Chapter 3: Digital Hurt The ubiquity of cyberbullying
CHAPTER 3
DIGITAL HURT
The ubiquity of cyberbullying
Haley is a school counselor at a high school in California.
She is just twenty-four years old, and she loves her phone.
I asked Haley how many of her counseling sessions have to do with phones or social media and she laughed. “Seriously?”
When she finally realized I wasn’t kidding, she said, “All of them. If they aren’t the cause of the conflict, then they certainly are an element in it. It’s just the way young people communicate today.”
“How different is it from when you were in high school just a few years ago?” I asked.
“It’s a whole new world,” she said. “A few years ago my friends and I enjoyed our phones—these kids can’t live without them. Some of them can’t sit through five minutes of my sessions without whipping out their phones like I’m not even in the room.”
“How much do devices contribute to bullying?” I asked, cutting to the chase.
“They’ve made it far worse,” Haley said. “It doesn’t stop at school. It blows up overnight, and we have to defuse everything that was said for the sixteen hours they were throwing hate off campus.”
“Give me an example,” I said.
“Last month someone posted a ‘nude’ on the school’s Instagram account—which they still don’t know how that happened, by the way. Anyway, the picture was a selfie from the neck down and the caption said it was a sophomore girl from the school…which it wasn’t. But that didn’t matter because the whole school thought it was. She finally switched schools.”
THE NEW NORMAL
Cyberbullying is a new level of hurt.
CYBERBULLYING IS A NEW LEVEL OF HURT.
Cyberbullying victims are the most likely to commit suicide. Young people who are bullied are twice as likely to contemplate suicide as their peers, but cyberbullying victims are three times as likely.1
What is it about cyberbullying that is pushing so many young people past the tipping point?
Digital communication experts from Common Sense Media define cyberbullying as “the use of digital-communication tools…to make another person feel angry, sad, or scared, usually again and again.”2
The definition makes sense. It’s fairly clear.
Then how come most young people don’t necessarily label this kind of cruel digital communication as “cyberbullying”?
I asked a local psychologist this question, and he answered without a second thought.
“It’s because they don’t know anything different.”
This particular therapist I interviewed works with a wellness program providing “Tier 3” counseling in local schools. That’s when a student’s depression or acting out becomes severe enough that the school feels the student needs to meet with a therapist. This program provides counselors who meet with the student one-on-one on campus for ten sessions, then the family for three sessions. He and his counselors deal with the repercussions of cyberbullying constantly.
“We see this all the time,” he said. “Adults know what it’s like to live life without tech, but students have never experienced a world without it. So the pressure of measuring up and being ‘liked’ is just normal for them. Yes, it’s adding to their stress in unprecedented ways, but they just don’t know any different.”
TWO SEISMIC SHIFTS
It’s easy for us to forget how different our perspective is. Most parents today were lucky to only have to endure this kind of drama or teasing from about 7:30 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. on school days. But now our kids are never free from the constant pressure of garnering “likes,” enduring snarky comments, and navigating mean posts and rants. Bullies now have a platform where they can make lives miserable 24-7.
When did this begin?
Two seismic shifts in this new millennium have opened up the floodgates for bullying 24-7: the rise of social media and smartphone adoption.
THE RISE OF SOCIAL MEDIA
Social media didn’t really gain traction with young people until MySpace exploded in early 2005. MySpace provided something that no other website, chatroom, or online community had perfected yet—an online community where young people could meet others, chat, and be whoever they wanted to be. In hindsight, it’s strange that it took a couple of decades for anyone to figure this out.
Even though home computers began to find their way into American homes in the 1980s, chatting of any kind didn’t really begin until the ‘90s, and even then, it was most often on a large desktop computer plugged into a phone line (some of us might remember the distinctive squawking of our 56K modem as it connected).
I worked with middle school and high school students in the early ‘90s, and I remember a small percentage of kids discovering online chatrooms. Most kids were aware of these online venues, but they had yet to become a huge part of youth culture. Frankly, kids were more excited about what color their new pager was.
Pagers are an interesting sidebar. Even back then young people showed a fascination with being able to “message” each other. Almost every kid I worked with (a few hundred teens a week) had a pager and would constantly get pages from friends with little codes like *411 if their friend just needed information or *911 if it was urgent. The biggest question I got from teens back then was, “Can I use your phone real quick? I got paged.”
Young people loved mobile communication. But online communication and mobile communication had yet to meet.
Back in the online world, the first social media site was Six Degrees, created in 1997.3 This site allowed users to create a profile and make friends. This site was followed by some blogging sites, but social media didn’t get going until MySpace and LinkedIn gained momentum in the early 2000s.
