passage is through his people’s mutual service to one another. For the apostle Peter, the glory of God is at stake in whether a Christian shows joyful hospitality and performs God-empowered service. For Clark and Sarah the service of the body of Christ was potentially a matter of life and death.

Clark and Sarah needed more than mere talk. They did not need counsel alone but ministry that springs to life in tangible ways. They needed help. In desperate situations like theirs, there is no place for the lifeless faith that wishes someone well while doing nothing practical to assist them (Jas 2:14–17). This was a time for the body of believers to come to the aid of Clark and Sarah.

The first thing I did after Clark and Sarah left my office was to call Sherry, the leader of our church’s care ministry. The care ministry traditionally organized one week of meals for families who had just given birth. Clark and Sarah had already received these meals, but I requested from Sherry that they needed meals for at least another two weeks starting tomorrow. I did not go into details. I simply explained that they were going through a difficult transition and could use some more help. Sherry did not ask a single question but affirmed that she would get right on it and have a meal there the next day. I also asked her to be thinking about some people who would help clean and assist in other ways around the house. Sherry said she knew of some ladies who could help, and she would wait to hear more from me.

The next person I called was my wife, Lauren. I am married to an amazing woman. We have three children, and the Lord has gifted my wife with an amazing and uncanny ability to care for little ones. On countless occasions I have been thankful that my wife always seems to know just what to do with our children. I shared Clark and Sarah’s story with Lauren and asked her to be available over the next couple of days to help out and give Sarah some wisdom as she figured out how to be a new mom. As I anticipated, Lauren was happy to help in any way she could.

After these two important phone calls which mobilized the help of the church, I spent some time in my office praying, going over the notes I had taken during our conversation, and developing a plan for how to help this couple. A number of themes had surfaced that needed attention. In addition to the emergency help that was needed to get Sarah on an even keel mentally, it was necessary to address some doubts that she had expressed about God’s goodness toward her. I knew that I also needed to speak to her fits of anger, among other things.

The next day when Clark and Sarah arrived at my office, Sarah’s improvement was noticeable. After our first meeting they had returned home, and Clark had ordered a pizza. Sarah ate and collapsed into bed. She said she felt relieved to have “permission” to take a break, knowing that Clark was caring for Zoe. She slept for 12 hours. Though she felt somewhat “guilty” for resting so long, she admitted that she felt much better.

I was glad to hear that she had rested well. I explained that it would be wise for them to spend the rest of the week getting stabilized. Some women in the church would provide meals as well as help out around the house when Clark went back to work the next day. I also told them that Lauren was available to help Sarah adjust to motherhood.

Sarah seemed concerned. I could tell she was not comfortable with what I was saying, so I asked her what she was thinking. She said that this was one of the things of which she was afraid. She seemed to see these women’s help as “proof” that she was a parenting failure. “I’m Zoe’s mommy,” she said. “I’m supposed to know how to take care of her, and I don’t. I’m just a bad mother.”

“Sarah, let me read you something,” I responded. I turned to Titus 2:3–5 and read it aloud:

Older women are to be reverent in behavior, not slanderers, not addicted to much wine. They are to teach what is good, so that they may encourage the young women to love their husbands and to love their children, to be self-controlled, pure, homemakers, kind and submissive to their husbands, so that God’s message will not be slandered.

Titus 2:3–5 was powerfully relevant for Sarah. When she protested against offers of help, she was overlooking two fundamental realities. First, she was missing the fact that Paul unashamedly identified two kinds of women: older and more experienced women, and younger and less experienced women. The mature women were to mentor the younger women, and the younger women were to open their minds, hearts, and hands to the practical wisdom of their seasoned older sisters. Sarah’s willingness to receive help from her older sisters in the Lord was not a mark of shame. Rather, her humble acceptance would affirm God’s design and allow for the proper functioning of his redeemed community.

Second, Sarah was overlooking the reality that good mothering is learned. Paul clearly stated that young women need to learn how to love their husbands and their children. Young women need to learn how to be good homemakers. Sarah’s misplaced feelings of guilt grew from frustration that her maternal love had not morphed instantly into maternal skill.

Many women who share Sarah’s struggles possess an overly romanticized view of motherhood. They imagine the gentle cooing and tender caresses of their soft, content baby. They envision the bubbly giggles and waddling first steps of a model toddler. They dream of the Christmas photo with three beaming faces broadcasting to the world a picture of familial perfection. They fail to consider the latching problems, the sleepless nights, the relentless fatigue, and the annoying smell of spit-up caked on two dozen shirts of yet-to-be-done laundry. Not in a million years did they imagine that they might not feel like making dinner on many nights or that they could go five days without a shower due to the tyranny of the urgent. They do not consider that many aspects of motherhood do not come naturally. They do not realize that the deepest joys of mothering and the lasting bond between mother and child are hard-won through days, weeks, and months of steadfast travail with their little one.

