Chapter 7 of 16

Chapter 6: “Ashley” and Anorexia

Chapter 6: “Ashley” and Anorexia

Chapter 6

“Ashley” and Anorexia

Martha Peace

“911—what’s your emergency?” answered the dispatcher. “One of our students has collapsed in the university library and isn’t waking up,” said the caller. “Her pulse feels fast and weak. Please hurry!” The library staff and fellow students had begun to gather under the curious silence that hovers over public medical emergencies. Hushed onlookers tried to put together the few puzzle pieces they saw scattered before them in the form of a thin 20-year-old sophomore English major. The full picture, however, would not emerge until the dust had settled.

How Image Became Everything

Up to this point Ashley’s brief college career had been a success. She had enrolled at a major state university close to home and had earned a 4.0 GPA her freshman year. She had grown up in a Christian home and had thought often in her teenage years about how she could serve the Lord. Her parents were happily married and had taken good care of their three children. Dad was a businessman, and Mom had stayed at home with Ashley and her two younger brothers (ages 14 and 12).

During her senior year of high school, Ashley had begun to grow concerned with her weight and appearance. At a petite five feet three inches, she felt like she needed to trim down, especially as she carried around the mental image of a best friend whom Ashley considered more attractive than herself. She did some research, set some goals, changed her diet, and kept up an exercise routine. What began as a desire to eat healthily eventually led to this otherwise successful college sophomore lying unconscious on the floor. It had now become a “911 emergency!”

The paramedics arrived and quickly took control of the scene. They immediately saw that Ashley was extremely underweight. Her pulse was weak and barely palpable, her breathing was rapid and shallow, and she seemed dangerously dehydrated. She remained only semiconscious as the paramedics inserted an IV, fitted her with an oxygen mask, hooked up a cardiac monitor, and rushed her with lights glaring and sirens blaring to the nearest emergency room.

The ER doctor ordered immediate blood work and soon diagnosed that Ashley was severely dehydrated and her electrolytes were abnormal. This affected her heart rhythm and her ability to think clearly. She was so weak she could not sit up, and she weighed only 85 pounds.

After her fluids and electrolytes were replenished by an IV, Ashley regained consciousness and was able to answer the doctor’s questions. He finally diagnosed Ashley with “anorexia nervosa” with secondary electrolyte imbalance and dehydration, but the ultimate diagnosis would run much deeper.

Bound for Beauty: What Is Anorexia?

As soon as Ashley’s parents received the diagnosis, they jumped online and began researching “anorexia nervosa.” What they discovered about their oldest child was shocking:

Anorexia is an eating disorder characterized by markedly reduced appetite or total aversion to food. It is a condition that goes well beyond out-of-control dieting. . . . The individual continues the endless cycle of restrictive eating, often to a point close to starvation. This becomes an obsession and is similar to an addiction to a drug. Anorexia can be life-threatening.

After discussions with university administration, Ashley’s parents and school officials made the joint decision to withdraw Ashley from school temporarily so she could be cared for in the comfort and familiarity of her own home. Once at home, she admitted to her parents that she had no energy and was frightened. Like any faithful mother would do, her mom began regularly preparing Ashley’s favorite foods; but most of what was placed before her she would only pick at or refuse to eat.

Her parents grew increasingly worried. As the days and weeks passed, they would cry, beg, or threaten Ashley with hospitalization or pretend not to notice her miniscule eating habits. Neither approach was working. Nagging only exacerbated the issue, and ignoring it was only going to lead back to the ER—or worse.

Thankfully, Ashley’s mother knew about a biblical counselor in a neighboring town. The first responders had been lifesaving, the medical diagnosis was essential, the Internet research had been enlightening, and the commonsense steps Ashley’s parents had taken at home were right and reasonable. Now that they were a few steps removed from the library floor, the ambulance, and the ER, more was needed for this “anorexia nervosa” than the medical world was able to offer.

Ashley’s mother called the biblical counselor and made an appointment.

Asking, Listening, and Understanding

After listening to Ashley’s mother explain what happened, I encouraged her that both she and her husband needed to come with Ashley for at least the first few sessions. Ashley tried desperately to get out of the appointment by promising that she would do better. Her parents wisely recognized the need for biblical counseling and gave her no choice.

The next day Ashley and her parents walked through my door looking discouraged and downcast. All three had been jolted by Ashley’s medical emergency and serious diagnosis, and her return home had been punctuated by constant conflict about her dangerous habits. Their previously stable family had been rocked by this life-threatening sin that made everyone, including Ashley, dread the next meal.

I could tell from the beginning that Ashley would be a hard case and immediately recognized two simultaneous emergencies: Ashley’s life and Ashley’s soul. I had counseled many other women who struggled with anorexia, and I learned to begin the process by asking questions, listening carefully, and attempting to understand them. Only then could I offer her biblical hope and guide her toward practical steps of obedience and wisdom.

At our first meeting I began to ask questions and gather information about Ashley’s life. She shared that she had “asked Jesus into her heart” when she was eight years old, but now she wasn’t sure if she was a Christian. “I grew up in church, and I still go to church with my family when I’m home from school. I used to read my Bible and pray but haven’t for several months now. I want to be a Christian, but I’m really confused.”

It is essential to understand someone’s salvation testimony because many professing Christians have not truly trusted in Christ and repented of their sins. Therefore, they do not have the proper motivations to change or the empowering presence of the Holy Spirit in their lives. At this point I didn’t know Ashley well enough to discern her spiritual condition, but it was vital for me to hear her own take on her Christian experiences and the spiritual influences in her life.

I also knew that people with anorexia often struggle with perfectionism. “Do you think you might be a perfectionist?” I asked. “Well, my family and friends think I am, but I’m not so sure,” Ashley offered. “I think I just want to do my best, which is a good thing.”

I asked Ashley how much she had weighed and what was going through her mind when she started on her initial diet prior to college. “I was a senior in high school, and I realized I was fat. I weighed 135 pounds, and I’m only 5 feet 3 inches. I just wanted to lose about 20 pounds and be little like my best friend. I did lots of research online, learned how to eat healthily, and then started working really hard at dieting and exercising. At the beginning I got a lot of compliments, so I doubled my efforts.”

