Chapter 10 of 16

Chapter 9: “Jason” and Homosexuality

Chapter 9: “Jason” and Homosexuality

Chapter 9

“Jason” and Homosexuality

Kevin Carson

When Jason arrived for counseling, he looked like any other single, career-minded 25-year-old. At first glance he would fit in almost any church. But as he began his story, Jason made clear that what brought him to Sonrise for counseling was also what made him feel alone, scared, and rejected by the church. A friend had heard about our counseling ministry and convinced him at least to try it. Although Jason was still fearful, he decided to come. He began, “I love God, and I believe he loves me and wants me to be happy. I just don’t know how my life fits together. I struggle with same-sex attraction. I spend time with other guys.” Jason’s struggle was with the sin of homosexuality.

As he told his story, Jason’s demeanor varied greatly: quivering lips, tear-filled eyes, awkward smiles, and intense scowls. He described how he grew up in the church and knew early on what the Bible teaches about homosexuality. He also explained his goal for counseling: “Since it’s a sin and God doesn’t like it, I don’t want to struggle with this anymore. I want to be happy and to feel good, but I don’t want to sin or to think about what God doesn’t want me to think about.” Although he described his struggle as a sin, he continued: “I enjoy the company of other guys, and it makes me happy. I know God wants me to be happy and have joy—and this is just one of the things that makes me happy.” Jason continued, “I wonder, though, how it fits together. I’m told—and I see it when I read the Bible—it’s not good in the Bible. Yet it seems good in my life.”

What do you do with Jason? His testimony is that he loves God and that he desires not to sin. Yet he is happy when he is with other guys and is sure God wants him to be happy.

Before you whip out your Bible and begin to wax eloquent regarding the wickedness of homosexuality, its hurtful consequences, its reckless health risks, and the overall disgust you may feel toward Jason’s life choices, there are several key issues to consider. As a counselor, your decisions prior to counseling Jason are as critical as your decisions when you counsel him. Who you are, how you live, and what you think about those whose lives are filled with sexual sin are critical questions to ponder. Every time a new Jason comes to you for help, your preparation for these initial moments of counseling matters greatly.

Getting Priorities Straight: Jason’s Counselor

Counselors in training often hear the adage, “A good counselor is first a good counselee.” If you hope to please God as you minister the gospel to others, it is important that the gospel first be at work in your own heart. This is sometimes referred to as self-counsel. The mature counselor considers his own thoughts, attitudes, desires, and behaviors, pursuing the Spirit’s refining ministry in his life as he seeks to develop the thoughts, attitudes, desires, and behaviors manifested by Christ when he ministered on earth (Eph 4:1; Phil 2:5). This process requires a lifelong commitment by the counselor and is essential before counseling those embroiled in sexual sin or any other sin.

In addition, with regard to homosexuality and other sexual sins, the counselor must carefully consider which potential authority is influencing his counsel. There are a number of options for an authority that could be influencing a counselor. The authority could take the form of his professed belief system (formal), or it could take the form of his practical beliefs that exercise real-time control over his thinking and counseling (functional), even though these practical beliefs differ from his professed belief system. Typically, the counselor operates from some combination of both formal and functional authorities. There are at least three potential authorities that influence a counselor’s approach to Jason: contemporary culture, previous experience, and scriptural knowledge.

Counseling from Contemporary Culture

Jason’s story presents almost a perfect case study demonstrating how easy it is for cultural perspectives to control one’s counseling. His parents divorced when he was four years old, and he lived with his mom who remarried almost immediately. Jason’s mom and stepdad went to church, but his father did not. Jason describes his mom as “very, very strict—I had to do everything by the book when I was living with her.” However, when he would go to his dad’s house every other weekend, things were different: “It was a release. It was an escape. I could do whatever I wanted.” Jason’s dad was uninterested in spending time with him (Jason described his father as “passive”), so he spent time primarily with “bad friends at my dad’s house.” The contrast was significant. “It was a different life, but I never let my mom know I was hanging out with those friends because she wouldn’t have liked any of them.”

At the age of seven he was first introduced to sexually explicit material through one of these friends. While upstairs in a friend’s house, they discovered magazines that included both heterosexual and homosexual pictures. Jason said, “Every time we had free time, we would go back to that same spot. We’d make sure no one knew we were there, and we’d put the pictures back just like we found them.” This launched a lifelong battle with the desire to view pornography. Over time curiosity and lust drove Jason to view primarily homosexual pornography.

While in junior high he realized that he enjoyed hanging out with his male friends as they were talking about girls. “I would talk to my guy friends about girls, and that was fine because I liked spending time with the guys. Plus, I didn’t want them to think I didn’t like girls.” As he moved into high school, Jason even dated a few girls. “I had several that I was really close to, but it was more of a cover to make sure nobody knew that what I really wanted was my guy friends and spending time with them.”

Jason never remembered a time when he chose homosexual behavior. “I just never liked girls,” he recalled. “In fact, I find that I’m often most interested in what people would call ‘girly’ things.” He used his image as an example: “My appearance is important to me, and I believe it’s important to God, too.” A typical week for Jason included a couple of trips to the gym, a haircut, getting his nails done, and going shopping. “It’s really important that when I go out, people notice that I take care of myself,” Jason explained. “I don’t want them to think otherwise, and I think God cares about it too.”

Over the years Jason’s desire for friendships dominated his behavior. He lived a life full of deception. Just as he hid his secret passions from his guy and girl friends, he believed he could not share his struggle with either his parents or anyone at church. “I would always think, If people figure out who I really am, I’ll lose all my friends.” He went on to describe his predicament: “I never shared my struggle. I thought a lot of people would stop talking to me, and I would lose all the friends I had . . . so I didn’t want to tell anybody at the church about this.” Therefore, he often found himself living with various levels of deception at home, around friends, at school, and at church. It was not until after high school that he began active homosexual practices.