As we discussed motherhood from these angles, Sarah was not fully convinced, but she was willing to trust me. Together we developed a plan for Sarah to spend the rest of the week getting adjusted, receiving help from the ladies in the church, talking to Lauren, relying on Clark to help out on some nights, and hearing the results from her doctor’s visit. I would check in with them every day either personally or through Lauren, and the three of us would sit down together in a week unless we needed to do so earlier.

The rest of the week progressed well. Families in our church provided abundant food each day. Sherry, the director of the care ministry, volunteered as an extra set of hands the first day Clark returned to work. She cleaned dishes, washed clothes, and bottle-fed Zoe while Sarah napped in the afternoon. Most importantly, she and Sarah sat and talked while Zoe slept, and Sarah began confiding in Sherry about all that had been happening. Sherry listened and responded graciously. It was the beginning of a close relationship.

Lauren also began to help Sarah get Zoe on a basic schedule. The purpose of the schedule was not to enslave Sarah but to serve her. Sarah began to see how helpful her new schedule could be because it helped her rule out options when Zoe was crying. For instance, if Zoe had just eaten well but had not slept at all, Sarah could know that it was her naptime. The schedule added some predictability to a normally chaotic time.

Lauren also told Sarah to call anytime she had questions or was upset. One afternoon Sarah called in tears. Zoe had slept well that morning and had eaten a full bottle, but she still would not stop crying. Sarah was not “freaking out” like before, but she was at her wit’s end and didn’t know what to do. After some investigative conversation, Lauren suggested that Sarah lay Zoe on the floor and alternately push her legs up to her chest and then stretch them back down. Shortly after starting these exercises, Zoe began passing gas and stopped crying. Sarah joked that flatulence never brought such relief to a mother!

By the time the next week rolled around, I found myself sitting in my office talking with a different couple. Sarah had not thought about harming herself or her baby since the afternoon of our first meeting. Naturally, she was still fairly stressed out, but her confidence that she could grow into a good mom was increasing. She was thankful for the friendships she was developing with Lauren and Sherry. Both she and Clark were each overwhelmed with gratitude for the cooking, cleaning, and counseling they had received from so many in the church. They were each tired, but neither was exhausted. Both felt encouraged that they were making progress.

In only a week God had showered his grace on Clark and Sarah, and they had come a long way. Their journey was not finished, however. There was more work to be done. There were still areas we needed to discuss to build on the good gains of their grace-filled first week.

Struck Down but Not Destroyed: Rejoicing in Suffering

Zoe’s birth had brought a unique blend of joy and turmoil into their lives. Much of this turmoil was simply due to their natural lack of knowledge about caring for a new child and the stress that attends this great responsibility. Much of the turmoil was related to Sarah’s physical condition. She needed food and sleep, and she had a deficit of both during the early days after Zoe’s birth.

Sarah’s challenges were not only relegated to circumstantial and physical issues. She was not merely an organism that required food and sleep for proper functioning. As her pastor, I was not merely a life-coach providing tips on how to care for infants. Sarah was a human in desperate need of an encounter with Jesus Christ, her King and Savior. I was a minister of the gospel of Jesus with a divine mandate to preach the gospel of grace to her in the context of our personal relationship. This means that if all I did was make sure she napped at the right times and received some guidance regarding infant care, I would have failed. Even if she stopped contemplating harming herself and her baby, such “counsel” would be incomplete.

Helping Sarah encounter her Savior meant at least two things in this situation. First, she needed help in understanding how Jesus wanted her to process her suffering. Second, she needed help in understanding how Jesus wanted to deal with her sin. We started with suffering.

Sarah was legitimately suffering in the aftermath of her daughter’s birth. The significant challenges she was facing were causing her to ask significant questions about God. Sarah was wondering why God would do this to her—how he could possibly care in light of all he was allowing her to go through. Sarah’s questions were not the fiery questions of a rebellious teenager shaking an angry fist in the air. Hers were the questions of an injured toddler who was feeling pain. She simply did not know where it was coming from or why it hurt so much. Sarah needed the reminder that, by the grace of Jesus, God was up to something good in this difficult time she faced.

