Chapter 11 of 16

Chapter 10: “Julie” and Addictions and Adultery

Chapter 10: “Julie” and Addictions and Adultery

Chapter 10

“Julie” and Addictions and Adultery

Robert D. Jones

What did I fear most when I became a lead pastor at age 26? It was not the fear of speaking before a crowd, shepherding people 40 years older than me, sharing the gospel, or leading an elder or deacon meeting. While these tasks challenged me as a young man, they produced no major consternation. Instead, what I feared most was facing a difficult counseling situation, the kind addressed by the biblical counseling contributors in this book.

In one sense my concern was unavoidable. Based on Scripture, I believed that my pastoral calling included counseling—that a shepherd must shepherd his members through their fears, conflicts, despair, sinful habits, and a host of other problems. I did not believe that God freed me simply to refer my struggling sheep to others, especially if their counsel would not center on Jesus and arise from Scripture. I could not dodge my duties to shepherd my people biblically. So I entered my pastorate with both a God-given command to counsel and a lingering fear about counseling the hard cases.

Hard cases, of course, come in many shapes and sizes. Some counseling scenarios are difficult due to the presence of bizarre behavior. Pastors may be perplexed by people acting in seemingly indecipherable ways—like manic or schizophrenic behaviors. The pastor’s response can range from curiosity to discomfort to feeling downright spooked. Other cases are tough because they come with a psychiatric label attached, one with medical-sounding language that seems too technical or mysterious for the average pastor. From his seminary days he might remember the Greek aorist tense or Jesus’ hypostatic union, but “bipolar” or “borderline personality” disorders appear to go beyond his training. Ministers unaccustomed to such jargon can feel stymied. Still other cases scare pastors because they feature entrenched sin patterns like pornography, complex relational dynamics like adultery, or life-dominating addictions like alcohol abuse.

The counseling case I want to share with you was hard for a number of reasons. First, the situation combined a host of these taxing components in one case. Second, I encountered it relatively early in my ministry when I was not accustomed to dealing with the kind of complex problems exhibited in the case. Third, the case was full of surprising developments. As I began, I believed it would be a fairly straightforward instance of marriage counseling. As the weeks and months progressed, however, I was shocked to discover how this seemingly straightforward situation quickly spun into the complexities of alcohol addiction, adultery, and persistent patterns of rebellion on the part of a wife and mother. These layered complexities created another complicating factor—a prolonged period of counseling. The case took over two years from start to finish.

Throughout the length and intricacy of this case, my own learning curve was steep. The story still stands out in my mind as a testimony to God’s grace because I learned so much as I saw God use my imperfect counsel, and I observed the power of God in the lives of one of his daughters who changed in spite of her own efforts to run from his grace.

Julie’s Background

A job transfer led Nate and Julie to our area from the Midwest. Both were college educated and in their early thirties. They had been married for eight years when I met them. Traveling with two young children and one on the way had made the move itself stressful, but now their greater problem was homesickness. They both greatly missed their friends and family and longed to return home.

Nate and Julie were committed Christians, and their search for a faithful church led them to our congregation where they quickly joined and found a home. Since they had no relationships in the area, the fellowship of Christian brothers and sisters proved indispensable in their lives—and would later prove indispensable in counseling. Earlier in their marriage they had suffered a serious church split which left them cautious about church participation but also hungry for caring, authentic fellowship. Their most recent church experience had been legalistic and theologically shallow, so they came to our church lacking doctrinal depth without an understanding of the deep riches of God’s grace.

My relationship with Nate and Julie began through informal church activities. My wife, Lauren, and others provided meals and babysitting when their third child was born. As we got to know them, Lauren and I began to sense some marital tension between them. Julie was also struggling in her relationship with the Lord and in her role as a wife, mother, and homemaker. Because of these concerns, I offered to spend some time with them in an effort to help. Nate was immediately receptive. Julie was cautious but willing.

The Initial Stage:

“Normal” Counseling with Little Success

We first met for counseling in October of that year. In setting up the session, both had expressed a desire for biblical counseling. They wanted to grow spiritually and strengthen their marriage. Following my typical pattern for marriage counseling, I asked Nate and Julie to allow Lauren to join us along with their small group leader, Todd, and his wife, Jan. In our opening sessions we spent substantial time getting to know Nate and Julie, learning their backgrounds and asking about their present struggles.

As we talked together, Julie revealed a broad spectrum of spiritual, physical, marital, and family issues. She indicated that these were “lifelong” problems, though the marriage issues had begun about five years ago after their first three years of marriage. Julie shared a long list of stressors: “life, anxiety, depression, perfectionism, being in control of situations.” She described herself as “overwhelmingly stressed out.” Julie also had a history of psychiatric diagnoses and was taking several different psychoactive medications to treat depression, anxiety, and bipolar disorder. To summarize, four key categories of information arose from both our first session and a precounseling form Julie filled out.

Julie’s Relationship with God and Her Neglect of Spiritual Disciplines

Unfortunately these two were virtually synonymous for Julie. She measured her spiritual status by the number of “quiet times” she observed. She spoke clearly about wanting to “develop spiritual disciplines” in her life—especially “daily time in the Word.” She had enjoyed more consistent Bible reading years ago. The deterioration of her zeal for God’s Word and the decline in her devotional habits greatly troubled her. She attended church regularly, but she usually failed to spend time alone with the Lord. Perhaps her most troubling comment was her admission that she was “afraid to be alone with God.” I immediately recalled an insight from one of my biblical counseling professors: Most counseling problems reflect a distorted view of God and a deficient relationship with Christ.

I talked with both Julie and Nate at length about their commitment to Christ, and I determined they were followers of Jesus, though with opposite personalities and differing levels of zeal and maturity. Nate was disciplined, steady, and zealous in his faith. At times he could be unaccommodating, critical, and intimidating. Julie ultimately manifested evidence of faith in Christ and submission to his Word, but her Christian life was random, sporadic, and fearful. Nate was rationalistic, thought in black-and-white categories, and could argue skillfully. Julie was emotionally driven and sought to avoid arguments with her husband. These differences exacerbated their marital conflicts. Nate’s forcefulness intimidated Julie; Julie’s cowering frustrated Nate. Nate’s ability to accomplish tasks shamed Julie; Julie’s underperformance irritated Nate.