“Do you have rules about what you absolutely will not eat?” I asked (well aware that two of the most common expressions of anorexic drive are strict dieting and relentless exercise). “Yes, but they are all based on healthy eating,” Ashley clarified. “I don’t eat any sugar, fat, or bread. No red meat; only lean chicken and fish. No starchy vegetables like potatoes. I do eat some fruit and nonfat yogurt.”

Ashley’s confident, detailed answers revealed that she had really put some time into this endeavor. I asked how she learned what’s healthy and what’s not. “From doing research online,” she answered. Her mother added, “She’s spent countless hours on the computer doing research.”

“And what about your exercise routine?” I asked. “Usually I fast-walk or jog about 45 minutes each day. Then I try to do 30 minutes of aerobic exercise and stomach crunches. Right now it’s difficult for me since I don’t have much energy, but I try.”

Ashley was sinfully obsessed and driven. She had a goal, even if it had become a moving target, and she had a plan. She had made great effort and great sacrifices to whittle her body down to the scant 85 pounds that had collapsed on the library’s floor.

Knowing that all of this had put a significant strain on their family, I gently asked Ashley about her relationship with her parents. “It used to be good,” she started. “But now they harass me all the time about what I eat. I tell them if they’ll just leave me alone, I’ll be fine.”

“What do you think would happen if you ate what your mom wanted you to eat?” I responded. “I’d be fat,” Ashley exclaimed, “and I’ve already worked too hard to get the weight off. I’m not going back there!”

As we continued to talk, I gained more and more clarity regarding Ashley’s thoughts, feelings, and motivations, along with the external factors, unique circumstances, and family dynamics that all contributed to the perfect storm of her drive to be thin and beautiful.

Knowing the enslaving nature of anorexia and the miserable bondage it promotes, I carefully asked Ashley if she had ever contemplated suicide or developed a plan for taking her own life. “Sometimes I’ve wished I were dead,” she admitted in a courageous act of honesty. “But I’ve never thought about how I might actually take my life. I’d never do that.” It was relieving to know that Ashley had never thought seriously about suicide, but that relief only freed me to focus my thinking about other items on my counseling agenda list.

A Path Sprinkled with Hope

As I continued listening to Ashley and her parents, I began mentally categorizing what I was hearing in order to clarify the many issues making up Ashley’s physical and spiritual emergency. As the conversation transitioned, I prayed for wisdom and wrote up a list of topics to address in our upcoming conversations. My spontaneous list looked like this:

  • hope
  • parental involvement
  • the gospel of Jesus Christ
  • medical care
  • restructuring eating/exercise habits
  • the big picture (remembering Christ and the two greatest commandments)
  • renewing the mind
  • vanity
  • perfectionism
  • Later I would go back and organize these topics into a logical order for subsequent sessions, but for now I just wanted Ashley and her parents to know some of the angles we would be taking and some of the conversations they could anticipate in coming weeks.

    Sprinkled throughout my questioning and listening were nuggets of hope that I offered to both Ashley and her parents. They were afraid and desperate. They needed to hear repeatedly that the hope found in the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ was as real as the air they breathed. Although the food Ashley feared and the weight she watched seemed to be in control, that control was an illusion. As long as she remained deluded, the bathroom scale and the bedroom mirror would rule her life. The illusion was not unbreakable. It could be (and would be) shattered by the good news of redemption.

    I told Ashley that she was embarking on a difficult journey but not an insurmountable one. By faith she could expect to overcome her self-consumed mentality. She could even grow to experience a sense of joy and gratitude when she ate her meals.

    I also reminded her that the bad news of sin, enslavement, and misery had been getting all the attention in her heart but that the good news of forgiveness, freedom, and renewal could take over the headlines as she learned to rewrite her thoughts with the truths of God’s Word. Her self-centered, harmful desires were sinful, but God would give her the grace of forgiveness and the power of repentance. God would forgive, and Ashley could change.

    “Ashley, I know you’re probably afraid that I’m going to make you eat and eat until you’re fat,” I predicted. “The truth is that God doesn’t want you to be uncontrolled or irresponsible in your eating. Instead, he wants you to exercise self-control, to have joy in what you eat, and to glorify him in all of it.”

    This process would be agonizing for Ashley, like an addict coming off a drug. I knew that the idea of altering her mentality, changing her perspective, and increasing her weight was petrifying to her. “We’ll move slowly,” I promised. “One of the things you’ll slowly learn is how to ‘trust in the Lord with all your heart, and do not rely on your own understanding’” (Prov 3:5). This would mean trusting in God’s perfect Word and following the scriptural wisdom of others instead of following her own deceitful, enslaving thoughts that had led her so far astray.

    A Book Filled with Hope

    What specific Scriptures would saturate Ashley with the hope she desperately needed? I spent some time reading and explaining some of the biblical passages that were most relevant and powerful for Ashley’s situation.

    In the midst of this physical, spiritual, and emotional storm, Ashley needed a strong ballast at the bottom of her swaying ship. She needed to lay the rock-solid truths of Rom 8:28–30 at the foundation of her efforts to change. Paul wrote:

    We know that all things work together for the good of those who love God: those who are called according to His purpose. For those He foreknew He also predestined to be conformed to the image of His Son, so that He would be the firstborn among many brothers. And those He predestined, He also called; and those He called, He also justified; and those He justified, He also glorified.

    Ashley needed to believe—truly believe—that she wasn’t predestined to be conformed to the air-brushed image on the cover of Vanity Fair or the plasticized image of a Hollywood superstar or even the real-life image of her best friend. Instead, if Ashley was a Christian, her focus needed to turn her vanity to glorifying God. The perfect image of Jesus the Son of God was her destiny, and that’s all that ultimately mattered. Before the universe had even existed, God had chosen Ashley, called Ashley, justified Ashley, and had made Ashley perfect in his sight. Now she only needed to learn how to grow into these established realities.

