Chapter 10 of 19

Chapter 7: The Bully In the minds of the bullies…and how to actually help them

Chapter 7: The Bully In the minds of the bullies…and how to actually help them

CHAPTER 7

THE BULLY

In the minds of the bullies…and how to actually help them

Bullies are people who use conflict as a means

for obtaining power. Some young people grow

out of this; others don’t and become old bullies.

–Bob Goff

Three categories of young people stand out on any given campus today: the bully, the bystander, and the bullied.

Which one were you?

Which one is your kid?

It’s an especially uncomfortable reality for parents to think about. One of my daughters looks back at her early years and admits, “I was mean. Honestly, once I got in with the popular kids, it was normal to laugh at those who weren’t.”

When my wife, Lori, and I first heard her admit that, the first words out of our mouths were, “You weren’t really that bad, were you?”

Funny, as I rethink my own reaction, I realize it’s leaning toward denial. Sure, as a parent you want to support your kid and help them not beat themselves up for their past, but there’s also a little bit of, “You didn’t really do that, did you?” which might really suggest, “We didn’t raise you that way!”

It’s hard to think of our own kid as a bully. Trust me, I don’t want to be the one pointing the finger at your kid. If there’s one thing that makes mama bear mad, it’s poking her cubs.

But that’s just it. Many moms and dads don’t realize what’s truly going on in the lives of their “cubs.” For teachers it’s even more difficult to discern. Many teachers are so overwhelmed with managing a classroom that they don’t have time to sort through the drama and discover what’s really happening in the lives of their students.

After listening to countless stories from young people in all three groups, as well as observing young people for the last three decades, I’ve found in most situations the evidence of bullying was obvious to anyone who cared enough to notice and knew what to look for.

So what do each of these kids look like?

Let’s spend a little time peeking into the mind-set of individuals in each of these categories: the bully, the bystander, and the bullied.

In this chapter we’ll look at the bully.

I’VE FOUND IN MOST SITUATIONS THE EVIDENCE OF BULLYING WAS OBVIOUS TO ANYONE WHO CARED ENOUGH TO NOTICE AND KNEW WHAT TO LOOK FOR.

RUDE, MEAN BULLY

I interviewed a kid I’ll call Jake who had a dramatic experience in middle school. He liked a girl I’ll call Becca and wanted to ask her to a school dance. So Jake did what any middle school kid does—he asked his friends to ask Becca’s friends if she liked him and wanted to go to the dance with him.

The verdict came back “yes,” so Jake decided to ask her.

At this particular school, many if not most boys asked girls in a very creative way. They would make a sign and hold it up in the cafeteria or get a friend to announce it over the intercom. Jake was pretty shy, and the thought of attempting a huge public “ask” frightened him. But listening to his sister’s advice, he bought a bouquet of flowers and waited in the center hall, a central hub where most kids hung out or at least passed through on the way to lunch, the perfect location to officially ask Becca to the dance. Becca’s best friend had class with Becca before lunch and assured Jake that she would be walking through there.

Everything was set.

As Jake stood there waiting, people began whispering and texting. “Jake’s going to ask Becca to the dance.” The buzzing traveled down the hallway where Becca and her best friend were approaching. People began making comments.

“Becca’s gonna go to the dance.”

“Watch out…Jake’s ready to pounce!”

Becca heard the comments and panicked, stopping dead in her tracks. She was only twenty feet from the center hall where Jake was waiting.

“What?” her friend asked.

“I don’t know if I want to go,” Becca said.

“What? But you said…”

Becca quickly darted in the bathroom where she hid for the entire lunch period.

Jake waited for about five minutes…five of the longest minutes of his life. Eventually the word reached Jake. “She’s not coming.”

The event is a painful memory for him to talk about.

But it wasn’t bullying.

People love to throw around the word bullying. Fact is, a lot of young people today are rude, mean, selfish…but not bullies.

I went to a workshop on bullying prevention from a professor at California State University, Sacramento where the presenter said something creative:

If someone does something “unintentionally” hurtful, that’s rude.

If someone does something “intentionally” hurtful, and they do it once, that’s mean!

But when someone does something “intentionally” hurtful, you tell them to stop or you don’t like it, and they keep doing it, that’s bullying.

