Chapter 11: Meet the Principal / Meet the Parents “Hello, my child is being bullied.”
CHAPTER 11
MEET THE PRINCIPAL / MEET THE PARENTS
“Hello, my child is being bullied.”
If an elephant has its foot on the tail of a mouse,
and you say that you are neutral, the mouse
will not appreciate your neutrality.
–Desmond Tutu
“Hello, I’m the parent of Michael, and he’s being bullied by Brayden!”
Most of the bullying stories in the interviews I conducted included a pinnacle moment where mom and/or dad contacted the teacher, the principal, or the parents of the other kids involved. In the overwhelming majority of the stories, that meeting didn’t go well. In fact, the words I heard most were: “It only made the problem worse.”
Why?
Are principals too busy to deal with kids who don’t play well with others?
Do parents of bullies have their heads buried in the sand?
Or is there a chance that parents of bullying victims are typically irrational at the moment?
Could it also have to do with the mere nature of a bully—bullies are angered and only provoked more when you involve the authorities?
IS THIS JUST AN IMPOSSIBLE SITUATION, OR CAN PARENTS AND SCHOOL ADMINISTRATORS ACTUALLY PARTNER TO MAKE SCHOOL (AND AFTER SCHOOL) A SAFE PLACE FOR EVERYONE?
Is this just an impossible situation, or can parents and school administrators actually partner to make school (and after school) a safe place for everyone?
TWO SIDES
There are two sides to every story.
As I interviewed the parents of children who had been the target of bullying and then the kids themselves, one of the recurrent phrases I heard was, “The school did little to fix the problem.”
Yet in my interviews with principals, teachers, and other school administrators, I kept hearing about parents who were accusative and unreasonable. One vice principal told me, “Often moms are so emotional about what happened, they are completely irrational.” I even had a female school administrator tell me, “I prefer working with dads. They are so much more black and white.” (Her words, not mine.)
It’s intriguing hearing both sides.
Obviously I understand the parents’ perspective. I was bullied mercilessly and felt like teachers did nothing. My own son was targeted by his entire fifth-grade class, and the principal did literally nothing to help the situation. These experiences probably even impede my objectivity in the matter. I would be excused from a jury immediately on any case involving bullying.
But having worked alongside teachers and principals for the last few decades, and having countless friends and family members who are teachers (my mom was a teacher, my sister-in-law is a teacher, my daughter is subbing right now and getting her credentials), I sympathize with their position. It’s not easy being a leader. Caring for young people is no easy task.
So why do these meetings often fall short of expectations on one or both sides?
Let’s look at both perspectives; then I’d like to offer some humble advice to each side.
FROM THE PRINCIPAL’S DESK
Often principals don’t hear from parents unless there’s a problem. They could be doing ninety-eight things right, but as soon as a problem erupts, they’ll have eight angry parents sitting in the waiting room.
This is understandable. Who has time to schedule a meeting with the principal just to tell her, “You’re doing a great job! I love the way you are present on campus and know my kid’s name.”
Principals probably wouldn’t even want hundreds of parents coming in just to say, “Thanks!” (Although they probably wouldn’t mind a nice note telling them exactly that.)
At times the principal and vice principal’s job is kind of like the job of the poor lady at the customer service counter at an airport: all she does is deal with problems. All day long she interacts with angry people who are stressed out of their minds because they just missed their flight to Orlando.
From what I’ve observed, many parents whose kids are experiencing bullying tend to enter the situation in blame mode.
“What are you going to do about this?!”
“How could you let this happen on your watch?”
Every administrator I spoke with discussed the struggle they felt because they legally are not allowed to reveal to parents facts about other kids. This handcuffs them in some ways. They would love to tell you, “I met with the little punk and suspended him for a year!” But they can’t tell you that. It’s a catch-22: while parents want to be able to have a certain level of trust in the administration, they often feel their trust has not been earned.
Parents also tend to enter the situation emotionally. I understand this completely. It’s hard not to be emotional when you see your child suffering. My wife and I were both basket cases.
But sometimes emotional overpowers rational. So now a principal has to deal with someone who honestly isn’t thinking logically. Many parents are blinded by anger as they enter the principal’s office and haven’t even considered anyone else’s perspective—or the chance that they might be getting only part of the story from their own kid.
I know, I know. For parents of a kid who is being targeted, this possibility might be difficult to consider. Remember, I know your perspective well. But looking back, I’ve come to realize there were things I didn’t know and some assumptions I made that kept me from dealing with certain situations fairly.