    Ashley also needed to believe that every morning when she reached for the alarm clock, swung her legs out of bed, and placed her bare feet on the floor to face another day, God would show her mercy, Jesus would be her sympathetic high priest, and the Holy Spirit would empower her to win the mental battle between lies and truth. By God’s grace he would enable her to make the moment-by-moment choices that seemed utterly impossible in the present. Ashley needed to share in the ancient hope of the Jewish prophet Jeremiah, who suffered such constant and intense hardships that he was called “the weeping prophet”:

    Yet I call this to mind, and therefore I have hope: Because of the Lord’s faithful love we do not perish, for His mercies never end. They are new every morning; great is Your faithfulness! I say: The Lord is my portion, therefore I will put my hope in Him. The Lord is good to those who wait for Him, to the person who seeks Him.

    (Lam 3:21–25)

    At every doctor’s visit, at every weigh-in, and at every meal, Ashley could “call this to mind” and “therefore have hope.” She could remember that God’s faithful love would keep her from perishing, his mercies would never end, his graces were rising fresh every morning with the sun, and that his faithfulness was great—far greater than any of the diverse challenges that were threatening her.

    Practically, Ashley also needed to know that in the moment of temptation, God would be faithful and would give her the help she needed, whatever that might look like on any given occasion. So I held out the hope of 1 Cor 10:13, which was written to Christians living in the midst of constant temptation in the cosmopolitan city of Corinth (a Las Vegas of the first-century Mediterranean world). Paul said, “No temptation has overtaken you except what is common to humanity. God is faithful, and He will not allow you to be tempted beyond what you are able, but with the temptation He will also provide a way of escape so that you are able to bear it.”

    Practical Guidance for the Physical

    After spending some focused time reading and explaining the biblical passages above and giving her a list of relevant verses to take with her, I began turning her attention to physical issues. Because she was facing a physical emergency, I explained to her that she would need to be under the care of a medical doctor. She would need to undergo a complete physical exam coupled with a weekly weighing at the doctor’s office. Her doctor would determine a healthy weight range for her height and weight. Her mother would need to go with her to each visit in order to track the weekly weigh-ins and hear the doctor’s advice.

    Many people seeking help for anorexia panic when they gain even a single pound, leading some counselors to set up a process that keeps all weight changes secretive. However, I believed that it was essential for Ashley to know about each weight change so she could learn to face the facts and to reshape her beliefs and values in light of reality. Instead of shoving things into the closet of denial, Ashley needed to learn to respond with hope and trust in the Lord.

    I asked that Ashley keep a food diary with her parents’ oversight. She was to eat a minimum of 1,600 calories per day and record the specific foods and the amount eaten at each meal. Even though this calorie intake wasn’t even enough for Ashley to maintain her current weight, I knew she would still panic over this increase in her daily food consumption. Therefore, I also assigned her to keep a “Self-Talk Log” where she would write down what she was thinking when she felt anxious, frustrated, or overwhelmed. This record would assist in evaluating how Ashley’s mind needed to be renewed. I also instructed her to limit her exercise to 20 minutes per day and warned that she might need to stop exercising entirely if her weight did not stabilize. Each of these steps—knowing her weight increases, keeping a food diary, recording her thoughts and feelings, and limiting her exercise—would be an extreme challenge for Ashley. She could always remember, however, that this new path—no matter how difficult—was still sprinkled with hope.

    Practical Guidance for the Spiritual

    Because Ashley was not just facing a physical emergency but also a spiritual emergency, she needed her eyes lifted up to the good news of Jesus Christ. I wanted to center her thoughts on the grace, forgiveness, acceptance, and power found in the message of the gospel. I assigned her the Salvation Handbook Bible study and asked her to read daily in the Gospel of John. She was to read all of John’s Gospel at least three times before our next meeting. I also asked her to record daily prayers in a prayer journal and to memorize Prov 3:5–8 and 1 Cor 10:13. I encouraged Ashley to read aloud to help herself concentrate since she might have difficulty thinking clearly due to her physical condition.

    Even though I don’t normally give out my contact information, I gave Ashley and her parents my phone number and e-mail address so they could contact me during the week if needed. This first week of adjustments was going to be difficult for both Ashley and her family, and they would need support.

    Facing Reality

    When Ashley and her mother arrived the next week, Ashley was clearly agitated. She was angry that the doctor had estimated her target weight at 115–120 pounds, meaning she needed to gain 30–35 pounds! She also felt like her parents were “on her case” about every bite of food she ate. Both Ashley and her mother began to cry in exasperation.

    Ashley’s food diary for this first week showed that she had eaten only raw or cooked vegetables, some fruit, and little meat. She had weighed in at 84 pounds at the doctor’s office, and he had threatened to hospitalize her if she didn’t start eating. Obviously, these were not good signs.

    In spite of her struggles, it was encouraging that Ashley had done the mental and spiritual homework I had assigned her even though it had been difficult for her to concentrate. We spent most of this second session reviewing her Salvation Handbook. Ashley told me, “I do think I’m a Christian, and I really do want to honor God. I still think that if everyone will just leave me alone, I’ll be all right.” I asked her, “If you died today and the Lord asked you, ‘Why should I let you into my heaven?’ what would you say?” Ashley replied with precise accuracy: “I am trusting completely in your Son’s death on the cross to save me—I am saved by your grace through faith.”

    Understandably, her thoughts and emotions were frightening and very emotionally painful for her. In her “Self-Talk Log,” she had written:

  • Everyone is watching me. Why can’t they leave me alone?
  • If I eat what my mother cooks, I will be fat!
  • There is nothing wrong with wanting to be healthy.
  • This makes me so angry!
  • I hate being home!
  • I don’t feel like eating.
  • It was not surprising that Ashley refused to face reality. Her sinful, habitual obsession with food and her body was deeply entrenched in her heart. Her unopposed thoughts and unchecked actions had formed deep ruts. Her self-image had become her god, and she was willing to fight to the death to keep this destructive god at the center of her life and happiness. Her self-consuming pride was blinding her to the reality of her situation and even to the obvious love that her parents were showing her.

    Remembering the Big Picture

    During the second meeting with Ashley, I concentrated on two main biblical principles. First, I wanted Ashley to focus on the big picture. This meant cultivating an abiding sense of gratitude for Jesus Christ, who had sacrificed himself on the cross to suffer the punishment for her sins so that she could be forgiven by God. When her heart was filled with this gratitude, Ashley would find it much more natural to honor God by doing what was right regardless of her feelings. Remembering the big picture also meant turning to Jesus as a sympathetic high priest who had experienced temptation as a human being and who was eager and kind in helping everyone who would ask him. Hebrews 4:14–16 states:

    Therefore, since we have a great high priest who has passed through the heavens—Jesus the Son of God—let us hold fast to the confession. For we do not have a high priest who is unable to sympathize with our weaknesses, but One who has been tested in every way as we are, yet without sin. Therefore let us approach the throne of grace with boldness, so that we may receive mercy and find grace to help us at the proper time.