Overnight MySpace became an unmonitored playground where kids flocked to post whatever they wanted to whoever they wanted…and parents didn’t have a clue. The site quickly became a favorite for pedophiles, like the high school teacher accused of making sexual advances to a fourteen-year-old girl on the internet, later arrested on computer pornography charges. The Tampa Bay Times contends that William Warren Greico, forty-two, “first approached the girl after he saw her posting on myspace.com.”4
Sadly, this wasn’t a unique event. Saturday Night Live even aired a sketch mocking this danger, with Andy Samberg teaching a “MySpace and You” night class at a community college where one mom and about a dozen pedophiles attended, all asking questions like, “So no one monitors this website? Excellent!”
I remember giving MySpace seminars to parents at this time, helping them understand the dangers of this new platform where literally anyone could be anyone in this fascinating new cyberworld where people scrolled through pictures looking for someone to chat with.
But still teens couldn’t get enough of this fun new way to “cruise” a strip populated with 99 percent young people.
MySpace drew teens to computers like locusts. I couldn’t even print out my airline’s boarding passes at hotels anymore because unattended teens and tweens would be hovering around the one or two online terminals provided by the hotel for “businesspeople.” Library computers weren’t used for research anymore; they were yet another location where kids could browse MySpace. Anywhere a kid could find a computer with a connection. Social media hadn’t gone mobile yet.
In 2005 MySpace was the seventh most popular English-speaking site on the web, beat out only by Yahoo, Google, Amazon, and a few others.5 But users didn’t notice that #38 on the list of sites was another social media site rapidly gaining popularity. It required a college email address. The site was called Facebook.
Facebook launched on February 4, 2004, but only for select people at Harvard. The online community eventually expanded to other colleges in the greater Boston area, and soon the whole nation wanted in. By 2006 the site was available to everyone age thirteen and older with a valid email address. By 2008 there were 100 million users…and MySpace was abandoned as quickly as it had emerged.6
MySpace who?
Meanwhile, the world was about to experience the second seismic shift that would open the door to 24-7 online access: the rise of the smartphone.
SMARTPHONE ADOPTION
As much as young people craved online communities like MySpace and Facebook, these online venues had yet to go mobile. In 2005 mobile communication and social media were two completely separate entities. Kids were either online on a computer connected to a wall or texting their friends on a phone. Pagers were so yesterday at this point, and texting was everything they could ever want (so they thought).
The biggest conversation among parents at this time was their kids’ obsession with texting. At first mobile providers charged per text, and that caused huge problems with families. Mom would open the AT&T bill and discover over four hundred dollars in texting charges. News outlets featured stories about kids texting three thousand–plus text messages per month. The amount of texts a kid texted almost became bragging rights. Mobile services quickly began offering “free text messaging.”
Meanwhile, technology was gaining speed in every area. New phones with new features were emerging each month. New entertainment devices like iPods and Xbox game systems were on every kid’s Christmas list. By late 2006 young people typically had at least three different gadgets they used frequently: a phone (for texting), a computer (for social media), and an iPod or game system.
It’s almost funny that it took until 2007 for someone to figure out that one device could combine all these platforms…and it was the same person responsible for making home computers so user friendly and commonplace.
In January 2007 a man wearing jeans and white sneakers stood on a stage and introduced a device that literally changed the world. His name was Steve Jobs, and his words proved to be prophetic.7
“Today Apple is going to reinvent the phone,” he said. He described it as a widescreen iPod with touch controls, a revolutionary mobile phone, and a breakthrough internet communications device—all in one.
And America loved it: phone, entertainment, internet, and communications all in one device.
First, Mom and Dad got the iPhone. But once the iPhone 3G came out in 2008, they got the new one and gave their old phone to their kids. Before we knew it, kids began owning iPhones.
Meanwhile, Android released its first smartphone, the G1, with a slide-out keyboard, in 2008. By February 2010 Android released a phone with full touchscreen capability and features that looked just like those of the iPhone…which is why in March 2010 Steve Jobs confronted Google chief executive Eric Schmidt about copying iPhone features in the Android, just the beginning of a lengthy legal battle between Apple and Android.8 But America didn’t care, they just kept gobbling up every new gadget that Apple and Samsung would deliver.
In 2010 kids who didn’t have the iPhone would borrow Mom or Dad’s iPhone to play Angry Birds, dreaming of having their own smartphone someday. Parents kept buying more, and gradually their kids got more. It’s no wonder that by 2012 over half of mobile phones in America were smartphones.
