Chapter 11 of 19

Chapter 8: The Bystander The chapter you might want to read with your kids

Chapter 8: The Bystander The chapter you might want to read with your kids

CHAPTER 8

THE BYSTANDER

The chapter you might want to read with your kids

We will have to repent in this generation not merely

for the hateful words and actions of the bad people

but for the appalling silence of the good people.

–Martin Luther King Jr.

“I feel guilty about it every day,” he told the crowd, a little choked by his own words.

The church youth group was captivated by Blake’s vulnerability.

Blake seemed like a normal high school kid: decent grades, a soccer player, and from a good home. But this particular young man was obviously plagued with guilt.

“I saw him being made fun of every day,” he said, “and I did nothing to stop it.”

Blake went on to share about how the two of them used to be really good friends. They went to the same school, hung out at recess, and went to each other’s birthday parties.

But then came middle school. In middle school you’re judged by who you hang out with, and Blake’s friend was definitely on the nerdy side. Blake’s new soccer friends noticed this and began making fun of him.

“Is he your friend?”

“Why are you hanging out with him?”

So Blake cut off his relationship with his friend.

The situation took a turn for the worse. By high school Blake’s athletic friends began regularly hurling insults at his old friend during lunch or in gym class. Blake never chimed in. He just watched in silence.

Blake confessed that he could still picture the look on his friend’s face. He was haunted by the image.

As I heard Blake’s story I winced, because I knew the story well.

Blake’s old friend was my son.

Blake was never a bully. He was the dictionary definition of a bystander, someone who watches and does nothing. Most kids on today’s campuses probably fall into this category.

But bystanders hurt others just the same. It’s a sin of omission. They know they should probably do something, but they don’t.

I don’t mean to imply Blake was a monster. Sadly, Blake’s story isn’t unique. Every campus I’ve visited is full of bystanders. The world is full of people who “don’t want to get involved.” And to Blake’s credit, he recognized it…although a little too late.

Every interview I conducted revolved around stories involving three groups of people: a bully, the bullied, and entire classrooms or hallways or playgrounds full of people who watched and did nothing to interfere.

Bystanders are commonplace.

Why are bystanders so hesitant to get involved?

THE STRUGGLE IS REAL

Bystanders have their own sets of issues. If they’re like today’s typical teenager, they probably spend too much time staring at screens; struggle with feelings of insecurity; feel overwhelmed by school and the pressure to succeed; and look to social media, music, and entertainment media for fulfillment. And what is it they’re hearing from every entertainment media source?

Do what’s right for you.

Embrace yourself and just be you.

Some of these messages are literally pounding them daily. Nielsen revealed that Americans listened to an average of 32.1 hours of music per week in 2017.1 That’s 4.59 hours of music per day, saturating our kids with messages of “let go,” “lose control,” and “I can’t stop.” And that’s just music; that doesn’t include Netflix, YouTube, social media, and other screen time.

What does all this add up to?

We’re raising a generation of young people with low self-esteem who are being conditioned to selfishly live for the moment.

Drop them into a social situation where someone else is being mocked or targeted. Typical responses from bystanders include:

• “Whew! At least it’s not me!”

• “That person being teased is actually pretty awkward.”

• “I don’t want to interfere because then I might be targeted as well.”

• “The jokes being made are pretty funny.”

Even if bystanders feel the conviction to say something or step in and defend the victim, those feelings are usually squashed because they require great risk.

How much risk?

Consider the fear of public speaking; now multiply it by ten. Not only does speaking up take guts, it risks long-term social consequences. The key phrase there is “long-term.” Sticking up for a bullying victim isn’t a one-shot deal.

Kids think about this—if you invite a kid to lunch “once,” what happens if they want to eat with you again the next day? Are you committing to eat with that person for the rest of the year? What would that do to your own social standing? Would your friends even want to eat with you anymore?

They also wonder—if you defend a kid who is being teased for wearing Shaqs, the affordable shoes at Walmart, and you wear LeBrons, which are well into the three-digit cost, are you being a hypocrite? Are you going to start wearing Shaqs to be more authentic? Are you supposed to change your entire wardrobe? There’s nothing wrong with nice shoes…right?