    As Ashley grew in her willingness to seek Jesus for mercy, grace, and help in her struggles, she would also learn to let him shoulder her burdens instead of bearing them herself. “God resists the proud but gives grace to the humble. Humble yourselves, therefore, under the mighty hand of God, so that He may exalt you at the proper time, casting all your care on him, because He cares about you” (1 Pet 5:5–7).

    Unlike the enslaving, burdensome, miserable bondage of anorexia and the condemning feeling that she could never be thin or pretty enough, Ashley needed to lift her eyes to the kind face of Jesus and open her ears to his gentle offer of grace. Instead of viewing every act of obedience as an impossible task, Ashley could grow into seeing Jesus’ commands as gentle, kind, and helpful:

    “Come to Me, all of you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest. All of you, take up My yoke and learn from Me, because I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for yourselves. For My yoke is easy and My burden is light.” (Matt 11:28–30)

    Loving God and Loving People

    Second, I wanted Ashley to focus on the two most important commands in the Bible: loving God and loving people. This had been Jesus’ response to a question asked by an expert in the Old Testament law.

    “Teacher, which command in the law is the greatest?” [Jesus] said to him, “Love the Lord your God with all your heart, with all your soul, and with all your mind. This is the greatest and most important command. The second is like it: Love your neighbor as yourself .” (Matt 22:36–39)

    I explained that loving God would mean obeying his Word. Jesus had told his disciples, “If you love Me, you will keep My commands” (John 14:15). Loving God would mean believing and obeying specific commands in the Bible even though she might feel temporarily frightened or bewildered by the dramatic changes these commands required.

    As she learned to value and trust the truths of the Bible over the entrenched lies of her own heart, Ashley would be following the exhortation of the apostle Paul: “Do not be conformed to this age, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, so that you may discern what is the good, pleasing, and perfect will of God” (Rom 12:2). I encouraged her constantly to push away her sinful obsessions about weight and food. Instead, she needed to fill her mind with thoughts that were true, honorable, just, pure, lovely, commendable, morally excellent, and worthy of praise (Phil 4:8). Although she was surrounded by internal passions and external appeals tempting her to set her mind’s eye on full-length mirrors, body measurements, weight loss, and passing compliments, God’s faithful Word was telling her to contemplate only those things that were truly meaningful, valuable, and lasting.

    As for loving those around her, Ashley’s family was naturally the first group on the radar. I encouraged her to make her family’s life easier (instead of more difficult) by gladly eating what was put before her instead of complaining or even rejecting it. She could also focus on spending time with her younger brothers and gladly sharing her life with her parents during this unexpected season of time that God had given them as a family.

    The Battle of the Mind

    We also spent time in this second meeting brainstorming together about how Ashley could renew her mind. The selfish, compulsive thoughts in her “Self-Talk Log” needed to be renounced and replaced by thoughts that centered on loving God and loving others. I wanted Ashley to see the stark comparison between the sinful, selfish, obsessive thoughts that were enslaving her and the biblical, selfless, reasonable thoughts that would free her.

    Sinful, Obsessive Thoughts

    Thoughts Centered on Loving God and Loving Others

    “Everyone is watching me!

    Why can’t they leave me alone!”

    “Everyone is not watching me, and those who are love me very much. I don’t blame them for being worried. Their worry is a sign of their care.”

    “If I ate what my mother cooked, I’d be fat!”

    “If I gratefully eat what my mother cooks, I will be showing love to her by not being selfish” (cf.

    1 Cor 13:5) “and showing love to God by not relying on my own understanding” (cf. Prov 3:5).

    “There is nothing wrong with wanting to be healthy.”

    “There is nothing wrong with wanting to be healthy, but according to my doctor, my eating habits aren’t healthy. I have to relearn what is healthy.”

    “This makes me so angry!”

    “Thank you, Lord, for this trial, and thank you that I am still alive and that you have given me a family and a counselor to help me” (cf. 1 Thess 5:18).

    “I hate being home!”

    “It’s God’s special blessing to me that I can be home and receive the help I so desperately need. I’m glad to be at home.”

    “I don’t feel like eating!”

    “I’ll eat whether I feel like it or not, and if I have to gain weight, I will just have to gain weight. I am going to honor the Lord. He will help me. I will remember that whether I’m eating or drinking, I should do everything to the glory of God” (cf.

    1 Cor 10:31).

    At this point in our meeting, Ashley’s parents interjected: “What should we do when she just sits and stares at her food and starts to tremble and panic?” My advice was, “Talk to her calmly and give her hope. For example, you could say, ‘I know this is difficult for you, but the Lord will help you. I want you to pick up your fork and take a bite of potatoes. Ask your heavenly Father to help you do what you know is right, good, and healthy. Let’s seek his help right now, and then we’ll keep eating.’ After you pray, continue with the meal and turn the conversation to something besides this issue.” I also reminded Ashley’s parents that if they observed Ashley’s physical state deteriorating, they should call her doctor or 911—it would be their judgment call.

    Resetting Ashley’s Diet

    I carefully looked through Ashley’s food diary for that initial week. One day she had managed to meet the target goal of 1,600 calories, but she promptly panicked and limited herself to 1,300 the next day. Most of those 1,300 calories were fresh fruit, which took almost more calories to digest than were contained in the fruit itself. Ashley had successfully avoided sugar, fat, juice, milk, and virtually all protein.

    I considered sending Ashley and her mother to a nutritionist, but I decided to start by requiring that she add several specific items to her diet. Ashley was to drink eight ounces of orange juice and two eight-ounce glasses of whole milk per day. I also asked her to add two teaspoons of butter on wheat toast at breakfast, a serving of regular mayonnaise on her sandwich at lunch, and a serving of rice, potatoes, or pasta with butter at dinner. If she had not yet eaten 1,600 calories by the end of dinner, she needed to eat one serving of ice cream, a candy bar, or a brownie. Since she was scheduled for a weigh-in at the doctor’s office the next day, I also let her know that if she had lost weight again, she would not be allowed to exercise until she had gained a few pounds back.

