Chapter 3 of 16

Chapter 2: “Mariana” and Surviving Sexual Abuse

Chapter 2: “Mariana” and Surviving Sexual Abuse

Chapter 2

“Mariana” and Surviving Sexual Abuse

Laura Hendrickson

Mariana’s Story

Mariana was a 45-year-old married woman with a history of severe sexual abuse in childhood who had received psychotherapy for dissociative identity disorder (DID) for 20 years. She had also been diagnosed with bipolar disorder when her pastor referred her to the Institute for Biblical Counseling and Discipleship (IBCD). Although Mariana was still taking an antidepressant and two mood-stabilizing medicines, she had stopped her psychotherapy for DID and had been counseled by her pastor for two years prior to coming to IBCD. Mariana was the third of six children born into an intact middle- class family. Her parents told the family repeatedly that Mariana was not her father’s biological daughter but that she was the product of the rape of her mother by Mariana’s paternal grandfather. Mariana also was told that her mother refused to bring her home from the hospital after her birth. Her Aunt Sophia, her father’s sister-in-law, took her home and named her. Mariana was returned to her parents’ home while still an infant, but her mother never accepted her.

Mariana’s father, an alcoholic, molested her for the first time when she was four years old. This abuse continued regularly over the next few years while her father continued his sexual relationship with his wife, who gave birth to other children. After a vicious fight between her parents when she was about seven, Mariana was given by her mother to her father to service him sexually. From this point on, Mariana and her father shared a bedroom while her mother slept with Mariana’s sisters. The family moved frequently from town to town to conceal the dark secret.

Mariana’s mother physically and verbally abused her. Mariana was neglected, stripped naked, and then beaten, locked in closets, and deprived of food. At Christmas she would receive no gifts. Her mother told her that she was evil, that God hated her, and she forbade her to pray or read a Bible. However, Aunt Sophia was sometimes able to take her to church. Mariana recalls loving Jesus from early childhood and experiencing his presence and comfort while being molested and abused. But because her mother taught her that God required perfection and punished harshly for disobedience, she internalized a legalistic worldview ruled by a harsh deity void of grace. Aunt Sophia moved with her children back to her native South America when Mariana was about 10, taking with her the only loving relationship Mariana would experience until her marriage.

In her adolescent years Mariana started cutting, turned to anorexic and bulimic behaviors, and struggled with depression. She eventually ran away from home to attend college, but she found it difficult as she struggled with an intense sense of shame and unworthiness. She habitually stayed awake all night to avoid having nightmares in a room with others and avoided showering or dressing in anyone’s presence.

While in college Mariana met her future husband, Leon, and began living with him. He suggested that she would not be so fearful and ashamed if they were married. She agreed although she feared that he would hurt her as her father did. In spite of her fears, the two were married. Soon they decided to have children.

Mariana called her mother in desperation when her firstborn daughter was four months old, asking how to make her child stop crying. Her mother exclaimed incredulously, “She’s four months old and still crying? Put a pillow over her face until she stops. You’ll only have to do it a few times, and she’ll learn.” This triggered an overwhelming flood of memories of childhood abuse. At this time Mariana began to fear that her husband would hurt their daughter, and she became verbally abusive toward him. She decided to address her own history of abuse with her parents, but her attempts over the next few years were unsuccessful. She cut off contact with them. When our counseling relationship began, Mariana had not spoken with her parents in 20 years.

In God’s providence a Christian couple named Julie and Pete came into Mariana and Leon’s lives. This couple built a strong relationship with Mariana and Leon and shared the gospel with them. Mariana and Leon both believed and entered, for the first time, a vital relationship with Christ. Julie was burdened to help Mariana with her emotional problems, so she brought her to their church’s deliverance ministry where they tried healing services and exorcism.

Mariana also saw multiple licensed professional Christian counselors. One of them told Leon that she was a pathological liar who could never be an adequate wife and mother because her own mother was “psychotic.” This female professional encouraged Leon to divorce Mariana, seek custody of the children, and keep them away from their mother. Others hypnotized Mariana and told her that she had multiple personalities, an idea she had not considered prior to counseling.

Mariana began experiencing flashbacks, vivid reexperiences of earlier abuse. Nightmares were constant. She engaged in self-mutilation, attempted suicide, and was repeatedly hospitalized. Over time Leon became concerned that her helpers, although licensed counselors, might not be competent. He insisted that she see a psychiatrist through their health maintenance organization (HMO).

Mariana spent the next several years under the care of Dr. Ergenbreit, who diagnosed her with DID (dissociative identity disorder was then known as multiple personality disorder). He hypnotized her, placed her on psychotropic medicines, and held psychotherapy sessions to talk with the various personalities he identified. Mariana’s life became even more chaotic. She required hospitalization and numerous extra therapy sessions to help her deal with her increasingly turbulent emotions. Dr. Ergenbreit told her that he could not perform all the therapy she needed, so he referred her to another Christian therapist who also hypnotized her. While seeing this therapist, Mariana began “remembering” things that she’s now quite sure never happened, such as murdering two children born from her relationship with her father and being the subject of bizarre satanic rituals.

Soon she transitioned to Dr. Freeman, a Christian psychologist who had published a book on multiple personalities and satanic ritual abuse. She met with him as often as three times a week for about eight years. His treatment was a collage of late twentieth-century therapeutic fads. He hypnotized her and led her through “healing of the memories” where she was encouraged to recall every detail of her abuse while visualizing Jesus as present to comfort her. She describes the vivid process initiated by Dr. Freeman as 10 times more painful than the initial abuse. His “overlay” of Jesus onto her memories never rang true to her. Ironically, she shared with Dr. Freeman that she had experienced Jesus’ comforting presence during her abuse as a child. He told her that was not really Jesus but an effect of her disorder.

Although Mariana was instructed to suppress her other personalities except during therapy, she began experiencing numerous episodes in everyday life where “they took over,” something that had never happened before the therapy began. Over time these alter egos became more and more distinct from Mariana herself, each having its own name, likes and dislikes, tone of voice, style of dress, and even handwriting. She was ultimately diagnosed with 35 personalities, and Dr. Freeman created a chart describing their characteristics and relationship to one another.

Mariana was encouraged to let “them” emerge in therapy so each one could talk to Dr. Freeman (often repeatedly) about the traumas they experienced. Two or three of them were sometimes asked to discuss an event together since many of them supposedly had overlapping memories. This approach resulted in Mariana’s painfully reliving each memory many hundreds of times. Not surprisingly, she descended into yet more emotional deterioration marked by wild mood swings and constant crises. She had been assured that she would get worse before she got better, so she continued with the therapy.

