Chapter 5: “Why Didn’t You Say Anything?” Avoiding the rush to blame
CHAPTER 5
“WHY DIDN’T YOU SAY ANYTHING?”
Avoiding the rush to blame
“What do you mean he hit you?
Why? What did you do
to provoke him?”
…And we wonder why our kids don’t come to us.
When I was in fourth grade, back when kids actually walked home from school, my brother and I got jumped on our way home.
Earlier that day, Sam, one of my classmates, stole my journal. My journal was a big deal—at least it was to my teacher, Mrs. Sumpel, who wanted us to write in it daily. Sam didn’t want to write in his journal, so he stole mine, erased my name from the top of every page, and wrote his name in its place (not a brilliant scheme by any means). I reported it to the teacher at the end of the day, and Sam denied it. The journal was nowhere to be found, so she said we’d deal with it the next day.
After school Sam and his brothers waited until my brother and I were halfway home and began picking a fight. They shoved me to the ground, pulled out a knife, and threatened us, but somehow my brother and I managed to flee.
I was terrified. I didn’t want to walk to school the next day. But my brother convinced me that we’d never be allowed to go anywhere on our own again if we told Mom and Dad. “Mom will freak!”
So we opted not to tell anyone.
The next day something surprising happened. When I arrived at school, Mrs. Sumpel was irate. She grabbed me by the shoulder and dragged me into the hallway. Sam was in the hallway crying (he was a far better actor than he was a criminal).
Mrs. Sumpel was fuming. She wagged her finger at me. “You are going to get some swats for this!” (Some of you remember the days when schools could spank. She had a big paddle hanging on her wall.)
She turned to Sam and in a soft voice asked, “Tell us what happened.”
Sam sniffed and wiped his tears. Finally he managed to point at me. “He stole my journal and said it was his.” He held up my journal.
Mrs. Sumpel shot her stare back toward me. “That’s one swat!”
Before I could object, Sam continued his Oscar-winning performance. “And then he and his brother cornered me after school…”
I was shocked. This kid was living in a house of lies!
Mrs. Sumpel turned to me once again. “That’s another swat!” She was livid. I think steam was actually leaking out of her ears.
Sam continued, “And then they shoved me on the ground…”
“And that’s another one!” Mrs. Sumpel said, frothing at the mouth.
“Wait,” I finally managed to interject. “Don’t you wanna hear my side of the story?”
Mrs. Sumpel reluctantly agreed.
“First,” I said, pointing to the journal, “that’s my journal. Take a look for yourself.”
Mrs. Sumpel hesitantly asked Sam, “Can I see the journal?”
Sam handed her the journal, and she began investigating every page. The name Jonathan was poorly erased on every page, clearly still legible, and the name Sam was scratched over it. As she flipped through the pages, her expression changed.
After a few moments, once she realized the major flaw in Sam’s story, I told her the true version.
With no apology, she quietly told me, “Okay, you can go.”
This experience cemented two things in my mind.
1. Mrs. Sumpel was straight-up crazy.
2. Teachers can’t be trusted.
The next year I experienced a similar occurrence with a teacher. I walked into the boys’ bathroom to find three or four older boys kicking the flush handles. One boy had done his best karate kick to flush the handle (which is actually a pretty sanitary way to flush if you think about it), and the other boys followed suit. I hadn’t even used the toilet yet when the principal barged in and herded all of us out into the hallway.
He lined us all up and went to his office to fetch his paddle. It had holes in it for less wind resistance and a harder smack. We called it “the whistler.” It had a very unique tone compared to the other paddles in the school.
“You guys were hurting school property!” he barked.
I spoke up. “Not me! I wasn’t even—”
“Quiet!” He wasn’t having any of it. We were all declared guilty without trial. He simply asked, “Who’s first?”
I can still remember the sound it made.
It didn’t take me long to realize, Adults frequently get it wrong.
SILENCE
“Why didn’t you say anything?”
The most common words adults use when they discover a young person has been bullied.
If only kids would answer honestly.
“Because I don’t trust you.”
“Because I knew you’d make the situation worse.”