Please consider the following ideas when approaching that principal, vice principal, or teacher:
SIX TIPS FOR PARENTS PREPARING TO MEET WITH THE PRINCIPAL OR TEACHER
1. PAUSE.
No meeting is so urgent that it requires you to walk in out of control.
Go on a run, a walk, a bike ride…whatever it takes to clear your head. Pray. Call up a friend and rant. Find a corner booth at your favorite Mexican restaurant and eat three bowls of chips (okay, I think I just confessed what I do). Just do something to get your senses about you so you don’t go into an important meeting like this emotionally wrecked.
I recently finished studying the book of Esther. This little book of the Bible offers a fascinating perspective on “pause.” The king pronounced an edict “to destroy, kill and annihilate all the Jews—young and old, women and children—on a single day” (Esther 3:13). The king’s wife, Esther, a Jew, was “in great distress” (Esther 4:4).
So what did she do?
She paused for three days. In fact, she encouraged everyone to do the same:
“Go, gather together all the Jews who are in Susa, and fast for me. Do not eat or drink for three days, night or day. I and my attendants will fast as you do. When this is done, I will go to the king, even though it is against the law. And if I perish, I perish.” (Esther 4:16)
If you read the rest of the story, you’ll be amazed what God does. After those three days, God orchestrated a series of events that changed the whole course of the book…all because Esther paused.
It’s never good to walk into an already volatile situation with only half your wits.
My friend Kim is a dean at a private school. She told me of times when parents came in so flustered that she needed to ask them to go home and calm down so they could simply talk.
“Try to be non-emotional,” Kim advised. “Use non-feeling words. Share the facts.”
Which brings me to my next tip for parents…
2. RECOGNIZE PERCEIVED VERSUS ACTUAL.
Sometimes when parents are emotional, they tend to generalize or even exaggerate.
“My daughter is being targeted by the entire school!”
Really? The entire school?
I remember when my son, Alec, was being targeted by a large group of bullies in his class. To him it felt like literally everyone.
Alec would walk around by himself during recess wishing someone would play with him. Even his one friend, Aidan, abandoned Alec once he realized a friendship with Alec would probably mean he’d be bullied too.
For us, it felt like “everyone” was against him. In hindsight, there were a few bullies and an excess of spineless bystanders.
If your kid is in this situation, describe the actual situation:
A group of about seven or eight girls are making fun of my daughter Addison at school and on social media. Here’s a printout of some of the posts. Even though it’s only about seven or eight of them who are aggressively and repetitively mocking her, many of her classmates are laughing and joining in. For example, earlier this week when Chloe posted this picture of Addison’s face on a gorilla’s body during fifth-period algebra, in addition to the seven or eight of those girls in her class, many of the other students in the class began making sounds like a monkey—Abigail and Emily, who have never said anything mean in the past, actually offered her a banana.
This kind of description is far more convincing than “Everyone hates my daughter!”
Collecting actual facts can be difficult for parents because sometimes we are hearing the stories secondhand, and at times our kids describe what they “perceive” more than what is “actually” happening.
That’s why it’s important not to rush this process. Part of empathetic listening is asking our kids how they feel. After we’ve done what we’ve talked about so much already in this book, making our kids feel noticed and heard, and resisting the urge to fix the situation right away, we eventually need to draw out some facts, maybe even in a separate conversation in which we ask, “Give me some specific examples of what you’re experiencing so I can better understand.”
Document. If there is proof, like texts or screenshots, collect those. Slowly collect the facts you need to rationally present actual events that occurred. If all you have is firsthand testimony, then that’s what you’ll need to present:
Sean told me that this week in the cafeteria Gavin and Dylan knocked his lunch tray out of his hands. As a result, Sean didn’t eat that day, but he seemed more shook up about the fact that so many of his classmates were laughing when it happened. This is the third time this has happened this month. His friends Seth and Jackson were there all three times.
Share the facts. Principals and teachers will appreciate having actual facts to work with. Feelings don’t always help the situation.
3. BE OPEN TO THE POSSIBILITY THAT YOUR KID MIGHT NOT BE INNOCENT.
I’m not suggesting you victimize your kid, considering her guilty until proven innocent. I’m just recommending you keep an open mind as you’re gathering information. Sometimes things aren’t what they seem.
My friends who are teachers and administrators joke that the most common response from parents is, “Not my kid.” You might know that well, because if you’ve ever confronted another parent about their child bullying your child, they probably responded, “What? My little Britney?”
Sorry, Mom, haven’t you heard? Britney’s not that innocent.