In March 2012 Pew Research reported only 23 percent of twelve-to seventeen-year-olds owned smartphones (a report reflecting 2011 numbers).9 That means at that time the majority of social media was still viewed by teens on a bigger screen plugged into a wall. But that would end soon.
Fast-forward to 2015. Pew Research released a new study revealing that 73 percent of twelve- to seventeen-year-olds had or had access to a smartphone. Their favorite social media platforms were now mobile (Facebook, Instagram, and Snapchat the top three).10
By 2018 the average age a kid got their first smartphone was 10.3 years old,11 and 97% of teens were using social media.12 And what were the first two apps young people wanted? Snapchat and Instagram. (Studies show they also use Facebook, but teenagers see that more as a site Mom and Dad use.)
Social media was now in their pocket.
A running meter of how many friends they had was in their pocket.
Every post drew instant feedback in their pocket.
Am I liked? I’d better check the device in my pocket.
Surprise, surprise, by 2018 almost every study on anxiety, depression, and teen suicide cited the smartphone as a key factor.
Why?
That’s the question everyone is asking.
LIKE ME
Who doesn’t want to be liked?
We now live in a world where the overwhelming majority of young people carry a device in their pockets constantly reminding them exactly where they rank at any moment compared to everybody else.
Think about it. When kids post a picture of their dog, Jake, sleeping upside down on the couch, within minutes they’ll know exactly how many people “like” the picture, a number that can easily be compared not only to other pictures they’ve posted but also to the pictures all their friends have posted. Not to mention, their “friends” or “followers” are also represented by a number—and young people know exactly what that number is, because that number equals value today.
How many “friends” do you have?
How many “likes” do you have?
Our kids live in a world where popularity is represented by a number, and almost every post they create is judged, critiqued, and measured.
I don’t want to go into too much detail, but a growing number of studies have emerged on this subject revealing some eye-opening realities, like kids sitting and watching for “likes” in real time after posting something, or removing posts that don’t garner enough “likes.”
OUR KIDS LIVE IN A WORLD WHERE POPULARITY IS REPRESENTED BY A NUMBER, AND ALMOST EVERY POST THEY CREATE IS JUDGED, CRITIQUED, AND MEASURED.
It’s all about the likes!
We might be bewildered by this new phenomenon…but young people don’t know any different.
One of the wellness counselors I interviewed explained, “To us mean comments on social media might be ‘bullying,’ but to them it’s just a whole different version of being popular. Being liked is a lot of work.”
Young people today are experiencing the life of a ’90s celebrity. Everywhere they went, these celebrities were followed by multiple sets of eyes judging them on their appearance, their day-to-day activities, even their offhand comments. All were subject to criticism.
Now, everyone lives in that world. They’ve opted into that world.
As a result, cyberbullying is becoming a blurry line. Is it really cyberbullying, or was that kid just being a little rude?
“I was just being real!”
“Just saying!”
Our culture celebrates rude.
Consider the concept of “diss tracks” in hip-hop culture, songs written with the intention of “dissing” or disrespecting people. Artists most young people treasure, like Kendrick Lamar, Eminem, Jay-Z, and 2Pac are famous for their diss tracks laying waste to other bigname rappers.13
So why not “lay waste” to other kids at school if we don’t like them?
And what better place to “throw shade” than on social media?
Sadly, cyberbullying is so pervasive, it has become the norm. Whenever someone posts a YouTube video garnering heavy traffic, criticism is unavoidable.
“You sound like a dying whale.”
“I can do better.”
“WTF!”
“I wanna mute this.”
People are mean in the comment section. It’s like they can’t help it. Maybe it’s because they’re hiding behind a screen name and don’t have the guts to say it face to face.
It happens quite often today. It did with Emily, a junior in high school I interviewed who had become the target of a group of “mean girls” at school. They wrote things on her locker and shouted things from across the hallway, never having the guts to confront her face to face. Then Emily would get pinged on social media from anonymous sources saying, “Yeah, that was me today!”
ANONYMITY
Anonymity always breeds lack of accountability.
Anonymous apps are commonly marketed as a place where you can be “honest”—which really translates “aggressively cruel.” These apps allow young people to give anonymous and unmoderated feedback (never a good combination) to other users. Picture a high school locker room where all the bullies wear masks and the coach is nowhere to be found.
Young people are attracted to anonymity in the online world since it allows them to be whoever they want to be. This draws people with low self-esteem because it feels safer than face-to-face communication. They can enter more guarded and present themselves as however they’d like to be seen. Sadly, these anonymous havens are typically rampant with bullies.