You can see how Jason’s story contains key elements often identified with male homosexuality: a dominant mother, a passive father, early exposure to sexually explicit pictures or acts, and an inclination toward homosexual tendencies. It is certainly true that there are many potential factors contributing to a person’s struggle with same-sex attraction. People are complex, and their responses to their diverse life circumstances can be complex. The critical issue is how I consider Jason: Do I see him as the product of his biological makeup or his genetic code, the result of a poor relationship with his same-sex parent, the outcome of early sexual stimuli, or one fearing rejection by others due to low self-esteem? If I accept contemporary secular explanations for homosexuality as part of the cause, then I am ultimately accepting culture as the authority for understanding and helping Jason. Or I can take the perspective that the ultimate cause of Jason’s homosexual behavior is his sinful heart and that all of these important pieces of data make up various significant influences or pressures to which his sinful heart responded.

Counseling from Previous Experience

A second potential authority for the counselor is his own previous life experience. When a person hears Jason’s story, similar stories may come to mind. Many personal experiences can cloud one’s ability to counsel Jason, such as your own past—whether you have committed sexual sins or you have been sinned against sexually; whether others you know were engaged in sexual sin but never changed, such as counselees who said they were changed but then returned to their original sexual sins, and so on. If you are not aware of this potential authority, then you might counsel Jason from your own experience rather than from what the Bible presents as the true authority in his situation. Again, the goal is to catch any differences between your formal and functional authority or theology.

Counseling from Scriptural Knowledge

A third potential authority is scriptural knowledge. Obviously, considering the convictions of this book, Scripture must serve as the foundation and source of the counsel offered to Jason. However, beyond the issue of right and wrong, the answers are not always simple when it comes to homosexuality and the Bible. You may never have considered what the Bible teaches about homosexuality or sexual sins in general, especially regarding the potential for and process of change. It is important not to allow a lack of knowledge to influence your opportunity with Jason and to create a wrong functional authority in this situation. I would want any counselor to consider a few key passages and their implications before counseling Jason.

Your Opportunity—Ministry (Hebrews 13:17). This verse says, “Obey your leaders and submit to them, for they keep watch over your souls as those who will give an account, so that they can do this with joy and not with grief, for that would be unprofitable for you” (emphasis added). First, as a counselor (functioning as an extension of the local church and under the authority of its leadership), you must recognize that God has called you to be a guardian of Jason’s soul. You have a great and weighty responsibility before God due to the spiritual direction you offer and the ministry decisions you make on behalf of those you counsel. What incredible accountability! God pays attention to the decisions made by Christians engaged in personal ministry! Think of it this way: God’s wonderful plan for you always includes the person in front of you, whether Jason or someone else. He has given you the opportunity to speak into this person’s life in a wise and godly way. Therefore, it is essential that you as a counselor carefully examine your heart to evaluate your attitude toward any individual God places in your ministry path. You are responsible for your response and advice to Jason.

Your Attitude—Humility (1 Corinthians 10:12–13). Each counselor is also wise to consider Paul’s explanation of temptation: “No temptation has overtaken you except what is common to humanity. God is faithful, and He will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation He will also provide a way of escape so that you are able to bear it.” Paul declared that no temptation falls outside of the biblical category of common human experience. This is an essential reminder because, when faced with someone like Jason engaged in homosexual sin, it is easier to see his issues as different rather than common. In fact, the cultural perspective on many life problems (especially when mixed with our own personal experiences) tempts us to believe that many issues fall outside of this biblical category of “common to humanity.” Paul helps us overturn our preconceived ideas regarding the problem or circumstance facing us. No matter how much I am tempted to believe that the person in front of me or the situation calling for my attention is different or abnormal, the Bible calls me back to a clear, biblical, and hopeful perspective. Paul reminds me that no matter how uncommon someone’s story may sound to me, I must draw my conclusions within the biblical boundaries of common human experience.

Paul chose the term peirasmos in this text, which is translated “temptation.” However, peirasmos is a neutral term, meaning either “temptation” or “trial.” The context determines its emphasis. As a trial, this term may refer to any pressured situation one may face where ultimately the person chooses to glorify God (Jas 1:2–12). As a temptation, it means that one’s heart has responded to any pressured situation in a way that involves temptation to sin (Jas 1:13–15). In either case the situation itself is the same. The difference is the individual’s heart response. One individual responds by enduring the trial and glorifying God; the other individual responds by being lured and drawn away to sin. Here in 1 Cor 10:13, Paul used the general sense of the term. He emphasized that there is no pressured situation (which would also include the temptation to sexual sin or homosexuality) that falls outside the category of typical human experience (anthropinos, translated “common to humanity”).

So how do you apply this biblical category of common temptation as well as the larger context of this passage to Jason’s situation? You ought to view Jason as a person who faces temptations, just like every other individual. Jason definitely has responded in ungodly ways to his temptations—he has chosen sin. Yet we must guard against our own temptation to focus primarily on the nature of the sexual sin and thereby miss seeing it as the untamed result of a heart full of sexual lust. The greater context of 1 Cor 10 suggests that from God’s vantage point committing sexual immorality is no more immoral than complaining (v. 10). For many of us, those guilty of sexual sin rank much differently from the average complainer in our church. Yet both sins fit within the biblical category of “common.”

Further, when we fail to recognize the common thread running through Jason’s sin and our own, we set ourselves up for failure: “So, whoever thinks he stands must be careful not to fall” (1 Cor 10:12). Counselors often respond poorly to those seeking help when we forget, even for a few moments, that we are equally susceptible to sin and that we must remain continually aware of our own hearts. The root of Jason’s sexual sin is the same fundamental root threatening to sprout in every counselor’s heart. Lingering too long on a revealing TV show, looking at an immodest picture online, imagining an inappropriate relationship, or taking a second look at an attractive guy or girl on the street are temptations for us all. Every single person engaged in personal ministry must heed this warning.

Your Hope—Change (1 Corinthians 6:9–11). Paul warns, “Don’t you know that the unrighteous will not inherit God’s kingdom? Do not be deceived: No sexually immoral people, idolaters, adulterers, or anyone practicing homosexuality [literally: passive homosexual partners, active homosexual partners], no thieves, greedy people, drunkards, verbally abusive people, or swindlers will inherit God’s kingdom” (vv. 9–10). Paul highlighted the general behavior of unbelievers in order to emphasize how believers should act consistently with our position in Christ (see Rom 6:1–10). He gave a lengthy laundry list of sins that generally characterize an unbeliever rather than a believer. Although his was not an exhaustive list, Paul clearly declared these sins as he dealt with a great majority of the moral issues a counselor typically faces. Notice that Paul included sexually immoral people, adulterers, or anyone practicing homosexuality.