Eventually Dr. Ergenbreit, who had performed hypnosis sessions and monitored Mariana’s antidepressant treatments for several years, left her HMO. Her care was assigned to Dr. Zimmer, who later diagnosed her with bipolar disorder and prescribed additional medications. As Dr. Zimmer learned more about Dr. Freeman’s treatment, he tried to persuade Mariana to stop seeing him. In turn Dr. Freeman believed that Mariana’s medicines were interfering with his psychotherapy, and he urged her to stop seeing Dr. Zimmer. Mariana continued to see both of them because the medicines blunted her emotions, and she maintained hope that her therapy would eventually bring a long-awaited cure.

Either her husband, Leon, or her friend, Julie, attended every session Mariana had with Dr. Freeman. Leon was asked to give his wife the freedom to work full-time on her traumas by relieving her of her household responsibilities, and he did so. Rather than helping her, however, this loss of responsibility produced even more deterioration in Mariana’s emotions and behavior. Ultimately she was unable to enter her own kitchen without experiencing flashbacks of abuse by her mother, and she was unable to shower without reexperiencing her father’s rapes. She stayed out of the kitchen and stopped bathing.

Dr. Freeman next told her that she needed to experience having a happy childhood with a good mother, so with Leon’s concurrence Mariana left him and their three children to move in with Julie and Pete. Together this new “family” reenacted Mariana’s childhood, starting from infancy, with Julie as her “good mother.” Mariana recalls tea parties, playing dress-up, and calling Julie “Mommy.”

Four months later Leon was no longer on board. He gave Mariana an ultimatum: Either she came home or their marriage was over. She returned home, but the turbulence continued. She struggled with her roles as wife and mother, never took up her household responsibilities again, and continued to have numerous flashbacks and emotional crises.

After she attempted suicide again and was confined to a psychiatric hospital for six weeks, her pastor visited her and offered biblical hope that she could change. He urged her to give up her therapy with Dr. Freeman, and she followed his advice. This pastor counseled Mariana for two years, telling her that her problem was not that she had a mental illness but that she had made sinful, selfish choices. He held a family meeting and emphasized to Leon and their children that Mariana was not sick but sinful. As a result the family became angry toward Mariana, and she became angry with God, languishing in guilt and shame. It seemed that all avenues of help had been fully exhausted, and Mariana lost hope. As the counseling stalemated, her pastor referred her to IBCD, where she met with two different female counselors prior to meeting with me.

Counseling Mariana

During the course of our formal counseling relationship, Mariana and I met together 58 times. This number of sessions is not typical and would become overbearing in other, simpler cases. The innumerable thorny strands, however, woven through Mariana’s story were embedded in her heart and wrapped around her soul; the wounds, inflicted both by others and by herself, were jagged and deep. Patiently cutting through this web with God’s Word and carefully applying the balm of his promises would require significant time and substantial patience from both of us. After our conversations I was convinced that Mariana was a believer, but she never received any instruction on how to live out her life as a Christian in a way that glorified Christ. It was a privilege to take the long road with her and help her in this regard.

Because of our abundance of conversations together, the counseling process is best shared by arranging the material chronologically and thematically instead of describing each individual meeting. Each major issue was discussed many times in counseling as new information emerged or new challenges arose.

Getting to the Truth

At our first session, Mariana told me that she had a problem with lying. She had been labeled a liar since childhood. She confessed that she was not even sure that everything she told me about her past had actually happened. Although she had always remembered having been molested and abused, some of her memories emerged as the result of hypnosis and other interventions.

Because she had been accused of lying by previous counselors, I wondered whether Mariana raised this subject at our first session to see how I would respond. I decided that since love thinks the best (1 Cor 13:7), I would presume that Mariana was telling me the truth in the absence of contrary evidence. I informed her that memories recovered under hypnosis are often unreliable or completely false but that the truth would probably become clearer to her as we worked together. I emphasized that I viewed my role as coming alongside her as a sister in the Lord, not as an omniscient counselor who could discern truth from falsehood. Although I could not tell her whether she had believed lies about her past, I could help her address the lying she knew she was doing in the present.

Many survivors of abuse are habitual liars because they were raised in families where dishonesty was a normal part of life. They have learned to use deceit to protect themselves. I asked Mariana why she thought she lied. “Because I don’t know what’s true anymore,” was her poignant response. Mariana also wondered whether this type of deception was really lying since she believed what she was saying at the moment she said it.

I told her that although her lying had become so natural that it seemed almost automatic, it really was still lying. Since Christ calls us to walk in the truth, breaking this habit was not optional for her. Mariana had to acknowledge that such deceit is sinful (Prov 28:13). This would mean taking responsibility for her deceptions and confessing her sin—agreeing with God that she truly had a choice about whether to lie.

This truth was the first expression of a theme we returned to repeatedly: Even though a sinful behavior may be practiced for so long that it feels involuntary, if we acknowledge it as a sin, repent of it, and ask for grace, the Lord will enable us to cast it away and clothe ourselves with the corresponding virtue (Eph 4:22–32). I balanced this principle with the complementary truth that her gracious Savior understood how difficult it would be to break a habit that had dominated her since childhood. He would be patient with her and would give her as much grace as she needed (1 Cor 10:13).

Making the Cross Central to Her Life Story

Like most abuse survivors, Mariana struggled with guilt and shame. As a coping mechanism, she had come to see her lying as an involuntary symptom of her mental illness. This perspective helped her endure the shame she felt for her many failures because seeing her lying as involuntary meant that her deceptions were not her fault. Such a self-deceiving perspective did not give Mariana the clear conscience she was longing for.

I told Mariana that her real problem was not mental illness but an inadequate understanding of what Christ had accomplished on her behalf through his sinless life and substitutionary death. She did not have to continue struggling with guilt over her failures because she had already been declared not guilty through Christ’s atoning sacrifice. She needed the truths expounded in Romans 6–8, truths which provide freedom from the guilt of sin and offer a divine source of power for battling ongoing temptation.

The worldview Mariana had learned from her previous counselors had done just the opposite—it defined her by the trauma she had experienced, reinforced her victimhood, and limited her perception of her power to change. Cutting hard against the grain of past counsel she had received, I told her that to understand the events of her life she needed to place Christ’s death at the center of her story.