I talked with a cheerleader about this issue, a kind, thoughtful girl who had a history of caring for people in need. I asked her if she ever felt torn if her popular crowd began teasing someone else. Her answer was intriguing.

“To be honest,” she said, “it’s not like I’m ever wanting to side with a bully; it’s more that I don’t necessarily want to start hanging out with someone who might be awkward and honestly difficult to get along with.”

Some might gasp at her frank response, but she verbalized what many realistically think. Sometimes bullied kids are bullied because they are socially awkward or different. This social awkwardness is only perpetuated by isolation. In other words, after time, awkward kids become even more antisocial and engage in repellent behaviors.

“TO BE HONEST,” SHE SAID, “IT’S NOT LIKE I’M EVER WANTING TO SIDE WITH A BULLY; IT’S MORE THAT I DON’T NECESSARILY WANT TO START HANGING OUT WITH SOMEONE WHO MIGHT BE AWKWARD AND HONESTLY DIFFICULT TO GET ALONG WITH.”

So what happens?

When a bystander decides to cross the invisible lines in the cafeteria and sit next to someone alone and isolated, the conversation isn’t always easy. It takes work. It’s…awkward. It doesn’t happen like in a Christian movie; it feels more like a Seinfeld episode.

What is the result?

Most likely the bystander checks that single good deed off their list, quietly thinking, I’ll never do that again, and returning to their normal group for the next lunch.

SELF-ABSORBED

Bystanders are far from perfect. Sure, they might not necessarily “bully,” but they dabble in social power plays. They throw a quick insult, then attempt to “cancel it out” with the phrase that erases all wrongs: “Just kidding.”

“Nice shirt. Did you get it from the Goodwill clearance rack?…Just kidding.”

This kind of trash-talking isn’t anything new. The book of Proverbs even chimes in about it: “Like a maniac shooting flaming arrows of death is the one who deceives their neighbor and says, ‘I was only joking’” (Proverbs 26:18–19).

In sports it’s almost part of the game. You mess with the other team. It’s a natural part of baseball, for sure.

But is this what we should expect with third graders on the kickball field?

How about sixth graders on the softball field?

Is it okay to “school someone”? In my research, many of the parents of younger boys shared that it was common for their kids’ friends to insult each other, followed by, “You got burned!”

Harmless?

What about subtle gossip? “Is it just me, or do you think Shalyn has gained a lot of weight?”

Is it bullying…or just gossip?

“OMG…why is she wearing that?”

“Where did she get those shoes?”

“Mean” may be inherent, because kids begin these social power plays at an early age. I remember in first grade being assigned to bring an apple to class for a project. I don’t remember the assignment, but I’ll never forget the comparison games I experienced that day.

I brought in a green apple, because that’s what my parents had in our fruit bowl on the kitchen counter. For some reason I had the only green apple in my class that day. I’m not sure why kids living in Denver, Colorado, in 1976 all favored red apples, but I do know that I was an outcast standing alone with a green apple.

In hindsight the way I was treated is actually hilarious. I can still remember the sarcastic comments my friends made.

“Why do you have a green apple?”

“I have a red apple. Red is much better than green.”

“Green apples aren’t even good.”

These idiots had obviously never made an apple pie. Red Delicious are the worst! But it didn’t matter. I was a lonely green living in a world of red, and I was immediately an outcast.

Was this bullying?

No, this was just normal self-absorbed behavior from a bunch of bratty little pie-hating first graders.

By fourth grade the meanness had graduated to shoes. My parents shopped at Kmart, and most of my friends’ parents didn’t.

Funny, we weren’t necessarily poor, but my mom definitely was a bargain hunter. And up to this point Kmart shoes hadn’t been a big deal…until a kid wearing Nikes noticed I was wearing Traxx.

Are you old enough to remember Traxx?

Traxx were the “Shaqs” of yesteryear. I wore Traxx most of my childhood. But once the Nike kids noticed my Traxx, the social lines were drawn in the sand. Within days I was literally being shunned because I wore Traxx.

I now realize this was borderline bullying. Certain kids repeatedly and aggressively teased me about wearing Traxx. I didn’t like it, and they didn’t care. They were just glad to be wearing Nikes.