    To the casual reader or to the person entangled in an anorexic lifestyle, these requirements may sound harsh or even physically unhealthy. Telling a radically self-conscious 20-year-old female that she must consume unwanted desserts if she has not eaten enough calories by the end of the day sounds uncaring at best. Yet this was exactly the point. Ashley was so entangled in a web of self-deception that she viewed the fundamentally life-giving act of eating as a threat to her well-being.

    Practical Steps Toward Freedom

    Because of this deep-seated self-deception, I knew it would not be enough simply for Ashley to hit the right calorie count each day or unwrap the after-dinner candy bar without a conflict with her parents. The ultimate battle was still in the heart, not at the dinner table. I asked Ashley to keep up her “Self-Talk Log,” recording the thoughts racing through her mind when she was struggling. In addition, I asked her to memorize 1 Cor 10:31 and Heb 4:14–16, to read daily in the Psalms and the Gospel of John, to pray each day for herself and for others, and to keep a “Think These Thoughts” journal. This journal contained Bible verses, good quotes from a book, or specific thoughts that Ashley knew she should be thinking. I told her to add to that journal each week and to review it when she found herself struggling.

    When Ashley and her mother left our second meeting, they still looked somewhat unhappy. At least they were no longer crying! Sometimes it’s the smallest glimmers of light that remind us that dawn is coming.

    It Takes Time

    Over the next several weeks, Ashley managed barely to eat 1,600 calories per day. It was clear that she was still hanging onto her self-imposed eating rules. At our fifth meeting I increased her calorie total to 1,800 and gave Ashley and her mom specific ideas for increasing the calories.

    She particularly objected to eating any kind of fat. I asked if she had been diagnosed with hyper-cholesterol disease. She hadn’t, of course. Therefore, despite her objections, her body was processing fat in a healthy way. So, instead of her preferred skim milk, I told her that she must drink whole milk. Instead of fat-free cheese, she was to eat regular cheese.

    Far more than pushing these practical dietary steps, however, I kept reminding Ashley of the big picture: God had forgiven all of her sins and freed her from slavery to sin through the atoning death and victorious resurrection of Jesus Christ. If she continued to turn to him as her redeemer and helper, thanking him for his daily grace and strength and turning to his Word to uproot lies and implant truth, she would grow every day whether she could see the growth or not. I also encouraged Ashley to thank God that she could trust him regardless of how she might feel at any given moment.

    Obviously it was difficult for Ashley to trust God over her own feelings and self-perceptions about her appearance. Very simply, she needed to know God better—who he is, what he’s like, and how he works. I gave Ashley the book The Attributes of God by Arthur W. Pink. She and her mother slowly worked their way through the book. I instructed Ashley to pray before and after reading each chapter and to record thoughts, quotes, and Scriptures from the book in her “Think These Thoughts” journal, looking up any Bible passages that were cited but not actually quoted in the book. After several weeks Ashley’s attitude began to change. She openly confessed that she had lied several times to her mother and to me about what she’d been eating. She had been exercising secretly on days when she felt like she’d eaten too much.

    Confessions of sin can seem negative, but they’re actually positive. Ashley was beginning to comprehend the powerful impact of Eph 1:7–8 in her life: “We have redemption in [Christ] through his blood, the forgiveness of our trespasses, according to the riches of his grace that he lavished on us with all wisdom and understanding.” She could confess her sin because she knew her sin was forgiven. Each week she continued to refine her thoughts even as she learned to renew her mind through the purifying power of God’s Word.

    At the same time, although I was experiencing more and more honesty from Ashley as her counselor, Ashley’s mother was quite alarmed by the exposure of her daughter’s sinful thoughts. I comforted her by telling her I was not surprised at the seemingly shocking perspectives that were being revealed week by week. After all, Ashley’s temptations were “common to humanity” (1 Cor 10:13). Therefore, Ashley’s mother could be confident that God was already helping her turn from her extreme self-focus to “set [her mind] on what is above, not on what is on the earth” (Col 3:2).

    Becoming Who We Already Are in Christ: Justification, Sanctification, and Glorification

    As Ashley grew to see and confess her sins and to grow in practical ways, what was her ultimate goal? To be like Jesus Christ—righteous in the sight of God. How would this happen? How would an emaciated 20-year-old lost in the vortex of her own sinful desires become a mature follower of Jesus fully devoted to his Word and his ways? If we zoom out for an aerial perspective (even a heavenly perspective) on this question, there are three major stages: justification, sanctification, and glorification. I made sure to concentrate on these stages in the early phases of my relationship with Ashley.

    First, justification is a 100 percent work of God where he declares us to be perfectly righteous in his sight because the punishment for our sins has been completely paid by the sacrifice of Christ, and the perfect life of Jesus has been credited to our moral account. “For all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. They are justified freely by his grace through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus” (Rom 3:23–24). Every true believer in Jesus is united with Christ in his death, burial, and resurrection. By God’s grace, the believer actually is united in Jesus’ death, which destroys the penalty and power of sin. The Christian is united in Jesus’ burial, which leaves the old sinful person behind in the grave. The believer comes alive in Jesus’ resurrection, which makes him a new person sharing in the new life of Christ. Because Ashley was “in Christ,” she was justified with Christ. Her justification happened at a moment in time when she fully trusted Jesus. It was a permanent, irreversible, invincible declaration. Ashley was justified—completely accepted by God.

    Second, sanctification is the “continuing work of God in the life of the believer, making him or her actually holy.” Unlike the one-time divine act of justification, sanctification is progressive. Ashley’s sanctification began the moment God saved her and would continue until the day she died or Christ returned. It would be a lifelong process of being transformed into the image of Jesus. Sanctification is simultaneously God’s work and our work: God convicts us of sin and trains us in righteousness. We are responsible to “work out [our] own salvation with fear and trembling” (Phil 2:12). Paul exhorted his apprentice Timothy to “train yourself in godliness, for . . . godliness is beneficial in every way since it holds promise for the present life, and also for the life to come” (1 Tim 4:7–8). I explained to Ashley that this self-training would mean renewing her mind and, by God’s grace, doing the right thing over and over again until it became a righteous habit. I also reminded her of the much-beloved promise in Rom 8:29: “For those He foreknew He also predestined to be conformed to the image of His Son.” The sanctification process is also a promise.