Drawing a time line to represent her life, I added a cross on the line, corresponding to the time she came to faith. I pointed out that when God forgave her and raised her to new life in Christ, her earthly life had divided into two parts—the old life and the new (Rom 6:2–11). Formerly she was powerless to stop sinning because she was enslaved to sin and loved her sin, but now she did not have to sin any more (Rom 6:12–14). God’s Word said that she had a choice.

Jerry Bridges’s book The Gospel for Real Life amplifies this theme as it richly illustrates how the redemption and restoration found in Jesus Christ intersect with everyday life. I asked Mariana to read this book with me so that she could soak herself in the truth that she was completely forgiven and cleansed. We worked through this book together for our first 20 sessions, utilizing the discussion questions to apply the book’s principles directly to Mariana’s own struggles. At the same time Mariana was intensively studying and meditating on Romans 6–8 in order to marinate her mind in the realities that she had been declared righteous by faith. She once was dead but is now alive. Her life had not been tweaked but transformed. She could now present herself to the Lord for obedience through his powerful grace.

Learning to Trust

By the mercy of God, Mariana began to respond vigorously—though somewhat legalistically—to my counsel. She contacted Julie, her “good mother” during her 20 years of psychotherapy, and confessed numerous lies. She also told Julie that she would not be continuing the “mother-daughter” relationship with her because she did not want to continue relating to Julie as a sick little girl.

I had not yet broached the topic of Mariana’s simulated relationship with Julie. Breaking it off had been Mariana’s own idea, but I did not argue with her. I would not have advised making a radical break like this so early in counseling, but since she had already taken the step, I tried to help her deal with the feelings engendered by cutting the cord with Julie.

Although she had acted boldly, Mariana soon was expressing fear that God was “stripping” her by removing some of her supports such as her make-believe relationship with Julie. If jettisoning relationships that had previously brought her comfort was the path of restoration, Mariana feared that she would be left with nothing. I encouraged her to trust the gentle Savior who will not break a bruised reed or put out a smoldering wick (Isa 42:3). I also pointed out that abuse survivors struggling with shame often feel that they are stripped, naked, and exposed. Reminding her that God does not strip us when we turn from our sin at salvation, the exact opposite truth—that he clothes us with Christ’s righteousness (Rev 7:13–17)—brought some helpful correction here to her thoughts and emotions. I offered Ezek 16:1–13 as an additional picture of how God clothes the unwanted and the unlovely (though I strongly cautioned Mariana not to read any further than v. 13 since the overall chapter was addressed to apostate Israel and not to faithful Christians). This became the first iteration of another major theme in counseling: Those who trust in Christ will not be put to shame (Rom 5:3–5; 10:11).

From a different angle I emphasized to Mariana that she had never needed a human “good mother” to help her recover from the evil that was done to her because God is her Father who had loved her and adopted her (Rom 8:15–17). Despite growing up in an abusive and unloving family, her restoration and stability in the present were not dependent on simulating a new earthly family. The fatherly care of her gentle and gracious God would be enough for her.

I also cautioned Mariana that she could not sanctify herself. Rather, she needed to trust Christ to sanctify her in his own time (1 Thess 5:23–24). Mariana objected that she did not like the idea of surrendering control to the Lord; and although control became an issue that we returned to repeatedly over the coming weeks and months, I decided not to address it too strongly at this early stage in our relationship. Instead, I encouraged Mariana simply to tell Jesus how she felt and trust that he would give her the grace she needed.

Trust can be quite difficult to learn, especially for someone with Mariana’s devastating past and long-standing patterns. Soon after we began talking about the issue of control, Mariana called me in hysterics, complaining of fear and uncontrollable mood swings. She told me that she was afraid I would lock her in the closet naked, something her mother used to do to her. It sounded like she was starting to view me as her new “mother,” so I reminded her of her recent decision to give up her simulated “good mother” Julie. As much as I wanted to reassure Mariana at that moment that I would never hurt her, I deliberately pointed her to the Lord rather than to my own reliability as her source of safety. I reminded her that she could apply the principles she was learning in counseling to what was troubling her as she looked to the Lord in prayer. I ended the conversation fairly quickly and prayed with her that she would look to him as her loving heavenly Father when she was afraid.

Mariana later wrote me a poem about this incident. She explained to me that she had fallen apart emotionally because she was overwhelmed by the hope that my counsel had engendered in her. Tellingly, she also referred to herself in the poem as “we.” The poem said that “everyone” had wanted to tell his or her stories to me, and this thought overwhelmed her. We talked about the feeling that there were many people inside of her, and I reminded her that although this was a powerful metaphor that captured her emotional pain, the Bible tells us always and everywhere that we are one person, not many personalities in one body. I continued to address my counsel solely to her as a whole person and never asked her to manifest any of her “alters.” Over time she abandoned the use of this metaphor to describe her internal state. Today Mariana says that she never had multiple personalities until they were “discovered” through hypnosis.

Confronting Seemingly Involuntary Phenomena

Mariana told me she understood that she did not have a mental illness, but she wondered why she was experiencing seemingly involuntary phenomena. As she began to fall asleep, she felt a spinning and falling sensation, saw flashing lights, re-experienced abuse, and became hysterical. This typically lasted several hours every Saturday night and required Leon’s intensive involvement to calm her down. She mentioned that her father had often raped her on Saturday night. This was also when her mother often abused her.

I wondered whether Mariana feared losing control as she surrendered herself to sleep (the desire to remain in control is common among survivors of abuse). This fear of losing control made sense to Mariana. I reminded her that Christ is always in control and he takes care of her even while she is sleeping (Ps 4:8). She would need to remind herself of this truth when she began to feel afraid. Even though these fearful sensations seemed to originate outside of her, they always occurred at a predictable time on Saturdays, so it seemed unlikely that these were truly random, involuntary events. Regardless of their source, Mariana’s challenge and calling were the same. God was summoning her to look to Christ in faith and to seek the calmness that comes from trusting him rather than surrendering to her emotions.

Mariana added that Leon would usually read Psalm 23 to her during these distressful times. These readings had a calming effect, but only after a couple hours of hysteria. I encouraged her that she could actually decide to calm down more quickly and to ask Leon to turn to the Bible first rather than bringing it out as a last resort. These seemingly involuntary experiences became less overwhelming and continued to end more quickly as Mariana and Leon adjusted their responses. After a few weeks, Mariana no longer experienced the terrible sensations. She admits that remnants of this behavior can still emerge today under severe stress (which is not surprising), but she is now able to deal with them on her own.