I went home and told my mom, “I need some new shoes.”

My mom looked at my shoes, confused, and asked, “What’s wrong with your shoes? They look fine to me.”

Luckily, my mom listened to her fourth-grade son share how the other kids were making fun of him for his shoes. I say “luckily,” because from my fourth-grade perspective I felt “noticed and heard” by her. I don’t know precisely why, but she decided to buy me some Nikes. They were royal blue with a yellow swoosh.

Was this the best move for a mom? Some might be hesitant to give in to this pressure to “fit in.” What are we teaching our kids?

I honestly don’t know if there is one right answer in these situations, but I’ll tell you this: it’s vital that parents make their kids feel noticed and heard. My mom did that for me back in 1980…and I can still remember the color of the Nikes. I think my mom gets a badge of excellence for that one.

A young girl named Rebecca told me about a similar incident when she was in fourth grade lining up outside of class after recess. One of the popular girls, whose name Rebecca will never forget, would always begin pointing at Rebecca’s shoes and whispering to her group of friends. Within minutes Rebecca would feel like the whole class was laughing and pointing.

“My mom was a single mom at that time,” Rebecca recalled, “and could barely scrape two pennies together, so we shopped at Kmart. While my shoes were the same style as their shoes, they did not have the tiny little name-brand blue rectangle on the back of them like these girls’.”

One ringleader.

A handful of followers.

A classroom of snickering bystanders.

The dilemma surrounding so many of today’s issues is that it isn’t just one bully making fun of one kid. Sometimes bullying occurs by a whole crowd of jesters who join in to fit in. Sometimes bystanders inadvertently evolve into bullies. In fact, sometimes even teachers join in.

My youth worker friend Wayne has seen quite a bit of bullying throughout his years of ministry. Wayne was bullied a lot as a kid, and he knows what it looks like. He also recognizes that parents and teachers can make a huge impact either way.

When Wayne was in high school, he had a particular math teacher who made the situation far worse. She was overly tolerant of banter in the classroom. When kids made fun of him, she didn’t intervene. So kids became bolder and hurled cruel insults at him for everyone to hear. Sometimes the teacher even laughed at the jokes.

Wayne felt betrayed and alone.

Some teachers might think, This is all in good fun.

Is it? Are you sure?

When does teasing cross the line?

Go back to the characteristics of bullying:

Aggressive behavior

Power play

Repeated

Take notice. Is the teasing harmless jests from friends? Do you ever see these kids hanging out together and having fun? Don’t be confused if you see the victim laughing. He or she might just be trying to save face. If one kid is being insulted repeatedly, it might not be in good fun. Don’t allow those doors to even open.

Bottom line: Restrict repetitive teasing. One wisecrack doesn’t make someone a bully. But if you see repetitive teasing, you need to intervene.

Yet adult intervention doesn’t eliminate bullying, simply because adults can’t be there 24-7. That’s why the best resource we have is our kids. We need to equip bystanders to advocate for kids who are bullied.

I firmly believe today’s young people are the cure for bullying. I speak to young people at countless events encouraging and equipping them to stop bullying at the outbreak.

WE NEED TO EQUIP BYSTANDERS TO ADVOCATE FOR KIDS WHO ARE BULLIED.

Bystanders don’t need to do what their name implies: stand by. They can stand up and do something.

Let’s look at what that actually looks like.

PEER INTERVENTION

When bystanders stand up and do something, it’s called peer intervention. I use the term peer intervention because those two words have become buzzwords in bullying research as researchers have come to realize how much difference one kid can make.

We can help our kids truly make a bullying breakthrough by teaching them the 5 Rs:

1. Recognize the effects of bullying

I recently finished writing a novel about a school shooting titled Bystander. The book follows three adults and three students the week of a school shooting on a high school campus. The perspective switches from a bully, to bystanders, and finally to a bullied kid pushed beyond the tipping point.

I wrote the book for one reason: to cultivate empathy. I want parents and young people to step into the shoes of others.

Much recent research has revealed that increased screen time is slowly killing empathy. The more people stare at screens and communicate using screens, the more socially hindered they become. We need to help young people look up from their screens, notice others, and think beyond their own little world.