Paul does not finish his discussion here. He said, “And some of you used to be like this. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God” (v. 11, emphasis added). Paul understood the “common” element of sin and temptation. He knew that all kinds of sinners have been saved. Jason has hope because God’s grace is powerful enough to take someone from being dead in sin to alive in Christ (Eph 2:1–10). It is this same powerful grace that gives any person enslaved to homosexual sin the hope of change. God’s grace is grace unto change (Titus 2:11–15).

Your Approach—Kindness (2 Timothy 2:24–26). These verses say, “The Lord’s slave must not quarrel, but must be gentle to everyone, able to teach, and patient, instructing his opponents with gentleness. Perhaps God will grant them repentance leading them to the knowledge of the truth. Then they may come to their senses and escape the Devil’s trap, having been captured by him to do his will.” Paul wrote these words to Timothy, his ministry protégé who was facing various ministry pressures. Paul instructed Timothy on how to minister well in the midst of these challenges. Notice the attitudes necessary for the Lord’s servants (including counselors): not argumentative but rather patient, kind to everyone, striving to teach, and offering correction with humility. When dealing with the sin of homosexuality and navigating the great cultural and moral debates in society, it is easy for a counselor to judge Jason inaccurately and harshly. Instead, with self-control and kindness, we should desire to communicate the truths of the Bible with the love and grace the Bible itself requires.

In our first session Jason shared about the struggle he had with his church. He reported that his pastor “talks about homosexuals as perverts and people who are lovers of themselves.” He later said, “Really, he [the pastor] just didn’t care for them [homosexuals] and it sounded as though he would just kick me out of the church if he knew how I was struggling.” Jason’s experience is similar to another man I counseled, who said of his church, “The pastors handed me off and passed me on to other people as if I were a baton. They didn’t seem comfortable with helping me and maybe not even comfortable talking to me.” Of course, the counselor often hears only one side of the story, and someone struggling with homosexual desires will certainly be extremely sensitive to any remarks about homosexuality coming from the church. Nevertheless, why do Jason and many others who share his struggle perceive that they are being treated with such disdain? Often it is because some Christians make thoughtless remarks and use sarcasm to address this hot-button sin, never considering the impact of their remarks on those who may be embroiled in an intense battle. Many Christians are repulsed by homosexuality and see the sinner not only as broken but also disgusting and dismissible. The reaction of society at large has often shared this disgust—picking on homosexuals, mocking homosexual characteristics, and generally rejecting the homosexual as a “sissy,” “mama’s boy,” “dyke,” “faggot,” and “queer.” Jason and others like him find themselves with nowhere to go—they are as rejected in the church as they are in the locker room—so they turn to other homosexuals for love and acceptance. But Paul reminded us that ministers of the gospel are not qualified to serve as ministers of the gospel if we contribute to this harsh and unloving approach toward those who most need our message and our counsel.

Your Calling—Restoration (Galatians 6:1–5, 10). This is the final passage a counselor should consider before counseling Jason because this is where Paul presented the Christian community with a clear vision of the goal of counseling:

Brothers, if someone is caught in any wrongdoing, you who are spiritual should restore such a person with a gentle spirit, watching out for yourselves so you also won’t be tempted. Carry one another’s burdens; in this way you will fulfill the law of Christ. For if anyone considers himself to be something when he is nothing, he deceives himself. But each person should examine his own work, and then he will have a reason for boasting in himself alone, and not in respect to someone else. For each person will have to carry his own load. . . . Therefore, as we have opportunity, we must work for the good of all, especially for those who belong to the household of faith.

The goal in counseling is always to work for the good of the counselee, and Paul declared that what is good is restoration, which refers to bringing a fellow believer back to a place of usefulness. It was a common word for fixing something that was broken or torn. This kind of restoration takes place when the counselor, with a gentle spirit, comes alongside the one in sin and helps carry the overwhelming baggage that we take on when we choose temporarily to enslave ourselves to sin and its consequences. At the same time the counselor must humbly evaluate his own heart to determine how he himself is doing in his efforts to live consistently with the gospel.

Galatians 6 orients the counselor toward the right goal: restoration. Restoration means that Jason would learn to live life with the ultimate purpose of pleasing God through the power of the gospel (2 Cor 5:9). This ultimate purpose is vital because, if the counselor is not careful, both he and Jason can end up with the sole functional goal of eradicating homosexual desires and cultivating heterosexual desires. However, the counselor should begin the counseling process with the understanding that God’s goal is that Jason return to a place of usefulness for God’s purposes, which means living life in the Spirit (Gal 5:13–26) and learning to say no to the temptations of the crucified flesh with its passions and desires (Gal 5:24). This means that both the formal and functional goal of counseling (in any situation) is for the believer to glorify God regardless of the type of temptation that needs to be overcome.

Once again the counselor must carefully consider his own attitude toward homosexuality and similar sins before beginning the counseling process. As I began with Jason, I could not let contemporary culture, personal experiences with others, a limited knowledge of Scripture, a lack of understanding about Jason’s specific sins, failure to see my own susceptibility to sin, or an underestimating of the possibility of real change keep me from ministering God’s Word effectively to this struggling soul.

Jason’s Struggle

You already know most of Jason’s story. He was a church-going 25-year-old from a divorced family where dad was passive, mom was dominant, and stepdad was absent. He stumbled across homosexual pornography at age seven and spent his junior high and high school years hiding his homosexual desires from everyone around him. After high school he began expressing his homosexuality in physical immorality, yet he maintained his secrecy, afraid that he would be rejected by his church community if the darkness of his heart were ever exposed. He came to me scared and confused, and only at the urging of a friend.