Shame, Fear of Man, and Pride

In a subsequent session Mariana visibly shook with fear as she demanded to discuss a subject of her own choosing. I had not observed this combination of fear and aggression previously. Rather than immediately asking her what she wanted to talk about, I asked her why she was shaking. She answered that she was afraid and ashamed. Her fear reminded me of the time when she was afraid I would lock her in the closet naked. I wondered whether she was experiencing a similar fear now. She replied that she was. Although she told me she did not believe that I would hurt her, she did admit (when I asked) that she had been visualizing me doing bad things to her prior to the session.

I encouraged her not to visualize or believe things she knew were untrue. I also told her that she could respond to frightening images like these by speaking truth to herself and telling herself that they were not real. Mariana had never considered talking down these false imaginations. Her previous psychotherapist had always received her metaphorical fears as reality, and she had never before been encouraged to reorient herself to actual reality when they occurred.

I reminded her that the Bible teaches that her ultimate aim is to glorify God, not to protect herself from hurt or humiliation. I encouraged her to identify the times she feared being shamed and to ask herself whose glory she was worried about—God’s or her own? I pointed out that even if I should say something cruel or painful to her, I would be the one sinning, not her. The shame would belong to me.

Once again Mariana was being called to trust in the one true God who is loving, gracious, and compassionate (Exod 34:6). No human being deserves ultimate trust because only God is trustworthy. If Mariana placed her trust in him, she would be safe in God’s care in spite of any threats. I told her that I could not promise her that I would not fail her in some way in the future since I am a sinful, fallible human being. I could promise her that if she placed her trust in the Lord, he would keep her under his care (Prov 29:25).

Finally, I explained how pride is linked to shame. Although Mariana often felt ashamed when she thought about herself, she could also be harsh, superior, and self-righteous toward the failures of others. I described how her shame and her pride were mirror images of each other, both springing from the same fountain in the heart (Prov 4:23). When we are relying on our own righteousness, we will always struggle with either pride or shame. When we feel that we have done well, we will grow proud. When we recognize that we have failed, we will fear exposure and will be ashamed.

Mariana endured relentless experiences of shame throughout her childhood. Her father had stripped her and used her physically while her mother had stripped her and exposed her emotionally (by shaming her before others). Most people who have experienced similar treatment are eager to prove that they are not as bad as they have been told. Clinging to Christ in faith was the only ultimate remedy for Mariana’s shame. God’s full acceptance of her on the basis of Jesus’ forgiveness and cleansing was the only reality powerful enough to undercut and eradicate the shame she felt from her past abuse and her own former sins.

Mariana was still sinful by nature. Apart from Christ her destiny would have been an eternity in hell. To find emotional peace, she needed to stop struggling to persuade herself and everyone else that she was good enough. Instead she needed to trust the One who had already made her good enough through Christ. To supplement these vital points, I asked her to read through Ed Welch’s When People Are Big and God Is Small, which explains how the enslaving desire to please others arises from a selfishly warped perspective in which the approval of others is weighty and threatening while our great Creator, Redeemer, and Judge stands small and shriveled in the background. I also asked her to meditate on the verses from Romans 6–8 that we had previously discussed for many weeks, journaling her responses as she struggled to master these concepts.

Dealing with Painful Memories

We next addressed the flashbacks Mariana experienced when she entered the kitchen or took a shower. Psychologists use this common term to describe overpowering memories that cause a survivor to feel as though she is actually back in the abusive situation causing her to lose partial or complete contact with reality. Mariana believed her flashbacks occurred randomly and involuntarily and she was powerless to stop them. She described them as an alternate reality entered involuntarily, a place where the real world no longer existed. After further questioning, however, it became clear that entering the kitchen or taking a shower often triggered painful memories. Understandably, Mariana responded to these memories with extreme distress and, ultimately, ended up cowering in a corner, screaming. These episodes required her husband’s heroic intervention to reorient her. The flashbacks could not be completely involuntary and random because they never occurred when her children were present. Normally, they occurred when Leon was available to comfort her.

I reminded Mariana that because her psychotherapists both tolerated and expected unrestrained behavior during flashbacks, Mariana had practiced relinquishing control of herself and her emotions for quite some time. To the contrary, the apostle Paul, despite being imprisoned and alone himself, still exemplified persistent joy (Phil 4:4) as he encouraged the believers in Philippi to dwell on things that are true, honorable, just, pure, lovely, commendable, morally excellent, and praiseworthy (Phil 4:8). Even though Mariana felt as though these experiences were beyond her control, the Bible teaches that she had far more control than she thought. Her emotional responses were not irresistible as she had come to believe. By the power of the Spirit, she could begin to express the fruit of the Spirit, such as self-control (Gal 5:22–23). I explained to Mariana that she could choose to look toward Christ in faith and remember that she did not have to yield to these temptations which were calling for her to abandon herself to an emotional reaction to her memories. Over time this habit would lose its power over her as she stopped yielding to it, just as any other habit does. I also shared with Mariana that I had experienced times of fear as well, though those moments had not led to hysterics. I told her that I am learning to look to the Lord in faith when I am afraid (Ps 56:3–4) and she could learn to do the same. Sharing openly about how God empowered me to trust him in the midst of my weakness gave Mariana hope.

However unpleasant her experiences, there was also a reward associated with them. Mariana received Leon’s full support and special attention while she was hysterical, revealing that she had learned to give up control of her emotions in a way that demanded her husband’s care. I suggested that she ask Leon to help her remember that she did not have to yield to her emotions when she became upset. I also urged her to listen to him the first time he spoke rather than having hysterics for a couple of hours and calming down gradually. She agreed to try this approach. They began praying together when these experiences began.

These outbursts were more resistant than the Saturday evening hysterics. Over time they became less frequent. Practically, I asked Mariana to focus on journaling potential triggers to these episodes, contemplating what she could have done differently after they ended, and applying the scriptural principles we discussed to her times of emotional upheaval. By the time we finished our counseling, her emotional patterns were showing substantial growth. She was only losing control occasionally and only in response to the most overwhelming situations, and she would usually recover quickly.

Identifying and Modifying Potential Triggers

As we worked together to bring these behaviors back under Mariana’s conscious control, I also tried to help her discover what was provoking them. Her journaling assignments helped us recognize her patterns of response as they came upon her. It became clear that although certain locations were definitely connected with the memories that triggered her outbursts, these memories were not simply the product of environmental exposure. What was going on in her heart was even more important.