ANY UNWANTED AGGRESSIVE BEHAVIOR(S) BY ANOTHER YOUTH OR GROUP OF YOUTHS WHO ARE NOT SIBLINGS OR CURRENT DATING PARTNERS THAT INVOLVES AN OBSERVED OR PERCEIVED POWER IMBALANCE AND IS REPEATED MULTIPLE TIMES OR IS HIGHLY LIKELY TO BE REPEATED.

Jake experienced a very hurtful experience, and most of the school actually thought Becca was “lame” for doing what she did, but Becca didn’t actually intend to hurt Jake. She was just fickle and acted selfishly, not considering how her actions affected others. In fact, afterward she felt terrible.

Becca’s rejection of Jake was “unintentional.” It wasn’t a power play (other than the fact that she exercised the right to change her mind), and it wasn’t ever repeated.

Bullying is all about power plays. And the more I interviewed bullies, the more I saw this firsthand.

POWER

Nick perfectly fit the axiomatic stereotype of “bully” in anyone’s mind.

Nick was big.

He was an athlete.

He was popular.

He was a toolbag!

For Nick it began the summer before high school. He hit puberty, grew several shoe sizes, began lifting weights, and could grow a beard overnight.

Nick looked old for his age. He used to buy alcohol and cigarettes at fifteen. His size helped him get bumped to varsity in every sport as a freshman, which didn’t hurt his popularity by any means. This gave him confidence…maybe overconfidence. In fact, Nick was voted “most outspoken” by his peers all four years of high school.

On the outside, Nick was living the dream; anybody would have wanted to be him.

On the inside, Nick felt like his life was falling apart.

Nick left his home at sixteen. His use of alcohol and drugs escalated to trying more illicit drugs. Nick dealt with his own pain by inflicting pain on others, but not just physically. Nick loved to “tease.”

Nick told himself it was just teasing, but he knew his relentless mocking was hurting his victims. He told me, “I didn’t care who you were, how big or small you were! Anything to get a laugh, belittle, or get attention.”

Before long Nick was acting like the proverbial bully you’ve seen in every teen movie, repeatedly insulting others, knocking books or lunch trays out of people’s hands, and instigating embarrassing pranks.

He quickly began meeting all the bullying criteria:

Aggressive behavior

Power play

Repeated

Nick had lots of moments he wasn’t proud of, but the one he seemed most ashamed of was when he turned on his best friend.

Nick and Josh had been friends since they were kids. They lived next door to each other and hung out almost every day. The two shared their deepest, darkest secrets…until Nick became popular. As Nick changed, their relationship fell apart.

One day Nick was looking through pictures on his phone and found a video he took of Josh the year prior. In Nick’s words, “Josh had this mad crush on this girl, but never had the nerve to tell her.” Josh and Nick brainstormed ways he could ask her out, and Josh even practiced asking her out by asking out his sister’s doll. Nick filmed this vulnerable moment.

When Nick found the video, he couldn’t resist the opportunity. So he posted the video for all to see, and Josh was mortally embarrassed.

The episode was of course detrimental to Josh. He was now labeled “doll dater” by everyone, including Nick. Thanks to Nick, many bystanders were now becoming bullies. They would tease Josh repeatedly, hoping to feel better about their own status by dropping his status a few notches.

Aggressive behavior

Power play

Repeated

That’s how it works. And Nick’s story is far from unique.

Consider Chrissy.

Chrissy used to get picked on by the other girls at her school. When she asked her dad what she should do, he told her, “If they do something mean to you, do something mean back to them. Stand up for yourself.” And so she learned how to fight.

“This is when I became the bully,” Chrissy told me. “For me the words ‘stand up for yourself’ meant to show you were the tough one. I was never the prettiest or the smartest, and never had the best clothes, but I could fight.”

Chrissy became a scrapper, and she was pretty good at it.

She remembers one fight in particular when a girl was teasing Chrissy about her clothes. She marched straight up to her, punched her in the face, then jumped on top of her and kept punching.

“From that day on, if anyone made me upset, I just beat them up.”

Chrissy’s lack of conflict-management skills moved her from bullied to bully. Now she didn’t just defend herself; she aggressively asserted her power by picking on others or intimidating them. Her defense mechanism had become her identity.

I was particularly sympathetic to Chrissy’s story since she was initially being picked on. I could even relate to her dad’s advice of “stand up for yourself,” although I would have worded it a little differently.

But how is a parent to know when their child becomes a bully?