Julie’s Psychological/Psychiatric Problems

Julie also reported problems with “depression and anxiety even before high school.” She wanted to be weaned off of her psychiatric medications which had been prescribed by different physicians. She also acknowledged being a perfectionist who nit-picked her own work and the work of others, maintaining unrealistic standards that led to a sense of failure and guilt. “When I fail, I usually dwell on it, feel guilty, and/or quit. I see myself as a failure as a Christian woman, wife, and mother. I want to be out of the bondage of guilt, failure, and anger toward my husband. I want to live in God’s promises.” She further described herself as someone with “low self-esteem,” a “people pleaser,” and one who constantly compared herself to others.

Julie’s Physical Problems

Four years earlier Julie was diagnosed with fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome. Then, a year before their move to our town, a car accident produced a serious back injury resulting in surgery, chronic pain, and ongoing acute flare-ups. Her doctor prescribed pain medication as well as an antidepressant, both of which Julie continued to take in her new town under the care of several physicians.

Julie’s Marriage and Family

Nate and Julie’s relationship problems began about five years prior to our meetings after three years of marriage. Julie rated their marriage as terrible—zero on a scale of zero to five. She cited better communication and more joint spiritual activities as the main ways to improve their relationship. In our first session Julie focused more on her personal struggles than her marriage problems, but it was still evident that both were highly problematic. She accurately pinpointed a major need when she expressed her desire to learn to “fear God more than my husband,” though her confused view of God made this honorable goal a difficult and distorted task. Early in our work together, she mentioned little about parenting struggles, but Nate made plain that Julie’s failure to discipline their children was producing household chaos.

What had Julie done so far about all of these problems? “I take medicines for anxiety and depression. As for everything else, I’ve done little or nothing.” The language of failure spoke loudly at every point.

Addressing the Issues

We first addressed Julie’s relationship with God, helping her learn to read and apply Scripture on her own. We also focused on issues we believed were necessary to bring immediate relief to their marriage: communication, roles, and parenting. Given the amount of spiritual, physical, marital, and parenting pressures she felt, we opened to Psalm 46 and surveyed the psalmist’s portrayals of God as our refuge and strength—on-site and mighty—amid an earthquaking world. We then helped Julie start a devotional plan where she would read a psalm every day (or every other day) in Psalms 120–134, a section of the Psalter with brief psalms and memorable images that help fix our eyes on the Lord. I also taught Nate and Julie my biblical peacemaking model involving a recommitment to please God and a willingness to examine, to confess, and to repent of heart and behavioral sins. I also shared some practical steps to love, forgive, and serve each other. During the upcoming week they were to read chapters 1–2 in Ken Sande’s book Peacemaking for Families, study and memorize some key Bible passages, and keep a journal of their conflicts so we could work through them in upcoming sessions.

Around this time we took a break for several weeks so that Nate and Julie could visit their family over the Christmas holidays. When Julie returned, she was not doing well in any area of her life, and her demeanor reflected total indifference. As we continued to learn about her, we found a woman overwhelmed with parenting, homemaking, and marital problems. “I feel pressured to perform. Then I fail. And I just want to give up.” Further, Julie felt that God was “very far away—he is still there and he loves me, but I feel overwhelmed; and I feel guilty when I don’t run to him.” Julie went on to describe her frustration that God was watching her fail in so many areas. The notion that God could ever say, “Well done, good and faithful slave!” (Matt 25:21), was far from her. She also repeated her previous admission that she was more afraid of her husband’s standard than God’s standard, even though she expressed confusion about what those standards might be.

First, in light of Julie’s difficulty grasping God’s grace, we began discussing a biblical view of performance. I explained to her, “God is not primarily looking at your performance, but the performance of Jesus your Savior for you, in your place.” Given her physical, marital, and homemaking pressures, we considered together Jesus’ temptations in Matt 4:1–11, but only in light of the broader context of Matthew. Julie was tempted to read this account exclusively as an example of how to fight temptation by quoting Scripture. Jesus’ method of fighting temptation here is certainly exemplary, but Julie needed to see that the point of the story was not for Scripture memorization. Jesus is not mainly our example for how to handle temptation by citing and following Scripture; he is first and foremost our Redeemer and Substitute. As the son of Abraham and the son of David (Matt 1:1–17), Jesus fulfilled the Old Testament covenant promises, and he comes to us as our Savior (Matt 1:21) and our Immanuel, God with Us (Matt 1:23). As the true Son of God (Matt 2:15), Jesus succeeded where God’s Old Testament son, Israel (Exod 4:22; see Hos 11:1) had failed. Jesus fulfilled the Old Testament, completing in his 40 days of temptation what Israel failed to do in 40 years of desert wandering—to perfectly trust and obey God amid overwhelming pressures. As the Son who always pleases his Father (Matt 3:17), Jesus is our righteousness. I reminded her, “Yes, Julie, you have failed. So have Lauren and I, and Todd and Jan, but Jesus never did. His perfect obedience there in the desert has been credited to you in the gospel of Christ. So, Julie, own the guilt for your failures, but hear the grace of God: ‘Julie, I love you. You are my daughter. My Son Jesus has perfectly succeeded. At the end of the day, his performance and not yours matters most.’”

Second, I reminded Julie of a sermon she recently heard from Romans 8 on God’s unconditional love for her in Jesus Christ. We encouraged her to cry out to God, “I do believe! Help my unbelief!” (Mark 9:24). Julie needed to preach the gospel to herself daily—to apply the truths about her finished justification, her definitional sanctification, and her unchangeable adoption. She needed to learn that she is loved and owned by God, her Father. Since her previous church experience had not been gospel driven, we spent subsequent sessions addressing and applying various facets of the gospel to her life as she read C. J. Mahaney’s The Cross Centered Life: Keeping the Gospel the Main Thing.