I learned that after a disagreement with Leon, Mariana would stew in anger and bitterness and would not speak further with him about the issue. She would begin to feel guilty and ashamed of her reaction and feared losing her relationship with him. This in turn would lead to self-deprecating thoughts, self-punishment, and ultimately despair. At this point a memory would arise, and she would have a flashback. The flashback produced an emotional release that reversed her negative feelings and brought Leon to her side to lovingly care for her. Once it was over, she felt much better. She also felt vindicated from the self-condemnation that had precipitated the attack because her breakdown had proven to her that she was not an angry person. Rather, the flashback reminded her that she was a victim of the anger and predation of others.

These breakdowns provided a way out of her emotional pain, but they also engendered constant chaos in the family (see Prov 14:12; 16:25). I reminded Mariana that God calls us not to suppress the truth in fear or shout the truth in anger but rather to speak the truth in love (Eph 4:15, 25–27). I encouraged her to practice speaking loving truth rather than suppressing her anger and bitterness until they erupted into rage or were transmuted into a flashback.

I also cautioned her that as she practiced this new behavior, she would inevitably fail at times. When she began stewing in anger, she needed to repent immediately and speak the truth to Leon in love. If she began to have a flashback, she could remind herself that she did not have to be mastered by her feelings.

I encouraged Mariana to see herself simultaneously as a sinner and one who is sinned against, pointing out that every single one of us shares in these dual identities. We do not have to deny our own sinful anger because we have a Savior who has already paid for our sins and credited us with his own righteousness. We can agree with what the gospel says about our sinfulness without becoming overwhelmed by guilt and shame. Further, we do not have to prove that we are victims rather than victimizers out of a desperate effort to persuade ourselves that we are righteous. We have Christ’s righteousness already. We can rest in this.

Perfectionism Versus Progressive Sanctification

As Mariana’s behavior began to improve, Leon asked when she would be well enough to take up her household responsibilities. By this he meant cooking, cleaning, and listening to him instead of just talking about her own feelings. This was the first time I became aware that a fundamental part of Mariana’s psychotherapy had been the expectation that Leon would take care of all the housework along with functioning as a sort of 24-7

co-therapist. He lived in hope that one day this unbalanced marital situation would end.

I told Mariana that she needed to begin resuming her responsibilities immediately because the way she was living stood against God’s clear design for a married woman (Titus 2:3–5; cf. 2 Thess 3:10–12). The excessive time available for introspection likely was contributing to her emotional instability. I also encouraged her to consider returning to college to finish her degree. She wrestled with whether she should do this so we studied the Proverbs 31 woman to discover the many different roles a believing woman might embrace to enhance her family’s enjoyment and security. Mariana ultimately did return to college and later studied biblical counseling as well.

As she began struggling to do the housework, I discovered that Mariana’s reluctance to do these chores was related to her shame. Because her mother had abused her and called her “dirty” when she did not clean perfectly, Mariana still felt ashamed when she “failed” to meet her mother’s standard in adulthood. For years she had alternated between exhausting herself trying to clean the kitchen perfectly and giving up because her efforts led to a sense of failure. These unpleasant responses caused her to avoid housework, and they even instigated flashbacks when she entered rooms especially associated with her shame, like the kitchen.

I also learned that Mariana had not shopped alone in years. She said she “couldn’t go anywhere” because she feared losing control of herself in public. To keep her calm, Leon either shopped for her or accompanied her when she went to the store. She also neglected cooking because she was avoiding the kitchen, and she slept much of the day while Leon was at work. All of these patterns kept Leon at her side, minimizing the amount of time she spent alone without him. Naturally, Leon longed for her to get up with him in the morning, make him breakfast, and see him off to work.

I set up an escalating exposure plan calling for Mariana to rise early, make breakfast, and go to the grocery store daily after seeing Leon off to work. She was to pray for grace before entering, pick up one or two items, and leave quickly. Even if she grew uncomfortable, she was to continue shopping instead of leaving in fear. Once she arrived home each day, she was to do some cleaning. The cleaning was limited at first, particularly in the kitchen and bathroom where her memories were most poignant. Finally, she was to make a quick dinner. Mariana’s confidence grew as she discovered that she was able to tolerate short exposure to the places and activities she dreaded. As she followed through, the exposures were lengthened until she shopped for everything and accomplished all the housework herself without experiencing distress.

A few weeks after beginning this program, Mariana nearly dropped out of counseling because she felt like a failure after becoming overwhelmed at Walmart. She had been able to talk herself out of the panic and had completed her shopping, but she was deeply ashamed that she had not fulfilled her assignment perfectly. I asked her about the rest of her week, and she told me that she had made breakfast for Leon and grocery shopped every day. I reframed her story as a victorious week, explaining that concentrating on this one struggle had caused her to cast the whole week as an overwhelming failure when the opposite was true. This kind of all-or-nothing thinking is common in abuse survivors. For Mariana, it triggered shame and flashbacks.

I emphasized the progressive nature of sanctification. Her journey was a step-by-step walk in which she would work out the Christian life daily as God energized her to accomplish his will (Phil 2:12–13). She needed to join Paul in framing the Christian life as warfare (Eph 6:10–18), recognizing that no warrior wins all his battles. This is why we must “walk by faith, not by sight” (2 Cor 5:7). She could rest in his performance (2 Cor 5:21), a theme I returned to repeatedly in subsequent sessions.

As flashbacks and other sensations began to decrease, Mariana began to recognize that she used her constant emotional crises to keep her husband close to her and to control the rest of her family. This realization provided fresh motivation to break her reactionary habits. She began to feel more pain over the suffering she had caused her own family than over the suffering her parents had caused her. She also began to shift her emphasis from seeking freedom from pain to seeking holiness, a mind-set which an earlier biblical counselor had emphasized but that Mariana had not understood until this phase of our time together.

Occasional setbacks continued to occur, but these now offered opportunities to identify the ways in which she allowed herself to avoid doing difficult things. One day she described her habitual choice of losing control of her emotions “like wrapping myself in a warm blanket.” The habit felt comforting because of its familiarity. In response we returned to Romans 6 and applied Paul’s teaching about the believer’s death to sin to Mariana’s personal challenge of dying to the attractive yet deadly habits of her thought life.