My friend Michelle, who works at a school, recounted a time when another parent called her up and accused Michelle’s son of stealing her son’s history book, crossing out his name, and putting his own name in its place. Michelle felt the words “Not my kid” almost leave her lips, but she had heard those words from parents far too many times. So she talked with her son later that night.
“I got a call from Andrew’s mom today about his history book. Is there anything I should know?”
That was all that needed to be said. He confessed to everything, and it was exactly as Andrew’s mom described.
I’ve witnessed stories of kids who claimed, “I was bullied,” when in fact that was the furthest thing from the truth. One girl who had a hard time making friends decided to bang her head against the bathroom wall until she passed out. She claimed “bully” and had a lengthy story ready. The truth eventually came out.
That’s why these situations take time and patience. When our kids cry “bully,” we need to listen first and resist the urge to victimize or blame. But this doesn’t mean wearing a blindfold. We still need to seek the truth. Sometimes the truth isn’t exactly what our kids—even our bullied kids—present.
Humility is always a good approach when you meet with the principal or teacher.
4. KNOW WHAT YOU WANT.
Know what your goal is for the meeting. Don’t just present a bunch of facts and hope that the principal or teacher knows exactly what to do. Make a specific request.
Here are some reasonable requests and questions from parents:
• Can I have these parents’ phone numbers so I can contact them and talk this situation through with them?
• What is your bullying protocol?
• What is a fair expectation for how this situation will be handled?
• Can you please not talk with the other kids yet, but simply observe the situation and see what you notice?
That last example is so important I want to highlight it as a separate tip.
5. ASK FOR OBSERVATION INSTEAD OF CONFRONTATION.
One of the biggest complaints I heard from both kids and parents was when the school administration called the bullies and the bullied together in one room to try to work it out. So be clear if that is not what you want.
Instead, ask the principal or teacher to just watch and see what they observe.
How many times have you heard me tell a story in this book about a lack of adult presence in the locker room, hallway, or cafeteria? Maybe the school administration could use a humble nudge to “watch” what goes on in the cafeteria and on the playground.
If our kids are telling us the truth, observation will be all the revelation you need.
Sure, some adults aren’t very sly about watching sensitive situations like this. But usually if a teacher or principal is made aware of potential bullying, the increased adult presence and watchful eyes can decrease the frequency of the bullying. If the bullying continues when adults are not watching, you obviously can schedule another meeting where you bring in new information about where and when so they can be proactive about looking for it.
If the bullying is happening on social media during the night, then a printout of the mean posts is all you need. And honestly, the principal isn’t necessarily the one who needs to solve that. You might need to…
6. MEET THE PARENTS.
One of my friends who is a school administrator told me, “The biggest problem of bullying we have on campus doesn’t even occur on campus! It occurs on social media the night before! But parents think it’s our job to solve it.”
If your daughter’s soccer teammates post mean stuff about her, it’s a good idea to go directly to their parents. Don’t do this unless you’ve already listened to your daughter and made her feel noticed and heard, and she asked for your help. I heard numerous testimonies from kids who said their parents intervened and made the situation worse.
“Do you think your mommy can save you?”
Conversely, I heard just as many share how they wish their mom and dad would have done something, but they didn’t. The only way to discover how your kid would like you to help is by being there for them.
What if your kid needs your help but doesn’t want it?
Do your best to equip your child with the tools they need to solve the situation by themselves. But if the situation doesn’t get any better, then it’s your job as a parent to step in.
Don’t expect an eight-, ten-, or twelve-year-old to know what’s best. Sometimes you need to step in and meet the parents of the other kids involved.
If you don’t know their parents, ask the school for their contact information.
When meeting with parents, remember some of these same tips:
• Pause. Don’t go knocking on some other mom’s door ready to start a fight. Take some time not only to calm down but also to think through the best way to confront the issue.
• Recognize perceived versus actual. Don’t go making generalizations or wild accusations. You’re addressing Mama Bear about her cubs. Chances are if you show her a printout of her daughter’s social media feed mocking your daughter, she still might defend her. So be prepared to calmly and rationally present facts that she can ponder.
• Ask questions and let them draw the conclusions. Instead of saying, “Your evil little daughter posted this,” try asking, “I didn’t really know how to react to this. Is this Instagram post from your daughter?”
• Give them time to think. Don’t expect them to have the perfect response. Give them the facts to chew on and the time to digest.
• End with a request to reconvene. Humbly ask them if they’d like to talk with their kid, hear their side of the story, and then meet together again to come up with a way to resolve the situation.
Hopefully parents will receive this gentle confrontation with an open mind, as opposed to “Not my kid!” Many times their reaction will depend on how the accusation is presented.
