Chapter 15 of 19

Chapter 12: School Shootings Pushed beyond the tipping point

Chapter 12: School Shootings Pushed beyond the tipping point

CHAPTER 12

SCHOOL SHOOTINGS

Pushed beyond the tipping point

My pain may be the reason for somebody’s laugh.

But my laugh must never be the reason for somebody’s pain.

–Charlie Chaplin

Do you remember where you were April 20, 1999?

Each generation has a date like this they recollect. For my parents it was the day John F. Kennedy was shot. For my grandparents it was Pearl Harbor. For my kids it was 9/11.

For me it was Columbine.

April 20, 1999, was a Tuesday, and I was with my five-year-old at his swim practice. I was twenty-nine years old and had been in youth ministry for almost a decade. My coworker Don called me on my cell phone.

“Are you near a TV?” he asked, obviously shaken up.

“No,” I said. “Why?”

He began detailing the events he was watching on the news, kids soaked in blood being lowered out of windows, SWAT team members escorting lines of frightened teenagers to safety, interviews with panic-stricken parents.

Time revealed that two students brought guns and bombs to school that day to act out some sort of revenge. Thirteen were killed, many more injured. And then we began to hear the word:

Bullied.

Bullying has become a significant contributing factor to countless acts of revenge on campus. Like the story of Alicia Graham.

Sound familiar?

Of course not.

Even if you studied school shootings, you wouldn’t recognize this name…by a few degrees of separation anyway.

Alicia Graham was targeted by a group of bullies at her high school, Franklin Regional High School in Murrysville, Pennsylvania, who taunted her frequently on social media.

“That’s how it is at Franklin,” Alicia said. “Everybody bullies everybody.”

Alicia’s dad printed out a list of the texts and cruel posts and brought them to the school, including a list of her tormentors.

“I felt like they kind of waved a gold wand over it,” he said, explaining that it was an affluent community. (Sadly, I keep hearing this again and again from parents whose kids were bullied.)

The problem didn’t go away. Alicia was still tormented by her aggressors. In fact, a few months later Alicia was attacked by a girl in the school cafeteria who hit her with a lunch tray and beat her until a teacher pulled the girl off of her. Alicia suffered a concussion and missed three days of school.

As for the list of tormentors?

It didn’t stop them.

Several months later, one of Alicia’s same tormentors posted something cruel on social media about another kid at the school, a quiet, shy kid named Alex Hribal.

Does that name sound familiar?

The next day, Alex took two knives to school, slashing the arms and faces of fellow students and stabbing people in the torso, leaving a total of twenty-one victims at Franklin Regional High.1

Am I implying that this one cruel social media post was the cause of the Franklin High School stabbing?

No. In fact, a lengthy manifesto was found in Hribal’s locker blaming other students for being cruel to him and actually praising Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold for their actions at Columbine back in 1999.2

Hribal was obviously a very disturbed young man whose actions are horrifying and unconscionable. Klebold, Harris…the whole list…reprehensible. Their actions inexcusable.

But what of the students who ridiculed these kids?3

And what about the administrators who let these kinds of activities continue under their watch?

THE BOY WHO CRIED, “BULLY.”

Bully has become almost a buzzword. Whenever a school shooting happens, you’re almost waiting for it.

The media sticks a microphone in a random kid’s face. “Was this kid bullied?”

“I’m not sure. I think so!”

Good enough. “He was bullied!”

The shooter’s defense attorney immediately begins laying the groundwork for his case. “It was bullying that drove him to act out.”

Bullying has become a go-to excuse for acts of violence like these.

Is there any truth to these claims?

Are many of the school shootings we keep seeing on the news a result of bullying?

It’s difficult to blame one cause for every senseless act of violence on campus. In many cases the shooters are killed and no one really knows why they did what they did. Some skeptics think bullying isn’t the problem.

“It’s mental illness that needs to be addressed.”

“Gun legislation is the problem!”

Even when students claim bullying, people aren’t always convinced. When Caleb Sharpe gunned down a classmate and wounded others at a Washington state high school, he actually told police he wanted to “teach everyone a lesson about what happens when you bully others.”4

Some claimed Sharpe’s answer was too simplistic. One of his classmates described him as “pretty mentally unstable” and “pretty interested in violence.” A “school shooting expert” said, “Instead of asking if someone was bullied, it’s important to take a broader view. The shooter’s mental health, home life, and school life all need to be considered.”5

This same expert claims he has studied dozens of school shootings and that they are rarely precipitated by bullying. He tried to support his statement by showing that only four of eighty-three intended victims of school shooters he studied were actually bullies.

I’m sorry, but I’m going on the record to say that I completely disagree with this “expert’s” claim that school shootings are rarely precipitated by bullying. What about the bystanders who laughed every time these kids were teased? In the eyes of the bullied, they are guilty by association.

I might mention as an aside that I’ve done over one hundred hours of research into school shootings, written a novel about one, and personally interviewed Columbine victims…and I don’t call myself an expert.

Let me just say this. Yes, mental illness and home life are huge factors. I’d call “home life” monumental, actually.

But I had an amazing home life. And I can tell you, if I had access to a gun in junior high, I would have considered blowing away not only the entire “Kill Jon Club” but every one of the smug bystanders who laughed at their jokes and T-shirts! (Wow, did I just put that in print?) By God’s grace, I never did. But take it from me: public ridicule does something to you mentally. It festers and boils, becoming something poisonous.

Maybe what I’m actually corroborating is his statement, “The shooter’s mental health, home life, and school life all need to be considered.” Because even if your mental health and your home life are good, if you are being targeted by your peers every day, it does something to you. It doesn’t have to be a mix of all these factors. That one factor alone just might be enough—your school life. It absolutely can change your mental health quickly.