Psychotropic Medicines

As we continued to work on the various habits and sensations woven through Mariana’s life, she was being weaned off her many psychotropic medicines. She started this process without discussing it with me in advance. Once I learned that she was already in the process of being weaned off her medicines, we spent several sessions discussing the role of medication and other physical interventions as they related to her emotional responses.

One drug after another was decreased in dosage and then set aside entirely. She found that her thinking became clearer, making it easier for her to identify unbiblical thought patterns and correct them. She concluded that being on high doses of several medicines had not controlled her emotional outbursts. They actually made it harder for her to recognize and battle the thoughts that precipitated them before a major episode occurred. She weaned herself of all her medications and participated in the remainder of her counseling without any of them being reinstated.

New Memories, Fresh Forgiveness, Fresh Repentance

After we had met together for a number of months, Mariana learned that her father had passed away two months previously. She had not been informed. This opened a long period of struggle with competing feelings of love and anger toward him. She grieved that she would never hear her father ask for her forgiveness. She also grieved to think that he was certainly in hell since he had died without Christ. His death revived many painful memories that would need to be discussed, and Mariana feared that she would be driven mad by her feelings. She found herself sorely tempted to retreat back into childlike behaviors due to the stress, a process she referred to as “making myself little.” I reassured her that she was capable of dealing with her feelings as an adult in Christ’s power, and she was faithful to battle her threatening emotions.

However, in the next few months, a flood of new recollections about her father’s sexual abuse emerged. Some of these were difficult to acknowledge. Mariana realized that once molestation had become a regular part of her life, she had responded sexually to her father and had even initiated sexual relations at times. She had done this in order to gain control of his abuse, which she perceived to be inevitable. This newfound acknowledgment produced great shame. Mariana also remembered thinking of him in a romantic way and begging him to rescue her from her mother by running away with her. To make matters worse, she also recalled sexually abusing two younger sisters several times when she was 10 years old. Victims of sexual abuse sometimes engage in abuse themselves because it makes them feel powerful and in control of others. Even as a child Mariana discovered that the sense of control was not worth the guilt she felt over mistreating her sisters, so she stopped on her own without her sin being discovered by others. The fact that Mariana had asked both sisters for forgiveness some years prior to beginning counseling did not eliminate her shame.

These were very challenging issues to discuss. I sought to comfort Mariana by reminding her that it was understandable for her to respond sexually to her father due to their long-standing forced relationship. God had created her as a sexual being, and it was not primarily her fault that she had learned to respond with pleasure under repeated stimulation. Her initial experience of pleasure was not sinful for her; the sin belonged to her father who initiated her into this perverted experience. With this in mind, we explored what responsibility she bore for the ways she may have engaged in the sexual relationship once she understood it was wrong, balancing this with the fact that her participation was coerced rather than consensual.

We used a similar balance of principles to address the sexual abuse of her siblings. I recognized that this response to her abuse was understandable in such a twisted situation. Yet it was still sinful. Understanding that reactions like these were not unique to her when it came to the hearts and bodies of sexual abuse survivors helped Mariana see that she was not irredeemable or freakishly evil, as she had feared. Her temptation was “common to humanity” (1 Cor 10:13), and Christ had already paid the penalty for her sins.

It was challenging for me to speak the truth in love into this difficult issue because in highlighting her responsibility for her own sins I ran the risk of sounding like Mariana’s harsh, judgmental mother who had blamed her for her own victimization. I encouraged Mariana to accept responsibility for her own sin while simultaneously insisting that she was not responsible for the sins that had been committed against her. This distinction was difficult for Mariana to make because the two issues had been linked in her mind. I emphasized again that the more we acknowledge our own sins, the more we realize that no one is purely a victim. We may have been grievously sinned against, but we have all responded in sinful ways. No matter what has been done to us, we all need forgiveness for our own sins. Failing to acknowledge this about ourselves only makes us hypocrites like the unforgiving servant (Matt 18:23–33).

When Mariana was able to recognize that she bore some responsibility for her sin without accepting the “dirty” and “evil” judgments of her mother, a great burden was lifted from her heart; she embraced Christ’s forgiveness eagerly. This victory opened the way for several weeks of discussion dealing with struggles that Mariana continued to have in her sexual relationship with her husband. As we examined right and wrong in the sexual realm through the lens of Scripture, Mariana found a great deal of release from guilt and shame.

Mariana experienced another sense of release and liberation two years after her father’s death when she spoke with her older sister for the first time in 20 years. Her sister was able to verify many of her memories. This objective voice helped Mariana answer some of her relentless questions about which memories were real and which were the results of suggestion and previous psychotherapies. She had spent many years often wondering whether she was “just making it all up.” Through her sister she learned that she had not experienced satanic ritual abuse and she did not murder the children she bore to her father. The real story was that her father’s incestuous children did not survive their premature births, possibly because Mariana was induced early by her parents. Mariana also learned that she had indeed been abused in the ways documented in her history. Putting this question to rest gave her a sense of peace and the ability to move forward.

After making this fresh family connection, Mariana carefully considered the possibility of confronting her mother about the abuse and giving her the opportunity to ask for forgiveness. By this time Mariana understood the gospel well enough that she was willing to extend forgiveness freely, but both of us were concerned about the potential for a serious setback if Mariana reopened her heart to her mother’s influence. In any case her mother was now suffering from dementia and was less likely to respond well to a confrontation than she might have in the past. We jointly decided to table the subject for the time being, but Mariana left counseling understanding that I was happy to help her tackle the issue in the future if the circumstances and timing were right.

Where Was God?

Mariana and I had discussed a myriad of issues during our time together, and there were several more angles yet to be addressed. One immense question now demanded our focus: “Where was God when I was abused?” How could God be all-knowing, all-powerful, and all-good in light of Mariana’s dark experiences? Such understandably common questions haunt the minds of abuse survivors.

A key passage I highlighted during these discussions was Exod 34:5–7 where God reveals himself to Moses with a description of his full-orbed character—compassionate, gracious, patient, and loving, and also just, wrathful, and full of vengeance for his enemies. I highlighted God’s compassion, mercy, and justice in the Psalms as well, asking Mariana to spend this season of counseling praying various psalms of lament that echoed her personal experience.

The lament psalms are blended expressions of grief and trust as suffering believers cry out in anguish asking God some of the most honest and direct questions found in Scripture. They are beloved by believers of every generation because they reflect the sincere questioning of sufferers and resound with the unique emotions that accompany the darkest experiences of life. However, the psalms of lament are also interwoven with a strong thread of faith as the psalmists cling to the belief that God’s steadfast love and unwavering justice will reconcile all of our pain and puzzlement in the end.