Third, we continued to help Julie develop biblical direction for becoming a godly wife, mother, and homemaker, depending on and appropriating God’s promises, power, and presence in her daily life. We returned to the refuge of Psalm 46 along with the Psalms of Ascent (120–134). We then unpacked Isa 41:8–10 where God promises his chosen people that he will always be powerful and present to help them; Phil 4:11–13 where God promises to enable believers to live with contentment even amid hard circumstances; and 2 Tim 4:17 where Paul declares that “the Lord stood with [him] and strengthened [him]” in the midst of loneliness and opposition. Practically, Lauren and Jan proved invaluable as mentors and accountability partners helping Julie prioritize and carry out her homemaking duties.

Nevertheless, when we reconvened the following week, Julie seemed to be in the exact same place. She had not been reading her Bible, and she had gotten into another major fight with Nate. When asked about God, she was full of qualifications: “God loves me, but I cannot please God, so what’s the use of trying?” she replied. Horizontal thinking dominated her. I once again reminded her of the gospel:

On the one hand, Julie, you cannot please God. Our sins will always mar us. But the good news of the gospel is that God is already pleased with you because you stand in Jesus his beloved Son, our substitute. The starting point for you, Julie, is to cry out to God, “God, have mercy on me, a sinner” (Luke 18:13 NIV), and then, in light of Jesus’ accomplishment on the cross, to thank God for that mercy. Julie, if you could get right with God through prayer and Bible reading, then why do you need a Savior? Reading your Bible is not a way to get right with God but to know the God who has mercifully saved and adopted you and to learn how he wants you to live in light of his grace.

We asked Julie and Nate to memorize and meditate on Col 3:12: “Therefore, God’s chosen ones, holy and loved, put on heartfelt compassion, kindness, humility, gentleness, and patience.” We longed for Julie to encounter her true identity in Christ as “chosen,” “holy,” and “loved.” In the same vein we also directed her to spend some time studying Ephesians 1 to deepen her grasp of her identity in Jesus as the foundation for God-pleasing obedience.

These twin themes—God’s forgiving, justifying, and adopting grace and God’s sustaining, invigorating, and enabling grace—marked our ongoing counseling. Whether we were talking with Julie alone or together with Nate, or whether we were discussing marriage, parenting, or homemaking, we repeatedly stressed the pardoning and empowering grace of God. Little did we know that these emphases would be foundational for what we were about to face. I mentioned earlier that this case had unforeseen elements. We were about to turn the corner into our first big surprise.

The Crisis Stage Begins: Julie’s Addictions Surface

Although we had been working with Nate and Julie for several months, their marriage had remained troubled, with little growth seen either in Julie or in their relationship. Instead, her anger toward Nate had increased, and she was beginning to voice desires to get out of the marriage. At the same time Julie knew that she was hurting Nate and the children. This added to her fears and guilt. Parenting problems continued over how to discipline the children, whether and when the children should sleep in Mom and Dad’s bed, and whether they should have more children. On the one hand Julie wanted to be a better Christian wife and mother. On the other hand she resented what she called Nate’s legalism, perfectionist demands, and condemnation of her: “He is just looking for ways to condemn me all the time.” While my counseling team did not view Nate’s standards to be excessive, a woman lacking discipline and seeking to escape from pressures found even reasonable standards of homemaking burdensome.

Then, in a counseling session in February (we had begun counseling in October), Julie admitted that she had begun drinking daily—resuming patterns of alcohol addiction that had been dormant for several years. She had grown up in a troubled home with two alcoholic parents and developed serious problems herself. Her drunkenness was doubly damaging—the problem of the alcohol itself was compounded by her mixing it with prescription medications. We spent time addressing her drinking, seeking to expose the blend of feel-good and escapist motives fueling this sin. It was essential to deal not just with the choice to drink or the dangers of drunkenness but also with the heart motivations driving her resurgent habits. We identified Julie’s sinful lust for alcohol as a worship disorder and an enslaving power (Rom 6:16), while presenting Jesus as the One who could set her free from all bondage (John 8:31–36). At the same time her choices and behaviors could not go untouched. As we labored to help Julie change from the inside out, we also examined ways she should avoid access to alcohol, and we laid down some practical boundaries as well as some strong accountability measures to help control this access.

Meanwhile, the marital strife and parenting struggles continued, and despair marked Julie’s mind-set: I feel useless, I feel lost, I can’t cope, I’m alone. In addition to her disillusionment, Julie continued to express her desire to leave the marriage. At this point Lauren and Jan began to spend more time with Julie between sessions.

Once again, however, things worsened when Julie had a minor car accident the following week. Not only were the children in the vehicle, but Julie had also been drinking and had fled the scene. Soon she was cited by the police and given a court date. I reported the situation to the elders of our church, one of whom joined us for the next counseling session. In this session Julie admitted that her use of alcohol was increasing as a means of dulling her depression, guilt, and fear while coping with the pressures of being a stay-at-home mom. She acknowledged that she was turning to alternatives other than God to relieve her pressures. Meanwhile Nate’s patience had grown thin, and he too acknowledged his sinful tendency to shortcut the Holy Spirit in his rush to change Julie. Out of concern for her and the children’s safety, our counseling team supported Nate’s decision to take away her car keys so she could not steal away to the liquor store during the day. Yet Julie’s reluctant acceptance of this reasonable decision demonstrated that her heart was not sufficiently humbled. We did provide her with the names and phone numbers of other stay-at-home moms in the area who could transport her and the children in case of medical emergencies or other needs.

During these sessions we continued to call Julie to a deepening repentance in light of Jesus’ atoning cross and victorious resurrection. Her combination of comfort-seeking escapism, hovering fear, and lack of basic skills was crippling her. We gave her practical instruction about prayer, especially encouraging her to address her anger with God by admitting to him where she felt he had let her down in her various forms of suffering. The same kind of humble honesty was also needed in her marriage since she needed to learn to confess her sins to Nate and to forgive him for his sins toward her, as together they learned to communicate graciously.

Julie also needed recommitment and practical training in homemaking and life management. She found it difficult to get up in the morning, make breakfast, and get the children going. She wrestled with eating junk food, neglected regular exercise, and struggled with carving out time to read her Bible and pray. Once again Lauren and Jan were indispensable as they provided hands-on help and mobilized other godly women to help Julie, all with her permission and gratitude. For instance, Lauren spent an entire morning with Julie at her home. After reading to the children and asking them to play quietly and only interrupt if it was really important, Lauren talked with Julie about the why and how of Bible reading and prayer, helped her set up a plan to read through Ephesians in small sections (three to six verses at a time), and encouraged Julie to battle her distracted mind by recording a daily prayer of thanksgiving to God based on the passage she read that day.