Whenever I speak to young people about bullying, I always tell plenty of stories. Stories help us all look beyond our own perspective and see through the eyes of others. Stories cultivate compassion and empathy.

Parents and teachers can raise awareness by talking about the effects of bullying and sharing stories that help young people consider the perspective of others. Many bystanders have never paused to think through the ramifications of laughing at someone, teasing them…or watching and doing nothing.

Help your kids see the reality of what bullying does to the one being bullied. Share stories that help them look through the eyes of others, then ask questions like, “Do you know anyone who gets bullied?”

2. Realize you can make a huge impact.

One kid can make a huge difference.

Really.

Just one.

Countless studies show that one friend is enough to prevent the downward slide toward depression.

A report in the journal Development and Psychopathology revealed, “Just one friend is enough to buffer an anxious, withdrawn child against depression. And it doesn’t have to be a particularly close friend—not an intimate or a confidant, as an adult would understand it, just some kind of social connection with someone their own age.”2

Just one friend made the difference. Kids who had no friends were by far at the highest risk for depression and anxiety, according to the two-year study. And the biggest asset against depression was friendship.

We need to help our kids understand just how powerful their simple acts of friendship can be.

Another study funded by the National Institute of Justice showed that peers can be the most effective at intervening when they see bullying take place. Peer intervention “may be the most effective counter to aggressive and microaggresive behavior.”3

Maybe a peer steps in and says, “Hey, that’s not okay.” Or if that’s too risky, maybe they approach the victim later and say, “Would you like to talk?” Those simple gestures are by far the most effective in helping those experiencing bullying.

Funny. Neither of these studies show adults as the most effective cure for bullying.

A friend is the most effective.

Just one friend makes a difference.

So where do these simple acts of friendship begin?

3. Resolve not to bully others.

Most movements begin with a decision, a commitment, a “resolve.” I think of Daniel in the Bible when he was plucked from the safety of his home and plopped down into a world brimming with temptations. He made a decision, a commitment. He “resolved not to defile himself” (Daniel 1:8).

Whenever I speak to today’s young people, I give them the opportunity to make a public commitment. It’s one thing to be moved with compassion. Commitment puts feet to those feelings.

Compassion without action is nothing.

I’m reminded of the powerful scene in the movie Hotel Rwanda—the true-life story of a Rwandan hotel manager who housed more than one thousand Tutsi refugees, protecting them from the Hutu militia.

The movie includes a sobering scene between the hotel manager, Paul (Don Cheadle), and a news photographer, Jack (Joaquin Phoenix), who has just filmed the ugly reality of the atrocities happening in Rwanda:

Paul Rusesabagina: I am glad that you have shot this footage and that the world will see it. It is the only way we have a chance that people might intervene.

Jack: Yeah and if no one intervenes, is it still a good thing to show?

Paul Rusesabagina: How can they not intervene when they witness such atrocities?

Jack: I think if people see this footage they’ll say, “Oh my God, that’s horrible,” and then go on eating their dinners.4

It happens all the time. People might be moved with compassion…but not moved off their butts to do anything about it.

Resolve is the decision to take action. Which brings us to specific actions kids can take…

4. Refuse to join in.

One of the most important actions kids can engage in is not engaging.

Bystanders have the ability and responsibility to avoid any behaviors that build up bullies by tearing down others. Bullies thrive on attention and affirmation. Give them neither.

So help bystanders learn to avoid the following:

• laughing at jokes at the expense of others

• listening to rumors, gossip, or hate speech from anyone

• physically standing with a group that is mocking or gossiping about others

Refusing to join doesn’t always necessitate speaking up and saying, “Hey, this isn’t okay.” Sometimes bystanders can walk away, or in class they can just keep their attention on their schoolwork.

If bullies don’t receive any affirmation or attention for their mean behavior, they’ll usually stop said behavior.

5. Reach out to someone who is hurting or alone.

The best bullying advice I have ever heard comes from Paul’s letter to the Philippians in the Bible:

Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit. Rather, in humility value others above yourselves, not looking to your own interests but each of you to the interests of the others. In your relationships with one another, have the same mindset as Christ Jesus.

(Philippians 2:3–5)

Can you imagine if everyone actually lived out this advice? We could cut down on a whole lotta bullying for sure!