As for Mariana, she found it helpful when I joined her in expressing gratitude for Jesus’ presence and comfort during her childhood abuse. She came to trust his character to work all things for good (Rom 8:28) even when she did not understand the details herself. The Holy Spirit ultimately did his greatest work in her heart as she listened to God’s Word preached by a pastor who had suffered deeply. This pastor exhorted his listeners to take refuge in God’s sovereignty and goodness and to entrust their dark experiences to his providential and good design for their lives. Mariana still says that she was fundamentally changed by her experience listening to this pastor and contemplating these truths, and she found peace and resolution regarding God’s role in her suffering.

Marriage and Family Issues

Several months passed, and the personal impact of her father’s death lessened. As Mariana’s emotions settled down, marital and family issues began to emerge. Because she had been disturbed for so long, the dynamic of her family had been substantially shaped by her struggles. Once she began functioning better, other family members began feeling safe enough to express their own long-suppressed emotions. Mariana and Leon began receiving marital counseling with a male IBCD counselor, and some of their adult children participated when necessary. I continued to support Mariana with individual sessions, as this period of counseling was challenging for her.

Mariana continued to feel safest when she was in control, but this produced friction in her marriage as Leon came to understand that God had called him to lead his family. He saw that yielding to Mariana was not really helping her grow (Eph 5:22–24). As they worked together to overcome old patterns and adjust their marriage to a biblical standard, both made many mistakes.

Leon initially became somewhat authoritarian as he attempted to lead his family, and Mariana alternated between challenging him angrily and taking refuge in hypersubmissive behavior, fearing that she might lose him. I continued to emphasize that Mariana should speak the truth in love (Eph 4:15) and gently correct Leon when he sinned rather than manipulating, raging, or suppressing her feelings (Eph 4:14–15, 25–27). She must make a gracious appeal when she disagreed with a decision (1 Sam 25:18–35).

At one point Mariana became concerned that Leon was engaging in unrepentant sin. She believed that submission required that she comply in silence with his choices for their family. I did not have firsthand information about this problem from Leon, so I did not confront it directly. It was, however, a good opportunity to encourage Mariana not to assent in silence to choices that she understood from Scripture as wrong (Acts 4:18–20; 5:27–29). I also encouraged her to bring her concerns to their marital counselor because biblical love does not passively accept a brother’s continuing in sin without correcting him (Luke 17:3; Gal 6:1–3; Col 3:16; Heb 3:13). We addressed a wife’s responsibility when she believes her husband is doing wrong, using the examples of Ananias and Sapphira (Acts 5:1–11) and Abraham and Sarah (1 Pet 3:1–7).

This balance of principles was difficult for Mariana to understand and even more difficult to put into practice because it was hard for her to confront lovingly when she was carried away by her emotions. She also struggled to respond appropriately to Leon’s biblical rebukes. During this period I had her supplement her meditation with assigned Scripture verses and her intentional practicing of new behaviors at home with readings in the book, Helper by Design by Elyse Fitzpatrick. I wanted her to saturate her mind with the wise biblical nuances that informed her role as a woman, nuances that would help her navigate this new marital balance.

As Leon and Mariana began to develop new interpersonal skills, both their marriage counselor and I encouraged them to seek oversight from their home church. An associate pastor was identified who agreed to meet with them, and the marriage counseling at IBCD ended. I began tapering the frequency of my meetings with Mariana.

A few months later, after the family enjoyed a three-week extended family Christmas in peace, Mariana agreed that she was ready to stop meeting with me. We spent a few weeks remembering what she had learned throughout our time together and reminiscing about how far she had come. At our final meeting Mariana understood that if she had difficulties in the future she could return for additional help.

Conclusion: Life After Counseling and Lessons Learned

I heard from Mariana from time to time over the next few years. She and Leon continued to face challenges in their marriage, and their relationships with their three adult children remained difficult. They had occasional, as-needed family counseling sessions at IBCD or with pastors at their local church. Over time, however, their family life calmed down. Mariana has now grown in her faith for several years without any psychotropic medications or personal counseling. The family has not required outside help in some time.

Leon took an entrepreneurial position and hired Mariana as his assistant. Their ability to function as marriage partners greatly improved as they worked together for nearly two years. She proved to be a capable helper for Leon, enhancing his earning ability significantly. They also trained as biblical counselors and began counseling couples together through their church’s counseling ministry. They are both currently working on their counseling certification through the National Association of Nouthetic Counselors (NANC).

Mariana reports that her daughter told her recently, “You aren’t even the same person you were before you began counseling.” Her older son recently married and gave Mariana and Leon their first grandson. Although her relationship with this son was once severely damaged, she now describes it as close and cordial. Her relationship with her younger son has been the hardest to restore, but she reports that recently a full reconciliation occurred in this relationship.

Mariana tells me that her life was permanently changed by my illustration of her life as a time line divided into old and new by the power of Christ’s death and resurrection. Prior to counseling, Mariana saw herself as permanently damaged by her terrible experiences in childhood—powerless to be anything other than a helpless victim. Seeing herself as clothed with Christ’s righteousness and risen to new life gave her hope that she could change the patterns of the past by relying on his power.

There are two opposite temptations that counselors face as they seek to work with a counselee who has a troubled past. One is to view conversations about the past as intrinsically healing; the other is to ignore the influence of the past. Psychotherapists, following Freud and his intellectual heirs, believe that rehearsing the injuries of the past with accompanying emotional discharge enables a counselee to master overwhelming trauma. However, this approach did not produce healing in Mariana. Rather, it enabled an intensification of her emotional responses that, in turn, multiplied her interpersonal chaos.

While the psychotherapy Mariana describes obviously presents a legitimate target for criticism, it is important to remember that her former psychotherapists were advising her at a time when there was a virtual mania for recovered memories. Numerous books on this subject were being published, many troubled women were convinced they had multiple personalities, and most therapists believed in the existence of satanic, ritual abuse. It is not as productive as it may seem to critique this extreme example of a therapeutic fad since few people continue to practice it.