To see this reminder, one of the many passages we looked at together was Rom 5:1–5:

Therefore, since we have been declared righteous by faith, we have peace with God through our Lord Jesus Christ. We have also obtained access through Him by faith into this grace in which we stand, and we rejoice in the hope of the glory of God. And not only that, but we also rejoice in our afflictions, because we know that affliction produces endurance, endurance produces proven character, and proven character produces hope. This hope does not disappoint us, because God’s love has been poured out in our hearts through the Holy Spirit who was given to us.

Paul declared that because we have been justified by faith in Christ, we can rejoice in the hope of the glory of God as well as in our sufferings. Paul’s perspective is astounding. We can all agree that Sarah should rejoice in the positive hope of the glory of God, but urging her to rejoice in her negative sufferings is so shocking it’s almost offensive. How could I help Sarah make sense of this divine exhortation?

I began by clarifying that Sarah was not called to rejoice at the suffering but to rejoice in the suffering. This distinction is essential. In other words, we are not called to rejoice at suffering in and of itself. Suffering is bad, suffering is hard, and suffering often comes at the hands of wicked people (though not in Sarah’s case). Therefore, we do not rejoice in suffering because we love the suffering in and of itself. We rejoice in suffering because we look forward to what God is able to do through our suffering. Paul celebrated the fact that through our sufferings and afflictions God is bringing about endurance, proven character, and hope.

This progression may sound strange. It makes sense that suffering would produce endurance. When a person bears up under burdens and challenges, endurance is a natural result. It also makes sense that endurance would produce proven character. When people learn to endure through trials and hardships, it bolsters their strength of spirit. It may seem less reasonable, however, that proven character would lead to hope. How can proven character lead to a kind of hope that does not disappoint (v. 5)? This question is answered in verse 2 when we see what kind of hope Paul is talking about. It is the hope of the glory of God.

The hope in Romans 5 is not the hope that we will someday escape our sufferings (though Romans 8 teaches this truth). The hope in Romans 5 is that our sufferings will lead to God’s being glorified. When God gives Sarah the strength to endure and graciously forges proven character in her through her afflictions, he gains glory for himself. This promise had the power to produce great hope in Sarah.

For this to work, Sarah must realize that her life and her situation were not ultimately about her but about her Lord. God was writing a redemptive story with her life in order to gain glory for himself. Because Jesus understood this, he taught his followers, “Let your light shine before men, so that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father in heaven” (Matt 5:16, emphasis added). Our lives and our works are not ultimately about gaining glory for ourselves but for our Father in heaven.

Clark, Sarah, and I sat together for weeks discussing these themes. We spent hours contemplating the comforting presence of Christ in our difficulties. We dwelt for a long time on the goodness of God in trials. We talked often about how Sarah could learn to view her times of difficulty as opportunities to trust the gentle grace of Jesus who was working to make her like himself (even in her hardest days), all for the purpose of blessing her and honoring his name. Sarah learned that she could call out to God in her darkest moments and receive timely help (Ps 46:1). She learned that she needed to start judging the degree of her blessedness not by the ease and comfort she might be experiencing at any given moment but by the degree to which she was being conformed to the likeness of Christ. Sarah began to gain confidence in the Lord’s care for her, and she was emboldened as she realized that this intense season of difficulty was not a horrible interruption in her life. Rather, it was a prime example of God’s gracious commitment to make her more like Christ and bring himself glory.

The Enemy Within: Fighting Against Sin

After a couple of weeks, as Sarah was more rested and had more confidence as a mother, she was increasingly encouraged about God’s love and care for her in the midst of her trial. It was now time to address another area where Clark and Sarah needed to encounter Christ. Until now we had been addressing Sarah’s physical needs and equipping her for motherhood along with providing spiritual comfort. I now needed to shift to another area—the ways in which Clark and Sarah had each sinned against God and against each other in their situation.

Sarah was not guilty of sin because she did not have mothering down pat or because she was sleep deprived and physically weakened, but there were aspects of Sarah’s response to her suffering that needed to change. When the biblical authors talk about change in the area of sin, they speak of confession and repentance. First John 1:7–9 reads,

If we walk in the light as He Himself is in the light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus His Son cleanses us from all sin. If we say, “We have no sin,” we are deceiving ourselves, and the truth is not in us. If we confess our sins, He is faithful and righteous to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.

The apostle John taught that walking in the light does not mean enjoying a sin-free existence. Rather, walking in the light means that we confess the sins we are sure to commit. John also said that when we confess those sins we will be forgiven because God is a faithful and righteous God who will never fail to accept Jesus’ payment for sin.