I’m sure Chrissy’s dad never fathomed that Chrissy would start using fighting to solve problems.

Did he ever ask?

Did he ever follow up?

PARENTING A BULLY

In 2018 the TV channel A&E aired a show called Undercover High where seven “undercover adults” posed as high school students for a semester in Topeka, Kansas. The show unveiled some eye-opening realities for many parents, like exactly how much smartphones have changed teen culture in the last five years alone.

But these incognito adults embedded in the high school campus also discovered something else that surprised them and many researchers: exactly how rampant bullying had become.

In a candid interview, Erin, one of the undercover adults, shared her insight as someone who admittedly bullied others in the past:

I think for a lot of bullies it’s not about looking to hurt someone in particular, but not being a target yourself, and just finding your niche. That’s the shoes I filled. I wanted to stand out, and I wanted to be seen. I went to a large high school, so being someone who was under five feet, I knew that I needed to make myself seem big.1

Erin, like Chrissy, just wanted to survive. She didn’t want to become the bullied…so for her, bully was a better option.

This is where the interview became especially intriguing. Erin was asked, “What would you suggest to parents if they think their teen is a bully?”

Erin’s answer was something you’re going to read repeatedly throughout this book: engage your kids in dialogue about what’s really happening in their lives. Erin suggested parents actually ask who they’re talking with, how they’re treating others. Maybe even specifically, “What did you do in the hallway today?”

Erin said, “Parents always ask, ‘How was school?’ but don’t think to dig deeper to what else is going on.”2

Erin’s insight is spot-on. In fact, all of the counselors I’ve interviewed and every single one of the studies I’ve read have two common denominators in their advice to parents: notice and listen.

We discussed how to “use our eyes and ears before our mouths” in the previous chapter. What specifically does this look like if our kid might possibly be a bully?

THE SIGNS WERE THERE

Earlier in the chapter I made the following claim:

In most situations the evidence of bullying was obvious to anyone who cared enough to notice and knew what to look for.

Let that sink in for a moment.

This book is full of stories and interviews where bullying went unnoticed. Sadly, whenever tragedy strikes—a suicide, a retaliation of violence—everyone looks back and concludes, “The signs were all there.”

What signs?

I will repeat my contention: In most situations the evidence of bullying was obvious to anyone who cared enough to notice and knew what to look for.

Cared enough to notice:

I’m going to make a leap and assume you care enough to notice. Why? You have this book in your hands right now. And if you really care, then today when you come into contact with that kid you care so much about, I’ll assume you’ll practice noticing, “using your eyes and ears before your mouth,” taking note of their attitude and behaviors, listening to what they talk about, and observing where they focus their attention. For many adults this will mean sliding aside our own devices for a given time during the day to take notice of our kids’ world.

Knew what to look for:

What does today’s bully look like? Is it always some big jock who pushes smaller kids around and steals their lunch money?

Girls typically engage in social power plays like belittling, ostracizing, and harassing. This might start with repeated name-calling, then graduate to shunning their victims from social circles—“You can’t sit here.” Sometimes this is just normal “drama.” But when it becomes repeated, aggressive power plays (think of our three checkboxes), it’s bullying.

Guys tend to be a little more physical, giving that hard bump with a stiff shoulder as they pass a weaker person in the hallway, slapping the back of the neck or legs, or even pushing and hitting. Not just one fight, but repeated, aggressive power plays (check, check…check).

Of course both guys and girls will dabble in both emotional and physical power plays, but typically it’s a little more physical with guys and a tad more “drama” with girls.

Sometimes the levels a kid will sink to are jaw-dropping. Like “allergy bullying.” Kids smear an unnoticeable trace of peanut butter across the keys of the keyboard of a kid with a peanut allergy. Or like the three fourteen-year-old Pennsylvania teens who in 2018 decided to target one of their classmates who had a severe pineapple allergy. One of these resentful girls rubbed pineapple all over her hands and deliberately high-fived the girl with the allergy.3 The girl had to get a shot with an epinephrine pen and was taken to the hospital in an ambulance. The leader was charged with aggravated assault and three other felony charges. Her two friends are facing similar charges.4

Parents and teachers need to take notice of how each of their kids treat others, even when they don’t think they’re being watched. I’ll reiterate: most kids aren’t half as sly as they think they are. Adults can feign looking down at their own device while subtly keeping their eyes on their kids. Again, most adults don’t pay much attention to young people, so young people aren’t used to someone actually taking notice.