Lauren also helped Julie establish a daily schedule with the kids. They also marked out regular bedtimes for the children, allowing ample time for Bible reading and personal care both before the kids awoke and after Nate left for work. Because Sunday mornings were hectic for Julie and filled with family conflict, Lauren explained the value of preparing for Sunday morning on Saturday night. This included washing and ironing Sunday clothes for each family member, preparing breakfast in advance (e.g., muffins or a breakfast casserole), giving the children their baths, and going to bed on time so that everyone could be well rested in the morning.

Lauren also encouraged Julie to wean all of the children from sleeping in their parents’ bed. This adjustment would require moving the bedtime ritual from Nate and Julie’s bed to each child’s bed as well as reclaiming the parents’ bedroom as a private room instead of a family playroom.

Finally, Lauren helped Julie recognize the anger and manipulation she directed towards her children when she was tired or experiencing pain—“I can never have time to myself!” or “Didn’t I tell you mommy has a headache?” While Nate himself had already said some of the things Lauren and other women were now saying, hearing them from other women made Julie more receptive. Julie seemed genuinely humbled by the attention and instruction she was receiving, and though she continued to lack consistency, homemaking and mothering went more smoothly when she applied what she was learning.

Once again, though, it seemed to be two steps back for every one step forward. As summer approached, the marital issues reheated. Julie wanted out: “We need a separation.” Nate and Julie fought about everything: Julie’s parenting, Julie’s homemaking, Julie’s medical care (gynecological problems), Julie’s addictions (alcohol, spending), and Nate’s leadership. Julie complained, “I’m afraid of Nate more than God. One nurse said that I’m in an emotionally abusive relationship.” To our counseling team Julie’s words sounded revengeful.

In our times together Julie confessed that God seemed far away and that her anger against both God and Nate were creating that distance. Julie admitted her guilt as a Christian, a wife, and a mother but still seemed to be avoiding full responsibility. One of our counseling team spoke up: “Julie, you seem to have decided that Nate is the cause of all your stress. Nate may add to your stress, but Nate is not to blame. Julie, you need to battle evil instead of battling Nate. Stop blaming Nate; go to God to ask for his help and receive his grace and mercy.”

We continued regular counseling with Nate and Julie through the summer but saw little growth. We discussed Julie’s lack of parental discipline over her children and her constant conflicts with Nate. Yet our focus on their marital dynamics was undercut by Julie’s minimal commitment to complete the practical homework assignments designed to help her establish new patterns of thinking and interacting. By the time fall arrived (which marked one full year of counseling), the marriage showed no significant improvement while Julie’s addictions to alcohol, cigarettes, and prescription drugs had increased. With the support of the church’s elders, Nate and our counseling team agreed that Julie needed to detoxify at an in-patient facility. Julie objected but eventually acquiesced. We found a recommended site in another state where she was admitted for 30 days. Our phone communication was limited during this time, but we were able to maintain minimal contact.

The Crisis Stage Continues: More Addictions and an Adulterous Relationship

The in-patient facility achieved its detoxifying goal: Julie emerged chemically clean of alcohol, and her psychiatrist even cut back on her psychiatric medications. But another serious problem had arisen during her month in rehab: Julie had been surrounded by a new set of relationships with non-Christian male and female patients who had influenced her negatively. The devastating news came while Julie was still in her 30-day program: she had committed adultery with one of the male patients. Overcome with guilt, she had called Nate from the facility to confess her unfaithfulness, and Nate soon informed us. I immediately called Julie, mentioned what Nate had told me, and tried to call her to repentant faith in Christ in the limited time we were allowed to talk.

The week Julie was discharged, we met with her and Nate several times. She explained what led to her adultery: “I felt camaraderie with several patients. This guy and I hit it off. I don’t know why I slept with him. He made me feel special, and I liked it too much.” It was difficult to tell if she was truly repentant. On the one hand she said: “I don’t feel proud. I want to see our marriage work, and I want our family to work. It felt right at the time, but I know it wasn’t right.” Yet there were strains of justification and no evidence of Spirit-wrought repentance: “I found someone who accepted me, who loved me for who I am. He pursued me, and I received his love and attention.” Moreover, her commitment to her marriage was lower than ever: “I’d get out of the marriage if I could, and I’ve wanted to for a long time. But I care about the kids. And I’m afraid I won’t make it on my own. I know God doesn’t want divorce, but I feel like I’m in a cage. I had the thought that after rehab I could be a better mom, but I can’t.” Julie was even considering a return to the town where the rehab center was located, keeping the connection alive through phone conversations with one of the unbelieving women she had met in the program.

It had become apparent to everyone but Julie that she had deep heart issues that needed radical attention. The core problems were not chronic pain, psychiatric medications, marriage and parenting failures, substance abuse, or even infidelity. At root Julie remained consumed with herself as she pursued happiness on her own terms. Self-will dominated her life, manifesting itself in both rebellion and unbelief. There was rebellion against God and his ways—the independent spirit depicted in Luke 19:14: “But his subjects hated him and sent a delegation after him, saying, ‘We don’t want this man to rule over us!’” Yet there was also a deep measure of unbelief and fear. Julie felt hopeless, helpless, miserable, and condemned, though she never recanted her faith in Jesus. While theologians debate whether sin ultimately springs from rebellion or unbelief, we saw both root sins staring us in the face.

Our intervention again included explicit instruction about the forgiving and empowering grace that Jesus promises to all who repent, believe, and follow him. Naturally, it also included firm, passionate pleadings from every one of our counseling team members, urging our sister Julie to turn back to God (we included specific steps for what such repentance would look like). Lauren and Jan even offered to meet with Julie privately for spiritual and hands-on help, but in the face of our manifold pleas and our offers of assistance, Julie never cried out to God for mercy and grace.