“Because you’re just going to tell me it’s my fault.”
My guess is that the school down the street from you has made some antibullying efforts. A school assembly. Posters in classrooms. Maybe even a policy that they are intolerant of bullying.
But are these broad gestures helping?
Do young people feel safe to speak up?
The US Department of Education conducted a recent study about victimization in which they asked over 24 million kids about bullying. That’s a lot of kids. In the study a little over 20 percent of sixth through twelfth graders said they had been bullied…yet less than half of those told an adult.
Sixth graders were most likely to tell an adult—over 60 percent of bullied kids said something. But by high school those numbers go way down, with only 35 percent of bullied freshmen reporting what happened, and only 26 percent of bullied seniors.1
I asked about a dozen of the teachers I interviewed how many incidents of bullying were reported at their schools. The average answer reflected less than 10 percent of students.
Less than 10 percent?
We’ve already looked at studies in this book revealing that anywhere from 20 to 50 percent of kids experience bullying on any given campus. Why are less than 10 percent of kids reporting bullying?
Why aren’t kids speaking up?
More importantly, how can a caring adult create a climate where kids feel safe to talk about being targeted?
WHY AREN’T KIDS SPEAKING UP?
RUSH TO BLAME
It’s never easy being a parent or teacher charged with the task of discipline—especially when there are different stories. When teachers experience a verbal exchange or disruption in the classroom, no buzzer goes off to alert them it’s a bullying situation.
It happens to parents all the time. We hear our kids raising their voices and know we should intervene. We’re like the Terminator seeing possible responses scrolling on our digital display:
1. “Knock it off!”
2. “What’s going on in there?”
3. “You two had better start getting along, or you’ve got another thing coming!”
If the fighting gets worse, we actually have to put down what we’re doing and go play cop or arbitrator. If they’re lucky, they’ll get the latter.
“Okay, someone tell me what happened.”
Then the stories begin.
“I was playing a video game and Michael came in and turned it off.”
“No, I didn’t! Chris was hogging the video games all day, and whenever I asked if I could play, he said, ‘You snooze, you lose!’”
“Did not!”
“Did so!”
Now it’s our job to find out what really happened, which often is the fault of both parties. That’s why we sometimes rush to the judgment.
“Well then, no one gets to play!”
Which is why most younger siblings opt not to tell on their sibling, because they know they’ll get in trouble too, regardless of innocence! (I’m speaking for all younger siblings!)
Sure, kids can experience bullying of sorts by an older sibling, but typically it’s just a selfish sibling exerting power control for their own self-seeking reasons. When it’s two random kids at school, the situation becomes all the more difficult.
The powerful documentary Bully2 includes a sobering scene where a principal catches two kids quarreling and makes the boys shake hands. One kid quickly complies, politely offering his hand. The other refuses to shake hands. The principal immediately scolds the kid who doesn’t offer his hand.
The scene was difficult for me to watch, as a kid who was picked on daily. In fact, many who have reviewed the film have commented something like, “I was screaming at the screen watching these stupid teachers and principals!”
The scene was frustrating to watch because we—the viewing audience—had a huge advantage over the principal: perspective. We had just spent the entire movie watching one kid make this other kid’s life miserable, taunting him and pushing him while other kids laughed. The principal caught the tail end of one of these interactions, seeing two boys not getting along, and tried to solve the problem quickly.
“You guys shake hands.”
This was an absurd effort at peacekeeping on several levels. First, what has handshaking ever solved? Someone please show me some data revealing that shaking hands calms tempers, erases wrongs, and promotes peace and harmony.
There is no such data.
Second, the principal rushed to a resolution. Schoolteachers and administrators have so much on their plates, they often don’t have the time it takes to truly listen to both sides of a story. So sometimes they try shortcuts to a quick resolution.
“Both of you quit it, or you’ll both be sorry.”
Maybe a threat like this will stop the bickering temporarily, but it rarely stops the problem. If feelings were hurt, they typically don’t heal themselves. The conflict usually resumes later exactly where it left off.