But parents aren’t the only ones with a stake in these situations. Teachers and principals also have a responsibility to address issues of bullying.
TIPS FOR PRINCIPALS AND TEACHERS
The last chapter of this book is devoted to what schools can do to break through the problem of bullying, so I don’t want to jump the gun, but here are a handful of quick tips that principals and teachers can consider specifically when parents or kids meet with you about bullying.
1. EMPATHIZE.
It’s difficult to stop and be a counselor for one kid when you’re responsible for countless others. But the best way to help not only the student but also the parents feel noticed and heard is to empathize.
Ask them what they’ve experienced. Maybe even offer a compassionate response like, “I’m sorry that happened.”
Parents will appreciate this.
Bullied kids need this.
You won’t lose your position of disciplinarian if you later find out their story was all a lie.
What is the downside of offering all kids—even the bullies—the presumption of innocence?
Which leads me to my second tip…
2. DON’T VICTIMIZE EVERYONE.
Sure, you don’t know everyone’s side of the story yet. But what if the kid sitting in front of you is truly an innocent victim of bullying? Have you already treated them like a criminal?
When you called them in to meet with you, did they have to sit in a waiting room where other students could see them? You know what kids do when they see a kid waiting for the principal.
“Oooh, busted!”
If you brought all the parties involved into the room, did you treat them all like they were guilty until proven innocent? I didn’t type that wrong. If a kid is bullied at your school, do they have to go through a trial to prove they’re not just some kid in a random fight?
Sorting out the facts might take time. That’s why you’ll need to…
3. BE OPEN TO IT TAKING MORE THAN ONE MEETING.
In my research, the typical response from schools was to call all the kids into the same room, ask for everyone’s side of the story, then make everyone shake hands and promise to play nice.
Bada boom, bada bing!
Is there a chance it’s not that simple?
I know you’re busy and you’d like to get this situation checked off your list, but consider what the families are going through.
Often it’s difficult to discern the truth in one meeting if you have no context or history observing the situation. It’s completely reasonable to listen and collect information during the first meeting, assure them you will personally observe the situation, and then set the next meeting on all of your calendars right then.
Eliminate the possibility of parents saying, “I never heard from her again!”
The second meeting also places a little pressure on you to actually do what you said: observe the situation.
4. TAKE TIME TO OBSERVE.
Watch the situation for a while. Talk with teachers or yard duty volunteers and ask them to keep a sly eye on the kids involved. Do some recon to find the truth of the matter.
Remember that bullies are often smooth socially and get along with adults well, whereas the bullied are often awkward and withdrawn. So be careful judging what you see sitting in the chairs in front of you at face value. The smooth-talking, rational kid might be the guilty one, and the frustrating kid making unreasonable outbursts just might be the one who is being targeted by Eddie Haskell sitting next to him.
Watch the smooth kid when he doesn’t know he’s being watched. Watch how he treats the awkward kid when he’s not in your office.
5. HELP THE PARENTS WITH CLOSURE.
Sure, there are facts you cannot disclose. But you can at least call up the parents and say, “I met with the parties involved, we found validity to many of your child’s claims, and several of the students involved were punished. Furthermore, we are going to continue watching the situation carefully.”
Maybe parents do want to know more. Maybe they want to hear that you hung up the bullies by their toes. But any reasonable parent would be happy just hearing that you actually followed through. That would have made me happy.
Parents, teachers, and principals typically all want the same thing in these situations: the truth. The key is partnering together to discover it. Hopefully these tips help in that process.
Be prepared: Some people are just difficult. At times you will do everything right and still receive a bad response.
Sadly, many of the stories I heard ended with the statement, “So we finally switched schools and that solved the problem.” Sometimes that’s what it takes, though hopefully it doesn’t come to that.
PARENTS, TEACHERS, AND PRINCIPALS TYPICALLY ALL WANT THE SAME THING IN THESE SITUATIONS: THE TRUTH.
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
1. What was one thing in this chapter that really stood out to you?
2. Why do you think so many of the parents Jonathan interviewed didn’t have positive experiences with their kid’s school?
3. Why do you think so many of the principals, teachers, and administrators Jonathan interviewed didn’t have positive experiences with parents?
4. Which to you is the most helpful of Jonathan’s six tips for parents preparing to meet with a principal?
5. Which tip for meeting the parents of a bully do you think is most helpful?
6. Which tip for principals and teachers do you think they need to hear the most?
7. If you are a principal or teacher, which tip do you think you need to hear the most?
8. What is one thing you can do this week to partner together as parents and administration to make school a safe place for our kids?