It is more valuable to focus on the biblical incongruity with the psychotherapeutic belief (still held today) that trauma must be reexperienced repeatedly in therapy so that the victim can “master” it. No scriptural principles suggest that repeated emotional indulgence produces healing. Rather, the opposite is suggested by the murderous outcome of Cain’s flaring bitterness (Gen 4:1–8) and Absalom’s simmering anger (2 Sam 13:20–29), to cite just two examples. Instead, Phil 4:8 commands us to dwell on what is true, honorable, just, pure, lovely, commendable, morally excellent, and praiseworthy.

Does this mean biblical counselors should ignore the influence of the past in their counseling? Mariana saw Christian counselors who encouraged her to forget what is behind her and reach forward to what is ahead of her (Phil 3:13). She was accused of making up her history of abuse, pushed to forgive before being given the opportunity to tell her whole story, and discouraged from discussing painful subjects. Much of this previous counseling focused on identifying and forsaking known patterns of sin, such as the lying that she mentioned at our first session.

These essential angles were an important aspect of my counsel to Mariana as well, and they formed a portion of every session we had together. Correction was offered from an empathetic perspective that formed slowly as I gradually learned all that she had endured. Because she knew that I grasped the enormity of what she had been through, she came to feel safe with me. It was essential for her to be sure that I was not secretly judging her as irredeemably “evil” as her mother had said for years. Because she knew that I understood how she had become the woman she was and that I did not condemn her for it, she was finally able to share her deepest secrets, such as the molestation of her sisters and her sexual response to her father. If she had not felt free to share these things, she might have left counseling still unsure whether she was truly counted righteous in Christ.

Christian women who have been abused in childhood often confuse the exhortations and commands in Scripture with the harsh judgments of their abusers. They feel condemned by the passages intended to comfort them. For this reason it is crucially important to build a firm foundation on the indicatives of Scripture (what God has done for believers and what is already true of believers) while simultaneously addressing failures to live in accordance with biblical imperatives (what Christians are to do in Christ). As I worked with Mariana to break down her destructive emotional habits, I constantly returned to the foundation of her possessing Christ’s righteousness. To make any substantial and lasting progress, she had to learn to rest in this reality instead of her own performance. As this truth became more deeply embedded in Mariana’s thinking, the perfectionism, guilt, and shame that stemmed from her failure to meet her mother’s standard of righteousness gradually lost its power over her emotions.

Another important factor in Mariana’s improvement was coming to believe the scriptural teaching that even disturbed women like her could change. First Corinthians 6:11 concludes a list of life-dominating sins with the frank statement, “Some of you used to be like this. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.” Mariana had participated in 20 years of Christian psychotherapy which had emphasized the truth of God’s love for her without adequately confronting her sin or unpacking Scripture’s expectation that true repentance would result in a changed life. A balanced biblical counseling approach addresses both of these truths.

At the same time we must be careful not to impart a “just-do-it” theology when confronting a counselee with the scriptural expectation that repentance will lead to change. Mariana came to counseling persuaded that her uncontrolled reactions to her overwhelming emotions were inevitable. She had already received Christian counseling that emphasized her need to stop reacting the way she was, to no avail. She truly wanted to change and had come to believe that Scripture testified that she had the power to change, but she still was not changing. This was one reason she kept returning to the supposed involuntary nature of the various phenomena she experienced.

Working with someone who has practiced surrendering herself to her emotions for years requires much patience. In this type of situation, the counselor must be willing gently to repeat core teachings as often as necessary. Concluding that counselees with severe disturbances are not really trying can have destructive results in their lives. More than one counselor, both spiritual and psychotherapeutic, had basically called Mariana a liar and a drama queen. She certainly could be both at times, but she was also a human being made in the image of God as well as a struggling believer who deserved to be respected as such even if she sometimes had difficulty conforming her behavior to the Bible’s standard.

This underscores the need to be realistic about the investment of time required of counselors who endeavor to help seriously disturbed abuse survivors. Although many such people respond well to a short-term course of counseling, deep-seated, chronic problems like Mariana’s require unbending patience, sincere love, generous time, proven trustworthiness, and a sturdy reliance on the power of the Holy Spirit ministered through God’s Word and prayer. Cases of severe sexual abuse can be like icebergs: vast and jagged portions of the story hidden beneath the surface emerge only gradually. May God provide abundant grace to all those he calls to this challenging ministry.

For the sake of privacy, all names used in this case study are pseudonyms.

See www.ibcd.org.

Jerry Bridges, The Gospel for Real Life (Colorado Springs: NavPress, 2003).

Ezekiel 16 employs powerful metaphors about nakedness, shame, and prostitution to illustrate Israel’s apostasy from her covenant God. I did not want Mariana to read the rest of the chapter and mistakenly identify herself with the disturbing and humiliating picture of apostate Israel.

I am indebted to biblical counselor Ed Welch for his understanding of multiple personalities as a metaphor rather than as an objective reality (see Edward Welch, “Insight into Multiple Personality Disorder,” The Journal of Biblical Counseling 14, no. 1 [1995]: 18–26).

Edward Welch, When People Are Big and God Is Small: Overcoming Peer Pressure, Codependency, and Fear of Man (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 1997).

For more information on this topic, see Laura Hendrickson and Elyse Fitzpatrick, Will Medicine Stop the Pain? Finding God’s Healing for Depression, Anxiety, and other Troubling Emotions (Chicago: Moody, 2006). Also see Dan Wickert’s more extensive discussion of medication in this book in “ ‘Mary’ and Paralyzing Fear,” 111.

I am indebted to biblical counselor David Powlison for the idea of using lament psalms with abuse victims (see David Powlison, Recovering from Child Abuse: Healing and Hope for Victims [Greensboro, NC: New Growth Press, 2008], 11–15). Some examples of lament psalms are Psalms 6; 22; 55.

Elyse Fitzpatrick, Helper by Design: God’s Perfect Plan for Women in Marriage (Chicago: Moody, 2003).

The National Association of Nouthetic Counselors (NANC) was founded in 1975 as “a fellowship of Christian pastors and laymen banded together to promote excellence in biblical counseling.” The word “nouthetic” derives from the Greek verb noutheteō which means “to admonish.” See www.nanc.org for more information including training and certification opportunities.

This “emotional discharge” is known in psychotherapeutic terms as abreaction.

I am indebted to biblical counselors Elyse Fitzpatrick and Dennis Johnson for emphasizing scriptural indicatives as well as imperatives in counseling. See Elyse Fitzpatrick and Dennis Johnson, Counsel from the Cross: Connecting Broken People to the Love of Christ (Wheaton: Crossway, 2009).

↑ Back to top

↑