In the documentary, the poor bullied kid refused to shake hands. He wasn’t about to shake the hand of the snake whose venomous daily attacks had left him feeling worthless and hopeless. The principal responded by shaming the kid who wouldn’t extend his hand. In fact, she dismissed the bully and began reprimanding the bullied.
SCHOOLTEACHERS AND ADMINISTRATORS HAVE SO MUCH ON THEIR PLATES, THEY OFTEN DON’T HAVE THE TIME IT TAKES TO TRULY LISTEN TO BOTH SIDES OF A STORY. SO SOMETIMES THEY TRY SHORTCUTS TO A QUICK RESOLUTION.
“He was willing to shake your hand. It was you who wouldn’t shake hands.”
At this point the victim realized it wasn’t just kids but also adults who were against him.
We should note, however, that apparently when the principal eventually saw the film and gained perspective on the entire situation, she felt terrible and signed off on the filmmakers showing this embarrassing scene because she thought it would help other principals avoid making the same mistake.
So how can we gain a big-picture perspective and avoid making mistakes like this? In other words, how can a parent, teacher, or any authority figure spot the signs of bullying and not rush to blame?
RUSH
Here’s a phrase parents hear from me a lot at my parent seminars: “Parenting is a lot of work.”
It takes work to notice what’s going on in the world of our kids, it takes work to be proactive about connecting with our kids, it takes work to truly listen to our kids, and yes, it takes work to uncover the truth in a disagreement between two kids.
Who has time for all this work?
The temptation is to rush through some of it.
But that doesn’t work.
In my research for my book If I Had a Parenting Do-over, I asked hundreds of parents just one question: “If you could go back in time and change one parenting practice, what would you do over?”
One answer kept emerging. It was the most common answer by a landslide.
“I wish I’d spent more time with my kids.”
The answer came in many forms: “I wish we would have had more family meals.” Or “I wish I would have actually walked into my kids’ room, sat down on the floor, and talked with them while they were doing their homework.”
But the gist was clear. They wish they would have devoted the time to connect with their kids.
You can’t rush through parenting, and you certainly can’t rush through getting to the bottom of a story.
Realize that getting to the truth takes time. If you’re a teacher and don’t have time to stop teaching thirty kids to deal with two, then send the two kids to someone who can spend the time. Schools need to be set up that way. Every kid should get a fair shot. No kid should be declared guilty when they only received a seven-second trial (more on this in chapter eleven).
Eliminate any rush to judgment.
Eliminate the rush to blame.
NO KID SHOULD BE DECLARED GUILTY WHEN THEY ONLY RECEIVED A SEVEN-SECOND TRIAL
BLAME
Hindsight is 20/20. If we could watch a movie and see the entire story, it would be much easier to avoid blaming the innocent—blaming the bullied.
But it happens all the time. It’s almost automatic. It’s why rape victims often don’t come forward. They know what responses they’ll hear.
• “Were you drinking?”
• “Did you lead him on?”
• “Did you actually say no?”
• “Why did you wait until now to say anything?”
Rape victims don’t want to come forward because they know they will be put on trial. The victim automatically becomes a suspect.
The same is true with bullying.
• “Are you sure that happened?”
• “Maybe he was just joking.”
• “Well, what did you do to make him so mad?”
• “Have you tried just ignoring him?”
How can we expect victims of bullying to ask for help when they know they will be interrogated?
How can we avoid rushing to blame?
The key is in resisting the need to “fix” the situation. Personally, I struggle with this because I am a fixer! But bullied kids aren’t typically ready to be fixed. Most of the time they just want to be noticed and heard.
That’s where we need to start.
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
1. What was one thing in this chapter that really stood out to you?
2. Why do you think most bullying victims don’t report bullying?
3. Why do you think most bystanders don’t report bullying?
4. What are some ways you might “rush” through parenting when it comes to either connecting with your kids or just getting to the bottom of a story?
5. What are some common ways we might unintentionally “blame” kids who are bullied?
6. Do you tend to want to “fix” your child’s problems right away, or stop to notice and hear? How does that typically work out for you?
7. What is something you can try this week to avoid rushing to blame?