Even if you don’t see any obvious power plays, bullies will show early signs of bullying behaviors.

EARLY SIGNS YOUR KID MIGHT BE A BULLY

• LOW SELF-ESTEEM

• SELF-CENTEREDNESS—A LACK OF EMPATHY FOR OTHERS

• ANGRY OUTBURSTS—BECOMING FRUSTRATED WITH THEIR OWN PERSONAL PROBLEMS AND TAKING IT OUT ON OTHERS

• ATTENTION SEEKING—SPECIFICALLY SEEKING STATUS OR SUPERIORITY

• POWER PLAYS—WANTING CONTROL OVER OTHERS, SOMETIMES IN RETALIATION FOR BEING BULLIED BY SOMEONE ELSE

• HAVING A MOM OR DAD WHO PARENTS AT EITHER EXTREME—THE PARENT IS EITHER A BULLY OR A WEAKLING MANIPULATED AND CONTROLLED BY THE KID

Bullies usually show several of these signs. Having one of these characteristics doesn’t make them a bully. In other words, if a kid just shows attention-seeking behaviors, that doesn’t mean they’re a bully. But if you see a kid with low self-esteem who hogs attention by repeatedly belittling others to make herself feel superior…then you might be seeing the early signs of a bully.

If you notice some of these signs, the next step is to engage the child in dialogue to gain a more accurate perspective on what you’ve observed. This requires less talking and more listening. Caring adults can have a much greater impact on kids when they move from a position of lecturing to a posture of listening. So when I say “engage your kids in dialogue,” I’m emphasizing the word dialogue, which means two people interacting, not one person lecturing (which is a monologue).

We talked about what this looks like in the previous chapter: empathizing with young people, making them feel noticed and heard. This opens the door to dialogue with them about their world, revealing many of their thoughts and attitudes about others. It also might open up opportunities to discuss how their words can affect others.

The best way to open up these doors of dialogue is through questions.

“Tell me a little about your disagreement with Taylor yesterday.”

“How did that make you feel?”

“How do you wish he would have treated you?”

“How did you respond?”

“If you had a do-over, would you respond the same way?”

Be careful not to switch to interrogation mode. These questions should be asked after you’ve already expressed empathy; you don’t want to immediately switch back to blame.

But sometimes parents, teachers, and school administrators need to get to the bottom of a situation. This requires a bit of digging—and this is why it’s so important for caring adults to notice and listen. A little investment of each can usually reveal any bullying behaviors at play. Once these are uncovered, it’s time for the bully (or bullies) to be counseled.

CONFRONTING COUNSELING A BULLY

Sometimes we need to remind ourselves that bullies need help just as much as the bullied. Trust me, acknowledging this truth can be difficult for me, especially when I see a mean kid abusing his power over someone weaker. This scenario brings up all kinds of hurt and makes me lose perspective.

As a quick aside, I’m going to mention this is where I really need to tap into God’s power and give Him control over my reactions to others. The more I soak in His love, the more it overflows to others.

It also helps to know that many bullies are victims too, or at least humans with real struggles and insecurities of their own. Bullying takes an emotional toll on all involved…not just the bullied. In fact, a new study on the impact of cyberbullying on children and young people across thirty countries revealed that “cyberbullies—those that perpetrate such abuse—are around 20 percent more likely to have suicidal thoughts and to attempt suicide than non-perpetrators.”5

It makes sense. Bullies not only are struggling with their own issues but are then plagued with guilt over how they’re treating others.

Some bullies are getting bullied at home. Dad or Mom is laying into Junior. This makes Junior feel powerless, so he turns around and picks on the “easy to pick on” at school, who in turn goes home and kicks the dog. You might have heard the expression, “It rolls downhill” (I paraphrased just a bit).

For those of us who might struggle to empathize with a bully, consider that they might also be “the bullied,” just like you or your child. They’re just paying it forward.

No doubt you’ve heard the saying, “Hurt people hurt people.” Consequently, bullies need our counsel.

The biggest help we can offer bullies is to teach them empathy. If we’ve already shown them empathy, they have an example to follow. But we can also coach them on what it looks like to step into someone else’s shoes and consider others’ needs before our own.