Our next two weekly sessions multiplied our summons for repentance. We turned to Joel 2:1–11, where God’s people had incurred his judgment through their disobedience, bringing on themselves a divinely orchestrated invasion of locusts. But in 2:12–13, the prophet shines a bright ray of hope: “Even now—this is the Lord’s declaration—turn to Me with all your heart, with fasting, weeping, and mourning. Tear your hearts, not just your clothes, and return to the Lord your God. For he is gracious and compassionate, slow to anger, rich in faithful love, and he relents from sending disaster.” Joel called God’s people to a thorough, heart-driven repentance—with inward sincerity, not outward hypocrisy—yet his call was rooted in God’s gracious character. Israel’s repentance would not make God gracious and compassionate. Rather, God is first compassionate, and on this basis he invites us to repent. Joel alluded to God’s famous self-revelation to Moses in Exod 34:6–7. It is God’s gracious character and his promise of mercy that lay the foundation for his invitation to his people to return to him. His grace also provides the assurance that Israel would be received should she embrace his kind invitation and choose to return. Julie needed to hear the prophet Joel as I reiterated his kind and serious summons:

Julie, you have turned away from the God who loves you, the God who loves you so much that he sent his own Son to die for you. Your life and marriage and family are reaping the consequences of your self-centered pursuits, and God your Savior is grieved. But he offers you this hope: Because he is the God of all grace and compassion, he will receive you, Julie, if you turn back to him with all your heart. Not just with some remorse and some new resolutions but with a heart that acknowledges your helplessness, hopelessness, rebellion, self-centeredness, and unbelief. And we all love you and are here to help you.

I wish I could tell you that this counsel and plea turned Julie’s heart. But it did not. Instead, things were about to worsen yet again.

The Crisis Stage Accelerates: Addiction, Rehab, Adultery . . . and Flight

Within a week Julie had taken another downward turn. Nate called to say that she had resumed her regular drinking and smoking, had left him and the children, and had moved in with a man she had met at a bar. She had also met with an attorney to discuss her plan for a legal separation followed by divorce. Not surprisingly, she did not want to meet with us.

We met several times with Nate alone, reminding him of God’s promises for his life and giving him practical counsel on what to do and what not to do. In our times together, in conjunction with the elders, our counseling team developed a six-point crisis intervention plan.

Step one was to reach out to Julie. We decided who among the counseling team, church leaders, and small-group members would phone Julie (and when) to seek her out and engage her in discussion. We wanted Julie to be overwhelmed by the magnitude and consequences of her sin, the sincerity and breadth of our love, and the active pursuit of God’s grace—but not by an uncoordinated free-for-all approach which might confuse her with competing voices and crush her with unrelenting pressure.

Step two was to keep the church leaders updated on the situation in case it became necessary to move farther down the path of restorative church discipline. Obviously, the process of confronting Julie about her sin had already begun, and we wanted to be sure our church leaders were involved in our intensifying efforts to reclaim her.

Step three was to continue ministering spiritually to Nate through ongoing counsel, encouragement, and accountability. We wanted to help him pursue Christ in the midst of such a difficult situation. Together we discussed his identity in Christ, his ability to forgive Julie from the heart, and how he should treat Julie, especially when she visited the children. We agreed that given her drunkenness, instability, and irresponsibility, Nate should not allow her to take the children out of his home unless she pursued legal action (which she did not). We encouraged Nate to be civil and loving when Julie visited, to express his love and commitment to her and their marriage, to invite her to repent and recommit to the marriage, and to allow her time alone with the children while he went upstairs.

Step four involved advising Nate on legal steps (in case Julie initiated proceedings), child-care decisions, financial matters, church ministry commitments, and his response to inquiring church members. As he bore up under the pressure of complex details, swirling emotions, and weighty decisions, we needed to be faithful to provide him with the kind of external objectivity that we all need when facing overwhelming circumstances.

Step five focused on practical assistance for Nate. Todd and Jan discreetly shared with their small group the big picture of Nate and Julie’s situation. Since these faithful small-group leaders had been involved from the beginning, they were able to share about the situation carefully and compassionately and then mobilize their small group to assist Nate with meals, child care, and occasional housecleaning so that he could continue his full-time employment.

Step six involved counseling Nate and Julie’s three young children on how they should view the situation and respond to their mother. We sat down with the children and tried to explain to them in simple and gentle terms that their mom was living somewhere else right now; that she still loved them; that she was not following Jesus and obeying God right now; that they should pray for her; and that they should love her, respect her, and obey her when she visited.

Seemingly unconcerned about the devastation and confusion she was causing her family, Julie continued her prodigal ways over the next three months, including sexual involvement with one or two other men. During this time we continued to reach out to her and minister to Nate.

In God’s providence there was a small breakthrough when Julie’s new boyfriend kicked her out of his house, replacing her with another woman. Our counseling team (in conjunction with church leaders) introduced her to a mature Christian woman in the community who took Julie into her home, established and enforced strict rules concerning Julie’s behavior, and sought to talk with her about the Lord.

As Julie began to sober up both physically and spiritually, she grew willing to meet with us again. We reemphasized God’s grace and promises, reiterated her need to repent, explained what repentance would look like, and once again discussed her commitments to the Lord and to Nate. During this period we also helped Nate develop a set of reasonable conditions for Julie’s return to their home. In order to return, Julie needed to make a firm commitment to break completely her sinful relationships with other men, to abstain from alcohol and smoking (except for a nicotine patch under medical advisement), to resume individual and marital counseling with a recommitment to completing her homework, and to embrace daily accountability with specific mature women that we had designated to help her. Julie also needed to commit to learn and apply godly parenting principles, homemaking skills, and time-management practices with the help of several older women who would mentor and assist her. Finally, she also needed to be honest with Nate and to support his efforts to follow Jesus in his own life and to lead both her and the children. After much discussion Julie agreed to these terms. After months of wayward rebellion, she finally moved back in with her husband and family.

The Restoration Stage Arrives: Julie Finally Begins to Repent and Change

If one defines counseling as a conversation between one person who is earnestly seeking wisdom and another person who is feeding welcomed insights to a listening ear, then I had done little “counseling” with Julie. While she dutifully came to each session (prior to her flight of rebellion), her behavior made clear that she did not really want our help. She made little effort to follow my counsel and carry out the instructions we gave her, nor was she forthcoming about the depth of her difficulties. Eventually she fled into a pattern of sinful living. So in one sense Julie was not—strictly speaking—a counselee.