As I got to know Jason, he began explaining more of his current struggles. He shared that he often fantasized about guys he saw when he was in public places. “I struggle with fantasizing and thinking about friends I know or even just people I see at the coffee shop or at the mall.” He further explained that the more he visited certain public places, the easier it was for him to quickly survey a room and “know” who was or was not “like” him. “When I go somewhere, I know that I can just take a glimpse around the room and kind of see who’s who and potentially spot the people who are just like me—and I can tell if they’re looking at me. Usually they smile. It happens a lot at the gym and the coffee shop, and particular places at the mall.” Jason continued to explain that this kind of self-trained intuition was one way he would often meet people. Another method was through the Internet in chat rooms (or similar places). Often these conversations would end with an agreement to meet somewhere in public and talk about their history, backgrounds, likes and dislikes, and how they came to this point in life. This process of meeting other potential partners through surveying the crowd at specific public spots or surfing the Internet (in particular chat rooms) is often referred to as “cruising.” In Jason’s case he was looking for long-term relationships of acceptance and love. In many cases, though, it was just a one-day or multiple-day experience. Jason explained his desires: “I feel loved when other guys are around me and pay attention to me, and we talk with each other about things that we both care about. I just love being around people who are just like me.”

Jason also described a life driven by feelings. Even as he helped me understand his concept of God, his conceptualization was a colorful illustration of his feeling-orientation:

One thing that really perplexes me is the way God is talked about in church, and he is willing to do so much for us in sending Christ and he cares about us so much. I feel like I care for my friends and the guys I am attracted to because I care for them like God cares for me. I wonder why my feelings are wrong. If God loves us and I feel loved when I am around another guy and we spend time together and I enjoy their company and it makes me happy, then why is it wrong if God wants me to be happy and have joy?

Jason understood how he felt and was allowing those feelings to guide his decision-making process. However, he did not know how to evaluate those feelings and ideas about God biblically.

The longer I talked with Jason, the more I recognized that his most powerful temptations arose on nights when he had spent the day alone. Returning home after a long day, he would sit alone and become angry, then down, and then he would stop caring about what happened next. To feel better he might choose a trip to the mall or a visit to an online chatroom; but either way he would go searching for some kind of connection with another guy to make himself feel better.

Like any other human being, Jason had a blend of thoughts, feelings, desires, and behaviors that needed to be considered in light of the gospel. If I were to focus solely on his homosexual desires, I would miss the greater whole. The temptation when counseling someone like Jason is to see the blinking neon light of homosexuality as the issue and to miss the many issues seething in his heart. But Jason’s fundamental problem was much bigger than an attraction to guys.

As I began to listen, I started making a list of issues to address as I sought to minister the gospel to this professed brother in Christ. Among other issues, I wrote:

  • lives for his feelings
  • craves attention from others
  • longs for affection, affirmation, relationship, acceptance
  • some rebellion against the legalism of his church and against his parents
  • anger
  • As you scan this initial list, you will notice a striking absence: the sin of homosexuality is not even on the list yet. This is because it is one issue among many. Although it will be necessary to pay particular attention to it, the issue of homosexuality is no different from any of the other issues in Jason’s life. Therefore, counsel to Jason must be able to address his experience of life as he knows it—dealing honestly about current research, the culture, his past, his behaviors; moreover, counsel must also in grace recognize that Jason needs a spiritual friend full of compassion and biblically sound advice who can help reorient Jason to understand his life through the lens of the gospel.

    Jason’s Process

    Jason was involved in high-handed and persistent sin. It is good and right to question whether Jason was a true believer—not because he struggled with homosexual behavior but because often his behavior (whether homosexual or not) was willful and persistent. In the first session I had asked Jason about his relationship with Jesus Christ. He professed to be a believer in Christ and could articulate the reasons. Therefore, I took him at his word and assumed that he was a struggling believer like so many other Christians. Ultimately his growth in Christlikeness proved this assumption to be correct, though there were bumps and questions along the way.

    Counseling someone like Jason is not an event but a process. Jason had heard plenty of platitudes, and he had heard the law of God his entire life. He needed counsel (and a counselor) that reflected the thoughtful sensitivity of 1 Thess 5:14: “And we exhort you, brothers: warn those who are irresponsible, comfort the discouraged, help the weak, be patient with everyone.” A main goal of mine was to be patient throughout the process. There would be times to warn and admonish, times to comfort and encourage, and times simply to help Jason through a particularly long day of struggle. Regardless, the road with Jason would require patience as we sought together to strengthen his ability to honor God in the midst of his daily battles. As you read about the process we walked through, keep in mind that these are only the big-picture steps we took together. Each primary concept or passage does not reflect a particular exchange or an individual session but lengthy conversations and multiple sessions. This long-term approach is mandatory in the long walk toward godliness because the road of leaving homosexual behavior is not a nine-to-twelve-week road.

    Normalizing the Abnormal

    My first session with Jason was tense. My goal was to demonstrate that I was genuinely interested in him as a professing believer, and I respected his courageous step to seek help. Jason expected to be dismissed by me as having a sin that was gross. I wanted him to know that I viewed him as a fellow struggler who needed God’s grace to change. The primary question in my mind was this: What is Jason’s experience of his current problem?

    There were many angles from which to approach Jason, but my hope was to address the broader battle of what was currently gripping his heart. Finding an accurate aerial perspective would require many questions and extended listening; developing the details of someone’s story and how he is currently responding to life pressures always takes time. As I listened to Jason’s story, it became apparent that he did not believe his experiences fit within the broader category of a Christian’s typical life experience. So before we ended our first session, I reviewed 1 Cor 10:13 with him in an effort to help him make sense of these things. Jason was aware that something was broken in his life—and it was him! I wanted him to have hope in the fact that although he felt so broken, he was actually no more broken than anyone else. His sinfulness did not relegate him to the fringes and the margins of humanity. Rather, his experience was part of common human experience. The good news for Jason was that God desires to demonstrate the glories of his marvelous grace and his never-ending faithfulness by redeeming and restoring broken people.