Someone like Sarah can find great encouragement here as she deals with her sin. Forgiveness is guaranteed for those who are trusting in Christ. They only need to walk in the light and confess their sins. The same logic is seen in the promise of Jas 4:6, “God resists the proud, but gives grace to the humble.” If Clark and Sarah were to know the forgiving grace of Jesus, humble confession and repentance were the steps to freedom.

There were definitely specific areas where Sarah needed to pursue confession and repentance of sin. One area was her responses of sinful anger toward Clark and Zoe. Yes, Sarah had been stressed and fatigued, but the Bible teaches that sinful anger is a spiritual problem before it is an emotional or physical issue (Mark 7:20–23; Gal 5:19–21; Jas 4:1–2). Even in a physically weakened condition, it is possible for Christians empowered by the Holy Spirit to respond to their physical trials with faith, hope, and love (Rom 8:9–11; 1 Cor 13:4–7; Gal 5:22–26). This reality was as true for Sarah as for anyone else. Sarah began to realize that she had never dealt with the patterns of anger she learned in childhood. Instead, they had just gone dormant. When she was living with her mother, Sarah’s anger would constantly flare up. While living with Clark, her external circumstances had changed, and the temptation had abated. Now that her temptation had returned, the sinful disposition of her heart reared its ugly head and revealed her need to repent.

As Sarah began the process of confessing her sin to God, to Clark, and even to Zoe (why not?), Jesus began to expose in her heart other patterns of pride and selfishness. Sarah came to realize that she had waited far too long to seek help because of her pride. Sarah had not wanted to admit that she needed assistance, advice, mentoring, or even a listening ear. She was reluctant for anyone to know that there were significant areas of ignorance in her life when it came to motherhood.

Sarah, like many mothers, wanted everyone to think that she was the perfect mom with the perfect family. She began to recognize that much of her physical suffering was the result of her own pride that refused to admit weakness or ask for help. Sarah began to repent of this pride, and the fruit of her repentance grew ripe as she began to request and accept help from our church.

Yet Sarah was not the only one who needed to draw near to Christ in a humble process of confession and turning from sin. Clark also had his problems. Clark and Sarah had a solid marriage, but Zoe’s birth had exposed patterns of selfishness for both of them.

It was strange to me that Sarah’s distress had to reach emergency status before Clark got involved. During one of our times together, I shared my concern. “You know, Clark, I wonder how you missed all of Sarah’s struggling going on right under your nose?” This question cut Clark to the core. He was deeply broken and began to see and confess his own selfishness. Without much thought, he had assumed that Zoe was exclusively Sarah’s responsibility. Whenever he heard Zoe crying, he expected Sarah to handle the situation. At night he thought only about getting to bed himself so he would feel ready for work the next day. After all, he reflected, “I assumed that since Sarah was staying home, she could take a nap whenever she wanted.” When Clark noticed that Sarah seemed sad and distressed, he simply assumed that this phase would pass and made no real effort to understand or resolve the problem. Clark was now realizing that his presumptuous behavior was recklessly selfish and unloving (1 Cor 13:5). Clark humbly sought forgiveness from God and Sarah for his culpable thoughtlessness.

As the weeks and months progressed, I met with Clark and Sarah less and less until finally we were not meeting regularly for “counseling” at all. During this time each of them was growing first and foremost in their trust in God and their walk with Jesus. They were also growing in their facility as parents, in their love for each other, and in their connection to their church body who continued to serve them well. The willingness to accept ministry from others was a huge change for this couple who had been in the habit of serving but not being served. This role reversal was necessary and humbling, and later it would help them return to their serving roles with a new love for those who had walked with them so faithfully. My time with this couple turned out to be a remarkable demonstration of the power of Jesus as he showered them with grace and life, perspective and perseverance in suffering, escape from sinful ruts, practical maturity in parenting, and vibrant connections among their brothers and sisters in our local church.

Conclusion

Are you equipped to help a young woman wrestling with thoughts of killing her baby and herself? As I have tried to demonstrate, I believe Christians are equipped to help in this way, but the great concern of my ministry is that many Christians never even would have tried to help Sarah and Clark. Most Christians would have dropped their jaws at one of Sarah’s siren phrases like “kill my baby” or “cut my wrists” and would have immediately passed this couple off to a secular professional. I understand that. Such phrases are alarming.