Church-based counseling is not consigned to the kind of finger-tapping approach that simply waits for the counselee to “come around.” Christ’s agenda for his people is much broader than that. Though much biblical counseling is reactive, we are not mainly to be responders but pursuers, like Jesus. Though Julie herself was not really pursuing change, our efforts to help her were not in vain for at least two reasons.

First, the sessions in my office were building a relationship between Julie and me, along with our counseling team. The time we spent together showed Julie our commitment to her. Even our admonitions and pleas were seen (as she later admitted) as acts of love, evidences to her that we truly cared despite her stubbornness. Our willingness to meet with Nate and Julie time after time in the face of paltry growth and growing opposition showed her God’s love embodied in her brothers and sisters. I’m afraid that in a professional, fee-based, nonchurch counseling setting, either Julie or the counselor would have ended counseling long before our final stage when restoration began to blossom.

Second, our church-based counseling went far beyond conversations in scheduled office sessions. As a team we were able to serve Nate and Julie practically and have conversations in more personal settings. Lauren, Jan, and two servant-hearted ladies from Julie’s small group were especially active in helping Julie, her husband, and their children through home visits, at-home companionship, cleaning, meals, and much more. Church-based counseling can and should go far beyond the weekly 50 minutes of talk therapy that so often qualifies as “counseling.” In our situation it was the body of Christ counseling Julie—patiently loving her in word, action, and presence, holding forth the hope of the gospel, and calling her to a meaningful commitment to Jesus and to her husband, children, and church. Despite the sporadic nature and apparent fruitlessness of the actual counseling sessions, God had been at work.

With her return to Nate and her family, we found in Julie a new desire to follow the Lord. In this sense she now became a true counselee. The prodigal daughter had returned. In many ways the work of individual and marital counseling was now just beginning. I found myself reviewing some of the same biblical teaching I had offered her earlier as well as reassigning some of the same practical assignments she had already been given. This time, though, the results were different.

Our team continued to address a variety of major issues in our remaining months of counseling, some of which differed from the issues we initially identified.

Fighting Old Addictions

While Julie stopped drinking, she continued to wrestle with desires to drink, smoke, and abuse prescription pain medications. Her previous injuries and surgery produced chronic bouts with pain, and she was still dogged by the desire to drown the pressures of life not only with legitimate relief but illegitimate “feel-good” means of escaping hardship. Her willingness to submit to accountability from her husband and friends was a vital behavioral fence. However, it was mainly the call to trust and obey God in the midst of pain coupled with the promise of a perfect body in the future that helped her guard her heart and endure by faith. Julie began to see how Jesus could indeed set her free (John 8:31–36) and how God’s Spirit could truly strengthen her as she faced the strong temptations to revert to addictive behavior. She was beginning to appropriate the truth of 1 Cor 10:13: “No temptation has overtaken you except what is common to humanity. God is faithful and he will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation he will also provide a way of escape, so that you are able to bear it.”

Strengthening the Marriage

Although Julie and her diverse problems have been the focus of this chapter, both Julie and Nate needed serious help to stabilize and strengthen their marriage. Most of all, they needed to learn to bear with, minister to, be gracious with, and forgive each other (Phil 2:1–5; Mark 10:45; Eph 4:29–5:2). Our team was so encouraged when Julie said, “I love Nate more than when we married.” A paradigm-creating passage that we unpacked and explored in several sessions was Col 3:12–17: In light of what God has done for us in choosing us, making us his own, loving us, and forgiving us (vv. 12–13), we should love our spouse with gospel-reflecting graces (vv. 12–14) and do all of our duties with God as our ultimate audience (v. 17). Because God has loved us, forgiven us, and humbled himself to serve us, we can love, forgive, and show humility toward our spouses. I helped Julie and Nate understand the triangular relationship of Christian marriage with God at the apex and their individual relationships with him and with each other completing the triangle. We also discussed Jay Adams’s pamphlet, What Do You Do When Your Marriage Goes Sour? which helped them see that biblical love is more a matter of service and commitment than merely a romantic feeling.

Restoring Sexual Intimacy

For Julie and Nate, sexual difficulties had existed long before we met for counseling, but their sexual relationship had virtually ceased during this nineteen-month saga. The challenge in their recommitted marriage included many of the factors that typically contribute to sexual problems—selfishness, resentment, ungodly communication—but was exacerbated by their joint consciousness of Julie’s infidelity. At times Julie experienced flashbacks of being with other men and would push Nate away, leading to recycled feelings of guilt over both her past actions and her present memories.

Further, earlier in the counseling process, we had encountered yet another surprise. During the months when Julie was living with the man she had met at the bar, Nate had confessed his own infidelity during a one-night stand early in their marriage. Although we had addressed Julie’s multiple adulteries in an initial way earlier on, we took Nate’s confession as a providential opportunity to deal thoroughly with their joint sins in this area. God in his grace brought about mutual confession, repentance, and forgiveness.

Weaning Off Psychiatric Medications

Before and during our lengthy counseling process, Julie had been taking a host of psychotropic drugs. Throughout counseling she had expressed a desire to come off of these drugs, and Nate had agreed. I reminded Julie on several occasions that other concerns were more pressing than the issue of her medications, assuring her that when the time was right, she would need to seek the oversight of a physician to wean her off of the medications. Now, in her season of restoration, she desired even more strongly to reduce her medications. Her prescribing doctors cooperated with her desire as she displayed more stability.

Yet there were still obstacles to overcome. Nate strongly desired that his wife be free of psychiatric medications, believing that a growing Christian should be able to handle life without them. But Julie was more ambivalent. On the one hand she agreed with Nate and felt guilty about needing her medications. On the other hand she feared what life would be like without them; depression was a terrifying prospect for her. On several occasions Nate’s desire led Julie to suddenly decrease or discontinue her doctor’s prescription without professional consultation. These rash decisions never ended well for Julie.