    As I sought to normalize what Jason considered abnormal, two particular emphases seemed to resonate with him. First, he could appreciate Paul’s encouraging words offered to those facing seemingly inescapable pressures: God would be faithful to help Jason by providing “a way of escape” so that Jason would be “able to bear it” (1 Cor 10:13, emphasis added). The idea of bearing a burden emphasizes a process of perseverance. I wanted Jason to know that we were not looking for God to work some kind of magic that would make his significant pressures disappear overnight. Instead, God promised that throughout the long journey of growth, he would provide grace equal to every challenge. So if Jason were willing, I was committing to walk the path with him and to help him through the process of bearing this burden.

    The second truth that resonated with Jason was the realization that God does not promise to alleviate our pressures. Instead, God promises to be faithful in the midst of our pressures. This truth is significant because it enables us to define counseling “success” in light of reality. Certainly, it was natural for Jason to set his sights on eradicating his struggle with same-sex attraction. Yet whether or not his temptation completely disappeared, by God’s grace Jason could obtain the necessary tools for making it through the temptation. Whenever and however he was tempted, Jason would have the strong help of a faithful God and the undying power of the gospel of Christ.

    Jason was willing to walk this journey with me and also agreed to take some practical steps to cultivate growth between sessions. I gave him some purposeful assignments for the first week. (1) Memorize 1 Cor 10:13 by writing it on a card and reviewing it five times each day. (2) Fill your mind with the statement “God’s grace is up to the challenge” by writing it down and reviewing it 20 times each day. (3) Begin reading 2 Corinthians 5 and write down preliminary thoughts about what it means and how it applies to your situation. (4) Begin a temptation journal where you record each instance when you are tempted so that you can begin to discern bigger themes in your life and struggle.

    For his temptation journal I wanted Jason to become a good journalist, observing and investigating his own heart so that we could use his recorded insights in a strategic battle against his sin and temptation. I asked him to answer questions like these:

  • What was going on when you struggled?
  • When did you struggle?
  • Where were you?
  • What were you thinking?
  • What were you feeling?
  • How did you respond?
  • Did you resist?
  • If you resisted, what were you thinking about?
  • How did you resist?
  • If you did not resist, what were you thinking about?
  • How did you respond to your failure?
  • The Gospel and the Love of Christ

    After hearing Jason’s story in our first session, the topic for our second session was clear: the love of Christ seen in the gospel. We began to consider the implications of this good news for Jason and his struggle. He had read 2 Corinthians 5 during the previous week, and we discussed what he thought it meant along with its implications for his circumstances. After putting the passage in its larger context and sharing with Jason its specific meaning, I focused our attention on three key verses. I hoped to help him begin to grasp a much bigger context for his life—the specific purpose of pleasing and honoring God. The only way this would happen was for Jason to understand the centrality of God’s love, seen through the work of Christ in the gospel.

    2 Corinthians 5:21. This verse says, “He made the One who did not know sin to be sin for us, so that we might become the righteousness of God in Him.” Paul explained the heart of the gospel message: God placed the sin of mankind on Jesus (including Jason’s homosexual sins) so that mankind could be forgiven (including Jason) and could enjoy a restored relationship with God. God treated Jesus as if he had sinned Jason’s sins, and God treats Jason as if he had lived Jesus’ perfect life of righteousness. I went on to explain how God imputes the righteousness of Christ to the believer. I wanted Jason to begin to comprehend the incredible love of God demonstrated by Jesus on the cross.

    Jason and I also discussed his previous week’s homework. He had more questions about 1 Cor 10:13 and had been encouraged by the constant reminder of God’s grace and faithfulness throughout the week. He had also begun his temptation journal which we took some time to review. His journal was specific for a few days and then trailed off toward the weekend when he had embraced temptation and gone cruising on the Internet. He visited the coffee shop and met with a man with whom he had previously interacted with online, but by God’s grace they did not go anywhere together. The weekend’s struggle provided a great opportunity to discuss the other two key verses from 2 Corinthians 5.

    2 Corinthians 5:9. This verse says, “Therefore, whether we are at home or away, we make it our aim to be pleasing to Him.” The goal for Paul and for every believer is to aim at pleasing God. Jason’s temptation journal was helpful at this point because it allowed us to hone in on his specific temptations and to review whether his guiding purpose in those moments was to please God or to please himself. For Paul, the compelling motivation to please God came from embracing the love of Christ in the gospel. “For Christ’s love compels us, since we have reached this conclusion: If One died for all, then all died. And He died for all so that those who live should no longer live for themselves, but for the One who died for them and was raised” (2 Cor 5:14–15). As Jason learned to consider Christ’s love for him, such recognition would serve as a strong motivator for a life of obedience to this One who died for him. Clearly, Jason’s weekend struggle came not from a desire to please Christ out of grateful obedience; rather, his desire to please himself dominated his thoughts and actions.

    Nevertheless, Jason’s sin over the weekend reestablished his need to live in recognition of the gospel. He desperately needed to adopt Paul’s life purpose as his own—to conduct himself in a manner well-pleasing to God. I tried to communicate to Jason that this restored lifestyle would not result from simple teeth-gritting efforts but would arise from his recognition of his righteous status in Christ due to Christ’s sacrifice on the cross.

    Before he left our second session, I gave Jason some more practical steps to take during the week. I wanted him to continue his helpful temptation journal and to go deeper into 2 Corinthians 5, recording his observations and thoughts as he read. I also had him start reading A Gospel Primer for Christians by Milton Vincent, which would continue to saturate his mind and heart in the glories of Christ’s work on his behalf. Jason also needed to make a serious structural change. From his temptation journal we had discerned that the coffee shop, the gym, and the Internet were all places where Jason was tempted most severely. We determined together that it would be wisest for him to quit going to the gym or the coffee shop and to install an Internet filter. I explained that these structural changes were not designed to please God simply by Jason performing them; instead, such changes would function as guardrails helping him keep his new commitments.