    Third, glorification is the final stage (both chronologically and conceptually) of our righteousness before God. Glorification is another 100 percent work of God where he transforms both soul and body into an immortal, righteous, sinless being. Ashley would finally be sinless when she went to heaven to be with the Lord. She could also hope in the glorious words of Paul that describe what our bodies will be like when we are raised from the dead at the end of time—we will be “raised in incorruption,” “raised in glory,” “raised in power,” and “raised a spiritual body.” Then we will “bear the image of the heavenly man [Jesus]” (see 1 Cor 15:42–49). On that final day, “He will transform the body of our humble condition into the likeness of His glorious body” (Phil 3:21). Ashley’s body would one day be perfect but not the false “perfect” she had envisioned for herself. Her version of “perfect” had led her into bondage and to the brink of death. God’s version of “perfect” would be truly ideal, flawless, and free.

    After I had explained these stages of justification, sanctification, and glorification, Ashley had a puzzled look on her face. “But I’ve always been taught that if I make any effort in my flesh, I’m ‘out of fellowship’ with God.” Ashley had believed the well-meaning lies that she should “let go and let God” and that her fellowship with God had a whimsical on-off switch. She needed theological correction regarding the balance of trust and action as well as the stability of her relationship with God. “Actually, we are to make an effort to grow, and we’re to ask the Lord to help us as he’s promised,” I replied. “But this ‘all or nothing’ idea of being in or out of fellowship is not true. A true believer is permanently justified in Christ, and nothing can change that, not even a believer’s remaining sin.” Of course, there are times when a professing believer needs to be warned that his constantly sinful patterns are demonstrating that he may never have been converted in the first place (Matt 7:21–23), but this was not what Ashley needed to hear at this time.

    I gave her an example of how her spiritual effort could please the Lord instead of displeasing him, as she’d been taught: “You could say to yourself, ‘I am going to eat this meal because I love the Lord, and it’s my joy to please him. He will receive the glory because He will help me obey him.’” From Ashley’s response it was clear that she was reconsidering what she had been taught in these areas. Her hope was slowly growing.

    God’s High and Holy Purpose in Hardship

    Another essential perspective I wanted Ashley to understand was God’s high and holy purpose behind his discipline of her. Even though she was experiencing the consequences of her own sin, she was not going through this process in vain. Hebrews 12 begins with an exhortation for Christians: “Let us lay aside every weight and the sin that so easily ensnares us. Let us run with endurance the race that lies before us, keeping our eyes on Jesus, the source and perfecter of our faith” (vv. 1–2). The supreme example of this perseverance is our Lord Jesus Christ who “endured a cross” and even “despised the shame,” all because he saw “the joy that lay before Him” (v. 2).

    I also encouraged Ashley with the next exhortation in Hebrews: to not “grow weary and lose heart” in the battle against sin (Heb 12:3–4). She could be confident that there was a high and holy purpose behind God’s discipline of her. The author of Hebrews explains further:

    In struggling against sin, you have not yet resisted to the point of shedding your blood. And you have forgotten the exhortation that addresses you as sons:

    My son, do not take the Lord’s discipline lightly or faint when you are reproved by him, for the Lord disciplines the one He loves and punishes every son He receives.

    Endure suffering as discipline: God is dealing with you as sons. For what son is there that a father does not discipline? But if you are without discipline—which all receive—then you are illegitimate children and not sons. Furthermore, we had natural fathers discipline us, and we respected them. Shouldn’t we submit even more to the Father of spirits and live? For they disciplined us for a short time based on what seemed good to them, but he does it for our benefit, so that we can share His holiness. No discipline seems enjoyable at the time, but painful. Later on, however, it yields the fruit of peace and righteousness to those who have been trained by it.

    (Heb 12:4–11, emphasis added)

    I continued emphasizing to Ashley that God did indeed have a high and holy purpose behind his discipline of her. His discipline was not meant to be destructive but constructive; purifying, not punitive. Even as I write this sentence, it is astounding to think that because of God’s goodness and grace, we can actually share his holiness. The pruning is painful in the short term, but it ultimately glorifies God and results in supernatural peace and righteousness. God’s graciousness toward us, in spite of our sin, is truly amazing!

    Hollow Beauty and Holy Beauty

    One major issue that God’s gracious discipline had exposed in Ashley’s life was vanity. Vanity is just as common as it is powerful. The word vanity refers to something that is “empty, futile, vain, or worthless.” In the sense of a love of beauty, it is an inordinate love of one’s own beauty, an “inflated pride in one’s appearance.”

    When I listed some of the possible signs of vanity, Ashley admitted she struggled with many of them. She was overly concerned about how she looked, and she almost constantly compared her appearance to others’. She was also unable to receive compliments. Instead of graciously saying “thank you,” she would become embarrassed or angry at the person complimenting her. She was often depressed or anxious because she believed herself to be fat, and she was on a quest for thinness that led her to abuse her body through anorexia.

    To cut through these deceitful desires, we embarked on a brief study through various Scriptures that address vanity. The Old Testament emphasis is summarized powerfully in Prov 31:30: “Charm is deceitful and beauty is fleeting, but a woman who fears the Lord will be praised.” Later the New Testament emphasizes the true beauty that shines when a woman adorns herself with proper clothing, good works, and a gentle and quiet spirit: “The women are to dress themselves in modest clothing, with decency and good sense, not with elaborate hairstyles, gold, pearls, or expensive apparel, but with good works, as is proper for women who affirm that they worship God” (1 Tim 2:9–10).

    Good works are done mostly behind the scenes. Few people, if any, know about them. Consider the woman who quietly works in the kitchen to clean up after the church picnic or sits by the bed of a friend recovering from surgery. She takes meals to the sick or cleans the house of the woman whose husband is dying.

    Together we explored possible good works Ashley could pursue in the coming week. After some brainstorming, Ashley decided to visit a woman from their church family who was in a nursing home. She would take her some flowers and read to her. After almost dying in her sin of hollow beauty, Ashley was beginning to learn what true beauty is in God’s eyes.