On one of these occasions, Julie slid into an out-of-control mania that could not be overcome even by hours of biblical talk. All of our efforts to talk her down—face-to-face or by phone—were fruitless. On one occasion, from 12:45–1:30 in the morning we sat by the phone as I repeatedly sought (to no avail) to center her mind on Ps 121:1–2: “I lift my eyes toward the mountains. Where will my help come from? My help comes from the Lord, the Maker of heaven and earth.” Thankfully, this episode was short-lived, and Julie was soon stabilized with the help of her prescribed medication. Despite these types of difficulties, over time Julie was able to reduce significantly her dependence on psychiactric medication through a controlled, physician-monitored step-down process.

Developing Parenting Skills

Marriage and parenting problems frequently merge in counseling, and Nate and Julie’s parenting differences were amplifying their conflicts. Four major recurring issues were simmering as they tried to parent their children together.

First, Julie was reluctant to discipline the kids. She admitted that she hated to hear her children cry or scream when she told them no. Her oversensitive capitulation also led her to butt in and overrule Nate even when he tried to parent the children with appropriate discipline. Here we helped Julie address her many fears by showing the biblical connection between love and discipline and explaining how a loving and controlled spanking was an appropriate and effective means of training her children. Along with sharing relevant passages of Scripture, we asked her to read Ginger Plowman’s insightful book, Don’t Make Me Count to Three.

Second, Nate and Julie disagreed about whether their children should sleep in bed with them. Julie was permissive, but Nate thought it needed to stop. Deep down Julie agreed, realizing that this issue was connected to her hatred of denying the children whatever they desired. As we discussed their disagreement in a controlled environment, Julie confessed her laxity and acknowledged its negative effects on the family. Together we worked out a reasonable plan to discontinue the habit.

Third, Nate and Julie disagreed on schooling options. In particular, they differed on the issue of homeschooling. Educating our children is a significant matter freighted with a heavy weight of responsibility and bound up with strong (and often divergent) opinions, so we knew it was essential to spend substantial time discussing this issue. Nate preferred that Julie homeschool their children and even did some hands-on teaching as they tried it. When Julie was unsuccessful, they wisely discontinued the step. This compromise turned out to be a major step in Nate’s life as he released one of his strong desires in order to serve the interests of his wife.

Finally, Nate and Julie disagreed about whether they should have more children. Nate wanted more, but Julie felt they should be finished. While this was clearly their decision, I encouraged Nate to let go of his agenda until Julie’s personal problems and their marriage problems improved. Even then I encouraged him to wait until Julie shared his desire for a fourth child. Nate agreed, and his humble acquiescence to Julie’s desire signaled another degree of change in his life as he grew in his love and service toward his wife.

Stabilizing Family Finances

Another area of pressure and conflict was Julie’s spending. At times her handling of finances was out of control, and she was often unwilling to stay within a budget. We helped Nate and Julie develop financial wisdom and budgeting practices by partnering with a church member trained with a biblically based financial counseling organization. Julie’s previous habit of running to the doctor’s office or emergency room and paying for prescriptions had taken its toll on their already-tight finances. To Nate’s frustration he was the one who frequently felt the weight of this debt. But as Julie learned to handle her personal struggles better and as their marital love and communication grew, they were able to reduce her expenditures and partner together on a spending plan.

Developing Homemaking Skills

Our formal counseling advice along with hands-on help from several godly women in the church helped Julie continue to develop her homemaking skills. It was encouraging to see how effective the body of Christ could be in such a practical area like nurturing a warm and efficient home environment. Women from both the counseling ministry and Julie’s small group volunteered to help. Improvements were small, but Lauren and Jan noticed steady progress.

Julie’s life was not perfect, but she was improving in many areas. With God’s help she had quit drinking and was enjoying significant victory over her increasingly irregular temptations. Under the care of a physician, Julie had also quit taking her psychiatric medication, and she was grateful to Jesus for his grace, which enabled her to respond to her trials without turning to prescription drugs. Nate and Julie’s marriage continued to grow as well. They were learning to navigate conflict, experiencing increased sexual intimacy, and maintaining their forgiveness for their previous sins against each other. Their children were becoming a renewed source of joy instead of a source of conflict as Nate and Julie grew in their ability to (jointly) apply loving, firm, and consistent discipline. They were also developing a healthy rhythm of income and spending which greatly reduced their conflict in this high-anxiety area of life. Seeing so many angles of good progress, we mutually agreed to discontinue formal counseling even though we continued to have ongoing conversations and check-up sessions. Their small group, which had offered such strong support and consistent help through their crisis stages, continued to be a source of fellowship and encouragement.

Conclusion: Lessons from a Hard Case

This case taught me a number of lessons, especially illustrating and confirming the value of both biblical and church-based counseling. First, in hard cases like these, psychiatric medications are not the answer; however, they may be useful for a limited time and limited purpose. Biblical counseling provides answers that psychiatric medications cannot. At best, medication can stabilize a person’s mind and mood for a season, but it cannot change the person. At the same time I was reminded of my need to communicate clearly with the counselee about her medications and to advise her and her husband on how to communicate with their doctors.

Second, in hard cases like these, secular counseling is not the answer. While Julie never pursued secular talk therapy on a weekly basis, she did receive some professional secular advice during her visits to her various psychiatrists. Her 30 days of rehab were also filled with individual and group therapy. But none of these efforts went deep enough to expose the self-centered, fearful, guilty, stubborn heart at the root of Julie’s struggles. And they never went high enough to connect her with her Redeemer, the one in whom she ultimately found forgiveness, hope, and the power for progressive change.

Third, in hard cases like these, even biblical counseling—if narrowly defined as mere biblical talk therapy—is not enough. Biblical counseling must not only be church based; it must also be church driven and church saturated. One of the critiques often leveled against biblical counseling is that we can leave observers thinking that all you need for successful counseling is a godly counselor, a Bible, the Holy Spirit, and a willing counselee. All biblical counseling that is faithful to the Scriptures will recognize the vital role played by the church in the life of a Christian counselee (see Romans 12; 1 Corinthians 12–14; Eph 4:1–16; 1 Thess 4:9–10; 5:12–15; Heb 3:12–14). People entangled in severe sins tend to isolate themselves for a variety of reasons. They are in love with their sin, ashamed of their sin, too proud to let others know, too self-sufficient to let others in, lack a true desire to change, believe they can beat their problems on their own, or don’t want to inconvenience their friends with their long-term problems that defy simple solutions. Julie herself was marked by some of these tendencies. As our counseling team walked with her over the long haul and our small group leaders discreetly mobilized her fellow small-group members, Julie experienced Christ’s love through us, his church.