    2 Corinthians 5:17. When Jason showed up for week three, he was visibly down. Although he had just committed to avoiding the coffee shop, the gym, and the Internet, he had done all three. “I wanted to do what was right,” he confessed, “but I felt like I couldn’t.” Early in the week he had been contacted by an old friend who was visiting from out of town. Jason had shared a relationship with this friend in the past. He wanted to go out. One thing led to another, with Jason failing to follow through on his commitments. Again, Jason’s sovereign God was allowing these circumstances in order to highlight the remaining key verse in our gospel-saturated chapter of Scripture: “Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation; old things have passed away, and look, new things have come” (2 Cor 5:17). This verse helped Jason realize that God had given him a new heart at salvation, and he could please God with this new heart. We once again discussed how God desired to change him from the inside out, and God had already started that process when Jason was born again. The difficulty Jason was facing was not the impossibility of earning God’s gracious salvation but the challenge of living consistently with the salvation God had already worked in his heart.

    It was a joy to help Jason recognize that God was changing him one step at a time and that God’s grace had actually been up to the challenge, even though he did not feel like it in the midst of his temptation. It was necessary to remind Jason that his goal was Christlikeness and that his life direction was to please God—to live like the “new” had really come. Despite his setback, if he would continue the journey of growth as a believer clothed in the righteousness of Christ, progress would come. Although Jason and I were both disappointed, it was essential that we not become discouraged with his failure. Rather, we needed to remember that Jesus had paid for Jason’s sin the previous week, and Jason still stood forgiven in Christ. Because Jason could see that growth would be slow, I also wanted him to remember that on some days being pointed in the right direction is as important as actual progress.

    For homework following this third session, I asked Jason to continue reading Milton Vincent’s A Gospel Primer because resetting his mind’s orientation toward the gospel would require a lengthy process. I also encouraged him to read 1 Cor 6:9–11 and to write down his initial thoughts about its meaning and application. We also created a stronger practical plan to keep him from getting online or visiting the coffee shop and the gym. Finally, Jason would also begin participating in a specific small group at church and would discuss his need of accountability with the group mentors.

    Identity

    When Jason initially came to me, he was wondering why his life felt so disconnected and disordered. He was afraid to share his story because he feared rejection and saw himself as broken. He did not identify with Christ or with the church, the body of Christ. He primarily identified with the guys he met online or while cruising his favorite public places. Even in his speech Jason often used terms like “us,” “we,” and “them.” He said, “In a sense we are outsiders to the public since we share a common bond in that we like other men.” He later said, “I just love being around these types of people who are just like me.” These are just a few of the instances where Jason identified strongly with others who practiced homosexuality. His self-perception is not uncommon. Often those wrestling with same-sex attraction or who have chosen a homosexual lifestyle see themselves as categorically different from family, childhood friends, coworkers, and church members. In many ways Jason is right. When he told his family about his struggle several years ago, his dad began viewing him as strange and different, and his mom wondered how she failed him. Early on his church also made clear through hurtful statements in sermons and insinuations in casual talk just how disgusting and unwelcome a homosexual was in the church community.

    It was important for me to replant Jason’s self-perceived identity in Jesus where it belongs. In this replanting process, 1 Cor 6:9–10 became helpful to Jason: “Don’t you know that the unrighteous will not inherit God’s kingdom? Do not be deceived: No sexually immoral people, idolaters, adulterers, or anyone practicing homosexuality, no thieves, greedy people, drunkards, verbally abusive people, or swindlers will inherit God’s kingdom. And some of you used to be like this. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God” (emphasis added). Jason took a major step forward when he recognized the massive shift Paul highlighted in the passage. Although Jason may have been associated with practicing homosexuals as an unbeliever, now his identity was in Christ as a washed, sanctified, justified person.

    It was exciting to hear Jason express how he understood and was encouraged by this new concept and determinative identity: “Just like I used to watch other guys who were like me and figured out how they looked, what they did, how they smiled, and how they carried themselves, you’re basically telling me that now I do the same thing as I look at Christ and see myself primarily as a follower of Christ.” Yes. God was constructing a critical foundation for growth in Jason’s life. Although Jason needed to change his actions significantly, he needed much more than behavior modification. Jason needed to learn about and embrace his justified and sanctified position in Christ. With this in mind, we spent some time in Romans 6 and 8 to clarify his spiritual position in Christ and how that union changed everything for him with regard to the power of sin (broken) and the penalty of sin (paid). We also considered the power of the Spirit which would enable him to change as a result of his position in Christ (Eph 1:19–23; 2:10; 3:16). To continue marinating his mind in these groundbreaking truths, I also asked Jason to begin reading Living the Cross Centered Life by C. J. Mahaney.

    Heart and Desires

    From our first meeting, Jason and I began discussing the biblical concept of the heart. I had intentionally introduced the concept to him as early as possible because it is such an essential human element in his long-term ability to grow in Christ. Jason also had behaviors that needed a radical transformation from day one, but altering his behaviors alone would produce a hypocrite as long as Jason did not comprehend the heart and its central role in living for God’s glory. He did not know that changing behavior alone is behavior modification, yet heart change leading to behavior change is sanctification. When we finally reached verses that specifically unpack the inner workings of the heart, Jason was excited since I had been leading him along this path. He had several questions ready for me. I had assigned him to reflect on Mark 7:20–23 where Jesus said, “What comes out of a person—that defiles him. For from within, out of people’s hearts, come evil thoughts, sexual immoralities, thefts, murders, adulteries, greed, evil actions, deceit, promiscuity, stinginess, blasphemy, pride, and foolishness. All these evil things come from within and defile a person.” Jason asked, “Is this why you told me in the first week that in many ways, you and I are the same?” I agreed and explained to him that the pressures that are common to humanity intersect with the heart—every person’s heart—and expose it.

    Jason was beginning to understand why I had so often referred to his behavior and then referenced his heart. He left this particular week of counseling greatly encouraged and full of hope that he was finally getting it. He even mentioned a separate issue at work: his reaction to a coworker demonstrated what was going on in his heart at the time. I was also encouraged and pleased with his temptation journal, which he was still completing carefully and honestly. Moving forward, I asked him to begin reading and contemplating Jas 1:1–18.

    A Setback

    The following week we had to skip our regular counseling session because of a work conflict. Because we were now weeks into the counseling process, I thought the missed week might be difficult for Jason but that the many truths invested in his mind would still have an opportunity to bear fruit. Through a text message, I let him know that I was available if something came up.