    We also talked about how she tended to surrender to her fear of not being thin, beautiful, and perfect by starving herself. We also explored the biblical alternative—trusting God, graciously accepting her natural appearance as a gift from him, and thanking God that although she could not attain her own “perfect” standard, by his grace she could be faithful.

    That week I asked Ashley to read the chapter on vanity in the book Damsels in Distress and to answer the questions at the end of that chapter. She learned that the world considers vanity a disease—a body image problem. In contrast, she learned that vanity is really an internal issue and that true holy beauty is on the inside—a godly heart. As she began to see that her sinful self-focus was truly ugly, she grew in gratitude for the grace and mercy Christ had shown her on the cross.

    The next week, Ashley’s “Self-Talk Log” reflected new attitudes—grief over her sin, confession to God, and a new softness toward those seeking to help her. She had gained only one pound since beginning counseling, so it was time to increase her calories to 2000 per day. I reviewed her food diary and gave her practical instructions such as how to add two more servings of fat, two more servings of bread, and two more servings of meat.

    I continued to remind her of the big picture—turning to Christ for comfort and help, expressing gratitude to him, and showing love to him by obeying him even if she felt afraid or frustrated. In addition, I encouraged her to keep considering how to show love to others in the midst of her own difficult circumstances.

    A Gentle and Quiet Spirit

    The apostle Peter, a married fisherman who became one of Jesus’ closest disciples, knew about true beauty. He exhorted the Christian women in his day:

    Your beauty should not consist of outward things like elaborate hairstyles and the wearing of gold ornaments or fine clothes. Instead, it should consist of what is inside the heart with the imperishable quality of a gentle and quiet spirit, which is very valuable in God’s eyes. (1 Pet 3:3–4)

    I knew I would need to explain what “a gentle and quiet spirit” really means. It did not mean Ashley needed to whisper when she talked or shift her eyes away from anyone who talked to her. It did not mean being passive or a pushover. It meant accepting that God’s dealings with her were right and good, instead of giving in to anger, fear, or constant arguing. It also meant cultivating a sense of true humility and modesty that sought the best for others instead of attention for herself. This kind of “gentle and quiet spirit” is “very valuable in God’s eyes.”

    The Flaw of Perfectionism

    In our first conversation Ashley acknowledged that others saw her as a perfectionist, but she herself disagreed. She thought doing her best was a good thing. Now that God had been softening her heart, however, she was more ready to consider the possibility that she really was a perfectionist.

    Perfectionism means striving for an impossibly high standard, usually for selfish ends. In the case of those who are anorexic, the perfectionist drive centers on having the perfect body and eating perfectly; but the underlying issues are selfish motives and sinful desires. Their distorted mind-set descends into bizarre thinking and behaviors because they are actually worshipping themselves. Hardened by their own pride, they become willing to destroy their own body and sacrifice themselves in the pursuit of their ideal self-image. Blinded by their self-righteousness, they cannot see Christ as their righteousness.

    I asked Ashley, “In light of eternity, just how important are your perfectionistic goals when it comes to your body?” Ashley thought for a while and said, “Obviously, it’s not important at all, but I just can’t stop thinking about food and my body!” Knowing that mental habits are incredibly stubborn, I assured her that altering her mind-set would take time, like all Christian growth. Yet God had given her several means of grace to help her. God had given her a new heart in place of the old, hard heart that spurns God and his ways. She possessed the indwelling Holy Spirit who would faithfully produce the fruits of the Spirit as she walked with him. She had God’s perfect Word that was breathed out by God himself, making it profitable for “training in righteousness, so that the man of God may be complete, equipped for every good work” (2 Tim 3:16–17). She was surrounded by other believers who would help her stop her self-focused thinking by speaking the truth to her in love.

    Ashley, along with her church family and the Christians who were helping her, would “grow in every way into Him who is the head—Christ” (Eph 4:15). “In other words,” I explained, “we all help each other become more and more like Jesus Christ.” With this hopeful aim in mind, I exhorted Ashley to persevere in renewing her mind by continuing to ask God to help her replace her old, sinful, habitual thinking with what the Bible calls the “new self, the one created according to God’s likeness in righteousness and purity of the truth” (Eph 4:24).

    I left her with three assignments for the coming week: (1) to memorize 2 Pet 3:18 and Heb 10:30, which would continually exhort her to grow in the grace and knowledge of Jesus Christ by persevering toward God’s promised reward; (2) to continue recording her thoughts in her “Self-Talk Log,” this time correcting her own thoughts instead of bringing them to me for correction; and (3) to keep working her way through The Attributes of God so her view of God would continue to grow into wholehearted admiration, trust, and devotion.

    Lingering Sin

    In coming days Ashley found herself continually badgered by her self-imposed rules about what she could and could not eat. She also found it difficult to shut out the running tally in her mind that tracked her calories and seemed to whisper ideas about how to make up for her food consumption by eating less at the next meal. This struggle intensified when I increased her calorie count or when she weighed in and saw that she had gained even as little as half a pound. After weeks of counsel, she finally admitted these rampant thoughts and began including them in her weekly “Self-Talk Log.” She was soon eating 2,200 calories per day without exercising, and her weight increased from 85 to 92 pounds.

    Even though she had gained weight, her sinful, habitual obsessions still tormented her mind. As we had discussed at the beginning of our relationship, we began talking about habits and how she would not be able to stop obsessing about food until she started being grateful to the Lord and setting her thoughts on pleasing him and showing love to others. This would require work on Ashley’s part, and she needed God’s grace to persevere. Here are some examples of what Ashley admitted to thinking, in contrast with the thoughts that I encouraged her to cultivate in order to renew her mind and honor God.

    Sinful, Obsessive Thoughts

    Grateful, God-Honoring Thoughts

    “I’m not putting gravy on my rice—it’s unhealthy and will make me fat!”

    “Mom’s gravy isn’t unhealthy for me because I don’t have a cholesterol problem. It’s God’s will that I gain weight and be grateful for this delicious gravy” (cf. 1 Thess 5:18).

    “That serving of ice cream is 160 calories. . . . Tomorrow morning I’ll skip breakfast but record some breakfast foods in my food diary.”