My friend Daniel Huerta, vice president of parenting and youth at Focus on the Family, has a great approach to bullies. Daniel is a licensed clinical social worker and counsels young people in his own practice. Whenever Daniel establishes a relationship with a bully and earns the right to counsel, he always uses “the fart analogy.”

BREAKING WIND

Daniel says he likes to use this approach with kids who are not getting the concept. He simply asks, “How do you think people feel when you enter the room?”

Questions like this gauge how in tune kids are with their own behaviors.

If they don’t seem to see how their own behaviors affect others, he asks, “How do you like it when someone walks into the room you’re in and lets out a big ol’ fart?”

This question usually draws a chuckle and creates some dialogue. No one likes smelling someone else’s bodily functions, so the analogy works.

Daniel continues, “Whenever someone farts, they might feel better, but everyone else has to suffer. The same is true when we insult or belittle others. We might feel better, but they don’t. They all want to leave the room.”

Most bullies aren’t getting the admiration and attention they’re looking for, so they rely on destructive behaviors to gain control, attention, power, or affirmation.

Daniel has had to tell some of his clients, “Whenever you walk into a room, stop letting out farts. It might make you feel better, but no one else likes it. Bring pizza into a room, not your farts.”

Don’t be afraid to use this analogy with a bully you’re counseling. After they exhibit some negative behaviors, you can pull them aside. “You just farted. Maybe you’re feeling better, but we’re not.”

Sometimes bullies don’t even grasp exactly what they have become. A caring adult or friend has to tell them. In their own minds they don’t see themselves as “bullies.” They might recognize that they’re mean, but they justify it as a tactic to gain power or control. Sometimes they don’t realize it because they have a group of followers who laugh, encouraging the behavior; but in reality these friends are afraid of the bully. So the bully continues the hurtful behaviors. They get some of the attention and power they’re seeking but don’t necessarily realize it’s at the expense of the other person.

SOMETIMES BULLIES DON’T EVEN GRASP EXACTLY WHAT THEY HAVE BECOME.

So many factors can create a bully. There are athletic bullies, rebellious bullies, wealthy bullies, low-income bullies, bullies with weak parents, bullies with bully parents…a combination of multiple factors. Bullies are complex. That’s why sometimes bullies will need professional counseling.

When I was researching for this book, I found an article about a young girl named Rebecca who was bullied so severely she had to switch schools. Sadly, thanks to the world of social media, the tormentors followed her.

Rebecca finally committed suicide.

Several bullies were brought into custody, including a fourteen-year-old female who authorities said “lacked remorse.” After Rebecca’s death, the fourteen-year-old bully posted on Facebook: “Yes, I bullied Rebecca and she killed herself, but I don’t give a f***.”6

If you don’t see any change in the bully’s attitudes and behaviors, don’t hesitate to contact a counselor for advice.

START EARLY

I encourage parents to begin having conversations with their kids about how to treat others early in life, like early elementary school. When they are in kindergarten and first grade, ask them about recess, who they played with, who they didn’t play with, and how that made them feel. Don’t turn every one of these conversations into a lecture; instead always lead them to discover their own answers, asking, “How did that make you feel?” and “How do you think they felt?” Help them get used to considering others’ feelings (something we’ll talk about in detail in the next chapter).

And don’t beat yourself up if your kids are already in their teens. It’s not too late to start engaging them in conversations about kindness (we’ll explore what this looks like in the next chapter).

Realize that bullying is very often a learned behavior. One or both of their parents might be struggling with the same issues. Mom or Dad might become bullies at work, at school, or at PTA meetings. All the while, little Christina or little Jake is sitting there taking it all in.

Our actions will speak waaaay louder than our words. The more we model empathy, the more they will see how it looks day to day.

Hopefully our kids aren’t bullies or bullied. But that makes them bystanders—and modeling empathy is just as important with bystanders to prevent them from developing into bullies.

Let’s take a closer look at the bystander.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

1. What was one thing in this chapter that really stood out to you?

2. Bully, bullied, or bystander—which one were you? Which one is your kid?

3. Describe the differences you observe between rudeness, meanness, and bullying.

4. What makes a bully a bully?

5. What signs, subtle or blatant, have you observed in bullies?

6. What signs from Jonathan’s list might you have missed in the past?

7. How can adults do a better job of teaching empathy?

8. What is one way you can model empathy this week?

↑ Back to top

↑