Fourth, in hard cases like these, situational dynamics and counseling angles can change drastically. What began as a straightforward marital case morphed into intense counseling with one spouse, at least for a majority of the time. My initial plan was to counsel Nate and Julie on their marriage, but soon it became apparent that we needed to focus more on Julie. While Nate was not faultless and needed to change and while their relationship certainly needed help, we had to make some in-flight adjustments and center our attention on Julie.

Fifth, in hard cases like these, change is a long-term process. No eight-to-twelve-week counseling period—or even an eight-to-twelve-month counseling period—was long enough for Julie. Many factors prevented this from being a short-term case: her entrenched “Christian” legalism, her prior bad church experiences, her varied and chronic medical problems, her dependence on pain medications, her lack of extended family support, her husband’s high standards and critical spirit, the pressures of mothering several small children, her dishonesty about the depth of her difficulties, and her months-long flight from her Christian community—not to mention the everyday hindrances emanating from the world, the flesh, and the Devil.

Sixth, in hard cases like these, biblical counseling ultimately relies on the power of God’s Spirit working through individual and corporate means of grace. This is true in any life situation no matter how simple or complex, brief or prolonged. But the hard cases reveal a more pronounced need—a desperation—for the powerful grace of God to act with precision. As I reflect on my relationship with Nate and Julie, I realize that I did a good job but not a great job. At times I should have intervened more quickly; early on I missed the depth of Julie’s problems; I could have probed more deeply into Julie’s life and history; I misunderstood her psychiatric medications and how the doctors were trying to treat her; I underestimated the strength of her addictions; and I failed to adapt my own counseling strategy with Julie quickly enough. While I had used many of the same counseling methods successfully for many years, in Julie’s case they didn’t seem to “take.” Through this hard case God was not only gracious in changing Julie but was equally gracious in growing me into a more competent counselor.

I am grateful to God for Julie. She became my sister and my friend. From my sideline coaching box, she showed me how God was at work. She modeled a dim but persevering faith in the face of numerous obstacles, including her own entangling sins. One of my counseling professors often wished upon his students that at every point in our ministry we would have at least one hard case—a stubborn, slow-to-change person—to serve as a perpetual reminder that sin is deep, change is hard, growth is progressive, love requires patience, and God alone transforms people in his time and in his way. With Julie, my professor’s prayer for me was answered.

All names and identifying details have been changed, and many components in this story are composites from other cases. Further, while much of my counseling with Nate and Julie focused on their marriage, this chapter focuses mostly on my work with Julie, both in joint sessions (with Nate) and individual sessions (without Nate). Even the joint sessions were focused mainly on Julie. It was chiefly her behavior that made this case so difficult.

This model is summarized in my book Pursuing Peace: A Christian Guide to Handling Our Conflicts (Wheaton: Crossway, 2012).

Ken Sande with Tom Raabe, Peacemaking for Families: A Biblical Guide to Managing Conflict in Your Home (Carol Stream, IL: Tyndale, 2002).

The early passages I had them memorize were Jas 4:1–2, which roots our conflicts in our selfish desires; Mark 10:45, where Jesus serves as the ultimate example of service; and Eph 4:32, which calls Christians to forgive as they have been forgiven in Christ.

The truth of definitional sanctification—also known as definitive sanctification, positional sanctification (though this term can be understood too narrowly), or initial sanctification—is underplayed in too many evangelical churches.

C. J. Mahaney, The Cross Centered Life: Keeping the Gospel the Main Thing (Colorado Springs: Multnomah, 2002).

For the sake of space and focus, I am not documenting the conversations we had with Nate in both joint and individual sessions. In these important conversations we challenged him about his own anger and frustrations over Julie’s failures and about his selfish demands that she change. His dreams of a strong, growing, exemplary Christian marriage too often controlled his heart and kept him from tenderly and patiently loving his troubled wife. He too needed the pardoning and empowering grace of God shown in Jesus. Over time we did see the Lord transform him.

At this point Julie was taking a shelf of prescribed medications including Lexepro, Klonopin, Wellbutrin, and Trazadone for anxiety, depression, and insomnia. She also took methadone for back pain, a Clonidine patch for nicotine withdrawal, and Synthroid for hypothyroidism, as well as over-the-counter Excedrin for occasional migraines. This diverse intake also meant that two or three different prescribing physicians were involved. Changing doctors—always seeking a new source of hope (and a new prescription)—frequently marked Julie’s path. This revolving door also produced further marriage problems because Nate saw Julie as both fleeing life’s pressures and overspending their money on office visits and medications that she would not need if she were truly seeking the Lord.

See Edward T. Welch, Addictions: A Banquet in the Grave (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 2001).

The NT clearly teaches the necessity of church discipline for the purity of the church, the validity of her testimony, and the spiritual health of her members; see Matt 18:15–20; 1 Cor 5:1–13; 2 Cor 2:5–11; Gal 6:1–2. These passages lay out clear principles and practices for gracious, loving, and firm church discipline which aims at restoration. However, while Matt 18:15–20 outlines the intensifying steps Christians and church leaders should take with wayward brothers and sisters, the length of time between each step depends on the unique dynamics of each situation. Paul explained how to deal with several different types of unhealthy church members, but his overarching principle is patience with all (1 Thess 5:14).

Jay E. Adams, What Do You Do When Your Marriage Goes Sour? (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 1975).

The substance of my approach can now be found in my Restoring Your Broken Marriage: Healing After Adultery (Greensboro, NC: New Growth Press, 2009). I also used Ken Sande’s excellent book Peacemaking for Families to aid in the confession, repentance, and forgiveness process.

Ginger Plowman, Don’t Make Me Count to Three: A Mom’s Look at Heart-Oriented Discipline (Wapwallopen, PA: Shepherd Press, 2004).

↑ Back to top

↑