    “Heavenly Father, forgive me for planning to lie. Tomorrow morning please help me not only to eat breakfast but to be grateful for it” (cf. 1 John 1:9).

    “Mom made us a chicken casserole, but I can’t eat it because I don’t know what ingredients she used.”

    “Love is not selfish. I can love my mom and influence my younger brothers by graciously eating what she’s made for our family” (cf. 1 Cor 13:5).

    “Any sugar, no matter what, is really bad for you. This is going to make me sick.”

    “Rejecting all sugar is nonsense. I have freedom in the Lord to enjoy sugar as long as I’m not gluttonous. Thank God for sugar!” (cf. Col 3:16).

    “There’s no way I’m eating that meatloaf. It’s red meat and it’s fatty. Everyone knows it’s unhealthy. I can’t believe my mom would do this to me!”

    “The truth is that I’m healthy and don’t have hyper-cholesterol disease, so I can eat a normal portion of meatloaf. It’s fine! Only my religious anorexia tells me ‘Don’t handle, don’t taste, don’t touch’” (cf. Col 2:20–23), “but Scripture clearly tells me to enjoy the freedoms I have in the Lord and that God has declared even meatloaf good!” (cf. Acts 10:9–16).

    “I’ll eat some of this biscuit so that my parents will get off my back. But tonight I’ll put in 20 more minutes of exercise to make up for it.”

    “Lord, please forgive me for making these deceptive plans. I’m going to eat this entire biscuit and be grateful to the Lord and to my mother for making it!”

    The Everyday, Ordinary Christian

    At this point I decided to walk Ashley through a brief study I’ve entitled “The Life of an Everyday, Ordinary Christian Who Is Maturing Towards Christlikeness and Thereby Glorifying God.” In order to develop consistency in her Christian walk, she needed to remember her absolute need for God’s supernatural grace to help her, and she needed to remember that God had not held back a single drop of grace that she needed in order to grow and blossom. She needed to hear the remarkable promise recorded by Peter:

    His divine power has given us everything required for life and godliness through the knowledge of Him who called us by His own glory and goodness. By these He has given us very great and precious promises, so that through them you may share in the divine nature, escaping the corruption that is in the world because of evil desires.” (2 Pet 1:3–4, emphasis added)

    Peter not only reminded us of our dependence on the Lord but also our responsibility to “make every effort” (2 Pet 1:5). What was Ashley to be pursuing? Faith, goodness, knowledge, self-control, endurance, godliness, brotherly affection, and love (vv. 5–7). As we briefly studied each of these characteristics together, we could clearly see that Ashley was putting diligent effort toward them. She was greatly encouraged by the promise that “if these qualities are yours and are increasing, they will keep you from being useless or unfruitful in the knowledge of our Lord Jesus Christ” (v. 8).

    Bound for True Beauty

    Ashley had come a long way from that day in the library when her heart had almost stopped beating. Her weight had continued to climb toward a healthy range as she passed the 100-pound mark. More importantly, she was learning to embrace the glorious “mercies of God” and to reclaim her body from the idolatrous altar of self-image and to lay it down each day “as a living sacrifice, holy and pleasing to God” (Rom 12:1).

    She still struggled with her own false standards of healthy eating, and she still felt misplaced guilt about violating her previous dietary rules. As her “Think These Thoughts” journal continued to expand, so did her heart for the Lord. By God’s grace and because of Christ’s redemption, she persevered and gradually turned from her self-absorbed obsession with her body and her food to a healthy love for God and a strong desire to please him.

    I continued spending time with Ashley, giving her hope, explaining the gospel, and reminding her of the big picture. We kept talking about renewing her mind, reclaiming true beauty, and seeing through the lies of perfectionism. I monitored her hand-written “Self-Talk Log” and “Think These Thoughts” journal, continuing to guide her through the process of correcting her own thoughts. We continued praying together as I exhorted her to trust God over her feelings.

    I continued to work with Ashley, her mom, and their doctor for five months. The time came when Ashley no longer needed formal counseling every week, so we shifted to every other week for the next two months. Toward the end of our formal time together, we met only once a month for three months. I knew it was time to dismiss Ashley from formal counseling when we found ourselves spending most of our time together discussing how she could help her friends with their various problems. This once angry, depressed, self-consumed young lady had developed an obvious joy in the Lord, and he was now using her as a special blessing in my own life and in the lives of her struggling friends.

    Ashley was one of my hardest cases—a legitimate double emergency with both her body and her soul threatened by the effects of sin. Once again, however, God’s grace proved to be greater than even the most enslaving sins. He had revived Ashley—all of her. As I watched this truly healthy, spiritually fit young woman drive away from our last counseling session, my heart echoed the praise of the psalmist: “The instruction of the Lord is perfect, renewing one’s life” (Ps 19:7).

    According to standard height/weight ratios, Ashley was at least 25 pounds underweight, regardless of her frame.

    Ashley’s parents found this definition of anorexia from www.medicinenet.com. For more information about the secular description of this problem see Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders: DSM-IV-TR (Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association, 2000), 583–89.

    An eating problem like the one Ashley battled is a serious matter of life and death. It is absolutely critical for any counselor to consult with a physician who can provide medical advice about the struggling person. This is especially the case given the high level of deceit practiced by those struggling with such eating problems.

    Martha Peace, Salvation Handbook (Bemidji, MN: Focus, 2005).

    Since I have a medical background, I was able to talk with Ashley and her mother in more detail about these topics. Some counselors may be more comfortable referring people to a nutritionist for counsel on what to eat.

    Arthur W. Pink, The Attributes of God (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2006).

    Millard Erickson, Christian Theology (Grand Rapids: Baker, 1985), 967.

    The Merriam-Webster Dictionary (Boston: G. K. Hall, 1977), 981.

    Ibid.

    For a more complete list see Martha Peace, Damsels in Distress: Biblical Solutions for Problems Women Face (Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R, 2006), 92.

    Ibid, 89–102.

    This section on perfectionism was adapted with permission from Amy Baker’s workbook Overcoming Perfectionism (Lafayette, IN: Faith Resources, n.d.). Available at www.fbclafayette.org/store.

    ↑ Back to top

    ↑