    When Jason returned the following week, it seemed like the wheels had come off. He arrived discouraged and with a poor attitude. When I greeted him and asked how it was going, he started crying and said that it was no use trying to change. As I asked some probing questions, it came to light that when he had left our previous session two weeks before, he thought everything was going so well that it couldn’t hurt to visit one of his favorite stores in the mall. As he walked in, he was immediately checked out by another guy. Jason pretended not to see him looking, but inside he burned with excitement over the attention he was receiving. He went about his business in the mall, but he could not stop thinking about the attention he had received. Eventually he created a reason to go back through the same area. This time he got closer just to see if he would receive the same kind of treatment. He did, and this time the night ended in physical sin. What was worse, Jason was concerned that he may have picked up an STD in the process.

    We both wept together as we considered the devastation of sin and how easy it is to be ensnared. Yet once again, in the providence of God, Jason’s sin provided the perfect opportunity to discuss the passage he had just been considering. His circumstances over the past several weeks allowed for an excellent illustration of the principle laid out in James: “No one undergoing a trial should say, ‘I am being tempted by God.’ For God is not tempted by evil, and He himself doesn’t tempt anyone. But each person is tempted when he is drawn away and enticed by his own evil desires. Then after desire has conceived, it gives birth to sin, and when sin is fully grown, it gives birth to death” (1:13–15). I had already told Jason that the term James uses for “trials/temptations” was the same term that appeared in 1 Cor 10:13 regarding the trials/temptations “common to humanity.” Now I explained to him that his experience in the mall was a significant pressure, though one that he had brought on himself. James teaches that when we are in a pressure-packed circumstance, we have a choice to make: either we can glorify God in the temptation, or we can succumb to our desires and sin. James makes clear that the determining factor in this decision is always one’s controlling desire.

    To clarify further, we looked back in chapter 1 where James has already taught these trial-laden Jewish Christians that God allows them to face pressure in order to grow in them the pieces of character which God knows they are missing (1:2–4). In the same way, God would provide the best possible situation (like the man who made eyes with Jason) to help Jason grow in godliness. If Jason was controlled by a desire to please God, then he would respond to the moment of temptation with self-control. But if his controlling desire was for the attention and affection of other guys, he would respond with lustful pursuits. Choices are determined by the heart’s treasure (Luke 6:45). Whatever Jason desired most and therefore worshipped in the moment would be the person or the object that would influence his decision to resist temptation and grow or to embrace temptation and suffer the consequences.

    This lesson was relevant for so many different issues in Jason’s life. It helped Jason see that his sexual sin was just that—sin. In God’s eyes it was a desire exercising control that it should not exercise, no different from any other desire that exercises control of someone’s heart. Desires for attention, affection, influence, or relationship could be just as sinfully controlling. Where Jason should have been controlled by the love of Christ that would then motivate him to love God and his neighbor, he instead used his time and his energy to satisfy his sinful lust.

    Casting this next week as a week of growth, I asked Jason to spend time considering Jas 4:1–10, which teaches that competing desires are at war within the believer. Since Jason’s desires (whether good or evil) would end up holding functional control over his heart, it was essential for him to recognize this battle. When someone does not get what he wants, that person has a choice either to accept what God has given as better (see Jas 1:17) or to fight to get what he wants (Jas 4:1–2). The choice is an issue of control, as well as an issue of worship. Jesus is clear that a person can only serve one sovereign at a time: “No one can be a slave of two masters, since either he will hate one and love the other, or be devoted to one and despise the other. You cannot be slaves of God and of money” (Matt 6:24).

    However, Jason could find good news in the book of James: “‘God resists the proud, but gives grace to the humble.’ Therefore, submit to God” (Jas 4:6–7). The proud want their own way and are unwilling to accept God’s plan as best in any difficult circumstance. They are unwilling to rejoice in the pressures that are designed to grow them into Christlikeness (1:2–4), rather than choosing to believe that God should give them exactly what they want. When he does not, they do whatever it takes to get it (4:2–6). Instead, James implored believers to be humble and to let God’s grace provide strength in the midst of trials. I encouraged Jason to recognize his dependence on God’s grace and to ensure that what was ruling him was nothing less than “Your will be done” (just like Christ). As he left this latest counseling session (after his hard fall into sexual sin), Jason seemed encouraged. This had been a difficult lesson about the deceitfulness of his heart, and it would not be the last. Amazingly, however, Jason’s gracious God was using even his sin to help him learn and grow in Christ.

    Other Key Areas of Growth

    With each new piece of the puzzle, Jason was learning not just about same-sex attraction and homosexuality but about embracing the gospel and its implications and living life to God’s glory, regardless of the particular desires that warred for control in his heart. As time went on, I addressed several additional areas of needed growth.

    Love. Love was no small issue for Jason. He deeply desired to feel loved. He longed for affection and a true sense of belonging. Early on as we discussed 2 Corinthians 5, we had worked on understanding and appreciating the love of Christ. As counseling progressed, we further unpacked the true meaning of love as reflected in the person of Jesus in 1 John 3 and Eph 3:14–21. Jason then began to see how the love of Christ served as the model which should dictate his own love for others. I urged him to find ways to selflessly serve others in and through his church small group.

    Walk. The Christian life is a walk. Paul makes clear that God desires the believer to walk worthy in unity, in love, in light, and in wisdom (Ephesians 4–5). Jason did not initially understand the dichotomy between what he wanted and what God wanted. He had been appropriately disappointed by many professing followers of Christ and needed to reconsider his everyday conduct as a proclaimed disciple of Jesus. He needed to reevaluate (1) the temptations around him, (2) his response to loving accountability, (3) his patterns of self-deception, and (4) his opportunities to love and serve others. As we worked on the daily discipline of living for God’s glory, we carefully unpacked how to recognize and flee temptation (Rom 13:11–14; Proverbs 4). During this time Jason also read and considered The Joy of Fearing God by Jerry Bridges.