Having noted that, I really believe the key to Clark and Sarah is found in Jas 1:19, “My dearly loved brothers, understand this: everyone must be quick to hear, slow to speak.” The principle of this verse is that we should listen first and speak last. Many Christians would encounter Clark and Sarah and be too quick to say, “I can’t help.” Look back at the story of Clark and Sarah. When you take time and listen well, Sarah’s extreme problem becomes understandable. When you push past the scary headlines and read the details of the story, the frightening buzzwords give way to understandable themes: rest, nutrition, practice in acquiring skills, and—most importantly—Jesus’ power to slay sin and bring solace in suffering.

One of my aims in describing my relationship with Clark and Sarah is to demonstrate how a big and frightening problem can actually become manageable when you take the time to listen carefully and commit to help. “Manageable” does not mean easy. Problems that require in-depth counseling are never easy. Rather, “manageable” means that with Scripture, wisdom, and thoughtful input from other Christians, you can handle each situation by God’s grace. I pray that meeting Clark and Sarah encourages you to accept that with your eyes open to Scripture and your ears attentive to the situational struggles of people, you can minister real help even in a hard case like this one.

I have worked with several couples who had struggles similar to the story told here. This case study combines details of these different situations. None of the identifying information in this chapter matches that of the real persons involved.

Clomid is an ovulatory stimulant used to induce egg production in women.

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-IV-TR (Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association, 2000), 386. “Postpartum” refers to the period following childbirth, so postpartum depression refers to the intense sadness women sometimes experience at this time.

Michael W. O’Hara and Annette M. Swain, “Rates and risks of postpartum depression—A meta-analysis,” International Review of Psychiatry 8, no. 1 (1996): 37–54.

Michael W. O’Hara, Janet Schlechte, David A. Lewis, et al., “Controlled Prospective Study of Postpartum Mood Disorders: Psychological, Environmental, and Hormonal Variables,” Journal of Abnormal Psychology 100, no. 1 (1991): 63–73.

DSM-IV-TR, 386.

Dorothy Sit, Anthony Rothschild, Katherine Wisner, et al., “A Review of Postpartum Psychosis,” Journal of Women’s Health 15, no. 4 (May 2006): 352–68.

Paul Reed, Nicola Sermin, Louis Appleby, et. al., “A Comparison of Clinical Response to Electroconvulsive Therapy in Puerperal and Non-Puerperal Psychoses,” Journal of Affective Disorders 54, no. 3 (Aug 1999): 255–60.

Deborah A. Sichel, Lee S. Cohen, Laura M. Robertson, et al., “Prophylactic Estrogen in Recurrent Postpartum Affective Disorder,” Biological Psychiatry 38, no. 12 (1995): 814–18; Channi Kumar, Ronan McIvor, Tony Davie, et al., “Estrogen Administration Does not Reduce the Rate of Recurrence of Affective Psychosis after Childbirth,” The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 64, no. 2 (2003): 112–18; Thomas Insel, “Spotlight on Postpartum Depression,” NIMH [online] October 28, 2010 [cited December 2010]. Available from the Internet: www.nimh.nih.gov.

Even though body and soul are separated at death, the scriptural expectation is that they will be reunited forever at the return of Jesus Christ (see 1 Cor 15:12–58).

Sarah did go to see her OB/GYN the next day; but unfortunately, the visit did not go well. There are medical tests that might have been performed, but her physician performed none of them. After asking her a few questions, her doctor insisted that Sarah seek psychiatric help. He informed her that he would check up on her in coming days, and if she had not contacted a counselor in the next day or so, he would be forced to report her to Child Protective Services. Thankfully, he was satisfied when they informed him that they were already meeting with a counselor, and they never heard from him again. I have heard similar stories from numerous families I have counseled. In one particularly unfortunate situation, a physician had a young woman placed in a psychiatric hospital after merely reading her answers on a questionnaire. I was deeply disappointed that this highly trained professional failed to provide us with the benefit of his medical expertise—which is what we needed from him. I say this not to insinuate that such responses from professional medical personnel are normal; I hope they are not. However, I say it to encourage women who are experiencing similar difficulties to avoid merely reporting their situation to their physician. In such instances a couple should demand that their medical providers administer physical exams and appropriate laboratory testing to rule out any organic causes for their problems.

Clark and Sarah had made the decision to bottle-feed Zoe, but in some instances a mother might have to remain available to feed or pump.

Clark and Sarah worked on a number of issues between sessions as well. They each practiced confessing and forgiving their sins to each other. They also worked together to develop a list of clear responsibilities for each of them so that neither would assume that a particular task was the other person’s responsibility. They also read Robert D. Jones’s book Uprooting Anger: Biblical Help for a Common Problem (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 2005). We discussed this book in order to help Sarah respond in the power of the gospel whenever she was tempted toward anger.

↑ Back to top

↑