I’ve got two words of proof for you: Dylan Klebold.

PUSHED TOO FAR

I’ve read every police report and watched almost every video on record of Columbine’s Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold. In my opinion, Harris might have had some serious mental issues. But not many had anything bad to say about his home life, even Eric himself. In fact, one day Eric was doodling in his school planner. He wrote a quotation from The Tempest: “Good wombs have borne bad sons.” Eric wrote this on the day marked “Mother’s Day.”

So if we were to create some checkboxes for Eric Harris, they might look like this:

Poor mental health

Bad home life

Rough school life

But what about Dylan Klebold?

Dylan showed no signs of mental illness, and every source shows he was from a very loving home.

So what pushed him over the edge?

Dylan wasn’t prom king. He wasn’t a jock. He was nerdy and loved video games. And he was a follower. Sadly, he started following a very bitter, sick young man named Eric.

What linked him with Eric?

They both were bullied by the same group at school.

Poor mental health

Bad home life

Rough school life

Bullying was a huge problem at Columbine. Even our school shooting expert couldn’t deny that.

I’m not going to start naming names, but a quick Google search will reveal countless articles about some of the “white-hatted” bullies at Columbine, a tough group of jocks who used to mock and intimidate anyone who didn’t measure up to their pathetic criteria.

A young man named Jonathan Greene experienced extreme bullying from a couple of “white hats” on the wrestling team. They used to actually pin him on the ground and give him “body twisters.” “He got bruises all over his body,” his dad recalled.6

Jonathan was Jewish. In gym class they hurled racial slurs about him, literally singing songs about Hitler and yelling out, “Another Jew in the oven.” The gym teacher, who was also the school’s wrestling coach, did nothing.

When Greene’s dad went to the wrestling coach and the guidance counselor, they told him, “This stuff can happen.”

Greene’s dad wasn’t having it. So he called the school board, which notified the police. The two athletes were charged and sentenced to probation. But both were allowed to continue football and wrestling.

Another one of the “white hats” began teasing a classmate about her breasts. When she went to her teacher, who was also a football and wrestling coach, he suggested she move to another seat.

Did you ever wonder why when Harris and Klebold started shooting they yelled, “All the jocks stand up. Anybody with a white hat or a shirt with a sports emblem on it is dead.”

Perhaps bullying had a bigger effect on these two than many of the “experts” realized.

On YouTube if you search for “Columbine basement tapes,” you’ll find a series of videos the two boys made just months before the massacre. Most of these videos have a common theme: revenge against bullies.

In these little video skits, a friend would say, “People are always making fun of me. I don’t like it. I need some help!” Then two boys dressed in trench coats would arrive on the scene to offer protection. You can watch take after take of Dylan yelling rants like, “Do not mess with that friggin’ kid. If you do, I’ll rip off your G*dd**n head and…”; then he would laugh between takes.

Dylan didn’t have a history of bitterness or hate…until he began experiencing bullying…and until he found camaraderie with Harris.

Harris had all kinds of bottled-up aggression. Police had even been tipped off to his website, which read: “I will rig up explosives all over a town and detonate each one of them at will after I mow down a whole area of you snotty rich [expletives]…. All I want to do is kill and injure as many of you as I can.”7

So are school shooters like Harris and Klebold unique? What about Sharpe? Hribal? Or Florida Parkland shooter Nikolas Cruz, whom classmates identified as being bullied every day? Are we seeing a pattern? Does bullying increase the chances of a kid using weapons and violence to solve their problems?

What influences a kid to bring a weapon to school?

The journal Pediatrics recently conducted a fascinating study in which they observed the likelihood of a student bringing a weapon to school. In their survey of American high school students, they found over 20 percent reported being a victim of bullying in the last year, and over 4 percent reported carrying a weapon to school.8

But the study really gets intriguing when additional risk factors are thrown into the mix. For example, when victims of bullying experienced three additional risk factors, like fighting at school, being threatened or injured at school, and/or skipping school out of fear for their safety, they were far more likely to bring a weapon to school. In fact, the subset of victims of bullying who had these three additional adverse experiences had a 46.4 percent likelihood of carrying weapons to school compared with just 2.5 percent for nonvictims.

Look at those numbers again and let that sink in for a moment.

Perhaps schools might want to develop some simple checkboxes for these risk factors?

I’m not here to cast stones or point fingers. Like you, I want solutions. And schools would be foolish to ignore studies like this revealing the “perfect storm” effect these multiple factors have on a kid’s mental health.

Schools, do you keep records of fights, threats, and skipping school? What if we put these factors into a database that trips an alarm as soon as two or more happen?

BULLYING DOESN’T TYPICALLY RESOLVE ITSELF. IT CAN’T BE IGNORED.

Bullying doesn’t typically resolve itself.

It can’t be ignored.

Sadly, when it is, some kids are pushed beyond the tipping point.

The last words of Sam Strahan before fifteen-year-old Caleb Sharpe shot him were, “I always knew you were going to shoot up the school.”9

So why didn’t he say something?

Maybe no one was listening.

How can schools listen and respond? Let’s take a look in the next chapter.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

1. What was one thing in this chapter that really stood out to you?

2. What were you doing when Columbine happened?

3. Do you think Columbine would have happened if there were no bullies at the school?

4. Why do you think Columbine teachers and coaches seemed so quick to look the other way?

5. How can schools do a better job of noticing incidents of bullying?

6. How can we all do a better job of noticing when a kid is being pushed toward the tipping point?

7. What is one thing you can do this week to proactively seek out isolated and ostracized kids?

↑ Back to top

↑