    Past. Up to this point in his life, Jason had not only sinned against many others but had also been sinned against by many—including many in the church. As part of the counseling process, Jason learned to view his past in light of Rom 8:28–29. Together we drew up a list of people he needed to forgive and people from whom he needed to seek forgiveness. If I were counseling Jason today, I would use Steve Viars’s book Putting Your Past in Its Place: Moving Forward in Freedom and Forgiveness. This book provides much-needed teaching for believers to view their past rightly—both in areas where we have sinned against others and where we have been sinned against. The book also contains a helpful chart to help strugglers see what kind of steps they should take to please God.

    Jason’s Progress

    I still have the privilege of working with Jason but now as a brother and friend in Christ more than as a counselee. I wish I could say that my friend has never struggled since the occasions recounted in this chapter, but that is not the case. Yet I do rejoice in the fact that he has not fallen into any physical relationships (temporary or permanent), and I remind myself that true progress in this life is not final victory but steady gains.

    When Jason’s struggles reappear, they usually follow a period of long, hard days at work without much interaction with other believers. The evening times can still catch him off guard if he is not careful. He does go to the mall occasionally and will visit a different coffee shop from time to time. But where and when he struggles, he shares it with his small group. He has found loving acceptance that does not compromise and a joy-filled life as he has connected more personally with his church. His deceitful life has been replaced with an open and vulnerable relationship with his small group, which keeps him accountable as he shares his temptations; the accountability even extends to how he shares his temptations.

    Jason has also grown in his understanding of the gospel and in his love for Christ. In a recent conversation I asked him how his struggle was going. To my delight we talked for 30 minutes as he expressed many different pressured-filled situations, but same-sex attraction never came up. It was not even on his mind as one of his most pressing struggles, and I sensed no need to bring it up either.

    Once again, homosexual desires were just one issue among many for Jason. Yes, the practice of homosexuality is wretched, destructive, hurtful to others, and filled with health risks. I am not minimizing either the sin or its devastating effects on the sinner and those he sins against. What I want you to hear is not that homosexuality is less of a sin but that homosexuality is another sin—one among many. Jesus Christ died on the cross for those who engage in homosexual sins, just as he died to pay the penalty for gossips, complainers, and speeders.

    When we stop to minister to someone like Jason, we must be vigilant to see his sin for what it really is—not what culture teaches, not what our previous life experience suggests, and not what a limited scriptural understanding tempts us to believe. Jason is a fellow struggler in need of the powerful message of the gospel, just like his counselor who desperately needs the power of the gospel. The reality is that every one of the issues surrounding Jason’s life could be equally true of heterosexuals. Do you think the average heterosexual has ever been sinned against? Lives for his feelings? Craves attention from others? Longs for attention, affirmation, relationship, and acceptance? Reacts against the legalism of his church or his parents? Wrestles with anger? Of course—all our temptations are common to humanity.

    Both the homosexual and the heterosexual are worshippers whose most fundamental need is humbly to embrace and serve the only true, real, merciful, loving God and Savior, instead of serving the false gods that war for our affections. May God give you and me the wisdom to grow in the midst of our own struggles and so be equipped to minister well to the next Jason.

    In this case, I counseled a male dealing with same-sex attraction. Factors contributing to same-sex attraction in females are often somewhat different. Some helpful resources regarding homosexuality (including potential contributing factors to homosexual tendencies) include Kerby Anderson, A Biblical Point of View on Homosexuality (Eugene, OR: Harvest House, 2008); Joe Dallas, When Homosexuality Hits Home: What to Do When a Loved One Says They’re Gay (Eugene, OR: Harvest House, 2004); David Powlison, “Sexual Sin and the Wider, Deeper Battle,” The Journal of Biblical Counseling 24, no. 3 (Spring 2006): 30–36; and Edward T. Welch, “Homosexuality: Current Thinking and Biblical Guidelines,” The Journal of Biblical Counseling 13, no. 3 (Spring 1995): 19–29. For additional material regarding the biblical view of sex and how to handle sexual temptation, see Joshua Harris, Sex Is Not the Problem (Lust Is): Sexual Purity in a Lust-Saturated World (Colorado Springs, CO: Multnomah, 2003); John Piper and Justin Taylor, eds., Sex and the Supremacy of Christ (Wheaton: Crossway, 2005).

    Homosexuality is always condemned in the Bible as sin. It is impossible to review the biblical data in this chapter, but using normal hermeneutical practices, each of the following verses declare homosexuality as a sin: Gen 19:1–27; Lev 18:22; 20:13; Judg 19:22–23; Rom 1:26–27; 1 Cor 6:9–10; 1 Tim 1:9–10; Jude 7.

    Not all of the homework I gave Jason appears in this chapter. In a message titled “Homework That Changes Lives,” presented at the NANC Annual Conference, 2006, Randy Patton teaches that the counselor should begin counseling with the end in mind and suggests the following six categories of homework for each session. These helpful biblical disciplines should be cultivated as long-term commitments in the counselee’s life: (1) daily Scripture reading, (2) Scripture memory, (3) theological reading, (4) regular church attendance and involvement, (5) serving others, and (6) consistent prayer.

    The counselor could assign a passage the week before and then discuss it at the next session (like I did with Jason) or assign the passage after discussing it in a session. I often assign the passage prior to discussing it in order to get a person thinking on their own. In our review the following week, I make sure the person understands the context of the passage and the specific meaning of the verses in question before having him share what he learned and asking him to unpack its implications for his particular situation.

    Milton Vincent, A Gospel Primer for Christians: Learning to See the Glories of God’s Love (Bemidji, MN: Focus, 2008).

    C. J. Mahaney, Living the Cross Centered Life: Keeping the Gospel the Main Thing (Colorado Springs: Multnomah, 2006).

    This perspective differs greatly from the world system. If Jason were to accept the world’s view of the heart and homosexuality, then it would be his biology/genetics, his family background, and his early exposure to pornography that would be cast as the controlling factors in his homosexual tendencies. But the Bible presents these same events not as the final determiners of Jason’s actions but only as factors that exercise influence (temptation). The final determiner is Jason’s ruling desire, or whatever exercises functional control in his life.

    Jerry Bridges, The Joy of Fearing God (Colorado Springs: WaterBrook, 1997).

    Stephen Viars, Putting Your Past in Its Place: Moving Forward in Freedom and Forgiveness (Eugene, OR: Harvest House, 2011).

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