It’s amazing what simple acts of kindness can do. But these acts are rare. Kids are all about “mine!” Put out two pieces of cake for your two kids and both will grab for the bigger piece. It’s uncommon to find a kid who genuinely offers the bigger piece to their brother or sister.

At school it’s the same. Kids typically value self above others, not the inverse.

But this generation of young people really wants to do something and make a difference. Often, they just don’t know how. It’s an interesting tension. They’re self-centered but want to help others. Sometimes a caring adult can help connect the dots showing how to get from A to B.

What would it look like to invite that awkward kid over to hang out after school…knowing full well that it might be awkward?

Passages like the one from Philippians 2 are impactful as we teach our kids how to reach out. Be humble. Consider others better than you. This is what Jesus modeled.

Showing humility and valuing others above self are concepts kids don’t spend much time thinking about, but you’ll be surprised how much kids will rise up when given the opportunity to demonstrate these values.

During spring break the middle school kids at my church serve the homeless in needy areas of San Francisco by doing something you don’t see very often—they wash their feet. Imagine seeing a junior high boy sitting on the ground washing the feet of a homeless man and then giving him new socks. I think that’s probably the dictionary definition of humility. For these kids it’s just doing what Jesus modeled in John 13.

It’s interesting how these kids make that connection of what humility looks like in other venues like school or even in their homes. Once you wash a homeless person’s feet, standing up and doing something for the bullied is much easier.

THE DECISION

Can one kid really make a difference?

It’s more than just research and articles—it’s happening all over the country. Parents and teachers shared with me numerous examples of kids who made a decision to do something about bullying, either as individuals or as part of a school program (and I’ll be sharing some fun examples of these “peer counseling” programs in my final chapter). Bystanders have amazing potential to stand up and make an impact in the lives of hurting kids. Bystanders don’t just have to “stand by.” One friend really does make a difference.

When I was in high school, that “one friend” was Matt. Matt wasn’t the most popular kid on campus, but he decided he was going to care for others no matter what anybody said.

I’ll never forget looking across campus one day and seeing Matt rolling a kid in a wheelchair to his class. Other kids were looking at Matt like, What are you doing that for, extra credit? But Matt didn’t care. When he saw someone in need, Matt acted.

Matt was in weights class with many of the football players, bench pressing and squatting enormous poundage and getting high-fives of congratulations. But at lunchtime, Matt would sit with a group of outcasts. Matt broke the unspoken lines of separation. He didn’t show prejudice in any way.

One kid made a decision to treat everyone the same.

Did Matt rid an entire campus of bullies?

No. Bullying still happened.

But Matt made a world of difference to the handful of lives he touched every day. I’ll never forget that.

Can you imagine what that campus would have looked like with even two “Matts”?

Three?

Matt was a bystander who provided real help to the bullied.

Let’s take a closer look at this group of kids who are targeted, mocked, and laughed at.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

1. What was one thing in this chapter that really stood out to you?

2. Why are bystanders so hesitant to get involved?

3. When does a “snickering bystander” become a bully?

4. Is it ever okay for a parent or teacher to participate in teasing a kid in good fun? Explain.

5. How can reading an article about bullying or reading a book about a school shooting help increase empathy?

6. What are some ways we can give bystanders an opportunity to “make a difference”? (Note: The last chapter of this book provides several examples.)

7. What is one thing you can do to encourage a bystander this week?

8. Who is one kid who might need to read this chapter with you? (I’ve included an extra set of discussion questions on the following page.)

KIDS’ DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

Questions to dialogue about with your kids

1. What was one thing in this chapter that really stood out to you?

2. Why is it that so many bystanders simply “stand by” instead of “standing up” for someone who is bullied?

3. Describe a time you saw someone being teased repeatedly or bullied.

4. When does gossiping or laughing about someone else become bullying?

5. Why do you think just one friend can make a difference in the life of someone who is picked on constantly?

6. Who is someone you know who might really need a friend?

7. What would be the difficult part of befriending this person?

8. What would it look like to invite an awkward kid over to hang out after school, knowing full well that your time together might be awkward?

9. What is something you can do this week to “stand up” instead of just “standing by”?

↑ Back to top

↑