Common Sense Media warns parents, “Anonymous apps are notorious hubs for cyberbullying because kids feel emboldened to say things they wouldn’t normally.”14 The Common Sense website offers all kinds of current examples of these apps, so I won’t date this book by including any in print, but you’ll see all kinds of popular platforms claiming they’re a fun place to share honest thoughts, when more often they’re just online hideouts where kids can say mean things that they’re too scared to say to someone’s face.
Parents who engage their kids in conversations about the apps they download can help their kids steer clear of these dangerous playgrounds where mockers and intimidators run free.
SEND NUDES…OR ELSE
As social media grows more prevalent, intimidation is becoming increasingly more common. Like the eighth-grade girl who had two different guys send her pictures of their penises, “which she did not want and had never asked for.”15 They asked her to reciprocate—sending a nude of herself—and she refused.
Unfortunately, the story doesn’t end there. Guys are persistent, and in this situation, she eventually gave in to another boy’s request—a boy she liked. Once she sent it, he threatened to post the picture to social media if she didn’t send more.
This young girl is not alone. In fact, she’s merely feeling the same pressure that countless girls across the world are feeling from guys who are coercing girls to send naked photos, even threatening them if they don’t. Researchers from Northwestern University studied 462 stories posted to an anonymous website by twelve- to eighteen-year-old girls. In most of the stories, girls reported persistent pressure to send nudes, where saying no rarely stopped the requests. Many refusals were met with repeated requests, anger, and even threats. Sadly, most of the girls didn’t know where to turn. As the report details: “Alternative tactics were largely absent from young women’s stories, indicating that young women do not have tools to successfully navigate the challenges they face.”16
The UK is experiencing similar issues, citing Instagram as one of the worst apps for cyberbullying. A survey of over ten thousand young people ages twelve to twenty discovered 42 percent had experienced cyberbullying on Instagram, and 37 percent on Facebook. The survey also discovered a disconnect between real life and online behavior. “Almost half (47 percent) said they don’t discuss bad things in their lives on social media, and instead prefer to present an edited version of themselves.”17
Young people are attracted to the opportunity to customize a “perfected” version of their online selves. If they find real conversation difficult, they can spend as much time as needed refining the perfect response in digital communication or posting the perfect picture. What young people don’t consider is the permanence of what they post. One momentary lapse in judgment, one offhand comment, one weak instance where they post a vulnerable pic, and it’s out there for good.
Experts are becoming more vocal about the role social media is playing in causing teen anxiety. Dr. Logan Levkoff, expert in parent-child communication, believes social media is creating a constant pressure for teens. “The challenge with social media is that it doesn’t give a young person freedom to make mistakes without being defined by them,” Dr. Levkoff explained to ABC News.18 Many kids feel like they are criticized on social media for almost everything they do.
Sometimes this criticism proves to be too much.
Two freshmen girls in Missouri were invited to a house party thrown by a senior. Fourteen-year-old Daisy was given a glass of alcohol…and then another. The next morning Daisy’s mother found her crying alone in freezing temperatures on the front lawn. A doctor discovered vaginal tearing. Daisy’s friend attested that she was forced to have sex despite saying no countless times.19
The town rallied behind the football players and began attacking Daisy on social media. Schoolmates began threatening her, tweeting that she would “get what’s coming.” They called her a liar and a skank.
The charges were mysteriously dropped, despite the evidence, like numerous witnesses who recalled seeing older boys carrying Daisy out of the house crying. The family eventually moved to avoid harassment.
Two years later in her new town, Daisy went to a party with some friends. That night people began attacking her on Facebook, saying she was a hypocrite and fake for going to a party. They began calling her a slut, claiming that she “wanted it.” The onslaughts continued through the weekend.
That Sunday night she attempted to take her own life.20
Cyberbullying’s reach extends further than any other type of cruelty and intimidation. It makes kids feel like no place is safe.
So what is the best defense against this threat?
CYBERBULLYING’S REACH EXTENDS FURTHER THAN ANY OTHER TYPE OF CRUELTY AND INTIMIDATION. IT MAKES KIDS FEEL LIKE NO PLACE IS SAFE.
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
1. What was one thing in this chapter that really stood out to you?
2. Which part of the “history of social media” brought back the most memories for you?
3. Countless experts blame the smartphone as at least a contributor to the rise in teen anxiety, depression, and suicide. Do you agree? Explain.
4. Why do you think kids who are cyberbullied are more likely to attempt suicide?
5. Why are people so blunt and rude on social media, especially on anonymous sites?
6. Why do so many girls give in to guys’ requests to “send nudes”?
7. How can parents create a “safe place” for their kids in a world where bullying’s reach extends further than any other cruelty and intimidation?
